HomeMy WebLinkAbout4090079 Correspondence
05/22/2005 08:38
. .
3173353504
SOLARI
PAGE 01
From: Solar Concepts, Inc.
Questions? Call: 317-335-3100
Fax: 317-335-3504
12111 E. 79'" Street
lndianapolis, IN 46236
E-Mail: solarconceDtsl@aolicom
WEBSlTE: www.solarconce~tsl.com
if j';).. - q)s::L
To: Adam Shriner,
JEFF KENDALL
RE.: Saftlty & Security window films and
ANSI Z97.1 (unlimited) and CPSC 1201 I & II
COMPANY: Cen1nll Inspections
PHONE: $71-2491
FAX: 571-2499
ADDRESS:
CITY:
STATE:
DATE: 06/22105
TIME: 08:10AM
P AOES IN~LUDINO COVER:
15 ::) 0 ~i\
(oq')-75~d--
Sirs:
(jlcfi't;b '7f
Enclosed please find documents containing test data on 3M Scotchshield and GlassGlu-d Safety/Security
window films.
Please note that both products did pass the required impact loads for individual glazed areas.
I
In addition, these products are presently being used in many high and medium security government locations.
!
If! can answer any questions feel free to call or contact Fred Bennett or John Weesner at the State Building:
Commissioners office. '
Incidentally I met with Jeff Kendall a couple years ago on this subject.
Thanks.
William R Swhear
Lo+ 77-
Woo&s ()~ W~ Ilio.);{Is Greel
ce. John Mahaney
~5/22/2005 08:38
3173353504
SOLAR1
PAGE 02
HunJ.mgggn
r...I, THlI., La~_.rl..I:eaIp.", ....
J9l2_._
OesMoino', _ 50313-25117
15'$\Z&V$lQI
;.",(51Sl282.1I'O
\"-'/
Lab. No. 2440l8.A
ANSX Z97.l CPSC 1201
REPORT OF TESTS
ON
organic Coated Glass ,
safety Glazing Material por Use In Buildings
IIndoor Applieations Only)
Rendered '1'0
Metallized Prod~cts
Pivision of ITD Industries. Inc.
2544 Te~inAl D~ive South
St. Petersburg, FL 13712
August 7, 1992
'-"
GENERAL
This report contains the results of te~t8 on organic ~ilm coated
1LS" and 1/4 inch annealed g1&85,perfomed in acco~ce with
American National. stancSaxds Imltitute' 8 Specifieation for Safety
G1azing Macerial used in BuU~!i8,' PSX 07.1-1984 (unlimited) and .
the Cede of Federal Regu:LaUons, ,Title 16. CPSC 1201 (category XX),
Safety Standard for Architect\J.ra1 Giuinsr Materials..
MATERIAL mmMY'M'lID
E1even 34 :It 76 inch spec:iJllen 'Of'each',tb:l.clcness (1.'8 inch and 1/4
inch required ~or impact) were' subIIlitted for testing. Adequate
sma11 samples ~or ~e weathering and f1~~hi~ity teses were also
supplied.
"-"
_COI'1ti"ued-
!mID
nae "'IlO"T I. SUaItCT TO 1MI ADf;GUAC"f ANO MPRllslMTATtV!. CMAAACTII" (HI' M SAW"'-&,
AND TO ''''Ii coYPRIHl!NSJVl.NUI Of'''': "'In "",OIIWED. ,"el\e.~e, IN 'MI "'lusn
O' ACCU".A.CY AND AV01DANCl! OF Mt$UflDlfIl"TANDING. AND to '"I! I!ND TtIAT CO"flleT
+h4PRUSIONS UAV .1: COtn'EVlEtI. OUOT....t.aNS FRO" 0" !CItAtiONS OF '''IS "'~Oll' A~.c
q6/22/2005 08:38
3173353504
SOU\R1
PAGE 03
2
Lab. NO. 244018.~
-'-...-"
DESCRIPTION OF SAMPLES
The samples consisted of l/B inch and 1/4 inch annealed glass
coated with a 0.004 inch poly film (designated NRL 400 C90r applied
by Suntrol Products of Gloucester City. NJ and shipped to ou~
labox-atory. The bulk of the samples were received April :a. 1992;
TEST METHOnS AND USULTS
IMPACT TEST
'----./
ANSI Z97.1-19B4 (Unlimited) and CPSC 1201 (Category II)
Six 34 x ,76 inch specintens of each thickness (1/8 inch and 1/4 I'
inch) were kept at a temperature of 70-eO"F for a lllinimum of fOur,
hours preceding the test. Bach specimen was struck once within 1/2 '
inch of center. with a Shotbag eOWltX'Ucted in accordance with Pig.
