The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About01-27-20 '6"KTNrC,'RR44 A 1 City o arme IIM.ii ii 1 1 /AMMO C Carmel Board of Zoning Appeals Hearing Officer Meeting Minutes Monday, January 27, 2020 Meeting Location: Carmel City Hall Caucus Rooms,2"d Floor, 1 Civic Square, Carmel, IN 46032 Hearing Officer: Mr. Leo Dierckman Staff Present: Angie Conn, Planning Administrator Nathan Chavez,Sign Administrator Joe Shestak,Administrative Assistant Legal Counsel: John Molitor Time: 5:15 p.m. Public Hearings: TABLED TO FEB. 24-Black Orchid Barber Lounge Sign. 1. 1knnG Doeket No.19120005 V 116 'Street Centre PUD Sections tenant allowed 2 th St ...d ed Planned Unit Development Ordinance 7 484 05. TABLED TO FEB. 24- (V) The Overlook at the Legacy,Lot 23. 2. Docket No. 19120009 V r egacy P SeetionWxhibit 8 Ntlin.25' front setback red for 3. Docket No. 19 4010 V Legac P��Sectien5 h-ibit 8 ' required, 5' requested.The site is located at 7227 Delmont Dr. and is zoned Legacy PUD Ordinance Z 501 07. (V) Copper Run Subdivision,Masonry Requirements. The applicant seeks the following development standards variance approval: 4. Docket No. 19120011 V Copperleaf PUD, Section 4.3,Exhibit C.12.0 5 homes with less than 50% masonry allowed, 10 requested. The site is located at approximately 13026 Copper Run Blvd. It is zoned PUD/Planned Unit Development Ordinance Z-631-18. Filed by Tim Ochs and Devin Brown of Ice Miller LLP, on behalf of Pulte Homes of Indiana. Petitioner: Tim Ochs, Ice Miller: • Having gone through the entire process in terms of the development of the PUD, it's important to note the variances here are consistent to the spirit of the architectural standards • We have 22 of the 28 lots under construction • The average home sale prices has exceeded what was presented to the Plan Commission and City Council Public Comments: None Department Report: Angie Conn: • We would want a copy of the recorded commitments within 30 days of when this variance is granted 1 BZA Hearing Officer Minutes 1-27-2020 • - Staff recommends positive consideration of the variance request Board Comments: Leo Dierckman: I have reviewed the info packet and department report and will approve this Approved 1-0 (V)Allied Solutions East Wall Sign. The applicant seeks the following development standards variance approval: 5. Docket No. 19120012 V UDO Article 5.39,SI-01.H Wall signs cannot be placed over architectural elements of building,East wall sign to cover three architectural columns/features. The site is located at 350 Veterans Way, in Midtown Carmel Block 1 and is zoned Midtown Cannel PUD/Planned Unit Development Ordinance Z-599-15. Filed by Christina Bruno of Bose McKinney&Evans LLP. Petitioner: Alex Intermill,Bose McKinney&Evans: • The proposed sign is a similar sign that was placed on the western façade. We were approved by the BZA for the sign on the western wall. • It's a 5 story building,which requires a large sign. The height of the sign complies, but not the width of the sign. Public Comments: None Department Report: Nathan Chavez, Sign Administrator: • Staff recommends approval of the variance request • The architecture elements limits the size of the sign Board Comments: Leo Dierckman: I have reviewed the info packet and department report and will approve this Approved 1-0 (V)Horner Carriage House Garage. The applicant seeks the following development standards variance approval: 6. Docket No. 19110012 V UDO section 5.02.B.3 Accessory Structure Ground Floor Area,Max.24' x 30' allowed,24' x 40' requested,. The site is located at 621 1"Ave NW and is zoned R2/Residence and Old Town Overlay Zone,Character Subarea.Filed by Jeffery Horner, owner. Petitioner: Jeffery Horner,Homeowner: • I have nothing else to add to what is already listed in my informational packet Public Comments: Judy Bowman, Old Grace Lane: Are they going to tear down the existing house? Rebuttal to Public Comments: Jeffery Horner: • A 24' x 40' garage with additional living space above the garage will be constructed behind the existing house. The current house will remain as is. Department Report: Angie Conn: • There's a few outstanding requests from the Engineering Department and those can be addressed through the building permits process Board Comments: Leo Dierckman: I've read the info packet and department report and have nothing else to add. Approved 1-0 2 BZA Hearing Officer Minutes 1-27-2020 (V) Caliber Collision Signage. The applicant seeks the following development standards variance approval: 7. Docket No. 19100021 V UDO Section 5.39 1 sign allowed,2 requested. The site is located at 503 W. Carmel Dr. (former Abra Auto Body&Glass and Hubler Express Collision site). It is zoned 11/Industrial. Filed by Linda Thompson of Cree Industrial Arts. Petitioner: Linda Thompson, Cree Industrial Arts: • The actual business is really far behind from the road, and it's imperative to have both signs Allison Mather, Caliber Collision • Having one sign or the other, it would still be difficult to find us. We will be adding a nicer monumental sign. Public Comments: None Department Report: Nathan Chavez, Sign Administrator: • There are few outstanding comments that can be taken care during the sign permitting process • Staff recommends approval of the variance request because the building is setback so far back Board Comments: Leo Dierckman: I have reviewed the info packet and department report and have nothing else to add Approved 1-0 (V) Gramercy West,Roof Slope. The applicant seeks the following development standards variance approval: 8. Docket No. 19120003 V PUD Ordinance Z-630-18,Exhibit D,Section 2.F.1 Min.6:12 roof slope allowed,4:12 requested for Lot B/F Townhomes(Area B/F Lots). The site is located at approximately 513 E. City Center Dr. and is zoned Gramercy Planned Unit Development. Filed by Ed Freeman of David Weekley Homes. Petitioner: Ed Freeman, David Weekley Homes: • I have nothing else to add to what has already been provided in my info packet Public Comments: Karen Carter,Carmel resident: What is being built? Can I see the current plans? Rebuttal to Public Comments: Ed Freeman: • Presented a copy of the overall site plan to Ms. Carter • There are 3 different townhome building styles, Federal, Georgian, and Greek Revival architecture styles within the Gramercy PUD • The Federal architectural style lower roof pitch does not allow us to meet the 6:12 roof slope. The Federal style is the only styled townhome that will have the 4:12 roof pitch. Presents an example of a 4:12 roof slope. Department Report: Angie Conn: • Staff recommends positive consideration of the variance request Board Comments: Leo Dierckman: I have reviewed the info packet and department report and have nothing else to add Approved 1-0 TABLED TO FEB.24-(SE)Westrick Short Term Residential Rental. 3 BZA Hearing Officer Minutes 1-27-2020