Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCCM-05-02-05City of .Carmel Office of the Clerk. Treasurer COMMON COUNCIL MEETING AGENDA MONDAY, MAY 2, 2005 - 6:00 P.M. COUNCIL CHAMBERS/CITY HALL/ONE CIVIC SQUARE MEETING CALLED TO ORDER 1. INVOCATION PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE RECOGNITION OF CITY ~MPLOYEES AND OUTSTANDING CITIZE. NS 4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES a. April 18, 2005 Regular Meeting b. April 18, 2005 Executive Session Meeting 5. RECOGNITION OF PERSONS WHO WISH TO ADDRESS THE COUNCIL 6. COUNCIL, MAYORAL AND CLERK-TREASURER COMMENTS/OBSERVATIONS ACTION ON MAYORAL,VETOES CLAIMS · Payroll · General Claims · Retirement COMMITTEE REPORTS a. Finance, Administration and Rules Committee b. Land Use, Annexation and Economic Development Committee c. Parks, Recreation and Arts Committee d. Utilities, Transportation and Public Safety Committee ONE CIVIC SQUARE CA.~,MEL INDIANA 46032 317/571-2414 ] O. OLD BUSINESS 11. a. Second Reading of Ordinance No. D-1731-04; An Ordinance of the Common Council of' thd City of Camel, Indiana, Amending Chapter 8, Article 3, Section 8-20(a)(1) of the Carmel City Co'~le (Establish a twenty-five mile per hour speed limit on certain portions of II Cherry Tree Road); Sponsor: Councilor Griffiths. PUBLIC HEARINGS a.First Reading 6f Ordinance Z-476-05; An Ordinance of the Common Council of the City of Carmel, indiana, An Ordinance Amending Building Height Restrictions in the · C-I/City Center District and C-2/Old Town District o~' the Carmel Zoning Ordinance; Sponsor: Councilor Rattermarm. First Reading of Ordinance Z-477-05: An Ordinance oft he Common Council of the City of Carmel, Indiana, Rezoning District Classification, Rezoning the Southeast Corner o£ Main Street and Range Line Road from the B-l/Business District, B-2/Business District and R-2/Residen~e District Classification to the C-2/OId Town District Classification} Sponsor: Councdor Rattem~ann. 12. .NEW BUSINESS a. First Reading of Ordinance D-1752-05: An Ordinance of the Common Council of the City of Carmel, ilndiana, Approving a Lease Between the City of Carmel Redevelopment Authority and the City of Carmel Redevelopment Commission, and Addressing Matters Related Theretoi[(Performing Arts Center); Sponsor(s): Councilor(s) Carter and ShatW ,ii b. First Reading 6f Ordinance D-1753-05; An Ordinance'of the Common Council of the City of Carmel, indiana, Amending and Restating Chapter 4, Article 1, Division III, Section 4-26, of!ithe Carmel City Code (Door-To-Door Vendors); Sponsor:' Councilor Griffiths. c. Resolution CC205-02-05-01; A Resolution of the Common Council of the City of · Carmel, Indiana! to Join the Central indiana Regional Transportation Authority; Sponsor: Councilor Kirb~i 13. 14. 15. OTHER BUSINESS ANNOUNCEMENTS EXECUTION OF I~OCUMENTS 16. ADJOURNMENT , COMMON COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES MONDAY, MAY 2, 2005 - 6:00 P.M. COUNCIL CHAMBERS/CITY HALL/ONE CIVIC SQUARE MEMBERS PRESENT: Mayor James Brainard, Council President Kevin Kirby, Council Members Rick Sharp, Brian Mayo, Joe Griffiths, Fred Glaser, Ron Carter, Mark Rattermann, Clerk-Treasurer Diana Cordray and Deputy Clerk- Treasurer Lois Fine. Mayor Brainard called the meeting to order at 6:03 p.m. Mayor Brainard pronounced the Invocation. RECOGNITION OF CiTY EMPLOYEES AND OUTSTANDING CITIZENS: There were none. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: Councilor Mayo made a motion to approve the Minutes of the April 18, 2005 Regular Meeting. Councilor Griffiths seconded. Council President Kirby called for the question. The Minutes were approved6-0 (Councilor Sharp abstained). Councilor Mayo made a motion to approve the Minutes of the April 18, 2005 Executive Session Meeting. Councilor Glaser seconded. Council President Kirby called for the question. The Minutes were approved 6-0 (Councilor Sharp abstained). RECOGNITION OF PERSONS WHO WISH TO ADDRESS THE COUNCIL: The following persons addressed Council in favor of Ordinance D-1752-05 (Performing Arts Center): Gall Eastburn Natalie Corey Larry Creviston Beth Renselle Winston Long Bruce Cordingley 1116 Mos? Drive, Carmel, Indiana 5873 Dawnwood Drive, Indianapolis, Indiana 179 Aspen Way, Carmel, Indiana 14474 Allison Drive, Carmel, Indiana 12316 Brookshire Parkway, Carmel, Indiana 770 Third Avenue SW, Carmel, Indiana Brian Shapiro Jerry Heniser Bill Ensign Joy Stafford Kathy Christie Nick Kestner Jeanne Book Don Bennett 46I 0 Woodhaven, Zionsville, Indiana 433 Autumn Drive, Carmel, Indiana 1627 O'Barh, Carmel, Indiana 24 Maple Crest Drive, Carmel, Indiana 5266 Apache Moon, Carmel, Indiana 2123 W. 106th Street, Carmel, Indiana 12550 Springmill, Carmel, Indiana 1489 Springmill Ponds Blvd., Carmel, Indiana The following persons addressed Council in favor, but with concerns regarding funding, of Ordinance D-1752-05 (Performing Arts Center): Edward Pipkin Nellie Pipkin 954 E. 108th Street, Homeplace 954 E. 108th Street, Homeplace The following persons addressed Council in opposition to Ordinance D-1752-05 (Performing Arts Center): Sandy Johnson Wayne Wilson Suzy Mills 9868 Woodbriar, Carmel, Indiana 24 Wilson Drive, Carmel, Indiana 2058 Barrel Racer Lane, Carmel, Indiana Cotmcilor Sharp made a motion to move item 12.(a) to this point on the agenda. Councilor Griffiths seconded. Council President Kirby announced the First Reading of Ordinance D-1752-05; An Ordinance of the Common Council of the City of Cannel, Indiana, Approving a Lease Between the City of Carmel Redevelopment Authority and the City of Carmel Redevelopment Commission, and Addressing Matters Related Thereto (Performing Arts Center). Councilor Sharp moved to introduce this item into business. Councilor Griffiths seconded. Cguncilor Sharp presented this matter to Council and referred to Mayor Brainard for a presentation to Council. Mayor Brainard distributed to Council a binder with letters of support from the community for the Performing Arts Center. Mayor Brainard referred to Willem Brans, Marks Paneth Strategy Group, for a presentation to Cguncil. Mr. Brans then referred to Sean Ryan, FRICS, Senior Consultant, Donnell Consultants Inc., who made a presentation to Council. Mr. Ryan then referred to Loren Matthes, H. Umbaugh & Company, who made a presentation to Council. Them was extensive Council discussion. C6uncilor Rattermann suggested to Council President Kirby that two public hearings he held on this Ordinance in Council Chambers and suggested that the public hefirings be televised. Councilor Rattermann also requested that two white boards be prepared with the following information: First white board is to be prepared by the Clerk-Treasurer: 1) City indebtedness 2) Debt payments 3) Who guarantees funding 2 Second white board is to be prepared by the Chairman of the Finance Committee, the Clerk-Treasurer and the Mayor: 1) What projects are being proposed for the future (5 year plan) Council President Kirby referred Ordinance D-1752-05 to the Finance, Administration and Rules Committee for further review and consideration and asked that the Chairman of the Finance Committee to hold the meetings in Council Chambers and, ii'possible, have the meeting televised. Council President Kirby called a recess at 8:30 p.m. Council President Kirby called the reconvened the meeting at 8:38 p.m. COUNCIL~ MAYORAL AND=CLERK-TREASURER COMMENTS/OBSERVATIONS: There were none. ACTION ON MAYORAL VETOES: There were none. CLAIMS: Councilor Mayo made a motion to approve the claims in the amount of $2,813 323.97. Councilor Griffiths seconded. Council President Kirby called for the question. Claims were approved 7-0. COMMITTEE REPORTS: Councilor Glaser reported that the Finance, Administration and Rules Committee had not met. The next meeting is scheduled for Monday, May 16, 2005 at 5:00 p.m. Councilor Sharp reported that the Land Use, Annexation and Economic Development Committee had not met. The next meeting is scheduled for Thursday, May 12, 2005 at 5:00 p.m. Councilor Carter reported that the Parks, Recreation and Arts Committee had not met. The next meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, May 10, 2005. Councilor Mayo reported that the Utilities, Transportation and Public Safety Committee had not met. The next meeting is scheduled for Monday, May 9, 2005. OLD BUSINESS Council President Kirby announced the Second Reading of Ordinance No. D-1731-04; An Ordinance of the Common Council of the City of Carmel, Indiana, Amending Chapter 8, Article 3, Section 8-20(a)(1) of the Carmel City Code (Establish a twenty-five mile per hour speed limit on certain portions of Cherry Tree Road). Councilor Griffiths presented this item to Council. There was brief Council discussion. · Council President Kirby referred to Doug Haney, City Attorney, for clarification of the law concerning speed studies (an engineering study is required before adopting an ordinance changing a speed limit). 3 Council President Kirby called for the question. Ordinance No. D-1731-04 was adopted 5-2 (Councilors Kirby and Rattermann opposed). PUBLIC HEARINGS Council President Kirby announced the First Reading of Ordinance Z-476-05; An Ordinance of the Common Council of the City of Carmel, Indiana, An Ordinance Amending Building Height Restrictions in the C-l/City Center District and C-2/Old Town District of the Carmel Zoning Ordinance. Councilor Mayo moved to introduce this item into business. Councilor Glaser seconded. Councilor Rattermann referred to Jon Dobosiewicz, Department of Community Services, for a presentation to Council. There was brief Council discussion. Council President Kirby opened the Public Hearing at 8:47 p.m. Seeing no one who wished to speak, Council President Kirby closed the Public Hearing at 8:48 p.m. Councilor Sharp made a motion to suspend the rules and vote this evening. Councilor Griffiths seconded. Council President Kirby called for the question. The motion to suspend the rules and vote this evening passed 7-0. Councilor Sharp made a motion to approve Ordinance Z-476-05. Councilor Griffiths seconded. Council President Kirby called for the question. Ordinance Z-476-05 was adopted 7-0. Council Presideht Kirby announced the First Reading of Ordinance Z-477-05: An Ordinance of the Common Council of the City of Carmel, Indiana, Rezoning District Classification, Rezoning the Southeast Corner of Main Street and Range Line Road from the B-l/Business District, B-2/Business District and R-2/Residence District Classification to the C-2/Old Town District Classification. Councilor Rattermann moved to introduce this item into business. Councilor Sharp seconded. Councilor Rattermann referred to Jon Dobosiewicz, Department of Community Services, for a presentation to Council. There was brief Council discussion. Council President Kirby opened the Public Hearing at 8:52 p.m. Seeing no one who wished to speak, Council President Kirby closed the Public Hearing at 8:53 p.m. There was no Council discussion. Council President Kirby referred Ordinance Z-477-05 to the Land Use, Annexation and Economic Development Committee for further review and consideration. NEW BUSINESS Council President Kirby announced the First Reading of Ordinance D-1753-05; An Ordinance of the Common Council of the City of Carmel, Indiana, Amending and Restating Chapter 4, Article 1, Division III, Section 4-26, of the Carmel City Code (Door-To-Door Vendors). Councilor Griffiths moved to introduce this item into business. Councilor Glaser seconded. Councilor Griffiths presented this item to Council. There was brief Council discussion. Council President Kirby referred Ordinance D-1753-05 to the Utilities, Transportation and Public Safety Committee for further review and consideration. Councilor Mayo requested that Doug Haney, City Attorney, attend the Public Safety Committee meeting on May 9, 2005. Council President Kirby announced Resolution CC-05-02-05-01; A Resolution of the Common Council of the City of Carmel, Indiana, to Join the Central Indiana Regional Transportation Authority. Councilor Glaser moved to introduce this item into business. Councilor Mayo seconded. Council President Kirby presented this item to Council. There was brief CounciI discussion. Council President Kirby called for the question. Resolution CC-05-02-05-01 was adopted 7-0. OTHER BUSINESS There was none. 4 ANNOUNCEMENTS There were ilone. EXECUTION OF DOCUMENTS Mayor Brainard adjourned