2 of the Code. swinging in a pendulum arc from a drop height of 12
inches. 1Il:loVe horizontal centerline ,of ~e specimen. If breakage i
did not occur. drop heigh!: was increased. to 18 inches and.;
subsequently. 48 inches.
. ODe specilllen of each thickness. ~#..,ted in acoordance,with~ I
Title 16 - CPSC Part 1201 (f"'ategory"i:I) from only a drop,haight'of
48 inches. ,'. . ' . : '
1
2
3
.
1
:!
3
.
0.121
O.Ul
0.121
0.1:l2
0.230
0.22'
0.232
0.226
110
110
.0
2" BOrboatal 8UI;
.0 11
J" Iforis,.,n:a1 Slit
No
2. Venical Slit
-Continued.
Pa\2ig Teollng UliOiilorla Co.. In..
0.. MolAls. .....
~6/22/2005 08:38
3173353504
SOLAR1
PAGE 04
3
Lab. No. 244018.A
. -..-/
,-no,
5 1/8 0.121 48 Coated 110 Opel11n!J, ,...
Pull Frem
FI:UllI
.. 1/' 0.121 4.8 Uncoat..d 110 ~l11ng, PUB
Pull Frem
FrIIIIItl
5 1/4 0.226 48 co...ted No OpenUlg. P.....
Pull Fram
prame
II. 1/4 0.228 48 Uncoated No OpeDin!l. PUll
Pull F:r.'ClIII
~
SPE~T:FrED
---,-
The specifications state that the impact test is satisfactorily
completed if anyone of the fOllo""ing safety criteria is met by
each of the specimen tested: 1) when brellkage occurs at 12, lB, .or
48 inch drop heights, nU1l\erous cracks and fillsures may occur but JJ,O
shear or openinS through which a 3-inch diameter sphere may be
treely passed _y develop;. 2) when disintegntion occurs at 12,
18 or 48 .inche~, the .ten largest e~C!~~re.E!" particles, obtained.3
minutes subsequent to test, shall "'e,.gh"11O''liiore~than the' equiva1ent
of 10 square inches of'the origina3: :s~cimen; 3) When breakage
occurs at 12, 18, or 49 inches, the stiffness and hardness. of the
specimen shall be dete~ned. A modulus of elasticity less than
750,000 psi and a R.ockwell Hardness less than M or R 140 shall
indicate satisfactory compliance; 4) the specimen remains lntact
after the 4B inch drop test, though not necessarily .r~:iJ1ing'
within the frame.
. CPSC Part: 1Z01 require.tt'~tnat:' tI:".3:f1.r....'h ~dtllllleter solid st:eel
sphere weighing' 4 pounds is retained when placed in the
opening and pe~t:ted ro remain for a period of one second.
For t:his criterion the ;impact:ed sample shall be placed, while
remaining in t:he subframe, in a horizoneal, :l.mpacr side up,
posit:ion.
R.@sult.g
Test samp1es Qomp1ied wirh referenced ANSr and CPSC 1201 impact
criteria in both thicknesses.
. -~on~inYed.
Pltlig Te.tlng laboralorie. Co., Inc.
0.. MoJNlI. tow.
~6/22/2005 08:38
3173353504
SOLARI
PAGE 05
MAXIM
HCNNOL04rfl$ IMe
PROJECT NUMBER:
3618 98-77268.2
PAGE:
DATE:
10f5
January 7,1999
MAXIM TECHNOLOGIES, INC.
3922 Delaware Avenue
De' Moines, Iowa 50313-2597
Report of AN 51 Testt on
Safety Glazing Material For Use In Bulldll1p
Spliced 4 milProddct,Applied to 118" and 1/4" Glas.
3M.Scouhshleld. SCLARL400
Prepared ror:
3M COMPANY
Atm: Ken Smith
Construction Materials Deputment
Building 207-1 w-08
St. Paul, MN 55144
~ab~
'l~t~
Client Purchase Order Number: STP 0003135
Prepared by:
Reviewed by:
Carl And.-easeu
Project Engineer
Mechanical/Metallurgical Dept.
Phone: (515) 266--5101
Tlmotby B. Cox 1'.E.
Product Service Man.ger
MecbanicallMcUllurgical Dept.
Tbe te.t reoulto contained in thi. report pertain only to the sample. .ubmltted for testing and not
nec....rIly to all oimilar products.
AS A, MUTUAL PROTEl:TtON TO CLIENTS, THe PUBLIC AND OURSElVES, AlL MAXIM TECHNOLOGIES. INC: REPORTS ARE SU.,MITl'eD AS THE CONFIOE.NTlAL
INP.ORMATlON OF CL.IENTS, ANO AUTHORIZATION pOR PU8L1CATlON OF STATEMEN1'S, CO~CL.USION!!l OR EXTRACTIONS ,.ROM OR REGARDING OUR
REPORTS 15 RESERvED PENDING OUR PRIOR WRITTEN APPROVAl.
