HomeMy WebLinkAboutPacket
OCT~10-2001 WED 01:20 PM CARMEL COMMUNITY SVCS
FAX NO. 317 571 2426
P. 09
. CARMEL/CLAY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
Cannel, Indiana
/~/;/;:o,
A:;\..v~,--LJ...J..~"
(::;'/.... /~
GlJI ,. ,,:::- \
":.:; ~t.Ct.\\jE\) ~\
~I {\t,1 10 'L~~\ 8.~'(
\ - uOC<2> 10/
.A "
/,,-Y
'10- .~__./\ (& /'
lil ~J~~
Oocket No. :
Petitioner:
FINDINGS OF FACT w \lSE VARIANCE (Ballot Sheet)
,.
2.
3.
4.
6.
DATED THIS
DAY OF
,20_.
Board Member
P8gw 7 or. - Ute vllflanct AppI\caIIOII
---- ~~--_.~-~- -~- ------- -------------_._--------------_.~-~---
.,
CARMEUCLA Y BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
CARMEL, INDlANA
Docket No.:
Petitioner:
FINDINGS OF FACT. DEVELOPMENTAL STANDARDS VARIANCE
1. The approval of this variance will not be injurious to the public health, safety, morals and general welfare of the
community because:
The proposed sign height & size will not be detrimental since it is
essentially the same as the existing case. Also, the elimination of one
.
sign will give a clearer look.
2. The use and value of the area adjacent to the property included in thE) variance will not be. affected in a substantially
adverse manner because:
Theadjacerit areas will not be affected adversely!,because the proposed sign
is similar to the existing. The.new sign will have an undated look. which
will help values.
3. The strict application of the terms of the Zoning Ordinance to the property will result in practical difficulties in the
use of the property because: '
The neadsof the'business to inform customers requires more than the code
allows. In addition, the existing signs could not meet current requirements.
DECISION
IT IS THEREFORE the decision of the CarmellClay Board of Zoning Appeals that Developmental Standards Variance
Docket No. ' is granted, subject to anyconcfrtions stated in the minutes of this
Board, which are incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof.
Adopted this.
day of
,199
CHAlRPERSON,Carmel/Clay Board of Zoning Appeals
SECRETARY, Carmel/Clay Board of Zoning Appeals
s:\forms\devstand.app
Conditions of the Board are listed on the back. (Petitioner or his
representative to sign).
007 ....
(105) .. 012
8 i
009 . e 001.001
il - ~.J Ac. a
(119) 5.05 Ac.
020.. 001
Mt.3 ~
J.04 Ac. 5.12 Ac.
71.2 '"
008
~ (118)
006 ~
~ (116) 007
(117)
..... 240.'
moO
015 il
(1)
0.41 Ac. " 013 II
177.0 II
016
(2)
O.41k.
il 017
(3)
0.42 Ie.
'S UNR
i 018 0
)>
(4) -<
---------------- @
0
Al (/)
Al
0.82 Ie. III
(5) ~ a
~
019 007
..
i (6)
0.42 Ie. 1.2065 Ie.
.....
....7 232..
006
020 .....
(7) @ 008 1. 7727 Ie.
---------------- 010 0.89 Ac.
I
Ii 1.416 At:..
1.16 Ac.
(8)
~
200..
CITY OF CARMEl- CLAY TOWNSHIP
HAMilTON COUNTY. INDIANA
APPUCATlON FOR' BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS ACTION
DeveLOPMENTAL STANDARDS VARIANCERI:QUEST
,F'EE: $450.00 for the first plus' $50.00 for. each additional section of the ordinance bein'g varied.
DOCKET NO.
DATE RECEIVED:
1) AppOcant InBi~ht Engineering, Inc.
Addr~: 650 EA Carmel Drive, Suite 310, Carmel, IN 46032
2)
Project Name: Shell Station
Phone: 870-0151
Engineer/Architect lnsiiht EDrsineerin2:. Inc.