the meeting following execution of documents at 9:00 p.m. ADJOURNMENT ATTEST: Clerk-Treasurer Diana L. Cordray, ,I/A. qVIC / / Clerk-Treasurer Diana L(Co IAMc Approved, Iv~9~o~r J~es Brai nar~d~ ~0000 O0 O0 000 ~ooooD~°°~°°~°°°°°°°°° CITY OF CAR3IEL REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION SCHEDULE OF ESTIMATED TAX INCREMENT FOR TIlE CITY CENTER REDEVELOPMENT AREA Surplus Year Payable Existing incremental assessed value (I) 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Current development in existing area: (2) Pedcor City Center Parcel B West Building Pedcor City Center Parcel 2B East Building Pedcor Building #3 9,890 sq. 1t. building Anticipated development: Est. 135,000 sq. ft. &retail/office (Parcels 12, 13, 21,26) Est. 100,000 sq. ft. of retail/office (Parcel 14) Total incremental estimated assessed value $23,625,604 $24,353,304 ~ $24,353,304 $24,353,304 $24,353,304 Tilnes net tax rate (3) Total estimated tax increment Plus estimated TIF replacement (4) Total tax increment and TIF replacement 1,246,000 1,246,000 1,246,000 1,246,000 1,226,700 1,226,700 1,226,700 1,226,700 2,400,000 2,400,000 2,400,000 680,000 680,000 680,000 9,450,000 9,450,000 7,000,000 23,625,604 26,826,004 29,906,004 39,356,004 46,356,004 $1.5212 $1.5212 $1.5212 $1.5212 $l.5212 359,400 408,090 454,940 598,700 705,180 64,334 $423,734 $408,090 $454,940 $598,700 $705,180 (l) Per database provided by the Hamilton County Auditor's office. (2) Per information provided by the Building & Code Enforcement for the City of Carmel and comparable buildings located in Hamilton County. (3) Equal to the 2005 gross tax rate of $2.0317 less the real property state property tax replacement credit of .251252 for the City of Carmel. (4) Assumes the State imposed levy is not rescinded. For Discussion Purposes Only Prepared by Umbaugh May 2, 2005 z ~Ooo~ CITY OF CARMEL REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION City Center Redevelopment Area and 126th St. Ecottomic Development Area HISTORICAL TAX INCREMENT Year Annual Payable Tax Increment % Growth 1999 $373,156 2000 767,076 106% 2001 1,156,584 51% 2002 1,510,095 31% 2003 (1) 2,620,624 74% 2004 (1) (2) 4,104,526 57% 2005 (1) (2) 4,824,711 18% (1) Includes the Tax Increment Replacement Levy. (2) Based on databases provided by the Hamilton County Auditor's office. Before 2005, only the City Center Redevelopment Area and the 126th EDA generated TIF revenue. For Discussion Purposes Only Prepared by Umbaugh May 2, 2005 6 .qrts Center Creating a cultUral center to enhance the community's quality of life William S. Kirsch President ~y Chief Executive officer CONSECO, INC. Mar6h 23, 2005 · CONSECO. The Honorable James Brainard, Mayor City Of Carmel 1 Civic Square Carmel, Indiana 46032 Dear Mayor Brainard: On behalf of Conseco, Inc., a Fortune 500 company based in Carmel, I wanted to say how much we appreciate and support all your efforts to make the city a great place to work and live. To continue to grow and thrive as an enterprise, Conseco needs to attract top talent from all parts of the United States, and we must retain the top talent already here on campus, so .the quality of life in Carmel is very important to us. The proposed Carmel Performing Arts Center is only the latest example of the forward-looking spiri( with which you and other civic leaders are working to achieve your vision of Carmel as a unique, attractive and welcoming city. We believe the Performing Arts Center will become another jewel in Carmel's crown, and as the city's largest employer we are eager to do our part to help the community make the Center a reality. Sinc. e~rffly William S. Kirsch President and CEO JOHN M, KYLE JOHN D. PROFFITT JEFFREY S, NICKLOY DEBORAH L. FARMER WILLIAM E. WENDLING, JR, ANNE HENSLEY POINDEXTER ANDREW M. BA RIx~ER MICHAEL A. CASATI JOHN S, TERRY RODNEY T. SARKOVICS $COWF R WYAWF AMY E, HIGDON JOLIE B, HENRY STEPHENIE K. GOOKIN$ CAMPBELL KYLE PROFFITT LLP ATTORNEYS AT LAW April 13, 2005 FRANK S. CAMPBELLa (1880-1964) FRANK W. CAMPBELL (1916-1991) ROBERT g CAMPBELL (1946-2004) Jame~ Brainard Carmel City Mayor One Civic Square Carmel, 1N 46032 Dear Mayor: I just wanted to expressto you my support for your position regarding the Cam~el Arts Center and wish you well in this endeavor. Very truly yours, JDP/acs ! One Penn Mark 11595 North Meridian Street Suite 701 Carmel, Indiana :46032 (317) 846-6514 FAX (317) 843-8097 I I1 I I I I il I I I I I I I I I I I SHIEL SEXTON April 20, 2005 Mr. James Brainard Mayor of Carmel Carmel City Hall One C~wc Square Cannel, IN 46032 RE: Carmel City Center and Concert Hall Dear Mayor: Than:k. you for your service and progressive vision for the City of Carmel. While I do not live in Carmel, my children attend school in Carmel and we choose to Spend a significant amount of our leisure time shopp/ng and visiting friends in the city. Please allow me to share why the ~vork you are doing is so important to Indiana. I have had the opportanity, to learn more about the Redevelopment Commission's plan under your leadership. Your advocacy and vision for a distinctive, upscale city center is a perfect example of what Indiana needs to become competitive in our global economy. The Carmel City Center ~vill offer amenities that do not exist in central Indiana communities today: upscale high density residential, integrated hotel and convention facilities, disfi¢ctive landscape, retail, and, most important, a world class concert hall. The capstone featare of downtown will be the successful construction of the concert and recital hall. This facihty *vi!l attract performances on a global scale, w~ich will further refine our culVaral diversity and repumnon for the mrs. The obvious byproduct will be growth in the cenu'al ' Indiana region through residential and private investment. The political rhetoric in Indiana centers on staving offthe "brain drain." Tl~e success of the Carmel City Center is worthy of significant recogni.t, ion ~or tipping the scales in the right direction. Adults, young and old, will find good reas(/fi to remain in Indiana because Carmel is creating a distinctive urban enviromuent that will be attractive for many generations to come. Thafiks again for your hard work and I completely support y.our vision· Sincerely, Ben Wilhelm Vice Presideht SePRO Corporation · 11550 North Meridian Street · Suite'600 · Carmel, Indiana 46032-4565 Phone: (317) 580-8282 ° Fax: (317) 580-8280 April 19, 2005 Mayor James Brainard City of Carmel One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 Dear Jim, I read the recent article in the Indianapolis Star regarding merits of the proposed Carmel Performing Arts.Center and would like to provide my local business owner's perspective. SePRO Corporation opened its doors for business here in Carmel in 1994. As a small business it is important that we attract and retain high' quality and professional employees. We find that when potential employees compare Carmel to other communities throughout the nation that Carmel's amenities and reputation will typically tip the scale in our favor. Public safety, schools, parks, and cultural amenities are all important considerations when selecting the foundation for a family's roots. I appreciate the city's forward thinking vision and feel the Performing Arts Center would 'only serve to strengthen my business' position when recruiting. support the concept of the Carmel Performing Arts Center and wish you success in your endeavors to make it happen. Sincerely, ~~ulpepper President & CEO GINOVUS 8888 Keys'cone Crossin~ INDIANAPOLIS, IN April 21, 2005 The Honorable James Brainard Mayor City of Carmel One Civic Square Carmel, 1N 46032 Dear Mayor Brainard I am writing to share my strong support for the Carmel Performing Arts Center as a part of the City Center project. As an economic development professional, I have great appreciation for well-planned projects, like the Carmel Performing Arts Center, that enhance a community's quality of life. As a principal in a site selection advisory services firm, I have traveled around the country to visit communities and sites to help businesse~ make effective decisions regarding the location and expafision of facilities. Businesses are careful to select communities that will attract potential employees to relocate, as well as communities that already haye a pool of qualified workers living there.. Cultural. amenities play an important role in helping a community attract and retain well-educated, high compensated citizenry which is an important decision making criteria for companies. As an economic devblopment professional; I am also keenly aware of the economic stimulus creat6d by projects such as the Carmel Performing Arts Center. Since this facility will be the only dedicated concert hall in Central Indiana, the Carmel Performing Arts Center will attract visitors from a wide regional marketplace. Once in Carmel, visitors will also spend money on hotels, restaurants, retail shopping, and other activities. This will result in substantial economic impact for the surrounding community. I applaud your efforts and viSion to create a world-class cultural environment in Carmel. The additiofi of the Carmel Perforating Arts Center will certainly contribute to Carmel's quality of life advantages that allow the community to attract and retain significant businesses. My family looks forward to taking advantage of this wonderful regional asset. Thank you. Sincerely, Larry Gigerich Managing Director .April 19, 2005 The Honorable James Brainard Mayor's Office 1 Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 Dear Mayor Brainard: Thanks so much for taking time to visit with us'and to bring us update to date on your plans for the Carmel Performing Arts Center. We certainly ' believe that the quality o? life in a region is integral to economic development. To recruit and retain employees, we believe that it is necessary for our region to offer a wide variety of cultural activities. In addition to our existing businesses, corporations and their employees considering relocating to the greater Indianapolis area, and Cannel in particular, can be expected to be deeply interested in the quality of life offered by the region. To slow the "brain drain," each municipality must do whatever it can to enhan6e then quality of life in our region. Whether we promote sports development or greenways or arts and culture, each contributes to a worlfl class region. Please knowthat you have our support for the Carmel Performing Arts Center and wish you much success in securing the collaboration needed to make this project a reality. Sincerely,, Mary Weiss President, CEO & Publisher iMar 30 05 04:03p Barb Simpson 317-848-0911 PRE kNCE II, INC. March 30,2005 Dear Mayor Brainard: I continue to read the various articles in the Carmel Topic, sand the Indianapolis Star regarding the proposed Carmel Performing Arts Center. As a resident & business owner in Carmel t would like to express my opinion to you relevant to this matter. The Carmel Performing Arts Center would bring only positive opportunities to the City of cai'mol, I personally would attend more concerts and other theatrical performances if I had the convenience of driving to downtown Carmel. I also believe those living in the surrounding communities would Support the Performing Arts Center as welt. The location of the Carmel Center would offer a safe environment, convenient parking, excellent restaurants and the proximity to their homes' in itself would make the overall traveling to and from the performances a pleasant experience. All one has to do is look around, see the major changes that have taken place over the past several years in our City: the addition of the Carmel Performance Arts Center would only continue to demonstrate that Carmel is the best city to live in, because we have it all... You have my total support in this venture, Thanks for making our City what it is todayl Barb Simpson, President Prestige Performance II, Inc. 326 John St. , Carmel IN. 46032~1215, 317/848-2950, Fax 317/848-0911 ENGINEERS · DESIGNERS · CONSTRUCTORS 6450 Guion Road Indianapolis, IN 46268 (317.) 