HomeMy WebLinkAboutNelson/Nygaard Consulting Assoc, Inc/DOCS/110,000/Transit PlanNelson\Nygaard Consulting Associates, Inc.
Department of Community Services - 2018
Appropriation #1192 43-404.00. 43419.99, 43-509.00; P.O.#102279 �Q i
Contract Not To Exceed $110,135.00
AGREEMENT FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES
THIS AGREEMENT FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES ("Agreement") is hereby made and entered into by
and between the City of Carmel, Indiana, acting by and through its Board of Public Works and Safety (hereinafter
"City"), and Nelson\Nygaard Consulting Associates, Inc. (hereinafter "Professional").
RECITALS
WHEREAS City owns and is responsible for the operation and maintenance of its property, personnel, public
works and infrastructure; and
and
WHEREAS, from time to time, City needs professional assistance in fulfilling its foregoing responsibilities;
WHEREAS, Professional is experienced in providing and desires to provide to City the professional services
("Services") referenced herein; and
WHEREAS, City desires to engage Professional as an independent contractor for the purpose of providing to
City the Services referenced herein;
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing recitals and the covenants and conditions set forth
herein, City and Professional mutually agree as follows:
SECTION 1 INCORPORATION OF RECITALS
The foregoing Recitals are hereby incorporated into this Agreement and made a part hereof.
SECTION 2 SCOPE OF SERVICES
2.1 City desires to engage Professional as an independent contractor for the Services set forth in attached
Exhibit A, incorporated herein by this reference.
2.2 Professional understands and agrees that City may, from time to time, request Professional to provide
additional or modified Services to City. When City desires additional Services from Professional, the City
shall notify Professional of such additional Services desired, as well as the time frame in which same are to
be provided. Only after City has approved Professional's time and cost estimate for the provision of such
additional Services, has encumbered sufficient monies to pay for same, and has authorized Professional, in
writing, to provide such additional Services, shall such Services be provided by Professional to City. A copy
of the City's authorization documents for the purchase of additional Services shall be numbered and attached
hereto in the order in which they are approved by City.
2.3 Time is of the essence of this Agreement.
[X:1Cmv=s7n*ESws k Goods S%vs\D0CS\2018Wdw" Nyyml AVemm DOCS.doc: U1W2UI9 93B AK
Nelson\Nygaard Consulting Associates, Inc.
Department of Community Services - 2018
Appropriation #1192 43-404.00.43-419.99, 43-509.00; P.O.#102279
Contract Not To Exceed $110,135.00
SECTION 3 CITY'S RESPONSIBILITIES
3.1 City shall provide such information as is reasonably necessary for Professional to understand the Services
requested.
3.2 City shall provide all data required for provision of Services. Professional may assume that all data so
provided is correct and complete.
3.3. City shall arrange for Professional to enter upon public and private property as reasonably required for
Professional to perform the Services.
3.4 City shall designate payment of the Services from City budget appropriation number 1192 43404.00, 43-
419.99, 43-509.00 funds.
3.5 City shall designate the Mayor or his duly authorized representative to act on City's behalf on all matters
regarding the Services.
SECTION 4 PROFESSIONAL'S RESPONSIBILITIES
4.1 Professional shall perform the Services pursuant to the terms of this Agreement and within any applicable
time and cost estimate.
4.2 Professional shall coordinate with City its performance of the Services.
4.3 Professional shall provide the Services by following and applying at all times reasonable and lawful
standards as accepted in the industry.
SECTION 5 COMPENSATION
5.1 Professional estimates that the total price for the Services to be provided to City hereunder shall be no more
than One Hundred Ten Thousand One Hundred Thirty Five Dollars ($110,135.00) (the "Estimate").
Professional shall submit an invoice to City no more than once every thirty (30) days for Services provided
City during the time period encompassed by such invoice. Invoices shall be submitted on a form containing
the same information as that contained on the Professional Services Invoice attached hereto as Exhibit B,
incorporated herein by this reference. City shall pay Professional for all undisputed Services rendered and
stated on such invoice within thirty five (35) days from the date of City's receipt of same.
5.2 Professional agrees not to provide any Services to City that would cause the total cost of same to exceed the
Estimate, without City's prior written consent.
(X:`,CoovutrWrof.Sm &Gooch SKSWMO 201MISM NY9"fd Agr t t DOCSAx:111M019938Aft]
2
NelsonWygaard Consulting Associates, Inc.
Department of Community Services - 2018
Appropriation #1192 43-404.00.43-419.99, 43-509.00; P.O.#102279
Contract Not To Exceed $110,135.00
SECTION 6 TERM
Unless otherwise terminated in accordance with the termination provisions set forth in Section 7.1
hereinbelow, this Agreement shall be in effect from the Effective Date through December 31, 2019, and shall,
on the first day of each January thereafter, automatically renew for a period of one (1) calendar year, unless
otherwise agreed by the parties hereto.
SECTION 7 MISCELLANEOUS
7.1 Termination
7.1.1 The obligation to provide all or any portion of the Services under this Agreement may be terminated
by City or Professional, without cause, upon thirty (30) days' notice.
7.1.2 The obligation to provide all or any portion of the Services under this Agreement may be terminated
by City, for cause, immediately upon Professional's receipt of City's "Notice To Cease Services.'
7.1.3 In the event of full or partial Agreement termination, and as full and complete compensation
hereunder, Professional shall be paid for all such Services rendered and expenses incurred as of
the date of termination that are not in dispute, except that such payment amount shall not exceed
the Estimate. Disputed compensation amounts shall be resolved as allowed by law.
7.2 Bindina Effect
City and Professional, and their respective officers, officials, agents, partners and successors in interest are
bound to the other as to all Agreement terms, conditions and obligations.
7.3 No Third Party Beneficiaries
Nothing contained herein shall be construed to give rights or benefits to anyone other than the parties
hereto.
