312806 6/16/2017 Cqq
CITY OF CARMEL, INDIANA VENDOR: 00353406
KRIEG DEVAULT CHECK AMOUNT: $""""15,431.09*
ONE CIVIC SQUARE ONE INDIANA SQUARE,STE 2800 CHECK NUMBER: 312806
?� CARMEL, INDIANA 46032 INDIANAPOLIS IN 46204 CHECK DATE: 06/16/17
DEPARTMENT ACCOUNT PO NUMBER INVOICE NUMBER AMOUNT LEGAL FEES DESCRIPTION
1180 4340000 447655 13,088.59 LEGAL FEES
1180 4340000 447656 2,342.50
0 Q � z 2 q �<
00 / 2 z > 0 /v/
/ 0 / t q #
\ q > R m
> Ln 2
%CL § \ C � :2f \ W O
( m m ■ O % >
}
A.
D c:l
■ \ 00OD cn
\ -n --1 k o / /
3 e 8 \ 2 q m
OL ^
� z
2
g
0 2
] / > -n O
C \ \ q
» ¥ |
�
) i a R - 2 >
& E _ CD / \
k / $ / / ƒ / m
0 A / k o
g $ } $ # 2
CL ;
/ [ / 0 \
/ CD 3 \ (D
a [ J /
/ \ k \
® CL / / \
& f - / f R
% 2 e
/ t .
\
k7 \ m0
i/ ) \ m \ / \
^ «
{ \$ \ D \
) \ 0 #
0 c $ � 4 0 /
RCD
\4kg
/C ° $ ° / ƒ C a
2 J ° _ # k »
� . ° / } §
%C ®
9 CCDr /
ic, 6� f _0
\/ / D
f�
CD \ k o >
§�
/ q. « >
/ \ / \
C $
/ 7 / § E / / § i 0
+ # f \ ® £ \ c
& c
/ CL / \ \ \
Q CD M
/ X
\ (
§ k ® / (
CL > fQ\
§ \
\
OD
; \
I §
� � \
One Indiana Square
(0KRIEGIDEVAULT. Suiie2800
Indianapolis. IN 46204-2079
T:317.636.4341
P:317.636.1507
Ped. I:IN It 35-1055087
City of Carmel
Attn: Douglas C. Haney, Esq.
One Civic Square 1 1 P02 RCVD
51 _
Carmel, IN 46032
May 15,2017
Invoice Number 447655
Our File#: CARL 00003 JCM
Indiana Family Institute, Inc. Litigation
FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES RENDERED THROUGH April 30, 2017
04/01/17 LYG Non Charge: Defense communications regarding proposed case management plan.
0.10 0.00/111- 0.00
04/03/17 LYG Non Charge: Email to Plaintiffs' counsel regarding case management plan.
0.20 0.00/hr 0.00
04/04/17 L,YG Communications with counsel regarding case management plan. Drafting Defendants'
.Joint Submission of Proposed Case Management Plan and Pretrial Order; arrangements
for getting agreement and filing same. Reviewing I'laintills' Amended Complaint and
affidavits, and notes relating to discovery, and outline argument for tomorrow's status
conference.
1.20 490.00/hr 588.00
04/05/17 BRM Call with Libby Goodknight to discuss Interrogatories and Requests for Production to IFI
and IFA.
0.40 310.00/hr 124.00
04/05/17 ,ICM Participate in status conference with all counsel and Court.
1.00 550.00/hr 550.00
04/05/17 LYG Final preparations for and participation in status conference with the Court. F011ow-up
email communications with counsel regarding Trial Rule 16(C) conference and case
management deadlines. Working on written discovery requests.
2.10 490.00/hr 1,029.00
INDIANA •IS GEORGIA FLORIDAMINNESOTA
CARL 00003 Pnge 2
Invoice/1447655
04/06/17 BRM Worked on, drafted and revised interrogatories and Requests for Production of Documents
to Indiana Family Action and Indiana Family Institute.
