HomeMy WebLinkAboutApplication
I~
I
'.
r'~........ ~_'.
i~ CITY OF CARMEL - CLAY TOWNSHI~
it
HAMILTON COUNTY. INDIANA
APPLICATION FOR BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS ACTION
APPEAL REQUEST
DOCKET NO.~.O'
DATE RECEIVED:
1) Applicant: Ja Lemmon Qserve Communications
Address: 4515 S. Hi h School Rd. Indiana olis IN 46241
2) Project Name: 1388 Queens Way
Engineer/Architect: Lawrence C. Suhre
Attorney: Thomas F. Bedsole. Attorney for Sprint Spectrum L.P.
Phone: (317) 237-3800
3) Applicant's Status: (Check the appropriate response)
(a) The applicant's name is on the deed to the property
(b) The applicant is the contract purchaser of the property
x (c) Other: Applicant is a tenant for the purpose of co-locatinQ a personal wireless service antenna on
existino tower.
4) If Item 3) (c) is checked, please complete the following:
Owner of the property involved: Edwin C. Zamber
Owner's address: 1388 Queens Way. Carmel. IN 46032
Phone: (317) 848-9739
5) Record of Ownership:
Deed Book No./lnstrumentNo.
9739910
Page:
Purchase date: September 22. 1997
N/A
6) Common address of the property involved: 1388 Queens Way. Carmel. IN
Legal description: See Attached Exhibit "A"
Tax Map Parcel No.: 17-13-03-00-00-028.017
7) State explanation of requested Appeal: (State what you want to do and cite the section number(s) of the
Carmel/Clay Zoning Ordinance which applies and/or creates the need for this appeal).
See Attached Exhibit "B"
8) State reasons supporting the Appeal: (Additionally, complete the attached question sheet entitled "Findings of Fact-
Appeal").
See Attached Exhibit "B"
BZA Appeal Application - pg 1
...........
9)
Present zoning of the proQ (give exact classification): S-1
D
10) Present use of the property: Residential
11 )
Size of 10Uparcel in question 6.09
acres
12) Describe the proposed use of the property Co-location of antenna on existina tower and construction of accessory
buildina.
13)
Is the property:
Owner occupied
x
Renter occupied
Other
14) Are there any restrictions, laws, covenants. variances. special uses. or appeals filed in connection with this
property that would relate or affect its use for the specific purpose of this application? If yes. give date and docket
number. decision rendered and pertinent explanation.
Appeal Request of Richard Deer filed AUQust 15. 2001. Docket Number A-97 -01
15) Has work for which this application is being filed already started? If answer is yes. give details:
Building Permit Number: 2001.0627.B - Revoked
Builder: Jay Lemmon. Qserve Communications
16) If proposed appeal is granted. when will the work commence? Immediately
17) If the proposed appeal is granted. who will operate and/or use the proposed improvement for which this application
has been filed?
Sprint Spectrum L.P.
NOTE:
LEGAL NOTICE shall be published in the Noblesville Daily Ledaer a MANDATORY twenty-five (25) days prior to
the public hearing date. The certified "Proof of Publication" affidavit for the newspaper must be available for inspection the
night of the hearing.
LEGAL NOTICE to all adjoining and abutting property owners is also MANDATORY. two methods of notice are
recommended:
1) CERTIFIED MAIL - RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED sent to adjoining property owners. (The white receipt
should be stamped by the Post Office at least twenty-five (25) days prior to the public hearing date)
2) HAND DELIVERED to adjoining and abutting property owners (A receipt signed by the adjoining and abutting
property owner acknowledging the twenty-five (25) day notice should be kept for verification that the notice was completed)
REALIZE THE BURDEN OF PROOF FOR ALL NOTICES IS THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE APPLICANT. AGAIN, THIS
TASK MUST BE COMPLETED AT LEAST TWENTY-FIVE (25) DAYS PRIOR TO PUBLIC HEARING DATE.
The applicant understands that docket numbers will not be assianed until all supportinq information has been
submitted to the Department of Community Services.
BZA Appeal Application - pg 2
-"
The applicant certifies b~\ing this application that he/she has beer-)vised that all representations of the
Department of Community Services are advisory only and that the applicant sh~ rely on appropriate subdivision and
zoning ordinance and/or the legal advice of his/her attorney.
<,
'. , Auditor of Hamilton County, Indiana, certify that the attached
affidavit is a true and complete listing of the adjoining and adjacent property owners concerning Docket No.
OWNER
ADDRESS
Auditor of Hamilton County, Indiana
Date
BZA Appeal Application - pg 3
"-
o
AFFIDAVIT
(;)
'.
I, being duly sworn depose and say that the foregoing signatures, statements and answers herein contained and
the information herewith submitted are in all respects true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief. I, the
undersigned, authorize the applicant to act on my behalf with regard to this application and subsequent hearings and
testimony. --;'~- - - - -r---;}
Signed: ~~
( ney for Sprint Spectrum~)
Thomas F. Bedsole
(Please Print)
STATE OF INDIANA
SS:
fYl II I..J oJ
(County in which notarization take place)
for ~Oli-NSDN'
../i' (Notary Public's county of residence)
7 rIoM!t5 f. 61.)~df..[.
(Property Owner, Attorney, or Power of Attorney)
County of
Before me the undersigned, a Notary Public
County, State of Indiana, personally appeared
and acknowledge the execution of the foregoing
instrument this
J.~
day of
~;;::~ ~ 0~'
Notary Public--Signature
,~,<r;~2~~t;?;/:;", ,..,
_",:- c', ..... _,4,-, ...-
~~~7"" ~ 1_' ~ ^. .....:.:c;% .'
~/_~ S L::.:. ..,r iSEi\L)'
.R""~' ~.~ .::
". ":~j:ii"~
"-:;:, ... ri.. ,
/.., /0,., ~$~~. ,$
";-~.IID',"~"~"'~ ,,,...."
"'.;' /_,,'~ r\ l" .\\,.
'<.iill/JIIII""'-
(JArtkteJ Ai.{
s
l.d 1'171
Notary. Public--Please Print
My commission expires:
jl - ~O - 09
BZA Appeal Application - pg 4
QOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE ~E
CARMEUCLA Y BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
Docket No.
Notice is hereby given that the Carmel/Clay Board of Zoning Appeals meeting on the day of
, 200 at 7:00 pm in the City Council Chamber, 2nd floor of City Hall,
One (1) Civic Square, Carmel, Indiana 46032 will hold a Public Hearing upon an Appeal of a decision rendered by the
Director of the Department of Community Services to
a;.
property being known as
The application is identified as Docket No.
The real estate affected by said application is described as follows:
(Insert Legal Description)
All interested persons desiring to present their views on the above application, either in writing or verbally, will be given
an opportunity to be heard at the above-mentioned time and place.
PETITIONERS
BZA Appeal Application - pg 5
i,
PETITI~IS AFFIDAVIT OF NOTICE OF PUBLlOARING
CARMEUCLA Y BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
I (WE)
DO HEREBY CERTIFY THAT A LEGAL
i (Petitioner's Name)
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE CARMEUCLAY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS CONSIDERING
DOCKET NUMBER
,WAS GIVEN AT LEAST TWENTY-FIVE (25) DAYS PRIOR
TO THE DATE OF THE PUBLIC HEARING TO THE BELOW LISTED OF ADJOINING AND ABUTTING PROPERTY
OWNERS:
OWNER
ADDRESS
STATE OF INDIANA
SS:
The undersigned, swear that the above information is in all respects is true and correct to the best of my
knowledge and belief.
Signature of Petitioner
County of
(County in which notarization takes place)
Before me the undersigned, a Notary Public
for
(Notary Public's county of residence)
County, State of Indiana, personally appeared
and acknowledge the execution of the foregoing instrument this
(Property Owner, Attorney, or Power of Attorney)
day of
,200
Notary Public--Signature
(SEAL)
Notary Public--Please Print
My commission expires:
BZA Appeal Application - pg 6
'/
o
o
Edwin C. Zamber
1388 Queens Way
Carmel, IN 46032
October 2,2001
..<:>~
~ \)-"~~^
i:'\I,'y- ,,/ ~
"".1' \<~.,I \
.; ~ '/'
':f 1.)r-. ~\:'\
"''l'' n 'TJ...-C,. ';: \
- u'~'1 f:/vrl) ',:'}':>\
~ Q '.-\
C '1 f-.--j
IJ. <'l1P'I ~. !
VCS Vj/'~i
/"'1
h:'" /
/\(0/
. i Tnf~)>
,..._-~
City of Carmel
Department of Community Services
1 Civic Square
Carmel, IN 46032
To Whom It May Concern:
This letter will serve as my authorization for Sprint Spectrum L.P. (including Qserve
Communications, Jay Lemmon, Locke Reynolds LLP and their successors, designees, assigns
and representatives) to pursue any and all actions that they deem necessary or appropriate in
connection with the location of Sprint Spectrum L.P.'s facilities and equipment at 1388 Queens
Way, Carmel, Indiana. This authorization includes but is not limited to the October 1,2001
filing of the Application For Board of Zoning Appeals Action Appeal Request of the Director's
decision to revoke building permit no. 2001.067.B.
Very truly yours,
~C.~
Edwin C. Zamber
533225_1
ORMEUCLA Y BOARD OF ZONING APOS
Carmel, Indiana
Docket No. :
Petitioner:
Sprint Spectrum, LP
FINDINGS OF FACT - APPEAL (Ballot Sheet)
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
DATED THIS
DAY OF
,20_.
Board Member
BZA Appeal Application - pg 7
~ )
_/ U
CARMEUCLA Y BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
CARMEL, INDIANA
Docket No.:
Petitioner:
Sprint Spectrum, LP
FINDINGS OF FACT - APPEAL
1. The Petitioner has properly followed the Appeals Procedures outlined in Ordinance Z-160, Section 30.2,
et seq.
2. Nature of action appealed from:
Revocation of Improvement Location Permit (2001.0627.B)
Agency: Department of Community Services
Date of Agency Decision: Auqust 23. 2001
3. Attached copy of Ordinance or materials which is subject of Appeal:
Section 5.0 - S-1 Residence District
Section 3.7 of the Carmel/Clav Zoninq Ordinance, entitled Definitions, specificallv the term "SUBDIVISION"
4. The written materials submitted to the Board does support the Petitioner because:
The use for which the ILP was qranted is a permitted use in the S-1 Residence district. and the lease of riqhts
to use the tower and construct an accessorv buildinq does not constitute a division of land. Therefore, the lease
arranqement does not constitute the subdivision of land.
5. The Agency (DOCS) and Official (Director) should not be affirmed.
6. The work on the premises upon which appeal has been filed shall not be stayed because the permit was properly
issued, and subdivision is not necessary.
DECISION
IT IS THEREFORE the decision of the Carmel/Clay Board of Zoning Appeals that Appeal Docket No.
is granted, subject to any conditions stated in the minutes of this Board, which are
incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof.
Adopted this
day of
,200
CHAIRPERSON, Carmel/Clay Board of Zoning Appeals
SECRETARY, Carmel/Clay Board of Zoning Appeals
S:\carmellanduseregs\checklist\appealapp rev1/24/2000
Conditions of the Board are listed on the back.
(Petitioner or his representative to sign).
BZA Appeal Application - pg 8
o
ZONING ORDINANCE
o
5.0 8-1 RESIDENCE DISTRICf
PuIl'ose and Intent. The purpose of this district is to provide for the development of
innovative residential environments in keeping with the rural character of this district, by
providing for a development process that allows a high degree of flexibility in the design
of single-family subdivisions. Further, it is the purpose of this district to provide for a
development process that allows for more efficient use of the land through the
introduction of open space and conservation lands within subdivisions. It is the intention
of this district to protect remaining significant natural features within this district by
placing an emphasis on less intensive urban land uses.
5.1 Pennitted Uses:
5.1.1 Antenna, if conocated on an existing or previously approved tower
Home occupation
Kenne~ residential
Single-family dwelling
5.1.2 Area Density Requirements for qualifying subdivisions shall be regulated on a
sliding scale based upon the amount of open space provided. (see subdivision
regulations, section 7.0)
5.2 Special Uses: (See Section 21.0 for additional regulations.)
Antenna, if visually integrated with or camouflaged on or within a structure other than a
tower (such as a chiinney stack, church spire, light standard, monument, power line
support device or water tower).
Artificla1lake or pond (not part of a plat)
Cemetery
Church, temple or other place of worship
College or University
Commercial greenhouse
Country club
Day nursery
Golf course
Kenne~ commercial
Kindergarten
Mineral extraction, borrow pit, top soil removal and their storage
Plant nursery
Power transmission line, in excess of 129 KV A
Private airplane or helicopter landing and/or service facility
34
ZONING ORDINANCE
u
o
".
Private recreational development or facility
Private water treatment and/or storage facilities
Radio or television transmission tower
Raising and breeding of non-farm fowl and animals (not a kennel)
Riding stable
School of general elementary or secondary education (accredited by the State)
5.2.1 Minimum Area Requirements:
~
Cemetery
Day nursery
Kindergarten
Plant nursery
Minimum Area (Acres)
30
1
1
10
5.2.2 Other Requirements:
Use
Mineral extraction,
borrow pit, top soil
Removal and their storage
Other Requirements
Minimum perimeter Natural Open
Space buffer (as defined in 7.3.B of
the Subdivision Regulations) of300'
when adjoining or abutting any
residential use or district
5.2.3 Special Ex.ons (see Section 21.0 for additional regulations)
WlI"eless telecommunications service tower, monopole-type construction only
5.3 Accessory Building and Uses (See Section 25.0 for additional regulations.)
5.3.1 Accessory uses and structures. are permitted under the following conditions:
(1) They do not alter or change the character of the premises;
,(2) They are on the same property as the principal structure to which they are
accessory;
(31 They are not attached to the principal structure, with the exception of an
allowable unifonn and continuous roof supported by customary supports or
joists, and no other connection or attachment between the structures exists;
(4) They are not erected prior to the erection of the principal building;
(5) They do not exceed eighteen (18) feet in height;
(6) When detached from the principal building, they are set back seventy-five
(75) feet or more from the front lot line. Comer lots and through lots are
exempt from this paragraph 6.
