Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPacket for BZA HO 05-28-19 STALIN Custom Exterior&Interior Signs S T LEY SI N,. STALEY SIGNS, INC. IND ! vNA1) o1, is P.O. BOX 515 AND INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46206-0515 YEARS cr"'� ■ - PHONE: 317-637-4567 ..anr1 c•ountin,; FAX:317-221-0123 SINCE 1 908 f---' Design,Manufacture,Install&Service L.7 a�i i.:� i1 W Lb , Docket # 1904003 V WestClay Fine Wine & Spirits MAY 1A 2019 & 12995 Petigru Drive - g Village of Westclay Uptown WestClay Fine Wine&Spirits is a new construction of a retail wine store that is set to open in May. We are requesting 43 sf wall signs on the East and West elevations of the building. The signs consist of'A"thick, satin black, aluminum letters. The letters are externally illuminated by goose neck light fixtures. The West elevation sign meets sign regulations and has received a sign permit. VOCW 18.3,A. (5)limited to one sign per business on each building façade fronting a street. We are seeking a variance to allow for a 43 sf wall sign on the East elevation, which does not front a street. The requested sign is an identical match to the sign on the West elevation. Strict application of the ordinance presents several practical difficulties to the business. The East and West elevations,both serve a Front/Main entrances to the business. The East elevation entrance will receive the most customers because it faces the parking lot. The allowed 6 sf sign would simply not be readable or even noticeable enough to draw customers towards the entrance. The East elevation also has the best visibility from 131'Street to the North and the new Tae Kwon Do academy to the East. Again, the allowed 6 sf sign would not be readable from an acceptable distance. In order to achieve a 6 sf sign that reads, "WESTCLAY FINE WINE& SPIRITS"the letters were only 7 ' "tall. WestClay Fine Wine&Spirits has agreed to trade their larger sign allowance on the South elevation for the proposed East elevation sign. In the future they would opportunity to seek permits for the smaller signage that would traditionally be allowed on a non-street frontage. Specifically,WestClay Fine Wine&Spirits requests that they be allowed secondary signage on the South elevation as described in the VOWC Section 18.3 (B), (E), (F), (G) and(H)through standard permit application process. This consists of: • 18.3 (B): 6 square foot wall sign • 18.3 (E): 10 sf projecting sign • 18.3 (F): 6 sf tree lawn sign • 18.3 (G): window/door sign • 18.3(H): awning sign Page 1 of 1 :".c....„s„, ::: . . . ., , , ,„,,v,..f , ' •' N 0. , 0 a 4 i .1:.,.. 40: , , ,fiet , „, •ir ' , • • * ' • *- * "' '''"' ' - ' , a - • ., . , mi" j .1,41,4‘,1,'1 AINN., m- --""lkilh' f N9Vg1303 It . . Z!,V3 st , . . ,.. „.„... . , ,_ . , ii. '1111,111/.14 I - . . .„.„,.. ..,,,,,,...., .-., To Pnmrose Schbol ", ..? a ===.* - • , , ,. , ,„ • fit-M•,===a r ... .„. .., ,,, . ...: at A.e 1,i2 a t .' ' ',' us Pp. macy , m / . . = .., „.., .:.,.,..,.. ,.. ... -., . . _ . --- ......... 