HomeMy WebLinkAboutEvans May Mechanical ComCheckCOMcheck Software Version 4.1.4.0
Mechanical Compliance Certificate
Project Title:
90.1 (2007) Standard
Project Type:Alteration
Location:Carmel, Indiana
Climate Zone:5a
Construction Site:
211 W. Main ST
Carmel, IN 46032
Owner/Agent:
Erice Hannum
Monon Developments Company
3050 Poplar Street
Terre Haute, IN 47803
(317) 518-5768
ehannum@garmong.net
Designer/Contractor:
William Maltby
Genesis Engineering
91 S. Main Street, Suite 200
Zionsville, IN 46077
(317) 847-7480
wmaltby@genesis-engineering.com
Project Information
Energy Code:
Evans May Wealth
Mechanical Systems List
Quantity System Type & Description
VRF Condensing Unit, Air Cooled w/ Heat Recovery Heat Pump
Heating Mode: Capacity = 162 kBtu/h,
Cooling Mode: Capacity = 144 kBtu/h, , Unknown Economizer
Fan System: None
SYSTEM COMPLIANCE EXEMPTION APPLIES
Exemption: Refrigerant change.
1 HRU-3 EAST
VRF Condensing Unit, Air Cooled w/ Heat Recovery Heat Pump
Heating Mode: Capacity = 81 kBtu/h,
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
Cooling Mode: Capacity = 72 kBtu/h,
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
Fan System: None
SYSTEM VERIFICATION REQUIRED.
1 HRU-3 WEST
Cooling: 1 each - VRF Zone Fan Unit, Capacity = 54 kBtu/h, No Economizer, Economizer exception: High Efficiency Equipment
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
Fan System: Unspecified
SYSTEM VERIFICATION REQUIRED.
1 FCU-3W-1
Cooling: 1 each - VRF Zone Fan Unit, Capacity = 48 kBtu/h
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
Fan System: Unspecified
SYSTEM VERIFICATION REQUIRED.
2 FCU-3E-4,5
Cooling: 1 each - VRF Zone Fan Unit, Capacity = 36 kBtu/h
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
Fan System: Unspecified
SYSTEM VERIFICATION REQUIRED.
1 FCU-3E-6
Project Title:
Data filename:
Evans May Wealth
P:\_2020 Projects\Leach and Russell - Monon on Main Second and Third Floor
Buldout\COMCheck\Mechanical COMCheck 3rd Floor.cck
09/08/20Report date:
101 ofPage
Quantity System Type & Description
Cooling: 1 each - VRF Zone Fan Unit, Capacity = 24 kBtu/h
Fan System: Unspecified
SYSTEM COMPLIANCE EXEMPTION APPLIES
Exemption: Relocation of existing equipment.
3 FCU-3E-1,2 AND FCU-3W-2
Mechanical Compliance Statement
Compliance Statement: The proposed mechanical alteration project represented in this document is consistent with the building
plans, specifications, and other calculations submitted with this permit application. The proposed mechanical systems have been
designed to meet the 90.1 (2007) Standard requirements in COMcheck Version 4.1.4.0 and to comply with any applicable
mandatory requirements listed in the Inspection Checklist.
Name - Title Signature Date
Project Title:
Data filename:
Evans May Wealth
P:\_2020 Projects\Leach and Russell - Monon on Main Second and Third Floor
Buldout\COMCheck\Mechanical COMCheck 3rd Floor.cck
09/08/20Report date:
102 ofPage
William Maltby PE 09/08/2020
Inspection Checklist
Requirements: 100.0% were addressed directly in the COMcheck software
COMcheck Software Version 4.1.4.0
Text in the "Comments/Assumptions" column is provided by the user in the COMcheck Requirements screen. For each
requirement, the user certifies that a code requirement will be met and how that is documented, or that an exception
is being claimed. Where compliance is itemized in a separate table, a reference to that table is provided.
Energy Code: 90.1 (2007) Standard
Section
#
& Req.ID
Plan Review Complies?Comments/Assumptions
4.2.2,
6.4.2
[PR2]1
Plans, specifications, and/or
calculations provide all information
with which compliance can be
determined for the mechanical
systems and equipment and
document where exceptions to the
standard are claimed. Load
calculations per acceptable
engineering standards and
handbooks.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
4.2.2,
7.4.1
[PR3]1
Plans, specifications, and/or
calculations provide all information
with which compliance can be
determined for the service water
heating systems and equipment and
document where exceptions to the
standard are claimed. Hot water
system sized per manufacturer's
sizing guide.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
Location on plans/spec: NOT APPLICABLE
6.7.2.4
[PR5]1
Detailed instructions for HVAC
systems commissioning included on
the plans or specifications for projects
>=50,000 ft2.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Exception: Requirement does not apply.