Austin Research Engineers . Chen-Northern . Empire Solis Investigations
Kansas City Testing. Southwestern Laboratories. Twin City Testing
An Affirmative Action, {~ Equal OpfJQYtunity Employer
";;~:::;:;:,,',::::ill_Ii;;"\::~:l;:~{(\'!.I~IIT .
M~Ht%Wiffim@~]:%1~~~::j:@~1~jf~~~%swr1%~1~t~t~m~i.rij~ife@W@1:g~1ijgI:~@tfR~:]:~rm:m~~tH!mm~~fNW~~~:~~~~;~'@U*t4t~~M'~1~1~~l~~~=~.~~
~5/22/2005 08:38
3173353504
SOLARI
PAGE 05
I
I
HUl!...tID~J!
Pa\Jl9 TotUng .......""_ "-'" Ioc.
3322 Delawa... Avenue
Oa Moines, lowe 50313-2597
(515)2e&.8101
Fax: (S1e)2il2.191l
Lab. No. 6030-93-5028.3
lU:PORT OF TESTS
ON
HIGH PERFORMANCE WINDOW FILM
Safety Glazing Material For Use In Buildings
Rendered To
Construction Materials Department
MiMesota Mining and ManufactUring
3M Center
Building 207-1 W-08
St. Paul, Minnesota 55144
November 23, 1993
GENERAL
This report contains the resultS of impact tests on 3M High Performance Window Film performed
in accordance with the Code of Federal Regulations 16, Chapter II, Consumer Product Safety
Commission, Part 1201, Safety Standard for Architectural Glazing Materials (January '91
Revision) .
AUTHORIZATION
Tests were authorized by Ken Smith and 3M P.O. No. T847594-KES. A l'ortion of the Testing at
Patzig Laboratories was witnessed by Ken Smith on 10/12/93.
Sl lMMARY OF RES1lI.TS
RE3SNEARLS (3 Mil Tint)
Complies with CpSC Category I and Category II when
applied to nominal 1/8" and 1/4" glass.
Complies with CPSC Category I and Category II when
applied to nominal 1/8" glass and complies with Category I
when applied to nominal 114" glass.
SCLARL 400 (4 Mil Clear)
-continued-
f!!i!J
THIS REPORT IS SUBJECT TO ANY ,.t.DEOUACY AND IlEi,PRESEt.lTAnVE CI-tA.AAC1'f.R Of THE SAMPlE.
ANO to TI-ll;: OOMPREHENSiVENESS OF THe TESTS PERFORMI!D. ll-tEREFORE. IN THE INTERESTS
01" ^CCllRACY AND A,VOtcANe~ 01" MI$UNOILRSiTANOINO. ANO TO TME e:ND T'-l"T IS CORRECT
IMPRliS510NS MAY DE CONVEYED. QUOTATIONS FROM OF! CIT'ATIONS OF T'HIS REPORT ARI!!
AUTHORIZED ONL V SUQJECT TOOuR REVIeW AND WRlf'TEN APPROVAL.
~rlll~I!11{l~11~ttjl'IIiI,.II_ili_1\_~_.ijllllltiJII
q5/22/2005 08:38
3173353504
SOU\Rl
PAGE 07
Page No. 2
Lab. No. 6030-93-5028.3
MATF.RIAL ~lJRMTTTF:n
Eight specimen of 34x75-inch dimension were supplied for testing impact resistance. The
samples consisted of nominal 1/4 inch and nominall/8-inch clear glass with 3M High
Performance Film professionally applied to one side and allowed to cure. The applied film was
held back from the edge of the glass 1/2". All samples were prepared prior to delivery to the
laboratory.
TEST METHODS AND REST JI TS
IMPACT TEST
Specimens were kept at a temperature of 70-80oF for a minimum of four hours preceding the test.
Specimen were placed alternately with the film facing the impact and opposite of the impact as
shown below. Each specimen was struck once within ]/2 inch of center, with a shot bag
constructed in accordance with specifications referenced, swinging in a pendulum arc, from a drop
height offorty eight (48) inches for Category II and from eighteen (18) inches for Category I.
Samples submitted for testing were prepared by others.
R R~lJLTS
F]LM IDENTIFICATION
SCLARL 400 " 4 mil Clear
Total Drop
Sample Film Thickness Height Results/Size of Opcmitlg
Nlm1bcr Side Inches Incbos
I Facing 0.121 48 Sbaltered. No opening.
Pull from frame totally.
