HomeMy WebLinkAbout13074-Comcheck-CarmelUnitedMethodistChurch.pdfCOMcheck Software Version 3.9.2
Mechanical Compliance Certificate
90.1 (20�7} Standard
Section 1: Project Information
Praject Type: Alteration
Project Title : Carmel United Methodist Church
Consfruction Site: Owner/Ageni:
fi21 5outh Rangeline ftoad Mike hlufnagel
Carmel, IN 46D32 Performance Mechanical Contracting
34p9 SutherEand Avenue
�ndianapolis, IN 46218
(317) 879-8255
mhufnagel@pm�inc-online.com
Section 2: General information
Bu[Iding Lqcation {for weather data): Carmel, Indiana
ClimaEe Zone: 5a
Section 3: Mechanical Systems L�sf
uanti Svstem 7ype 8 Description
HVAC Sysiem #7:
Desig nerlCo ntractor:
Earl Wade ("Bob") Boulware, P.E.,
M.B.A.
Design-Aire Engineering
220 Narth Coilege Avenue
lndianapolis„ IN 462p2
(347)464-9090
dae@daengineering.com
Heating: 1 each - Radiant Heater, Efeckric, Capacity = 39 kBtulh
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
Cooling: 1 each - Rooftap Package Unit, Capacity = 30 kBtulh, Air-Cooled Condenser
Proposed Efficiency = 13.50 SEER, Required Efficiency = 13A0 SEER
Fan System: None
SYSTEM COMPLIAIVCE REQUIRED.
HVAC Sysfem #8:
FEeating: 1 each - Radiant Heater, Eleckric, Capac'sty = 54 kBfulh
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
Cooling: 1 eath - Rooftap Package Unit, Capacity = 48 kBtulh, Air-Cooled Condenser
Proposed Efficiency = 13.OD SEER, Required Efficiency = 13.00 SEER
Fan System: None
SYSTEM COMPLIANCE FiEQUIRED.
Section 5: Compliance Statement
Complrance Statement: The proposed mechanical alteration project
specifications and ofher calculations suhmitted with this permit applic
meet the 94.1 (2007} Standard, Chapter S, requirements in COMche
Requirements Checklist.
��� w�or �"��`� ��� �� _ �� m�A `
Name - Title ��� � �� �.� Sic
Section 6: Post Construction Complia
.....,,,
I� ��s consistent with the buiEding plans,
E�i � alteration project has been designed to
and to v�th the mandatary requirements in the
�� �� ����
Date
Project Title: Carmel United Methodist Church Report date: 08130I13
Data filename: Z:113p7a-METH CHURGHICorr�check113074-Comcheck-CarmelUnitedMethodistChurch.cck Page 1 of 2
0 HVAC record drawings of the aetuai installation and performance data for each equipment provided io the ownerwithin 90 days after
system acceptance.
� HVAC O&M documents #or a!I mechanical equipment and system pravided to the ownerwithin 90 days after system aceeptance.
0 Written HVAC ba[ancing repoft provided to the owner.
The abav� post construction requiremenfs ha�e heen completed.
Principal Mechanicai �esigner-Name Signature
Dafe
Prpject Title: Carmel United Methodist Church Report date: Q8/30l13
Data fifename: Z:113074-METH CWURCF{1Comcheck113074-Comcheck-CarmelUnitedMethodistChurch,cck Page 2 of 2
COMcheck Software Version 3.9.2
Inspection Checklist
Requirements: 1 a0.0% were addressed directly in the COMcheck saftware
Text in the "Comments/Assumptions" coiumn is provided by the user in the GOMcheck Requirements screen. For each requirement,
the user certifies tha# a code requirement will be met and how that is docurr�ented, or that an exception is being claimed. Where
campliance is itemized in a separate table, a reference to thai table is provided.
1 High lmpact (Tier 1} 2 Medium [mpact (Tier 2) 3 Low Impact (Tier 3)
Project Title: Carinel United Mefhodist Church Report date: D8130113
Data filename: Z:113074-METM CHfJRCHIComcheck113074-Comcheck-CarmelUniiedMethodistChurch.cck Page 1 of 7
90;9 (200T) p�an Reriiew Complies? CommentslAssumptions
Sfandard
_ .: : _.
A.2.2, 6.4.2 : Pfans, specifications, andlor calculations `❑Camp[ies ; Requirement wil[ be met.
[PR2]' ' pro�ide a!I information with witich ❑Qoes Not Comply;
� compliance can be determined for the []f�ot bbser�able :�ocation on planslspec: ME301, M109
' mechanical sysfems and equipmenE and �Hnt ApplicabEe
document where exceptions fo the siandard • '
� are claimed. Load ca[cufatians per °
� acceptable engineering standards and
,handbooks.
