HomeMy WebLinkAbout12 December 21 MinutesCRC Meeting, December 21, 2016
1
CARMEL REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION Meeting
Wednesday, December 21, 2016
ATTENDANCE:
President Bill Hammer Present
Vice President Dave Bowers Present
Secretary Henry Mestetsky Present
Treasurer Christine Pauley Present
Member Bill Brooks Present
Member Jeff Worrell Not Present
Member Michael Kerschner Present
Executive Director Corrie Meyer Present
Deputy Director Michael Frischkorn Present
Office Manager Michael Lee Present
Legal Consultant Karl Haas Present
Bond Counsel Bruce Donaldson Present
President Bill Hammer called the meeting to order at 6:33 p.m.
The Pledge of Allegiance was said.
Approval of Minutes
November 16, 2016: Mr. Mestetsky moved to approve, seconded by Mr. Bowers. Approved
unanimously.
Financial Matters
Mr. Lee stated the Commission’s end of the month November balance totaled $2,646,793 with
the TIF balance at $881,560 and, including the restricted funds, the balance totaled $7,371,263.
Update on Outstanding Receivables
Mr. Lee stated there are two outstanding receivables:
1) Project Blue invoices of $15,643.
2) Initial Energy Consumption Fee for The Mezz of $173,205
Approval of Claims
Mr. Lee stated that there are non-operating invoices in the amount of $10,212,170.82. The reason
for the amount of expenses is the bond debt service.
Mr. Lee requested the Commission to approve the non-operation invoices in the amount of
$10,212,170.82. Mr. Bowers moved to approve, seconded by Mr. Mestetsky. Approved
unanimously.
Mr. Lee stated that there are disbursements from the City Center Phase II Bond fund in the
amount of $1,961,475.45. Mr. Mestetsky moved to approve, seconded by Mr. Bowers. Approved
unanimously.
Mr. Lee stated that there is a disbursement to be paid out of the Midtown Phase 1A Bond fund in
the amount of $864,844.46. Mr. Mestetsky moved to approve, seconded by Mr. Bowers.
Approved unanimously.
Mr. Lee stated that there is a disbursement to be paid out of the 2016 COIT Bond in the amount
of $19,320.00. Mr. Mestetsky asked about the final design for the Monon Boulevard project
CRC Meeting, December 21, 2016
2
timeline. Mrs. Meyer stated that the design would be complete in about six months. Mr. Bowers
moved to approve, seconded by Mr. Brooks. Approved unanimously.
Executive Director Reports with Update on Properties
Mrs. Meyer said that the CRC has had a big year starting with the City Center bond issuance. The
Proscenium property was sold with demolition completed. The former Arby’s site will be
acquired by the CRC and an RFP issued for the redevelopment of that site in 2017. The CRC has
started a design initiative on the Monon Trail. The Center Green ice rink is also in the design
stage. The CRC will help facilitate burying a mile of Duke Energy power lines along 1st Avenue
from Carmel to 1st Street NE. The Park East garage will begin its façade install in the coming
weeks.
The Midtown East North garage will begin going vertical in the next month. The Allied building
has its steel structure going up. There will be a high level of coordination between developers and
city departments because of the number of projects happening in a relatively small area. All of the
projects should be complete by 2018 with approximately 2000 apartment units being constructed
within that timeframe.
Finally, the build out on the 4th floor of the Palladium will begin in 2017 with the design in
process. Mr. Bowers asked how the staff was holding up with all of this activity. Mrs. Meyer
thanks the CRC for its support in staffing and thanks the CRC consultants who have helped with
the various projects.
Committee Reports
The Finance Committee did not meet in November.
The Architectural Review Committee did meet on December 7th. The Committee reviewed the
design drawings for the Midtown West project, specifically the mixed use building façade as it
relates to the residential area to the north. Also, the Committee discussed the grade issues on the
Midtown West office building. The Committee also reviewed the sign options for the Tarkington
Garage.
Old Business
Action Item #1: Approval of Declaratory Resolution for Meridian and Main allocation areas
Mr. Donaldson presented the Declaratory Resolution that will break down the Meridian and Main
allocation area and create a new allocation area as the projects occur.
Mr. Bowers moved to approve the Declaratory Resolution. Mr. Brooks seconded. Mr. Mestetsky
abstained with the remaining commissioners approving the resolution.
New Business
Action Item #2: Approval of Resolution 2016-19 re: Acceptance of Arby’s parcel transfer
Mrs. Meyer is asking that the CRC accept the former Arby’s parcel as approved by the City
Council in its November meeting. The CRC will offer the parcel for redevelopment and sale.