35
ZONING ORDINANCE
o
o
.,
(7) When closer than ten (10) feet to main building, they shall be considered as
part of the main building and shall be provided with the side and rear yards
required for the main building; and
(8) When more than ten (to) feet from a main building, they may be erected
within five (5) feet, or easement plus three (3) feet, of a side or rear lot line,
but not within any easement.
5.3.2 A private swimming pool may be permitted as an accessory use, but shall be
located only within the side or rear yard.. No swimming pool or its deck shall be
closer than ten (10) feet to the property line. For purposes for safety, the
following shall apply:
(1) walls or fencing deemed to be impenetrable by the enforcing authority, that
is not less than five (5) feet high completely surrounding the swimIning
pool and the deck area with exception of self-closing and latching gates
and doors, both capable of being locked; other means not less than five (5)
feet high and deemed impenetrable by the enforcing authority at the time of
construction and completely surrounding the pool and deck area when the
pool is not used; and
(2) a combination of subdivisions (1) through (2) that completely surrounds
the pool and deck with the exception of self-closing and latching gates and
doors which are capable of being locked; and
(3) in conjunction with (1), (2), or (3) a safety pool cover may be used
provided that:
A there is a continuoUs connection between the cover and the deck, so as
to prohibit access to the pool when the cover is completely drawn over
the pool;
. B. it is mechanically operated by key or key and switch such that the
cover cannot be drawn upon or retracted without the use of a key;
c. it is capable of supporting a four hundred pound imposed load upon a
completely drawn cover,
D. it is installed with a track, rollers, rasiIs or guides; and
E. bears an identification tag indicating the name of the manufacturer,
name of the installer, installation date, and applicable safety standards,
if any. AMENDED BY Z-261 & Z-272.
5.3 .3 Tennis courts may be pennitted as an accessory use but shall be located only
within a side or rear yard. Open wire mesh fences surrounding tennis courts
may be erected to a height of 16 feet if such fences only enclose a regulation
court area and standard apron areas. Lighting of the court area shall not create
more than five foot candles of light 25 feet from the court perimeter.
5.3.4 Quarters for bonafied servants employed by the occupants of
the dwelling are permitted.
36
ZONING ORDINANCE
o
o
"
5.3.5 One guest house with cooking facilities may be permitted as an accessory
building on lots containing not less than one (I) acre.
5.3.6 Accessory lighting is permitted; however, no lighting shall cause illumination at
or beyond any lot line in excess of 0.1 foot-candles of light. .
5.3.7 Private radio, television reception and transmitting towers and antennae are
permitted subject to applicable local, state and federal regulations. No
structure shall be located or permitted within ten (10) feet of a power
transmission line.
5.3.8 Accessory uses such as public utility installations, private walks, driveways,
retaining walls, mail boxes, nameplates, lamp posts, birdbaths and structl1res
of a like nature are permitted in any required front, side or rear yard.
5.4 Height and Area Req}lirements (See Section 26.0 for additional regulations.)
5.4.1 Maximum height: 25 feet.
5.4.2 Minimum lot area:
A Lots without service by a community water system and a community sanitary
sewer system, 43,560 square feet.
B. Lots with service from a community water system, and private septic system,
35,000 square feet.
C. Lots with service from a community sanitary sewer system and private water
system, 25,000 square feet.
D. Lots with community water system and community sanitary sewer system
15,000 square feet.
5.4.3 Minimum Lot Standards.
A Minimum front yard: 40 feet.
B. Minimum side yard: single-family home - 10 feet;
all other uses - 20 feet.
C. Minimum aggregate of side yard: single-family home - 30 feet;
all other uses - 50 feet.
37
ZONING ORDINANCE
Q
(;)
"
D. Minimum rear yard: single-family home - 20 feet;
all other uses - 15 feet.
E. Minimum lot width: single-family home - 120 feet;
all other uses - 200 feet.
F. Maximum lot coverage: 35 percent oflot.
5.4.4 Any lot within a qualifying subdivision, as described in Chapter 7.0 of the
subdivision regulations, is exempt from the requirements of sections 5.4.2 and
5.4.3.
38
o
D
~,
.
PLo\T
ROADWAY WIDTH
ROW HOUSE OR TO'N"'N HOUSE
SorL ~"L-\P
STREET
SUB 0 [\tlSION
TYPE OF OWNERSHIP
TYPE OF STRUCTURE
vlSrON CLEA.R..-\NCE ON CON'RNER LOTS
ZERO LOT LINE"
C. Section 3.i of me CarmeVClay Zoning Ordinance (2-239), as amended, e~rided Dennitions, is
hereby further amended to change the definition of the tenn "StTBDMSION'. to read as follows:
"S lJBDIVIS ION. Any of the following shall be considered the subdivision orland requiring plat
approval by the Plan Commission:
(1) The division of any parcel of land (recorded after January 21,1980, and before
January 1,2000) into three (3) or more parcels. sites or lots. ,"'hen more than cwo
(2) of the lots are less than five (5) acres in area, for the purpose of crans fer of
ownership. or building development. excluding cemeteries; or
(2) The improvement (before January 1,2000) of one (1) or more ~arcels of land for
residential. commercial or industrial structUres or groups of str":lcrures involving c..'1e
subdivision and allocation of land as streets or other open spaces for common use
by owners. occupants or tease holders or as easements for the ex:ension and
maintenance of public se'.ver, water, storm drainage, or other pt:Jlic utilities and
facilities: or
(3) .-\ny division (recorded after December 31. 1999) of a lot or otr.er parcel or land
\vhere: (.-\.) the division results in two (2) or more smaller lors or parcels. at least
(Wo (2) orwhich are less than ave t5) ac:'es in area; (B) the division results in cwo
(2) or more smaller lors or parcels. any of which from on or utilize an e:l.Sement of
access; or (e) the division is for the purpose ofbuilding deve!c~mem (excluding
cemeteries) and a street is ro be dedicJced. reserved, or other..v13e platted.
All diVIsions ot" land recorded 3.~er a certain c::.re. :l.S specified in this ce:inition. from a lor
or other parcel of land described on or before (hat date in the records O~. :~e Hamiiton
County Recorder shall be counted in determinir.g the number 0 f lots or ?ucels for the
purpose of this derlnition. The original loc or parcel shall also be cOLm:ed for this purpose.
D. Section 3 orthe Floodplain Ordinar.ce (Z-237).:.1s ~mended. is here~y iur:::er :lmended to
include the following subparag:-1;Jh (hl:
Ordinance ::\0.
?~ge Three or' S.:...en P:lges
u
u
EXHIBIT A
Legal Description
A PART OF mE NORTHWEST QUARTER OF SECTION 3, TOWNSHIP 17 NORTH OF
RANGE 3 EAST IN HAMIL TON COUNTY, INDIANA, BEING MORE P ARTICULARL Y
DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:
BEGINNING AT A POINT ON mE WEST LINE OF SAID QUARTER SECTION WHICH
BEARS NORTII 00 DEGREES 09 MINUTES 55 SECTIONS EAST (ASSUMED BEARING)
470.00 FEET FROM mE SOUTIIWEST CORNER OF SAID QUARTER SECTION, THENCE
NORTH 00 DEGREES 09 MINUTES 55 SECONDS EAST UPON AND ALONG SAID WEST
LINE 509.93 FEET TO A POINT WHICH BEARS soum 00 DEGREES 09 MINUTES 55
SECONDS WEST 1605 FEET FROM mE NORTIIWEST QUARTER OF SAID QUARTER
SECTION, TIIENCE SOUTH 89 DEGREES 50 MINUTES 05 SECONDS EAST 520.38 FEET,
THENCE SOUTH 00 DEGREES 09 MINUTES 55 SECONDS WEST 509.93 FEET, THENCE
NORTH 89 DEGREES 50 MINUTES 05 SECONDS WEST 520.38 FEET TO THE PLACE OF
BEGINNING, CONTAINING 6.09 ACRES, MORE OR LESS (5.57 ACRES NET OF RIGHT OF
WAY)
r
u
u
EXHIBIT B
IN THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
CITY OF CARMEL, INDIANA
SPRINT SPECTRUM L.P.
Appellant,
Re: Revocation of Building Permit
Number 2001.0627.B by MICHAEL P.
HOLLIBAUGH, in his Capacity as
DIRECTOR OF THE DEPARTMENT
OF COMMUNITY SERVICES,
CARMEL, INDIANA,
) Docket No.
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
APPEAL
Appellant, Sprint Spectrum L.P. (hereinafter "Sprint") by counsel, and for its Appeal of
the revocation of its location improvement permit by Michael P. Hollibaugh, in his capacity as
Director ("Director") of the Department of Community Services (the "Department"), Carmel,
Indiana, and any other applicable capacity, states as follows:
SUMMARY OF THE CASE
This Appeal arises out of the Director's decision to revoke an improvement location
permit (the "Building Permit") for property located at 1388 Queens Way, Carmel, Indiana (the
"Site"). The Building Permit permits the collocation (i.e., the installation and operation) by
Sprint of certain wireless communication antennae and related improvements and equipment
(collectively, the "Sprint Antenna Equipment") on an existing 135 foot tall antenna tower
property (the "Existing Tower"). The collocation of the Sprint Antenna Equipment on the
Existing Tower is necessary to provide seamless, reliable wireless telephone and other
V3 - APPEAL OF REVOCA nON OF LOCA nON IMPROVEMENT PERMIT TO CARMEL ZONING BOARO.DOC
u
o
communication services to persons located in parts of the City of Carmel and environs. The
Director's purported revocation of the Building Permit was arbitrary, capricious, illegal, unjust,
impermissible and contrary to applicable law. Pursuant to the Carmel/Clay Zoning Ordinance
(the "Carmel Code"), the Director's actions entitle Sprint to, inter alia, an order reversing and
nullifying the Director's attempted revocation of the Building Permit.
PARTIES
1. Sprint Spectrum L.P. is a Delaware limited partnership, with its principal place of
business at 2300 Shawnee Mission Parkway, Westwood, Kansas, authorized to provide personal
communications services ("PCS") under license by the Federal Communications Commission
("FCC") in the State of Indiana.
2. Michael P. Hollibaugh is the Director of the Department and, in that capacity, is
responsible for issuing building permits in the City of Carmel, Indiana.
YJ - APPEAL OF RE\'OCA TlON OF LOCATION IMPROVEMENT PERMIT TO CARMEL 10NING BOARD.DOC
((v
o
o
JURISDICTION
3. Section 30.1 of the Carmel Code authorizes this Board of Zoning Appeals to hear,
review and determine appeals taken from any order, requirement, decision or determination
made by the Director or any administrative official or board charged with the enforcement of the
Zoning or Subdivision Control Ordinance of the City of Carmel.
4. The Board of Zoning Appeals has jurisdiction to hear and determine this Appeal
pursuant to Section 30.1 of the Carmel Code since this Appeal stems from the order,
requirement, decision and determination by the Director to revoke the Building Permit.
BACKGROUND FACTS
A. Sprint's PCS System
5. Sprint, along with its affiliates, is a communications venture committed to
providing a single integrated offering of wireless telephone and other communications services
by building a national wireless network using PCS technology under the brand name "Sprint
PCS." PCS technology is a new generation of wireless service that uses digital transmission to
improve available telecommunications services. It provides a clearer connection, greater
security to users and better accommodates the requirements of internet and other data
transmission. Moreover, PCS technology has substantially greater potential capacity than analog
wireless technology.
6. On or about June 23, 1995, Sprint, through a partnership, was the successful
bidder at the auction held by the FCC for a PCS wireless broadcast license in the Indianapolis
V) . APPEAL OF REVOCA nON OF LOCA nON IMPROVEMENT PERMIT TO CARMEL 30NING BOARD. DOC
, .\
\.:.j
o
o
Major Trading Area ("Indianapolis MTA") which includes Carmel, Indiana. Sprint's
Indianapolis MTA license expires on June 23, 2005.
7. In order to meet its continuing obligations under the FCC license and to serve its
customer base, Sprint must develop and maintain a system of "cell sites" to serve portable
wireless communication handsets and mobile telephones. These "cell sites" consist of antennae
mounted on poles, buildings or other structures, connected to small equipment cabinets located
near the antennae. The antennae feed the low power radio signals received from mobile
communications devices through electronic devices located in the equipment cabinets and,
ultimately, into an ordinary phone line from which the call can be routed to anywhere in the
world.
8. Cell sites are integral to Sprint's PCS network. To maintain effective,
uninterrupted service to a PCS telephone user traveling in a given area, there must be a
continuous interconnected series of cells, which overlap in a grid pattern approximating a
honeycomb. Additionally, each cell site must be located within a limited area so that it can
properly interact with the surrounding cell sites and thereby provide reliable coverage throughout
the cell. Each antenna has a limited maximum coverage area, the extent of which varies,
depending upon several factors, including the height of the antenna, local topography and
vegetation, and the configuration of various existing structures.
9. Sprint's engineers have determined that the Site is critical to the overall
engineering and technical plan of Sprint's network in the Indianapolis MT A.