7.4 Relationship
The relationship of the parties hereto shall be as provided for in this Agreement, and neither Professional nor
any of its agents, employees or contractors are City employees. Professional shall have the sole
responsibility to pay to or for its agents, employees and contractors all statutory, contractual and other
benefits and/or obligations as they become due. Professional hereby warrants and indemnifies City for and
from any and all costs, fees, expenses and/or damages incurred by City as a result of any claim for wages,
benefits or otherwise by any agent, employee or contractor of Professional regarding or related to the subject
matter of this Agreement. This indemnification obligation shall survive the termination of this Agreement.
[X Wwrws\Pru&Sm & Goods SwADOCS1201Mdm Nygwd Ag—ml DOCSA-1/102019938 W
Nelson\Nygaard Consulting Associates, Inc.
Department of Community Services - 2018
Appropriation #1192 43-404.00. 43-419.99,43-509.00; P.O.#102279
Contract Not To Exceed $110,135.00
7.5 Insurance
Professional shall procure and maintain with an insurer licensed or authorized to do business in the State of
Indiana such insurance as is necessary for the protection of Professional from claims under workers'
compensation, occupational disease and/or unemployment compensation acts, because of negligent errors
and omissions, because of bodily injury, including, but not limited to, the personal injury, sickness, disease,
or death of any of Professional's employees, agents or contractors and/or because of any injury to or
destruction of property, including, but not limited to, any loss of use resulting therefrom. The coverage
amounts shall be no less than those amounts set forth on attached Exhibit C. Such insurance policies shall
not be canceled without thirty (30) days' prior written notice to City, except non-payment of premium.
7.6 Liens
Professional shall not cause or permit the filing of any lien on any of City's property. In the event such a lien
is filed and Professional fails to remove it within ten (10) days after the date of filing, City shall have the right
to pay or bond over such lien at Professional's sole cost and expense.
7.7 Default
In the event Professional: (a) repudiates, breaches or defaults under any of the terms or conditions of this
Agreement, including Professional's warranties; (b) fails to perform the Services as specified; (c) fails to
make progress so as to endanger timely and proper completion of the Services and does not correct such
failure or breach within five (5) business days after receipt of notice from City specifying same; or (d)
becomes insolvent, files, or has filed against it, a petition for receivership, makes a general assignment for
the benefit of creditors or dissolves, each such event constituting an event of default hereunder, City shall
have the right to terminate all or any part of this Agreement, without liability to Professional and to exercise
any other rights or remedies available to it at law or in equity.
7.8 Government Compliance
Professional agrees to comply with all laws, executive orders, rules and regulations applicable to
Professional's performance of its obligations under this Agreement, all relevant provisions of which being
hereby incorporated herein by this reference, to keep all of Professionals' required professional licenses and
certifications valid and current, and to indemnify and hold harmless City from any and all losses, damages,
costs, liabilities, damages, costs and attorney fees resulting from any failure by Professional to do so. This
indemnification obligation shall survive the termination of this Agreement.
7.9 Indemnification
Professional shall indemnify and hold harmless City and its officers, officials, employees and agents from all
losses, liabilities, claims, judgments and liens, including, but not limited to, all damages, costs, expenses and
attorney fees arising out of any intentional misconduct or negligent act or omission of Professional and/or any
of its employees, agents or contractors in the performance of this Agreement. This indemnification obligation
shall survive the termination of this Agreement.
[X: wTwsWof Ss & Goods Sva1DOCS1 OMNd; Nygwd Ag-1 DMA-11IM0199.38 AK
Nelson\Nygaard Consulting Associates, Inc.
Department of Community Services - 2018
Appropriation #1192 43-404.00. 43419.99, 43-509.00; P.O.#102279
Contract Not To Exceed $110,135.00
7.10 Discrimination Prohibition
Professional represents and warrants that it and each of its employees, agents and contractors shall comply
with all existing and future laws prohibiting discrimination against any employee, applicant for employment
and/or other person in the subcontracting of work and/or in the performance of any Services contemplated by
this Agreement with respect to hire, tenure, terms, conditions or privileges of employment or any matter
directly or indirectly related to employment, subcontracting or work performance hereunder because of race,
religion, color, sex, handicap, national origin, ancestry, age, disabled veteran status or Vietnam era veteran
status. This indemnification obligation shall survive the termination of this Agreement.
7.11 E-Verify
Pursuant to I.C. § 22-5-1.7 et seq., Professional shall enroll in and verify the work eligibility status of all of its
newly -hired employees using the E-Verify program, if it has not already done so as of the date of this
Agreement. Professional is further required to execute the attached Affidavit, herein referred to as Exhibit D,
which is an Affidavit affirming that: (i) Professional is enrolled and is participating in the E-verify program, and
(ii) Professional does not knowingly employ any unauthorized aliens. This Addendum incorporates by
reference, and in its entirety, attached Exhibit D. In support of the Affidavit, Professional shall provide the City
with documentation that it has enrolled and is participating in the E-Verify program. This Agreement shall not
take effect until said Affidavit is signed by Professional and delivered to the City's authorized representative.
Should Professional subcontract for the performance of any work under this Addendum, the
Professional shall require any subcontractor(s) to certify by affidavit that: (i) the subcontractor does not
knowingly employ or contract with any unauthorized aliens, and (ii) the subcontractor has enrolled and is
participating in the E-verify program. Professional shall maintain a copy of such certification for the duration
of the term of any subcontract. Professional shall also deliver a copy of the certification to the City within
seven (7) days of the effective date of the subcontract.
If Professional, or any subcontractor of Professional, knowingly employs or contracts with any
unauthorized aliens, or retains an employee or contract with a person that the Professional or subcontractor
subsequently learns is an unauthorized alien, Professional shall terminate the employment of or contract with
the unauthorized alien within thirty (30) days ("Cure Period,). Should the Professional or any subcontractor of
Professional fail to cure within the Cure Period, the City has the right to terminate this Agreement without
consequence.