4.2.2, 7.4.1 ' Pfans, specifications, andlor calcufations ��Complies �teq�a9remenf will be met.
[PR3]' � pro�ide all informa#ian wifh which �❑noes Not Comp3y
; campliance can be deiermined for ih� ���ot Observable ; Location an planslspec: M00'f , M101
: service water heating systems and ;��fot Applicable
' equipment and document where exceptions � '
�to the standard are c[aimed. Hot waier
� system sized per manufacfurer's sizing �
guide.
6.7.2.4 ; Defailed instructians far h]VAC systems ❑Complies �xceptian: RequiremenE does not apply.
[PR5]� ' commissioning inc[uded on the plans or ❑Does [Vof Comply �
� specifications for projects >=50,OD0 ft2. ��lot ObservabEe ; �acation on planslspec: M001, Nt10'i
j❑Not App[icable
Additional CommentslAssumptions:
1 High [mpaci (Tier 1) 2 Medium Im�act (Tier 2j 3 Low Empact (Tier 3)
Project Tifle: Carmel United Methodist Church Report date: OSI30/'[3
�ata filename: Z:113Q74-METH CHURCHIComch�ck113Q74-Comcheck-CarmelUnitedMefhodistChurch.ccic Page 2 of 7
6.4.3.8 1 Freeze protection and snowlce melting LJComplies Exc�ption: Requirement does not apply.
[F09]3 ' sysfem sensors for future connection to ❑Does iVot Comp[y -
; conirnls. ❑Nat Observable �.ocation an plansls�sec: M001, M 1 Q1
�Not Applicable
Additiona[ CommentslAssumptions:
1 High Impact (Tier 1) 2 Medium impact (Tie€ 2} 3 Low Impact (iier 3)
Projeci 1'itle: Carmei Uniied Methodist Church Repart c[ate: 08/30/13
Data filename: Z:113074-METH CHURCHIComcheck113074-Comcheck-CarmelUnitedMefhodistCh�rch.cck Page 3 of 7
HVAC equipment eifciency verifi�d. ; Efficieney:
Non-NAECA HVAC eq�ipmant '
labeled as meeting 9fl.1.
6.4.3.4. i : Stair and efe�ator sha�E venEs have
(ME3]3 ' motarized dampers t�at automatically
; c�os�.
[M E5]a
; Outdoor air and exhaust systems
� have mntnrized dampers that
� automatically shut w�en not in use
' and meet maximum leakage rates.
; Check gravity dampers where
; allowed.
� VentiEation fans >0.75 hp have
� automatic controls to shut off fan
;when not required.
6.4.3.9 , f�emand control ventiiatioro provided
[ME6]' for spaces �5p0 it2 and >4p
� people/1000 ff2 occupanE density and
; ser�ed by systems with air side
�economizer, auto mndulating outside
air damper control, or design airflow
� >3.000 cfm.
6.4.4.'f.1 ; Insufation exposed io weafher
[ME7]a ; profected from damage. [nsulation
; outside oF the conditioned space and �
I assaciated with caaling systems is
: vapor retardant. �
6 4.4 i 2 '; HVAC ducts and plenums insulated. ; R-
[NiE8]2 i;`� �
`i I
3
;1
HVAC piping insu[ation thickness.
Ducts and plenums sealed 5ased on
static pressure and iocation.
6.4.4.2.2 ' Ductwork operating >3 in. wafer
[ME11 ]3 ' calumn requires air [eakage iesting.
6.4.4.2.2 ' Ductwo€k operating >3 in. water
[ME19]3 ; column requires air leaEcage testing.
E�ciency: lJComplies See the Mechanical Systems list for
❑Does Hot Comply yalues.
:[JiVot Observable -
[]Noi Applicable
;,[]Complies Excepiion: Requirement does
aC�Does NoE Comply; not apply.
;�Not Observahl� :
';�NotAppEicahle �-ocation on planslspec: hf�001,
.
`:; . .. . . .. _,��. ...... .., M 101
,❑Complies �xception: Gravii}I dampers
<��Daes Not Comply;acceptabie in buildings 3 stories.
�❑Not Observab�e �
;❑NatApplicable �ocation on p[anslspec: M001,
3 M10'{
; R-_
in. in.
,LJCampEies ; Requirement will be met.
�ODoes Not Comply ;
I�Not Qbservable ;�-flcatian nn planslspec: MOQ1,
!�NotApplica6le �M101
I�Complies ' �xception: Systems wiih a
'�❑�oes Not Comply design outdoor airfiow less than
'❑Not Observable :'��DO cim.