1.80 310.00/hr 558.00
04/06/17 LYG Assist with draft of written discovery requests. Communications with defense counsel
regarding Trial Rule 16(C) conference and review of draft case management plan.
0.40 490.00/hr 196.00
04/07/17 BRM Worked on and drafted Interrogatories to Indiana Family Institute and Indiana Family
Action.
1.50 310.00/hr 465.00
04/10/17 LYG Non Charge: Communications with defense counsel regarding status of Trial Rule 16(C)
conference.
0.10 0.00/hr 0.00
04/11/17 BRM Drafted and revised Request for Production of Documents and interrogatories to Indiana
Family Institute, Inc.
190 310.00/hr 589.00
04/11/17 LYG Communications with all counsel of record regarding case management plan and Trial
Rule 16(C) conference. Review redline from plaintiffs to case management plan.
"Telephone call and email with defense counsel.
0.70 490.00/hr 343.00
04/12/17 BRM Non Charge: Worked on and revised Answers to Interrogatories and Request for
Production of Documents to Indiana Family Institute, Inc.
0.30 0.00/hr 0.00
04/12/17 JCM Work on issues relating to coordination of Case Management Plan.
0.50 550.00/hr 275.00
04/12/17 LYG Coordinate defense strategy and defense conference call/follow up communications to
discuss plaintiffs' proposed revisions to case management plan. Analyze revisions and
assess alternative deadlines and case management schedule. Prepare proposed redline in
response to plaintiffs' proposed revisions, and draft cover email to plaintiffs' counsel.
Follow up on draft of written discovery requests. Communications with plaintiffs' counsel.
2.00 490.00/hr 980.00
04/13/17 LYG Communications with defense counsel regarding additional changes to revised case
management plan; make changes to CMP and cover email. Communications with
plaintiffs' counsel regarding same. Revise and expand drafts of first set of interrogatories
and requests for production from Carmel Defendants. Prepare for Trial Rule 16(C)
conference with counsel. Participate in "Trial Rule 16(C) conference with counsel and
follow up communications regarding same.
5.40 490.00/hr 2,646.00
04/14/17 LYG Receive and review email and redline of case management plan from plaintiffs' counsel.
CARL 00003 Pale 3
Invoice#447655
Defense communications regarding same. Proposed revisions to same.
0.80 490.00/Ilr 392.00
04/17/17 LYG Communications with defense counsel regarding plaintiffs' latest revisions to CMP.
Telephone call with defense counsel. Create new redline with proposed changes and
proposed email to plaintiffs'counsel.
1.30 490.00/111- 637.00
04/18/17 LYG Telephone call with defense counsel regarding final revisions to Case Management Plan
and cover email. Emails with plaintiffs'counsel regarding approval of plan and filing
same. Finalize same for filing.
0.30 490.00/hr 147.00
04/19/17 ADY Non Charge: Electronically filed the Proposed Case Management Plan and Pretrial Order
with the Hamilton County Superior Court.
0.10 0.00 /hr 0.00
04/19/17 LYG Communications with Kathy Moorhouse in Court's chambers regarding proposed Case
Management Plan. Communications with defense counsel regarding discovery and status
conference. Prepare for conference.
0.50 490.00 /111- 245.00
04/20/17 ICM Preparation for telephonic status conference with Court and all counsel. Participate in
telephonic status conference.
1.00 550.00/111- 550.00
04/20/17 LYG Receive and review approved Case Management Plan and Pretrial Order and coordinate
calendaring of same. Revisions to written discovery requests to IFI. Working to
update/prepare written discovery requests to IFA. Prepare for and participate in telephonic
status conference with the Court; follow up calendaring of additional deadlines: follow up
communications with Court regarding submission of proposed order.
1.90 490.00/hr 931.00
04/21/17 ADY Revised Carmel Defendants' First Request for Production of Documents and Carmel
Detendants' first Set of Interrogatories to Plaintiff, Indiana Family Action, hlc.
0.50 195.00/hr 97.50
04/21/17 LYG Finalize set of written discovery requests to Indiana Family Action.