The E-Verify requirements of this Agreement will not apply, should the E-Verify program cease to exist.
7.12 Severability
If any provision of this Agreement is held to be invalid, illegal or unenforceable by a court of competent
jurisdiction, that provision shall be stricken, and all other provisions of this Agreement that can operate
independently of same shall continue in full force and effect.
{X1Cootr.ti\Rof.S—& Goods Svts1DM%201Mdw Nyg—dAU—w DOCS.-1/1020199:58 AM
Nelson\Nygaard Consulting Associates, Inc.
Department of Community Services - 2018
Appropriation #1192 43-404.00. 43-419.99, 43-509.00; P.O.4102279
Contract Not To Exceed $110,135.00
7.13 Notice
Any notice, invoice, order or other correspondence required or allowed to be sent pursuant to this Agreement
shall be written and either hand -delivered or sent by prepaid U.S. certified mail, return receipt requested,
addressed to the parties as follows:
14gW l
City of Carmel
Department of Community Services
One Civic Square
Carmel, Indiana 46032
ATTENTION: Mike Hollibaugh
PROFESSIONAL:
NelsonlNygaard Consulting Associates, Inc.
621 SW Morrison St., Suite 1250
Portland, OR 97205
ATTENTION: Managing Director
Douglas C. Haney
Corporation Counsel
One Civic Square
Carmel, Indiana 46032
Notwithstanding the above, City may orally provide to Professional any notice required or permitted by this
Agreement, provided that such notice shall also then be sent as required by this paragraph within ten (10)
business days from the date of such oral notice.
7.14 Effective Date
The effective date ("Effective Date") of this Agreement shall be the date on which the last of the parties
hereto executes same.
7.15 Governing Law; Lawsuits
This Agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the State of Indiana,
except for its conflict of laws provisions, as well as by all ordinances and codes of the City of Carmel,
Indiana. The parties agree that, in the event a lawsuit is filed hereunder, they waive any right to a jury trial
they may have, agree to file such lawsuit in an appropriate court in Hamilton County, Indiana only, and agree
that such court is the appropriate venue for and has jurisdiction over same.
7.16 Waiver
Any delay or inaction on the part of either party in exercising or pursuing its rights and/or remedies hereunder
or under law shall not operate to waive any such rights and/or remedies nor in any way affect the rights of
such party to require such performance at any time thereafter.
[X:\CmffW& f..Sv k Giab Svc3\D0CSUQ19 N&m Nnaud Aar m wl D0C&doc:1/11 2019 9:Stl AM)
6
Nelson\Nygaard Consulting Associates, Inc.
Department of Community Services - 2018
Appropriation #1192 43-404.00.43-419.99, 43-509.00; P.O.#102279
Contract Not To Exceed $110,135.00
7.17 Non -Assignment
Professional shall not assign or pledge this Agreement nor delegate its obligations hereunder without City's
prior written consent.
7.18 Entire Agreement
This Agreement contains the entire agreement of and between the parties hereto with respect to the subject
matter hereof, and no prior agreement, understanding or representation pertaining to such subject matter,
written or oral, shall be effective for any purpose, No provision of this Agreement may be amended, added to
or subtracted from except by an agreement in writing signed by both parties hereto and/or their respective
successors in interest. To the extent any provision contained in this Agreement conflicts with any provision
contained in any exhibit attached hereto, the provision contained in this Agreement shall prevail.
7.19 Representation and Warranties
Each party hereto represents and warrants that it is authorized to enter into this Agreement and that any
person or entity executing this Agreement on behalf of such party has the authority to bind such party or the
party which they represent, as the case may be.
7.20 Headings
All headings and sections of this Agreement are inserted for convenience only and do not form a part of this
Agreement nor limit, expand or otherMse alter the meaning of any provision hereof.
7.21 Advice of Counsel
The parties warrant that they have read this Agreement and fully understand it, have had an opportunity to
obtain the advice and assistance of counsel throughout the negotiation of same, and enter into same freely,
voluntarily, and without any duress, undue influence or coercion.
7.22 Copyright
City acknowledges that various materials which may be used and/or generated by Professional in
performance of Services, including forms, job description formats, comprehensive position questionnaire,
compensation and classification plan and reports are copyrighted. City agrees that all ownership rights and
copyrights thereto lie with Professional, and City will use them solely for and on behalf of its own operations.
City agrees that it will take appropriate action with its employees to satisfy its obligations with respect to use,
copying, protection and security of Professional's property.
7.23 Personnel
Professional represents that it has, or will secure at its own expense, all personnel required in performing the
services under this agreement. Such personnel shall not be employees of or have any contractual
relationship with City. All of the services required hereunder will be performed by Professional or under his
supervision and all personnel engaged in the work shall be fully qualified to perform such services.
PbCatndslProCSv d Goods Svcs\DOCS120181Ndsw Nygaard Agremat DOCSAml/1012019935 AMA
Nelson\Nygaard Consulting Associates, Inc.
Department of Community Services - 2018
Appropriation #1192 43404.00.43-419.99, 43-509.00; P.O.#102279
Contract Not To Exceed $110,135.00
7.24 Records and Inspections
Professional shall maintain full and accurate records with respect to all matters covered under this
agreement for three (3) years after the expiration or early termination of this Agreement. City shall have free
access at all proper times to such records and the right to examine and audit the same and to make
transcripts there from, and to inspect all program data, documents, proceedings and activities.
7.25 Accomplishment of Proiect
Professional shall commence, carry on, and complete the project with all practicable dispatch, in a sound
economical and efficient manner, in accordance with the provisions thereof and all applicable laws. In
accomplishing the project, Professional shall take such steps as are appropriate to ensure that the work
involved is properly coordinated with related work being carved on within City's organization.