Phone: 848-9040
Attorney:
N/A
Phone:
3) Applicant's Status: (Check the appropriate response)
(a) The applicant's, name is on the deed to the ,property
(b) The appliCant Isthe contract purchaser of the property
x
(c) cnher: . Owner, Agent
4) Ifltem 3) (c) Is check-ed, please complete the following:
OWner of the property involved: EClUilon Enterprises
Owner's address: 5405 W. 96th Street. Indpls.. IN 46268
5) Record of OWnership:
Deed Book NoJlnstrument No. 9834341
Phone: 870-0151
Page:
- Purchase date:
6-25-98
6) Common address of the property involved: 3202 E. 96th Street
Legal description: ~"'''' At-t-At'h",~
. . ..
Tax Map Parcel No.: -! 4~ -.94-08-010.000 ,
7) State explanatiqn of requested Developmental Standards Variance: (State what you want to do and cite the section
number(s) of the CarmeVClay Zoning Ordinance which applies and/or creates the need for this request).
This location fallswillhin the B3 zoning requirements. This Qart of the, code
;
allows for one sign, 10 square feet & 5 feet tall. We propose to replace 2
signs that total 210 square feet with two signs that are 86 square feet. We ask
for a variance to permit two signs that are 43 square feet each and 6ft. 10" tall
8)
State reasons supporting the Developmental Standards- Variance: (Additionally; complete the attached question
sheet entitled "Findings of Fact-Developmental'standards Variancej.
, '
The needs of the business to inform c'ustomers require more than one, sign, '
'at 10 square feet. 'By replacing 2 signs with 2' smaller, yet matching signs,
the site will have a more un~form look.
9) Present zoning of the property (give exact classification):
10)
Size of lot/parcel in question: '
1. 416
acres
11) Present use of the property: gasoline sales/ convenience store/ carwash
, 12) Describe the proposed use of the property: gasoline sales/convenience store/carwash
13)
Is the property: , Owner occupied
Renter occupied
xx
'Other
14) Are there any restrictions, laws, covenants, variances, special uses, or appeals filed in connection with this property
that would relate or affect its use for the specific purpose of this application? If yes, give date and docket number,
decision rendered and pertlnentexplanatlon; ,
NO,
15) Has work for which this application is being filed already started? If answer is yes, give detans: No
BuDding Permit Number.
Bunder.
16) If proposed appeal is granted, when will the work commence?
Immediately
17) If the proposed variance is granted, who will operate and/or use the proposed Improvement for which this
applicatIon has been filed?
Owner
~
, LEGAL NOTICE shall be pUblished In the Noblesville Dailv Ledaer a MANDATORY twenty-five (25) days prior to
the public hearing date. The certified '''Proof of Publication" affidavit for the newspaper must be available for inspection the
night'of the hearing.
LEGAL NOTICE to all adjoining and abutting property owners is also MANDATORY. two methods of notice are
recommended: '
1) CERTIFIED MAIL . RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED sent to adjoining property owners. (The white receipt
, should be stamped by the Post Office atleast twenty.five (25) days prior to the public hearing date.)
. ,
AFFIDAVIT
I, hereby swear that I amtheowner/contract purchaser of property Involved In! this application and that the foregoing
signatures, statem~nts and answers herein contained and the information herewith submitted are in all respects true and
correctto the best of my knowledge and belief. I, the undersigned, authorize the applicant to act on my behalf with regard
to this application and subsequent hearings and testimony. :
signed:" '" 6r- _h
(Property OWner, Atto~eY, or Power of Attorney)
Date
Rob Roy, Engineer 1
, (Please Print) " :
STATE OF INDIANA
ss":
County of Hami;I.ton
(County in which" notarization takes place)
Befo~e me the undersigned, a Notary Public
for Hamilton
(Notary Public's county ofresidence)
" County, State of Jndiana~ personally appeared
!
Rob Roy
(Property Owner, Attorney. or Power of Attorney)
;
. . and aclqtowledge the ex~cution of the foreg~ing instrument this
day of
.1:~" 2001 i
"",.....""
~,,"b~~hW. ""'"
~~.:.~.fl.Y 8~"~O ~
.:'J~-'O\ '?:~
= ~"~EAL) ".'(' ~
- . . .