0.30 490.00/111- 147.00
04/23/17 LYG Non Charge: Receive and review entry from the Court regarding telephone status
conference and supplemental dates with respect to pretrial deadlines.
0.10 0.00/111- 0.00
04/26/17 LYG Further revisions to draft of discovery requests to IFA. Communications with defense
counsel regarding written discovery and strategy related to same.
0.80 490.00/111- 392.00
04/27/17 .ICM C,OmIII UnlCat1OnS with Court and Counsel regarding finalization and entry of Agreed Case
CARL.00003 Pane 4
InvoiceN 447655
Management Plan. Communications with client relating to same.
1.00 550.00/hr 550.00
04/28/17 LYG Reviewing authorities cited in Plaintiffs' Second Amended Complaint; working with
paralegal to identify, research and pull legal authorities cited in Plaintiffs' Second
Amended Complaint in order to start preparing legal defense on merits of constitutional
claims.
0.60 490.00/hr 294.00
04/30/17 LYG Researching information related to Carmel City Council proceedings
0.60 490.00/hr 294.00
Total Fees for this Matter: 29.40 $ 13,019.50
BRM Branic, Matthew C. 5.90 hrs 294.24/hr 1,736.00
LYG Goodknight, Libby Y. 19.40 hrs 477.37 /hr 9,261.00
JCM McDermott, Jeffrey C. 3.50 hrs 550.00/hr 1,925.00
ADY Yeskie, Amy D. 0.60 hrs 162.50/hr 97.50
Total: 29.40 hrs $ 13,019.50
04/30/17 Computerized Research- Westlaw 69.09
Total Disbursements for this Matter: $ 69.09
TOTAL I FES: $ 13,019.50
TOTAL DISBURSEMENTS: $ _ 69.09
TOTAL CHARGES FOR THIS BILL: $ 13,088.59
This invoice is due upon receipt.
Please make checks payable to Krieg DeVault LLP and reference the invoice number.
One Indiana square
K R I E G D E VAU LT Suite 2800
Indianapolis. IN 46204-2079
T:317.636.4311
P:317.636.1507
Ped. I;IN 11 35-1055087
•
City of Carmel
Attn: Douglas C. Haney, Esq.
RCVD
One Civic Square 1�_30_17P02 57 _
Carmel, IN 46032
May 15,2017
Invoice Number 447655
Our File #: CARL 00003 JCM
Indiana Family Institute, Inc. Litigation
FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES RENDERED THROUGH April 30, 2017
04/01/17 LYG Non Charge: Defense communications regarding proposed case management plan.
0.10 0.00/hr 0.00
04/03/17 LYG Non Charge: Email to Plaintiffs' counsel regarding case management plan.
0.20 0.00/hr 0.00
04/04/17 LYG Communications with counsel regarding case management plan. Drafting Defendants'
.Joint Submission of Proposed Case Management Plan and Pretrial Order; arrangements
for getting agreement and filing same. Reviewing Plaintiffs' Amended Complaint and
affidavits, and notes relating to discovery, ane] outline argument for to status
conference.
1.20 490.00/hr 588.00
04/05/17 BRM Call with Libby Goodknight to discuss Interrogatories and Requests for Production to IFI
and IFA.
0.40 310.00/hr 124.00
04/05/17 JCM Participate in status conference with all counsel and Court.
1.00 550.00/hr 550.00
04/05/17 LYG Final preparations for and participation in status conference with the Court. Follow-up
email communications with counsel regarding Trial Rule 16(C) conference and case
management deadlines. Working on written discovery requests.
2.10 490.00/hr 1,029.00
ILLINOISINDIANA •• FLORIDA •
CARL 00003 Page 2
Invoicell 447655
04/06/17 BRM Worked on, drafted and revised interrogatories and Requests for Production of Documents
to Indiana Family Action and Indiana Family Institute.
1.80 310.00/hr 558.00
04/06/17 LYG Assist with draft of written discovery requests. Communications with defense counsel
regarding Trial Rule 16(C) conference and review of draft case management plan.
