HomeMy WebLinkAbout14040233 Correspondence ,
o���°F�''�¢,, _ . CITY OF CARMEL / CLAY TOWNSHIP
cQ�THt.'8.���A • ' -
� COMMERCIAL / INSTITUTIONAL
New Structures / Additions / Accessory Structures
N �
�aniaNp A.PPROVALS FROM CITY, TOWIYSHIP, AND COLiNTY AGENCIES
PROJECT �'{or%Lo� nk PERMIT # / ll ''�623.3
DESCRIPTIOM CONTACT I`I o 5017�`( Wk F2�— -
LOCATION PHONE OFFICE
ADDRESS ��-16 W CArML� MOBILE
E-MAIL
NOTES
OK? AGENCY � ' CONTACT APPROVALS NOTES
City of Carmel Angie Conn 571-2281 Planning & Zoning d" 1
� De artment of . OK+Sfa" �"g I rLh f � 5 6
P Planner. •
Community Services �nn@ca�mel.in v Architectural Elevation Drawin s Q(4- Jr
,�e, City of CarmeC Racliel Keesling 571-2424 Planning &Zoning
�� Department of Planning Administrator
Community,Services rke slin carmel.in. ov Administrator
J City of Carmel' Daren Mindham 571-2283 Urban Forestry
��� Department of Urban Forester
CommunitySeryices dmindhamCa�carmel.in. ov Landsca in Plan
� City of Carmel David Littlejohn 573-2306 Alternative Transportation
Department of Planner
Community Services little'ohn carmel.in. ov
City,of Carmel Gary D`uncan . 571-2441 Engineering j(-� f c� Z
OEngineering Asst: City Engineer Right-of-Way Pe�mit o��"d:~9 � $
Department gduncan((alca�mel.in.gov Street Cut Permit
S:�Penniis�POrms�Com��u'ciel-Ins�i�utioneLNrv�S�me�wes&AJdliiortPAppmvels Fo�n Agencies Lazt Updutal Mmeh^_8,201 i Page I of?
I
OCity of Carmel 7ohn Thomas 571-2441 Stormwater Management
Engineering StormwaterManager StormwaterPermit ���Sta��h� j�f 4��
Department h masocarmel.in. ov Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan '
OCity of Carmel Dave Barnes 571-2441 Engineering
Engineering Administrator Bonding
Department dbamesCa�carmel.in, ov Board of Public Works Approval
City of Carmel Chris Ellison 571-2600 Fire Prevention
� Fire Department Deputy Fire Marshall �� � �✓(1
celli on carmel.in. ov Plan Review
� City of Carmel John Duffy 571-2443 Sewer/Water Utilities )
Utilities Department Director Sewer Permit �� 5��
duff carmel.in. ov Water Permit
OCity of Carmel Pam Lux 571-2288 Addressing
Building & Code Assistant D�
Services lux carmel,in. ov Street Address Assi nment
Clay Township Ryan Hartman 844-9200 Sewer Utility
ORegional Waste District Engineer �K `1�30
District an.hartman ctrwd.or Sewer Permit
� Hamilton County Larry Beard 776-8500 Food Establishment Permit
Health Department Environmental Specialist Septic Permit
IdbCo�co.hamilton.in.us Well Permit
Hamilton County David Lucas 773-7770 County Roads I
� Highway Department Staff Engineer Right-of-Way Permit - v� cf �
delCalco.hamilton in.us Street Cut Permit
� Hamilton County . Greg_Hoyes 776-8495 Drainage
Surveyor's-0ffce Plan Reviewer �� SI$`
rhCalco:hamilton.in.us Re ulated Drein Outlet Permit
O Duke Energy Shirley Hunter 896-6711 Electricity Availability
Engineer Technologist
Shirle .Hunter duke-ener .com New Service Re uests
(� Vectren Energy �oanie Clark 776-5532 Gas Availability /
���� Engineering Tech U�� ,J lv`
Iclark Vectren.com New Service Re uests
OIndianapolis Power& Dan Davenport 261-8133 Electrical Availability
Light Engineering Tech
dan.davenportCalaes com New Service Requests '
S?Penniis�FOUru�Cnmmer�ipl-ina�imtionoPNmr Stm�tv.ea&AdduonstF{µorvvats hom.Fgenoies Lui Uptla�eA MareM1 38.2014 Pagc]oR
�—.
�
WIGHTMAN SL.ASSOCIATES. INC.
ENGINEERING•SURVEYING�ARCHITECTURE
Benton Harbor Office:
�303 Pipcsrone Road
Ben[on Harbo[MI 49022
Apri124, 2014 reiepn�,�,�:
(zb�)�z�-oioo
Tod Rm.
Ciry of Carmel (sn19z7-o�09
Building Dcpartment F'�
One Civic Square Izb���z�-i3oo
Carmel,IN 46032 �u�s�te:
www.wightman-assoc.com
Atten+.:on: Mr. Niek Mischler
RE: HOR7ZON BANK— 121'6 W. CARMEL DRIVE
Dear Mr. Mischler:
Thank you for spending time witb me on the telephone to discuss the plan review buildine pernut proceduie.
Attacbed please find thereview package. The package contains:
• 3 sets of sealed plans that have the affidavit stickers attached.
• A�copy of the State R'elease
• Theperntitapplication
The project was verbally approved by John Tliomas in the Engineering Department so we are in the process of
providing the city with the required sets of plans avd other documentation. A copy of Mr. Thomas's ]etter is also
attached.
Horizon Baiilc is very arixious to start construction on the projeet. Please let me know if there is anything 1 can do
to assist you in your review and issuance of the pernvt.
Very truly yours,
WIGI3TMAN & ASSOCIATES, INC.
�
Chnstopher J. Brayak, AIA
cbrayak@wi glihnan-assoc.com
CJB/cb
tinclosure
cc: Jim Jaksa
P\L0343 Horizon Rank-Horiznn Bank Cnrmel iNW I Docmneovs�A10 Cums drnce'�014.0414 BMdino D�I I¢docc
BENTON HAR�OR • P�R�AGE o ALLEGAN
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Clark Brent [Breni.Clark@tonnandblank.com]
Sent: Thursday, May 15, 2014 12:17 PM
To: Christopher J. Brayak
Cc: Thomas, John G; Barnes, David R; Duncan, Gary R;Jordan, Alex; Mishler, Nicholas F;
Boone, Tiffany; Hollibaugh, Mike P; JimJaksa
Subject: Re: Horizon Bank - Carmel
Bonds will hopefully be available next Tuesday.
Brent Clark
Director of Field Operations, Central Indiana Region
Tonn and Blank Construction, LLC
317-450-4985 cell
317-423-1020 ext 127
On May 15, 2014, at 12:00 PM, "Christopher J. Brayak" <cbravak(a�wi�htman-assoc.com>wrote:
Thanks John,
Nick Mishler has received confirmation that the Utility fees were paid. Tonn and Blank construction is
obtaining the Bonds and the ROW permit.
I will check on the progress obtaining the bonds and get back with you today.
Thanks,
Chris
- -- _ __. —__ _ --- ---- .. __ - — - -
From:Thomas,John G [mailto:ithomas@carmel.in.�ov]
Sent:Thursday, May 15, 2014 10:06 AM
To: Christopher J. Brayak; Barnes, David R; Duncan, Gary R;Jordan,Alex; Mishler, Nitholas F; Boone,
Tiffany
Cc: Hollibaugh, Mike P;Jim Jaksa; Clark Brent
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank-Carmel
Good morning Chris,
You are correct. We still need the following before release;
1. The right of way performance bond
2. The right of way permit
3. The storm water control performance bond
4. Payment of any necessary City of Carmel Utility fees.
Sincerely,
John Thomas, CPESC, CMS4S
Storm Water Administrator
City of Carmel Engineering Department
(p) 317-571-2314
(f) 317-571-2439
1
From: Christopher J. Brayak [mailto:cbravakCa�wiahtman-assoc.coml
Sent: Monday, May 12, 2014 5:28 PM
To: Thomas, John G
Cc: Hollibaugh, Mike P; Jim Jaksa; Clark Brent
Subject: Horizon Bank - Carmel
HiJohn,
The Planning dept approved the Horizon bank elevations today.The only outstanding issues that I recall
from your letter are the row performance bond, the ROW permit,The utility fees and storm water
control bond.
I believe that Horizon has paid the utility fees. Have you received the bonds and ROW permit. Please let
me know if you have received the required documentation.
Thanks,
Chris
Wightman& Associates, Inc.
Christopher J. 8rayak AIA
2303 Pipestone Road
Benton Harbor, M149022
269-927-0100 Main
269-927-1300 Fax
877-927-0109 Toll Free
www.wi¢htma n-assoc.com
DISCLAIMER
Elecironic tlocumenis pmvided 6y Wighiman 8 Assaciates, Inc.are an instrument ol service and are being providetl solely as a convenience m the
user. W ightman&Associates,Inc.makes no represemation regarding the fimess al�his documentalion foi any particular purpose or suitability lor use
with any software or hardware. Due to�he easily alterable naWre ol eleclronic documems,through either intentional or unintenlional means,W igh�man
8 Associales,Inc.does not make any express or implied warranty for Ihe accuracy or completeness ol lhis documenlation. Hartl copies shall prevail in
any tlispu�e over the accuracy or sutiiciency oi elecironic documents and are available throu9h this ollice. The information pmvided is pmprietary and
shal�nol be copietl elecironically or otherwise or used lor any purpose noi authorized in writing by W ighiman&�Associales,Ina Through the use ol Ihe
iniormation contained herein,ihe user agrees to intlemnily and hold W ightman 8 Associates,Inc.and its=mployees harmless Irom any loss.damage,
liabiliry or cost,including reasonable a�lomey's tees,arising Irom any use or reuse ol any elec�mnic documen[(s)or in�ormation as conlained herein.
�'� PlctiBionsidertheeneironntent6eforeprintingthi=email.
The information contained in this e-mail and any accompanying documents is intended for the sole use of
the recipient to whom it is addressed, and may contain information that is privileged, confidential, and
prohibited from disclosure under applicable law. If you are not the intended recipient, or authorized to
receive this on behalf of the recipient, you are hereby notified that any review, use, disclosure, copying, or
distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient(s), please contact the sender by e-mail and
destroy all copies of the original message. Thank you.
z
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Christopher J. Brayak [cbrayak@wightman-assoc.com]
Sent: Thursday; May 15, 2014 12:00 PM
To: Thomas: John G; Barnes, David R; Duncan, Gary R;Jordan, Alex; Mishler, Nicholas F;
Boone, Tiffany
Cc: Hollibaugh, Mike P; Jim Jaksa; Clark Brent
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank - Carmel
ThanksJohn,
Nick Mishler has received confirmation that the Utility feeswere paid.Tonn and Blank construction is obtaining the
Bonds and the ROW permit.
I will check on the progress obtaining the bonds and get back with you today.
Thanks,
Chris
.— __ —___-- -------- -- ___ _—_ _.�_ _
From:Thomas,John G (mailto:ithomas(ilcarmel.in.�ov]
Sent:Thursday, May 15, 2014 10:06 AM
To: Christopher J. Brayak; Barnes, David R; Duncan, Gary R; Jordan, Alex; Mishler, Nicholas F; Boone,Tiffany
Cc: Hollibaugh, Mike P; lim laksa; Clark Brent
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank-Carmel
Good morning Chris,
You are correct. We still need the following before release;
1. The right of way performance bond
2. The right of way permit
3. The storm water control performance bond
4. Payment of any necessary City of Carmel Utility fees.
Sincerely,
John Thomas, CPESC, CMS4S
Storm Water Administrator
City of Carmel Engineering Department
(p) 317-571-2314
(f) 317-571-2439
From: Christopher J. Brayak [mailto:cbrayakCa�wiqhtman-assoc.com]
Sent: Monday, May 12, 2014 5:28 PM
To: Thomas; John G
Cc: Hollibaugh, Mike P; Jim ]aksa; Clark Brent
Subject: Horizon Bank - Carmel
HiJohn,
The Planning dept approved the Horizon bank elevations today.The only outstanding issues that I recall from your letter
are the row performance bond, the ROW permit,The utility fees and storm water control bond.