B. The Site Development Process
V3 - APPEAL OF REVOCATION OF LOCATION IMPROVEMENT PERMIT TO CARMEL40NING BOARD.DOC
o
Q
10. On or about May 14,2001, Sprint entered into a lease agreement with Edwin
Zamber to install and operate a PCS antenna array and related equipment on the existing
approximately 135 foot tall antenna located on the Site. Sprint has determined that if it had not
been able to collocate on the Existing Tower, no other suitable existing towers or structures were
available within its requisite search area, and that Sprint therefore would have had to build its
own tower support structure to meet its coverage requirements.
11. The Property is zoned "S-l Residence District" pursuant to Section 10-30 of the
Carmel Code. Collocation of an antenna facility on an existing tower facility is a "permitted
use" in the S-l Residence District pursuant to Section 1O-30(b) of the Carmel Code.
12. On or about February 22, 2001, a contractor for Sprint contacted the Department
to discuss the Sprint Antenna Equipment. In connection with those discussions, the Department
staff acknowledged that the Sprint Antenna Equipment was a permitted use, and requested that
Sprint house its ground level equipment in a brick clad equipment shelter (the "Shelter"). A
separate shelter is not needed by Sprint for installation or operation of the antenna, and Sprint's
ground-level PCS equipment could have been housed in, among other things, equipment cabinets
or in the basement ofMr. Zamber's home. The Shelter's architecture and style duplicates the
design and character of the existing home and pool house, and it meets all applicable zoning
requirements, including height and setback. As a part of the approved plans and specifications,
Sprint agreed to landscape the area surrounding the Shelter.
13. The Shelter is permitted as part of a collocation pursuant to Section 1 0-30(b) of
the Carmel Code.
V3 - APPEAL OF REVOCATION OF LOCATION IMPROVEMENT PERMIT TO CARMEL 30NING BOARD DOC
c~ ~ ~:\
o
(.)
14. On or about April 17, 2001, Sprint, through Acquisition Mercenaries, Inc., its
~
contractor, made application with the Department for the Building Permit. On or about June 4,
2001, Sprint submitted revised plans for the Building Permit application to include the Shelter
requested by the Department's staff.
15. On or about June 15,2001, the Department issued the Building Permit for the
Sprint Antenna Equipment. The Building Permit bears identification number 2001.0627.B
(Copy attached hereto as Exhibit 1).
16. On or about July 9, 2001, Sprint engaged Q Serve Communications ("Q Serve")
as the general contractor for the installation of the Sprint Antenna Equipment.
17. On or about August 6,2001, Q Serve began construction pursuant to the Building
Permit. The Shelter's foundation and all four block walls have been constructed. The brick
veneer of the Shelter is partially complete and other necessary building materials have been
delivered to the Site.
18. On or about August 15,2001, an owner of property adjacent to the Site filed an
application for an appeals action with the Board of Zoning Appeals objecting to the issuance of
the Building Permit.
19. On or about August 15,2001, Jeff Kendall, Building Commissioner for Carmel
issued a stop work order on the project.
20. Without notice or hearing, on or about August 23,2001, the Director sent Q Serve
a one-page letter revoking Sprint's Building Permit. (Copy attached as Exhibit 2) (the
VJ - APPEAL OF REVOCA nON OF LOCA nON IMPROVEMENT PERMIT TO CARMEL60NlNG BOARD. DOC
"'J)
\"-"'.
u
v
;.
"Revocation Letter"). The Revocation Letter sets forth but one basis for the purported
revocation:
This office has determined that, prior to the issuance of a
permit for the proposed "Equipment Shelter" on the "Lease Area"
(as described in your Application for Improvement Location
Permit), the "Parent Tract" should have been divided into two (2)
or smaller parcels. Under Chapter 3 of the Carmel Clay Zoning
Ordinance, this constitutes the subdivision of land requiring plat
approval by the Plan Commission.
At no time prior to its receipt of the Revocation Letter had Sprint been informed of any alleged
need for plat approval by the Plan Commission.
21. Sprint has incurred over $400,000 in site development expenses through the date
of the Revocation Letter.
22. The Revocation Letter prohibits Sprint from operating a facility necessary to its
provision of continuous and uninterrupted wireless communications services and, therefore,
Sprint cannot carry out its federally-imposed obligation to provide such services to the
Indianapolis MT A under its licenses. The FCC granted Sprint the licenses to provide PCS
service intending and requiring that such service would be in place as soon as possible. The
permit denial has adversely impacted Sprint's ability to fulfill this Federal goal. In addition, the
Revocation Letter has caused Sprint to suffer a loss of consumer goodwill and critical market
share. This results in a competitive disadvantage which Sprint might not be able to overcome.
CLAIM FOR RELIEF
23. Without waiving or otherwise limiting any other claims or causes of action
available to it, Sprint hereby states and avers that each of the following bases, in and of itself and
without regard to any other basis, compels the reversal of the Director's determination,
VJ - APPEAL OF REVOCATION OF LOCATION IMPROVEMENT PERMIT TO CARMEL 10NING BOARD.DOC
, /)
'.. -
o
o
,.
requirement, decision and order under the Revocation Letter and the declaration that the
Revocation Letter is null and void.
A. The Director's Revocation of the Building Permit is Not Permitted Under the
Carmel Code
24. Indiana state law empowers Indiana municipalities to exercise certain powers
concerning the subdivision of real property. That power is not unlimited, but is subject to the
terms and conditions respecting the same imposed by the laws of the state of Indiana and such
further limitations as may be imposed under applicable local ordinance. The Sprint Antenna
Equipment is not the type of facility which falls within the ambit of applicable subdivision
control law, and the purposes and intents of such regulation would not be furthered in this
context
25. Under applicable local ordinance, no "division" has occurred relative to the Sprint
Antenna Equipment, hence the City has no right, power or authority to impose its subdivision
control ordinances with respect thereto.
26. Even if that were not the case, subdivision control authority does not extend to
utility facilities.
27. The specific provisions of the Carmel Code which explicitly authorize the
collocation of the Sprint Antenna Equipment trump any conflicting provisions of general
applicability.
28. Under the Carmel Code, neither the Director, nor any other board or official, has
the right to issue the Revocation Letter or to attempt to revoke otherwise the Building Permit.
Vl _ APPEAL OF REVOCATION OF LOCATION IMPROVEMENT PERMIT TO CARMELgONING BOARD. DOC
(:,~ \
\.... _" ~e-/'
..
u
o
"
29. Since the sole basis for the revocation of the Building Permit is the alleged failure
-'
to obtain subdivision approval, but no subdivision approval is required under applicable local
ordinance relative to the Sprint Antenna Equipment, the Revocation Letter was without legal
basis, and must be reversed.
B. Other Claims
30. The Sprint Antenna Equipment and the Building Permit are also subject to other
federal and state laws which are not within the purview of the Board of Zoning Appeals.
31. A failure by the Board to reverse and revoke the Revocation Letter or to issue any
other relief herein requested may entitle Sprint to pursue any and all such additional claims,
causes of action and forms of relief. Sprint expressly reserves all of its claims, causes of action
and other rights.
WHEREFORE, Sprint prays that the Board enter an order approving this Appeal and
reversing the Revocation Letter, thereby declaring the same null and void, and for such other and
further relief as the Board deems appropriate. Please furnish to the undersigned copies of all
reasons relating to your decision.
Respectfully submitted,
LOCKE REYNOLDS LLP
BY'~
. Tho edsole-, in 5980-49
Attorney for Plaintiff,
Sprint Spectrum L.P.
LOCKE REYNOLDS LLP
201 North Illinois Street, Suite 1000
V3 . APPEAL OF REVOCATION OF LOCATION IMPROVEMENT PERMIT TO CARMEL~ONlNG BOARD.DOC
!' ; '\- ~)
\..';'- /
,"
II
u
P.O. Box 44961
Indianapolis, Indiana 46244-0961
Phone: (317) 237-3800
Fax: (317) 237-3900
VJ - APPEAL OF REVOCATION OF LOCATION IMPROVEMENT PERMIT TO CARME4.WN1NG BOARDDOC
Q
(")
~j
~ _ Jun 15 01 01:08p
o
31705 8224
tN)I.{...tt..}.:ll 7A~t:1f
p.2
CITY OF CARMEUCLA Y TOWNSHIP
BUILDING PERMIT
LOT NO.
Type of Construction: OTHER
Type of Improvement: CELLTOW
APPROVAL STAMP
..
~~
RElEASEO FOR CONSlRUcnON subjecf
10 compUance with aD Regulations of
state and local Codes DEPT OF
COMMUNJ'IY SERVICES CIIY OF
CARMEL I etA. y TOWNSHIP INDIANA
PERMIT NO. 2001.0627.B
DATE: 06115/2001
CONTRACl'OR :JAY LEMMON, Q SERVE COMMUNICATIONS
TENANT:
OWNER: EDWIN C & DONNA B ZAMBER
SITE ADDRESS: 1388 QUEENS WY
SUBDIVISION:
ZONING: -
POST: l\IIUST BE VISffiLE FROM STREET
This Building Permit must be posted with this side visible from the street prior to
inspections and must stay posted until ALL inspections have been approved. ANY
. FAILURE TO COMPLY WILL RESULT IN A REFUSAL OF INSPECTION.
NOTICE
THIS CONSTRUCTION
The Carmel \ Clay Zoning Onlinance provides for a penalty
:my construction is continued wit!out having any one of the
following inspections scheduled, perfonncd. and approved.
IS NOT APPROVED
FOR OCCUPANCY
This penalty will be based on the fee sttucture in Ordinance
Z-289, 1993.
This oenaltv also applies to any constmction that is found to
be occupied before a Certificate of Occupancy is issued.
This is to certify that a buDding permit bas been issUed on this project\building iD accordance with the OrdiDances or
the City of Carmel\Oay Township.
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES
- BUILDING PERMITS DIVISION
1 Civic Square
Carmel, IN 46032
(317) 571-2444
EXHIBIT
I 1
Jun 15 01 01:09p
Q
31705 8224
p.3
o ALL PERMITS ISSUED WILL REQUIRE ONE OR :MORE OF THE INSPECTIONS SHOWN
r, BELOW:
o To schedule, ClIll571-2444 or 2475; footings and underslab call 571-2449
o Refer to inspectWn procedure sheet for detlIiIs on scheduling
Date FOOTINGS
o Approved 0 Not Approved
..
".-.
Date UNDERSLAB ~.
OnsoectiOD is for enet'I!V & 'Ore-nom nre'Oaration)
D Approved 0 Not Approved
Date ROUGH-IN
D Approved 0 Not Approved
o Approved 0 Not Approved
o Approved 0 Not Approved
Date BONDING & GROUNDING
o Approved 0 N~t Approve.d
. -
Date METER BASE
o Approved 0 Not Approved
Date FINAL
(Furniture or product constitutes occupied. See warDing below)
o Approved 0 Not Approved
o APIFved 0 Not Approved
o Approved 0 Not Approved
o Temporary C/O
Date' FIRE DEPT. INSPECTION (571-2600)
(Commercial only)
: DApproved 0 Not Approved
WARNING
No building/strUcture or portion thereof shall be used or occupied until ALL provisions of the codes have been complied with
and the structure has been approved foroccnpancy. Occupancy prior to issuance of the Certificate of Occupancy is prohibited
per section 29.4.3 of the Carmel/Clay Zoning Ordinance, Carmel City Code, Chapter 7-20; Section 307 of the General
Administrative Rules of the Indiana Fire Prevention and Building Safety Commission, and Section 308 of the Unifonn
Building Code.
DEPARTMENT OF CONINIUNITY SERVICES
()np r;vit' ~ml~TP r~TmPl ThJ L1hl\~,)
. Jun 15 01 01:0Sp
Q
31705 8224
p.4
INSPECTION PROCEDURES
.;
All construction must follow FEDERAL. STATE, and LOCAL CODFS, which include:
1. Indiana Building Code -1998
2. Indiana One & Two Family Dwelling Code -1997
3. Indiana Plumbing-Code 1991
4. Indiana Mechanical Code 1998
5. Indiana Electric Code - 1997
6. Carmel! Oay Zoning Ordinances -1980
7. Indiana Swimming Pool Code -1989
8. JndiaIUl Energy Conservation Code -1993
A MINIMUM OF 24-HOUR NOTICE IS REQUIRED IN SCHEDULIN~ ~ INSPEcnqNS EXCEPT
FOOTINGS AND UNDERSLAB. For footing aT underslab, call 571-2449 between 8:00 a.m. and 9:00 a.m. fOT same
day inspecti01L Pool but7ders may also use the 'rooting line" to schedule bonding inspections. ALL O'I'HER
inspections must be scheduled 24 hams in advance: 571-2444. . .~'>
'.. . ..
The owner or their representative, in the case of additions, remodels, etc., must provide entry.
The following inspections are required with your Building Permit
FOOTINGS: Same day scheduling...{571-2449). This must be done between 8:00 a.m. and 9:00 a.m. Have
ready: Permit number and the time you need the inspection!
A. Inspection is to be made before you pour.
B. Grade stakes are required to be installed.
C. All water pumped out and scraped dean to solid ground.
D. Double check yom site distance requirements & setbacks to property lines.
E. Make sure you are behind the building line.
UNDERSLAB: IISlabs on Graden. SaI;\e day scheduling...571-2449 between 8:00 a.m. and 9:00 am.j again, have
permit number and the time you need the inspection ready! (INSPECTION IS TO BE MADE BEFORE YOU POUR!)
A At this time the insulation shall be installed in any approved configuration for a total combined length of
48". FOI details, refer to the Indiana Energy Conservation Code 1993. . -'
B. The IIVapor BarrierD must also be installed at this time.
C. Pea gra'lJel should be in place.
ROUGH..;IN: 24-hour notice is required on all inspections beginning at this stage of construction: 571-2444.