;❑NotApplicable
� Location on planslspec: MDO'[,
; ���M101
, �
j❑Compl€es �;Requirementwill be met.
�❑Does Not Cornply E
;j�Not Observabie ;Location on planslspec: MOD1,
�❑NatAppficable ��01
;�Camplies ' Exception: Ductslpfent�ms
�Doss Not Camply ; located in heated, semi-heated,
;[]Not Observable :or cooisd spaces.
;❑Not Applicable
Location on planslspec: M041,
� M'E 01
;❑Complies 'Exception: �ipingwithin HVAG
❑Does Not Comp[y ; equipment.
'j]Not Observable :
;❑NofApplicable �-ocation on planslspea: M001,
M149
�❑Complies I Requirement wilE be met.
�❑Does NotComply;
;❑Not Qpsenrab[e ',�ocation vn planslspec: M001,
;nni.,� n.,n��..�hio ;M101
CompGes ' Exceptian: Requirement does
Does Not Comply not eppEy.
Not 06serva6fe '
Not Applicabfe � Location on pEanslspec: Mp01,
� N{10'f
� See fhe M�chanica! Sysfems lrst for
� velues for NVRC System #7.
�Compiies ! Exception: Req�tirement does
❑Does Not Comp[y not apply.
❑Not Observable
❑NoiApplicable �-ocation on planslspec: Ma01,
M101
See ihe Mechanica! Sys[ems lisf for
values for NVAC Svstem #8.
1 High lmpact {Tier 1) 2: Niedi�m Impacf (Tier 2) 3 Low Impact (T'ser 3)
Project Titl�: Carmel United Methodist Chureh Report date: 08/34/13
Data filename: Z:113074-METH CHURCHICnmcheck113074-Comcheck-CarmelUniiedMethodistChurch.cck Page 4 of 7
6.5.2.3 ' �ehumidi€ication controls provided to
[NiE�9j3 'preveni reheating, recooling, mixing of
' hot and cold airstreams or concurrent
heating and cooiing of the same
' airstream.
6.5.4.1
[ME25J3
6.5.5.1
[ME30]�
; HVAC pumping systems >1� hp
� designed for va€iable fluid flow.
' �xhaust air energy recovery on
; systems �=5,000 cfm and 70% of
;design supply air.
Kitchen hoods >5,000 cFm have ma[ce
up air �=5p% of exhaust air volume.
fi.5.7.2 � Fume hoods exhaust systems
[ME33]' �>=15,Opp cfm have VAV hood
;exhaust and supply systems, dir�ct
; make-up air or heat recovery.
6.5.8.1 ; Unenclosed spaces that are heated
(ME34]3 � use oniy radiant heat.
�
�
6.5.9 Hot gas bypass limited to: <=240
[N[E35j� ' kBtulh — 50% >240 kBtulh — 25%
E
6.5.9 ; Hot gas bypass limited to: <=240
[ME35]� � kBtulh — 50% >240 kBtulh — 25°/a
Adctitional Corr�mentslAssumptions:
�
L1Complies Exception: Cooling capacity 80
❑Does Hot Comply:kBtulh and capabiliiy to unload
❑Not Observab[e ;�ooling equipment.
❑Not App[icable
Locatior� on plar�slspec: M001,
' M'f o 1
❑Gamplies ' Exception: 5ystems with three
❑Do�s Not Comply ; or fewer control va[ves.
❑Not 06servable
❑NatApplicab[e �ocation on planslspec: M001,
M1€71
❑Comp[ies Exception: Requiremeni daes
❑�aes Nat CompEy ' not apply.
❑Nat Obseroable :
[�Not Applicable • �-ocation on planslspec: M001,
M1��
❑Complies Exeeption: Requirement does
❑t�oes t�at Comply � not apply.
❑iVot Observabie ;
❑Not App[icable �-�cation on planslspec: MOOi,
Mi01
❑Cnmplies Exception: Requirement does
�,�Does Not Comply � not apply.
❑Not Observable �
pNotApplicabie 'LocaEion nn planslspec: M001,
M1Q1
',❑Complies `.Exceptian: Requirementdaes
I❑Does Not Com�1y °not app[y.
�`CjP1ot Obseroable `
;❑[�otApplicaisle Location on planslspec: MU01,
Miai
i❑Complies : Requirement will be met.
�❑Does Not Comply ;
i❑Noi 06servable ;�-�cation on planslspec: M00'f,
�❑NotApplicable M901
See the Mechanrca! Systems list for
values for NVAC System #7.
❑Comp[ies Requirement will be met.