I believe that Horizon has paid the utility fees. Have you received the bonds and ROW permit. Please let me know if you
have received the required documentation.
Thanks,
Chris
3
Wightman & Associates, Inc.
Christopher J. Brayak AIA
2303 Pipestone Road
Benton Harbor, MI 49022
269-927-0100 Main
269-927-1300Fax
877-927-0109 Toll Free
www.wi�htman-assoc.com
DISCLAIMER
Elecimnic documenis provided by Wighiman 8 Associates, Inc. are an insirument ol service and are being provldetl solely as a convenience �o the usec Wighlman &
Associates, Inc.makes no represenlation regarding�he filness of this documenlation for any particular purpose or suitabiliry br use with any soRware ar hardware. Due to Ihe
easity allerable nawre of electronic documenis,ihmugh either inrentional or uninlenlional means,Wightman&Associates.Inc.does not make any express or implied warranry
br Ihe accuracy or completeness of�his tlwumenlation. Hard copies shall prevail in any tlispute over the accuracy or sulliciency ol electronic tlocumems and are available
through thls ofiice. The.information providetl is proprietary and shall not be copied electronically or otherwise or used for any purpose not aWhorizetl in writing by Wightman 8
Associates, Ina Through Ihe use ol the inlormatiomcontainetl herein,�he user agrees to indemnity and hold Wighlman 8 Associates, Inc.and its employees harmless Irom
any loss,damage,liabiliry or wsl,inclutling reasona6le avomey s�ees.arising irom any use or reuse ol any eleclronic documen�(s)or inbrmalion as comained herein.
�� Please cansider the r�ivi�ronment beforr prin;ing this emaii.
4
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Thomas, John G
Sent: Thursday, May 15, 2014 10:06 AM
To: 'Christopher J. Brayak'; Barnes, David R; Duncan, Gary R; Jordan, Alex; Mishler, Nicholas F;
Boone, Tiffany
Cc: Hollibaugh, Mike P; Jim Jaksa; Clark Brent
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank - Carmel
Good morning Chris,
You are correct. We still need the following before release;
1. The right of way performance bond
2. The right of way permit
3. The storm water control performance 6ond
4. Payment of any necessary City of Carmel Utility fees.
Sincerely.
John Thomas, CPESC, CMS4S
Storm Water Administrator
City of Carmel Engineering Department
(p) 317-571-2314
(f) 317-571-2439
From: Christopher]. Brayak [mailto:cbravakColwiahtman-assoc.com]
Sent: Monday, May 12, 2014 5:28 PM
To: Thomas, John G
Cc: Hollibaugh, Mike P; Jim )aksa; Clark Brent
Subject: Horizon Bank- Carmel
HiJohn,
The Planning dept approved the Horizon bank elevations today.The only outstanding issues that I recall from your letter
are the row performance bond, the ROW permit,The utility fees and storm water control bond.
I believe that Horizon has paid the utility fees. Have you received the bonds and ROW permit. Please let me know if you
have received the required documentation.
Thanks,
Chris
Wightman & Associates, Inc.
Christopher J. Brayak AIA
2303 Pipestone Road
Benton Harbor, M149022
269-927-0100 Main
269-927-1300 Fax
877-927-0109 Toll Free
www.wi�htman-assoc.com
DISCLAIME{i
Elecimnic dacumenis pmvided by Wighiman& Associates, Inc. are an instrument of service and are being provitletl solely as a convenience m the user. Wighiman 8
Associates,Inc.makes no representation regaNing ihe litness ol lhis tlocumentalion for any particular purpose or suitability far use with any software or hartlware. Due to Ihe
easily al�erable naWre o�electmnic dowments.thmugh eilher intentional�or uninlentional means,Wigh�man BASSOCiates,Inc.does not make any express or implieA wartanty
for Ihe accuracy or compie�eness o�Ihis dacumentatioa Hard capies shall prevail in any dispute over the accuracy or suliiciency ol electronic daument5 and are available
5
Ihrough this ofiice. The information provided is pwprietary and shall noi be copietl eleclronically or otherwise or usetl lor any purpase nol authorized in writing by Wighiman 8
Associates. Inc. Through Ihe usa ot the information containetl herein,the user agrees to indemnify and hold W ighlman 8 Associates,Inc.and�ils employees harmless Irom
any loss.damage,liabiliry or cost,including reasonable attorneys fees,arising Irom any use or reuse oi any elecironic document(s)or inbrmation as contained herein.
�'� Plen9e zonsider tha envirorunent befwe printing this email.
6
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Clark, Joanne L. (jlclark@Vectren.com]
Sent: Thursday, May 15, 2014 8:45 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank
I understand.Thanks, Joanie
From: Mishler, Nicholas F [mailto:nmishler@carmel.in.gov]
Sent: Thursday, May 15, 2014 8:24 AM
To: Clark, )oanne L.
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank
This is �m EXTERNAL email. STOP. DON"C CLICK links or OPEN atYachments unless you are sw�e ihe source
and cnnteiit of the emait is credible.
We have had some issues with builders not getting approvals with Duke Energy,so I figured I would cover myself and start getting the OK from
everyone who is involved with TAC.
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administra[ive Assistant
8uilding&Code Services
(317)571-2489
y,�Piease mnsider th�environm�n;before p�inting this emaii
From: Clark, Joanne L [mailto:ilclarkCa�Vectren.com] �WLL �~ W
Sent: Thursday, May 15, 2014 6:51 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank
Hi Nick,
Is this some[hing new, I don't remember ever having this question asked before? I can't think of any reason why Vectren
would hold this project up so go ahead and release the building permit.
Thank you,
Joanie Clark
Vectren Energy Delivery
317-776-553Z
From: Mishler, Nicholas F [mailto:nmishlerC�carmel.in.qov]
Sent: Wednesday, May 14, 2014 4:27 PM
To: 'Hunter-shirley.hunter@duke-energy.com'; Clark, )oanne L.
Subject: FW: Horizon Bank
'fhis is un EXTERNAL email. STOP. L�ON'T CLICK links or OPEN auachments imless vou are sure the source
and content of the email is credible.
�
Good afternoon-
Is Ihis project ok ro release the building permit?
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assistant
Building&Code Services
(317)571-2489
`�Please mnsidnr;ns enviror,m=nt before prineng this email
From: Christopher J. Brayak [mailto:cbrayak(a�wiqhtman-assoc.com] �
Sent: Tuesday, April 29, 2014 9:07 AM
To: Greg R. Hoyes; Mishler, Nicholas F; Conn, Angelina V; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas, John G; Barnes, David R; Jordan,
Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank
Hi Greg,
What is the Outlet Request submittal and how can I get it to you?
Thanks,
Chris
— -- --- --_._ ___.__ _ — — — _._ __.._ __�__.� — —
From: Greg R. Hoyes fmailto:Gre�.Hoves@hamiltoncountv.in.�ov]
Sent:Tuesday, April 29, 2014 8:15 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F; Conn, Angelina V; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas,John G; Barnes, David R;Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; ChristopherJ. Brayak
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank
Nick
The Hamilton County Surveyor's Office still needs an outlet request submitted per our TAC review letter. If you have any
questions, please let me know.
� .�fo��, ae, es��e, �r��se
Plan Reviewer
Hamilton County Surveyor's Office
From: Mishler, Nicholas F [mailto:nmishler(alcarmel.in.00v]
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-Wold, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; Greg R. Hoyes;
'jclark@vectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, John M; Kempa, Lisa L; David E. Lucas; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas, John G;
Barnes, David R; Larry D. Beard; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, Joslyn; ]ordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subject: Horizon Bank
Good afternoon-
I received plans for the new Horizon Bank,a 7;332 square foot structure at 1216 W.Carmel Dr.. I have attached a digital set of the site and
elevations. Please let me know what your departmen[will need prior to the release of a building permiL. Also,please copy Douglas Robertson and
Christopher Brayak on your reply. They are both mpied on this email.
8
If you have any questions,let me know.
Thanks,
Nick MiShler
Administrative Assistant
Building&Code Services
(317�571-2489
6,3j PlPnse consider(he environmen[b2fore Fli'inting[his email
This message (including any attachments) is intended only for the use of the individual or entity to which it is
addressed and may contain information that is non-public, proprietary, privileged, confidential, �nd exempt
from disclosure under applicable law or may�eonstitute as atrorney work product. If you are not the intended
recipien[, you are hereby notified that any use, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this communication is
strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, notify us immediately by telephone and (i)
destroy this message if a facsimile or(ii) delete this message immediately if this is an electronic
communication. Thank you.
This messa�e (including any attachments) is intended onl'y for the use of the individual or entiry to which it is
addressed and may contain information that is non-public, proprietary, privileged, confidential, a�d exempt
from disclosure under applicable law or may constitute as attorney work product If you are not the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that any use, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this communication is
stricdy prohibited. If you have received this communication in en�or, notify us immediately by telephone and (i)
destroy this message if a facsimile or(ii) delete this message i�nmediately if this is an electronic
communication. Thank you.
9
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Clark, Joanne L. [jlclark@Vectren.com]
Sent: Thursday, May 15, 2014 6:51 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank
Hi Nick,
Is this something new, I don't remember ever having this question asked before?I can't think of any reason why Vectren
would hold this project up so go ahead and release the building permit.
Thank you,
Joanie Clark
Vectren Energy Delivery
317-776-5532
From: Mishler, Nicholas F [mailto:nmishler@carmel.in.gov] �
Sent: Wednesday, May 14, 2014 4:27 PM
To: 'HUnter-shirley.hunter@duke-energy.com'; Clark, ]oanne L.
Subjed: FW: Horizon Bank
This is an EXTERNAL email. STOP. DON'T CLICK Iinks or OP6N attachments unless you are sure the source
and content oPthe email is credible.
Good afternoon-
Is this project ok to release the building permit?
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administretive Assistant
Building&Code Services
(317)571-2489
�-3'j Piease mnsider tlie environm�nP beforn prin[inq[his emall
From: Christopher J. Brayak [mailto:cbravakCalwiqhtman-assoc.com]
Sent: Tuesday;April 29; 2014 9:07 AM
To: Greg R. Hoyes; Mishler, Nicholas F; Conn, Angelina V; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas, John G; Barnes, David R; Jordan,
Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank
Hi Greg,
What is the Outlet Request submittal and how can I get it to you?
Thanks,
Chris
10
- -- ---_�__,...�� _ . __ __.__ �_ __ __ _ _ ____- - - -
From: Greg R. Hoyes [mailto:GreR.Hoves@hamiltoncountv.in.�ov]
Sent:Tuesday, April 29, 2014 8:15 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F; Conn, Angelina V; Duncan, Gary R;Thomas, John G; Barnes, David R;Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; Christopher J. erayak
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank
Nick
The Hamilton County Surveyor's Office still needs an outlet request submitted per our TAC review letter. If you have any
questions, please let me know.
�� ��, ae, �.��.,�t, �,r�se
Pian Reviewer
Hamilton County Surveyor's Office
From: Mishler, Nicholas F [mailto:nmishlerCalcarmel.in.qov] �
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-WOId, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; Greg R. Hoyes;
'jclark@vectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, John M; Kempa, Lisa L; David E. Lucas; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas, John G;
Barnes, David R; Larry D. Beard; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, ]oslyn; )ordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subjed: Horizon Bank
Good afternoon-
I rereived plans for the new Horizon Bank,a 7,332 square foot strucmre at 1216 W.Carmel Or.. I have attached a digital set of the site and
elevations. Please let me know what your department will need prior ro the release of a building permit.. Also,please copy Douglas Robertson and
Christopher Brayak on your reply. They are boih copied on this email.
If you have any questions,let me know.
