HomeMy WebLinkAboutLetter from Charles Harris, M.D. Hamilton County Health Department
18030 Foundation Drive, Suite A
Noblesville, In 46060
Phone: (317) 776-8500 or Fax: (317) 776-8506
November 7, 2016
Mr. Andrew P Thomas
33 W National Ave
Brazil, IN 47834
Re: 1150 W. 116th variance application name Bed and Breakfast, Events
Dear Mr. Thomas:
This office has received the variance application for a residential structure located at 1150 W.
116th Street Carmel to be used for a commercial business as a Bed and Breakfast and Event
center. You visited this office and spoke with one of our environmentalists regarding a bed and
breakfast, mentioning at the end of the conversation the possibility of hosting public/private food
events in addition to the Bed and Breakfast use. This office has several concerns that will need
to be addressed before the facility would be approved or permitted to operate as a Bed and
Breakfast or a Food Establishment. There are two specific food regulations, depending upon the
type of operation, as well as separate rules for residential and commercial on-site sewage
disposal requirements that are applicable.
As the site currently utilizes a residential on-site septic system installed 21 years ago, this change
of use needs to reviewed and approved by the Indiana State Department of Health (ISDH)
Division of sanitary engineering prior to local health reviews. This office was copied on an
email from ISDH referencing a bed and breakfast of 6 bedrooms or less could be reviewed by the
local health department. I contacted ISDH, and included the variance application document
submitted to Carmel Technical Advisory Committee for a 7 bedroom bed and breakfast plus
event location use for up to 250 people description. ISDH responded and stated nothing was
mentioned to them regarding the intention of special event uses.
This office further researched the existing on-site septic system installed in 1994. The aerial
photography available on the Hamilton County GIS map room indicates seasonal wetness issues
in the area of the onsite septic system. On-site septic systems are regulated separately for
residential and commercial use. A replacement system would be required to meet current
commercial sizing requirements. The matter of changing use of a structure is not a one to one in
regards to wastewater flow calculations and sizing requirements.
Given the information this office has received and gathered, at this time we cannot support the
use of the current residential structure and onsite septic system for a Bed and Breakfast nor a
Food Establishment. If the location is to be used additionally for special events, a separate
kitchen facilit y must be provided which meets the Retail Food Establishment requirements 410
IAC 7-24. A Bed and Breakfast must meet the Sanitation for Bed and Breakfast IAC 7-15.5
requirements. Either commercial use of the property must have an adequately sized and
approved onsite septic system to accommodate a wastewater flow for a seven (7) bedroom Bed
and Breakfast or Food Establishment with 250 occupancy capacity as applied for under Rule 410
IAC 6-10.1.
I have attached the Email correspondence from ISDH, historic aerial photography, and existing
residential septic system plans as installed in 1995.
Respectfully,
Jason LeMaster, REHS
Director of Environmental Health
CC; Alexia Lopez, Carmel Department of Community Services
Mr. Robert Synko, ISDH Sanitary Engineer
Enclosures
Feet
0 100
1150 W 116th
1996
Printed: Nov 04, 2016
The information on this web site is provided and hosted by Hamilton County, Indiana. Continued use of this web site is conditional
upon your explicit acceptance of the terms and conditions set forth in this disclaimer document. The data provided herein may be
inaccurate and/or out of date. Any person or entity who relies on this data for any purpose whatsoever does so solely at their own
risk. Neither Hamilton County Indiana nor its employees or officers warrant the accuracy, reliability, or timeliness of any of the data
provided herein. This data is provided “as is” without warranty of any kind. Hamilton County may elect to discontinue this service
without notice at any point in the future.
Feet
0 100
1150 W 116th
1998 Tennis Court removed & Site Const
Printed: Nov 04, 2016
The information on this web site is provided and hosted by Hamilton County, Indiana. Continued use of this web site is conditional
upon your explicit acceptance of the terms and conditions set forth in this disclaimer document. The data provided herein may be
inaccurate and/or out of date. Any person or entity who relies on this data for any purpose whatsoever does so solely at their own
risk. Neither Hamilton County Indiana nor its employees or officers warrant the accuracy, reliability, or timeliness of any of the data
provided herein. This data is provided “as is” without warranty of any kind. Hamilton County may elect to discontinue this service
without notice at any point in the future.
Feet
0 100
1150 W 116th
2004
Printed: Nov 04, 2016
The information on this web site is provided and hosted by Hamilton County, Indiana. Continued use of this web site is conditional
upon your explicit acceptance of the terms and conditions set forth in this disclaimer document. The data provided herein may be
inaccurate and/or out of date. Any person or entity who relies on this data for any purpose whatsoever does so solely at their own
risk. Neither Hamilton County Indiana nor its employees or officers warrant the accuracy, reliability, or timeliness of any of the data
provided herein. This data is provided “as is” without warranty of any kind. Hamilton County may elect to discontinue this service
without notice at any point in the future.
Feet
0 100
1150 W 116th
2007
Printed: Nov 04, 2016
The information on this web site is provided and hosted by Hamilton County, Indiana. Continued use of this web site is conditional
upon your explicit acceptance of the terms and conditions set forth in this disclaimer document. The data provided herein may be
inaccurate and/or out of date. Any person or entity who relies on this data for any purpose whatsoever does so solely at their own
risk. Neither Hamilton County Indiana nor its employees or officers warrant the accuracy, reliability, or timeliness of any of the data
provided herein. This data is provided “as is” without warranty of any kind. Hamilton County may elect to discontinue this service
without notice at any point in the future.
Feet
0 100
1150 W 116th
2014
Printed: Nov 04, 2016
The information on this web site is provided and hosted by Hamilton County, Indiana. Continued use of this web site is conditional
upon your explicit acceptance of the terms and conditions set forth in this disclaimer document. The data provided herein may be
inaccurate and/or out of date. Any person or entity who relies on this data for any purpose whatsoever does so solely at their own
risk. Neither Hamilton County Indiana nor its employees or officers warrant the accuracy, reliability, or timeliness of any of the data
provided herein. This data is provided “as is” without warranty of any kind. Hamilton County may elect to discontinue this service
without notice at any point in the future.
Feet
0 100
1150 W 116th
2015
Printed: Nov 04, 2016
The information on this web site is provided and hosted by Hamilton County, Indiana. Continued use of this web site is conditional
upon your explicit acceptance of the terms and conditions set forth in this disclaimer document. The data provided herein may be
inaccurate and/or out of date. Any person or entity who relies on this data for any purpose whatsoever does so solely at their own
risk. Neither Hamilton County Indiana nor its employees or officers warrant the accuracy, reliability, or timeliness of any of the data
provided herein. This data is provided “as is” without warranty of any kind. Hamilton County may elect to discontinue this service
without notice at any point in the future.
Feet
0 100
1150 W 116th
2016
Printed: Nov 04, 2016
The information on this web site is provided and hosted by Hamilton County, Indiana. Continued use of this web site is conditional
upon your explicit acceptance of the terms and conditions set forth in this disclaimer document. The data provided herein may be
inaccurate and/or out of date. Any person or entity who relies on this data for any purpose whatsoever does so solely at their own
risk. Neither Hamilton County Indiana nor its employees or officers warrant the accuracy, reliability, or timeliness of any of the data
provided herein. This data is provided “as is” without warranty of any kind. Hamilton County may elect to discontinue this service
without notice at any point in the future.