1171 . Co ,... il—' - -- '' . li. , pois....iiwp 1 The,National Bank,, ' 1, 4I' 1,*t7 j'4,. , , . ‘. . i ..01, ,, ...,P ' /111 W S 1\''' ',.,.. ' ., 4001111‘ TAE KWON a a ' rg" - .. . . , ,.. .. ,...„,„:„. ..-.,. , ..... ....iir ilim, . ,,,..4:',,,,„:!,',1,,----, ' ‘,4't.:' We '' - * '14:. • .. , . "*" ' „ .. . .. 1. .,,, .. . , . ...,olipi* ' ret.,"....1,..„-..-7.1 ,.: ' ','t',`, 111 firitti..,t,si St 4,0.0.10,*, pa. 4.,1 -ill Pk.'k p ' — I 1 ,ILY,, -14 . ........ ' -‘ 1 ' -40 1 f , PeItgri.1Drve ... '' 1 • ..„ ,,..... '$ . . . , ',' ' - ,. , 0". ' • lc - , ,, .„.. ,...., ....„, ., ,.- ......tezzatz -1 , ,. , .,,•_ 1, : .. .. 4.... . . 4 ( . .... 4,e.,,,,,...,....„.„. „ .,. . , .. ,, ,_ . .v,,..‘ -, • • 1 :,;....-,„ ' ,,-- - .' ,, , , 1 ...:r • ' . ''-'- - . " ' '-''' , - ' • - __ ' •- F ' .... .., - a ' 4 "47ifgli- ''.‘ Li 6 ''' . 'aNt•-••=-/ 3° .7., ,... , . '71 IL t' — '-'f' ' ' ., . . , • ,,,, . . .. .. , , ., ,..., ,,..,, , . • wan . i ).- 1 si ',z. - ' -;;;:..,". ., so, .., , .. 4 " 04j ., . . .., , all 1 . 4t. -'-' aik #4*,' 4,0‘..C-00-' -'„ , ._ ‘.. •.... ...., ...... ,00.3. l'- 0 4 . 11; - **I* - , ...... _,,,.,. . , • MOP' . ' C2=441.400.0.0. 00 le Ai , it .. , .. . 1 Lial1111111' 1 , : ' - . . , . ,..,... , • ... .. ... . 1 1 9 / 2 /- 223 I I. S I N S JP MORGAN CHASE BANK,NA. 6 Nra Rw.69T s, II INST.#2007-36415 _I I "f 4£ (, STOR19 8 , iC.904.{9 \ 1 I NV RNsxf6'RCP)-898.52 .. 8,, I RN QiT(EX1eRCP)-8964, • iI. 1 r fi i (J.)4 .A` ] 1 L_J' - 904.22 ..�' STORM NEi 1. INV 12 .899.08 --..--.. ` C.981.38 N(MT k I +i cuKexn'rta)•9ao.ss NV au,p+;(,e•.->=e99.o5 ;111 II CONSTRUCTION UNITS PROPERtt LINE • ' i ���JJJ © 0 e 0 ilD,mo Abler- In111 • 11 01111T-,-,owl cm ffmanur l, ,_,.. C ?..,:_r4.1 cONsmucrioN Limns I m Q itiszo >ho I 6-1 l is. I PR°RET'> 5 8 I III I® :**1�,�-y�,Q'R�'ZR PROVIDE REVISED I Ob.„mil/A fi PART of >Q R-5.0' ��, � � �„,►�a��U,mM t�'!� STANDARD DUTY in BLOC%'w W} y :�►�e:-• 1 .. ,�1.a`�A.Ni "G�.' ASPHALT OR 6- Is vtu.A¢a 11 T11Jr �1 CONCRETE ( ;� N io 3 MESTCLAY,$EC 'LL t i40.1��, 20 , ./ PAVEMENT re- � 8003-8 _ PC a,SLOE 254 j 01 I ,, Q '� ''L I v, ( ( E(24'NE?.900.0! 56184 s9.E«•1 i '%�''� E(2:7.-900.15 OII !55* a- O' l' ILDIN O +ice" - BD NEMI I iI , 4 y)rimy;±3,841 i <^ grim= raeaeau I V11„.„......„././ . a m 7 p ir FF=907 �I9 .4'1.1 I R a <,mi 1 ® I PROPOSEI r,-,--„,.6,-- r.. a g y O- b i © ce;7411 a)®1 1 ,.W/F2i�r��n'R © I — m, F� (BY O a. OEC m IL JP I�y�I N UNDER COP I ® I' 42.0' E••� I �T 10,51 i 8.,5.0' i1 x zg i m ei 8 Lam! I FF=c 0 GAFFED BREBA 0 i® b E' M:3 ® , �if��'���--_J �L�� 't N E&J ENTERPI 3 AT CORNER ,r NOripa�9 ®���MI�i471116 JJ / INST.#2017 m = isenco ®Oce siin i� N RA I G II�� t,-, � � di® .!_.__��� OR POWDER GOAT 1i�� R-74.2' 0 ® il'47-r4 STEEL i w q= CAPPED WEAR ,7!' 40..4e., . . .IR • - - is •.r 'saarECEx'ECVNO { 0.0$ONHEtis,AND 10'MUD TO UNE �� - - ` 6'p #! 06906E FEN CONE? �► ±2,653 SF ��' `�j I(.906.55 900.50 a ' — CONs18UCTi0N UMIT$ :��• 11$17404$4 • \, ,,, �a< ►®<��_ r aA� "Ma k E(2: .900 i0 PRQ�tT\/LRE � O�sa®���� , �� R�1a■kIOD°_i,�_T g r i ..;. e���` �l� ■ yy ■■ MENT /R tom O 5' /--�,_ ` wv• �sH S....-. •�•.9 . ,Q .�r`,I y �i ®i(�I_�_,..