A DO NOT INSULATE BEFORE ROUGH-IN
B. The Building Permit shall be located in a front window, with lot num.ber facing the street. In the case of
porch and additions. remodels. etc.. permit should be placed where it can be easilv reached
C. BUTI..DING PEIDvnTS !vIDST BE POSTED OR TIlE INSPECTION WILL NOT BE PERFORM:ED, AND A
RE-INSPECTION FEE WILL BE CHARGED.
D. Rough-In of electrical wiring, plumbing, and HV AC required at this pOint.
E. Structure is to be weather tight..windows and doors in, roofing shingles on. ~
F. All draft stops & fireblocking to be installed.
PLEASE NOTE: A Do Not Occupy sticker will be posted at the time of the rough-in inspection. This must not be
removed tmtil a Certificate of Occupanc:;y has been issued from the Dept. of Community Services, Cannel. IN. This
notice does not indicate a problem with construction, only that a Cj 0 has not yet been issued, therefore, it cannot
be occupied.
METER BASE:
A Grounding is required for customers service ~trance equipment. Grounding shall be in accordance:with.
the provisions of the National Electrical Code.
B. A ground connection for customer1s service equipment shall not be made in or on the meter mounting
device for Public Service Indiana.
C Conduit to meter base mUst be 2" rigid steel, or Schedule 80 PVC and must extend 18" minimum below
grade. Schedule 40 is NOT permitted.
D. When this inspection has been approved. a green meter tag, marked approved bv our inspector. will be
placed inside the meter itself; at that time, the appropriate Utility can be scheduled.
#
Jun 15 01 C1:0Sp
Q
317 Os 8224
p.s
FINAL RESIDENTIAL: PERMIT MUST REMAIN POSTED OR r.dIS INSPECTION CANNOT BE PERFORJ.VIED.
A. All electrical plumbing, and mec..l-wrlca1 work, as well as any items that are determined to be in the interest of
public safety and welfare shall be 100% complete prior to approval of final inspection or issuance or a Certificate
of Occupancy. .
B. Final grading, rear and side swales shall be completed prior to final, nweather permitting. n .
C. After final inspection is performed; a minimum of 24 hours is required before a Certificate of Occupancv will be
issued..
FINAL COMMEROAL 1", pfJ A ~ L() rt~ SCOt!- Bre..w qr.-D.ar 5; f <to i Y1 ~~b I
Must first contact the 1VG ~g1fke (S7l-266a}-cu.ld schedule a final Inspectidn..!J After we have the Fire e
Inspector's approval that all fire and safety codes are in compliance, then the Contractor needs to contact D.O.C.S.
to schedlf1e a site inspection to ensure all plans were followed per Plan Commission approval, weather ~t#ng. ~
At that time the Building Inspector shall conduct a Final inspection, and if approved, a Certificate or Occu~
issued PRIOR to any occupancy of the structure or any Tenant Space.
AN ADOmONAL FEE WILL BE CHARGED fOR. ANY INSPECTION THAT R.EQUIRES MORE THAN ONE TRIP FROM
THE BUILDING INSPECTOR. $SO.OO FOR RESIDENTIAL $90.00 FOR COMMERCIAL PAYABLE BEFORE FURTHER
INSPECI10NS wnL BE SCHEDULED. .
NOTICE
The Carmel Zoning Ordinance provides for a penalty if any construction is continued without having anyone of
the above inspections scheduled, performed, and approved. This TJenalty will be based on the LATE FEES established
with the fee stnlctuTe: established in Ordi7UZ1tce Z-289. Section 29.6.8. "Late Fees on Inspections". This penalty also armlies to I
any construction that is fuund to be occupied before a Certificate of Occupancy is issued.
.
CARMEL ZONING ORDINANCE,SECllON 29.4.3(1): No land shall be occupied or used and no building hereafter
erected, reconstructed or st:rw:turaIly altered shall be occupied or used. in whole or in part, for any pUl'pose whatsoever,
until a Certificate of OCCl1pancy shall have been issued by the Building Commissioner (Dept. of Community Services
Director) stating that the building and use comply with an of the provisions of this Ordinance applicable to the building,
premises or the use in the distrid in which it is to be located.
~!A~~!A4AAAAA.~A!AA4AA~AA44~AA~lAA~AAAA!A!A~AA4~AAAAA4AAAAAAA414AA4AAAA~AAAA4AA4AAAAA4AAA44lAL14AAAAAA4AA4AIAAAAAi~AAJA4!AAAA~AAA4A~4A~
CITY ENGINEER POLICY SUMP PUMP WATER DISCHARGE OunETS
. It shall be the responsibility of the builder to provide for an adequate discharge outlet for a sump pump.
* If a subsurface storm water drainage system is available (adjacent) to the building site, the sump pump shall
discharge via a pipe to this system. This must be shown on the submitted site plans in detail and the Cannel City
Engineer must inspect the connections.
* If a flowing stream is available (adjacent) to the building site, the sump pump shall discharge directly to this
stream. This must be shown on the site plan in detail.
* If no other way exists for discharge, the sump pump pipe outlet shall be located in an area between the back wall
of the house and the middle of the rear yaxd. In no circumstance shall the sump pump outlet be closer than
twenty-five feet, zero inches (25'00) to the easement of the storm water swale or to the J'lOJ'erty line. 'This location
. shall be shown on the site plan in detail. ..
PER THE CITY UI'ILITIES, GEOTIIERMAL HEAT PUMP WATER DISCHARGE OUTLEr
1. The Oty Utilities MUST be notified of any type of well.
2. IntemaI. back flow devices are required on all wells.
It shall be the responsibility of the builder or property owner to provide for an adequate discharge outlet
for geothermal heat pumps.
* It is highly recommended that a closed loop syste:J;n for a geothermal heat pump be used in Carmel and Oay
fu~~. _.
· Injection wells are not recommended for use in Carmel/ Oay Township. Special permission from the Cit)' of
Carmel must be obtained if this is the only system that can be used. Contact the Water Department (571-2.442) for
additional information.
* If a water discharge outlet is proposed for the geothermal heat pump system, it must outlet directly by pipe into
either a flowing stream, storm water system or a subsuxface storm drainage tile system. The cormection must be
inspected by the Carmel City Engineer and must be shown in detail on the site or plot plan. If the sump pump or
geoth~ heat PumP is to dis~ge into a Co~ty regulated clxainageway, it will need to tie directly into a
Jun 15 01 01:10p
III
, Ca.rmeJ-Ctay
....,t"
Township
Q
3170
8224 p.6
--1 "" -; (\ \
Pe:mitNo. ..!l.'}.. j I J 1
Date
Roll File
'.~
Application for
Improvement Location Pennit
NAME
PJIONB
fAX
BUILDER
Jay ~, Q Serve QoJrmJmI-.tioDs
(317) 856-1694
(317) 856-0198
STIlEEJ' .'
OTY
STA'l'Ii
TENANT NAME
if licable}
fIPK~..~cmol lad, InUANlJ?Olls,
r
Sprint Speet:rim, IP, d/b/a Sprint PeS
IN
ZIP
46241
..
...
OWNER
NAMS
!l:1win C. Zambez:'
PHONE
(317) 848-9739
fAX
'.
".. ~..
C'm?" 1
sa:nOIt
Sl'REEl'
1388 Qt:Bens Way,
en
LOT
SOBDlVlSlON
LOCATION
See attached
ADDRESS OF CDHSTItucnON
1388 QlBmS Way, C;u-rnA'l, Irdiana
A. TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION Do plans include a porch? F. TYPE OF IMl'ROVEMENT
1. 0 Single Family 0 Yes 0 No L 0 New Structure
2. [] Two Family 2. D. Addition: Porch Room
3. [J Multi-Family Type of Foundation 3. D Remodel 0 Commercial Tenant Space
4. [] Co~ial' Industrial DCra~!sPace \ 4. 0 Foundation Only
5. KI OTHER unstaffEd ClBasemcnt :\ 5. 0 Demolition
(Specify) ~W ralloXlS~ \\ 4.. ~ 1" 6. Xl AccC5SoryBuilding, .
. equ1pzent sheltar./ ~ v .,~ 7. 0 Gara.J:l ~~ Attached
B. SEWER. !Doe '-. il'l5\'r\"'\C! .}"'\....s X
1. [J Public (Name of System ); G....~"-GQ.....~ r,eqtit3.-"'--YES _ NO--.-
2. [] Private (Septic Tank. etc.) '~_.-' I ~~~a. r~~~~-::.",J.e.s c'%S _ NO
R:' I< ~ ~~~.~. V" ri\'\(':~'" -X
C. WATE . D:m9 ::~. ~ io etif.'t'i:Juwg c.'E...... .U ~.-- NO_
1. [J Public (NameofSystern } E':t.~..... ~ g'~'i.~'-r~e~ T~~~ _' ..~ NO-L
2. [] Private (Well ' ) j.).J.-; ("I:: CO~..j~ I G\.Jo.~ ' Ildftt
D. ZONlNG: S-2 1~'i"1 \J~~i.~~a~~tractor
E. ESTll\1ATED COST OF CONSTRUCTIO*~{ _ -U{--ct Of .... tttg~... - .
(Excluding Land Value) ""'\.: !.o'~.,_ Plumbing License # [] UPC or 0 CABO
.....*****.****.**...***..*....************..*******.******..*.**.***.**..**..**....***................**...
.The undCJ'Signed agrees that any construction, reconstruction, enl:ui~r. relocation, or alteration of structure, or any change in the use of land or StrUctUre
requested by this application will comply witli, and conform to, all applic:able laws of the Slate of'Indiana, and the"'Zoning Ordinam:e of.crnt Indiana.. 1993
(Z-289) and amendments, adopted under authority one. 36-7' et seq, General Assembly of the State of Indiana, and all Acts amendato~ thereto. I furthe
certify that only kitchen, bath, and floor drains are connected to the sanitary sewer. I furtber c:ertify that the construction will Dot be used 'or occupied unti
a CertifiCllte of Occupancy has beeR issued by the Dep:u1ment oC Community Services, Carmel. Indiana. .
./J tfl. / ~...-;7 ..", 'r INSPECrIONS.!~EEDED:: - .....-,...
/ .." /4., .. ..~ ,. ,..4'- "
.,t;. . -~ r& P ;:footillglUnder S)alr""R.oug~~J1'" ~~~.~e . . (
19nature of Owner or Authonzed Agent . :", t;.___..... < "'-.' ':';:----. ...---- / . , r/:J
Ja-cas A.L. ~~t).~11D, AI:tormy for Spnnt /.......Site/ J/"'- Final ,.... . {_C1~'" _,
spect:r\m, II' (see attached lease agraeu:ent). . ~/ 1Af..X~~~;:.-;.~ cr'r;;;;- <.:-7' c; I .
Penmt (Square Foota :/ ....././, . ,1. .' ....,.J - -' .
ro' ) (P Numbe ) .. .. ..,.,-.' .',
\.. nnt. hone r . .;:.., i \...' . -:-
(317) 269-2500 /' ~
-Inspection Fees:
'....
Certificate of Occupancy:
P.R1.F.:
..t...r~/ ~:l
-' i b... -
,
. ..,. ~'~
(..~'-"
Sewer Capacity Allotted
..-
Plan Comm,ission1BZ?-Docket #:
,: '" ,.'
. .,' ~ : ." I" - .."-,,,
/ .."" / r:'-;--' ~. /
J ,,' ' / j. ,..,..,.r" 1 i /1 .......... .
l........ i ;/ .-.......-.., "". '~q \.. ....J';- , ,-
~,_ .. ~#i .","; ...,..{_~~.,_--""
TOTAL:. . \ /I ~ .:;) Jf:/ <' "
,~, .: J 'I I ::!~ rt( 1 r".f"--'
_ . ".i" : rl ;to ,.:," _
c.....~"') 1
l ! lCl;t; J
- - -- --.-. - -- - -
Ap'pllcations: City of CarmQlay Township QitNO: 2001.0627.8
2oo1.0656.B 06/1512001
Application for Improvement Location Pennit RoD File: 1113030000028011
"
BUILDER LWI PR_ FAI
I JAY LEMMON, Q SERVE COMMUNICATIONS 11(317) 856-1694 I 1(317) 856-4198 I
... ......- an/SUR/Dr
I 14515 S HIGH SCHOOL RD IIINDPLS,IN 46241 I
- - -_..
TENANT NAME I I
1iI",-'
OWNER IAIII PROIl FU
. I EDWIN C & DONNA B ZAMBER II( ) - I I( ) - I
STllHI' an nAR Dr
11388 QUEENS WAY I I CARMEL IIIN 1146032 I
LOCAnON un SIIIDIYIIIOI .Am IlWPI ZUIIIG un an ,lWP
- 1VtIP
- iiiDiUi OJ ClIIITlIlImOl - SlIITI .---.--......-----.--
an Dr
1388 QUEEltS wy CARMEL 46032
o New Structure
o
o
o
o
o
B
o
o Commercial Tenant Space
Report Type:
~ I CeBula! Tower
Lot Split Y IN Ea Aood Zones Y IN EB
Sump Pump Y IN. Manufactured Y IN.
Construction Notes Trusses
Co-locates on an existing amateur radio tower constructed at this site in 1987 by owner Zamber. Owner will partner with Sprint, who
proposed to remove the horizonal antenna arrays and install its 'slick type' PCS antennas on the tower, while maintaining the remaining
amteur radio antennas on the structure. The existing tower is 130' tall, proposed antennas wJll reach 100'. Correspondence in file.
Equipment shelter is 20' x 22'. PER LL: Did not have to go through PC or BlA. NOR DID ORIGINAL TOWER. No corresponding
minutes.
TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION
I OTHER
o
o
o
o
@
Do plans include a
porch? Y I N
Single Family
Two Family
Multi-Family
Commercial/lndusttial
Farm
.