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Adminis[rative Assistant
Building&Code Services
(317)571-2489
`,3j Pleasz consider[h=environment b_Fore prin;iny+tFi�-emal
This message (including any attachments) is intended only for the use of the individual or entity to which it is
addressed and may contain information that is non-public, proprietary, privileged, confidential, and exempt
from disclosure under applicable law or may constitute as attorney worh product If yc�u are not the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that any use, dissemination, distribuCion, or copying of this communication is
strictly prohibited. If you h�ve received this communication in error, notify us immediately by telephone and (i)
destroy this message if a facsimile or (ii) delete this message immediately if this is an electronic
communication. Thank you.
ii
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Duncan, Gary R
Sent: Tuesday, May 13, 2074 9:09 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F
Cc: Barnes, David R; Thomas, John G; Greskamp, Dan
Subject: Re: Horizon Bank - docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS
Scratch this email...wrong project.
Sent from my iPhone
On May 13, 2014, at 9:07 AM, "Ouncan, Gary R" <Rduncan(cacarmel.in.�ov>wrote:
We need to sign the plans and date them tomorrow when we get the bonds.They will need to schedule
a precon. We are ready for full release conditioned on them having a preconstruction meeting with us.
Gary
Sent from my iPhone
On May 12, 2014, at 3:39 PM, "Mishler, Nicholas F" <nmishler@carmel.in.eov>wrote:
Gary,.where does this one stand?
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assis[ant
Building&Code Services
(317)571-2489
y�j FI2z<c mnsider t'h�environrner[be4ore R%ii�ting:hi5 tma(I
From: Conn, Angelina V ��
Sent: Monday, May 12, 2014 3:36 PM
To: 'Christopher]. Brayak'; Motz, Lisa
Cc: 'douqlas.robertsonCaltonnandblank.com'; Hardin, Steven D.; Jim]aksa; Hollibaugh,
Mike P; Keesling, Rachel M; Mishler, Nicholas F; Clark Brent; Blanchard, Jim E
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank - docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS
Good afternoon, Chris—
Thank.you for working with the Planning Dept. to finalize the exterior architectural
building elevations. Attached are the stamped/approved elevations, including that final
change made to add in the limestone cap to the large window the North Elevation.
(Lisa—please add this pdj to Loser FicheJ.
Sincerely,
Angie Conn, Planning Administrator
City of Carmel Planning & Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Servires
1 Civic Square, 3rd Rr., Carmel, W 46032
12
Office: 317-571-2417 � Direct: 317-571-2281 � Fax: 317-571-2426 � E-mail:
aconnCalcarmel.in.00v � Web: www.carmeldocs.com
Please consider the environment be(ore printing lhis e-mail
From: Mishler, Nicholas F �
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-WOId, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren;
'Hunter, Shirley A'; 'Greg R. Hoyes'; 'jclarkCa�vectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, ]ohn
M; Kempa, Lisa t; 'David Lucas'; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas, John G; Barnes, David R;
'Larry Beard'; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, Joslyn; Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douqlas.robertsonC�tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subjed: Horizon Bank- docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS
Good afternoon-
I received plans for the new Horizon Bank,a 7,332 square foot structure at 1216 W.Carmel Dr.. I have
attached a digital set of[he si[e and elevations. Please le[me know wha[your department will need prior
to the release of a building peimiL. Also,please copy Douglas Robertson and Christopher Breyak on your
reply. They are both copied on this email.
If you have any questions,let me know.
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assistant
Building&Code Services
(317)571-2489
w,3j Pleasa mnsider the�n`+ironment before printing thls email
<Elevations, Approved. 5-12-2014.pdf>
13
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Duncan, Gary R
Sent: Tuesday, May 13, 2014 9:08 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F
Cc: Barnes, David R; Thomas, John G; Greskamp, Dan
Subject: Re: Horizon Bank - docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS
We need to sign the plans and date them tomorrow when we get the bonds. They will need to schedule a precon. We
are ready for full release conditioned on them having a preconstruction meeting with us.
Gary
Sent from my iPhone
On May 12, 2014, at 3:39 PM, "Mishler, Nicholas F" <nmishler@tarmel.in.aov>wrote:
Gary,where does this one stand?
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Astistant
Building&Code Services
(3ll)571-2489
y-�j°lease cansider the en�eirnnment Uefore prinfing this eiriail
From: Conn, Angelina V
Sent: Monday, May 12, 2014 3:36 PM
To: 'Christopher J. Brayak'; Mo�, Lisa
Cc: 'doualas.robertsonCa�tonnandblank.com'; Hardin, Steven D.; Jim Jaksa; Hollibaugh, Mike P; Keesling,
Rachel M; Mishler, Nicholas F; Clark Brent; Blanchard, ]im E
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank - docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS
Good afternoon, Chris—
Thank you for working with the Planning Dept. to finalize the exterior architectural 6uilding elevations.
Attached are the stamped/approved elevations, including that final change made to add in the
limestone cap to the large window the North Elevation.
(Liso—please add this pdi to Laser FicheJ.
Sincerely,
A�gi2 COM, Planning Administrator
Ci[y of Carmel Planninq &Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civic Square, 3rd Plr., Carmel, IN 46032
Office: 317-571-2417 � Direct: 317-571-2281 � Faz: 317-571-2426 I E-mail: aconnC�carmel.in.00v � Web:
www.carmeldocs.com
Please consider the environment belore printingthis e-mail
From: Mishler, Nicholas F
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
14
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-Wold, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A';
'Greg R. Hoyes'; 'iclarkC�lvectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, ]ohn M; Kempa, Lisa L; 'David Lucas';
Duncan, Gary R; Thomas, John G; Barnes, David R; 'Larry Beard'; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, Joslyn; Jordan,
Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertsonCaltonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subjed: Horizon Bank - docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS
Good afternoon-
I received plans for the new Horizon Bank,a 7,332 square foot structure at 1216 W.Carmel Dr.. I have attached a digital set of
the site and elevations. Please let me know what your department will need prior to the reiease of a bui�ding permit.. Also,
please copy Douglas Robertson and Christopher Brayak on your reply. They are both copied on this email.
If you have any questions,let me know.
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assistant
Building&Code Services
(3ll)571-2489
�fj Please consldar tne environmenc teinre prinnng this emaii
<Elevations, Approved. S-IZ-20t4.pdf>
is
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Conn, Angelina V
Sent: Monday, May 12, 2014 3:36 PM
To: 'ChristopherJ. Brayak` Motz, Lisa
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; Hardin, Steven D.;Jim Jaksa; Hollibaugh, Mike P;
Keesling, Rachel M; Mishler, Nicholas F; Clark Brent; Blanchard, Jim E
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank - docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS
Attachments: Elevations, Approved. 5-12-2014.pdf
Good afternoon, Chris—
Thank you for working with the Planning Dept. to finalize the exterior architectural buiiding elevations. Attached are
the stamped/approved elevations, induding that final change made to add in the limestone cap to the large window the
North Elevation.
(Lisa—please add this pdi to Lase�FicheJ.
Sincerely,
Angie CoM, Planning Administra[or
City of Carmel Planning & Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civic Square, 3rd Flr., Carmel, IN 46032
Office: 317-571-24ll � Direct: 317-571-2281 � Fax: 3ll-571-2426 � E-mail: atonnCo)carmel.in.qov � Web:
www.carmeldocs.com
Pleage consider the enrronment before prir.ting fhis e-mail
From: Mishler, Nicholas F
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-WOId, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; 'Greg R.
Hoyes'; 'jclark@vectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, ]ohn M; Kempa, Lisa L; 'David Lucas'; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas,
]ohn G; Barnes, David R; 'Larry Beard'; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, )oslyn; Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subjed: Horizon Bank - docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS
Good afiemoon-
I received plans for the new Horizon Bank,a 7,332 square foot structure at 1216 W.Carmel Dr.. I have attached a digital set of the site and
elevations. Please le[me know what your department will need prior to[he release of a building permit.. Also, please copy Douglas Robertson and
Christopher Brayak on your reply. They are both copied on this email.
If you have any questions,let me know.
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assistant
Building&Code ServiCes
(317)571-2489
�-j Plesse consld�a Lhe enviromnere���fore pNnein�{[hisemail
16
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Christopher J. Brayak [cbrayak@wightman-assoc.com]
Sent: Monday, May 12, 2014 10:52 AM
To: Conn, Angelina V
Cc: Hardin, Steven D.;Jim Jaksa; Hollibaugh, Mike P; Keesling, Rachel M; Mishler, Nicholas F;
Clark Brent;'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC dockei no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Attachments: 130343_A2-1 - EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS_Sealed.pdf
Good morning Angie,
As requested, attached please find the sealed revised elevations for the Carmel Horizon Bank building per our discussion
last week.
it is our understanding that this is the last requirement of the Planning Department for approval.
Please feel free to call if there are questions or comments.
Thank you for your help in pushing this through the system.
Chris
____ __-- - ___._ __ _...._____._...�_� . --- - ._ v ___......_ __. _ _. .
From: Conn,Angelina V [mailto:Aconn@carmel.in.gov]
Sent: Friday, May 09, 201412:03 PM
To: Christopher 1. Brayak
Cc: Hardin, Steven D.;Jim Jaksa; Hollibaugh, Mike P; Keesling, Rachel M; Mishler, Nicholas F
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank(PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADIS)
Good afternoon, Chris—
Thank you for working with the Planning Department to amend and finalize the architettural changes, made to the
building after the Plan Commission's approval.Whenever you are ready, please email me revised Sheet A2.1, Exterior
Elevations, so that the DepartmenYCan stamp/approve it.
Then, we will let Nick Mishler(in the Carmel Building Permits Dept.) know about the approval, so that you may continue
to move forward with the permitting process.
Sincerely,
Angie Conn, Planning Administrator
City of Carmel Planning &Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civic Square, 3rd Flr., Garmel, W 46032
Office: 3ll-571-2417 � Direct: 317-571Q281 � Fax: 317-571-2426 � E-mail: aconnCalcarmel.in.qov � Web:
www:carmeldocs.com
Please consider the environment betore printing Ihis e-mail
From: Christopher]. Brayak[mailto:cbrayakCalwiqhtman-assoc.coml
Sent: Thursday, May O8, 2014 8:58 AM
To: Conn, Angelina V
Cc: Hardin, Steven D.; Jim Jaksa; Hollibaugh, Mike P; Keesling, Rachel M; Mishler, Nicholas F
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Hi Angelina,
Thank you for the review. We look Parward to working withyou and Mr. HoEli6augh to create a development that khe
City, Horizon Bank and Wightman and Associates will be proud to be associated with. We have reviewed yaur newest
comments regarding the exterior elevations for the project. Some of the requested changes are achievable while some
i�
of the changes are not viable or practicai. 4Ve will make the chanUes that are practical, achievable and improve the
aesfhetics af the building.The revisions that are not practical or do not improve the character of the will not be made.
Below I offer an explanation for our for our thinking.Also attached please find a copy of the exterior elevation that you
marked up visually describes the requested changes you outlined. I have marked on our response as described below on
the elevations.
The compromises we will enad, as described below, are both in the sprite of your thinking and within the Owners
design intent while being practical and achievable.
These changes do not affect code compliance so we expect that tne City planning and building departments will not hold
up issuance of a buiiding permit for additional review time to address these changes. Plea>e contirm [ha[these
proposed revisions will not liold up permittin�;.
Please review these proposed modifications with Mr. Hollinbaugh. We need to know how to proceed by the end or the
day on Friday the 9`'' .
Thanlc you for your time and consideration of tnis issue.
Please feel free to call if you have questions or comments.
Thanl< You,
Chris
- -- --- - - -- - ___ ___ .� __ -- - -_ —
From: Conn, Angelina V [mailto:Aconn(�carmel.in.aov]
Sent:Wednesday, April 30, 2014 2:35 PM
To: Christopher J. Brayak
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; Keesling, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike P;Jim Jaksa; Mishler, Nicholas F
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank(PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Good afternoon, Chris-
The Department would like to work with you to get the revised exterior architectural elevations approved,
administratively.The Department offers a few design change suggestions, below. Please see the comments, below, as
well as the attached marked-up .pdf, and please respond to each comment. Thank you.
1. South Elevation- It seems like there are too many of the 2" recessed face bricked in area/squares. Is there any
way to remove the middle row of them? If not is not possible,then maybe convert a few of the upper and lower
bricked in areas to a spandrel window with limestone cap?
