HomeMy WebLinkAboutNMMP 07080022 ADLS Amend - E & W signsCityofCarmelDepartmentofCommunityServicesDivisionofPlanningZoningLETTERofGRANTSeptember242007DougStaleyStaleySignsIncPOBox515IndianapolisIN46206vRENorthMeridianMedicalPavilionShmageDocketNo07080022ADLSAmendDearDougTheSpecialStudiesCommitteeoftheCarmelPlanCommissiontookthefollowingactionatitsmeetingSeptember042007regardingtheArchitecturalDesignLightingLandscapingandSignageAmendmentADLSAmendapplicationforsignagelocatedonbuildingsABlocatedat12188NorthMeridianStreetCarmelAPPROVEDDocketNo07080022ADLSAmendNorthMeridianMedicalPavilionSignageTheCommitteeapproyeda95squarefootwallsignfacingMeridianStreetanda115squarefootwallsignfacingIllinoisStreetthesignfacecoloriswhiteilluminatedwhiteatnightthelogosmayhavecolorandilluminatewithcolorbutwillnotexceed25ofthetotalsignareaInordertoassisttheDepartmentsreviewpleaseattachacopyofthisletterwhenmakingapplicationforpermitsregardingtheimprovementscontainedwithinthisapprovalDonothesitatetocontactmeifIcanbeoffurtherassistanceSincreyavvuAngelinaVConnPlanningAdministmtorDepartmentofComnmnityServices3175712417CsRacleJBooneCJFiileDocket07080022ADLSAmendNorthMeridianMedicalPavilionSignage
uuADLSADLSAl1ENDMENTAPPLICATIONArchitecturalDesignLightingLandscapingandSignageDATE101ADLSFees83400plus11100peracreADLSAMENDFeesSignonly27750plus5550signBuildingSite55600plus5550acreDOCKETNO1fOt1fI1LSYldRECEVEDUG7007nfCSReceivedDateStampADLSXADLSAmendCheckedByDPAttachedPreviousDPYesNoNameofProjectNorfhlIuldlYIjGoRVITypeofProjectuJaIIStlSkrMcaothc5I11dJsProjectAAAddressI2I9AgNTrtUId51bvao000ProjectParcelilli2J2L5QoJ2Ja12LLJ2JlpttcrW1LegalDescriptionpleaseuseseparatesheetandattachNmneofSApplicantSCIeJcJVISTr1CApplicantAddressOSOlSJTjDITAltlt20rofContactPersonYtLJjSklejryTelephone31137SI7FaxNo517Ut3EmaildicleJJre5clejSvNameofAllI0JLandownerYercfQvIlIlectcqrwtnILltTelephone57S7cOOLandownerAddressLjDIf1VlfsjvtloPbJJYTvJ4l4PIptIC2S0PlotSizeZoningClassificationE0Reiged12292006SFORMSPCAppliciltilJncurrent20Q1pcapplicationsDUfI1MEAPP200doc1
uuPresentUseofProperty111edCo01OUCAKvUlljSProposedUseofPropertyNewConstructionYesNoLNewIRevisedSignYesXNoRemodeledConstructionYesNoXNewParkingYesNoNewLandscapingYesNoLNotethatrequiredfeesaredueaftertheapplicationhasreceivedadocketnumberandnotatthetimeofapplicationsubmittalDoNOTbringapplicationfeesatthetimeofsubmittalRevised12292006SFORMSPCApplication3curre1t2007pcapplicatiQnsADLSAMENAPP2007doc2
uuParkffigNoofSpacesProvidedNoSpacesRequiredDesi2IJInformationTypeofBuildingNoofBuildingsSquareFootageHeightNoofStoriesExteriorMaterialsColorsMaximumNoofTenantsTypeofUsesWaterbySewerbyLIGHTINGTypeofFixtureHeightofFixtureNoofFixturesAdditionalLightingPlanstobesubmittedshowingFootcandlespreadsatpropertylinespertheordinanceSIGNAGENoofSignsf1vJSSIlTypeofSignsWcIITidLHSLocationsVJeSflevo85AjE4itl0esiElevbfE1JSRDimensionsofeachsign5ecJt1cJJlljSSquareFootageofeachsignl0ecElevIc1IalEatEleJ511s1TotalHeightofeachsignLIabeJrlLANDSCAPINGPlanstobesubmittedshowingplanttypessizesandlocationsItheundersignedtothebestofmyknowledgeandbeliefsubmittheaboveinformationastrueandcorrectSignatureofRevised1229201J5EOtu1SfCApplicatiotlsCUJlsnt2007pcapplicationsADLSAMENAPP2UU1doc3
IjlJelsIrlnrkIIwigIIiiiIluI15rm10J2IjtsoIOoiij21jrujI1mnfr1IiJIj1iilliiriIeItIilfIIItuIIIIIbrIiIiIIrIIiLIIlJoI11IIJJ1Ij1Itgi1IiIIIiblgIIt1IiIiJ12fjl1triIjIoJII0IIiIL1UglrrI0QCIISlSIII11eifr1IkIIIIj1IiriiiLLrLIttrkd1I1i1iiIIiiIIIIIIIj1JIiIfiiSiIJIIIltJt1ifXtVlIqlriYItr71S4I1jII1IarI11EItIIIiIlisiiIi1ihJiiIg111IIWWUU5ziw0Iu
316243101uurtJGWIlllLPage1of6OptMeridian94YzcThisrenderingisStaleySignsIncsubmittedforuseinconnectlonwiththestatedprojectDisplayDistributionorDuplicationwithoutpriorwrittenconsentisstrictlyprohibitedCUslomerLthNMdMdIPINolesauenIaneleaaVIIonPageCshownarerepresentativeonlyandarenolIntended1of6lorpurposes0exactmatchingSTALEYSIGNSINCPOBox515IndianapolisIN46206Tel3176374567Fax3172210123wwwstaleysignsloJllprojectExistingWallMountLetterOptJonInstallationMeridianStreetSideMeridianDrawn070920078yVARoemerI7RnrScale11610