SUB
Type of Foundation
o Crawlspace
o Basement
o Slab
OTHER_________
I1PEI:InI
Plumbing Contractor I
Plumbing Ucence # INONE
ESTIMATED COST OF CONSnwcnON
(Excluding Land Value) 1$ 85,000.00
I Code Book
TYPE OF IMPROVEMENT
I cm TOW
Addition - Porch
Addition - Room(s)
Remodel
Foundation Only
Demolition
How Many?
D
Accessory Building
Garage - Detached
Garage - Attached
...-.---.----..- --.-----------------------.-..-------------------.- -..---- - - .. _.- --'. -
-.-.- -----.---------------------------.--------- ----------_._-- - - -.- - - - - ....-....
The- lIIItlenill'wd ..,reeI dllll RI1l' conotnxtion. rftons.....tian, enIar:en-t. reIoClItian, or ~ of JlrlX1W"e. or any cIIm:e in tIw \.... oflcDd or nncruro. requcotod 1Iy lhis oppIic:acion
"iD o:mtlJl!y with, aDd coo","" 10 aD applicableLnts..fdleSnlteolTndhma, and tIw "Zooinc OnIi_eurc-.nnclladioua-I9!/3- (LZ89) """ ammd......... """pr...1 undera"dlU~ one
3(,.7 .. ~ C""""l ,\~ of d>o State olIDdi.n&. and aD ,u.. amoodlIlnry lhofttn. IIUrrbor <fftify that ~ Idtdlnt. hlIdt.laundry, and fluor dni....~ ....._..0 In rbo ....."'ry ""'ff.
I further rrrtit). """ me <ot.._d.. wiD not be -' .... occupied until. ('.cnirocare ofOtxupe...,. 11M '-n m.d by tbe ~rh""" o(ClJlIlatIIIIi., !';en;ccs. ('ar...r! huliQI1IL
Pennit Fee: I. 398_00
Inspection Fees: . O.OD
Certificate of Occupancy: . 42.00
PRlF: . 0_00
TOTAL: I. 440.00
Extended Building Description
ICO LOCATE CELL TOWERlRADIO TOWER @ RESIDENCE
T1I'I
Footing
Underslab
Meter Base
Rough-In
Signature of Owner or Authorized Agent
(Print)
(Phone Number)
Sewer Capacity Allotted
Plan Commission I BZA Docket #:
__JJ_~__--' . IJun 15.-2001
Reviewed/Approved: DepL of Community Services
I
Fee Received By:
AlG. It>>
11(0. t.
; ~ Final Structure
Final Site
Bonding I Groun~~
~~
11323 I Sq.FL
I$QUARlFODTAGII
SNt
Q
PARR RICHEY Q
~REMSKEY
(DMoKION
1600 MARXl!.T TOWER.
10 WEST MARXl!.T STREET
INDlANAPOUS. INDIANA 46204
(317) 269-2500 . (317) 269-2514 Fd
india.aaporJS@parrbw.com
ATTORNEYS
www.parrlaw.com
February 22, 2001
~
R~~'~:':?I!)
FED 26 .i~OI
Oocs
James A.L Buddenbaum
jbuddenbaum@parrlaw.com
Steve Engelking, Director
Department of Community Services
City of Carmel
One Civic Square, Third Floor
Carmel, Indiana 46032
Via: Federal Express
Re: Collocation on Legally Established Amateur Radio Tower
Dear Mr. Engelking:
Sprint Spectrum, L.P., d/b/a Sprint PCS, is proposing to collocate on an existing legally
established amateur radio tower located at 1388 Queens Way on a 6.09 acre parcel owned
by Edwin C. Zamber, as depicted on the enclosed map indicating the location of Mr.
Zamber's property and existing tower. As you know, Sprint, is a public utility licensed
by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) to provide commercial mobile radio
service in the form of personal communication service (PCS) to the general public. As
such, Sprint is required to provide adequate and reliable PCS service which, in turn,
requires the construction and operation of communications transmitting and receiving
antennas throughout its service area at locations which are dictated by customer use and
system engineering requirements.
As you are also already probably aware, Sprint and other wireless carriers have a great
need for additional coverage and capacity in Carmel, generally and, particularly in
western Clay Township. The difficulty is locating a site which is unobjectionable to the
community, but still meets the service carrier's system engineering (radio frequency)
requirements for provision of adequate and reliable service. This proposed collocation
will accomplish both objectives. Collocation at this site will greatly improve Sprint's
ability to serve its customers and the general public in this area without imposing a new
antenna structure on the neighbors.
The existing 130' guyed-wire type amateur radio tower was constructed in 1987 by Mr.
Zamber and has three large horizontal antenna arrays, as depicted in the attached
Lebanon Office
225 West Main Srrec:r . Lebanon, Indiana 46052-0668 . (765) 482-0110 or (317) 269-2509 . (765) 483-3444 Fax . lc:banon@parrlaw.com
o
o
February 22, 2001
Page 2
photographs. Sprint proposes to remove the horizontal antenna arrays and install its
"slick type" PCS antennas on the tower, while maintaining the remaining amateur radio
antennas on the structure. The "slick" antennas will be attached and closely "hug" the
main support structure to maintain the same silhouette of the tower as exists today. No
structural improvements to the tower will be required because the structural engineers
have determined the guy wires, in conjunction with removal of the horizontal arms,
results in sufficient loading capacity for the PCS antennas. Sprint will also locate its
radio equipment in a nicely designed compatible shelter at the base of the tower, as
depicted on the enclosed Drawing C2.
The proposed collocation is permitted under the CarmeVClay Zoning Ordinance in this
S-1 residential district. Section 5.3.7 of the S-1 Residence District Zoning Ordinance
provides "fp Jrivate radio and television reception and transmitting towers and antennae
are permitted subject to applicable local, state and federal regulation" and, thus, the
existing structure is legally established. Under Section 5.1 of the Ordinance, as amended
by the Wireless Ordinance, Sprint's proposed collocation on this legally established
tower is permitted in the S-1 district.
Therefore, one behalf of Sprint PCS, we are requesting written confirmation that Sprint's
proposed collocation on Mr. Zamber's existing legally established amateur radio tower is
a permitted use. I have enclosed two (2) full size and two (2) reduced sized site and
construction plans for your use during your review. If you deem appropriate, you could
merely mark the plans as "permitted" and "approved" as a means to memorialize the
grant of our request. Upon receipt of such written confirmation, Sprint will apply for the
appropriate building permits before proceeding with its collocation. Please call if you
have any questions or need further information before proceeding with this request.
Very truly yours,
JALB/js
Enclosures
cc: John Molitor
Patrick Allen
(Doel 30280)
-U
o
5 I'"
.1.0 UNIT /ACRe
).
lJ(
\0
, --.. -. . ...-- .~. _ 0'.-<<
, .....
~
, :z
.....
v
~ . ~ 34
-I /:
.1.0 UNIT J\CRE
"
.~. >-
'. c(
-J
. U
'121
"
~
o 0
/
I
I
I
.' I
~
o (0 ~
o
;E,
.~
GTON
IZl
"--
o
,
LJ
o
....,
Q'
0
0
~ J
a:
w
~
Z
I ~
~
IZl
of WINDEMERE:
0~
.\
.\
. \,
.\ ~O~PEAGATE
}
-....
""
n
LAUREL WOOD' ,
[Zl
,---_. --.
DOL.:
lZl
I: II. .
~
n \
5-1
1.3 UNITS/ACRE
I 1\ /1 In I / I I
5-1
1.3 UNITSI eRE
o
"
;-
u U
SLM & Associates, Inc.
7230 Hosler Road
Leo, IN 46765
(219) 627-8970
i::'
, .
January 17,2001
Mr. Mark Norville
First Group Engineering, Inc.
5714 West 74th Street
Indianapolis, IN 46278
Re: Sprint pes Site 303 (Zamber)
Mark,
Attached please :find the structural calculations for the above referenced site.
The tower mapping infonnation, that was provided to our firm, should be considered a
vital part of your project file.
Three new "close mount" antennas are to be installed at 110'. The six new antenna cables
should be "bundled" and installed on an "open" face of the tower.
See the attached qualifications sheet for minor confirmation I modifications that are
required to facilitate this co-location.
Based upon the above referenced calculations and qualifications, it is our opinion that, the
proposed antenna mounting produces loading within the capacities of the existing 135'
guyed tower. Any future loading would require further structural review.
Steven L. Manor, P.E.
",,,au,,,,,,
~,,~\~ ~N L At. "",'-
~,;.c.(.' ..._.. r4A..,~
,~C-.,v ....STEi1.-..'1;~ ..,
S -J.A(,(!)\ ~~h.~ ~
~ .~ N ..,
~ i 0 ':.. ~
~ {#870332 j cc ~
~~""'. STATEOF ./ t:;f
".--0. . ~~
~ ~.'~~OIAtl~.....~ ~
"'-"'" .sS;-O-'N'-'~~ ~~\\,,~
"f t\ ,,\
'f'If,,"'"
f ·
o
Q
~
ZAMBER
.Qnalificatimls
. Standard materials were asswned in this analy~is:
. A36 steel members.
. A53 Gr. B pipes.
. ERS guys.
. The calculations assmne that the connections, anchors, and
foundation capacities match those of the members.
. Confonnation / modification requirements are as follows:
. A325N or equal bolts are required at the leg splices.
. The rotor base capacity shall match that of the tower or
the lower tower section shall be replaced.
~
....
:ZA-~~ 0
Q
... j I'
V? ()
M ~.
'\
,
...
"
I\)
"
C
I
C
VJ
\
,
~
IJ"
()
)
~
t-1
I
c
,
~
I
ai
, ;
t'.l
1
1
I
I
1-
~
~
..
II]
\\
\
\
\
'j
\"
(
1-1 ~l
,
~oo' -1 /0. I
/or: 25
\
\
.
I
/7/ _I
.'.,
" .
.-
'Z~N..~~
~
~
a
,
~
~
~
~
~
$1.
%/-6 t-y
6 P'-/6C:
o
u
2ar-:2/{
-
/oW07e-
S6~rloJo-./ cax/~r)
(//t2- r4-Glf)
'/ "
/ L C/e,c.,t^M-F~6N~6
~ .2.,fJV r ~ ....-- ...2 f"
'9 fI; -:. ~G .- (SOL-/~)
Ae-- (3 C I,S)C.~~~"I.)
l' 7 (2J')(S/Iz,'./,)
~ /.//r-~'Z..
whee
ib- ~ S" k.
7.7\A.e~ 2. ~O AL
~~
.s -0 C/.GCVN"'--'r'd.e~G6
7> Y"'- . &7')" -
r I; /-l~ ''[S(1~//:>''
pi ;::.. 2.7"5"
)/~.. (o)(/o)(l.7Sp"l.) ~
-: z~ i Z ~~ "t- ~.. 7~ ;fA., :. "& _ '1--4- -If'-z-
"
6 c/.e.c...9 r'-,,9~'-y o.f).~(~t?"
}> / t - " .I'/~tlc.
( 0') %'f 60"'~': (;) 'YI A."r)
~ .
o
Z;t~t:a-
~'UH-T
G,tf'GS.
~~.
jJJ~"
o
~ o~ 2S"'
~li"L- S5CT/c-l (' 6X/S;/ "')
( e 0) L.,~bS J
( 7:,...~,- /oe- /0' ~ccr/-=- )
(3) (/0) (~/tJ~R-I,) - 2~~S"~
(if) (/c') (.f6<1'IL/,) :: g 4:"os-q..
(ZJ) (Z.I) (. (-fo IJ,I,) - Z. ,.1/-6'11-
~ "-,,:?Q04
7or'+-~ - ....::::.. LL
: .
o
o
ZAMBER
~~r Z~
~
riAl EIA - 222 - F
Hamilton Co., IN => V :
70 mph (basic wind speed)
(112" radial ice)
~
1=> D+Wo
II => 0 + .75Wi + I
F = (qz Gh) l(Cf Ae) + sum(Ca Aa)](horizontal force)
Kz = (Zl33)^217
qz = .OO256Kz*V^2
(exposure factor)
(velocity pressure)
Gh = .65 + .60/(h/33)^1n
h = ~ => Gh = 1./1-
See table on page ~ of Z.s for
Z => Kz, Kz => qz, & qz => qz Gh
(gust response factor)
.,
'. .
Q
o.
~ o-~ 25
ZAMBER
V(mph)=
:m.
Gh=
1M.
Section L z Kz QZ QZGh
1 37 18.5 0.85 10.63 12.12
2 30 52 1.14 14.28 16.28
3 30 82 1.30 16.27 18.55
4 30 112 1.42 17.79 20.28
5 8 131 1.48 18.60 . 21.20
. '
'~
. ,
. .' .. ..
o
Z+M6~
o
[ or Z ~
Cr~ ~.4et.-4.7e+~.~
e ~ OF~;/~)//lc
II- F ':. tJ.O..,c-t ~
;!L;' f/S\'/{o) (11/~iL -r2,92h"l.)~ ~4.1f/+-r'-
At;.::' {I 'r.( H~)(l3rJ :. 2/0.6()-H"L
e... =- It L 66 Y C;:.. L. fl (;=oe.Gc- C oli',;'l-;:/C/"~J'lT)
At:::" /J;VAF -f bLAL f~
!lp=- 0. 0 +1':L 7 .It/'.. ~ o. O~." 1..
IJ i" ::. /. 0 /e,.. . s / ~ '- + , s"7 ~ . (0
J? ;/6' 7- Cco) (;t~ y GIlT ~ I f~ ;I~ )
& F,<jCo'" /
,P'~ /0 ..( d'-c. r/c~
.
