HomeMy WebLinkAboutBPW-10-07-98City of Carmel
CARMEL BOARD OF PUBLIC WORKS & SAFETY MEETING AGENDA
WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 7, 1998 --10 A.M.
COUNCIL CHAMBERS / CITY HALL / ONE CIVIC SQUARE
MEETING CALLED TO ORDER
Approval of Minutes
a. September 16, 1998, regular meeting
b. September 23, 1998, special meeting
Contracts
a. Agreement for Provision of Services; Indiana University Department of
Pharmacology and Toxicology; Chief Michael Fogarty, Police Department
b. Agreement for Professional Services; Rust Environmental and Infrastructure,
Inc.; Kate Boyle, City Engineer
c. Agreement for Professional Services; Certified Engineering, Inc.; Kate Boyle,
City Engineer
d. Agreement for Installation of Wireless Wide Area Communications
Network; Network Engineering, Inc.; Teny Crockett, Director of Information
Services
Claims
a. $15,665.13 9/9/98
b. $34,807.69 9/16/98
c. $41,567.12 9/23/98
d. $21,860.95 10/98
Request to Use City Property/Close Street
a. Request to Use Gazebo for Brownie Troop Ceremony; Denita Raymont,
Carmel Brownie Troop 790; Saturday, May 22, 1999, 1 to 6 p.m.
b. Request to Use Gazebo for Fund Raiser; Marlene Reynolds, Capitol City
S.D.A. School; Sunday, October 18, 1998; 9 a.m. to 7 p.m.
c. Request to Use Gazebo for Easter Sunrise Service; T. Lane Sims, Carmel
Friends Meeting (and other churches), Sunday, April 4, 1999, 7 to 10 a.m.
Other
a.
Promotion of Officer to Master Patrol Officer; Chief Michael Fogarty, Police
Department
Promotion of Officers to First Class Patrol Officer; Chief Michael Fogarty,
Police Department
Resolution BPW-10-07-98-01, Authorization to Use Alternative Disposal
Methods to Lease City Property at 473 3rd Ave. SW for a Telecommunications
Facility; Douglas C. Haney, City Attorney
ONE CIVIC SQUARE CARMEL, INDIANA 46032 317/571-2400
f.
g.
h.
i.
Resolution BPW-10-07-98-02, Authorization to Use Alternative Disposal
Methods to Lease City Property at 901 N. Rangeline Road for a
Telecommunications Facility; Douglas C. Haney, City Attorney
Resolution BPW-10-07-98-03, Approval of Special Agreements and
Arrangements for Discharge of Wastewater; John Duffy, Utilities Director
Change Order #3 for Wildwood and Thornhurst Utility Improvement
Project ($51,939.30); John Duffy, Utilities Director
Secondary Plat Approval; Lost Oaks at Haverstick, Section 2A and Stone Haven
at Haverstick, Section 2A; Brett Wright, Centex Homes
Open Cut Requests; 126th Street East of Gray Road and Rangeline Road South
of 116th Street; Cathy Miessen, Indiana Gas Company
Street Light Request; 116th Street and Pursel Drive, Lake Forest Subdivision
Entrance; John Retzlaff, Lake Forest
Adjournment
CARMEL BOARD OF PUBLIC WORKS MEETING MINUTES
WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 7, 1998 --10 A.M.
COUNCIL CHAMBERS / CITY HALL / ONE CIVIC SQUARE
MEMBERS PRESENT: Mayor James Brainard; Board Members Billy Walker and Mary Ann
Burke. Clerk-Treasurer Diana Cordray and Deputy Clerk Rebecca Martin also attended.
Mayor Brainard called the meeting to order at 10:01 a.m.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES: Board Member Burke moved to approve the minutes of the
September 16, 1998, regular meeting, and the September 23, 1998, special meeting. Board
Member Walker seconded. The minutes were approved 3-0.
CONTRACTS:
Agreement for Provision of Services with Indiana Universi _ty Department of Pharmacology and
Toxicology: Mayor Brainard moved to approve the contract. Board Member Walker seconded.
The contract was approved 3-0.
Agreement for Professional Services with Rust Environmental and Infrastructure. Inc.: Mayor
Brainard moved to approve the contract. Board Member Burke seconded. The contract, which
was for Fire Station #3 culvert replacement, was approved 3-0.
Agreement for Professional Services with Certified En~neering. Inc.: Mayor Brainard moved to
approve the contract. Board Member Walker seconded. The contract, which was for evaluation
of options to improve the 126th Street and Auman Drive/Lexington Boulevard intersection, was
approved 3-0.
Agreement for Installation of Wireless Wide Area Communications Network with Network
Engineering, Inc.: Mayor Brainard moved to approve the contract. Board Member Walker
seconded. The contract was approved 3-0.
CLAIMS:
Mayor Brainard moved to approve the claims as listed on the agenda. Board Member Burke
seconded. Claims were approved 3-0.
REQUEST TO USE CITY PROPERTY/CLOSE CITY STREET:
Mayor Brainard moved to approve the following requests. Board Member Walker seconded. The
requests were approved 3-0.