5: -e- ! =
: ~ Q: =
; '.-1-0 .;:to' ~$
",($l;:'.?'-1/i ~\)~., ~
'.,:1'1; '" X.., ~,'t;...
"'I ~OF \~,,\,..
'"........"
- ~M 4l"~ fiJ;
Notary Public-Signatur~
Herschel W. Roll
Notary Public-Please Pjint
i
Mycornmission expires: J~ly pi. 2008
-----~-- ----- ~ ~~--_._-~_. --~_..-
I
I
,
I
'I
I
,
I J
~~U~ ~~---------------~-~~-i
SIC. '1-11.... I
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ S2~TH UNE S.:.E__1/4, SEe:... "t"17-4 _ _ ..
S 89'57'00. E 237.00' I P.o.8.
..;
:"
o
I
I.&J
::>
z
~
<
w
z
~
~
w
~
J
I
ill
..I
I
I
I
j
I
III
P r.
.
I-
I
.
-LEGEN D"
I
CD
lIONUlIENT SIGN
lIID-RlSE SIGN
CANOPY SHEU. PEClEN
CAR WASH ENlRANCE SIGN
CAR WASH EXIT SIGN
I
~----~\l
~ \ \1
~~~ \ \I
~ *" ,
I'~~,---
. ~~. \
~ \
MOlE: SEE SHEET 1 Of' 10 FOR SIGN DETAILS
Ig J
~J~.II
:III F:'F:'
a fie.
0)
c
--
...
G)
..... G)
NORTH ~c
0)--
(j) -- Q .
Cl)CU
.5w.5
~
INCHES
fI' I" r
J 10 .
20 <<l
FElT
'--
<Qo
..0. -
-
o
..
---------------------------
96th STREET
S lI8'lI7'OfI' E 2ilO.OO'
~1lLCOR.
~ '~7-4
--------
<Qo
(
<Qo
LAND DESCRIPTION
'lRACT IIINST, 8UoQ41
PART at 1HE !ASf HAIl at 1HE SOUlHEAST ClUARTER at I5!C'I1ON 7.
~~~~r.:r':='llIN COUIITY. JlDlANA.
_Il1O 237.00 FEET SQU1H II IlElRES 57 1IIlU1ES 00 SECONOS !ASf
=Jfm~~.=:,~=-~
67ON~~lH~~'c:u'~=--=r II
SOU1H LI<< 2CIO.00 RETI 1H!NCl! NOR1Il 00 _ ~ IIIIIMB 00
RCCNDS !ASf :MO.CIO RETI 1H!NCl! NOR1Il II _ 67 lIINU'IrS CIO
SECCNIllI ..,. PARALLEL llI1H 1HE saulH UNE at _ EASI' HAIl
2A3lI FEET 11) 1HE EASI' NCNT-at-WAY LH! at STAll Rl>>D 4.111
1llENCE SQU1H 00 _ 02 1INJ1IS 30 SECONOS lAST ON AlII
ALONG _ RlGHT-<lF-WA'I UNE Il12.ta RETI lHENCE SQU1H 113 IlERES
OIl111UlD CIO SECClNDS EAST ON ANO ALCNG SIoID RIGHT-at-WAY LI<<
18.11 RETI 'llENCE SOU1H CIO _ ~ IoINU1IS 00 S!CCNDS VIST
_ FEET 11) 1HE PI.AOE at IIEllIIININlI. OCNT_ 1.411 AalElI, _
~~~'=.'lS,_-WAY.
~ EXISTING SIGN LOCATION PLAN
PRO.JECT INF'llRMAllON:
SHELL @
3202 EAST 96TH STREET
CARMEL, INDIANA
~E.l. DRAWING NUMBER: 1801-SLP.dwlI PROoECT HUllER: 1801
SCALE: 1 -20' SHEET NUIIIlER:
DA'lE: 04/10/01 1 0 F 1 0
DRAWN BY: HwR '
F1EI.D BOOK 1111-1
~
I
~
co
~
Iii
0
H W
I
lJJ I
::>
z
~
<C
lJJ ; j ~
Z
g co
~ I
lJJ ill -LEGEND"
~ ~
CD WONUMENT SIGN
..I ?E CAR WASH END DECAl.