7.26 Debarment And Suspension
7.26.1 The Professional certifies by entering into this Agreement that neither it nor its principals nor any of
its subcontractors are presently debarred, suspended, proposed for debarment, declared ineligible or
voluntarily excluded from entering into this Agreement by any federal agency or by any department, agency
or political subdivision of the State of Indiana. The term "principal" for purposes of this Agreement means an
officer, director, owner, partner, key employee or other person with primary management or supervisory
responsibilities, or a person who has a critical influence on or substantive control over the operations of the
Professional.
7.26.2 The Professional certifies that it has verified the state and federal suspension and debarment status
for all subcontractors receiving funds under this Agreement and shall be solely responsible for any
recoupment, penalties or costs that might arise from use of a suspended or debarred subcontractor. The
Professional shall immediately notify the City if any subcontractor becomes debarred or suspended, and
shall, at the City's request, take all steps required by the City to terminate its contractual relationship with the
subcontractor for work to be performed under this Agreement.
7.27 Access to Public Records Act
Professional understands and agrees that any "public record", as that term is defined in Indiana Code 5-14-3-
2(m), as amended, that is related to the subject matter of this Agreement, whether the same is in the
possession or control of the Professional or the City, shall be subject to release under and pursuant to the
provisions of Indiana's Access to Public Records Act, as codified in Indiana Code 5-14-3-1, et se ., as
amended.
[XXoot aas\ProCSm & Goads SwODOM7D151Msoo Ny&Md Ara l DOCSda:1110S2019 938 AM)
Nelson\Nygaard Consulting Associates, Inc.
Department of Community Services - 2018
Appropriation #1192 43-404.00. 43419.99, 43-509.00; P.O.#102279
Contract Not To Exceed $110,135.00
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have made and executed this Agreement as follows:
CITY OF CARMEL, INDIANA
by and through its Board of Public
Works and Safety
BY:
ames Brainard, Presiding Officer
Date:
1
Lori S. Wats ember
Date: �.J (�
ATTE T, Y
G
ristine S. Pauley, Clerk-Tre s rer
Date:
P0Ca*a=\ftCSmdhoods Svcs1DOCS1201 SWtim Nygurd AVce lDOCSAX:l/10'2019938 AM
NELSONINYGAARD CONSULTING
ASSOCIATES, INC.
BY:
� 4' a
Authorize Signature
Printed Name: CA H A 0 V, L LrX^'l L
Title: F1'4A'JGr— M J
FIDITIN: 5S —2,597,413
Last Four of SSN if Sole Proprietor:
Date: � ( 71� I I
NELSON
NYGAARD
December 6, 2018
City of Carmel, Indiana
Transit Plan
Submitted by
Nelson\Nygaard Consulting Associates
706 South Hill Street, Suite 1200, Los Angeles, CA 90014
213-785-5501
NELSON ---
N YG A A R D CONTACT: Hazel Scher TITLE: Senior Associate
EMAIL: hscher@nelsonnygaard.com
Firm Qualifications and Experience
We Put People First
Nelson\Nygaard Consulting Associates, Inc. is an internationally recognized firm committed to
developing transportation systems that promote vibrant, sustainable, and accessible
communities. Founded in 1987, Nelson\Nygaard has grown from its roots in transit planning to
full -service transportation firm with over 130 people in offices across the United States.
Nelson\Nygaard puts people first. We recognize that transportation is not an end by itself but a
platform for achieving broader community goals of mobility, equity, economic development, and
healthy living. Our hands-on, national experience informs but does not dictate local solutions.
Built on consensus and a multimodal approach, our plans are renowned as practical and
implementable.
NelsonlNygaard specializes in:
Transit
(■ I Transit planning is at the core of Nelson\Nygaard's practice. Our experience covers all types of
transit service. Our clients range from rural providers to municipal operators to large urban
agencies. We specialize In designing transit services that achieve mobility and sustainability
iL�3r goals.
Emerging Mobility
Nelson\Nygaard is committed to emerging mobility solutions that address specific mobility
challenges and Improve access for all. Our experience includes facilitating public -private
tt#' partnerships for transit and paratransit services. Improving first/last mile access. and developing
services that tallor technology enhancements to local context to improve local circulation.
Paratransit and Community Transportation
Nelson\Nygaard boasts some of the leading paratransit planning experts In the U.S. We develop
p the best strategies to increase operating efficiencies and meet ADA compliance and service
quality standards.
706 SOUTH HILL STREET, SUITE 1200 LOS ANGELES, CA 90014 213-785 Exhibit-5500 �����
www.nelsonnygoord.com
TRANSIT PLAN
City of Carmel
Project Understanding and Approach
After completing a regional transit plan in 2016 that did not garner enough public support for a
successful ballot initiative, Hamilton County remains unnerved by any fixed -route transit service.
As the neighboring community to Marion County and Indianapolis, Carmel is envisioned as the
first extension of the IndyGo Red Line. While currently unfunded beyond the Marion County
boundary, the development of this High Capacity Transit service in the coming years warrants a
complementary plan for providing access to the Phase 1 terminus and eventually feeder options to
the Phase 2 service through the core of Carmel. In addition, Carmel's vibrant Arts and Design
District and other local destinations may warrant some form of local transit service to provide
residents and visitors with alternative transportation options.
Nelson\Nygaard is excited about the opportunity of assisting the City of Carmel with evaluating
local and regional mobility needs, particularly as it relates to access to employment, education,
health care, regional transit, and other community resources. We designed a work plan that uses
comprehensive analyses and stakeholder engagement as a foundation for potential mobility
solutions and strategies, while enabling our team to deliver a product that meets and exceeds
expectations.