On the south elevation there are onlv 3 recessed 6rick squares. we aoree to delete the center recessed brick detail over
the dooc We will retai� the brick recesses to the left and ri�ht of the door to maintain [he rhvthm developed usin�
these recesses in the west and south facades. Tf;e recess over the door will be deleted to make that bav speciai avi[h the
door.This door however is not intended to be used to enter the buildin¢. It is an emersencv exit onlv.
2. South Elevation -for the 2" recessed face bricked in area that is located between the 2 doors, please elongate
that to be more of just a 2" recessed bricked in area (without the square limestone accents), to make is look
more like a bricked in window area with limestone cap and sill ?
I do not see merit in creatin� bricked in window ooenin�s. It aeates a look that there was a mistake in the desi�n.
3. South Elevation-can you change that one upper 2" recessed face brick area/square to become a spandrel
window,with limestone cap and sill?
We will �ot install fake windows with spandrel alass.The fake widows will not sit in the wall like thz real windows
because the depth of the wall will be different and the windows will alwavs look differen[ frorn the remainin�; windows
in the buildin�because the�vindows are requires to be clear class and the spandrel glass will be black. We avill add a real
window in this location if our svuc2ural enQineer determines it is feasible and I think he will. There was an issue with the
stair towers earlv on the desiRn bewuse we had too many openin�s in the stair tower which was also bein� used as
shear walls.This also creates a bit of a problem with the HVAC svstem which is alreadv at capacitv at the south side of
the buildin� buc since the stair is not a habitable s�ace we should be ok.
18
4. West Elevation- Again, it seems like there are too many of the 2" recessed face brick area/squares. Maybe
remove the one at the top right corner and also remove the one at the lower right corner. And/or add in a
spandrel window with limestone tap and sill?
We intentionallv desinned in the recessed squares to create the rhvthm described above and as descri6ed abave we will
not add fake windows as thev add no value to the buildin�. We 4vill however add a new window in Iieu of a spandrel
widow in the upper ri�ht comer of the west elevation. This window will be into the break room and will create a more
pleasant space for the users. We originally had a window desianed in this space 6ut the HVAC issues described above
forced us to remove it. We mav have to revise the NVAC svstem to make this space comfortable or request that a tint be
allowed on this window to reduce the heat�ain. We will also have shadeson this window to reduce heat aain. We
cannot add the lower tivindow on the west elevation, The fire department Siamese tonnection is locaTed in this bav and
a pipe will be installed from the fire depart connection uo inro the first floor ceilina space which will �o throu�h the
center of the proposed windo�v.The recessed 6rick will be retained at this location.
East Elevation- please add a 2" recessed, bricked in window area, or a spandrel window to the upper left corner, and
then remove the window that is halfway up on the left side.
The relocation of the window or addition of the soandrel �lass as vou indicated in vour sketch is not feasi6le. There is
control ioint where the CMU 6ack up wall at the stairwav meets me metal stud back up wall in the rest of the buiidin�.
This ioint is required in this precise location. We �vill relocate the window that is located at the stair landin�directly up
to be in line with the remainina second floor windows. The window wiil be difficuli to dear and qeoole�vill not be able
to look out this window however it will still admit li�ht into the stairwav.
Angie COnn, Planning Administrator
City of Carmel Planning &Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civic Square, 3rd Flr., Carmel, IN 46032
Office: 317-571-2417 � Direct 3ll-571-2261 � Fax: 317-571-2426 � E-mail: aconnColcarmel.in.qov � Web:
www.carmeldocs.com
Please consider the environment belore printing this e-mail
From: Christopher]. Breyak [mailto:cbravakColwiahtman-assoc:com] �� � �
Sent: Tuesday, April 29, 2014 11:30 AM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Mishler, Nicholas F
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; Keesling, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike P; ]im ]aksa
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Hi Angela,
We had to move the stair lotation in order to meet a code requirement. In relation to the sYair relocation, There was a
window issue that the�plan commission didn'[ like but allowed. It was an issue with an odd window type and spacing as I
remembec The window issue was corrected with the change as well. We felt this was a minor issue that wouidn't
require Plan Commission approval.
I apologize for not resending the elevations for review.
Chris
- --- -°— -- — - --- � __ __ __
From: Conn, Angelina V fmailto:Aconn@carmel.in.�ov]
Sent:Tuesday, April 29, 2014 11:17 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; Christopher 1. Brayak; Keesling, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike P
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank(PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Good morning, Nick-
The site plan looks good. However, the proposed exterior architectural building elevations are slightly different than
what was approved by the Plan Commission, and I have circled the areas in red on the attached pdf delineating the
19
areas that are different. I need to run this by the Planning Director to make sure we can approve these changes
administratively.
Angi2 Conn, Planning Administrator
City of Carmel Planning.& Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civic Square, 3rd Flr., Carmel, IN 46032
Office: 3ll-571-2417 ( Direct: 317-571-2281 � Fax: 317-571-2426 � Email: aconnCalcarmel.in.aov � Web:
www.carmeldocs.com
Please consider the environment before printing this e-mai!
From: Mishler, Nicholas F
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-Wold, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; 'Greg R.
Hoyes'; 'jclark@vectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, John M; Kempa, Lisa L; 'David Lucas'; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas;
John G; Barnes, David R; 'Larry Beard'; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, )oslyn; Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subjed: Horizon Bank- docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS
Good afternoon-
I rereived plans for the new Horizon Bank,a 7,332 square foot structure at 1216 W.Carmel Dr_ I have attached a digital set of the site and
elevations. Please let me know what your department will need prior to the release of a building permit.. Also,please mpy Douglas Robertson and
Christopher Brayak on your reply. They are both copied on this email.
If you have any questions,let me know.
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assistant
Building&Code Services
(317)571-2489
d,�j Please considzr the environmen:BEforP p�in[ing Yhis emf�il
20
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: ChristopherJ. Brayak [cbrayak@wightman-assoacomJ
Sent: Friday, May09, 2014 12:49 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V
Cc: Christopher J. Brayak; Hardin, Steven D.;Jim Jaksa; Hollibaugh, Mike P; Keesling, Rachel M;
Mishler, Nicholas F
Subject: Re' Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS�
Thank you Angie,
the elevations will be emailed to you on Monday.Thank you so much for your time on this. I hope you have a good
weekend!
Chris
Sent from my iPhone
On May 9, 2014, at 12:02 PM, "Conn, Angelina V° <Aconn@carmel.in.�ov>wrote:
Good afternoon, Chris—
Thank you for working with the Planning Department to amend and finalize the architectural changes,
made to the building after the Plan Commission's approval. Whenever you are ready, please email me
revised Sheet A2.1, Exterior Elevations, so that the Department can stamp/approve it.
Then, we will let Nick Mishler(in the Carmel Building Permits Dept.) know about the approval, so that
you may continue to move forward wi[h the permitting process.
Sincerely,
Angie COnn, Planning Administrator
City of Carmel Planning &Zoning Division �
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civic Square, 3rd Flr., Carmel, IN 46032
Office: 317-571-2417 � Direct: 317-571-2281 � Faz: 317-5714426 � E-mail: aconn(alcarmel.in.qov � Web:
www.carmeldocs.mm
Please consiAe�the environment belora printing this e-mail
From: Christopher J. Brayak [mailto:cbravakCalwiqhtman-assoc.com]
Sent: Thursday, May 08, 2014 8:58 AM
To: Conn, Angelina V
Cc: Hardin, Steven D.; ]im Jaksa; Hollibaugh, Mike P; Keesling, Rachel M; Mishler, Nicholas F
Subjed: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Hi Angelina,
Thank you for the review. We look forward to working with you and Mr. Holiibaugh to create a
development that the City, Horizon Bank and Wightman and Associates will be proud to be associated
with. We have reviewed your newest cornments regarding the exterior elevations for the project. Sarne
of the requested changes are achievable whil� some of the changes are not viable or practicai. We �vill
make the changes that are practical, achievable and improve the aesthetics of the buiiding. The revisions
that are not praetical or do not improve the character of the will not be made. eelow I offer an
expianation for our for our thinking. Also attached please find a copy of the exterior eleva[ion that you
marked up visually describes the requested changes you outlined. I have marked on our response as
desaibed beiow on the elevations.
21
The cc�mpromises we will�anac?, as de�cribed below, are both in the sprite of yoar thinking a;�d witnin
the Owr7er, desi�r7 int�nt while beinp practical ard acnievable.
These changes do not affect eoee cornpliance sa 4+re�xpect that the City planning anc] buildirg
departments will not hold up iswance�of a building perrnii for ad�'itiona! revie+%✓time to address these
�hanges, Please confirm fhat these proposed revisi�ns will not hold up oermitting.
Please review these proposed modifica[4ons vvith i�fl,�. HoIlinbaugn, We need to I<n�w now tQ praeeed by
the eod ef tn2 day on friday tne 9`�' .
7hank yau for your tim� and cansideratian of this issue.
piease fecl frse to call if you have Guesticns or eommcnts.
Thank Y�u,
Chris
From: Conn,Angelina V[mailto Aconn(o�carmel.in.eov] � ��� ^ -m_v _ _ _ _
Sent: Wednesday, April 30, 2014 2:35 PM
To: ChristopherJ. Brayak
Cc: 'dou�las.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; Keesling, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike P;Jim Jaksa; Nlishler,
Nicholas F
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank(PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Good afternoon, Chris—
The Department would like to work with you to get the revised exterior architectural elevations
approved, administratively.The Department offers a few design change suggestions, below. Please see
the comments, below, as well as the attached marked-up .pdf, and please respond to each comment.
Thank you.
1. South Elevation— It seems like there are too many of the 2" recessed face bricked in
area/squares. Is there any way to remove the middle row of them? If not is not possible,then
maybe co�vert a few of the upper and lower bricked in areas to a spandrel wlndow with
limestone cap?
On ihe s�uth elevation Chere are or,lv 3 reressed brick sqaares.we a�ree Co delete the center' recessed
brick detail over.he door We will retain tfi2 �rick recesses fi�khe left and ri�ht of the door tn maintain
Ef�e rhythrn devti�ped usina t'nese recesses in the �uest and south facad�s.The r2cess �ver the door vvill
be deleted to rnake thaf bav spacial with Lhe dooc This �onr however is nct inCended to 6e usqd ±o
entEr the bui!din�. It is an emer�encv exit ox7lv.
2. South Elevation -for the 2" recessed face bricked in area that is located between the 2 doors,
pfease elongate that to be more of just a 2" recessed bricked in area (without the square
limestone accents), to make is look more like a bricked in window area wi[h limestone cap and
sill ?
1 do not see merit in creatin� bricked ir:window openin�s. It creates a look that tivre tivas a n;isYake in
the desi�n.
3. South Elevation—can you change that one upper 2" recessed face brick area/square to become
a spandrel window,with limestone cap and sill?
We svill noL ii�lstall fake wtndows with suandrel��ass.The fake a�idUdvs will not s4t ir,the w�allli'�ce thn rea1
windows��ecause the�deoth af the wafl will be different and the windows will alvvays look �itferent from
the remaining pfindows ir thebuildir� beca�;se the windo�,vs are requires to be elear class�nd the
spands'el�lass vviil be black. We vviil a<id a real window-in this location if our strcctural en ig ne�r
determines'St is fea�ibie and I ehihk he wiil. 1 here Uvas an iss�ia witfi tkie stair towers early on the aesi�n
beeause.we had too manv openin�s in th� skairtower:��hich was also�ein_g used as shear walls. This alsc
creates a bit oF a aroolem�with the HV;�C s�stem which is alrea�v zt ca�acitv at the south sicie of thc
buildinp bu�t since thescair is not a nabitable space we shot:id be ok.
zz
4. West Elevation— Again, it seems like there are too many of the 2" recessed face brick
area/squares. Maybe remove the one at the top right corner and also remove the one at the
lower right corner. And/or add in a spandrel window with limestone cap and sill?