291-6130 FAX (317) 297-7618 www.thefreijecompany, com City of Carmel, Indiana Mayor James Brainard City Hall, Mayor's Office One Civic Square Carmel, Indiana 43032 March 10, 2005 Dear Mr. Brainard: The Freije Company was started in 1959. In I997, it was purchased by Tieman &' . Hoover, Inc., and we have been blessed with substantial growth since then. We do a substantial amount of negotiated, engineering design and build work, which requires us to hiJ:e professional engineers on a regular basis. In order to maintain a very high level of quality and professionalism, we go into the marketplace on a very regular basis to hire the best employees thot we can find and bring them to Indianapolis to work. As you are aware, The best available people are not always the easiest to convince to .move to the Indianapolis area. We read with great interest dae article in the Indianapolis Star regarding the development of the Carmel Performing Arts Center, and think that is the type of forward thin~dng project that we believe will assist us in attracting the very best to th/s area. I am sure you are aware that the best professionals are usually rather expensive people. It would be nice to have this marvelous facility as.another tool to use to help us obtain and retain the type of professionals we want to bring here. Please know in advance that The Freije Company would be proud to assist you in supporting this fine facility as you deem ndcessaryl We are certain that this type of facility would be used by several of our current employees, and also by future professionals hired f6r this area. Thank you again for your for~vard thinking. Bi g f i Ss JOURNAL ~jjj 41 East Washington St., Suite 200 I Indianapolis, Indiana 46204 I phone 317.634.6200 f fax 317.263.5060 I www.ibi.com March 15, 2005 Mayor Jim Brainard One Civic Square Carmel; IN 46032 Dear Mayor Brainard: As both a central Indiana businessman and Carmel resident, I am writing to express my support of proposed Carmel Performing Arts Center. I believe it is a valuable project with the potential to sig~xificantly enhance the quality of life and the economic future of Carmel and greater Indianapolis. It has b~come more and more obvious to business leaders and economic development prof6ssionals that the richness of the cultural environment in any area is extremely important in attracting new business and convin~mg existing businesses to grow. Thb kinds of professionals that we seek to attract and retain as citizens of central Indiana are people who appreciate culture m~d the arts. What's more, the people who already live here deserve such an environment. On another Ievel, culture and the arts hold promise for affecting change in people and making us all more "human'' as ottr .world becomes a colder and colder place. This is a dimension of ourselves that We must nurture and grow if w~e are to reach our full potential as people and as a community. It would seem that the proposed performing arts center--with its unique, state-of-the-art design- provides an excellent opportunity and would be a key element in pursuing this strategy. Such a one-of-a-kind facility would be a prize for any conwnunity. Sincerely~ President & P~Jot~sher 2 5th M~rch 14, 2005 Jim Brainard Mayor City of Oarm81 One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 Re: Carmel Performing Arts Center Dear Jim: I was excited to see the article in the newspaper about.the proposed Performing Arts Center and '1 am writing you to encourage you to proceed in bringing this to fruition. This type of facility/is truly unique in its focus and flexibility, and as such would help to add ~ dimension to the cultural life of the entire central Indiana community. : As part of the corporate fabric of the community, please know of our desire to see the cultural fabric strengthen and would be willing to support the center's activities and programming. Best wishes as you pursue this worthy project. Sincerely, K~ith J. DeTrude KJD:jas 3850 Rriority Way, South Ddve · Suite 218 · I~dianapolis, indiana 46240 · 317.573.3850 · Fax 317,573,3854 MIsO James ~. ~mslden! & ~EO MIDWEST INDEPENDENT TRANSMISSION SYSTEM OPERATOR, INC. · March 8, 2005 The Honorable James Brainard Mayor of Carmel, Indiana One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 Dear Mayor Brainard: I am w.riting to express the Midwest ISO's support for the proposed Carmel Performing Arts Center, and to pledge our tangible support, from either an organizational or individual level in the future. The Midwest iSO hired its first employee in ~.999. Today, we employ more than.500 p. eople, most of whom work at our headquarters in Carmel. Many of these professionals came from major cities in the Midwest, from other areas across the U.S., and from around the world. The quality of life in and around Carmel is a major factor that enables the Mid'vest ISO to attract and retain such a large number of talented people. To that end, the Carmel Performing Arts Center will help us continue to attract the professionals required to manage the Midwest's electric grid. M~ny of our high-caliber reliability and control personnel were recruited fron~ major utilities and come from large Midwest cities that have active performing arts communities. A number of our high-tech information systems operators come from the world market where they enjoyed a focus on the arts in their prior hometowns and educational institutions. A world-class Performing Arts Center would be a most desirable asset as future candidates consider relocating to Carmel. Maintaining and enhancing the area's quality of life is pivotal, not only for the Midwest ISO but for other area businesses, to our continued ability to attract and retain the necessary professional talent in our fields. I believe the Ca~:mel Performing Arts Center is a sound investment and will do a great deal to further enhance what is already a very desirable place to~ .live and work. Sincerely yours, P. Torgerson' · President and CEO ~,~ 701 City Center Drive ~Carrnel, Indiana 46032 ~317-249-5400 ~ www.midwestiso.org 'Qal $treet Chairman & CEO ~ March .10, 2005 Honorable Jame~ Brainard, Mayor City Of Carmel One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 Dear Mayor.Brainard: I am writing to voice our support for the proposed Carmel Perforating Arts Center. AsOak Street grows, it is important for us to be able to attract national clasi employees from different parts of the country. The continued development of the Carmel and Hamilton county areas will help us attract that talent. Mary Jo and I have lived in Carmel now for 11 years and have seen substantial change for the better. We applaud the continuing of these efforts Oak Street supports the Carmel Performing Arts Center and would consider financial support of{his venture if needed. Keep the momentum going. Very truly yours, Chairman & CEO Oak'Street Mortgage, LLC 11595 N. Meridian St. Suite 400 Carmel, IN 46032 317-805-3111 Fax: 317-805-2412 oakstreetmortgage.com H.M.S. Cutter, LLC Manufacturers' Representatives 9105 Spring Mill Road Indianapolis, IN 46260 Phone 317.846.9620 Cell 317.496.8373 Fax 317.846.4596 March 28, 2005 The Honorable Jim Brainard I am a theatre person and have been one all of my life. Prior to moving to Indianapolis I lived in Milwaukee and Cincinnati. My wife and I miss the quality theatre we had in those cities very much. i travel extensively and NOBODY references Indianapolis as a theatre Center. As a Manufacturers Representative I entertain customers on a regular basis. Here in the city of Indianapolis we have great sporting events but our theatre is extremely lacking. Did you know that USA Today recently mentioned that more people attend theatre than basketball and football events combined? The theatre experience is one that i prefer to utilize as a form of entertainment with customers. First it includes my spouse and my customers spouse and then it leaves an indelible image that is often'talked about for years. You have a wonderful opportunity here Mr. Brainard and believe you have the foresight and leadership to make that something wonderful happen. Let me list the obvious benefits to your community. 1. You will greatly help the dining establishments in your city. 2. You will differentiate yourself from the sports class of Indianapolis and elevate Camel Indiana as the cultural center of Indiana.' 3. You may draw long running Broadway and Off Broadway productions a~d the mega crowds that are seen in cities like Chicago~ Dallas, Kansas City and Toronto, but never found in Indianapolis, I will risk the integ~rity of this letter by assuming you may want to bury two negative images with a new performing arts center. 1. The image of Carmel as a bedroom community and 2. The image of Carmel as a ultra conservative bastion that does not want diversity. Very truly yours, Held II I FUN, & HD Honorable James Brainard, Mayor One Civic Square Carmel,.IN 46032 . March 23, 2005 Dear'Mayor Brainard, The proposed Carmel Performing Arts Center is the cornerstone of the next phase of developing Carme! into a world class communitY. As a Carmel resident of more than 12 years, our community is in dire need of an arts facility such as the one proposed. Further, a facili!y of this quality is necessary to anchor continued growth in Carmel, not in numbers but in culture and quality of life. Some of Carmel's best kept secrets are its performing arts presently in place but unable to flourish because' Carmel lacks the presentation' and performance facility. One example is the high school performing arts. That is a wodd class program and should be given the opportunity to expand and grow which will not happen until a larger and more accessible facility is available. Carmel has an orchestra. In 12 years I've seen them one time...at Deer Creek. A performing arts Cacility would enable Carmel to attract world class performances by a variety of artists. We would love to attend.concerts in winter but driving to the Circle is time-consuming. We attend'the Conner Prairie concerts during summer and the Carmel Gazebo concerts. Just look at the response those events get...imagine if that quality of entertainment was available 12 months a year in Carmel. The economic impact should also be considered. When we go downtown it's usually for a Christmas concert on a Sunday. Beyond the event, we'll get some shopping done downtown, have a nice dinner downtown and try to take in another event downtown. I'm certain the restaurant and shop owners would like a chance to compete for that business but until Carmel has a Performing Arts Center, it won't be possible. Beyond competing for business is competition for co~porate centers looking for places to relocate. The Performing Arts Cenler will be critical in securing new business to Carmel. In closing, it seems to me we better jump on this before our neighbors in Zionsville and Noblesville figure it out. I believe the area can only support one facility of the scope being proposed in Carmel. We'll draw people from Zionsville, N0blesville andcities north of Carmel, who would otherwise ddve past us to get to Indianapolis. Best of luck getting this done. Let me know if there is anything I can do to help. President 3710 Washington Blvd, · Indianapolis, IN 46205 · T: 317.923.3456 · F: 317.923.5361 .W: richmarc.com Classic 'Toys March 25, 2005 The Honorable Jim Brainard One Civic Square Carmel, In 46032 Dear Mayor Brainard: I am writing today in support of the City of Carmel's plan to build a Fine Arts Center. I represent Kits & Kaboodle Classic Toys. In that capacity, I would like to say this project would have a very positive impact on my business. I say this for many reasons. One, the availability of the opportunities to enjoy these events will make employees easier to recruit and retain. The addition of several events in Carmel will bring additional people to my new business located offof 146th Street. Lastly, the improved way of life to this area will make it a vibrant and exciting place to live and have a business. I will continue to support the Arts in this area especially the Carmel Community Players because of these reasons. I hope you will continue to provide the area with the best possible amenities such as the Fine Arts Center. Together we can make the commtm~ty a better place t9 live and work. Sincerely, Teneen Dobbs 6101 N. Keystone Avenue · Indianapolis, IN 46220 Office Phone: (317)255-6415 Store Phone: (317) 255-4763 · Fax: (317) 255-4768 Eldorado SoluUons, ThC N. Me, ,a. 6°° ~El. dorado Carmel, IN 46032 (8~) 531-10~ ~~ www. Eldorad~hem.