1.1 Kickoff Meeting
Following the notice to proceed, we will initiate the project with a kickoff meeting to bring
together City of Carmel staff and key members of the Nelson\Nygaard team. The consultant team
will personally meet with staff for the following purposes:
■ Discuss project objectives and priorities
■ Fine-tune the project scope and schedule
■ Identify relevant data from prior planning work
■ Discuss immediate next steps, upcoming meetings, and deliverables
As part of our kickoff meeting activities, we also propose to spend time onsite touring the city to
observe recent development and other changes. We encourage staff to accompany us as we tour
the city and also recommend convening as a group at the end of our site visit to discuss our initial
impressions and ideas. This process ensures we develop a common understanding and get up to
speed quickly.
A draft kickoff agenda will be submitted to staff for review and revision prior to the meeting and
notes will be recorded. Following the kickoff meeting, we will refine the project schedule as
necessary and pro -Me a meeting summary. We will also set up a standing biweekly conference
call time for the project team in order to ensure that there are frequent opportunities to check in
and that any issues may be resolved in a short timeframe.
1.2 Stakeholder Engagement Plan
Our team will integrate stakeholder participation throughout the planning process to ensure that
the project reflects the shared needs, priorities, and values as expressed by leaders in the
Exhibit
Nelsonftgaard Consulting Associates, Inc. 2 CiT ! C'
TRANSIT PLAN
City of Carmel
community. Following the project kickoff meeting, our team will finalize the stakeholder
engagement plan discussed more in Task 3.
2.1 Document Review
Immediately following the kickoff meeting, we will conduct a thorough review of relevant
comprehensive and transportation plans and studies. We will confirm a list of existing documents
to review during the kickoff meeting, but anticipate that it will include the following:
■ Carmel Clay Comprehensive Plan (2oi6)
• Central Indiana Transit Plan (2oi6)
■ Indianapolis MPO 2045 Long Range Transportation Plan (2017)
■ Indianapolis MPO Transit Impact Study (ongoing)
■ Midtown Redevelopment Plan (2012)
■ Merchant's Square Redevelopment Plan (2012)
The document review will provide background on community goals, objectives, and policies. We
will also review relevant research, surveys, and inter -local agreements as directed by staff.
2.2 Land Use and Infrastructure
As a starting point in our analysis of existing conditions in Carmel, we will develop a series of
maps and narratives detailing zoning, future land use, public -owned parcels, proposed
development, existing roadway network, street characteristics, signalized intersections, and traffic
volumes. We will also map multimodal transportation features, such as the existing sidewalk and
bikeway networks, curb ramps, pedestrian crossings, and bicycle facilities to demonstrate how
they might interact with transit.
This multimodal assessment will inform the development of initial service concepts. Because
pedestrian access is a crucial aspect of transit usage, we will use a combination of field evaluation
and Nearmap high -resolution imagery to identify physical barriers to mobility, such as highways,
large parcels, railroads, and waterways.
2.3 Transportation Services Inventory
Currently the Hamilton County Express is the only general public transit service in Hamilton
County. In addition, the Primelife Enrichment service provides transportation to persons over the
age of 50. For each service, we will produce a profile that will summarize eligibility, availability
(days of service, hours of operation, etc.) and fare, if any. In past transit studies for similar
communities, we have obtained travel pattern data from transportation providers to gain insight
on travel demand and unmet public transit needs.
We will request trip manifest data from each service operator to understand origin/destination
usage patterns of these services. By summarizing and mapping this data we Nvill be able to
understand where the major trip generators are within Carmel, and whether trips are being made
locally (starting and ending in Carmel), connecting to other parts of Hamilton County, or
connecting to Marion County. If available, we %rill also map usage patterns of Carmel's Zagster
Bike Share system in order understand opportunities for integrating modes and broadening the
potential for multimodal trips.
Exhibit
Nelson\Nygaard Consulting Associates, Inc. 3ofD
TRANSIT PLAN
City of Carmel
We will also request relevant data from CIRTA's Commuter Connect vanpool program to identify
travel patterns of commuters living or working in Carmel. While the service is no longer
operational, we will also request historical information on the commuter express service that
operated between 2oo8 and 2014 to connect residents to Indianapolis, as it may serve as an
indicator of latent demand for future transit service. In addition, we will request any statistics on
ridership that may have been collected in the 2018 holiday season on the Carmel Holiday Trolley
to understand if there may be opportunities to expand this service to other parts of the year.
2.4 Comprehensive Market Analysis
Understanding demand is a fundamental step in developing a transit plan. Using the latest
Census American Community Survey (ACS) data, we will develop maps depicting population,
employment and other demographic or socio-economic densities. We will also create a transit
demand index map to illustrate which residential areas have the greatest need for transit service.
In addition, we will analyze data from
the U.S. Census Longitudinal
Employer -Household Dynamics
(LEHD) to understand local and
regional employment travel patterns.
LEHD data will provide information on
where residents of Carmel work and
where employees working in Carmel
live in order to identify the strongest
potential markets for job -access
service. LEHD data can alsobe
segmented by income and industry to
pinpoint the home -work travel flows of
populations that are more likely to use
transit.
TRANSIT PROPENSITY
-'� - . �-L•r ter -
Through the review of existing documents and collective staff knowledge, we will also identify key
destinations and activity centers.
Indianapolis MPO population, employment and travel demand data will provide insight into
existing travel patterns and anticipated growth in Carmel. Nelson\Nygaard will create maps
showing trip volumes between Carmel and other areas of the region that will help inform major
origin and destination patterns.
2.5 Peer Review
The purpose of the peer review is to evaluate transit best practices of cities similar to Carmel to
identify best practices and potential pitfalls involved in the development of transit services. The
cities selected for this analysis will be similar in terms of population, density, predominant
commute patterns, and proximity to major regional urban centers.
Transit characteristics evaluated in this peer review include the evolution of transit service,
operating structure, funding strategies, ridership performance, local partnerships, and regional
coordination. The peer review will also include case studies that demonstrate a variety of ways
that cities with similar characteristics as Carmel have structured, implemented, and developed
new service, and partnered or contracted with neighboring transit system. Findings of the peer
Exhibit
NelsonlNygaard Consulting Associates, Inc. cl600
TRANSIT PLAN
City of Carmel
review are intended to inform city council members and members of the community of how
Carmel compares with peer cities in terms of transit needs and options.