0.40 490.00/hr 196.00
04/07/17 BRM Worked on and drafted Interrogatories to Indiana Family Institute and Indiana Family
Action.
1.50 310.00/hr 465.00
04/10/17 LYG Non Charge: Communications with defense counsel regarding status of Trial Rule 16(C)
conference.
0.10 0.00/hr 0.00
04/11/17 BRM Drafted and revised Request for Production of Documents and interrogatories to Indiana
Family Institute, Inc.
1.90 310.00/hr 589.00
04/11/17 LYG Communications with all counsel of record regarding case management plan and Trial
Rule 16(C) conference. Review redline from plaintiffs to case management plan.
Telephone call and email with defense counsel.
0.70 490.00/hr 343.00
04/12/17 BRM Non Charge: Worked on and revised Answers to Interrogatories and Request for
Production of Documents to Indiana Family Institute, Inc.
0.30 0.00/hr 0.00
04/12/17 .iCM Work on issues relating to coordination of Case Management Plan.
0.50 550.00/1-ir 275.00
04/12/17 LYG Coordinate defense strategy and defense conference call/follow up communications to
discuss plaintiffs' proposed revisions to case management plan. Analyze revisions and
assess alternative deadlines and case management schedule. Prepare proposed redline in
response to plaintiffs' proposed revisions, and draft cover email to plaintiffs' counsel.
Follow up on draft of written discovery requests. Communications with plaintiffs' counsel.
2.00 490.00/hr 980.00
04/13/17 LYG Communications with defense counsel regarding additional changes to revised case
management plan; make changes to CMP and cover email. Communications with
plaintiffs' counsel regarding same_ Revise and expand drafts of first set of interrogatories
and requests for production from Carmel Defendants. Prepare for Trial Rule 16(C)
conference with counsel. Participate in Trial Rule 16(C) conference with counsel and
110110w up communications regarding same.
5.40 490.00/hr 2,646.00
04/14/17 LYG Receive and review email and redline of case management plan from plaintiffs' counsel.
CARL 00003 Page 3
lnvoicOf 447655
Defense communications regarding same. Proposed revisions to same.
0.80 490.00/hr 392.00
04/17/17 LYG Communications with defense counsel regarding plaintiffs' latest revisions to CMP.
Telephone call with defense counsel. Create new redline with proposed changes and
proposed email to plaintiffs' counsel.
1.30 490.00/hr 637.00
04/18/17 LYG Telephone call with defense counsel regarding final revisions to Case Management Plan
and cover email. Emails with plaintiffs'counsel regarding approval of plan and filing
same. Finalize same for filing.
0.30 490.00 /hr 147.00
04/19/17 ADY Non Charge: Electronically filed the Proposed Case Management Plan and Pretrial Order
with the Hamilton County Superior Court.
0.10 0.00 /hr 0.00
04/19/17 LYG Communications with Kathy Moorhouse in Court's chambers regarding proposed Case
Management Plan. Communications with defense counsel regarding discovery and status
conference. Prepare for conference.
0.50 490.00/hr 245.00
04/20/17 JCM Preparation for telephonic status conference with Court and all counsel. Participate in
telephonic status conference.
1.00 550.00/h1• 550.00
04/20/17 LYG Receive and review approved Case Management Plan and Pretrial Order and coordinate
calendaring of same. Revisions to written discovery requests to IFI. Working to
update/prepare written discovery requests to IFA. Prepare for and participate in telephonic
status conference with the Court; follow up calendaring of additional deadlines: follow up
communications with Court regarding submission of proposed order.
1.90 490.00/hr 931.00
04/21/17 ADY Revised Carmel Defendants' First Request for Production of Documents and Carmel
Detendants' First Set of Interrogatories to Plaintiff, Indiana Family Action, Inc.
0.50 195.00 /hr 97.50
04/21/17 LYG Finalize set of written discovery requests to Indiana Family Action.
0.30 490.00 /hr 147.00
04/23/17 LYG Non Charge: Receive and review entry from the Court regarding telephone status
conference and supplemental dates with respect to pretrial deadlines.