Mr. Mestetsky moved to approve. Mr. Brooks seconded. Approved unanimously
Action Item #3: Authorize purchase of Monon and Main parcels
CRC Meeting, December 21, 2016
3
Mrs. Meyer asked to CRC to authorize the purchase of the Monon and Main parcels to assist with
the Monon and Main redevelopment project for $1,614,750. Mr. Lazzara provided an overview of
the project located at the corner of Monon and Main Street.
Mr. Brooks moved to approve. Mr. Mestetsky seconded. Approved unanimously.
Action Item #4: Approve Monon and Main Project Agreement
Mrs. Meyer asked that the CRC approve the Monon and Main Project Agreement. There will be
more documents to come which will include guaranties and requirements of the developer. The
use of the plaza area will go through the BPW much like other public spaces. Mr. Hammer asked
if “Jazz on the Monon” would continue. Mrs. Meyer said that it would. Mr. Bowers noted that he
and Mr. Higgins, with the London Witte Group, met with Mr. Lazzara regarding the capacity and
finances of the developer and that they were satisfied.
Mr. Bowers moved to approve. Mr. Brooks seconded. Approved unanimously.
Action Item #5: Approve Midtown West Project Agreement
Mrs. Meyer asked the CRC to approve the Midtown West Project Agreements. Mrs. Meyer
described the project and the use of a 25-year TIF bond. The bond would be sold in conjunction
with other bonds. Mrs. Meyer also reviewed the layers of protection on the project. Mr. Hammer
asked if the bond would go through the bond bank. Mrs. Pauley said that it would.
Mr. Mestetsky moved to approve. Mr. Bowers seconded. Approved unanimously.
Action Item #6: Approve contract for Monon plaza design, construction documentation, and
construction administration
Mrs. Meyer asked that the CRC approve the Rundell Ernstberger Associates contract amendment.
The CRC needs to move faster on the Monon Plaza than on the Monon Boulevard because of
construction timing. Design would be complete in June with construction starting this summer.
Mr. Mestetsky asked if the design for the plaza would mesh with the trail project. Mrs. Meyer
said that this is a benefit of having one firm do both projects as the design would be the same
throughout the area.
Mr. Bowers moved to approve. Mr. Mestetsky seconded. Approved unanimously.
Action Item #7: Approve letter of engagement for architecture/engineering services
Mrs. Meyer asked the CRC to approve a letter of engagement with Woolpert to be its architect on
call. This arrangement would allow staff to turn work around more quickly and efficiently. Mr.
Bowers asked how this is paid for. Mrs. Meyer noted that the work would often be done under the
various project reimbursement projects so the amount of costs would be paid for via the
developer. Mr. Mestetsky asked if the CRC is getting the best deal in this situation. Mrs. Meyer
stated that we can ask for other architects so the costs should be the same or lower.
Mr. Brooks moved to approve. Mr. Bowers seconded. Approved unanimously.
Action Item #8: Approve letter of engagement for accounting services
Mrs. Meyer asked the CRC to approve a letter of engagement with the London Witte Group.
Primarily the CRC uses the London Witte Group to help review the finances of developers and to
CRC Meeting, December 21, 2016
4
review budgets and cash flow management. Mr. Bowers said that the London Witte Group has
been a great help.
Mr. Mestetsky moved to approve. Mr. Brooks seconded. Approved unanimously.
Action Item #9: Approve Tarkington signage construction package
Mrs. Meyer asked the CRC to approve a signage construction package for the Tarkington Garage.
Because the garage is confusing for the public, the CRC asked for proposals to improve the flow
of traffic including a gateway sign for the entrance. Staff sought three bids. The first bid was from
CSI for $85,192 but they did not bid the gateway sign. They noted that the sign could be between
$50 and $100,000. The second bid was from ISF Sign Specialists for $104,672.26 but did not
build the gateway sign and instead proposed a blade sign on the Civic Theater building. Without
the gateway sign, the entrance is still difficult and confusing to find for the public. The third
proposal is from Signworks which includes all of the items that were requested for a total of
$149,995.00. After reviewing the bids and the work being done, staff recommends the Signworks
bid because it includes all of the elements.
Mr. Brooks moved to approve. Mr. Mestetsky seconded. Approved unanimously.
Action Item #10: Approval of Revised 2016 Budget
Mr. Lee asked the CRC to approve the revised budget based on the numbers as of the end of the
year.
Mr. Bowers moved to approve. Mr. Mestetsky seconded. Approved unanimously.
Other Business
None at this time.
Adjournment
Mr. Bowers moved the meeting be adjourned subject to the execution of documents, seconded by
Mr. Brooks. The meeting was adjourned at 7:46 p.m.
The next regularly scheduled meeting is Wednesday, January 18, 2016 at 6:30 p.m.
An executive session was held prior to the public meeting in which the purchase or lease of real
property was discussed. The Commission hereby certifies that no subject matter was discussed in
the executive session other than the subject matter specified in the public notice.