2.6 Existing and Future Conditions Report
Technical work described in tasks 2.1-2.5 will be summarized in an Existing and Future
Conditions Report, which uses visually appealing maps and graphics to present key findings and
identify transit needs, challenges, and opportunities for implementing transit, paratransit or
other emerging mobility services in Carmel.
Deliverable: Existing and Future Conditions Report
3.1 Stakeholder Meetings
In collaboration with City of Carmel Community Relations Department, we will compile a
database of stakeholders that represent different segments of the community. We anticipate
inviting representatives from the following organizations as well as other stakeholders identified
by city staff (in particular, elected officials):
■ Neighborhood or Home Owners Associations
• CIRTA
• Janus Developmental Services
■ PrimeLife Enrichment, Inc.
• St. Vincent Health
■ IU Health North
• Carmel Arts & Design District
• OneZone
■ Carmel Clay Public Library
• Carmel Clay Schools
■ Monon Community Center
We propose two rounds of stakeholder meetings. The first round will take place after the
completion of the Existing and Future Conditions Report to solicit feedback regarding mobility
needs and opportunities. A second round of stakeholder meetings will take place after the
development of initial service alternatives. Stakeholder meetings will be designed in such a way as
to solicit information that responds to core questions but also allows for open-ended
conversation. It is very important that we gain a complete understanding of the community
desires and concerns. To encourage participants to speak frankly, we will ensure their comments
are anonymous and present results so that comments are summarized by theme.
In addition, members of the project team will be available to brief elected officials at strategic
points of the study. Discussions with elected officials would be conducted on an individual basis
and would take place either in person or by phone, as schedules permit. Briefings would likely
take place during both rounds of stakeholder outreach, but can be tailored to an appropriate time
commitment from each elected official as advised by City staff. To support these briefings, we urill
develop concise presentations or documents that can be used to summarize other stakeholder
Exhibit
NelsonlNygaard Consulting Associates, Inc [�/r�
TRANSIT PLAN
City of Carmel
feedback, service alternatives, as well as next steps. In our experience, it is equally crucial to have
conversations with elected officials who are supportive of transit as well as with those who are
wary of transit in order to gain consensus around a vision for transit services.
Deliverables: Technical Memorandum summarizing stakeholder feedback
4.1 Vision, Goals, and Objectives
Following the first round of stakeholder engagement, Nelson\Nygaard will facilitate a workshop
with city staff to develop a realistic vision, goals and objectives for the possible implementation of
transit service. We anticipate working closely with staff to develop realistic and attainable goals
and objectives based on service evaluation findings, community desires, and political support. We
typically categorize goals and objectives into themes that represent social, economic, and
environmental priorities. This practice is useful in communicating the vision to decision -makers
and stakeholders. Along with existing conditions findings and stakeholder feedback, it will also
serve as a foundation for the development of initial service alternatives.
4.2 Initial Service Alternatives
Based on the market research, stakeholder feedback, and project goals and objectives, we will
create a series of initial service alternatives designed to serve various markets. In evaluating the
viability of local and regional mobility options, it is important to consider all modes, vehicle types
and operating scenarios, including but not limited to:
■ Fixed -route transit
— Local circulator bus
— Connections to Marion County
— Commuter transit
■ On -demand transit
— Paratransit
— General-purpose dial -a -ride
— Flex route
■ Emerging mobility
Transportation Network Company (TNC) partnerships
Microtransit
Initial service alternatives will consist of route alignments, proposed stop locations, projected
service parameters (headways, span, and hours of operation), potential vehicle types, estimated
operating and capital costs.
4.3 Service Alternatives Refinement
After receiving feedback on the initial service alternatives from staff and the stakeholders, we %%rill
refine the service alternatives to reflect comments, concerns, or additional needs identified. Once
the refined service alternatives have been reviewed and approved by city staff, we will develop a
short-term and long-term operating and capital plan, described in Task 5. A simplified version of
Exhibit /+_
NeisonlNygaard Consulting Associates, Inc. 6 J6
TRANSIT PLAN
City of Carmel
the refined service alternatives will also be developed in a graphic format that is easy for a range
of audiences to comprehend.
Deliverable: Technical Memorandum documenting Vision, Goals and Objectives
5.1 Operating and Capital Plan
After finalizing service alternatives based on feedback from staff and stakeholders, we will
develop a detailed short-term and long-term operating plan, which will summarize vision for
transit in Carmel as well as how that may evolve as Central Indiana grows and invests in transit.
The operating plan will include a detailed implementation schedule. Depending on the
recommended mobility options, the operating plan will likely include many of the following
elements:
■ Map of route alignments and stop locations
■ Preliminary route schedules .,..1 �_ WK �� `
■ Service hours and vehicle requirements
• Future expansion options,
■ ADA regulations_
■ Operating options
— City owned and operated' r
-- City owned and third party
operated
w
— Turn key
• Performance measures and standards, and associated monitoring activities
■ Staffing needs
■ Marketing and communication strategies
Nelson\Nygaard will also identify capital needs to support potential service investments,
including but not limited to:
■ Fleet needs and replacement schedule
■ Bus stops signage and installation
■ Bus stop amenities such as benches, shelters, lighting and bike facilities
■ Design and construction of a transit center or mobility hub
■ Customer -focused technologies such as real-time arrival and fare collection apps
■ Infrastructure improvements and last -mile solutions such as sidewalks, crosswalks,
signalized intersections
The capital plan will have a planning horizon that reflects the short- and long-term elements of
the operating plan.