Page2of6OptMeridian92164c1IcThisrenderingisClStaleySignsIncsubmittedforuseInconnectionwiththestatedprojectDisplayDistributionorDuplicationwithoutpriorwrittenconsentisstrictlyprohibitedCUomerLthNMidMdIPINotesauerIaneleaaVllonPageCshownarerepresenlalJlQonY6ndarenotlntended2of6forpurposesofexactmalchingSTALEYSIGNSINCPOBox515IndianapolisIN46206Tel3176374567Fax317221023vwslaleysigllScOInProjectExistingWallMountLetterInstallationMeridianStreetSideOptionMeridianDrawn07092007ByVARoemer17rScale111610
Page30f6OptIllinoisSq115Ft33J3411IIccSTALEYSIGNSINCPOBox515IndianapolisIN46206Tel3176374567Fax3172210123slaleysignscol11ThisrenderingisClStaleySignsIncsubmittedforuseInconnectionwiththestatedprojectDisplayDistributionorDuplicationwithoutpriorwrlttenconsentIsstrictlyprohibitedcustomerLauthNMeridianMedicalPavilionPageshownararepresentativeonlyandarenotlntendedProject3of6ferpurposesoflIxactmatchingTypicalWallMountLetterOptionInstallationIllinoisStreetSideillinoisDrawn07092007ByVARoemerO2oArScale11610
ThisrenderingisStaleySignsIncsubmittedforuseinconnectionwiththestatedprojectDisplayDistributionorDuplicationwithoutpriorwrittenconsentisstrictlyprohibitedCuSlomerLthNMdMdIP1NotesauerlIaneleaaVIIonPageCoUhownererepresentativeonlyanderenotIntended4of6forpurposes01exactmalcl1lng26620IISTALEYSIGNSINCPOBox515IndianapolisIN46206Tel3176374567Fax3172210123VSfaIcysignsCO111ProjedTypicalWallMountLetterInstallationIllinoisStreetSideDrawn07092007ByvARReviSionI0810112007VARoemerScaleoemerRevisionII0810612007VARoemerOptionllinois11610Page40f6OptIllinoisSq111Flcc
Page50f6OplIllinoisSq115esFlc1111lIirIcSTALEYSIGNSINCpOBox515IndianapolisIN46206Tel3176374567Fax3172210123WstacysignSCOIllThisrendering15StaleySignsIncsubmittedforuseinconnectionwiththestatedprojectDisplayDistributionorDuplicationwithoutpriorwrittenconsentisstrictlyprohibitedCustomerLthNMdMdIPINolesauenIaneleaaVllonPageshownarerepresenlatlYeonlyandarenotlntended5of6forPLIfPOKlIofexactmatchingProjectFullElevationViewofIllinoisStreetInstallationTypesDrewn07092007ByvRRevIsion108lll112007VARoemefoemerReVlslonII0610612007VARoemerOpUonScaleIllinois13210
off of City Center Drive and the petitioner will probably return at some point in time when
building 93 is developed and request a variance The square footage and materials are consistent
with the Ordinance
Department Comments Rachel Boone The Sign Ordinance permits one ground identification
sign per street frontage and the petitioner has two therefore the petitioner is allowed two signs
There are three entrances to this site and the petitioner was advised not to apply for a third sign
but to apply for a variance later when that portion of the site is being constructed The three
direction signs are in compliance20 square feet 4 feet tallthe design is consistent with the
entire site At this time the Department is recommending positive consideration
Note The wall signage is not being presented at this time
Susan Westermeier made formal motion to approve Docket No 07080020 ADLS Amend City
Center at Penn 122
d Street Penn as submitted seconded by Wayne Haney APPROVED
3 0
5 Docket No 07080022 ADLS Amend North Meridian Medical Pavilion Signage
The applicant seeks approval for 6 new signs The site is located at 12188 A B N Meridian St
It is zoned B 6
Filed by Doug Staley Jr of Staley Signs Inc
Doug Staley Jr Staley Signs 1133 Burdsal Parkway Indianapolis Also in attendance David
Campbell Property Division of North Meridian Medical Office Bldg The site is located at 12188
North Meridian Street A and B Buildings
The applicant is seeking approval for six new wall signs Two of the signs will be located on
Building A currently occupied The remaining four signs will be located on Building B which is
currently under construction
Note A variance will be required for the number of signs and for two signs to face a public right
ofway for both buildings The request for variance will be heard at the September BZA meeting