~m . SENT VIA E-MAIL March 22, 2005 Thc Honorable Iim Bralnard One Civic Square carmel, EN 46032 Re: carmel Performing Arts Center Dear Mayor Brainard: This letter is being written to convey my support for youx attempt to develop a performing arts center in Carmel. As I am sure you can appreciate, the mom goods and services which Cannel can offer, thc mom attractive Carmel becomes to my employees (currcmt and prospective). Four years ago when I purchased Eldorado 'Chemical Company, a Texas-based firm, I moved it's headquarters to Carmel. Although we employ over 60 people, I was not able to entice any of my Texas employees to relocate to Carmel (or the surrounding areas). Although I don't think anyone chose not to move simply due to the lack of a performing arts center, the lack thereof was one more item that did not · "stack up" to that which my [former] employees were accustomed. To the extent that Carmel can increase the quality of life offerings for its citizens (including raising the standards of theater by virtue of a performing arts center), the easier (or less difficult) it will become to convince very qualified people tO relocate to our headquarters. [ hope that you are successful in obtaining thc necessary support from the City Council for this very worthy project. Respectfully, ' ELDoRADo CHEMICAL COMPANY, 1NC. Ted Schenberg President and CEO TRS/tbm PUBLISHINO * COMMUNICATIONS * MARKETING * BRANDIlqG * SALES ST~V~ G~.~'m~a P~sm~rr .' 877 BPdDLE COURT. CARMEL, 1N 46032-1289 Mayor Jim Brainard City of Cannel One Cannel Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 March 23, 2005 G6od morning, Mr..Mayor. I have been reading wth great interest the local media reports of discussion and action on the Carmel Performing. Arts Center. I do so, because I am an ardent supporter of your vision and plan, not only for the CPAC, but for all of Carmel. A Chance for a 1,600-seat concert hall? In Carmel? Are you kidding me? Up until recently, I never dreamed that would be a possibility for our community. I don't believe, one can put a pdce tag on the resulting cultural enrichment the CPAC would foster. Beyond that, l believe the opportunity to attract businesses and families to the city, by offedng yet another crown jewel, if you will, would increase significantly. ' When City Council President Ron Carter told the gathering at City Hall last week that "we make [his kind of investment bec.~use we want to make Cannel the best place to live, work, and raise a family anywhere in the state of Indiana and anywhere in the Midwest," that certainly resonated with me. I have had offers to relocate for both employment and business Opportunities. Even 'though they Were for higher income, my family and I opted to remain n Carmel,.becaQse after 10 years of tiring here we certainly consider it home - and we have no intention of leaving. Schools, pa~k~s, a "new" Old Town, ,the Arts & Design District the City Center project, the Monon Trail, road and street improvements, Centra park, new sewers and other infrastructure ... the llst goes on ... and without adversely affecting my taxesl Bravo[ What more could a citizen want? I'm simply a small businessman, really a sole proprietor, but even I see the ove~/helming value the CPAC would bring, Beyond that, we now have the opportunity to further solidify Carmel's "place on the map". It is.my reP/ertl hope the cPAC will become reality. .. My town needs the CPAC, and I believe my town wants th~ cPAc. i'm hopeful the City Council Shares my sentiments. Sincerely, Steve Greenberg m~, ~ ~aa n'7~;'7 Cell. 317.847.5022 ~m~: Crreenlak01(~sbcglobal.net Brainard, James C' From: JENNELWIL~aol.com Sent: Tuesday, March 22, 2005 12:29 PM To: Brainard, James C Subject: (no subject) Dear Mayor Brainard, As a re§ident of Carmel I want to applaud your efforts to develop our city into a'world class cultural arts destination. Ttm '~,itality and beauty of Carmel has warmed our hearts. As an Indianapolis b~siness owner, I recognize the importance for continuously striving to better our community and to raise and improve the standards by which we live, By providing opportunities for cultural enrichment we broaden.our own and our children's views of the world. We also, encourage cultural and individual diversity and hopefully make this a place for one to be proud to call home. Sincerely, Jennifer Nelson Williams President Aaron-Ruben-Nelsen Mortuary 1328 West 86th ST. Indianapolis, IN 46260 I Advisors March 22, 2005 The Honorable James Brainard Carmel City Mayor 1 Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 Re: Carme! Performin~ Arts Center Dear Mayor. Brainard: As you are aware, 40186 Advisors is a $27 billion investment advisory finn located in Carmel. We are highly dependent on attracting and retaining highly compensated professionals. Because of this, quality Of life issues are an important part of our human resources p~an as we compete for top talent with firms located all over the country. We appreciate your effort to create the proposed Carmel Pefforming Aris Center. This facility will be a positive recruiting tool for our company as we seek to grow our business, helping us attract and retain talent, and also providing an excellem venue for business entertainment; conferences, meetings, and ceremonial occasions. 40186 looks forward to working with you as a sponsor to help the community develop this facility. rely, Eric Johnson President 40186 Advisors, Inc. 535 N. College Drive Carmel, IN 46032 317.817.4086 OrchardSoftware 15 March 2005 Dear Jim, As Orchard Software has grown, our needs from the commumty have changed. Perhaps it is coincidence, bu~ the city projects being considered and undertaken today seem to be planned in parallel to our company needs, and this is exciting for us. Orchard was founded 12 years ago with three employees. Today we employ 82 and should grow beyond 1/00 before year-end. Roughly 70% of our employees already lived in this area, but we clearly attract employees from across the country. The progressive development here in Carmel has helped us overcome the otherwise uneventful image held by Indianapolis, making it easier to attract and retain employees. We average 27 "hotel weeks" per month in Carmel. Orchard provides week long classes to train lab managers on the use of our medical software. When our new Carmel City Center is complete, we hope it includes a hotel. Housing our guests in such an environment,' with shops and a Performing Arts Center, will make their experience here an exciting one. Because our guests a~e predominantly without cars, a pedestrian space is exactly what is desired. As a Company we hope to support these projects in two ways. One is housing our out of town guests at the City Center. The second is support of the Performing Arts Center, both through the purchase of event tickets and through financial contributionS. Thank you for the progress and development in Carmel that has happened under your. Stewardship, and for the plans you are' helping to make reality for Carmel's City Center. Best Regards, · Rob Bush, President Orchard Software Corporation 701 ~ongressional Boulevaxd, Suite 360 · Carmel, Indiana 46032 · (800) 856-1948 · fax (317)573-2633 KEYSTONE AT THE-CROSSING March .17, 2005 Mayor James Brainard City Hall carmel, 1N 46033 Re: Carmel Performing Arts Center Dear Mayor: ~ wanted to take the opportunity to express mT support.for the above facility. The Center is a natural compliment and enhancement to our community's interest in performing arts. From a business perspective, the Center, I believe, will be one of those subtle community facilities that help us to retain and attract good business. As a current member of the Carmel Library Foundation Board and past Carmel Clay School Board member, I can assure you that both young and adult members of our community will benefit from the Arts Center. [~est Wishes, i~Cke, CFP® Wealth Management and Exceptional Service March ! 4, 2005 Mayor ,lames Brainard One Civic Square Carmel iN 46032 RE: Proposed Performing Arts Center Dear Mayor Brainard: ,~ As an owner, in partnership with Zeller Realty Group, of over 500,000 sq ft of commercial office sp, ace on the Mer d an Corridor in Ca.-rnel, I am writing in strong support of Carmel's ·proposed Performing Arts Center. Sucl~ a space would not oniy provide an additional venue for the Indian~;polis Symphony Orchestra and' other-local groups; .but also for national and international performers as well. Addftienally,'when not in use for profession, a~ performances, it could be udtized for other community events. J feel that this Ce~,,er would be a wonderful asset for Carmel, Central Indiana) and the State of Indiana. Thank you for all your good work. Yours truly, Geoffrey G. Lor~ GG /sej .. BUCKINGHAM COMPANIE. S, AMO® March 10, 1005 Mayor James Brainard City. of Carmel One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 Dear Mayor Brainard: I wanted to write and express my congratulations and support on the progress'being made at City Center. As you know, our firm h.as significant investments in your city and thus the success and health of the City of Carmel at large. To that end, we are supportive and appreciative of your efforts, at City Center and the performing arts center specifically. We feel that the performing arts center would be an asset to the community for the long- term. Please rest ~Sured'that we would be willing to consider support for the performing arts center as appropriate. Sincerely, . BUCINGHAM COMPANIES, AMO President BBC/jle ~uzak 13 Vincennes Road lianapoJJs, IN 46268 7 471.7050 Tel 7 471 ·7060 Fax ~0 820.2294 APril 21, 2005 Mayor Jim Brainard One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 Dear Mr. Mayor', I'm writing in support of the proposed Carmel Performing Arts Center'. · As a business person, I sell the benefits Of an Arts-enriched life everyday--I work for Muzak! I preach the experience that music creates to business owners in our commurdty, and all around the Midwest. Even ~vhile majoring in music education at IU, I knew how important music can be to one's hfe, regardless of age or economic oppomm/ty. I also feel strongly that our facil/~y should be accessible to many arts groups, large/small, musical/theatrical. Nbw as a parent of 4 small children, I relish the opportunity to expose them to various facets of the arts. I believe it's in our communities' best interest to keep that exposure right here in Carmel, I think the bond Our.children w/ll make with the community will be indel!ble. I still remember my first symphony concert~--and it changed my life! Having reviewed the proposed facility (Brans doc), I also think that it's "righ~ on" for what we need. And I must selfishly say, as a member of the Carmel Symphony Orchestra (the "other" CSO) I can't WAIT to play our first concert theret Much as Indianapolis needs Cam~el to have 146th street to relieve traffic flow on the north side, carmel needs the Performing Arts Center to relievethe void in accessible arts in our community. The PAC needs to be here, now. I can't offer you facts and figures on the financial impact, but I can tell you as a musiciar~ bUSiness person, taxpayer, parent, that the quality of life improvement alone will pay dividends long after we're both gone. Please getth6 PAC. deal sealed! I'll come help dig ifI have to. RespectfuLly'submitted, Matt Greven Carmel, IN April 21, 2005 The Honorable James Brainard Mayor · CITY OF CARMEL One Civic Square Carmel, Indiana 46032 Dear Mayor Brainard: As you know, both Pedcor and its already more than 80 employees located or soon to · be located in Carmel ale sirongly in favor of the City's pursuit of the Carmel Performing Arts Center. Having such a center in Carmel coupled with the other developments being pursued by Carmel i~ both its City Center as well as in the Arts District will be a substantial Economic Development benefit. No edge city will have what Carmel will have and that will give us an opportunity to attract the best businesses which will have the highest paying jobs. · Please also accept this letter as our commitment to financially support the Performing Arts Center particularly with its opgrating costs. Good luck with this. great project. Very truly yours, PEDCOR INVESTMENTS, A LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY BrUce A. Cordingley President IBOSE McK & EVANS LLP ATTORNEYS AT LAW Kendall C. Crook · 2700 First indiana Plaza 35 North Pennsylvania Street Indianapolis, IN 46204 Direct Dial: (317) 684-5134 Fax: (317) 223-0134 E-Ma]: KCrook@boselaw.com April 20, 2005 The Honorable James Brainard Mayor City of carmel One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032' RE: Carmel Perforfi~ing Arts Center Dear Mayor Brainai:d: We at Bose McKinney & Evans LLP have been following the recent news stories concerning the proposed Carmel Performing Arts Center With great interest. On behalf of attorneys aqd staff of the law firm, I would like to applaud your vision for the future of carmel. The Performing Arts Center will be a wonderful addition to the cultural opportunities available in Central Indiana. Bose McKinney & Evans looks forward to supporting this cultural initiative and contributing to the growth of the entire community. We wish you the best of luck in making this dream a reality. KCC:jlw 614652_i David J. Tudor President & Chief Executive Officer ,.. ACES POWER '~,,,~'M A R K E T I N G April 26, 2005 The Honorable.James Brainard Mayor ~ity of Carmel One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 Dear Mayor Brainard, On behalf of ACES Power Marketing (APM), I am writing to show our support for the Carmel Performing Arts Center project. ' As you know, APM moved into its new headquarters facility in Carmel in February, 2005, after conducting a national search for a new location. Our business requires the ability to h/re and maintain highly sldlled professionals, whose decisions are highly influenced by "quality of life". At APM, our employees recogrfize the importance of work and life balance, and cultural ame~fifies will certainly enhance the quality of life in the Carmel area. The carmel Performing Arts Cent'er will increase opportunities available for Central Indiana citizens to be exposed to a wider variety of cultural experiences. Citizens will be able to attend world-class perfom~ances and enjoy enhanced opportunities to dLrectly participate in activities in the arts. I know om: employees will.appreciate and take advantage of these new opportunities. Based upon the success to date of the City Center, Clay Terrace, and other projects, we are very excited about the future of Carmel. Once completed, the carmel Performing Arts Center will truly be a world class performance venue to be enjoyed by generations to come. Sincerely, President and CEO ~O LIFe.., SUPPQRT TO THE E×PLOR~:R,.. A BASE April 26, 20O5 Mayor James Brainard City of Carmel One Civic Square Carmel, Indiana 46032 Dear Mayor Brainard, I wish to express my full support: and enthusiasm for the proposed Concert Hall project to be included in the Carmel Performing Arts Center. I believe this venue would attract ail of the performances that currently by-pass Indiana that require a higher quality of acoustics than exists at all Indiana venues. Fulfilling this need would not only insure success but be a great addition to the community by bringing the arts to the suburbs and close to those that would patronize the facility. EATON. INVESTMENTS LTD.. INC. one Meddia~ Pad~ Place 12220 N. Meddian Street, Suite 165, Carmel, IN 46032 Phone 317.575.7991 Fax 317.575.7989 www. Eato nlnvestme nts.com April 29, 2005 Mayor James Brained City of Carmel One Civic Square Carmel, ~ 46032 Mayor Brainard, Thank you for taking the time to share with us the planning information for the Carmel Performing Arts Center. The Performing Arts Center will certainly be a tremendous addition to the ongoing City Center Project. As an organization that is based in Carmel and develops many residential communities within Carmel, we are excited for the positive economic impact that the Performing Arts Center will bring to the City of Carmel. Further we feel the Performing Arts Center will increase the residential value for 6ur homeowners by further distinguishing Carmel as.the. premier sub-market wittfin the Indianapolis Area. Again, Thank you for providifig us with insight into this project and we look forward to remaining involved in the progress of the C,armel Performing Arts and City Center. Respectfully, Greg Huff Division President, Pulte Homes of Indiana PEOPLE. TRUST. EXPERIENCE?' LAUTH Robert L. Lauth Chairman & CEO March 8, 2005 · The Honorable Jim Brainard Mayor, City of Cannel One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 RE: Performing Arts Center Dear Ma2Jor Brainard, I wanted tO take a moment to express my strong support for your efforts to build the Carmel Performing Arts Center. I know I am joined by many other local business leaders when I say that it will undoubtedly play a major role in attracting future businesses to our city while enhanc!ng the lives of all who call Carmel "home." I am hopeful that you will be successful in your endeavors, and it would be our intention to support the project financially, should that be necessary. I wish you all the best of luck !n the pursuit of your goal. Sincerely, 401 pENNSYLVANIA PARKWAY · INDIANAPOLIR, INDIANA ' 46280 ' (317) 848 6500 DEVELOPMENq' ' CON STRUCq~2ON rLI AC2VAN'T'AG E M E II C AI- Ma~2,2005 Mayor James Brainard One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 Dear Jim, Shad and I are in full support of the planned performing arts center for Carmel. I have taken the time to understand the financial projections and planning that have gone into the pro forma and believe them to be sound. It is clear to me that a facility with a unique market niche will enhance our lifestyle while at the same time improving the local business climate. I would be happy to do anything we can to make sure that our community does not miss the opportunity to create a jewel that future generations will enjoy. Please be assured that Shad and I will proudly support this project. Carmel must continue to look for ways to remain competitive and provide a superior lifestyle for its residents. I believe this is the good way to ac..complish that goal. Sincerely, Jeff Worrell Owner 12415 Old Meridian Carmel, IN 46032 800-577-5694 fax: 800-390-0162 www.advantagemedical.com Centra£ Incliana ®ance q nsemS£e Suzann ~)e£ay Artistic CDirector Michael Casey Clark Assistant Director · BacwardMoffat Guest Artist ~oard q£ ©irectors Jq:f Sanfffy President Tami Tfiter Vice President Only O'Ma~a · Secretary edta sink Treasurer Members at Large Tom oluck Kathy Cl~risti* Patte Cole Lisa Grieden (Debbie Lipscomb Pam ~etzlaff 20ply Smith Connie Btak Karen Wheeler Past Presidents Juc~ ~eck June {Ellen qviel fidviso~ ~oard Hancy Herman Terra Kovner P, gn Morgan April28,2005 Honorable Mayor James Brainard Carmel City Hall One Civic Square Cannel, Eq 46032 Honorable Mayor Brainard, Central Indiana Dance Ensemble, Inc. Would like to express their support for the undertaking of the Performing Arts Center of Carmel. As a pre- professional dance company based out of Carmel, we would like to have a venue for the company to call home. In order for CEDE to continue to provide quality full-length ballet production~ for Central Indiana, we require a venue that will allow the company ~o produce quality dance performances. We have utihzed the Carmel Performing Arts Center, Westfield High School Auditorium and Mil perform the 2005 Nutcracker at the Zignsville Performing Arts Center.. We foresee having a Performing Arts venue in Carmel would grow the arts across the north side and bring the much deserved notoriety to Carmel. As members of Regional Dance America, our company was selected to host the 2008 RDA Mid-States Festival. Tiffs will bring over 600 individuals to the area to attend classes and perform. A venue like the one intended would be an excellent showcase for the three performances that take place at the festival. Unfortunately, the Performin Arts Center will not be completed by the time of our festival in 2008. Sincerely, Jeff Sankey Board of Directors, President cc.-/CO 1142 Linden Lane, Carme~ IH46033 Web: wwav. CIDZ~ance. org Phone: 017) 844-7453 Bmai£ CI~E~ance@yahoo. com P-,.YLAND HOMES® 9025 North River Road Suite 190 Indianapolis, Indiana 46240 317-846-4200 Tel 317-846-4224 Fax rytand.com May 2, 2005 Hayor .lim Brainard Carmel City Hall One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 Dear Mayor Brainard: ! just wanted to let you know that Ryland Homes ~s in support of the Carmel Performing Arts Center. If there is anything we can do to add to the success of this project, please do not hesitate to contact me.: Regards, Alan .1. Goldsticker Division President March 28, 2005 Mayor Jim Brainard' One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 Dear Mayor Brainard, I would like to write in support of the Performing Arts Center, soon to be voted on. I am in favor of the city of Cannel growing in the area of the arts. We have a great need in our ~onnnunity to promote the arts if our city is going to attract culture and status, I was in support of the Monon and was one of the first families in Hamilton County to sell my property to the city. Today the Monon is enjoyed by mahy families and promotes wellness within our cOmmunity. We have the need to create a balance in this community. I feel we are top heavy in the area of sports and not all children and families can participate. My son, being disabled, cannot express himself in sports and enjoys the arts. I would like to see our city be placed on the map as a well rounded community that Serves the need of all people. Thank you, Vickie Cornelius 1112 Sed0na Pass Indianapolis, IN 46280 846-4493 · leck, Nancy/S -'rom: ~ent: roi ~ubject: · Beth A. Renselle [barensel@earthlink.net] Saturday, April 02; 2005 8:23 AM Jbraihard@ci.carmel.in.us. Nheck@ci.carmel.in.us. Performing Arts Canter ~ayor Brainard, was watching the Carmel TV channel the other day and saw your ~onderful presentation on the proposed Performing Arts Center for ~armel. I want to tell you I am so delighted to see Carmel leap forwkrd ~ith such a wonderful project. I.am a lover of the arts, especially live ~erformances. [ am certain that such a facility will attract and keep the type of 5mployer that Carmel and Hamilton County desires in its community. It ~ilt also provide many new jobs for Carmel in the way of restaurants, ~iners and shopping in general. What a grand way to attract and introduce Carmel to many people outside the community. [ intend to support the Performing Arts Center by purchasing tickets for nyself, my family and as gifts for my friends. Please count me in for a ~onation for such items that you might heed such as trees, park benches, bricks etc. I want to also offer my services as a volunteer to work on this project, if there is anything that I can do to help you, please feel free to contact me. Carmel has been my residence for 30 years. I am now retired from the corporate world and am so grateful for ail that you and your staff have accomplished for Carmel. Keep up the good work and keep Carmel at the fore front as the most desirable place to live in Indiana. Wishing you success beyond imagination-- Kindest regards, Beth A. Renselle 14474 Allison Drive Carmel, Indiana 46033 317-846-8448 "barensel~earthlink.net" P.S. Love those round-a-bouts March 23, 2005 Mayor James Brainard One Civic Square Carmel IN 46032 Dear Mayor Brainard: According to today's newspaper, the proposed plan for developing a Performing Arts Center in carmel has passed the.Redevel0pment Committee and is scheduled for consideration by the City Council. Please accept my urgent endorsement for this project. As one who seriously appreciates classical and other good music, as well as live theater, I feel this center is essential for the continued development of Carmel as a quality and livable community. Inaddition it is important to us since we are acvancing in the retirement phase of our lives and intend bsfore long to look for senior level housing accommodations. We would definitely prefer they be in Carmel and conveniently located when we no longer can drive our car. It is hoped that the Council will keep people like us clearly in mind when they consider this matter and vote )ositively for the development of this Center.' Sincerely, C.A.Boswell Mayor Jim Brainard 1 Civic'Square Carmeli IN 46032 As a former Carmel resident and very interested member ( the arts community, there and elsewhere, ! want to commend you for wanting to further the necessarY growth arts and culture for your community. Arts are such an essential part of the education of all persons, which gives us our own unique form of humanity Therefore, ]~ do hope you will want to include in your expansion of civic improvements