__ 131'' 20,7_6 • : -w' . . - "\_ DELETE SIDEWALK �7 'i#�I + P 7�`IQtIaip— tE •E(24 sy-900.7, I / \\ o �triP!c9\9!y ql BORN" r RIVER ROCK E)-900.50 /7/ +J \ \ 4�=�� DELETE LIGHT '9, GARDEN FIXTURES ©m 11 W $-..T TA(�T CIRCLE 1"."-. i ®\ © 12 SCARED Rc II/ 40'RIGHT-OF-WAY \ v � %' = 1'%ENE' 0uW R.60.9.SAN WIN E \` AT CORNEA 4D © R..5.0. ilD !1V 6,(EPS.NC)-892.'"I 0 CONSTRUCTION LMT, INV NOY) MV PUT(S) 1 s _ _ _ _ HARLESTON_ STREET ) _ - _ - - e 1 I I 94'RIGHT-OF-WAY SAN NANNIXE ...._... TC 906.25 ( I .,1(EJ(6,-.Cj.897. NV a/(n(e P cYe974949 i /S 6 V / N // 9'-6" I I 8'-11 1/2" I 8'-1" 1 WESTCLAY FINE WINE & SPIRITS 3/8"=1'-0" Flat Cut Aluminum Letters. Externally Illuminated with Goose Neck Fixtures by General Contractor Brick Wall END VIEW 3"=1'-0" 1/4"Thick Waterjet Cut Aluminum x 3"Aluminum Painted Satin Black 19" Stud Mount • This rendering is 6d StaleySigns,Inc.,submittal for use in connection till the statedpmjmt.Diapda,',Distribution or Duplication shaft prior wTum"mnsem is strictly prohibited. ,''��E 9���`� ;i C""""""'WESTCLAY FINE WINE&SPIRITS ".lis ann,�a«.�p aa�"�a� nn.,.rind are"a� Page pas, nt ia�p"rp.aea of Let a,awl�laR. 1 of 1 SINCE 1908 West&East Elevation Y.O.Bos 515 Indivwpulia.Indiana 46206 Shop Drawing Option: p`I°"Te - 1' P/ .al # 0l'� °'"` Seale:/otairoroi04-15-2019 `PD.Staley Jr. 1--9t-6"1 I_811 „2"1 r 8t_1a 1- AWNING NOT SHOWN FOR CLARITY (1 `j 19'W_ € -,'- . -- ' t_:s —F ,:I-," ,�" 11 a $m l� 1 t } j �INNIII&NIINIIIIIINNIIINr11NN1111NNN11111NIFpINNN1 Nn 'iIIpINIntlINpN1N111111NtlilillNlW1111111N911111NN11. - }- S -'i �33yyEtrt I 011 -, Jt... !ill 1 i - i 4 il rj.- I- -, - : L7 — y{ Jiif Yi 1 um 1 1 111it I.. �®� V✓I III � Sl {k I III 11.—III Ifi't 1 L..I1�i 11- : f.-a I' -lig „,,-.,1,=11!=,1,:=1,t=1,1.=- 1-11_ —,--1----,,,,,-,Ii1IF_:!f 1-0812.A5-1 1-0841,A1--1 BLDG A - EAST 43 Sq. Ft. `”"' Thu tetdahyd u O&slcy s.,.,Im.,dwattal for use In cone 11on with the stated p oje..Display,Distribution or Duplieetbn Mdwort prior written.ntuem is strlaly prohibood. arillsSfaCiS5 Pro:et Notes: WESTCLAY FINE WINE&SPIRITS .t ions-hewn a<e Rptexenbtha ant,,and ate not Page ptnlapr: ntendat air pirrpuua of e>awt matehhtg' 1 O)F 1 SINCE 1908 East P.O.Bos 515 Indivwpolis.India a 46206 Elevation °"'"": A-2 Tel:311,Z....1/7/ 56.7.:11:::43.1.7J„2.1;0123 lar.. state: n_ e » ww04-15-2019 R'D.Staley Jr.I 1/8 —1-0 L 96'____I r8'-111/2"1 r 8,-1rr 1 ___. c___: .__._____. 1_________, „..... .: PARAPET_n i 19n W_ IiiEgl \'ESTCLAY • FI\E „, &SPIR _.T _I —1.........L.,.•1,1611 _ i _ tg 4 F k�� m >:r- _ y .`�- a it Ex t .£. _L i it z 7 r _ _E WV: -!Ljfqiyalt T.71 r- " r` r'-~ -IN s��� 1._._.,,i ® _ - _,. .e1.:-! lt_,h-! .1iI . x.11 Ji -7-: .! a;- 1 li L - I i_-. .?y --- am ' FIRS' 0 0 BLDG A - WEST 43 Sq. Ft. " -- ----- This mulcting b O Staley Signs,huv,submitted for use in eonrwvxlon with the stilted project.Disp*Distribution or Ihtpllntbn without prior%Titre"ivttsem is strictly prohibited. � Cusuxner: Notu: S1) �{� ;SIGN WESTCLAY FINE WINE&SPIRITS . b,,,hnw ammpr�ntarl.,.ppt,,ana,mnnt Page jLrllilfiil< Project. West n endal for purpbea of ea wd maohhtq. 