5.2 Financial Plan
Nelson\Nygaard will estimate operating and capital costs and recommend funding strategies for
new transit investments specified in the operating and capital plan. This effort will involve
Exhibit ._
NelsonWygaard Consulting Associates, Inc 7A
TRANSIT PLAN
City of Carmel
comparing the cost/benefit of each operating options. We will also evaluate the feasibility of
potential economic development and community partnership funding sources, in terms of their
ability to generate revenue, technical feasibility, and political acceptance. Potential non-
traditional funding sources include partnerships with government entities, sponsorships in the
form of advertising revenues, and public -private partnerships with major employers. Our project
team has experience helping transit providers negotiate agreements with benefiting partners to
fund the implementation of new transit service.
5.3 Draft Report
The products of the previous tasks will be summarized and compiled in the form of a draft plan,
prior to the submittal of a final plan. Nelson\Nygaard will provide an electronic copy of the draft
plan to city staff for review and comment. We will then schedule a conference call with city staff to
discuss comments and proposed revisions.
After the draft plan is revised to reflect city staff comments, we will present the draft plan to
Carmel City Council during a work session or regular board meeting. We will also be prepared to
answer any questions from the public.
5.4 Final Report
After receiving feedback from City Council, Nelson\Nygaard will revise the draft report and
produce a final report. We will provide printed and electronic copies of the final report along with
an executive summary that includes projects goals/objectives, key findings, stakeholder feedback
and recommendations.
Deliverables: Draft and Final Reports
We have assembled a team with relevant experience to fit the specific needs of this project. Full
resumes of each staff member are included in the appendix.
Project Manager: Hazel Scher
Principal -In -Charge: James Gamez
Deputy Project Manager: Alex Mercuri
Exhibit A _
NelsonlNygaard Consulting Associates, Inc. a fin
TRANSIT PLAN
City of Carmel
Total Silting Rate
James Gamez
Principal)
$180.00
Hazel Scher
Senior
Associate
$165.00
NelsonNygaard
Alexander
Mercuri
Associate
$130.00
Labor Costs
Jewel
DeGuzman
Associate2
$130.00
GIS Analyst
GIS Analyst
5110.OD
Designer
Designer
$110.00
Total Total
Labor Hours Labor Costa
Travel
Expenses
Meeting
Expenses
Total
Diradt Expertfes
Total
Costs
is
S2,
$2,
1 Project Initiation
1.1 I6ckollMeetng
12
12
12
361
S5,7
35,7D
1.2 Stakeholder Enagement Plan
4
8
81
201
53,09
— 080
Task Total
16
20
20
0
0
56
38,780
S3.
s0
$3,62
S1$40
2 Existing and Future Conditions Analysts
11 Document Review
12
$,,
31,7
2.2 Land Use and Infrastructure
2
4
8
8
22
$2.940
$2,940
2.3 Transportallon Services inveniory
4
8
8
20
52,58
S2,58(
2.4 Comprehensive Market Analysis
4
8
24
36
$4.340
$4
2.5 Peer Review
4
8
16
4
32
$4,640
$4,64
2.6 Existing and Future Conditions Report
4
18
8
1
1 1
$7,200
$7
Task Total
10
40
401
281
401
16
174
S23,4
$0
S28
S Stakeholder Engagement
3.1 Stakeholder Meetings
af
4OF
401
1
1241
11
$15,88
S15
Task Total
•
8
401
ri
401
r
01
D
24
.r
114
S115,8111
S4,700
54,7
520,
E 81 161 SZ360
52,36C
4 Servlee Ahernattves
4.1 Vision, Goals and Oboctves
8
8
8
24
$3,800
BO ,
42 Initial Service Allemafves
16
16
16
81 16
72
S10,400
$10,40C
4.3 Service AlemalvesRefinement
8
a
8
24
$3,64
Task Total
32
32
24
81 21
0
1
$17,84
$3,425
$0
$3.42
$$3.6464
5 Public transportation Framework
5.1 Operating and Capital Plan
a
24
8
$6,440
56,44
5.2 Financial Plan
8
16
1 16
$6,160
$6.1 60
5,3 Draft Report
4
16
16
81 24
681
S8.9601
$8,96
5.4 Final Report
4
16
81
8
36
$5.280
S5,28
Task Toe
..SE
24
72
2424
a 32
1841
526,84
$925
SCI
S92
$27.765
PROJECT TOTAL HOURS 9 2Nj 15(,l E01 721 721 662
PROJECT TOTAL COST 515,2001 536,300; S20.280; 31.BOC� 57,9Mi 57,920 I S97.4601 ,6T Sol 512.67 St10,135
TRANSIT PLAN
City of Carmel
Project Timeline M
This draft timeline shows an assumed start date of mid -February 2019 and a duration of approximately 9 months. Following this schedule
stakeholder engagement would occur in late May and July. Summer months can be difficult to schedule stakeholder workshops due to summer
travel. We are open to revising this schedule, either to frontload our work so that stakeholder engagement is complete before summer, or to
wait until Fall 2019 to conduct the second round.
.,••i�. , `d Hct Ipr:l AI hrs
poc.Coi " •�' tt ;y� 21 t� t5 :' 29 fl t� :? 3 t0 i/ 21
------
7"9
bIY.
� t B t; 2: 25
lwpall Sep:e �r CgopH Yo'+empH Caclmce•
5 t7 •9 tf 2 9 16 i3 7: 7 t1 2; i8 1 t A 2 9 6 13 1;
-�
NelsonlNygaard Consulting Associates, Inc.
N.'W•P:
Invoice
Name of Company:
Address & Zip.
Telephone No.:
Fax No.:
Project Name:
Invoice No.