CAR WASH EXIT DECAl.
I
N01El SEE SHEET 10 Of 10 F'OR SIGN DETAILS
r.
Il1"
-
I
l-:-----T~
~ \\1
~:~ ,
. ~~-- \
~ \
I
I
I
I
I~
I
I
I __~ !
~.- ~~--------------------I
r. ,J.t.ar. 1/4,
..y..,,....
____ ____ ~l!..TH UNE S~_1/4. SEC._7.:~ ___ _ __ __ ..
S 89'57'00. E 237.00' I. P.o.&.
o
il J
!I~ II
:III F:"F:"
::a ~~
U) __
4... -
.
'--
'Go
96th STREET
-8 si'i7'ocr E 2OO.GO' -
. . /ar.tlllR.
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ --.f'-IK Ita 'Ci,....
NORTH
~
C)
C
--
...
Q)
... Q)
.cc
C)--
-- C) ·
(l)C()
.5w.5
<Qo
(
<Qo
-
It'
~
fEET
10
,.
10
r
,
<<l
t)
LAND DESCRIPTION
TRACT " INSTf _,
PART Of lItE EAST HAlT Of 1HE SllU1HEAST QUMlER Of S!ClIllN 7.
'IOWSHP 17 HOR1lt, lWlGE 4 EAST IN HAIIILTOH COUNTY. ICDlAHA,
MaRE PIIIITICUI.M.Y IlESCR8ED AS fllWlWB:
_ 2.'S7.ao FEET SOUlH 8ll DrllAEES 111 MICU1IS ao S!COHDS EAST
CASSUIEII ~) Of 1HE lIQU1'HIIIaT CORNER Of THE EAST IW.F Of
tHE 8QU1HEAST Ql/MlER ~ 17 HOR1lf, RANGE 4
~7~~ ~:C~811
8QU1H IJII! lOQ.ao ao IoINlITE8 ao
_ EAST 240.00 87 IINU1E8 ao
_ lIIEBT P EAST IW.F
28UlI FEET 10 THE ROAD 431.
_ 8QU1H ao CII AND
ALCHQ SAID AICHT-elF 1H IS! DEGREES
OS MlCUlES ao SE -oF-WAY UN!
7&81 PEE1I 1HDlCZ 03 SECONDS lIST
4OJlO FEET 10 1HE CClHT_ 1.418 ACRES, IIClAE
OR lIllS. IIUIloECT 10 AU. ~ _-WAY,
EASElIENT8 AND IlES'I1IlmOIl8
PROJECT 1NFlIRMA1lON:
2 OF 10
~
, ,
"
"
"
"
:~~j}"l!t1f'~;'~\!;~~l~'j;
, , "
I
SOUTl-l EL~ATION - G-STORE
~
..
~
Q :.;.~<<..::
o :....." 0
.. '~:';':l;"(~;~~"\:l";:'".i^t';~,,~
" "
""
.i>f;;:'if,'~;(:',~'1~~~,1~f;lill~\]",i\;i'~ilf'{}~~i
'-. .....
I; J!
j!)i: II
.II uJ I F:"F:"
al EE
";.-. :','.:
"'( . -.:..'':.'
:::.~::~~ L:'~";(k.:
iii ,..;::, m
. ". ."
:." ::~';' :: ~.
".".:.. ....
.:-.::..:.::..:.;
:- :"..
......'..., ..,.:.:
WEST ELEVATION - C-~TORE
EAST ELEVATION - C-S"(O~E
C)
C
.-
...
CI)
E!
Q.-
..... C) ·
0.fj()
C C
- -
(I
~ EXISTING C-STORE ELEVATIONS
SHELL @
3202 EAST 98th STREET
CARMEL, INDIANA
~T lNFORIlAlION:
NORTH EL~ATION - C-STORE
~E.~ DRAI'llNG NUMBER: 9801c-~dwG
SCALE: 1 4' . 1'-0
DAlE: 04/10/01
DAAWI\I BY: HwR
F1aD II/A
PROJECT NUlIBER: 9801
SHEET NUMBER:
3 OF 10
~
.. (;)ft D
I
" " " "~ " " "
" " "" " "
r----=;. " "
OJ
III .1 I I II I I I I I. I
~.~{::.~~~:' .:',. ,. :..:.~t~:~;~:~\;
... ... '" '. .~
.::'(' 0 .,. ~., ';':1; ,;".