1 of 1 SINCE 1 9 0 8 50.Box 515 Indianapolis.Intlimia 46206 Elevation °pnpt` A-2 Tel:317.6.17.4567•Fax:317.221.0123 http:./Avww.stilleysIgna.com/ D''-04-29-2019 '"D.Staley Jr. ' swi 1/8"=1'-0" remove Column asi#3 0472.A4 A------------ / 0472.A5 — -- '"ZAME PARAPET AIL _ - - T ''-1-111- i --=--U'111/1111 I 11 1111 II 1111111 11K 11 I i II III I aUnuu nm uuanuna 's_�-' 0430.A1 '-� _ az : --'�a 35.a111ali�ill�lfa11�111?IIIZ�af,�i1 gI11E';gria-2i?° L� 8a'£�Tr° _ 3r?• ---.e--�a-- - --- ir-Ma-:�zEEIIE11 all IHIII=111 1 1 I I =a�3rvEaa==�£'a-r= SsTi-E ingusigim- 1a II 1 1111 liII%II1 - q11 IIIIll1 pill/IIIIIIl11H111l-1�llll - -•I111111I11111 III II 1111.0 i..' 0430.A3 �-�11 i1 L111 111111191111111111= 3111111E111111-II-IIII�IH11111111I 11 NII s�1111111111111�1111111�H 1 1 HI I z-L-a.-s •imua.s--.e_�r=sss-_-esa.-a_ —sa„4-sea. sea- 1§: ,., r =-ar31; a- zEIE-==T_k---s11�-a�T_a--'_=3�' in.=6T_-1- .Lrs 3E-r----.16-...m... ,,,; ta-arT�r-� - r 44.4.- �r=-a.=—Efai ie-Mir-a ,..:Win..-6,-3--1------E ii E-7. aEa-x6-30. a 44 E4 ' Ee-,4..- �.i-�ia£s .s �nrsE s= s r' _3 .---,i 1:-.-1--.4!r---,,„---;---.._ E.f--i}_3-=-'- -_ETsz=-#===_r -_'_. i'r _{'_i"s _-3 sra_r d'-'-] DUMPSTER a �z.- _ �`rt�&- "£ s_s`2-.-rs-�Y- z�;=#=-'s-'a-==== ======i: ' E , r.,"x:r,Ls- --Esa3c-a=te-sjgTs£- wymee-.Ta-SEN =a-: ENCLOSURE t--a - t_-__z - -=----- -dei NOT SHOWN -1:,--,-;-:'---:' y' r' as�se4zrs�e-r-ems_--a�=.£?r=£iii-_��s- .ririis3 j-�T.a�z-=- -a- X85 - 1 rr rFl---7---m ii--sr=i— :.z;47 'E:21:=ssr aF3?- - FOR CLARITY -.. �- �---z-- - Np -EL''_=�--_- ps 1 F. ,�-, -Y. ,5t£3-rr-¢z£YLri=s-----a�s�rs .m..: r.rsz-- -- R- 3 milad.-; I _ _ FIRST FLOOR Aili 0 0 I I { 1 - ,, t.__,, ,I__,1 --,,,,__,,,___,11_,1,__111_111- i i-i i-n,-iii-,i i-i, - n-iii-i, BLDG A — NORTH This rendering is 0 Staley Signs,Inc.,submitted for use in connection with the stated project. Display,Distribution or Duplication without prior written consent is strictly prohibited. SI�► ���` ,�./ Customer: Notes: J { West Clay Fine Wine & Spirits .Colon;shown are representative only,and are not Page cn Project: intended for purposes of exact matching. 1 Of SINCE 1908 North 1 Option: P.O.Box 515 Indianapolis,Indiana 46206 Elevation - '11:317.637.4567 •Fax:317.221.0123Date: Rep: Scale: 1/pt,-1'-0» http://�..staleysigns.eom/ 04-19-2019 D. Staley Jr. O — ififrard MI".1 -' PARAPET s- . , 16'-g„ psi 44)/ntalmnaunluan nh ul�ll loll®Ir�uall uIIunI hInuulninl'I u - 3- - _ I�1� - — ..3E gin�ll lIili:l _n i �IIn,�; = ,YTiE i •_ t= - ._T =. .. 5 i--_€= = =1 l lanai --- 3 11 1 _mi —_----- :gaa"rHiL3E E.- ii....iii..; -_ € �.�T T 4E - ili us i —i iii iii—iP . _ a _=% 3ftInlnimmnllnlgnio minium Ilni�lld/nnnllnlmmin lminnng 3.34' �? rifsir,INIIII�$ it _ i1--„y4�i S7 _2.2422-- a y�la2.T—S py ry�p� p iply�ZnZ E GC_L..�-� — R ullum®I NIUUN�IC:F IPI= ni�niliTIT nrnllX�w��N�W,.W,,gms OW 'i�tl� �t� �i�iii+gensi =2"1177:1,--.C... iNtt$ 7C \.ice—g s PM=r -Liteplu 37 _, 41 f q9 - '�- - S �I Mei Ft'-tPSLTi I�=Mikf il'tft I i 1'�- z LL :$ J 43 �sssae.-tus 4.E.74gra":•:s}'—z�-�. { z s� T a testi— g him . I- -..:=1:::.