❑does Not Comply;
❑Not Obseroable :�acatian an planslspec: M001,
❑NotApplicable =M�01
'< See ihe fvlechanical Systems list for
; values ior NVAC Svsiem #8.
7 High Impact {Tier 1} 2 Nfedium Impact (Tier 2) 3 Low Impact (Tier 3)
Project Title: Carmel United Methodist CF�urch Report date: 0813p113
Dala filename: Z;113074-METH CHIiRCHIComcheck113074-Cnmcheck-CarmelUnitedMethodistChurch.cck Page 5 of 7
Efectric motors meet requirements where
applicabie.
Additional CommenislAssumptions:
�Complies Requirement will be met.
C�Does Not Comply�
❑Not Observab[e , Location on planslspec: MOOi, M101
1 High Impact (Tier 1) 2 Medium [mpact (Tier 2) 3 Low Impact (Tier 3)
Praject Title: Carmel United Mefhodisi Church f2eport date: 0813�113
Data filename: Z:113074-METH CHIiRCHIComcheck113074-Comcheck-CarmelUnitedMethodisfChurch.ccK Page 6 of 7
90.1 (2007�; Fir�al inspection Comp[ies? Camm�ntslAssumptions
Sfandard : '
_ , _
6,4;3 1 1 ; Heaiing and coofing to each zone is '�Complies Requi€ement wil! be met.
[FI2]2 >' controlled by a thermostat controi. ODoes Not Comply'
`` �Not Observabfe : Location on planslspec: M001, M10'[
€ �Nof Applica6le °
6.4;31 2, ;; Thermostatic controls have a 5°F ❑Cnmplies � Requirement will be met_
6.4:3 2, � deadband. ❑Does Not Comply ;
6�4;3 3, �� �❑Not Observable =�acation on planslspec: MOD1, M101
6 4:3 3 1 ; ❑Not Applicable
6:4:3;3:2::::: i:
[FI3]z:. . 's '.
6.4.3.7 When humidification and dehumidifcaiion OCamplies Requiremenf will be mef.
[FI6j3 are provided to a zone, sirnultaneous '❑Qoes Not Comp[y;
, aperation is prohibited. ❑Not 4bservable ;�-dcatian on planslspec: M401, M 1 Q1
� ❑Not Applicable
8.7.2.1 "Furnished HVAC as-bu[It drawings ;�Complies Requirement will be met.
[F[7]3 �submitted within 9D days of system 'ODoes Not Comply
,acceptance. ,❑NotObservable �
;�NotApplicable
6.7.2.2 ; Fumished OS�M manuals for HVAC systerr�s:❑Complies ; Requirement will be met.
[FIS]3 'within 9R days of system acceptance_ �❑Does Not Comply;
❑Not Obsenrable �
� ;❑Not Appficable
6.7.2.3 ;An airandlpr hydronicsystem balancing OCampl€es ;Requirementwill be met.
[F19]' 'report is provided for HVAC systems ❑Does Not Comply �
serving zanes >5,000 ft2 of concfitioned [j Not Observable ; Location an planslspec: M0f31, M 101
� area. �,[jNot Applicable
6.7.2.4 1 HVAC control systems have been tesied to :❑Complies Requirement wilE be met.
[FI10j' ' ensure proper operation, calibration and �Does Not Comply
�,adjustment of controls. �Not Observable ,Location on planslspec: N[00�[, M101
;❑�[otApplicable °
6.4.3.2 ,iemperature controls have setpoint overlap ;C1Complies ; Ftequire€nent will be met.
[FI20]1 restrictians. '❑�oesNoEComply;
:�iVoi Observable ;�-ocation on planslspec: MD�1, M107
❑Not App[icable
6.4.3.3.1 ' HVAC systert3s equipped wiih at least one '❑Complies � Requirement wi11 be met.
[FI21]� � auiomafic shutdown confrol. �Does Not Camply;
❑Not Observahle �-ocation on planslspec: MOfl1, M701
❑Not Applicab€e
6.4.3.3.2 ; 5etback controls a[low automatic restart '❑Complies �' Requirement wil[ be met.
[F122j' and temporary operation as required for �Does Not Comply�,
� maintenance. �Not Qbseroabls ;Locatian on planslspec: Mp01, M101
;❑NotAppGcable
Addifiianal CommenislAssumptions:
9 High lmpact {Tier 1) 2: Medium Impact (Tier 2) 3 Low Impact (Tier 3)
Project Tifle: CarEnel United Meihodist Church Report 0813D113
Data filename: Z;113Q74-METH CNURChilComcheck113D74-Comcheck-CarmelUnitedMetF�odisfChurch.cck Page 7 of 7