W / c:J "eo" .~
Cr ~4- :- /.. ~~( /-//-/T4Z9Y1'?')::' S. 6 fl'-r 7.
_ -rs: v-.f / ~
.7SCr- ~(f- ::. / P--~ 6. ~ (;7 -fI} f- 3. 44;;, ~) -- tJ. -{' / .,4l.
cc. "//0;0...( -'= t:J- rI
/,;.
/ , /2J/Z- /-1/-= J eft" *
37
Z .30 /0: Zo /'Sr 1-J-{ jl
3 , /aSS /-S.r ~7/L
:so
1- , .sz f- It
30 ~a Z-o /.I/~
-S 6' 2/. zo /-.I.r /1-6"#
: .
o
7!:-A'/~ 4lJ1Z.-
o
7 cFZS
.-
6X1~7/N G
~rt:fNN~
( "'c e-oJd ,l\Aov.,../7'(;t'1) .....)
(C~rnVl /Yr~ /*~~ /-A-Ar~ ~"NC. /IJ.-tl"-O-S ')
(I) e... /0 1 lj & / ,: 2, (5 I
D'.1 / I
..~ '
W6161f'T
~A-/I'-l (/)f-'{ (/o.79f1tI,) ~
r!t f" ; " ,r; eJ- J
C~-5. (0).2.0' ( 10"1,) ::.
( ~ / "w..,../,P ")
~6 r. -b II-
/ro.o#-
TO,/A-l-
a~~6~
6' ;54-
y (;3 Z:S 1Il- /~~ ')
Ice
NVf/~
c.~
( J) ('f6) f0.os/Tf.) ~ /~7. ~ 11-
[t){u] (.1Z,'-'/') =- /?z z,ilt
rc:r~c.... z.. 8 4. ~Jt.
h~a=-G~ y(/~Zd.~~-~)
IIiNO
.il
( rA-G~ )
(wlo /t:..-tf- C.':;N7'~~ )
CA-' =- ~ Z-
/4:; ()) (/b-~(j~7.-)
;:> C....,. ~ ,;. .zo. z:, \"" -/r'l.-
#~ <J;z. Cn- ~.
("d' / ~ /cf~S-/..Ir ~ ::s 7-6 It.
9 t1 / ~ ZO.Z.CJ/i~;> 4-1/#
/Zc!" =:;> z/.z.o /(1=' 7> I!JZJ /#
~AA~ 0
o
If OFZS
'. .
,Jew ltt6NN~ (e. /IDJ
/J "/ II ~ "
/ie; /iTT/fcH.N'-tS-7-I1 t\
("(' C~0S4 N\O\JNr~ ... ')
[ (~) 'e.-
lJ..k. ( 3) e.-
/cc1 ( .3)
(3) e.,
/0 ~
-::.
( e(S) L,C-b~ ")
64-~
=- -b6!1
S b .' x o"~ ~3~ j
e.- 2.Z~
t10~
~ /zol't.
MI'4D .
(w-;O /Gc- CGNTt:,..e1t.--..!:.)
CA- =- I 4-
/!r =- (3) (3./{-/'-r1-) = 133ff~
?C~ /I /I- ;. /3.oC -f"'.f'"Z-
J~ C #": 20. z8/-rr 37 r .:. Z.{ ~ No
.!i1
. .
-z.AIf\~~
:
o
9 or 2. S
N1!:'1--l C Ir i3 <..~
(0 I ~ //0') [ (6') e- / S"i"]
DL
-
~~
~x...., @@. ~
~. .?,(/.' '-, .
.-' "".j ..~
Lb) e-
re) e
,.
,6 VN!Jt..el)'~
(C}u~T. /~
/'I~&t... )
( 12.(/)<<> )
/ce
(I. 0 It/, ) ~ [. 0 ft./,
(l ~ JL-I. ) ;; 7 0 ft.!,
w/o /Ct1-
Ck~/Z-.
(::,) (./3~ {'fl.! )y{~4' . f~H%
( ~) ( .2 / ~ .fr"/') r C,+ IIA- .. .1/~Z./,
Q.,.7~ ~ .~/#z~
WINO
.7-::; '^' ;; C-6
5 C"C-r/ c--./ L 'IF' b~ F"
-
/ 37' /Z.J Z j#sr Z6~"
2 ::5 0' /rra/'J/ 2664
-3 ~Ol / t:f.$ /.t r 3z..c:8i:Z
4- /\5' ZfJ. Z /)/"Jl' /~c)J
.
ZAMBER
(Gravity Loads In #'s)
(Per Leg)
Section L Web DL DL Ice Ice Cables Cables
'(1 ) 1(1)(accum) '(1 ) 1)(accum) 2)(DL+lce' I(2)(accum)
5 8 Z 80.00 80.00 24.00 24.00 0.00 0.00
4 30 Z 299.00 379.00 90.00 114.00 179.00 179.00
3 30 Z 299.00 678.00 90.00 204.00 414.00 593.00
2 30 Z 299.00 977.00 90.00 294.00 414.00 1007.00
1 37 Z 369.00 1346.00 111.00 405.00 511.00 1518.00
Total 1346.00 405.00 1518.00
o
(1) Total load I (3) legs.
(2) Total new cable load 1(1) leg.
Existing cable loads => (1) "other" leg.
(3) Approximate load per leg (max).
o
..
~
()
1\
N
V\
..
"
Exist. App, Exist. App, New App, New App, Total Section
3)(DL+lce 3)(accum) 3)lDL+lce I(3)(accum) (accum)
465.00 465.00 0.00 569.00 5
465.00 930.00 40.00 40.00 1642.00 4
465.00 1395.00 40.00 2910.00 3
1395.00 40.00 3713.00 2
1395.00 40.00 4704.00 1
1395.00 40.00 4704.00
c
o
~
~
')\
~
. .1
ZAMBER
(Wind Loads In #'s)
(Per Face)
(@ w/o Ice or .75 w/lce) Maximum
Section L Web Tower Cables Exist. ADD. New App. Total Section
5 8 Z 146.00 146.00 -S i
5 128 429.00 429.00 ~
4 30 Z 524.00 156.00 680.00 ~-
4 98 411.00 411.00 -!-
4 110 265.00 265.00 '
3 30 Z 479.00 328.00 807.00 ~--
3 68 376.00 376.00
2 30 Z 436.00 288.00 724.00 2-
1 37 Z 386.00 265.00 651.00 I -
I
Total 1971.00 1037.00 1216.00 265.00 4489.00 Total
'0
o
..
~
.,
)
~
\ '. 0
. ~##'1.($~ 0 /~ o~ z.s
,....
l-
\-? l..1
!'.) ...,
+z,,"" ~ 0\) "
~ '\
;" z. r;; """>
r-.
Z6'S{/::, ~
~34- ..-- .
-F 0
. .
~ "- f"?
"""
. 4--1/1'f
~ ,If1/.4- -:r
-~
. ()
t1
~r~ 37-( I:l.
~
/l~
'"
~
"'-
C
tI7
@ 'il
~
-:
'*
'- .......
"-
"" ')
~
~
<:::I
1
~
Q
1
~
~
""'-'
3
FA"
Ii,)
o
o
/t-4rLS
. . ~,
f.JHDEFOF:MED
SHAPE
y
L
1~
?H
')
~
..
I
4H
4
~L5-l
'J
MIHIM
X 8. 000E+008
Y 9.000[+983
-yo
l'IAXlMA
X l.35aE+OO2
Y 5.0el?.E+OO9
General Frame Analysis v2.02
SLM &ASSOCIATES 0
o
-Lr~ 2,5_,
r
=======~=========================================================
NODE
NO
NOD A L
NODAL COORDINATES
X Y
I N FOR MAT ION
SUPPORT CONDITIONS
CODE PX STIFF PY STIFF M STIFF
=============================================================================
Units Ft Ft K fIn K IIn K -In fDeg
1 o .000- 0.000 H-
2 37.000 ' 0.000 H'
3 67.000' 0.000 H'
4 97 .OO<Y 0.000 H-
5 . 127.000- 0.000 H-
6 135.000- 0.000
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
ELEM
NO
NE
NODE
E L E MEN T
PE ELEM
NODE LENGTH
I N FOR MAT ION
BETA PROP ELEM
ANGLE TYPE TYPE
NE
HINGE
PE
HINGE
---------------------------------------------------------~-------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------.
Units : Ft Deg
1 1- 2 37.000 ' 0.00 1 BEAM
2 2 - 3 30.000 ' 0.00 1 BEAM
3 3 - 4 30.000- 0.00 1 BEAt-1
4 4 5 30.000 0.00 1 BEAM
5 5 6 8.000 0.00 1 BEAt1
=============================================================================:
PROP
NO
PRO PER T Y I N FOR MAT ION
SECTION
NAME MODULUS AREA
I
DIST
=======.======================================================================:
Units: K fIn 2
In2
In4
Ft
1 .;.l18i(s8 /
2 . ~ ) I GO t
1C.2
9':'0
=============================================================================:
REC
NO
LOAD
CASE
E L E MEN T
LOAD .LOAD
TYPE SYS
LOA D
DIST
SPEC
I N FOR MAT ION
DIST
PX
PY
M
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------.
----------------------------------------------------~;-----------------------
Units : Ft K 1Ft K 1Ft Ft-K /1
Description
Element List Y
r r UNIF
GLO
DIST
B
E
o . 00 -
37.00.....
0.00
0.00
-0.01/
-0.01./
0.'
0.(
Description
Element List 2/
General Frame Analysis v2.02
, .' SLM &ASSOCIATES
o
o
/ 6,,' ~
=============================================================================.
REC
NO
LOAD
CASE
E L E MEN T
LOAD LOAD
TYPE SYS
LOA D
DIST
SPEC
I N FOR MAT ION
DIST
PX
PY
./
2
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
M
1 UNIF
Description
Element List 3,
3/ l' UNIF
Description
Element List
.( t
Description
Element List
5/ 1"
Description
Element List
11, ~
4-
UNIF
b
UNIF
l'
UNIF
Description
Element List 2'
12"' l' UNIF
Description
Element List
13-' 1....
Description
Element List
14.... 1"
3"
UNIF
4....
UNIF
Description
Element List 3'
23- l' CONC
Description
Element List 4-
24 ' 1, CONC
Description
Element List 5......
25 - l' CONC
GLO
GLO
GLO
GLO
GLO
GLO
GLO
GLO
GLO
GLO
GLO
DIST
DIST
DIST
DIST
DIST
DIST
DIST
DIST
DIST
DIST
DIST
8
E
0.00'
30.00,.
8
E
0.00"
30 . 00 ~
8
E
o . 00 '
30.00.
8
E
0.00....
8 .00 ...
B
E
0.00'"
37 .00....
B
E
0.00'"
30 .00 ....
B
E
0.00....
30.00'"
B
E
O.OO~
13.00'
B
1.00 ...
B
1.00
B
1.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
.S:> . 00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
-0 .01~
-0.01'
-0 .02'
-0.02'
-0.02 .
-:0.02 .....
-0.02
-0.02
-0.01....
-0.01-
-0.01-
-0.01-
-0.01~
-0.01_
-0.01-
-0.01-'
-0 .38 ,.
-0.41-
-0.43"
0.'
0.'
0.'
0.'
0.'
0.'
0.'
0.'
0.'
0.'
0.'
0.'
o.
0.'
o.
o.
o.
o.
o.
General Frame Analysis v2.02
SLM &ASSOCIATES
i_ ..
.Q
o
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------.
______________________________________________________-----------------______0
17o~Z5
REC
NO
LOAD
CASE
E L E MEN T
LOAD LOAD
TYPE SYS
LOA D
D.IST
SPEC
I N FOR MAT ION
DIST
PX
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------.
PY
M
Description
Element List 4 ./
34 " 1; CONC
GLO
DIST
B
13.00 ./
0.00
.~
-0 .27/
0.'
General Frame Analysis v2.02
SLM &ASSOCIATES
Q 0
===================================================================L~=~?=~=
NOD A L
D I S P LAC E MEN T S
NODE
NO
LOAD
CASE
DX
DY
ROTATION
=~===========================================================================:
Units In In Deg
1 1 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0069
2 1 0.0000 0.0000 0.0020
3 1 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0005
4 1 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0026
5 1 0.0000 0.0000 0.0045
6 1 0.0000 0.0068 0.0040
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
ELEM
NO
LOAD
CASE
E L E MEN T FOR C E S
NODE
NO AXIAL SHEAR
MOMENT
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Units: K
K
K -Ft
1
1
1
2
0.0000
0.0000
0.2574
-0.3934
0.0000
-2.5152
2
1
2
3
0.0000
0.0000
0.3918
-0.3321
-2.5152
-1.6197
3
1
3
4
0.0000
0.0000
0.7142
-0.4688
-1.6197
-3.2026
4
1
4
5
0.0000
0.0000
1.0047
-0.,.3514
-3.2026
-1.0130
5
1
5
6
0.0000
0.0000
0.5750
0.0000
-1.0130
0.0000
============================================================================="
REA C T ION S
NODE
NO
LOAD
CASE
PX
PY
MOMENT
==============:===============:=====:====:=========:========================='
Units: K
K
K -Ft
oeneral frame AnalYS1S v2.U~
SLI'-1 &ASSOCIATES
,. ~ .
U 0
/?~~Z5
====~============================================================-----:------
REA C T ION S
NODE
NO
LOAD
CASE
PX
PY
MOMENT
=============================================================================
1
1
0.0000
0.2574
0.0000
2
1
0.0000
0.7852
-0.0000
3
1
0.0000
1.0463
0.0000
4
1
0.0000
1.4735
0.0000
5
1
0.0000
0.9264
0.0000
..
General Frame Analysis v2.02
SLM &ASSOCIATES
l.. ..