0.10 0.00/111- 0.00
04/26/17 LYG Further revisions to draft of discovery requests to IFA. Communications with defense
counsel regarding written discovery and strategy related to same.
0.80 490.00/hr 392.00
04/27/17 JCM Co111111Lill 1CatiOnS With Court and Counsel regarding finalization and entry of Agreed Case
CARL 00003 Page 4
Invoice#437655
Management Plan. Communications with client relating to same.
1.00 550.00/hr 550.00
04/28/17 LYG Reviewing authorities cited in Plaintiffs' Second Amended Complaint; working with
paralegal to identify, research and pull legal authorities cited in Plaintiffs' Second
Amended Complaint in order to start preparing legal defense on merits of constitutional
claims.
0.60 490.00/hr 294.00
04/30/17 LYG Researching information related to Carmel City Council proceedings
0.60 490.00/hr 294.00
Total Fees for this Matter: 29.40 $ 13,019.50
BRM Branic, Matthew C. 5.90 hrs 294.24/hr 1,736.00
LYG Goodknight, Libby Y. 19.40 hrs 477.37/hr 9,261.00
JCM McDermott, Jeffrey C. 3.50 hrs 550.00/hr 1,925.00
ADY Yeskie, Amy D. 0.60 hrs 162.50/hr 97.50
Total: 29.40 hrs $ 13,019.50
04/30/17 Computerized Research- Westlaw 69.09
Total Disbursements for this Matter: $ 69.09
TOTAL FP.ES: $ 13,019.50
TOTAL DISBURSEMENTS: $_ 69.09
TOTAL CHARGES FOR THIS BILL: $ 13,088.59
'phis invoice is clue upon receipt.
Please make checks payable to Krieg DeVault LLP and reference the invoice number.
\ § § z / /c
n
/ 2 = k I
\ q /2 2 E
c p c U 2
/ 0 m � 2 k -
9
E g q f t �
\ 2 � U)
# -n > % 0
E m
/ o / [ § r \>
3 � > k
CL _w z
3 02
) f > -n O
j 7 \
o w |
Sr
) a a e S f
_ z
k % } / / <a K k
CL F \ O m
CD 3 e \ & Q
g D { ; at Z
CL
cu 2 / § k
E » E 7
m m ( § CD=
0 % 0 A
C / ( � � k
o Z & - ?
= a - 2 m
w , g { \ i
E 7 - f ƒ §
m 3 a
ƒ
Q , >
// \ \ ] m \ { k
mn # y /
tT
{\ . k )
) / o (
0 � t � 0 CP/ a 4 0 (
Do UI m ƒ C a
R0 « _ } 03 / Z >
k/ ° �
/
Er CLFT
a< / [ } &
yE ; a 0 >
}/
C) � \ o D
k
0m > 00
k
Cl) 0 \
n / / d CD
#_ 2E § R 0 -
T ® /
w 2 = . E E } } n
B E - _® M ®
G CL a {
k ^ \ \ (
[ _ > \ \ §
c & Q a
o
§
C) ® k
t.
One Indiana Square
KRIEGIDEVAULT. Suite 28°°
Indianapolis,IN 46204-2079
T:317.636.4341
F:317.636.1507
Fed. EIN#35-1055087
City of Carmel
Attn: Douglas C. Haney, Esq.
One Civic Square
Carmel, IN 46032 05-30-1w02 :54 R C V D
i
May 12, 2017
Invoice Number 447656
Our File #: CARL 00004 JCM
Carmel Energy Center
FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES RENDERED THROUGH April 30, 2017
04/03/17 JCM Meeting with Steve Engelking regarding energy center.
1.00 475.00/hr 475.00
04/04/17 BPH Review notes of meetings regarding energy center issues. Draft summary memoranda of
the same.
0.80 250.00 /hr 200.00
04/11/17 JCM Preparation for meeting with John Duffy. Preparation of witness summaries.
1.50 475.00/hr 712.50
04/12/17 BPH Non Charge: Prepare for and meet with John Duffy regarding energy center.