an arts center, which wiil include theater. Theater brings families together for a common goal of using their creativity, imagination and ingenuity, which is essential to the growth of the human spirit. Good luck with ail your endeavors in making Carmel a mot wonderful place to live, Very sincerely Phyllis Harvey Past Member of 5 Theater Boards, Carmel & Tndianap April 20, 2005 Jim Breinard Mayor City Carmel Carmel City Hall One Civic Square Carmel, In 46032 Subject: Carmel Performing Arts Center Dear Mayor Breinard: My wife and I have great interest in seeing Carmel develop a world class performing arts facility. We are residents Of Pike Township in Marion County and we frequently attend the varied offerings et the Pike Performing Arts Center. As you know, the PPAC and ~he Warren Performing Arts Center are ancillary to high schools and are therefore dissimilar from what is being proposed. In.fact, the facility you are proposing will complement the PPAC by increasing the limited number of venue dates, available in centre/Indiana. Although the PPAC is a relatively new facility, similar in size to the one contemplated for Carmel; it has a number of shortcomings that your facility can overcome. Fii"st, the PPAC balcony is not ADA accessible and lacks public rest rooms. Many concert and theater goers enjoy the visual perspective and lower pricing of balcony seating and s~ould not~ be inconvenienced by budgetary concerns. Second, the PPAC was never built as a concert hail and it leaves a bit to be desired acoustically and aesthetically. I understand the acoustics will be one of the hallmarks of Carmel's new facility. For those of us fortunate enough to have heard a performance in a great hall, it is a distif~ctively unique and pleasing experience. A concert hall with second class acoustics is like watching every basketball game from the balcony of Assembly Hall. Finally, we believe the stature of a community is complemented by its facilities. Carmel is fortunate to have best in class public and prtvate facilities in many respects. It is appropriate and long-overdue that Oarmel's high stature in so many categories would be made complete by providing a cultural facility fei" fha performing arts befitting the community's image. This investment will pay dividends for generations, I fondly.remember hearing violin virtuoso Joshua Bell years ago at Eadham College. Imagine the impression such a visitor would have on your community! But you will not be able to attract such talent until this facility is built. Best wishes to you and your councii as you embark upon-this exciting project! Sincerely, / ~. R~p!ss Rellar ' L.-FO~ Moore Road Indianapolis, IN 46278 [~ttu~D At,ti ~R~ ~sn 0~ pug ~oddn~ o~ pno:td oq ptno,,-: *,~ ~[~zu~o ~o ~u=p!s~x ~¥ :p~u.ma~t ~0,(~Ial za=(] ~a~nbs ~}O ~uo ~00[ '0£ q~ E~09£ Nv[ 'IOU,U~D p~o'E u~paof O180I sd!II!r[cI 'V lPUOA~ · 7820 PinevieW Ct. · Indianapolis, IN 46250 · wtbecker~mae.com March 29, ~2005 Mayor Jim Brainard One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 Dear Mayor Brainard, I am writing this letter to express my support of a Fine Arts Center in the city of Cannel. I am a retired Police Chief and have been in the Indianapolis area for a little over four years. After spending the majority of my life in San Die~o, California, I moved to the mid-west to accept the Police Chief's job in Champaign, Illinois. After a couple of years I decided that I wanted to retire. Missing the big city and all it has to offer, my wife and I started looking for another place to live. We found Indianapolis, liked what it had to offer and moved Ii,re in 2001. Many of the things we look for in a community are pretty obvious. We are interested in public safety cost of living, quality of life factors, shopping, etc. However, one deciding factor that is very important Jo us is the availability of art and eultu~ e. This shows us the diversity and maturity cfa community, and without it we wouldn't have settled here. I know you have all the economic background you need to show the impact a cultural center can make on a community. I ant not a statistician or pollster. I am a common citi~un looking for a well-rounded life experience for my wife and myself. The abundance of museums, galleries, community theaters and other creative outlets has made our decision to move here worthwhile. I firmly believe that thq impact of art and culture on a community and its residents is immeasurable. Providing a healthy, learning environment enriches everyone. Starting our children out in life with the ability to experience a broad band of culture is, hi my mind, one of the grdatest gffis We can give them. I urge you to pursue and support the proposed Fine Arts Ceater in your city. If I can be of any assistance in this cause, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, Jay R. Brill 358 Mallard COurt carmel, IN 46032 March 23, 2005 Mayo~ Jim Brainard Carmel City Hall · One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 .. Dear Mayor Ji:m'Brainard: ' As a ihirty-year resident of Carmel and citizen active in the community, I would like to applaud your efforts toward the very much-needed Community Arts Center. Our city is well known as one being on the Cutting edge of excellence with frae schools, wonderful parks, beautiful and thriying downtown area, several arts organizations, and much more. The proposed Performing Arts Center would draw even more culture to our city and enrich our residents and future residents even more. As a past president of the Carmel Symphony Orchestra Board and patron of the arts, I know our fine orchestra has been a gYPSY group for it's entire thirty years of existence, playing and rehearsing in different, and not always quality Venues their entire existence. To have a permanent home will only enhance what they, and all the other'performing arts groups in the area, have to offer the commurdty. An anonymous poem captures my thoughts on what the new center will offer Carmel citizens.. For the common things of every day, God gave man speech in the common w-ay. For the deeper things men think and 'feel, God gave the poets words to reveal. But for heights and depths no words can reach, God game man music, the souls own speech. Respectfully, Mayor: Th.is facility is very important to our great city in attracting business to our city and retaining qualified employees in this area. Wewili§u@port thePAC financiatly in the future Bestwishes AIPea~lman P.S. For an informative newsletter, click http:llwww.homeownemews.comlciAtPearlman Al Pearlman,'. Realtor F.C. Tucker Co., Inc. "Buying or se.lling your h0me is a milestone... Trust the professional who puts your needs first." http://www, alpearlman.com mailto'.pearlman@alpearlman.com 317-846-7751 VM 1-888-612~1983 Dear councilman Sharp, Before you pass through the doorway into the Council chambers on Monday, May 2"d, I ask that you take a moment to reflect upon the many great things that our City has achieved Qver the past several years. You should be inspired by a landscape of commerce that has become the envy of many, a school system that is renowned for scholarly achievement, a public library that is impressive by .any standard, a public parks System that has evolved into a haven of green space arid tranqui~.ity and a dynamic City infrastructure that continues to transform itsel~ into a so[id foundation for tomorrow's growth. Despite this impressive list of meaningful accomplishments, the source of what will become your greatest inspiration remains poised Ori.the COuncil Agenda, ready to evolve from vision tb reality. Imagine a sunny'spring day in May, 2011. You are strolling acrOss, the plaza Outside carmel's City Center'hotel. You happen to overhear a conversation between two individuals, each commenting on the architeci.ure of City Center, marveling over the i~yout of the structu.res, embracing how.the · atmosphere lends itself to people actUally interacting with people. As you gaze across this rea!ity that was or'ce a vision, you appreciate the painstaking efforts of the planning process that were directly respohsible for the project's ultimate suCceSs. Perhaps even more importantly, you realize ~at you were an integral part of the creation of this' model of new urbanism, including its successful engine for growth, the Carmel Performing Arts Center. The Carmel' perfOrming Arts Center (PAC) is the key to a successful City Center project. I'm basing my comment on fact as I know ii., not on.the rhetorical banter of the ill-informed that manytimes prevails in political and/or controve¢sial issues. I've spent many hours immersing myself in TIF legislation, formulation and project specific projections, t~ve reviewed the basis upon which the selection of a Concert Hall structure was chosen as the best use of space within the City Center boundary: I've reviewed the significance that the Arts play in economic development. I understand the importance of investing in a unique attraction to stimulate an increase in pedestrian traffic. I also realize the imperative nature of creatir~g a quality of life that satisfies the needs of corporate leaders and managers - - a critical requirement in maintaining and adding knowledge-based economy companies' to:our community. Let's first consider our return On this $80 million investment. The PAC will provide the quality of attraction that will draw visitors from not only local jurisdictions, but from areas throughout the State Of Indiana and the Midwest as well. If it were not for the exquisite quality of the venue, its draw!ng power would become impeded, negating its very purpose of being. Visitors to the PAC will stroll through our shops, eat al our restaurants and stay.at our hotels. Because their experiences are noteworthy, they will share with neighbors and business colleagues"their desire to return. Visitors new and old begin to find themselves returning to the City Center, expanding their visits to include the Carmel Arts Disti-ict, walking throughout the community~ purchasing and ¢:onsuming along the way. With each step, they Will g~nerate revenues for both merchant and government alike. BY merely extrapolating.this behavioral pattem, it begins to become very apparent that the ultimate economic impact to the community goes far beyond the PAC's bottom-line. While on the topic of bottom-line, some are concerned that the pAC will eXPei'ience an operating revenue shortfati. First,.we should remind ourselves that the PAC is a not-for-profit center. As is the case in most other not-for-p~'0fi'~ performing arts qenters, annual operating expenses'are greater than Operating revenues. The deficit shortfall is remedied through a variety of sources, including individual, corporate, and foundation gifts and grants, memberships, sponsorships, and when poss.ib!e, investment income from endowment funds. It is absurd to suggest that if our PAC exPei'iences an operating Shortfall, it is the consequence of gross idefficiency or over zealous projections. It is equally absurd to suggest that .our Carmel community cannot offset the operating shortfall through the above- .mentioned methods (even without an endowment fund). Most importantly, evaluation of true PAC operating performance should include consideration of the "ripple effect" impact that PAC.will have on job creation and revenues for businesses across Carmel, not to mention increased property values. Some believe that mone~, invested in the arts is money that could have been reallocated to some other economic development initiative. To reflect on that thought, let's Io0k ho further than the Apdl 26, 2005 press release by the Indianapolis Cultural commission and the Arts Council of Indianapolis. Acoo~ding to Keira Amstutz, director of cultural affairs for the City of Indianapolis, "C~Jltural-venue investments totaling more than'S362 millior~ come to fruition in Indianapolis this year." To promote this achievement; Indianapolis, despite its own financial woes, is launching a $2.8 million marketing · campaign. The release goes on to say, "In the weeks ahead, people from ChicagO to Cincinnati and from Fort Wayne to Champaign, Illinois, will begin to see and hear about Indianapolis' cqltural scene andthe new developments underway in the circle City.'; This action by the City of Indi. anapolis is one example that demonstrate~ the belief that investing in the arts yields significant economic benefits. On recognizing