2 Opposite 0.125 48 Shattered. No openitlg.
Pull from frame totally.
3 Facing 0.230 48 ShaUcred. No opening.
Pull from frame tOtally.
4 Opposite 0.230 48 Shllltcred. No opening.
Pullli'oro frame totally.
-continued-
HuNTINGDON ENGIN~~ING &. ENVlRONMENTAL.INC.
"
I
,
I
I
DES MOINES. IOWA
,
",,";""':""':I;,::<:::..;.x&:,~;:;;;';:O~l~~~"':""I<~:t~~;::::>>.;,<':;;::w.<:;''";:i:*;
<~;...t.::~~<'i:w.\~~~'";:~;rt~"*1~~@'~~
"~~~:,~"",,,*"," . ::';""",'A!~""",~,;","'~".r,.:%\
_:,:::;~'lfj:tr;:~~:"""J~:;""".:'~,*,<,,,,*"v~t%~:~,:.9,~'
... ... ..~:::N~::.......",,'.tt.';~';':;::;S:)::~~!:':':':'t':';<1;t';';<;l>>,ij:":';"";"':~~~~h';:~
~6/22/2005 08:38
3173353504
SOU\R1
PAGE 08
\
Page No. 3
Lab. No. 6030-93-5028.3
FILM IDENTIFICATION
RE35NEARl ,S -1 mil Tint
Total Drop
Sample Film Thickness Height Results/Size of Opening
Number Side Inche, Inch..
1 facing 0.121 48 Shattered. 4" horizontol ,lit.
pun from frame _ny.
2 Opposite 0.120 48 Sharrered. No opening.
Pull from frame totallY.
3 Facing 0.229 18 Shattered. No opening.
Pull from frame top, one ,ide.
4 Opposite 0.230 18 Shattered. No opening.
Respectfully submiucd,
PATZIG TESTING LABORATORIES CO., INC.
/?t. r:: RA
Kelly E. Robert, P.E.
~.u.I'~~
Carl C.Andreasen, S.E.I.
KER:CCA:AM:mkw
3 pc Above
P..~ T.llti"9 Labnorq,tcri85 Conine.
Dl!ll!l MOines, Iowa
1~1!~lr~il~I~II~\~I~II~I..II'~.III.:';;~,::,.._,~~l~,~L
~5/22/2005 08:38
SOLARI
PAGE 09
3173353504
. Hul!ti.!!g~_9J!
PaWg rolllllg .....orlIIotl.. Comp""1lne.
3322 ~wa.'" A.venue
081 Moine;, loWlil 50313.25i7
(515)266-&101
Fox: (!l15)2U.1ll1O
Lab. No. 6030-94-5069B.2
REPORT OF TESTS
ON
HIGH PERFORMANCE WINDOW FILM
(Safety Glazing Material For Use In Buildings)
Rendered To
Construction Materials Department
Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing
3M Center
Building 207-1 W.08
St. Paul, Minnesota 55144
July 29,1994
OF.NF:RAL
This report contains the passing results of Xenon Weathering tests on 3M Window Film
performed, in accordance with the Code of Federal Regulations 16, Chapter n, Consumer Product
Safety Commission, Part 1201, Safety Standard for Architectural Glazing Materials (January '91
Revision).
At JTHORTZAT10N
Tests were authorized by Ken Smith and 3M 1'0. No. E435302-NAS.
!';UMMARY 01' RE!';UI.TS
~amnle Identification Adhesion ~
S35NEARL (Orey) 1/4" Complies Complies
1/8" Complies Complies
SCLARL400-33 1/4" Complies Complies
1/8" Complies Complies
SCLARL 400-43 1/4" Complies Complies
1/8" Complies Complies
SCLARL 150 1/4" Complies Complies
1/8" Complies Complies
.Continued-
{g
THIS REPOR.T IS SUBJECT TO ANY A.DEQUACY AND REPm::$ENTA11VE CHARAC11!:R OF THE SAMPlE.
AND TO THE COMPREtiENS/VeNESS OF n-IE TESTS PE~ORM6.0. Tl-4I!:REFORE, IN THE INTERESTS
OF ACCURACY AND AVOIC....NCE OF MI.!SUNOf:RO"TANDlNQ, -"NO TO TtlE eN" THAT IS eOl'lll'l:I!.CT
IMPRESSIONS MAV BE CONVEYED. QUOTATIONS PROM OR CITATIONS OF THIS REf"QRT ARe:
AU'fl-IORI.:?;!<D ONLY SUBJECT rOOUR RE.Vn:~w AND VfflITT'EN APPROVAL
Ir~llIfi~"~li1DIIIII_I~iiR.fli!lll_111I1~.:::,::,::~:':~"