We intentionallv desi�ned in the recessed spuares to create the rhvthm desaibed above and as
described above we Gvill not add fake windows as thev add no value to the buildin�. bVe wili hovfever
add a new window in lieu of a soandrel widow in the upper ri�ht carner of the west elevation. This
window will be into tne break room and 4vill create a more pleasant space for the users. We orieinailv
had a window desi�ned in this space but the HVAC issues clescribed above forced us to remove it. We
mav have to revise the FIVAC svs.em to make this space comfortable or requesk [hat a tintbe allowed on
this window to reduce the heat�ain. We will aiso have shades on this window to reduce heat�ain. We
cannot add the lower window on the west elevation.The fire department Siamese connection is located
in this bav and a pipe will be ins±ailed from the fire depart connection up ir�to the first floor ceilin� space
which will�o through fhe center of the proposed window. 7he recessed brick will �ve retained at this
location.
East Elevation— please add a 2" recessed, bricked in window area, or a spandrel window to the upper
left corner, and then remove the window that is halfway up on the left side.
Tne relocation of the window or addition of the spandrel �lass as vou indicated in vour sketch is not
feasible. There is control ioint where the CMU back up wall at the stairwav meets the metal stud back up
wall in the rest of the buildin�. This ioint is required in this qrecise location. We�vill relocate the windo�.v
that is located at the stair landir:e directiv up to be in line with the remaininQ setond floor windows. The
window will be difficult to clean and people �vill not be able to look out this window however it will still
admit IiQht irto the stairwav.
Angie Conn, Planning Administrator
City of Carmel Planning &Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civic Square, 3rd Flr., Carmel, IN 46032
Office: 317-571-2417 � Direct: 317-5714281 � Fax: 317-571-2426 � E-mail: aconn(olcarmel.in.00v � Web:
www.carmeldocs.com
Please consider the environment belore?rinting this e-mail
From: Christopher 7. Brayak [mailto:cbrayak(a�wiqhtman-assoc.com]
Sent: Tuesday, April 29, 2014 11:30 AM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Mishler, Nicholas F
Cc: 'doualas.robertsonC�o tonnandblank.com'; Keesling, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike P; Jim Jaksa
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADlS)
Hi Angela,
We had to move the stair location in order to meet a code requirement. In relation to tlie stair
relocation, There was a window issue that the plan commission didn't like but allowed. It was an issue
with an odd window type and spacing as I remem6er.The window issue was corrected with the change
as well. We felt this was a minor issue that wouldn't require Plan Commission approval.
i apologize for not resending the elevations for review.
Chris
From: Conn,Angelina V [mailto:AconnC�carmel.in.¢ov]
Sent:Tuesday,April 29, 2014 11:17 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F
Cc: 'dou�las.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; ChristopherJ. erayak; Keesling, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike
P
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
23
Good morning, Nick—
The site plan looks good. However, the proposed exterior architectural building elevations are slightly
different than what wasapproved by the Plan Commission, and I have cirded the areas in red on the
attached pdf delineating the areas that are different. I need to run this by the Planning Director to make
sure we can approve these changes administratively.
Angie Conn, Planning Administrator
City of Carmel Plannin9 &Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civic Square, 3rd Flr., Carmel, IN 46032
Office: 317-571-24ll � Direc[: 3ll-571-2281 � Fax: 317-571-2426 I E-mail: aconnC�carmel.in.qov I Web:
www.carmeldocs.com
Please considei the environment belore printing this e-mail
From: Mishler, Nicholas F ��
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-Wold, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A';
'Greg R. Hoyes;'iclarkCalvectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, ]ohn M; Kempa, Lisa L; 'David Lucas';
Duncan, Gary R; Thomas, John G; Barnes, David R; 'Larry Beard'; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, ]oslyn; ]ordan,
Alex
Cc: 'douqlas.robertsonCa�tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subject: Horizon Bank- docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS
Good afternoon-
I received plans for the new Horizon Bank,a 7,332 square foot structure at 1216 W.Carmel Dr.. I have attached a digital set of
the site and elevations. Please let me know what your department will need prior to the release of a buiiding permit.. Also,
please copy Douglas Robertson and Christopher Brayak on your reply. They are both ropied on Ihis email.
If you have any questions,let me know.
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assistant
Building&Code Services
(317)571-2489
`-�Please consider,ne znvironmen:before puntmg this email
Q0140501122844.pdf>
24
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Conn, Angelina V
Sent: Friday, May 09, 2014 12:03 PM
To: 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Cc: Hardin, Steven D.; Jim Jaksa; Hollibaugh, Mike P; Keesling, Rachel M; Mishler, Nicholas F
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Attach ments: 20140501122844.pdf
Good aftemoon, Chris—
Thank you for working with the Planning Department to amend and finalize the architectural changes, made to the
building after the Plan Commission's approval. Whenever you are ready, please email me revised Sheet A2.1, Exterior
Elevations, so that the Department can stamp/approve it.
Then, we will let Nick Mishler(in the Carmel Building Permits Dept.) know about the approval, so that you may continue
to move forward with the permi[ting process.
Sincerely,
Angie Conn, Planning Administrator
Ciry of Carmel Planning & Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civi� Square, 3rd Rr., Carmel, IN 46032
Office: 317-571-2417 � Direct: 317-571-2281 � Fax: 317-571-2426 I E-mail: aconnC�lcarmel.in.00v � Web:
www.carmeldocs.com
P(ease consider the environment before printing this e-mail
From: Christopher]. Brayak [mailto:cbrayak@wightman-assoc.com] � �
Sent: Thursday, May 08, 2014 8:58 AM
To: Conn, Angelina V
Cc: Hardin, Steven D.; Jim Jaksa; Hollibaugh, Mike P; Keesling, Rachel M; Mishler, Nicholas F
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Hi Angelina,
Thank you for the review.We look Forward to worl<ing with you arid Mr. Hollibaugh to crea[e a development that the
City. Horizon Bank and Wightman and Associates will be proud to be associated with. 4��e have reviewed your newest
comments regarding ihe exterior elevations for the project. Some of the requested changes are achievahle while some
oF the cnanges are not viable or practical. We wiii make the changes chat are practical, achievabie and irnprove the
aesthetics of the building. The revisions that are not practical or do not improve the character of the will not be made.
Below I effer an explanation for our for our thinking, Also aitached please find a copy of the exterior elevation that you
marl<ed up visually descri6es the requzsted changes you ouilined. I have marked on our response as descnbed bela,v on
the elevations.
The compromises we will enad, as described below, are both in the sprite of your thinking and within the Owners
design intent while being practical and achievable.
These changes do not affect code mmpliance so we expect that the City planning and building departmer,ts will not hold
up issuance of a building permii for additional review tiine to address these changes. Please confirm that these
proposed revisions wiil nat hold up permitting.
Please review these proposed modifications with Mr. Hollinbaugh. We need to know how to proceed by the end of ihe
day on Friday the 9`" .
Thank you for your time and consideration of this issue.
Please fenl free to cail if you have questions or comments.
Thank You,
Chris
25
Fram: Conn, Angelina V [mailto:Aconn@carmel.in.�ov]
Sent: Wednesday, April 30, 2014 2:35 PM
To: Christopher J. Brayak
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; Keesling, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike P;Jim Jaksa; Mishler, Nicholas F
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank(PC docket no 13070009 DP/AD�S)
Good afternoon, Chris—
The Department would like to work with you to get the revised exterior architectural elevations approved,
administratively. The Department offers a few design change suggestions, below. Please see the comments, below, as
well as the attached marked-up .pdf, and please respond to each comment. Thank you.
1. South Elevation — It seems like there are too many of the 2" recessed face bricked in area/squares. Is there any
way to remove the middle row of them? If not is not possible, then maybe convert a few of the upper and lower
bricked in areas to a spandrel window with limestone cap?
On the south elevation there are onlv 3 recessed 6rick squares. we apree to delete the center recessed 6rick detail over
the door. 4Ve tivill retain the brick recesses to the left and rieht of the door to maintain the rhvthm developed usinR
these recesses in the 4vest and sou[h facades. The recess over the door evill be deleted to make that bav special evith the
door. This door however is not intended to be used to enter the buiidinR. It is an emeraencV exit oniv.
2. South Elevation -for the 2" recessed face bricked in area that is located between the 2 doors, please elongate
that to be more of just a 2" recessed bricked in area (without the square limestone accen[s), to make is look
more like a bricked in window area with limestone cap and sill ?
I do not see merit in aeatin� 6ricked in �vindow oper,inas. It rzates a Iook that there was a mistake in the desi�n.
3. South Elevation—can you change that one upper 2" recessed face brick area/square to become a spandrel
window, with limestone cap and sill?
N/e will not install fake windows with spandrel �lass. The fake evidows will not sit in the wall like the reai windows
because [he depth of the wali evili be difterent and the windows will alwavs look differe�t from the remainina windows
in the buildin� because the windows are requires to be clear c!ass and the spandrei plass will be black. We will add a real
window in this location if our structural eneineer determines it is feasible and I think he will.There was an issue with the
stair towers earlv on the desianbecause we had too manv openinQS in the stair tower which was also bein� used as
shear walis.This also creates a bit of a pro6lem with the NVpC system which is alreadv at capacitv at the sauth side of
the building but since the stair�s not a habita6le spaw we should be ok.
4. West Elevation— Again, it seems like there are too many of the 2" recessed fate brick area/squares. Maybe
remove the one at the top right corner and also remove the one at the lower right corner. And/or add in a
spandrel window with limes[one cap and sill?
We intentionallv desi�ned in the recessed spuares to create the rhvthm described above and as described above we will
not add fake windows as thev add no value to the buiidin�. We will howevzr add a nzw windew in lieu of a spandrel
widow in tne upper ri�ht corner of the west elevation. This window will be into the 6reak room and will create a more
pleasant space for the users. Wz ori�inali�a had a window designed in this space but the HVAC issues described above
forced us to remove it. We mav have to revise the HVAC svstem to make this space comforta6le or request that a tint be
allowed on this windoev to reduce the heat t;ain. We will also have shades on this window to reduce heat Kain. We
cannot add the lower window on the wes+, elevation. rhe fire department Siamese connection is located in this bay and
a pipe will 6e installed from the fire depart connection up into the first floor ceilin�space which will �o throu�h the
center of the proposed window The recessed brick will be retained at this location.
East Elevation— please add a 2" recessed, bricked in window area, or a spandrel window to the upper left corner, and
then remove the window that is halfway up on the left side.
The relocation of the window or addition af the spandrel la& ss as ou indicated in vour sketch i, not fea,si�le, 1�here�is
controi ioint where the CMU back up wall at the stairway meets the metal sYUd back up wall in the resY of the buildin�.
26
This ioint is required in this precise location We will relocate tne window that is located at the stair landina directiv up
to be in line with the remainin�second floar windo�NS. The window wiil be difficult to dean and peoR�e rovill not be able
to look out this window however it will stil! ac7mit liolit into the stairwav.
Angie Conn, Planning Administrator
City of Carmel Planning &Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civi� Square, 3rd Flr., Carmel, IN 46032
Office: 317-571-2417 � DirecL 317-571-2281 � Fax: 317-571-2426 � E-mail: aconn�acarmel,in.00v � Web:
www.carmeldocs.com �
Please consider the emironment be/ore printing th,is e-mail
From: Christopher J. Brayak [mailto:cbravakCa�wightman-assoc.com] �
Sent: Tuesday, April 29, 2014 11:30 AM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Mishler, Nicholas F
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; Keesling, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike P; Jim ]aksa
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Hi Angela,
We had to move the stair location in order to meet a code requirement. In relation to the stair relocation, There was a
window issue that the plan commission didn't like but allowed. It was an issue with an odd window type and spacing as I
remember. The window issue was torrected with the change as well. We felt this was a minor issue that wouldn't
require Plan Commission approval.
I apologize for not resending the elevations for review.