The signs facing Illinois Street will be 115 square feet of sign area per the Ordinance and is being
requested by the applicant The signs facing Meridian Street are 95 square feet as approved by
Variance and this is what the applicant is requesting The signs will be internally illuminated
individual channel letters with white faces The logos may not exceed 25 of the total signage
area
Department Comments Rachel Boone The Department is recommending positive consideration
of the sign package as presented
Susan Westermeier made formal motion to approve Meridian Docket No 07080022 ADLS
Amend North Medical Pavilion Signage for a 95 square foot wall sign facing Meridian Street
and 115 square foot wall sign facing Illinois Street the sign face color is white illuminated white
S P1anCommission Minutes SpecStudyCommittee PC SS Committee 2007 SS2007sept04 6
ONE CIVIC SQUARE CARMEL INDIANA 46032 317571 2417
at night and the logos may have color and illuminate with color but will not exceed 25 of the
total sign area seconded by Wayne Haney APPROVED 3 0
Note The Petitioner will be appearing at BZA on September 24 2007 for a variance relating to
the number of signs and for two of the sign to face public right ofway
6 Docket No 07080021 ADLS Amend Key Bank
The applicant seeks approval for exterior building renovations and site changes The site is
located at 501 E Carmel Dr and is zoned B8Business
Filed by Thomas Mesuk of Gensler Architecture Design and Planning Worldwide
Thomas Mesuk Architect Gensler Architecture 48 Wall Street Suite 900 New York New York 10006
architects for Key Bank Also present Christine Stanfield Key Bank
The petitioner is proposing renovations to the existing building located at 501 East Carmel Drive The
changes involve a stucco band at the top of the building new roofmg and a brick stain on the existing brick
surface Other changes involve new lighting fixtures and new signage Currently the bank has a sign
facing AAA Way and one facing Carmel Drive A third sign was proposed on the north side above the
ATM and a ground sign at the corner of East Carmel Drive and AAA Way
The color and stain of the stucco and brick were shown The existing trim around the windows the under
side of the soffit and the doors will be re painted a white color
Christine Stanfield commented that preference of Key Bank corporate is to maintain the two wall signs
such as they have currentlynot the pylon signpass on the sign at the end of the canopy for the drive
thru and reduce the size of the ATM sign to meet the requirements
Department Comments Rachel Boone The signs facing east do not face a public street or right ofway
and would not be supported by the BZA for a variance The size of the ATM is larger than permissible and
is being reduced to three square feet Either the wall sign facing Carmel Drive or the ground sign is
permissible but not both
Christine Barton Holmes commented that the petitioner is primarily up dating and cleaning the fagade
Scott Brewer has reviewed the landscape plan and the Department is recommending positive consideration
The sconce lighting is acceptable to the department
Mr Mesuk sated that the landscaping plan was primarily for the front of the entry off of AAA Way that
was to be up dated with new plantings There is not really much of an overall in regard to the existing
Wayne Haney noted that the improvements give the building more a residential look than commercial and
he was agreeable to that Are the down spouts being taken out Also the ac load will be increased with
the dark roof
Mr Mesuk responded that the down spouts will remain the three dimensional asphalt shingle will be used
and will replace the existing roof which is showing definite signs of aging
Steve Stromquist asked about the Key Bank logo displayed over the ATM and whether or not it was a
change
S P1anCommission Minutes SpecStudyCommittee PC SS Committee 2007 SS2007sept04 7
ONE CIVIC SQUARE CARMEL INDIANA 46032 317571 2417