HomeMy WebLinkAboutPacket for HO 03-23-20 PZ-2020-00001 V
Bastian Solutions Wall Sign
10585 N. Meridian Street
Bastian Solutions has an existing wall sign 10585 N. Meridian that reads, "Bastian Solutions"
with their swoosh logo element. After this sign was permitted, manufactured, and installed,
Bastian Solutions became a strategic partner with Toyota Logistics. As part of the partnership,
their logo changed to include "a Toyota Advanced Logistics company". The new logo has been
utilized at a facility further North on US 31 in Westfield. Now, Bastian Solutions needs to use
the new logo at 10585 N. Meridian as dictated by their brand standards.
We are seeking a variance of the allowable wall sign height. 70% of the tenant's spandrel
height can be used for signage. We are requesting to use 90.7% of the height.
An exception to the 70% rule is critical for several reasons. First, if the proposed sign height
allowed, Bastian Solutions will be able to re-use the existing "Bastian Solutions" letters and
swoosh. We will only need to make and install new letters that read, "a Toyota Advanced
Logistics company". Manufacturing and installing an entirely new sign would create significant
cost increase and wasted resources/materials. At the proposed size, the new letters are 4 %"
tall. This is about the minimum letter height that should be used on a building of this size. If
they 70% rule was applied, they letters would be less than 3" tall.
Thank you for your consideration.
Doug Staley, Jr.
Staley Signs, Inc.
Petitioner
'
.- • (74 c. .
. ,
, • ... ..• (11"L1'14i t*P",,...,,....c.'1 ii 0 '
,
C, - t.
.._
.r,,,' ... + ,,1
i . ';', i C.:•, k
1 4 . - .
1 '4-
,. ..
. - - •
fie'4... ii 1 211 t. ..ir
c--- 4 - 1 ' 1..
li 'A '
' ''.' I. •*4 4i. ':
„. ..
•.•.../.. d° .t.. ,C 4 4 .'7,:,-, d• .• LI
I - •' (4 -
I& Ittt.WI 1 t, _.L., ;;.. . 111 1.
. . . Ivo ,. . .. ,.. •a ,1 : ; ,
;./ . ...,
1 41 i . ..* • 41; ., '.! : , ,. ...I
- • , . /ii,!1•441111i114:1.r. • . 4114,-.1 .. ,.
'
rd. . swes . 1 ,4 ". = ,, ;.,...tt ; f .`-••••••2•-` •
I mei. ' $•- - It
tit.ait: ,- ' ' (t.r. i T =', '.s - - " ' •
14 I,- -- ,,,.....•4.0. 1,411 • 1•401... 4
• lEI:me:„„;,..a... „ .. - .....1. I Ali -11i..‘k.-"'
. .
. ,. . ....__„ . . ,
A•
• 0, ),..,• . ; t , .. NO
I zs'T.1*'tl.littkritillif tj ' ' . •
,_.- . ',• .Lt. 2 t- .-.,''..2*.t,".... '-'--;" . . - '„ -6",?;‘, CI
..............--:_-, .-...,.... — ,,...:.;0:-4--,-17,',.-,:, .. .i•. If. kt,-.4 -f. i= .. ,' , .1,"\ '-' mk. ',99,. ;„,r f• •Y`.•
•''-'-. t."•P ;'l 1' ''Z.:1';'.'''.f.I.tki•4:••ft.IF .'..;,??. •' ,' ''' '. .:.•" r',,i, * *: ' ••';‘,' .41:44 4"-''' 4 - '4.1 t s 17:
ail
. • ;
-- s .. .
- .1,- •-• ......:-.• .Ivp 0. .
(is 31s- ......., ,
•• . -.. , ,A
--•:L.ajmmavr..z-a___--:7-:-7---•...___,,___„,
...• . • • -4
A•11,
;!)=' US i S `;••••-•;;........-
' e.• c'D -- -
i I
, - ,
NI Mc Pq)I A Ni C1-
-N riERIDIAN ST 1
taw
-
1146"4"4""r1*412:1"44."-rn'ml'IM701206100444C4000rViVerir rift-Egleicatre1440141' ''4 I. '''1
, 1:4-S5 E,--, '- - - —•- -- -----t-.--,r,."-.'-'-------''"'-''''''-'-'-'•N MERIDIAN ST.."-., •.:, " -.1, rl MERIDIAN.110°.,
•
- ...-
„..