Chris
- - ----- -- - -- -- - - -- -
From: Conn, Angelina V [mailto;Atonn(�carmel.in.�ov]
Sent:Tuesday, April 29, 2014 11:17 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; ChristopherJ. Brayak; Keesling, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike P
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Good morning, Nick-
The site plan looks good. However, the proposed exterior architectural building elevations are slightly different than
what was approved by the Plan Commission, and I have circled the areas in red on the attached pdf delineating the
areas that are different. I need to run this by the Planning Director to make sure we can approve these changes
administratively.
Angie Conn, Planning Administrator
City of Carmel Planning�&Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civic Square, 3rd Flr., Carmel, tN�46032
Office: 317-571-2417 � Direct: 317-5714261 � Fax: 3ll-571-2426 � E-mail: aconnCcicarmel.in.qov � Web:
www.carmeldocs.com
Please consitler the environment belore printiny this z-mail
From: Mishler, Nicholas F
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-Wold, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; 'Greg R.
Hoyes'; 'jclark@vectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, John M; Kempa, Lisa L; 'David Lucas'; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas,
John G; Barnes, David R; 'Larry Beard'; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, )oslyn; Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subject: Horizon Bank - docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS
z�
Good afternoon-
I received plans for the new Horizon Bank,a 7,332 square foot structure at 1216 W.Carmel Dr.. I have attached a digital set of the site and
e�evations. Please let me know what your department will need prior to the release of a building permit.. Also,please mpy Douglas Robertson and
Christopher Brayak on your reply. They are both copied on this email.
If you have any questions,let me know.
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assistant
Building&Code Services
(317)571-2489
b,�j Vlease mmid2r d�e envirnnment before pneting[hls email
28
Mishler; Nicholas.F
From: ChristopherJ. Brayak [cbrayak@wightman-assoc.comJ
Sent: Thursday, May 08, 2014 4:50 PM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F
Cc: Conn, Angelina V; Thomas, John G; Hollibaugh, Mike P; Jim Jaksa; Hardin, Steven D.
Subject: Horizon Bank Carmel
Hi Nick;
Thank you for providing the status update for the Horizon Bank Plan Review and permit. As you indicated, there are no
plan review comments requiring attention but you are still waiting on the Engineering Department's and Planning
Department's sign offs in order to issue the permit. I will follow up with those departments to determine the status.
Thanks for your work,
Chris
Wightman & Associates, Inc.
Christopher J. Brayak AIA
2303 Pipestone Road
8enton Harbor, MI 49022
269-927-0100 Main
269-927-1300 Fax
877-927-0109 Toll Free
www:wi�htma n-assoc.com
DISCLAIMER
Electronic documents provided by Wightman 8 Associates. Inc. are an instmment of service and are being provided solely as a convenience m !he user. Wightman &
Associates.Inc.makes no representalion regarding.ihe ti�ness of this documeniation lor any particular purpose or suitsbiliry lor use with any soltware or hardware. Oue to[he
easily alterable na�ure o�eleclronic documenls,Ihrough.either intentional or uninlentional means,W iqhtman&Associa�es,Inc.does not make any express or implied warran�y
for the accuracy or completeness ol ihis Hocumenlation. Hard copies shall prevail in any dispute over the accuracy or sufiiciency of electmnic documents and are available
chrough this office. The informa[ion pmvided is proprielaryand shall not 6e copied elec�ronically or olherwise or usetl lor any purpose not au�horized in wriling by Wighlman 8
Associates�, Inc. Thmugh Ihe use o�the information wntzined herein.�he�user agrees m intleriinify and hold Wightman&Associates, Inc. antl i�s employees harmless imm
any loss,damage,liability or cosi.induding reasonable a�tomey's lees,arising from any use or reuse ol any elec�ronic tlocument(s)or iniormation as con�ained herein.
�"� I'lazse mnstder the encir�iiment betore printin�this emaii.
29
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Greg R. Hoyes [Greg.HoyesQa hamiltoncounty.in.gov]
Sent: Thursday, May 08, 2014 4:20 PM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank
Yes,we received the permit and it was issued yesterday afternoon. They are now good to go. Thanks.
a�/Cel� ..`��1�� !IL', L'.1:.L1, �c°SG'
Plan Reviewer
Hamilton County Surveyor's Office
_ �.__.—����_�---_ ___m ___W_.___.._.�____.__---- ___ _«_
From: Mishler, Nicholas F [mailto:nmishlerCalcarmel.in.qov]
Sent:Thursday, May OS, 2014 3:40 PM
To: Greg R. Hoyes
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank
�Greg;any updates on this one?
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assistant
�Building&Code Services
(317)571-2489
yy�'jPl-�seconil �neen+droorr:uzfarepii?ingthlsecidii
_,_. ,„„„._,__.... �........__......-.�... .___.�___.._._..'__..�.,._._._m.._..__.._......_..m_ . . ............... __°.______._�._......._..
From: Greg R. Hoyes [mailto:Greg.Hoves(a�hamiltoncounty.in.00v]
Sent: Tuesday, April 29, 2014 8:15 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F; Conn, Angelina V; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas, John G; Bames; David R; Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.mm'; 'ChrisEopher]. Brayak'
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank
Nick
The Hamilton County Surveyor's Office still needs an outlet request submitted per our TAC review letter. If you have any
questions, please let me know.
l� .�fitl�.e�� CZG; L'.t.,$2; G'��ISC'
Plan Reviewer
Hamilton County Surveyor's Oflice
_ _ .___ _— ____�...._.__�__.�._._ , — _ ______._.... _
From: Mishler, Nicliolas F [mailto:nmishler(a�carmel.in.qov]
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-Wold, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; Greg R. Hoyes;
'jclark@vectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, John M; Kempa, Lisa L; David E. Lucas; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas, John G;
Barnes, David R; Larry D. Beard; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, Joslyn; Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subject: Horizon Bank
Good aftemoon-
30
I received plans for the new Horizon.Bank,.a 7,332 square foot structure at 1216 W.Carmel Dr.. I have attached a digital set of the site and
elevations. Please let me know what your department will need prior to the release of a building permit.. Also,please copy Douglas Robertson and
Christopher Brayak on your reply. They are both copied on this email.
If you have any questions,let me know.
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assistant
Building&Code Services
(317)571-2459
y,�jii�.�s�ton il th=em%iri n r:� b2icrep rJngthiser�2il
31
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Christopher J. Brayak [cbrayak@wightman-assoc.comj
Sent: Thursday, May 08, 2014 8:58 AM
To: Conn, Angelina V
Cc; Hardin, Steven D.; Jim Jaksa; Hollibaugh, Mike P; Keesling, Rachel M; Mishler, Nicholas F
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Attachments: 20140501122844.pdf
Hi Angelina,
i hank you for the revieu. We laok forward to working�.�vith you and Mr. Hollibaugh to creaTe�dcv�io�ment tnat the
Ctty, Horizon 6an4 and Wigh2n5an and Associates 4vill be �r�ud to be essociated �Niti�. We havs rs�ie;veci your newes.
comments regarding th� exteri�r elevatlons far�[he praject. S�me of the requestad changes are achi�vabie wliile sorrie
of the chan�es are not viable or practical. UVe�vil(mal<e [he ch�nges that are pr�actical, achieva�ale and improve the
aestheYics of the building. The revisions ihat are�not practical or do not improve the charaeter of the wiil not be made�.
E3elotni I cffer an explanatien far�our for our thii�king.Alsc attached p;ease find a cop� of the extericr elevakf�n that yau
marked up visually descri6es the requested changes vou outli�ed.J nave marked on our response as described 6el�w on
the elevations.
Tne compromises we wil(enack, as described belowr, are both (n ihe sprP#e o�f yaur thinking and within tha Ow?ers
design in�ent �cihile beina practical end achievable.
Thes� charg=s do not affect cude compfiance so we expect that tne Ci�y planning and buiiding deoa�ments wiil�not�hcld
up issuance of a building permit for adciitional review�ime to adriress these changes. Please confirm that these
prcposed revisiQns will nat hold up permitting.
Please revie�v these proposed mo�+ifications�v�th lvir. Hailinoaugh. We need fo knov� hoUr Yo proceed ty tne end of th,e
day on Friday the 9r'
Thank you for yaur t(me and consideration of this issue.
Please feei free to call if you have ouestions or comrnents.
Thank You,
Chris
_�_ w_w_ ____ ------- ---_...�-- -- —�__ _-- _ _ .
From: Conn, Angelina V [mailto:ACOnn@carmel.in.gov]
Sent: Wednesday, April 30, 2014 2:35 PM
To: Christophe�J. Brayak
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; Keesling, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike P; Jim Jaksa; Mishler, Nicholas F
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Good afternoon, Chris–
The Department would like to work with you to get the revised exterior architectural elevations approved,
administratively. The Department offers a few design change suggestions, below. Please see the comments, below, as
well as the attached marked-up .pdf, and please respond to each comment.Thank you.
1. South Elevation– Itseems like there are too many of the 2" recessed face bricked in area/squares. Is there any
way to remove the middle row of them? If not is not possible, then maybe convert a few of the upper and lower
bricked in areas toa spandrel window with limestone cap?
en the�south elevation there are only 3 recessed 6rick squares. we agree to ��lete the center rece�sed brick cietail over
the door. We�,vill retain the brick recesses to the le`t and rlght�f the door to maintain tl;e�rhythm dev�looe� using
these recesses in*he west and sou[ii facades.�he recess over the door will be deieted to make ehat bay��ecial with the
door.Tnis dnor however is not inTended ta be�used ko�nter the buildin�. It is an eme�gency exit or!y.
2. South Elevation -for the 2" recessed face bricked in area that is bcated between the 2 doors, please elongate
that to be more of just a 2" recessed bricked in area (without the square limestone accents), to make is look
more like a bricked in window area with limestone cap and sill ?
32
I do�not see merit iri creaTing k�ricked in �*lindow openings. It creates a !ook that th�re way a miatake i;� thc desi�n.
3. South Elevation—can you change that one upper 2" recessed face brick area/square to become a spandrel
window, with limestone cap and sill?
iNe avill not install fake wirdovvs witi� �pandrel giass.7hE fake wicla��nrs wifl not sit ia the wall Jike the real windo4vs
because the depth ot the wa!! �vill be different and the windo��;s luill a(arays Eao1� different from the remainin^ Ga��ndosus
in the 6uitc�ing because the U�ir��daws are requires to be clear class and the spandrel glass�vill be biack. �ite will adtl a real
window in this locatio� if our stru�:turai engineer determiizes it is feasib�e dnd !Ehink he v✓ill.There was an issue with the
s.atr towers early on the design because we had tao mar�y openings in the stai;tawer U1hicF was also Geir,g used as
shear walls This aEso creates a bit o�a probiem wiih cl��e H'��C sy�tem �vhich is already �at cap�ei�y at tPze south side of
ths 6uilding but.since the stair is nat a h�bltable space we shoulcl be ok.
4. West Elevation— Again, it seems like there are too many of the 2" recessed face brick area/squares. Maybe
remove the one at the top right corner and also remove the one at the lower right corner. And/or add in a
spandrel window with limestone cap and sill?
We intentionally designed in the recessed �quares to create the rhythm descri6ed above and �s describe�i abeve we wili
not add fake wlndo��rs as they add no �ralue to Che building. We will however add a xaew wsndow in lieu c;a spandrei
widow in the up�er ri�ht corner of the +ntest elevati�n. This windcw will be into the break room ar7u Urili c;earp� more
�Ieasarrt space for th2 users. NJe�originally liad a win�ow desigr�ed in t;iis space �ut tne Nl��1C lssu�s descrihed above
ForcEd us to removc iC. �rVe mey have to r�vis� the HVkC�ys*.em to make this spaee cernfortable or request tha�t a tint be
allov�ed on this �.vindew to reduce the heat�ain. b�Je wili also have shades on this�,vindo�.v ta reduce neat gain. iNe
cannot add the lower window on the west elevatit�n. The Fire department Siamese connection is Iccateci in fhi� oay and
a pipe wiil be�insr�lEed frorri the fire depart connectio:� up intG the first floor wiiing space wfiich �A;ill go t;nro�_igL Che
centee of Tne proposed window.7he recess2t� brick will be retained aC this locaiion�.