Request to Use Gazebo for Brownie Troop Ceremony; Denita Raymont. Carmel Brownie
Troop 790: Saturday. May 22. 1999. 1 to 6 p.m.
Request to Use Gazebo for Fund Raiser: Marlene Reynolds. Capitol City S.D.A. School:
Sunday. October 18. 1998.9 a.m. to 7 p.m.
Request to Use Gazebo for Easter Sunrise Service: T. Lane Sims. Carmel Friends Meetin~
(and other churches): Sunday, April 4. 1999.7 to 10 a.m.
OTHER:
Promotion of Officer to Master Patrol Officer and Promotion of Officers to First Class Patrol
Officers: Police Chief Michael Fogarty stated that Officer Janet Uhrick had met all criteria for
promotion to MPO and that she had never be~n placed under departmental discipline. He stated
that Officers Phillip Hobson, Brett Keith and Curtis Scott had met all criteria for promotion to
First Class Patrol Officers and had completed their performance evaluations. Mayor Brainard
moved to approve the promotions. Board Member Walker seconded. The promotions were
approved 3-0.
Resolution BPW-10-07-98-01. Authorization to Use Alternative Disposal Methods tO Lease City.
Property at 473 3rd Ave. SW for a Telecommunications Facili _ty: Mayor Bralnard explained the
City desired to lease approximately 500 square feet of land adjacent to the City's communication
tower with the right to use a portion of the tower as a telecommunications facility. He stated that
approval of this resolution was needed so the City could begin negotiating leases. The mayor
further explained that whatever lease the City entered into must include a "terminable at will"
clause in case the City chose to move the location and sell it. Mayor Bralnard moved to approve
the resolution. Board Member Walker seconded. Board Member Walker asked if the City was
required by federal law to lease telecommunication sites to a certain number of vendors. City
Attorney Douglas C. Haney stated the City was required to make good faith efforts to
accommodate collocation but could use discretion whether to approve a company's use of the
facilities if it was not in the City's best interest.
Resolution BPW-10-07-98-02. Authorization to Use Alternative Disposal Methods to Lease City
Property at 901 N. Rangeline Road for a Telecommunications Facili _ty: Mayor Bralnard moved
to approve the resolution. Board Member Walker seconded. The resolutions were approved 3-0.
Resolution BPW-10-07-98-03. Approval of Special Agreements and Arrangements for
Discharge of Wastewater: Mayor Brainard explained that this resolution would allow anyone
who had portable toilets to discharge them into the City's wastewater system for a fee. Mayor
Brainard moved to approve the resolution. Board Member Walker seconded. Utilities Manager
John Duffy stated the City had not done this before, but that the Utility would have complete
control over the companies who discharged their portable toilets into the system. Mr. Dully
stated the projected yearly revenue fi.om allowing the Utility to do this would be $25,000 to
$40,000 for the City. The resolution was approved 3-0.
Change Order #3 for Wildwood and Thomhurst Utility Improvement Pro_/ect ($51.939.30): Mr.
Duffy stated that this was the last change order for the project and explained that poor soils had
contributed to the need for it. Mayor Brainard moved to approve the change order. Board
Member Burke seconded. The change order was approved 3-0.
Secondary_ Plat Approval. Lost Oaks at Haverstick. Section 2A and Stone Haven at Haverstick.
Section 2A: Mayor Brainard asked the city engineer if Centex had donated the right of way
needed to enlarge River Road between the north boundary of Prairie View and the school site.
He asked specifically if the City had a deed for the property. Kate Boyle, the city engineer, stated
the right of way dedication was part of Centex's plat. Mayor Brainard moved to approve the
plats. Board Member Walker seconded. The mayor asked how the right of way had been granted
to the City, whether in a commitment fi.om the plan commission, on a plat or in a deed. Ms.
Boyle stated the right of way had been dedicated by way of the plat and the commitment to make
certain improvements had been approved by the Board previously. She stated she was not sure if
the fight of way dedication by plat included a deed. The mayor stated a deed was necessary and
asked the engineer to follow up on the issue. The plats were approved 3-0.
Reauest to Open Cut 126th Street East of Gray Road Center Line and Rangeline Road South of
116-th Street: Indiana Gas Co.: Steve Kalk, work coordinator for Indiana Gas, explained the gas
company needed to access valves called "critical valves" in order to comply with federal law. He
stated the mount of traffic traveling over the valves had not been good for them. Mayor
Brainard addressed another subject to the gas company. He stated that construction on Hazel
Dell Parkway had been slowed substantially because the gas company was not responding to
requests by the City's construction engineer to move a gas line that was already supposed to have
been moved. Mayor Brainard asked Ms. Boyle to try to reach Charlie Buell of Milestone
Contractors, the construction engineer for the Hazel Dell project, on his cell phone to find out if
he needed anything else from Indiana Gas to complete Hazel Dell Parkway. The mayor
suggested that the Board, if the members agreed, put this item aside until Ms. Boyle reached Mr.
Buell.
Street Light Request for 116th Street and Pursel Drive at Lake Forest Subdivision Entrance:
Mayor Brainard stated the city engineer agreed the proposed lights met the City's requirements.