• 77 :* ‘''i. *\, '-'1
- ..,
IllkjllPIIPIIPIP
....0.. ,-,.....4.4........4.141.,--:=.--r-- .
)1 465 IN "*.• 1 -. • it ---s--
, , ;----- _ .'
a • : •-• ,
`71)r --I
•*..,---
TIT
''' L, 1
•.P. • •
III ' ':' --•
i
/ ._„
. '
It- .., '
e • ,,,...,A.
• •
, I l'..•1;10'0,''., ,,
, •'' I
• , ,,.. i ir t 11 , ?..,),,7, .
'--.. , j• Ili .., i.
, .,,,- ..' -0-fitekv) _:;:,.' ,.....:: - ' - . 1 I •
. - • ,'''r 4
.
ri"
.......
4
Vt
- ' .i •SF.
, ,.41)..-14...• 1., '
Mk 4
.
If 1 '' . 4 • •••• rfi r
. k• ''°'.' . ' —; 1 4
....,- * ..,. - .
i .t..: b-• '
C/ ..„,
. .. ) •ii.-.....r .1 .
14 ,.,„ ' .4. ''i. ••*.
/ ' -,
. . •.., , 4 ,• t• - ,,.‘ . o
,,,...:.., ,.......
_, ...
_.
. .....
- -. AMIE MINI JIM* ....fin,,,, MANIA s ,...,
- - -
3 .-4,—
..... _......_._...._. •ENNS
,
-4,-i 4,.-
a.
c_1\\'' , ' • 4 •'''..-1
V . ' 3."•''' '1, ' - ..
. • NSSNMIN0.114P-
- ' us,, • .'>.:'- ' .
../r
.::
, • ti. .
..
IN III - ', .iii ...4 .
Ell r* - •icl A illkOM X -',.
• • * \ -,
,
11'-5 3/4"
:..-
.. .
5'-8" -_ Bastian _ 28 3/8 B
• SOLUTIONS ` -
0/H
a TOYOTA ADVNICED LOGISTICS COMP Y 4 3/4" T
1
h.,
r -
-,,y
k,ac saa
• lIt • 1 .
40,,,
t':
' rr ` •
41111.
This rendering is®Staley Signs,Inc.,submitted for use in connection with the stated project. Display,Distribution or Duplication nit bout prior written consent is strictly prohibited.
gni /FY SIGNS Customer: Notes:
Bastian Solutions •Colors shown are representative only,and are not Page
ProjeeC intended for purposes of exact matching. 1 y of 3
SINCE 1 9 0 8 Wall Sign Options option.
I!O. liox 515 Indianapolis. Indiana 462O(, -
rr1:.11T.11: /tt,t•tt•.StalCVSi o.li.�;(>7 IasinS.J.cuan .�
hat (Im'ol� Date.12-13-2019 KepD. Staley Jr. Scale:3/32"=1'-0"
,
11'-5 3/4" -
PMS 300 Blue
During Day & Night
Black During Day
& White at Night
28 3/8"
5'-8" astian
I -
PMS
88 Blue
S O 1 I O V Du n2 Day &
9
White at Night
4 3/4"I a TOYOTA ADVANCED LOGISTICS company
1/4" Flat Cut Out
Aluminum Letters
Painted Black
This rendering is®Staley Signs,Inc.,submitted for use in connection with the stated project. Display,Distribution or Duplication without prior written consent is strictly prohibited.
STA JFY SIGNS Customer: Bastian Solutions Notes:
•Colors shown are representative only, areand not
Project: intended for purposes of exact matching. f 3 2 o
SINCE 1 9 0 8 Wall Sign Options Option:. 1
CO. Box 515 Indianapolis.Indiana 46206
Tel:317.63 7.456 7 • lax:317.221.0123
/�t�t�c.,rdc�sins.com,
I fi Date:12-13-2019 Rep:D. Staley Jr. ! Scale: 1/2»=1t-0�,
lot t:
Wall 2447 White Acrylic Faces with
3M Blue Vinyl Overlay
Blue
5" Deep Logo
Black
Returns
0 2447 White Acrylic Faces with
Dual Black Vinyl
28 3/8"
B
JT 6500K White LEDs
Power
Supply r 1" Black Trim Cap on Letters
Enclosure ri
2447 White Acrylic Faces with
3M Dual Blue Vinyl
91/2"
S
6500K White LEDs
1/4" Flat Cut Out Aluminum
---- - Letters Painted Black tt
T
1 This rendering is®Staley Signs,Inc.,submitted for use in connection with the stated project. Display,Distribution or Duplication without prior written consent is strictly prohibited.