East Elevation— please add a 2".recessed, bricked in window area, or a spandrel window to the upperieft corner, and
then remove the window that is halfway up on the left side.
The relocation of the windoWr or add;tion aF:he sp�r�drei glass as you inciicated ir� yc�ur sketcn is not F2asible. There ls
control joir.Y where the CMU back up wali at the stairway �neets the metal stucl back uo watl iri ttre res2 of the bui�ding.
?his joint is required in this precise iocatiori.We will relocate tne window That is iocate�i at thesta�r Iandir,�;direct;y up
to be in line with the r2maining second flear evindaws. Th? Ufindox will oe difficult to clean and people will na: he �ole
ta Iook oi�t tf�is�Nirdow hawever It u�ili >tiil admit Ilgh� inec ahe sCair�vay.
Angie Conn, Planning Administrator
City of Carmel Planoing &Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civic Square, 3rd Flr., Carmel, W 46032
Office: 317-571-2417 � Direct: 317-571-2281 � Fax: 317-571-2426 I Email: aconnCalcarmeCin.qov � Web:
www.carmeldocs.com
Please cons�der the environment before printing[hls e-maii
�.___..___ ___ '..�..___..._ _._..._.___ .._.._..__...._,........__._ __.____._. _,..,....__....,..v.�,..
From: Christopher J. Brayak [mailto:cbravakCo�wiqhtman assoc.com]
Sent: Tuesday, April 29, 2014 11:30 AM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Mishler, Nicholas F
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; Keesling, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike P; Jim Jaksa
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Hi Angela,
We had to move the stair location in order to meet a code requirement. In relation to the stair relocation,There was a
window issue that the plan commission didn't like but allowed. It was an issue with an odd window type and spacing as I
remember.The window issue was corrected with the change as well. We feit this was a minor issue that wouldn't
require PIan�Commission approval.
I apologize for not resending the elevations for review.
33
Chris
, -- -- ------_. _ �� –—�
From: Conn, Angelina V [mailto:Aconn(cacarmel.in.¢ov�
Sent:Tuesday,April 29, 2014 11:17 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; Christopher 1. Brayak; Keesling, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike P
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank(PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Good morning, Nick–
The site plan looks good. However,the proposed exterior architectural building elevations are slightly different than
what was approved by the Plan Commission, and I have circled the areas in red on the attached pdf delineating the
areas that are different. I need to run this by the Planning Director tomake sure we can approve these changes
administratively.
Angie Conn, Planning Administrator
City of Carmel Planning &Zoning Division
Dept, of Community Services
1 Civic Square, 3rd Flr„ Carmel, IN 46032
Office: 317-571-2417 I Direct: 317-571-2281 � Fax:. 317-571-2426 � Email: amnn(olcarmel.in.aov � Web:
www.carmeldocs.com
Please cbnsider the environmenY beiure prrnting ihis e-mail
._,.,_-__.____.__.__�.___�.....____..._....__....___.._..__.mmmm......._.._..........._............_..�'_."____�......._.._.______. _____.._..__._._
From: Mishler, Nicholas F
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-Wold, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; 'Greg R.
Hoyes'; 'jclark@vectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, John M; Kempa, Lisa L; 'David Lucas'; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas,
]ohn G; Barnes, David R; 'Larry Beard'; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, Joslyn; Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; `Christopher J. Brayak'
Subject: Horizon Bank - docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS
Good afternoon-
I received plans for the new Horizon Bank,.a 7,332 spuare foot structure at 1216 W.Carmel Dc. I have attached a digital set of the site and
elevations. Please let me know what your department will need prior ro the release.of.a building permit.. Also,please copy Douglas Robertson and
Christopher Brayak on your reply. They are both copied on this email.
If you have any questions,le[me know.
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assistant
Building&Code Services
(317)571-2489
�,-�j Claas¢con id--i6e enviro r�e ,6eiore pnr•ue�thl5�mail
34
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Conn, Angelina V
Sent: Tuesday, May 06, 2014 10:38 AM
To: Mishler; Nicholas F
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank -docket no 13070009 DPlADLS
Nick-
Last week, I sent the architect some review commentsJsuggestions for some architecture changes. I have not heard back
from the architect yet. Our Dept. has not yet stamped/approved the Elevations.
Angie Conn, Planning Administrator
City of Carmel Planning &Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civic Square, 3rd Rr., Carmel, IN 46032
Office: 317-571-2417 � Direct: 317-571-2281 � Fax: 317-571-2426 � E-mail: aconnCycarmel in.aov � Web:
www.carmeldocs.com
Ptease consider the environmenf betore printing this e-�ttail
_._ . _______.___._....__ _ _..___..._..�_..._._,._, _�,......w.�.,....____.._.__�.___...._�.....,..�.
From: Mishlec, Nicholas F
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; �'rttlejohn, David W; Donahue-WOId, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; 'Greg R.
Hoyes'; 'jclark@vectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, John M; Kempa, Lisa L; 'David Lucas'; Duncan, Gary R; 'lliomas,
John G; Barnes; David R; 'Larry Beard'; Luz, Pamela K; Kass, Joslyn; Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher). Brayak'
Subject: Horizon Bank- docketno 13070009 DP/ADLS
Good aftemoon-
!received plans for the�ew Horizon Bank,a 7,332 square foot structure at 1216 W.Carmel Dr.. I have attached a digital set of the site and
elevations. Please let me know what yourdepartmeot will need prior to the release of a building permit.. Also,please copy Douglas Robertson and
Christopher Brayak on your reply. They are both copied on this email.
If you have any questions,let me know.
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assistant
Building&Code Services
(317)571-2489
y'-�PI_ase mr id :he envN�,�r� .�cefore p r n;[FIi emaii
35
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Kempa, Lisa L
Sent: Monday, May 05, 2014 1:51 PM
To: Duffy, John M; Spearman, Ted A; Bames, David R; Mishler, Nicholas F; Cook, Steve L;
Hollander, Greg H; Smith, Jerry G; Luper, Michael E; Wolfe, Edward W; Hoover, Aaron
Subject: Horizon Bank
We received payment for water and sewer fees for Horizon Bank at Old Meridian and Carmel Dr.
Checkno. 7020118
SewerConnection $1600
Water Connection $2717
Sewer Avallability $432.70
WaterAvailability $640.34
Review $150
�isa /�e�rpa
Carmel Utilities
30 West Main Ste 200
Carmel, IN 46032
317/571-2267
36
Mishler, Nicholas F
Fram: Conn, Angelina V
Sent: W ednesday, April 30, 2014 2:35 PM
To: 'ChristopFierJ. Brayak'
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; Keesling, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike P; Jim Jaksa;
Mishler, Nicholas F
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLSJ
Attachments: Elevations proposed, 4-30-2014.pdf
Good afternoon, Chris—
The Department would like to work with you to get the revised exterior architectural elevations approved,
administratively. The Department offers a few design change suggestions, below. Please see the comments, below, as
well as the attached marked-up .pdf, and please respond to each comment.Thank you.
1. South Elevation— It seems like there are too many of the 2" recessed face bricked in area/squares. Is there any
way to remove the middle row of them? If not is not possible,then maybe convert a few of the upper and lower
bricked in areas to a spandrel window with limestone cap?
2. South Elevation -for the 2" recessed face bricked in area that is located between the 2 doors, please elongate
thatSo be more of just a 2" recessed bricked in area (without the square limestone accents),to make is look
more like a bricked in window area withJimestone cap and sill ?
3. South Elevation—can you change that one upper 2" recessed face brick area/square to become a spandrel
window, with limestone cap and sill?
4. West Elevation— Again, it seems like there are too many of the 2" recessed face brick area/squares. Maybe
remove the one at the top right corner and also remove the one at the lower right cornec And/or add in a
spandrel window with limestone cap and sill?
5. East Elevation— please add a 2" recessed, bricked in window area, or a spandrel window to the upper left
torner, and then remove the window that is halfway up on the left side.
Angie Conn, Planning Administrator
City of Carmel Planning &Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civic Square,3rd Flr., Carmel, IN 46032
Office: 317-571-2417 � Direct: 317-571-2251 I Fax: 317-571-2426 � E-mail: aconnfa�carmel in.qov � Web:
www.carmeldocs.com
Pleass considerYhe environment befora prindng this e-mail
_ _._._._..........`_._.._ _._.._ _..__. ___ "____.___.._..,...______�_...._.._.___
From: Christopher J. Brayak [mailto:cbrayakCa�wiahtman-assoc.com]
Sent: Tuesday, April 29, 2014 11:30 AM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Mishler, Nicholas F
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; Keeslin9, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike P; )im ]aksa
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Hi Angela,
We had to move the stair location'in order to meet a code requirement. In relation to the stair relocation,There wasa
window issue that the pian commission didn't like but aliowed. it was an issue witfi an odd window type and spacing as I
remem6er.The window issue was corrected with the change as well. We felt this was a minor issue that wouldn't
require Plan Commission approval.
I apofogize for not resending the elevations for review.
Chris
37
_. .._ - - _ __-- -- - ----
From: Conn, Angelina V [mailto:Aconn(c�carmel.in.ROV]
Sent:Tuesday, April 29, 2014 11:17 AM
70: Mishler, Nicholas F
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; Christopher J. Brayak; Keesling, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike P
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Good morning, Nitk—
The site plan looks good. However, the proposed exterior architectural building elevations are slightly different than
what was approved by the Plan Commission, and I have cirded the areas in red on the attached pdf delineating the
areas that are different. I need to run this by the Planning Director to make sure we can approve these changes
administratively,
Angie Conn, Planning Administraror
City of Carmel Planning &Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civic Square, 3rd Flr., Carmel, W 46032
Office: 317-571-2417 � Direct: 317-571-2281 � Fax: 317-571-2426 � E-mail: aconnCalcarmel.in.qov � Web:
www.carmeldocs.com
Please consider(ha environmen7 before p�iniing ihis e-mail
�____ __.__.__ _ .__.._...._ _...._..._�_ _._.___�......____--
........._�._..`.____.'_.___.__..___..__
From: Mishler, Nicholas F
Sent: Monday, April Z8, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-Wold, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; 'Greg R.
Hoyes'; 'jclark@vectren.com;'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, John M; Kempa, Lisa L; 'David Lucas'; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas,
John G; Barnes, David R; 'Larry Beard'; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, Joslyn; Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subject: Horizon Bank - docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS
Good afternoon-
i rereived plans for the new Horiron Bank,a 7,332 square foot structure at 1216 W.Carmel Dc. I have attached a digital set of ihe site and
eleva4ions. Please let�me know what your department will need prior ro the release of a.building permit. Also,please mpy Douglas Robertson and
Christopher Brayak-on your reply. They are bo[h copied on this email.
If you have any�questions,let me know.
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assistant
Building&Cade Services
(317)571-2489
�'-�`j Ple�se can i���.he enviv r� r � si�re� n nZ tnls erri�li
38
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Ryan Hartman [Ryan.Hartman@CTRWD.ORG]
Sent: Wednesday,April 30, 2014 8:48 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank
Nick,
Carmel is providing sanitary sewer to this building therefore CTRWD hasno comments. Thank you.
Ryan Hartman, District Engineer
= r Clay Township Regional Waste District
,������ 10701 N. College Avenue, Suite A Indianapolis, Indiana 46280
Phone - 317-844-9200 Mobile - 4"Jebsite - www.dnvd.ora Email - rvan.hartmanCnlctrwd.ora
2013 Public Education Award Recipient 2013 Governor's Award Recipient
�/�2t �tiVtfUttfli@rtI
�2#�?t�d�0i'T i�r
tba wx,�aua5ty�s�ptr�'
Public Education Category Outreach/Education Category
_� _ ._.__._. _________ _ �._ _� __ _�.. ._ _ _.._.,.�. __...___.
From: Mishler, Nicholas F [mailto:nmishlerCalcarmel.in:aov]
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-Wold, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; 'Greg R.