Mayor Brainard moved to approve the request. Board Member Burke seconded. The request was
approved 3-0.
Board members signed documents and recessed for about 20 minutes.
Ms. Boyle returned and stated she was unable to reach Mr. Buell. She stated she did speak to
David Black of Milestone, who stated they had received plans from the gas company about a
month ago showing a certain gas pipe line to have been abandoned that was not. She stated that
this was the pipe workers struck a few days ago. Mayor Brainard stated he was not so much
concerned about that mistake, which had been remedied, but wanted to know if there were other
utilities that needed to be moved. Ms. Boyle stated that this line was the only line that still
needed to be transferred to the replacement line, and that Milestone was told the gas company
would fix the error on Thursday. Ms. Boyle stated the contractor was unable to move forward
with the project until the gas company moved the line. The mayor and Ms. Boyle discussed how
long the gas company knew it needed to have the line moved. Mayor Brainard left the meeting
for several minutes to talk with Mr. Black on the phone.
Mayor Brainard returned to the meeting and stated that Mr. Black indicated these pipe line
abandonments had been on the relocation plans given to the gas company last September. Mayor
Brainard stated he was inclined not to consider the gas company's requests until this error, which
had halted the City's $20 million Hazel Dell project, was corrected. He stated he would be
willing to call a special meeting to approve the gas company's request, but the gas line
preventing construction on Hazel Dell had to be moved.
John Fansher, area manager for Indiana Gas, said he understood the City's concern. He
explained that someone had miscalculated the location of the pipe by 50 to 60 feet, but the gas
company was not aware of this until the line was struck. He stated that Mr. Kalk met with
contractors on site and assured them the gas company would move the pipe as soon as possible.
Mr. Fansher explained some other problems the gas company had had finding locates at Hazel
Dell Parkway and Cherry Tree Road.
In response to the mayor's question as to why the gas company put valves under intersections,
Mr. Fansher explained that this method was no longer practiced today. The mayor asked if the
gas company's request for the open cut included a proposal to move the valve out of the
roadway. Mr. Fansher stated they had no plans to move the valve, and that even though the gas
company checked the valves annually it usually didn't have to open cut the road. He explained
that this open cut was required because the valve box had been crushed and dirt had gotten
underneath it. Mayor Brainard stated he didn't want to approve the street cut if the gas company
wasn't going to remedy the need to cut the street in the future and asked why the gas company
didn't put the new valve box outside of the roadway. Mr. Fansher stated it would be too
expensive. The mayor explained the road the gas company wanted to cut was a "15-year" road
that was only three years old, and that the taxpayers were the ones who paid for it. Mr. Fansher
stated that if the gas company moved the pipes, this would be reflected in rate increases to the
customers.
Board Member Walker asked why the valve wasn't moved years ago and recommended moving
the valve outside the road. Mr. Fansher explained the gas company historically complied with the
City when asked them to move its lines. Mr. Fansher stated the gas company wanted to work
with the City and provide the best service to its customers without raising rates. Ms. Boyle
interrupted the meeting to let the mayor know that Mike Knolting from Milestone was on the
phone. The mayor left the meeting for a few minutes to talk with Mr. Knolting. Board Member
Walker asked Mr. Fansher if boring was an option. Mr. Fansher said it was a very costly option.
Mayor Brainard returned to the meeting and moved to table the request until the engineers
working on Hazel Dell Parkway reported the gas company had taken care of all problems. He
stated he would call a special meeting at that time to reconsider this request. Mr. Fansher stated
he understood the City's position of wanting assurance the gas company would follow up on its
commitment to move the line on Hazel Dell. He stated the utility was committed to moving the
line this Friday. The mayor stated the City had just acquired the right of way for the Henshaw
property along Hazel Dell, but wondered if the gas company could disconnect this line on Friday
also. Mr. Kalk and Mr. Fansher stated they would see what could be done. The mayor also
mentioned the Geographic Information System (GIS) and stated he hoped the gas company
would work with the City as the system was developed.
Mr. Fansher apologized for the delay in the Hazel Dell project and stated they would take care of
the issue as soon as possible. Board Member Burke seconded the mayor's motion to table the
request. Board Member Walker asked how important it was for the gas company to repair the
valves. Mr. Fansher stated the valves served the library and Clay Junior High and were
considered critical in a major gas emergency. Mayor Bralnard asked if the gas company could
get to the valves and shut them off if needed. Mr. Fansher said no; this is why they needed the
street cut. He stated the only way the gas company could shut off the gas flow at this time would
be to dig a large hole and squeeze the valve slowly for a minimum of four hours.
The mayor withdrew his motion and moved to approve the request. He asked the gas company to
please work with the City to alleviate the problems on the Hazel Dell project. Board Member
Burke withdrew her second. Mayor Brainard moved to approve the request. Board Member
Walker seconded. Mr. Fansher asked if the mayor had any more concerns. Mr. Fansher explained
gas lines to the Cannel Motel should be shut offthis afternoon. The request was approved 3-0.
The meeting was adjourned at 11:24 a.m.
Res:~
Cferk-Treasurer Diana L~ordray, IAMC
Apprqved, ~ t
Attest:
Cler'~~IAMC