Q
o
z.. () ..P Z5
==================================================================._~ ---
NODE
NO
NOD A L
D I S P LAC E MEN T S
LOAD
COMB
DX
DY
ROTATION
=============================================================================.
Units In In Deg
LOAD COMBINATIONS:
COMB 1 : 1.00 X CASE 1
1 1 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0069
2 1 0.0000 0.0000 0.0020
3 1 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0005
4 1 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0026
5 1 0.0000 0.0000 0.0045
6 1 0.0000 0.0068 0.0040
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------.
ELEM
NO
LOAD NODE
COMB NO
E L E MEN T R E P 0 R T S
SIGN CONVENTION : BEAM DESIGNERS
AXIAL SHEAR MOMENT MAX MOM/DEFL DIS'
==============================================================================
Units
K -Ft /In
Ft
K
K -Ft
K
LOAD COMBINATIONS:
COMB 1: 1.00 X CASE 1
1 1
2 1
3 1
4 1
.~
1 0.0000 0.2574 0.0000 1.8839 14.6.
2 0.0000 -0.3934 -2.5152 -0.0146 16.31
2 0.0000 0.3918 -2.5152 0.6656 16.2.
3 0.0000 -0.3321 -1.6197 -0.0015 16.6'
3 0.0000 0.7142 -1.6197 0.8824 12.5:
4 0.0000 -0.4688 -3.2026 -0.0025 12.1!
4 0.0000 1.0047 -3.2026 2.4363 13.0(
5 0.0000 -0.3514 -1.0130 -0.0111 15.11
uenera~ rrame AnalYS1S v~.o~
SLM &ASSOCIATES
u
o
2/6~ l5
.. .
=============================================================================
ELEM
NO
LOAD
COMB
NODE
NO
E L E MEN T R E P 0 R T S
SIGN CONVENTION : BEAM DESIGNERS
AXIAL SHEAR MOMENT MAX MOM/DEFL
DIS
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
5
1
5
6
0.0000
0.0000
0.5750
0.0000
-1.0130
0.0000
-0.0007
8.0
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
REA C T ION S
NODE
NO
LOAD
COMB
PX
PY
MOMENT
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Units : K K K -Ft
LOAD COMBINATIONS:
COMB 1 : 1.00 X CASE 1
1 1 0.0000 0.2574 0.0000
2 1 0.0000 0.7852 -0.0000
3 1 0.0000 1.0463 0.0000
4 1 0.0000 1.4735 0.0000
5 1 0.0000 0.9264 0.0000
..
UM-l!cnL- Q
Q
zz, o..c &5
L G6 S.
{/so- /J- "j ;///I'a- (Co,v~C:-<'/Arhlq)
K<- to J= / 1- r-~ . 'S" 4-"
~~ ~ 0/. 'i-'b -:y t; So /Cjo If I'-~ f
A ~ . ((~:.. z. "7 /....-"'4_ =- /3. z 7 "-
!l~/>7 ~ 1-.10"- c-t::...-
All ,-~
///~/,..,JO :. 3. Z. c>
/J I ,.. /J J:.
~ ;:'/6Zr 0/ ~/_~1 Z~ 3(
~r.,,'-::' 7tJCJ:.
,
/33 A...,,- ~ /7('{ L
4-~
\. S/2./c-c
"../? 1'-
~#~ OL-
.~
~,,~
3~'" fj ~ /I::, .//I-Jz-
/jf"? 5>;' ~ .os J...., '-
_ /fr- Z-
CCNr/~
-
o~ ~,r:7~
/J~d~Oc-S~ ~"'A~/O~'" ;;'<5(7)
- <:.... / // ~
7/ 3.?tJ ). /-Z6' AI 6..
c ,..I :5Z~ II OIC- 6-Gtv~L- (/;.=..Z/~
9 b,7ZlL/..cf.9~~, aiL-
w
~~~
w~~
.....
o
z:s c~ V5
/~" ~
/6 SO' ~ eyz.,/J:)
t- ::. ). 0 =Zs. ,t~ }-- ;: 4 /2 S-,~-
t.l/r ~ ZGO y;; ~ 3,. 73"'"
) ~ _ z.. D /< .,.. ~ ;y A,t.- -:; . 7 r- '<-.
/J~ A,-;~oolL..
4/ _ !oo'L.-
V w,,.,;e; -
~/,,",J:} //..rc.tf ;:. . ~o L
;2'-0 ~ # 6'7l:-
oJ'
--fI
. .
-~T
-~T
~T
~T
Zrl''!> vt-- U
o
Cy~
// ...
'/ If 1- (; f.I ys.
~A-'l-~
A~"..,., ~
/ cS"-
?(O~
"c:~.. - 3.. s 7 cL-
4=./~"-
~
t: $/4'7
'If _
,g :/of/
.
L =. 71~
.
L~_2JL
..
~9'
-I
, I I
/00 -1 /2,7 .,.1 ~
Z 4-o~ l~
- 1/;1
jatl.~~~~~;_oc:.~ _ (J __... _.... TT!'CIt-IfI8'/'J-r'
, '9 ...., ca::JVi=:lWfRlr'ESS
A.:< ./'",-
2.75" ./f
I
I
I
'"
'. 51"
I
I
I
;
I
'/
I
/;-
j/
RF
CONNECTORS
EJec1rical
~'n\JtI\ Beaf1';w,e\l:
Elevato" Be;;!':1'",;cth
Gain
Po/waller.
Port-[C>-POI! (SQIa!ien
Frcnl.\O-83t:< RarW
Elidrieal OOto1'lb'l Orliofls
VSWR
Conn!!dOt~
Power Handling
Passive :r.tf:rtr.;;-~\;l<i.;'Jn
go'
i.
t5.5 dei (i1.4 cad;
Slant. :t<lS'
~Jj)~
~ 25 is ~ so de Typ.)
Q'. ~'. ,.-
t.35:t Ma'j
1:ry~ N 'Jf ?- '6 C~N ;far.--.aLoj
ZSO war.s CW
<-,41 d8c i2 :on.;
@ .043 d"5m {'2OW} ea.i
Cha:;$is Ground
liqhWI'!<J Prctec:ior.
~ 2.501<z,'O.
......02
0- i 6- XXXF
-
-
-
-
Mechanical
Oimtr.sicl7s (t;; W ~ ~)
S6itl t 8in x 2.7Sin
(i 42 ::.'n )( ,~.J em I 7J) CJ1\1
;&1 mph (:241 i(rr.il".r;
:1.1ft (.29 m)
~ itls (~Ot! N;
511hs {139 Nl
18 Ills (82 k9}
~~t,=::! WiM V~locily
EG'_livalet!1 Rat "!at~ Naa
,l:<0J'lI Wil!d L:!.;d @ 100 mpI1 (i61 kph:
Sid!! ~""ltld Load @ tllO mph P$11Cph\
Wetghl .
..
Note: Pal.rn P'ending and US Patellt nu~' S. 757 246.
\Qfu!! and 9CL"lr.$ :re ~~ _ VlIIialioll! ...ay ~C::>Jf. Sceci!ita!ior.!:-qy
~~e wilIlo.Itr.cSl;e d;;e b GMIdlll<lU$ pItlQIlCt ~/IllltItS. ~ ~altem
da~ i3 ~a~ Ir-..m :ne ~ Of _ "'It ....1I eita __ ~:Yrite't13.= ~
~<<~l all :;~3!es.
~:" . :_-..:~._: '. .,- :'.' ->:":- -: .<- '~I-:Ai:i:N: ....l",.iiii~-iD.:ri-~J("s~~-:.~.: ~~.~~_:'-,,::c'.~':r~.::Y:;~.'::'-:'~:." .' ~_...::c>::_~
-:. - - -~- :- ~ . .... -~...~ -_..~ . ~ . _ . t" ~C . '~,l~. ~,~: \::.l K:"',. -&....L~,~h'~ '~.' : ~ - _ '.<>; :-_ #. _'
_.- _ -' ".. _ .::- - - ~- -.".- - _._f -- _ .-._--. '... .:;. 0" .;." '- r.o '. . . _:...:,.... ..._~_:....._..__ ~""'-....
: Medel Number
; .__A!T~-P99.:!..L_ _.__.: . S!ar.~M9\d (~Il3.~lhan~L.~-!.~~!!!.!:.~~ !I?_~.9fnct1.J10 !'Jir.! 08 cm.1.O..!?1.cm) _
: MTG.SOZ-,Q ; SwWeltAcur.t __ ._.MOIdItm.ifuJ~~illatiM~nt__.. .
.~_'.-.-Mr~~:~X)(~io...-.. ----~. ~~;n;CaI ~:tL;U){;!s---' 0.. 1(j.1J(0. . lS' Medlamcal[Tcwn:jjl
. . ~c;..cX~.fo.'.. .....-- -.~ir'1i:ic7tiiKi~'-'-'-- ...... "3ar.ien:ias"fic;i~Of2anl~r.as-;&Q:'i::ar. .
. . MT~QZ"(}u. _ ..:..' U~..9~:~o~~C'" .....~:~Pr.~~~}j~.~~,T~~E;Q~Poj?=::...
~j~:~.x..iC:._..._. . .....__~~_l!~-'\C~t__. Uu _' . __~.~~'.dj3f!'e.~!_S"-:$S:_._ .___.__
. Mod~l numb€!' -sroQWO :epreSill".l! a setlllS al Pltl:!l.lc:s. See .no~o1(ir;g ,-oplions settio:t fer slt.!-::ilic rr.cdel nUlnb$f'.
...__._~~. .......---- ....--.... ------ ~,...-:,,-_..- ......... .. ....... ...~. - ._- -- ....
f..' ~ ....
~ ": Ot ~;! ; "
Description
r
:.0'
Azimu,..,
246
E~'I/\S Wift:';e~:;
f- i (770") .582-0555
F"ax ~1(77G) 729-0036
I
(2//0
Comments
J'.'
.. fI"
"
.- .,
.
.,
:.
~ !
\
it
~
.,.
. "-'~',
i
u (J
......~~
n:tI1Le-
Because you want it right on the first approach
February 2, 2001
Site ID#/Name: IN54XC303/Zanbur
To Whom It May Concern:
Airspace Safety Analysis Corporation (ASAC) has conducted an aeronautical study on Fepruary 2,
2001 for Sprint PCS. The study was to determine a proposed structure's effect, if any, on navigable
airspace. ASAC's study is conducted in accordance with Part 77 of the Federal Aviation
Regulations, FAR (14 C.F.R Subchapter E, Part 77) and Part 17 of the Federal Communications
Commission, FCC Rules and Regulations (47 C.F.R Part 17). The proposed construction site is
located in the Indianapolis MTA. The NAD 83 site coordinates are Latitude 390 57' 03.19" North,
Longitude 0860 10' 57 .60" West. The site has a surface elevation of 857 feet above mean sea level
(MSL). The structure has a proposed height of 115 feet above ground level (AGL), which includes
the additional height of any antennas, etc. This gives an overall structure height above mean sea
level of 972 feet AMSL.
The site is located 32,583 feet or 5.36 nautical miles on a True Bearing of 143.84 degrees from the
approach end of Runway 36 at Indianapolis Terry Airport, the nearest landing surface for
regulatory compliance purposes. The surface elevation at this point is 922 feet AMSL. The site is
located 35,076 feet or 5.77 nautical miles on a True Bearing of 146.65 degrees from the airport
reference point (ARP) of this public use, instrumented airport.
FAR Part 77 prescribes various airspace surfaces and slopes established at and around airports.
Part 77.13 prescribes slopes and surfaces which, if exceeded, require the sponsor of the structure to
provide the Federal Aviation Administration with Notice of Proposed Construction. FCC Rules
Part 17 also specifies this requirement. Additionally, Part 77 Subpart C prescribes various airspace
surfaces and slopes which, if any exceeded, require the FAA to provicle public notice inviting
comments prior to issuing a determination. Subpart C also prescribes surfaces and slopes which, if
exceeded, would identify the proposed structure as a Hazard to navigable airspace.
ASAC has determined that a proposed structure height of 115 feet AGL (972 feet AMSL) at this
site would not exceed any FAR Part 77 or FCC Part 17 notice requirement surface. Therefore,
FAA Notice of Proposed Construction or Alteration is not required for this structure.
Should Notice of Proposed Construction or Alteration b~ filed with the FAA, ASAC is confident
the proposed 115 feet AGL (972 feet .AJ.\1SL) structure will be approved at this site upon
completion of the FAA's aeronautical study.
STY 39171-01
Page 1
1903 Phoenix Boulevard, Suite 250, Atlanta, Georgia 30349
678.924.8000 . Fax 678.924.8006 . www.asacinc.com
,," ..
o
(,,)
Pursuant to Federal Aviation Regulations and FAA Policy, proposed Construction or Alteration
that does not require notice to the FAA, normally does not require obstruction marking and/or
lighting.
The maximum structure height at this site that would not require Notice to the FAA is 200 feet
AGL (1057 feet AMSL). Exceeding this height requires that a Notice of Proposed Construction or
Alteration form be filed and that FAA approval be obtained prior to beginning construction.
This letter and the opinions expressed herein are intended for the exclusive use of Sprint PCS in
making appropriate regulatory filings and may not be reproduced by other parties in any form or
manner.
Should you have any.questions regarding this letter or the study conducted by ASAC, pl~ase feel
free to contact my office anytime at (678) 924-8000.
Sincerely,
ysis Corporation
nneth R Patterson
Aeronautical Specialist
..
STY 39171-01
Page 2
i\ST&.~
,
..
o
o
"
ADDENDUM
ASAC Study No.:
Site ill #/Name:
STY 39171-01
IN54XC303 *Zanbur
AM BROADCAST STATION IMPACT:
FCC rules protect existing AM Broadcast Stations from possible adverse affects caused by
emissions from newly constructed cellular radio towers.