-- 1111.11111111111111 Nil= � , FIRST FLOOR T1 — — 0'-0„ O —11I-1�I: Th� --i--III—I —=-11I--=; —=1iI=IIi- II=111=1 =( -11I=111—I __111=I-1II— — i- 11=111= BLDG A — SOUTH SMALEY 'rThis rendering is©Staley Signs,Inc.,submitted for use in connection with the stated project. Display,Distribution or Duplication without prior written consent is strictly prohibited. SI( 4S Customer: Project: Notes: West Clay Fine Wine & Spirits •Colors shown are representative only,and are not Page �' South Option: intended for purposes of exact matching. 1 of 1 SINCE 1908 P.O.Box 515 Indianapolis,Indiana 46206 Elevation Tel:317.637.4567 •ISIax:317.221.0123DSEC: Rep: Scale: »_ 7 ii http://www.staleysigns.com/ 04-19-2019 D. Staley Jr. 1/8 1-0 BALLOT SHEET: FINDINGS OF FACT, DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS VARIANCE CARMEL ADVISORY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS (Petitioner to fill out 15t two blanks only) Docket No.: 19 Oti 000 'J V Petitioner: '1"-. Dv q f c s j 1--e r/ Cy 7( 1. 2. 3. DATED THIS DAY OF , 20 Board Member Page 10 of 12 Filename:Hearing Officer Development Standards Variance Application&Instructions 2019 Revised 01/10/19 FINDINGS OF FACT SHEET-DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS VARIANCE CARMEL ADVISORY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS (Petitioner to fill out 1-3 +first two blanks) Docket No.: PZ19040003V Petitioner: F. Douglas Staley, Jr.for Westclay Fine Wine &Spirits 1. The approval of this variance will not be injurious to the public health, safety, morals and general welfare of the community because: The proposed variance is for a wall sign. The sign identifies the name of the store "Westclay Fine Wine & Spirits". It will be fabricated with high quality materials and installed to meet industry and building code requirement. 2. The use and value of the area adjacent to the property included in the variance will not be affected in a substantially adverse manner because: The is a retail area of the Village of Westclay. Surrounding commercial buildings have multiple wall signs such as National Bank of Indpls, Chase Bank, CVS Pharmacy, and the new Tae Kwon Do. The proposed signs are very conservative in design & match architecture nicely. 3. The strict application of the terms of the Unified Development to the property will result in practical difficulties in the use of the property because: Even though the East elevation of this building does not have a traditional street frontage, it is the front/main entrance of the building. This elevation has significant visibility from 131st St and other surrounding businesses. Not having an East elevation sign would put this retail business at a significant disadvantage. DECISION IT IS THEREFORE the decision of the Carmel Board of Zoning Appeals that Development Standards Variance Docket No. is granted, subject to any conditions stated in the minutes of this Board, which are incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof. Adopted this day of , 20 HEARING OFFICER, Carmel Board of Zoning Appeals SECRETARY, Carmel Board of Zoning Appeals Conditions of approval of the Board, if any, are listed on the Letter of Grant. Page 11 of 12 Filename:Hearing Officer Development Standards Variance Application&Instructions 2019 Revised 01/10/19