" " "
'\
'\ "
II
'\
"
"
~ORTH EL~ATION - C-STOR~
~QUTM EL~ATION - C-STOR~
I
I
"
"
;~~;<j~:f~~,~,~~}i~jl\~~;t
(:
o
Il
I II I I II III II I II II
.-. .. _....". ~;. hr ,-: .. ..". ".~' :..l!" ,":
: > .< ,., ., '. ~ '. ..:, ".~~:.~,.~: ~:~:~;:;:
!Illi
5.1 &&
Q
c
--
as
... G,)
.cc
Q)--
-- c:D ·
U)cu
.5w.s
&i
!
i
~
..
;
~
I
I
I I
o
-;:,:~;>:::+;;,;:~:'~:j;':s~:,~L,:,:;;t,,, "
I!I . I!l . '. ",.,."....... ',' "~ ,... " "
· 2. ,: ;;:,f,:;:;2;;:';F:;;:<,j'::~,\:,~
-
V(E~T ELEVATION - CAR WA$H
IPJllIIHI
-
UI
o
I
h
,t~'i'~18\t~~,t,~;;:~,~i}"~}'{;~2i\\~:';'1;i:'~;"j
'1'l'0, ""'1'1 ,.,.,
EAST ELEVATION - CAR WASH & C-$TOR~
-
~ PROPOSED C..STORE ELEVATIONS
PRO.IECT 1NF0000AlKlN:
SHELL @
3202 EAST 98th STREET
CARMEL, INDIANA
I.E.I. DRAl\lNG NUMBER: 9801c-atafe,d"ll PRO.JltCT NUIl8ERl 8801
SCALE: 1/4' .. "-0. SHEET NUlIEIER:
~~~~: 4 OF 10
~ lOOK ~ MIA
~
WEST ELEVATION - CAR WASH
~
I
~
..
~
NORTH ELEVATION - CAR WASH
SOUTH ELEVATION - CAR WASH
I
liS .I
!5i;.11
:!;: 'I t::"t::"
cZuslJ SiSi
C)
c
--
..
CD
.... CD
.cc
C)--
-- Q .
tl)C()
.5w.5
~
mr EXISTING CAR W ASH ELEVATIONS
PRO.JECT INF'llRMAllON:
EAST ELEVATION - CAR WASH
SHELL @
3202 EAST 96th STREET
CARMEL, INDIANA
I.E.I. DRAWlG NUMBER: 9801cal'WCllh.dwg PROoECT NUIlBal: 9801
SCALE: 1/4" . 1'-0. SHEET NUlIIlER:
DAlE: 04/10/01 5 0 F 1 0
DRAWN BY: HwR
F1D..D BOOK N A
NORTH ELEVATION - CAR WASH
WEST ELEVATION - CAR WASH
SOUTH ELEVATION - CAR WASH
EAST ELEVATION - CAR WASH
I
SI J
~liI_1I
:1;.:1 .t=:'f:'
8hasB e.e.
Q
c
--
..
CD
..... CD
..c:c
Q--
.- Q .
U)CU
.5w.5
.
~JrPROPOSED CAR WASH ELEVATIONS
PROJECT INF'llRNA nON:
SHELL @
3202 EAST 96th STREET
CARMEL, INDIANA
I.E.!. DRAYoING NUN8ER: 8801__ PRO.JECT NUMBER: 8801
SCALE: 1/4" - 1'-0" SHEET NUIIBER:
DAlE: 04/10/01 6 0 F 1 0
DRAWN BY: HwR
FIELD BOOIC , N/A
Iii
!
i
~
..
;
~
I
{I
.......
I
I
T
I
14t<D
I
I
WEST ELEV A TI ON
I ....... I I
I <D4t I I 1 I I I
~
..