1.50 0.00 /hr 0.00
04/12/17 JCM Interview with John Duffy.
1.00 475.00/hr 475.00
04/27/17 BPH Draft memorandum of meeting with John Duffy regarding Energy Center.
1.00 250.00 /hr 250.00
04/27/17 TMG Researched the statute of limitations !and whether>�
applies.
Drafted a memorandum summarizing research
1.00 230.00 /hr 230.00
GEORGIA
CARL 00004 Page 2
Invoice#447656
Total Fees for this Matter: 7.80 $ 2,342.50
TMG Gordon, Tiaundra M. 1.00 hrs 230.00/hr 230.00
BPH Holler, Blake P. 3.30 hrs 136.36 /hr 450.00
JCM McDermott, Jeffrey C. 3.50 hrs 475.00/hr 1,662.50
Total: 7.80 hrs $ 2,342.50
TOTAL FEES: $ 2,342.50
TOTAL CHARGES FOR THIS BILL: $ 2,342.50
This invoice is due upon receipt.
Please make checks payable to Krieg DeVault LLP and reference the invoice number.
One Indiana Square
KnIEG -1EVAULT Suite 2800
Indianapolis, IN 46204-2079
T:317.636.4341
F:317.636.1507
Fed. EIN 4 35-1055087
City of Carmel
Attn: Douglas C. Haney, Esq.
One Civic Square
Carmel, IN 46032 0 5-3 0-1 P 0 2 5 4 R C V D
i
May 12, 2017
Invoice Number 447656
Our File#: CARL 00004 JCM
Carmel Energy Center
FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES RENDERED THROUGH April 30, 2017
04/03/17 JCM Meeting with Steve Engelking regarding energy center.
1.00 475.00/hr 475.00
04/04/17 BPH Review notes of meetings regarding energy center issues. Draft summary memoranda of
the same.
0.80 250.00 /hr 200.00
04/11/17 JCM Preparation for meeting with John Duffy. Preparation of witness summaries.
1.50 475.00/hr 712.50
04/12/17 BPH Non Charge: Prepare for and meet with John Duffy regarding energy center.
1.50 0.00/hr 0.00
04/12/17 JCM Interview with John Duffy.
1.00 475.00/hr 475.00
04/27/17 BPH Draft memorandum of meeting with John Duffy regarding Energy Center.
1.00 250.00 /hr 250.00
04/27/17 TMG Researched the statute of limitations !and whether
applies.
Drafted a memorandum summarizing research
1.00 230.00/hr 230.00
GEORGIAINDIANA ILLINOIS
CARL,0000+
Invoiceg 417655 Page 4
Management Plan. Communications with client re)ating to same.
1.00 550.00/hr 550.00
04/28/17 LNG Reviewing authorities cited in Plaintiffs' Second Amended Complaint; working with
paralegal to identify, research and pull legal authorities cited in Plaintiffs' Second
Amended Complaint in order to start preparing legal defense on merits of constitutional
claims.
0.60 490.00/hr 294.00
04/30/17 LYG Researching information related to Carmel City Council proceedings
0.60 490.00/hr 294.00
Total Fees for this Matter: 29.40 $ 13,019.50
BRM Branic, Matthew C. 5.90 hrs 294.24/hr 1,736.00
LYG Goodknight, Libby Y. 19.40 hrs 477.37/hr 9,261.00
JCM McDermott, Jeffrey C. 3.50 hrs 550.00/hr 1,925.00
ADY Yeskie, Amy D. 0.60 hrs 162.50/hr 97.50
Total: 29.40 hrs $ 13,019.50
04/30/17 Computerized Research - Westlaw 69.09
Total Disbursements for this Matter: $ 69.09
TOTAL 1-1=:ES: $ 13,019.50
TOTAL DISBURSEMENTS: $ 69.09
TOTAL CHARGES FOR"THIS BILL: $ 13,088.59
'phis invoice is due upon receipt.
Please make checks payable to Krieg DeVault LLP and reference the invoice number.