Purchase Order No:
Date:
Goods
Services
Person Providing
Goods/Services
Date
Goods/
Service
Provided
Goods/Services Provided
(Describe each good/service
separately and in detail)
Cost Per
Item
Hourly
Rate/
Hours
Worked
Total
GRAND TOTAL
Signature
Printed Name
EXHIBIT C
INSURANCE COVERAGES
Worker's Compensation & Disability Statutory Limits
Employer's Liability:
Bodily Injury by Accident/Disease:
$100,000 each employee
Bodily Injury by Accident/Disease:
$250,000 each accident
Bodily Injury by Accident/Disease:
$500,000 policy limit
General Liability:
Each Occurrence:
$250,000
General Aggregate Limit (other than
Products/Completed Operations):
$500,000
Products/Completed Operations:
$500,000
Personal & Advertising Injury:
$500,000
Damage to Premises Rented to You:
$250,000
Medical Expense Limit (any one person):
$ 50,000
Commercial Auto Liability (owned, hired and non -owned)
Per Accident Combined Single Limit
For Bodily Injury and Property Damage: $500,000
Umbrella Excess Liability
Each occurrence and aggregate: $1,000,000
Maximum deductible: $ 10,000
EXHIBIT D
AFFIDAVIT
C.AAIne ri r\ e ______,being first duly sworn, deposes and says that
he/she is familiar with and has personal knowledge of the facts herein and, if called as a witness in this
matter, could testify as follows:
1. I am over eighteen (18) years of age and am competent to testify to the facts contained
herein.
2. I am now and at all times relevant herein have been employed by
Nelson\►J1�aord GcnSyt:L%V,� A�soc�a�l'e- , znC-. (the "Employer")
in the position of x,; h c4 h oe tit v%W r
3. I am familiar with the employment policies, practices, and procedures of the Employer and
have the authority to act on behalf of the Employer.
4. The Employer is enrolled and participates in the federal E-Verify program and has
provided documentation of such enrollment and participation to the City of Carmel,
Indiana.
5. The Company does not knowingly employ any unauthorized aliens.
FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT.
EXECUTED on the a3P--" day of 20 19 .
,
1 1
Printed: C IM&Js oGui-Ile rm v
I certify under the penalties for perjury under the laws of the United States of America and the State of
Indiana that the foregoing factual statements and representations are true and correct.
S96 A r , A<:-i46Z) C►r� c. r Fvi jA —t�E� t�r>2�� +✓ is �A i` —�
Printed: ;Zic;44, A3 J . AI E,14F--,-�%4
NO-1-4;;ty 10u64-c—
S-rATE err
C G u.\3 I OF SA V
A notary public or other officer completing this
certificate verifies only the identity of the individual
who signed the document to which this certificate
is attached, and not the truthfulness, accuracy, or
validity of that document.
State of California
County of San Francisco
Subscribed and sworn to (or affirmed) before me on this 23rd
day of January , 20 19 , by Catherine Guillermo
proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the
person(s) who appeared before me.
RICHARD J. NEMETH
N COMM. #2228902 'p
NOTARY PUBLIC-CALIFORNIA O
SAN FRANCISCO COUNTY tV
If *My ti rT. Ezpirs Feb. 12. 2022
(Seal) R 'Signature
City o Carmel
INDIANA RETAIL TAX EXEMPT
CERTIFICATE NO. 003120155 002 0
Page 1 of 1
PURCHASE ORDER NUMBER
JL
FEDERAL EXCISE TAX EXEMPT
102279
ONE CIVIC SQUARE
- 35-6000972
THIS NUMBER MUST APPEAR ON INVOICES, AIP
CARMEL, INDIANA46032-2584
VOUCHER DELIVERY MEMO, PACIONG SUPS,
SHIPPING LABELS AND ANY CORRESPONDENCE
FORM APPROVED BY STATE BOARD OF ACCOUNTS FOR CITY
OF CARMEL - 1997
VENDOR NO.
PURCHASE ORDER DATE
DATE REQUIRED
REQUISITION NO.
DESCRIPTION
12/7/2018
372988
NELSON/NYGAARD CONSULTING ASSOC INC Dept of Community Service
VENDOR 116 NEW MONTGOMERY ST SHIP 1 Civic Square
SUITE 500 TO Carmel, IN 46032-
SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94105 -
PURCHASE ID BLANKET CONTRACT PAYMENT TERMS
31830
QUANTITY UNIT OF MEASURE DESCRIPTION
Department 1192 Fund: 101 General Fund
Account: 43404.00
1 Each Transit Plan
Account: 43-419.99
1 Each Transit Plan
Account: 43-509.00
1 Each Transit Plan
Send Invoice To
Dept of Community Service
1 Civic Square
Carmel, IN 46032-
I •- OF CAq
NI
7
PLEASE INVOICE IN DUPLICATE
FREIGHT
UNIT PRICE EXTENSION
$63,000.00
Sub Total
$19,306.25
Sub Total
$27,828.75
Sub Total
$63,000.00
$63,000.00
$19,306.25
$19,306.25
$27,828.75
$27,828.75
DEPARTMENT ACCOUNT PROJECT PROJECT ACCOUNT I AMOUNT
PAYMENT $110,135.00
SHIPPING INSTRUCTIONS ' AIP VOUCHER CANNOT BE APPROVED FOR PAYMENT UNLESS THE P.O. NUMBER IS MADE A
PART OF THE VOUCHER AND EVERY INVOICE AND VOUCHER HAS THE PROPER SWORN
SHIP PREPAID. AFFIDAVIT ATTACHED. I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THERE IS AN UNOBUGATED BALANCE IN
'C.O.D. SHIPMENT CANNOT BE ACCEPTED. THIS APPROPRIATION SUFFICIENT TO PAY FOR THE ABOVE ORDER.
'PURCHASE ORDER NUMBER MUST APPEAR ON ALL SHIPPING LABEL
'THIS ORDER ISSUED IN COMPLIANCE WITH CHAPTER 99, ACTS 1945 I -.
AND ACTS AMENDATORY THEREOF AND SUPPLEMENT THERETO. ORDERED BY
MiKe Homoaugn
TITLE Director
CONTROL NO. 102279 CLERK -TREASURER
James Crider
Administration