the.significance of quality of Iife in our community, let's review'the follOwing scenario. As the U.S. economy made its way through the most recant cyclical downturn, many old-school manufacturing jobs were lost. In Indiana alone, over 104,000 (net) manufacturing jobs have been lost since D~(Jember 1999. Many of those jobs will never return in their odginal form, neither will the companies. As a result communities across America are attempting to rertool (or retrain) their respective W°rkforces and .identify creative ways to attract new com'p~hies, ail in an attempt tO stimulate local economies. The endresult, ~/e as a community are now competing for our econom!c lives. Our existing quality of life has sustained, our past.successes. But, v~e are now cpnfronting unparalleled competi{ion. Communities that possess geographic leverage in the form of oceans, mountains and dyers are attempting to pursue many of the ~ame COmpanies as Carmel and other geographies in Indiana. We have no choice'but to re-invest in quality attractipns like PAC. We must continually stdve to imp[ove ourselves, our community and our competitive edge. The moment that we stop re-investing will be the moment our fate is sealed. The City of Carmel is at a crossroads. We are POised to continue our journey on the road to greatness. At the same time, ou~ city could easity take the path ofmedioCdty. You are in a position to chart our ultimate course. As you and your fellow Councilmen deliberate this monumental issue over the next two weeks, I hope that perhaps you'll find yet another moment to pause and reflect upon the many great things that our City has achieved over the past several years. W~th this reflection, however, I would ask you to envision the legacy that you wish tO create. Ponder the difference between mediocrity and greatness. Shakespeare wrote, "Be not afraid of greatness." Joseph HeIler wrote, "Some men are bom mediocre, some men achieve mediocrity and some men have mediocrity thrust upon them." In closing, I ask you to embrace the greatness we have yet to achieve as a city. Recognize that greatness by appro¥ing the PAC. Create a egacy that symbolizes. your commitment and ddve to ensure that the future of our community is truly ,qreat. Thank you for your careful thought and consideration regarding this important matter. Re'spectfully, 433 Autumn Ddve (Townhomes at City Center) Cc: Brian Mayo Joe Griffiths Fred Glaser Mark Ratterman Kevin Kirby · Ron Carter April 27, 2005 Mayor James Bminard Carmel City Hall One Civic Square Carmel, 1N '46032 Dear Mayor Brainard: As residents and taXpayers of Carmel for over 37 years we would like to go on record in support of the proposedpeffOrming-Arts Center ir/Carmel. Carmel has ·always been a first class city in all phases ot operation and construction and The Performing Arts Center should also be a first class facility. We believe that the Carmel Performing Arts center would attract people from all over the Midwest whe would want to attend the many events in this state-of-the-art facility in Carmel. We, along with the entire Carmel community, are looking forward to the Carmel Symphony Orchestra finally after 30 years have a permanent home and a facility tha~ would maximize their extraordinary talent. We know that Carmel businesses would benefit greatly from the many performances held at the Performing Arts Center. Restaurants, hotels mad shopping areas would see increased business from residents 6f surrounding communities and out of town visitors who would want to see performances in a one of a kind fac!lity. Any effort to cut comers and downgrade the design of the Performing Arts Center should be resisted by all. This Center should be "a first class· facility for a first class city"! Let's build a state-of-the-art .facility 'now .that will reflect the quality of the .Carmel community, and finance it so that people moving into Carmel over the next twenty years can participate in its cost and share in its pride. Best Reg~ f /[a~~dllaBadger ' 846.1579 CC: Mr. Fred Glaser - 5th District Councilman Mr. Ron Carter- Councilman-m-Large Mr. Mark Rattermann - Councilman-at Large April ~6r ZOO5 I am i~riting in support Of the Carmel ~erf0rming Arts Center. Having lived in the area for over 36 years, I have witnessed many new and exciting changes and additions to our community. When i! learned of the possibility of a Performing Arts Center', I was thrilled. The growth of Carmel and the many improvements which have already taken~place have contrlbutBd to a quality.. of life, The proposed Performing Arts Center with its. design and technicl featu~es~would most certainly attract a variety of musical~ theatrical, and dance organizations. I feel that with the proper marketing skills~.for promoting a stateLof-the-art facility, this would prove to be a successful Cultural venture. We must preserve the Arts! Very truly yours, Mrs. Phillip Cole Mayor James Brainard City of Carmel On.e Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032. Dear Mayor Brainard: I write this letter io support Carmel's plan to buiid a Carmel Performing Arts Center. As a member of the Carmel Symphony Orchestra, I know the value of a performance cente~: from a pe/former's perspective. O0e of the most Personally rewarding experiences I have had as a member of the Carmel Symphony fs through our efforts to reach out to young children and expose them to the joy of music. Each February carmel High School is packed with grade-school children who come to hear us perf0~n - enough that we now have two performances. To see the young faces eager to hear our music i~ refreshing,and the cultural and educational benefits of having a permanent performing arts center will ensure that children continue to be exposed to a variety of fine art performances, f The 1,600-seat concert hall will be an ideal venue for large musical ensembles that i'equire natural ac0usti(isl such as symphony orchestras, band and choirs..It would also be able to'be used by a wide rankle of other artists including solo a~sts, hands, Counb'y & Western~ jazz, world musrc and mal~y others. The smaller 500-seat Multi-Purpose ROom/Flexible Theater space would be ideal l'or smaller theatrical, musical and dance organizations, Both the 1600- and 500-seat spaces also could be used t~or conferences, meetings, classes, school programs and social, ceremonial and civic occasions. The benefil~ to the community are endless. Indiar!ap01is while it has made great strides in developing major sports facilities, attracting top sp~rts franchises, and building it~ educational and.cultural infras~ucture still lags among metropolitan areas of i!s size in. having performing ads facilities that are acknowledged beyond [hdianapoli~ for being of the highest quality. It is this gap that the Carmel Performing Arts Center will fill - by creafJng not on!y a Superb arts and e,n. tertainment venue serving audier!ces throughout the region but.also a beaqon that signals to the entire world Central Indiana's dedication to e~c~lience. ' The Carme) Symphony Orchestra has never had a permanent performance venue; we have asked our patrons often to travel to Wesffield a~d Fishers to attend our concerts, they have been extraordinar ly suppo~ve and followed us, AS many of our playei's, like my.se]f, are volunteer players who reside in Indianapolis and surrounding communities, We sacrifice work and family time to travel wherever rehearsal spa~.e is available. This dedic~on is due to the commitment we have to the Carmel community to provide a quality symphony orchestra, The Performing Arts Centor ~,,ill certainly benefit the Carmel Symphony, but it will benefit the entire community'as well - and ' particularly youth. Please sbpport [he Carmel Performing Arts Center! Maryann P. Snyder 11585 Shelborne Road Carmel, Indiana 46032 (317) 733-8340 .Fax (317) 733~8336 E-maih mpsnyder(~_ ~indy.rr.com April 26, 2005 The Honorable James Brainard Mayor, City of Carmel One Civic Square Carmel, 1N 46032 Dear Mayor Brainard: I write to express my strong Support for the proposed performing arts center in Carmel. As a mother of a young growing family'and a patron of the arts, I know a state'of-the-art concert hall will provide and attract the high-level cultural entertainment we want and deserve in Carmel. Certainly, the demographics of 0ur area xvould support this type of programming. It w6uld also be so nice for the ~armel Symphony Orchestra to have a permanent home so they can offer even more educational and cultural opportunities for area families and youth. In my opinion, they are the "great undiscovered jewel" of Carmel culture. With a permanent home and offices "right in our own backyard" many more families would have the opportunity to attend concerts .and benefit from the expanded educational programming of this self-described "family~frier~dly" orchestra. (As a.little gift growing up in Carmel in the ~970s, I have many fond memories of listening to the Carmel sYmphony play in various church basements around Cannel.) In short, the proposed Carmel Performing Arts Center is good for Carmel families and good for the community at large. Many thanks to you and your administration for your vision and hard work in bringing the arts. closer to home and in helping to Shape a more- defined imag~ of Carmel. The performing arts center isan imp6rtant piece in the quality of life puzzle Carmel aspires to complete. Sincerely, City of Carmel, 'Indiana Maygr fames Brainard City Hall, ·Mayor's Office One Civic ,Square Carmel, Indiana 43 032' April 29, 2005 Dear Mr. B~ainard: ! have been a resident of Noblesville for over 13 years. During that time, I have made many lX"ipS tO The Carmel area for 'dinner and entertainment purposes. The Carmel Symphony is one of the least known, but highest quality sources of entertainment available.m residents of th/s area. Almost always, a trip tothe symphony is preceded by a dirmer outing. I read with great interest the article in *_he Indianapolis Star regarding the development of the Carmel Performing Arts Center, and think that is the type of forward rhinldng project that I believe will assist us ~ attracting the Very best tO this area. k would sure be ~/onderful to be able to attend such a high quality facility without having to drive to the center of Indianapolis and fight that traffic. Thank you again for your forward thinking. I hope you are able to get the City Council to approve tkis wonderful facility, and really get Carmel on the Arts map. Very truly yours. Donald H. Cleveland 141 Stony Creek Overlook Noblesville, IN 46060 Brainard, James C From: Sent: To: Subject~ Mark O. Bradley [mbradley@iupui.edu] Saturday, April 30, 2005 7:53 PM Brainard, James C Performing Ads center Dear Mayor Bra±nard, I am writing you to give my views on the proposed Performing Arts Center. I think that this is yet another step in the right direction for the city of Carmel. Most cities tend to overlo6k the importance of a facility such as you have proposed. This is the kind of thing that raises a city the size of Carmel, to the next level. The arts in general have long been an important part of human culture. The performing ~rts have been not only a source of entertain~aent, but a reflection of popula9 views and social commentary. From the first days when a lone figure stood before a fire on the ground and acted out the dram9 of the days hunt, to the political commentaries of William Shakespeare and the Social awareness inspired by Arthur Miller as he spoke out agaihst the modern-day witch hunt. of Senator MaCarthy in his play "The Crucible".' As the city of Carmel continues to grow, bringing in people f~om all over the country and world, we need to be prepared to not only address the issues of roads, sewers and business, but we need to move forward on all aspects of cultural development. A performing Arts Center, as you propose, can only enhance the appeal of Carmel to all who look here for business or a place to call home. Please continue your fine Work and I am sure that the City Counsel will see the tremendous value of this project and move forward. It's time for the state of Indiana not to just be thought of as a place that you fly over to get somewhere else. Good luck and much success. Sincerely, Mark O. Bradley Brainard, James C From! RMBook2@aol.com Sent: Sunday, May 01,2005 2:39 AM To: , Brainard, James C; dbowden@indiana.edu; Kikokoko@comcast.net