Additional Comments/Assumptions:
1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3)
Project Title:
Data filename:
Evans May Wealth
P:\_2020 Projects\Leach and Russell - Monon on Main Second and Third Floor
Buldout\COMCheck\Mechanical COMCheck 3rd Floor.cck
09/08/20Report date:
103 ofPage
Section
#
& Req.ID
Footing / Foundation Inspection Complies?Comments/Assumptions
6.4.3.8
[FO9]3
Freeze protection and snow/ice
melting system sensors for future
connection to controls.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Exception: Requirement does not apply.
Additional Comments/Assumptions:
1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3)
Project Title:
Data filename:
Evans May Wealth
P:\_2020 Projects\Leach and Russell - Monon on Main Second and Third Floor
Buldout\COMCheck\Mechanical COMCheck 3rd Floor.cck
09/08/20Report date:
104 ofPage
Section
#
& Req.ID
Mechanical Rough-In
Inspection
Plans Verified
Value
Field Verified
Value Complies?Comments/Assumptions
6.4.1.4,
6.4.1.5
[ME1]2
HVAC equipment efficiency
verified. Non-NAECA HVAC
equipment labeled as meeting
90.1.
Efficiency:_____Efficiency:_____Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
See the Mechanical Systems list
for values.
6.4.3.4.1
[ME3]3
Stair and elevator shaft vents
have motorized dampers that
automatically close.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Exception: Requirement
does not apply.
6.4.3.4.2,
6.4.3.4.3,
6.4.3.4.4
[ME4]3
Outdoor air and exhaust systems
have motorized dampers that
automatically shut when not in
use and meet maximum leakage
rates. Check gravity dampers
where allowed.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
Location on plans/spec:
EXISTING ERV
6.4.3.4.5
[ME5]3
Ventilation fans >0.75 hp have
automatic controls to shut off fan
when not required.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
Location on plans/spec:
NOT APPLICABLE
6.4.3.9
[ME6]1
Demand control ventilation
provided for spaces >500 ft2 and
>40 people/1000 ft2 occupant
density and served by systems
with air side economizer, auto
modulating outside air damper
control, or design airflow >3,000
cfm.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
Location on plans/spec:
EXISTING ERV
6.4.4.1.1
[ME7]3
Insulation exposed to weather
protected from damage.
Insulation outside of the
conditioned space and associated
with cooling systems is vapor
retardant.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
6.4.4.1.2
[ME8]2
HVAC ducts and plenums
insulated.
R-_____R-_____Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
6.4.4.1.3
[ME9]2
HVAC piping insulation thickness._____ in._____ in.Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
6.4.4.2.1
[ME10]2
Ducts and plenums sealed based
on static pressure and location.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
6.4.4.2.2
[ME11]3
Ductwork operating >3 in. water
column requires air leakage
testing.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Exception: Requirement
does not apply.
6.4.4.2.2
[ME11]3
Ductwork operating >3 in. water
column requires air leakage
testing.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Exception: Requirement
does not apply.
6.4.4.2.2
[ME11]3
Ductwork operating >3 in. water
column requires air leakage
testing.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Exception: Requirement
does not apply.
1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3)
Project Title:
Data filename:
Evans May Wealth
P:\_2020 Projects\Leach and Russell - Monon on Main Second and Third Floor
Buldout\COMCheck\Mechanical COMCheck 3rd Floor.cck
09/08/20Report date:
105 ofPage
Section
#
& Req.ID
Mechanical Rough-In
Inspection
Plans Verified
Value
Field Verified
Value Complies?Comments/Assumptions
6.4.4.2.2
[ME11]3
Ductwork operating >3 in. water
column requires air leakage
testing.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Exception: Requirement
does not apply.
6.4.4.2.2
[ME11]3
Ductwork operating >3 in. water
column requires air leakage
testing.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Exception: Requirement
does not apply.
6.4.4.2.2
[ME11]3
Ductwork operating >3 in. water
column requires air leakage
testing.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Exception: Requirement
does not apply.