SnhI \ II...I !IY SIGNS Customer: Notes:
Bastian Solutions •Colors shown are representative on and are not
Page
h;
Project: intended for purposes of exact matching. 3 of 3
SINCE 1 9 0 8 Wall Sign Options option:
1!(). Box 515 Indianapolis. !ntii;ina 4620() -
ki aj 7.p: /wwa • Fax:/www.staleysigns.coni
12'•1 Date'12-13-2019 RePD• Staley Jr. seale:1 1/2"-1'-0',►tut r ;tt�tw.st,dc�si ns.cum' —
......-
_
1 '... %,..-:', :.-..„.,, - -,-' ,.,•:";..-----i',.' •,,,'-'-':,-..---,--:-,-,,-.-',»,—;--;; .- . ' i
. _.,
- -•
1 ••-- .. - ---"'"'", ------'---- _ .. ...... .,. _ —.
. ,
-...,;.::.---.— ,s• .11'' ' ' '--'--- .
- -- - ' —
-• -" .".--:..--,,,,:•-t•.,:::"7,-.-,.'-- 1.: . . ,
. .. . .
'' I '-' • \ t —
ii,„,,,,
g r!
• ,'"=Irdow....*"-
,„.,;.0.'-'•;':!;-:;:',',... , ,
L4.!-;•x•Y''''.---.! ,,,,,,
, .
- , -•- ,
- ••.'• -
• . . - - -,--
- - .
el,
,,, - --- - --
j.
. - -
fa.
, ..
---r------
%1
•
BALLOT SHEET: FINDINGS OF FACT, DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS VARIANCE
CARMEL ADVISORY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
(Petitioner to fill out 1st two blanks only)
Docket No.: PZ-2020-00001 V
Petitioner: Doug Staley, Jr. on behalf of Bastian Solutions
1.
2.
3.
DATED THIS DAY OF , 20
Board Member
Page 10 of 12 Filename:Hearing Officer Development Standards Variance Application&Instructions 2020 Revised 1/2/20
FINDINGS OF FACT SHEET-DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS VARIANCE
CARMEL ADVISORY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
(Petitioner to fill out 1-3 +first two blanks)
Docket No.: PZ-2020-00001 V
Petitioner: Doug Staley, Jr. on behalf of Bastian Solutions
1. The approval of this variance will not be injurious to the public health, safety, morals and general welfare of
the community because:
The proposed sign will be manufactured and installed using the highest quality materials
and workmanship that meet or exceed industry standards.
2. The use and value of the area adjacent to the property included in the variance will not be affected in a
substantially adverse manner because:
Bastian Solutions is requesting to add their tag line that reflects their partnership with
Toyota. This addition fits nicely on the building and is very tasteful in design and
materials.
3. The strict application of the terms of the Unified Development to the property will result in practical
difficulties in the use of the property because:
The tenant is adding "a TOYOTA ADVANCED LOGISTICS company" to its existing
sign. This tagline is required by their brand standards. If Bastian was to meet the
current spandrel height requirements, they would have to manufacture and install and
entirely new sign. The additional expenses and resources would not be reasonable.
DECISION
IT IS THEREFORE the decision of the Carmel Board of Zoning Appeals that Development Standards Variance
Docket No. is granted, subject to any conditions stated in the minutes of this
Board,which are incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof.
Adopted this day of , 20
HEARING OFFICER, Carmel Board of Zoning Appeals
SECRETARY, Carmel Board of Zoning Appeals
Conditions of approval of the Board, if any, are listed on the Letter of Grant.
Page 11 of 12 Filename:Hearing Officer Development Standards Variance Application&Instructions 2020 Revised 1/2/20