Subject: CARMEL PERFORMING ARTS CENTER Dea¢ Mayor Brainard: As 40 year members of the Community of Carmel, Jeanne and I wish to express our enthusiastic support for the proposed Performing Arts Center tO be located in Carmel's neTM City.Center. After studying carefully the proposed plans in detail, and listening to the innovative means of funding to be used, it is clear to us that now is the time to implement the plans, and set the stage for a new cultural environment in Carmel. Arriving in Carmel in 1969, with a family of four children to raise, we found an adequate school system which has since become outstanding. But, a cultural environment was just beginning. The high school had only a marching band, and several choral groups. Our clarinet playing daughter could play and march with the band, but our violinist daughter was one of only two individuals in the school playing a stringed instrument; she and one boy were the only two. (They played duets in the school talent show and won!) Slowly, the school built up its music education programs. But, not until .1976, when several talented friends met regularly at the United Methodist Church .on Range Line Road to practice classical music together, did a little community orchestra begin to entertain friends and members of the town with concerts at the old Carmel High School..With the encouragement and promotion of the Methodist Minister, Warren Saunders, its first Board president, the group enlisted more players, (all unpaid volunteers) and a paid director, and became the Carmel Symphony Orchestra. Not too long after its beginning, we became subscribers to the CSO concert series, and remain participants to this day. Thirty years later, Carmel High School has its own award winning symphony orchestra, an outstanding string program, bands and choral groups of all kinds, and an outstanding drama program. In addition, elementary and junior high schools in Carmel all have strong music programs with excellent teachers, as well. Meantime, with over 65 players, some of them paid professionals, and an outstanding Music Director, the CSO has grown from a few loyal friends into an outstanding community orchestra, ranked as one of Indiana's very best, with a dedication to providing music education and entertainment for all ages. By agreement with an earlier Carmel Clay Board of Education, Carmel High School was to be the CS©'s home venue, and for a number of years that worked. But, when the high school began to develop its own outstanding music departments and performances, it became increasingly difficult to fit the CSO into the season for performances. For some years now, the CSO has found it necessary to seek other places to play, many out of town, and the need has become more than ever urgent for it to have its own home. We hope the CSO can look forward to the beginning of its 30th Anniversary Season next October 1, with the firm knowledge that, at last, Carmel Symphony Orchestra will have its own performance hall. The blending of business, retail, entertainment, dining and cultural opportunities in one easily reached location, will greatly enrich the .lives of Carmel citizens. Therefore, we strongly urge the members of the City Council to vote YES to move on with this project. Sincerely, Robert (and Jeanne) Bdok Doreen Squire Ficara Executive Director PauIa S. Eat3n Presideht Pa{~l G. Reis Vice President Janis I., Wagner Treasurer Abigail G. Frantz Secretarp Board Members Debbie Apple Linda M. Bachofner Sandy Barretto Joyce Burrelt Theresa Brust Maria DeSantis Greg Di~rthaler Pamela S. Ferguson Noel Heymann Alexandra Jackiw, CPM Dee Kerber Evan Lurie Cherie P!eOes Peter Reist, C.P.A, Anthonette Sandoval _ExOfficio Dr. Chdrlcs P. Conrad Marjorie Flynn Prof. Ed~,drd J. Manetta Betty Sanford Phyllis Morrissey R. Carol Skinner Brenda Tolson Douglas Haney -The Honorable Mayor James Brainard City of Cannel One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 By a unanimous vote, Mayor Brainard.., ·.. the Board o£Directors of the Carmel Arts Council very definitely. supports the build/rig of the Performing Arts Center in Cannel. It is the absolute necessary central point for the growing arts in the area, · and for economic development, considering the outside attraction of promoters of cultural events in Cannel. This, in tam, enhances the quality of life and job opportunities for the citizens of Cannel. Sincerely, Doreen Squire Ficara Executive DireCtor ' 40 W. MAIN STREET CARMEL, IN 46032 GALLERY (317) 582-1455, OFFICE (317) 844-4989 lutheran Church, Missouri Synod 4850 East 131st; Streeg Came)., Indiana 46033 817-814-4252 FAX: 317-814-4260 www.carmelluiheran.org March 30, 2005 Mayor Jim Brainard One Civic Square Carmel, IN2 46032 Dear Mayor Braina]rd, It was nice having breakfast with you recently at the Hamilton County Prayer Breakfast. Your participation in spiritual-community events is most appreciated. I admire your boldness in leading Cam~el to be a community that truly makes a difference in the lives of its citizen~. Specifically, I would like to comment on the Performing Arts Center being proposed for central Carmel.. As a pastor of a large church in the community, we envision usage of such a facility. We would lik~ to be able to sponsor Contemporary Christian Artists in concert, yet our sanctuary 0nly seats about 600 people. I understand that the proposed seating would be for over 1600 people. This would be a wonderful venue for such events. We also enVision rgnting such a facility to host a "unity" Sunday on an occasional basis. We currently offer 5 different weekend worship opportunities with about 1200 people in total attendance. The Arts Center would enable us to worship together under one roof. Our Director of Music was especially excited to see the possibility of an organ also being provided for the Performing Arts Center. If you would like to further discuss these ideas, please give me a call. May God bless you as you lead the community of Carmel! · Pastor Luther C. Brunette Our Mission: To reach out, care £or~ and build people to,card maturity in Christ. The Rev. Luther C. Brtmet~e,' Senior Pastor Melissa Christian, DCE, Din, Youth & Young Adults The l~ev. Daniel Schumm, Associate Pastor James H. Gladstone, Director of Music The Rev. Donald R. Haase, Associate Pastor Max Murphy, Direcctor of Contemporary & Youth Music Greater Indianapolis Chapter Circle City Sound Barbershop ]ffarmony SOciety Mayor of Cannel Mr. James Brainard; · Dear Mayor Brainard I have followed with great interest and enthusmsm the progress of Carm¢ s Civic Center~ For 38 years mY family and I lived in Carmel. We started the House of Meridian Furniture and Interior Design Company located on the same property now occupied by the Glass Chimney restaurant mad Design Center. F0r the past 42 years I have beena member of the Barbershop Harmony Society. Oar chorus name is Circle City Sound. The chorus was established in Indianapolis in 1948. Today we have about 120 members. Most of our members live in Carmel; Westfield, Fishers, Noblesville, and north IndianaPolis. An additional 700 + Barbershoppers live in other Indiana communities. With no exception these Barbershop singers are equally as interested and enthusiastic as I am about the propOsed Cohcert Hall to be part ortho Carmel Civic Cegter. For more than 20 years we held our Annual Show in Clowes Hall. A lovely auditorium in a beautiful setting. Due to their escalating rental costs and stage hands fees, we moved our Aunu Show to the warren p~ffoiming Arts Center on Indianapolis's east side. There are ma~y fine and talented pigaal~ationS; like ibc BarbershoppO~s, who would be grateful for a.fine hall with the lates~ acoustics and seating a/rangnment in which to perform. · .Another Organization that I belong to is the carmel Rotary C!ub~ We have been part of the Monma T~all development, arid now we are pleased to be a part of the Civic Center "rooting section". I can't speak for the Rotary Club, but i know many Rotary members who are supportive of the building of the Concert Hall. Many of us remember the classic English Theater on the Circle: Indy's d0wntown had the Cirele~ LoeWs Lyric, Indiana, Athenaeum and the Murat theaters Where live entertainment performed. Four o£these theaters are going sirong, but'only 2 ~e qualified for major productions: Clowes Hall and the Mum~. T0day with the Complex sound, staging and lighting effectS, there is a need for another perfOrmance hall to acCOmmodate all of the theatrical requirements of major productions.. Who would not truly enjoy an opera, concert, play,'!eeture, Circus royale.., whatever, in a fine hall, With unmatch6d sound effects and exciting deSign? 0ka~,, so we all agree d beautiful Hall is fine, but we all know the most important thing in th/s auditorium' is the sound, the view toward the stage, lighting, and the feeling you get When you sit in a grea$ hall and become part of the performance. The proposed Concert Hall of Camel will be a world class entertainment destination. It w4.11 be so inviting, so tasteful~ and most importantly so wonderful to be mesmerized by the performance. Yes, the cost will be major, but manageable, and not a burden to the taxpayers. We now have the opportunity to build one of the most important concert halls in the world. This building should not be carmel's answe~ t0'La Scala or the Paris Opera House, bu~ carmel's civic expression cfa magical place to b/hag our families to enjoy a great a~ternoon or evening of unparalleled sights and sounds. ' MaYor Brainard, ~ don't believe the question should be "whether to build it Or not"...but when b~ikling ii.,. do it Correctly. Doing it wrong will actually cost more money. UNIVERSITY of I~NDIANAPOLIS~ (317) Fax: (317) http://t hratre, uindy.~ March 26, 2005 The Honorable Mayor Jim Brainard · One Civic Squarae Cannel, IN 46032 Dear Mayor Brainard: congratulations on the wonderful potential of the new Arts Center!. I have been in theatre for over thirty years. I was on staff at the Repertory'Theatre at Christian Theological Seminary for twenty-three y~ars~ and am still active at Carmel Commtmity Players. I also teach.theatre at the University of. Indianapolis. "NO NATION, STATE OR COMMUNITY IS ANY BETTER THAN ITS ARTS." ART IS A WINDOW TO THE HUMAN CONDITION." We kn0~v this fi~om history. Rome fell because 6f its deterioration in the arts.. And · when art. deteriorates, the nation deteriorates. If we neglect the arts and its potential to mirror life, we fail our nation. This proposed center for theatre and music Can show this state and community the importance of these arts and offer so many other rewards in hundreds of areas... With high hopes to success. ~dith. Bruce 7342 Pymbroke Drive Fishers, IN, 46034 ebmce~uindy, edu . . C.s,.R I.EL CLA' VETERANS MEMORIAL EO. Box 12 Carmel, IN 400 April 14, 2005 Mayor James Brainard City of Carmel One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 RE: Performing Arts Center Dear Mayor Brainatd: I wish to express my support of the proposed Performing Arts Center for Carmel. I believe it willbe of great benefit to the residents and businesses of Carmel as well as those of the greater IndianaPolis area. The entii'e City Center complex will blend business, retail~ dining, entertainment, and educational opportunities, ultimately imprOVing the quality of life for residents of Carmel. Creating this Unique and special environment in support of the arts will attract local, regional, national and may be international artists and performers, resulting in many thousands attending events and activities scheduled there. As President of the Carmel Clay V6terans Memorial Corporation, I am pleased that a cultural and educational facility such as the Carmel Performing Arts center is in such close proximity to the Veterans Memorial site. The visitors to the Performing Arts center will also have the opportunity to Visit the Veterans Memorial and be impacted by it. With its highly visible location, the Veterans Memorial will make a statement to all who vt'6W it that Carmel and Clay Township value and honor the Hves and sacrifices of our military men and women. I appreciate the vision, foresight and planning that has gone into making a world class suburb, which will be a drawing card for new residents, new businesses, and visitors, including leading performers and musicians. Sincerely, ' willis A. Eh~ign Lieut. Colonel USAF (Ret.) President