W
EAST ELEVATION
I
I
aNt
I
I
I
I
I
as .I
~)": II
:11.1.I1 f:"f:"
ci m lJ 6,6,
I
{I
aNt
0)
c
--
..
CD
..... CD
.cc
0)--
-- 0) ·
U)CU
.5w.5
NORTH ELEVATION
I I
I
I
.
~ EXISTING CANOPY ELEVATIONS
PROJECT 1NFIlRMA1ION:
SOUTH ELEVATION
SHELL @
3202 EAST 98th STREET
CARMEL, INDIANA
~E.I, DRAWING MUII8ER: 9801CANOPY,dWll PRO.ECT NUllBER: 9801
SCALE: 1/." - 1'-0" SHEET NUlIIlER:
DAlE: 04/10/01 7 0 F 1 0
DRAWN BY: HwR
FIELD BOOK '" MIA
'-------
I
~I
I
I
I
I
I
~I
...,.
I
EAST ELEVATION
>Nt
I
NORTH ELEVATION
>Nt
I
SOUTH ELEVATION
\. ........-... -
'--L..-. _...
I
I
I
I I
"'---
--...
I
I
1;;
I
;51 J
~!~ II
_wI ,::-,::-
ala lili
=
c
--
~
CD
... CD
.cc
=--
-- Q .
U)c()
.5w.5
.
PROJECT INFORMA liON:
mr PROPOSED CANOPY ELEVATIONS
SHELL @
3202 EAST 96th STREET
CARMEL, INDIANA
~E.~ DRAWING NUlIBER: 8801CANCPY.dll9 PROJECT NUlIBER: 9801
SCALE: 1/4 . 1'-0. SHEET NUlIBER:
:"'~~:01 8 OF 1 0
FIELD BOOK " N/A
I
I I
"'---
-.....
1t.a1t
Ir-Jot
l'-11t
II"""T""T
I . I:- w.-
T
T
I 000'
T 1:1:,
T ~
1 T =- 000'
T
Food II8rI I:., 000'
t
ElGS1lNG _UIIalT SIGN
CD
;rr
[ Car Wash
DaS1IlCl 24" IlURFG 1I_1tIl PEClEN SIGH
(CNIllPl')
CD
"-4'
Ent;~nc~ IE;"
ElGS11NG 10" CAR WASH EN~CE SIGH ElIIlI1INll 10" CAR _ ElIIT 8GH
CD
CD
CD
ElIISlIlC _RISE SIGH
.
~
i; .I!
!Jo;.1I
:lull F:'F:'
JilI8 SiSi
Q
c
--
..
CI)
.... CI)
.cc
Q--
-- Q .
Cl)CU
.5w.5
.
PROJECT INRlRMATlON:
= EXISTING SIGN DEl AILS
SHELL@
3202 EAST 96TH STREET
CARMEL, INDIANA
PROolEOTN_ 9801
8HEETN_
I.E.I. DIlAWINll NUMBER: 9a01SIGN.llWg
IICAL&: 114' _ I'
DATE: 04110101
DRAWN BY: HwR
f'IELll BOOK t: N1A
9 OF 10
j;;
~
I
~
i
~
..-at
@~
.....
000'
000'
000'
........
I
PllCPClSED IICNIIIENT SlIlN
CD
i
m
I 2'~' I
Enter
_ ff' CWI WASH EN1!R SlOIl
CD
t
liU .I
~J~ II
~ uJ "I F:'F:'
ala 6-6-
C)
c
--
...
CD
..... CD
.cc
C)--
-- Q .
.cu
.5w.5
CD
I t'-tO" I
Exit
_ff'CWIWASH ElITSIGIl
(t
SHEET
TlT\.E:
PIlOJECT INFORMATION;
PROPOSED SIGN DETAilS
SHELL@
3202 EAST 96TH STREET
CARMEL, INDIANA
I.E.I. DRAWING NUMBER: G801-8IG1fS.DWG PRO.lECT NUMBEII: llIlOl
SCAl&: 114". I' SHEETNUMBI!R:
=~~~A 10 OF 10