6.5.1,
6.5.1.1.1,
6.5.1.1.2,
6.5.1.1.3,
6.5.1.3
[ME12]1
Air economizers provided where
required, meet the requirements
for design capacity, control
signal, ventilation controls, high-
limit shut-off, integrated
economizer control, and provide
a means to relieve excess
outside air during operation.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
6.5.2.3
[ME19]3
Dehumidification controls
provided to prevent reheating,
recooling, mixing of hot and cold
airstreams or concurrent heating
and cooling of the same
airstream.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
Location on plans/spec:
NOT APPLICABLE
6.5.4.1
[ME25]3
HVAC pumping systems >10 hp
designed for variable fluid flow.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
Location on plans/spec:
NOT APPLICABLE
6.5.6.1
[ME30]1
Exhaust air energy recovery on
systems >=5,000 cfm and 70%
of design supply air.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
Location on plans/spec:
EXISTING ERV
6.5.7.1
[ME32]2
Kitchen hoods >5,000 cfm have
make up air >=50% of exhaust
air volume.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Exception: Requirement
does not apply.
6.5.7.2
[ME33]1
Fume hoods exhaust systems
>=15,000 cfm have VAV hood
exhaust and supply systems,
direct make-up air or heat
recovery.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Exception: Requirement
does not apply.
6.5.8.1
[ME34]3
Unenclosed spaces that are
heated use only radiant heat.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Exception: Requirement
does not apply.
Additional Comments/Assumptions:
1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3)
Project Title:
Data filename:
Evans May Wealth
P:\_2020 Projects\Leach and Russell - Monon on Main Second and Third Floor
Buldout\COMCheck\Mechanical COMCheck 3rd Floor.cck
09/08/20Report date:
106 ofPage
Section
#
& Req.ID
Rough-In Electrical Inspection Complies?Comments/Assumptions
10.4.1
[EL9]2
Electric motors meet requirements
where applicable.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
Additional Comments/Assumptions:
1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3)
Project Title:
Data filename:
Evans May Wealth
P:\_2020 Projects\Leach and Russell - Monon on Main Second and Third Floor
Buldout\COMCheck\Mechanical COMCheck 3rd Floor.cck
09/08/20Report date:
107 ofPage
Section
#
& Req.ID
Final Inspection Complies?Comments/Assumptions
6.4.3.1.1
[FI2]2
Heating and cooling to each zone is
controlled by a thermostat control.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
6.4.3.1.2,
6.4.3.2,
6.4.3.3,
6.4.3.3.1,
6.4.3.3.2
[FI3]2
Thermostatic controls have a 5 °F
deadband.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
6.4.3.5
[FI5]3
Heat pump controls prevent
supplemental electric resistance heat
from coming on when not needed.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
Location on plans/spec: NOT APPLICABLE
6.4.3.5
[FI5]3
Heat pump controls prevent
supplemental electric resistance heat
from coming on when not needed.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
Location on plans/spec: NOT APPLICABLE
6.4.3.7
[FI6]3
When humidification and
dehumidification are provided to a
zone, simultaneous operation is
prohibited.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
Location on plans/spec: NOT APPLICABLE
6.7.2.1
[FI7]3
Furnished HVAC as-built drawings
submitted within 90 days of system
acceptance.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
6.7.2.2
[FI8]3
Furnished O&M manuals for HVAC
systems within 90 days of system
acceptance.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
6.7.2.3
[FI9]1
An air and/or hydronic system
balancing report is provided for HVAC
systems serving zones >5,000 ft2 of
conditioned area.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
6.7.2.4
[FI10]1
HVAC control systems have been
tested to ensure proper operation,
calibration and adjustment of controls.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
6.4.3.2
[FI20]1
Temperature controls have setpoint
overlap restrictions.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
6.4.3.3.1
[FI21]1
HVAC systems equipped with at least
one automatic shutdown control.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
6.4.3.3.2
[FI22]1
Setback controls allow automatic
restart and temporary operation as
required for maintenance.
Complies
Does Not
Not Observable
Not Applicable
Requirement will be met.
Additional Comments/Assumptions:
1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3)
Project Title:
Data filename:
Evans May Wealth
P:\_2020 Projects\Leach and Russell - Monon on Main Second and Third Floor
Buldout\COMCheck\Mechanical COMCheck 3rd Floor.cck
09/08/20Report date:
108 ofPage
1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3)
Project Title:
Data filename:
Evans May Wealth
P:\_2020 Projects\Leach and Russell - Monon on Main Second and Third Floor
Buldout\COMCheck\Mechanical COMCheck 3rd Floor.cck
09/08/20Report date:
109 ofPage
Project Title:
Data filename:
Evans May Wealth
P:\_2020 Projects\Leach and Russell - Monon on Main Second and Third Floor
Buldout\COMCheck\Mechanical COMCheck 3rd Floor.cck
09/08/20Report date:
1010 ofPage