Hoyes'; 'jclark@vedren.com'; Ryan Hartman; DufFy,John M; Kempa; Lisa l; 'David Lucas'; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas,
John G; Barnes, David R; 'Larry Beard'; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, Joslyn; ]ordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subject: Horizon Bank
Good afternoon-
I received plans for the new Horizo� Bank, a 7,332 square foot strucwre at J216 W. Cannel Dr.. I have
attached a digital set of the site and elevations. Please let me know what your department will need prior to the
release of a buildina permit. Also, please copy Douglas Robertson and Christopher Brayak on your reply.
They are both copied on this email.
If you have any questions, let me know�.
Thanks,
39
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Christopher J. Brayak [cbrayak@wightman-assoc.com]
Sent: Tuesday, April 29, 2014 11:30 AM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Mishler, Nicholas F
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com`, Keesling, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike P;Jim Jaksa
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Hi Angela,
We had to move the stair location in order to meet a code requirement. In relation to the stair relocation, There was a
window issue that the plan commission didn't like but allowed. It was an issue with an odd window type and spacing as I
remember. The window issue was corrected with the change as welL We felfthis was a minor issue that wouidn't
require Plan Commission approval.
I apologize for not resending the elevations for review.
Chris
--- -- --- -- -- ___
From: Conn,Angelina V [mailto:AtonnCdtarmel.in.�ovJ
Sent:Tuesday, April 29, 2014 11:17 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; ChristopherJ. Brayak; Keesling, Rachel M; Hollibaugh, Mike P
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank(PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Good morning, Nick—
The site plan looks good. However,the proposed exterior architectural building elevations are slightly different than
what was approved by the Plan Commission, and I have circled the areas in red on the attached pdf delineating the
areas that are different. I need to run this by the Planning Director to make sure we can approve these changes
administratively.
Angie Conn, Planning Administrator
City of Carmel Planning &Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civic Square, 3rd Rr., Carmel, IN 46032
Office: 317-5714417 � Direct: 317-571-2281 � Fax: 317-571-2426 � E-mail: amnnC�lcarmel.in.qov � Web:
www.�armeldocs.com
Please conside�fhe environment belore printing N�is e-mail
From: Mishler, Nicholas F
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-Wold, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; 'Greg R.
Hoyes'; 'jclark@vectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, John M; Kempa, Lisa L; 'David lucas'; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas,
]ohn G; Barnes, David R; 'Larry Beard'; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, ]oslyn; Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher]. Brayak'
Subjed: Horizon Bank- docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS
Good afternoon-
I received plans for the new Horizon Bank,a 7,332 square foot structure at 1216 W.Carmel Dc. I have attached a digital set of the site and
elevations. Please let me know what your department will need prior to the release of a huilding permiL. Also,please copy Douglas Robertson and
Christopher Brayak on your reply. They are both copied on this email.
If you have any qcestions,let me know.
Thanks,
41
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Conn, Angelina V
Sent: Tuesday, April 29, 2014 11:17 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher J. Brayak'; Keesling, Rachel M;
Hollibaugh, Mike P
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank (PC docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS)
Attachments: Elevations proposed, 4-29-2014.pdf
Good morning, Nick—
The site plan looks good. However,the proposed exterior architectural building elevations are slightly different than
what was approved by the Plan Commission, and I have cirded the areas in red on the attached pdf delineating the
areas that are different. I need to run this by the Planning Director to make sure we can approve these changes
administratively.
Angie Conn, Planning administretor
City of Carmel Planning & Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1 Civic Square, 3rd Flr., Carmel, W 46032
Office: 317-571-2417 � Direct 317-571-2281 � Fax: 317-571-2426 � E-mail: aconnCo�carmel.in.00v � Web:
www.carmeldoa.com
Please consider fhe environment belore prnting this e-mail
..._._.._.�.....�.
From: Mishler, Nicholas F
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-Wold, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; 'Greg R.
Hoyes'; 'jclark@vectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, John M; Kempa, Lisa L; 'David Lucas'; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas,
]ohn G; Barnes, David R; 'Larry Beard'; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, Joslyn; ]ordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subject: Horizon Bank- docket no 13070009 DP/ADLS
Good afternoon-
I rereived plans for the new Horizon Bank,a 7,332 square foot struc[ure a[1216 W.Carme�Dr.. I have attached a digi[al se[of the site and
elevations. Please let me know what your department will need prior ro the release of a building permit. Also,please copy Douglas Robertson and
Christopher Brayak on your reply. They are both copied on this email.
If you have any questions,let me know.
Thanks,
Nlck Mishler
AdminisVative Assistant
Building&Code Services
(317)571-2489
V-'�Please ronSiUer:i;e environmerH before printing Ctls emall
43
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Christopher J. Brayak [cbrayak@wightman-assoc.com]
Sent: Tuesday, April 29, 2014 9:07 AM
To: Greg R. Hoyes; Mishler, Nicholas F; Conn, Angelina V; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas; John G;
Barnes, David R;Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank
Hi Greg,
What is the Outlet Request submittal and how can l get it to you?
Thanks,
Chris
-— --- -- _ . .- —
Fram: Greg R. Hoyes [mailto:Gre�.Hoves(�hamiltoncountv.in.aov]
Sent:Tuesday,April 29, 2014 8:15 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F; Conn, Angelina V; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas,John G; Barnes, David R;Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; ChristopherJ. Brayak
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank
Nick
The Hamilton County Surveyor's Office still needs an outlet request submitted per our TAC review letter. If you have any
questions, piease Iet me know.
��et� ��fo��, ClC; G'.y✓6Z, C'.��'SL'
Plan Reviewer
Hamilton County Surveyor's Office
_.__�m .__._.._.�. __ m.._. .._�.._. .__._ _----... __ w . ...___.__ _. ___ _.,_._-------_.__._ ----..---
From: Mishler, Nicholas F [mailto:nmishlerCa�carmel.in.aov]
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-Wold, Alexia K;.Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; Greg R. Hoyes;
'jclark@vectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, ]ohn M; Kempa, Lisa L; David E. Lucas; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas, John G;
Bames, David R; Larry D. Beard; Wx, Pamela K; Kass, )oslyn; ]ordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subject: Horizon Bank
Good afiemoon-
I received plans for the new Horizon Bank,a 7,332 square foot structure at 1216 W.Carmel Dr.. I have attached a digital set of the site and
elevations. Please let me know what your department will need prior to the release of a building permit.. Also,please�copy�ouglas Robertwn and
Christopher Brayak on your rep�y. They are 6oth copied on this email.
If you have any questions,let me know.
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assistant
Building&CodeServices
(3ll)571-2489
y-�j Pt��srcor i 1 iz envii� r i before P �t�n�this zr�jil
44
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Greg R. Hoyes [Greg.Hoyes@hamiltoncounty.in.gov]
Sent: Tuesday, April 29, 2014 8:15 AM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F; Conn, Angelina V; Duncan, Gary R;Thomas, John G; Barnes, David R;
Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com';'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank
Nick
The Hamilton County Surveyor's Office still needs an outlet request submitted per cur TAC review letter. If you have any
questions, please let me know.
�� .��, ae, e��>� �FSe
Plan Reviewer
Hamilton County Surveyor's Office
From: Mishler, Nicholas F [mailto:nmishler(a�carmel.in.qov]
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-WOId, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; Greg R. Hoyes;
'jclark@vectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, )ohn M; Kempa, Lisa L; David E. Lucas; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas, ]ohn G;
Barnes, David R; Larry D. Beard; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, Joslyn; ]ordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subjed: Horizon Bank
Good afternoon-
I received plans for the new Horizon Bank,a 7,332 square foot structure at 1216 W.Carmel Dr.. I have attached a digital set of the site and
elevations. Please let me know what,your department will need prior to the release of a building permit.. Also,please copy Douglas Robertson and
Chrisropher Brayak on your reply. They are both copied on this email.
If you have any questions,let me know.
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assistant
Building&Code Services
(317)57L2489
�3j Please c:msider the enviror.mer:t S^fom prin;ir.g�his emNi!
46
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: Duncan, Gary R
Sent: Monday, April 28; 2014 4:33 PM
To: Mishler, Nicholas F; Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-Wold, Alexia K;
Mindham, Darerr, 'Hunter, ShirleyA; 'Greg R. Hoyes`, 'jclark@vectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman';
Duffy, John M; Kempa, Lisa L; 'David Lucas'; Thomas, John G; Barnes, David R: 'Larry
Beard'; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, Joslyn;Jordan, Alex; Glaser, Fred J
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'ChristopherJ. Brayak'
Subject: RE Horizon Bank
Nick, the following items are in process for Engineering.
1. 9 final sets of plans for stamp and signature by the City Engineer and Carmel Utilities. (thought we might
need 11, but county is not involved so only 9 are required)
2. Submit storm water control 6ond to Dave Barnes in our office for 100%of the approved engineer's
estimate.
3. Pay all fees to Utilities.
4. Submit Right of Way performance bond to Dave Barnes.
S. Obtain Right of Way permit from Fred Glaser in our department. flaaser@carmel.in.�ov
6. Record (example attached) and submit final, bound O&M manual.
7. Submit completed storm water permit application.
Alex J, have we received plans? Dave B, do we have the bonds? Lisa K, have your fees been paid? Fred G, have you
received a right-of-way permit application?John T, have you received the recorded 0&M manual?
Thanks so much!
Gary
From: Mishler, Nicholas F
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-WOId, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; 'Greg R.
Hoyes'; 'jclark@vectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman'; Duffy, )ohn M; Kempa, Lisa L; 'David Lucas'; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas,
]ohn G; Barnes, David R; 'Larry Beard'; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, Joslyn; Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subject: Horizon Bank
Good aftemoon-
I received plans for the new Horizon Bank,a 7,332 square foot structure at 1216 W.Carmel Dr.. I have attached a digital set of the site and
elevations. Please let me know what your department will need prior ro the release of a building permit.. Also,please copy Douglas Robertson and
Christopher Brayak on your reply. They are both copied on this email.
If you have any questions,let me know.
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assistant
Building&Code Services
�317)571-2489
b�j Piet.;r consider:he envi;c^ment before p:i�ting[his emai!
47
Mishler, Nicholas F
From: David E. Lucas [David.Lucas@hamiltoncounty.in.gov]
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 4:04 PM
To: Mishler; Nicholas F; Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-Wold, Alexia K;
Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; Greg R. Hoyes; 'jclark@vectren.com"Ryan Hartman';
Duffy, John M; Kempa, Lisa L; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas, John G; Barnes, David R; Larry D.
Beard; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, Joslyn; Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com; 'Christopher J. Brayak'
Subject: RE: Horizon Bank
Nick,
This project is outside of our jurisdiction. We have no comments or concerns at this time.
David E. Lucas
HCHD Prqject Coordinator
1700 S 10'�Sn'eet
iVoblesville, LV 46060
Phone: 317-773-7770
Direct: 317-770-�74
__�._.____�_— _---...... � ____��..__ . ___� _ «_ ____ _ .,.,__..._?.
From: Mishler, Nicholas F [mailto:nmislilerCa�carmel.in.gov]
Sent: Monday, April 28, 2014 3:15 PM
To: Conn, Angelina V; Littlejohn, David W; Donahue-WOId, Alexia K; Mindham, Daren; 'Hunter, Shirley A'; Greg R. Hoyes;
'jclark@vectren.com'; 'Ryan Hartman; Duffy, John M; Kempa, Lisa L; David E Wcas; Duncan, Gary R; Thomas, John G;
Barnes, David R; Larry D. Beard; Lux, Pamela K; Kass, Joslyn; Jordan, Alex
Cc: 'douglas.robertson@tonnandblank.com'; 'Christopher]. Brayak'
Subject: Horizon Bank
Good afternoon-
I received plans for the new Horizon Bank,a 7,332 square foot structure at 1216 W.Carmel Dr.. I have attached a digital set of the site and
elevations. Please let me know what yourdepartmentwill need prior to[he release of a building permit.. Also,please copy Douglas Robertson and
Christopher Brayak on your reply. They are boih mpied on tFls email.
If you have any questions,let me know.
Thanks,
Nick Mishler
Administrative Assistant
Buiiding&Code Services
(317)571-2489
y„�j��'(ezse con=_itl�r the en-ii-l�imenk be�on_p�int�n6[h is eriiait
48