ASAC found no evidence of AM Broadcast Stations which would impact the study site.
..
STY 39171-01
Page 1
u
Q
ASAC Study Number: S,V sel,' J -0 J
Site Name: {(J 54}zCJ 30 ~
Enclosed is a completed FAA Form 7460-1 and
chart for your site. You should review, sign and date
this form prior to mailing it to the FAA. If available,
always attach a "2C accuracy" survey statement to this
packet to expedite FAA approval.
Please notify us when vou tile this Form with the FAA
and of subsequent FAA correspondence received, such
as acknowledgement, negotiation letter, determination,
etc. This information will allow us to better track the
processing of your site by the FAA.
PLEASE NOTE ITEMS CHECKED
o "2C accuracy" survey statement is required
o "Extended Study" is required
..
Please Type or Print on This Form
o
Q
Form Approved OMB No. 2120-0001
<<) Failure To Provide All Requested Information May Delay Processing of Your Notice FOR FAA USE ONLY
AeronaulicaI Sludy Nunber
u.s. Department of Trensoortation Notice of Proposed Construction or Alteration
Federal AviaIion AdminisIralIon
1. Sponsor (person, company, etc. proposing this actionl: 39 0 57 ' 03 19 n
9. Latitude:
Attn. of: Vio Oirvonis Site #IN54XC303 0 , n
Sorint Sorectrum. loP. 10. Longitude: 086 10 57 . 60
Name:
Address:9801 West Hiooins Road 11. Datum: ua NAD 83 0 NAD 27 o Other
Suite 220 12. Nearest: City: CI~ State: In_
city:Rosemont State:.!h- Zip: 60018
Telephone: (847) 384-3010 Fax: 18471 384-3061 13. Nearest Public-use (not private-use) or Military Airport or Heliport:
......... ... --. I~
2. Sponsor's Representative (if other than #1): 14. Distance from '13. to Structure: ~ "1~ I\JU
Attn. of: Kenneth R. Patterson
Name: Airsoace Safety Analvsis Cornoration 15. Direction from '13. to Structure: 1A"::I QAO Tn'..
Address: 1903 Phoenix Boulevard Suite 250 857 ft.
16. Site 8evation (AMSL):
City: Atlanta State: GA Zip: 30349 17. Total Structure Height (AGU: 115 ft.
Telephone: (678) 924-8000 Fax: (678) 924-8006 18. Overall Height ('16. + '17.) (AMSL): 972 ft.
Ii] 0 o Existing 19. Previous FAA Aeronatical Study Number (if applicablel:
3. Notice of: New Construction Alteration
Ii] 0 .OE
4. Duration: Permanent Temporary (_ months, _ days)
End W"_;" 20. Description of Location: (Attach a USGS 7.5 minute
5. Work Schedule: Beginning Aft... FAA AppM"". Quadrangle Map with the precise site marked and any certfied survey.)
6. Type: Ii] Antenna Tower 0 Crane 0 Building o Power Une The proposed site is located 1,740' Southeast from the
intersection of West 116th. Street and Ditch Road. (chart
0 Landfill 0 Water Tank 0 Other attached). The site is located 5.77 NM on a True Bearing of
7. MarkingJPainting and/or Ughting Preferred: 146.650 from the ARP of INOIANAPOUS TERRY.
o Red Ughts and Paint ua Dual . Red and Medium Intensity White
o White . Medium Intensity o Dual . Red and High Intensity White
o White. High Intensity o Other
8. FCC Antenna Structure Registration Number (if applicable):
21. Complete Description of Proposal: Frequency/Power (kW)
This proposed personal communications installation will operate in the 1850.0 - 1910.0, 1930.0 -
1990.0 MHz band with 1640.0 Watts ERP per Channel.
.p
Notice is required by 14 Code of Federal Regulations, part 77 pursuant to 49 U.S.C.. Section 44718. Persons who knowingly and willingly violate the notice
requirements of part 77 are subject to civil penalty of $1.000 per day until the notice is received. pursuant to 49 U.S.C.. Section 46301 (a).
I hereby certify that all of the above statements made by me are true. complete. and correct to the best of my knowledge. In addition. I agree to mark
and/or light the structure in accordance with established marking & lighting standards necessary_
Date Typed or Printed Name and Title of Person Filing Notice Signature
Vio Dirvonis, Acting Site Development Manager
S
2
2
01
3
9
1
7
1
FAA Form 7460-1 (11-98) Supersedes Previous Edition
NSN: 0052-00-012-0008
o
o
[~--=-~
\!) ",-=,.._.,1
,~ -'~ e~~
1'1
!l- -----
--to
I,
i
I) \
_.".....~-".
II;
\~,O ~
~.,d
'" "-r-'
L-t
'I'
I A,'
': :1"
'......--'1
I)'
P"""'" _:'" /~ ''. "'~
~... ~
. - -.....-.
; te-." /
~\~ \-
i.-., ~?-~..S.
-' ._ m,
", _ v <'
'';:~ \'
,.~ \ \ i
-'-" .".......-1
_ _._ _ :.... ;~....:-_ .;~~..... ....1;". -
Please Type or Print on This Form
Failure To Provide All Requested Information May Delay Processing of Your Notice
(.)
o
1. Sponsor (person, company, etc. proposing this action):
Attn. of: Vio Dirvonis Site #IN54XC303
Name: S rint S rectrum l.P.
Address:9801 West Hi ins Road
Suite 220
city:Rosemont
Telephone: (847) 384-3010
9. Latitude:
39 0
n
;;
o
u.s. Department of Transportation
Federal Aviation ~~~
Notice of Proposed Construction or Alteration
State:J!:..... Zip: 60018
Fax: 847 384-3061
o
10. Longitude: 086 10
11. Datum: [iI NAD 83 0 NAD 27 0 Other
12. Nearest: City: CI~
n
57.60
State:
13. Nearest PubIic~ (not private-use) or Military Airport or Heliport:
14. Distance from #13. to Structure:
15. Direction from #13. to Structure:
City. Atlanta
Telephone: (678) 924-8000
State: GA Zip: 30349
Fax: 678 924-8006
16. Site 8evation (AMSL):
17. Total StrucIUre Height (AGL):
18. 0veraD Height (#16. + '17.) (AMSLI:
857 ft.
115 ft.
972 ft.
3. Notice of:
4. Duration:
= 19. Previous FAA AeronaticalStudy Number (if applicable):
IAJ New Construction 0 Alteration 0 Existing
IiI Permanent 0 T~mporary ( _ months, _ days)
- OE
5. Work Schedule: Beginning Aft... FAA AWrmr.l1 End
20. Description of Location: (Attach a USGS 7.5 minute
Quadrangle Map with the precise site marked and any certfied survey.)
The proposed site is located 1,740' Southeast from the
intersection of West 116th. Street and Ditch Road. (chart
attached). The site is located 5.77 NM on a True Bearing of
146.650 from the ARP of INDIANAPOUS TERRY.
6. Type: IiI Antenna Tower 0 Crane 0 Building 0 Power Une
o Landfill 0 Water Tank 0 Other
7. MarkingJPainting aOOJor Lighting Pref8lTed:
o Red Ughts and Paint [iI Dual - Red and Medium Intensity White
o White - Medium Intensity 0 Dual - Red and High Intensity White
o White - High Intensity 0 Other
8. FCC Antenna Structure Registration Number (if applicable):
21. Complete Description of Proposal: Frequency/Power (kW)
This proposed personal communications installation will operate in the 1850.0 - 1910.0, 1930.0 -
1990.0 MHz band with 1640.0 Watts ERP per Channel.
5
2
2
O'
.~
3
9
1
7
1
Notice is required by 14 Code of Federal Regulations, part 77 pursuant to 49 U.S.C., Section 44718. Persons who knowingly and wilfingly violate the notice
requirements of part 77 are subject to civil penalty of $1,000 per day until the notice is received, pursuant to 49 U.S.C., Section 46301 (a).
I hereby certify that all of the above statements made by me are true, complete, and correct to the best of my knowledge. In addition. I agree to mark
and/or light the structure in accordance with established marking &.Iighting standards ,leCeSSCIIy_
Date
Typed or Printed Name and Title of Person Filing Notice
Vio Dirvonis, Acting Site Development Manager
Signature
N: 0052-00-012-0008
FAA Form 7460-1 (11.98) Supersedes Previous Edition
1
o
o
':
.
J~'~'-:~J
~Il'~'~~ .
~jt:.- .
."'11 .
il :.:
l-. "';';:"-,- '.:
f.
,: '..-
;~
~. Y" 1'-'- r"-..
~ ~ ...
P..-.._/.r- .\\
., '~..i ;
.' . " ~..~.. """
:",.~_.,._".
.-''t \
'~
i-.\ . ~. ~l5. .
-' "." m._
:\.A '. <.
, {
.",' 1
::===~."\. \
,
..
\>i.:-~'" "85
-.,.-....::
__~", :,1
. ;
~an-24-01 02:51P fge ~
Q
II v
GrOtID
~~tl
Ms. Katie Zalar
SprinI Spec1rUm, L.P.
9801 Higgins Road, Suite 220
Roscmont.IL 60018
Dear Ms. Zalac
2-C SURVEY CERTIFICATION
The following are du: tinal geographic coordinaa:s for the below listed site.
GEOGRAPHIC COORDINATES
P.02
Consulting Engineers
5714 WC.'1l 74th Strcct
Indianapolis, IN 46278
Phone (317) 290-9549
Fax (317) 290-9560
5246 Hohman Ave.
Suite 206
Hammond. IN 46320
Phone (219) 931-5226
Latitude 39 degrees -1L-
Longimde ~ degrees--1L
minures 03 .19
minutes S7 .60
seconds (NAD 83)
seconds (NAD 83)
minures 03.05
milUlteS S7.63
Lati1ude -2L degrees-21-
Longi1ude ~ degrees--1L
NAD27 CONUS
seconds (NAD 27)
seconds (NAD 27)
E1evalioo of Ground:
Elevation of Top of Existing Tower:
Elevation of Top o(Pembouse Roof:
Elevation at Top of E:usting Antenna:
(NGVD 29)
(NGVD 29)
(NGVD 29)
(NGVD 29)
856.58
N/A
N/A
N/A
DislarlCe to. nearest Runway:
Appl'Oltimate bearing:
Source:
Date: January 24, 2001
Re:
1NS4XC303C
lONe.
Zarnber
Site Name
Localion:
lndiaDa
Stare
...
Carmel
City
I <:emfy that me latitude of -1L.. .2L..J!L. J.L' N and the Iongillllle of ...!L-. -1!L....11.-...!!Q.-. W are accurate TO wiIhin :i:
SO feet horizonrally: and that the UlWCI' site elevation o( 856.58 AMSL is accurate to within :t 20 feet venically. With a planned S1I1Il:IIIre
height of AGL, the overall height should be AMSL. The hoJizom:aJ datum (coordinates) are in terms of rl1e Narth
American Datum of 1983 (NAD 83) and are expressed as degrees. minutes and seconds, to the nearest Itundrcd1h ofa seamd. The vertical datum
(heights) are in terms of rl1e National Geodetic Vertical Datum of 1929 (NGVD 29) and are determined to rl1e nearest foot.
1"""" . ~
~,~ .Q ~ CERTIFIED BY:
!~/~ r / /A
:Sf No ~~L ~
~ ~l8 .. ==...;.,"::; ~... '"Xl18
~ ~
SP1UNTl97-90S.03 ~ ~~~~~
.., I ~
~~l SUP' ,.",
STREETS - HIGIIWAYS -'~filil6>-':~TRUcrURES - WATER -SEWER - SURVEYING - RIGIIT-OF-WAY SERVICES
Seal
/h..,.J:,1
. Date
ACTIVE ~1EMBERSHIPS:
~ACECMember .
Suppartitr) Exr:8IIera
- In Engm.ing
.&~ ..-..:MIMXWTVOI'
~ CML_
~_SDaETY
OF POlCIFESSIllNAL
;.., UlND SUAvE\"OAS, INC.
it DOSrmm:OP
I'f1' ~ ftAHSPOaTA1ION
...- aoc_
~ '",":JtN"'UOf<AL
IllC1fT or WA\"
ASS(X:IATlON
o
o
Site Configuration Form
Latitude
(Decimal Seconds)
I.., .... IN54X.C303,. ".
GJ
t. . .:...390 5]' 00".. .
/. '86~-11'OO't
t
(
I.
Cascade 10
Candidate 10
longitude
(Decimal Seconds)
Structure Type
(Lattice, Monopole, Guyed, Roof Top, Water Tank, Other)
Polarization
(Vertical, Horizontal, Slant 450)
I
[",.
,.........
. ".
t
Existing
. Dual Polarization' . ",'-g.L~<~~
Diversity Scheme
(Horizontal, Vertical, Dual Polarization)
Slant 45
. .n'.. ....... .. t
..... ....- .
.,- .... ".".. "
,- . . '.
. ",' .
Sector Configuration
tenna Type.,~.Omni} ·
. ~" ":. ~". .
~terUrleff<~' _
Alpha
. Directional
tOO'
09
.: "
Beta
Directional' .
1'00'
120.
(}O,
Gamma
Directional
1'00'
240.
Antei1J'13 ,ModEll: .
~naGaiO:cdai)',
~w;jt:~~r .
....'~,~~b;,;..
,,{Pf}~)( 8!~x:L75" .
'56" x 8" x ~~ 75"
RF Engineer.
Date:
u
PARR RICHEY
~REMSKEY
(0MORION
(;)
1600 MARKET TOWER.
TEN WEST MARKET STREET
INDIANAPOUS. IN 46204-2970
(317) 269-2500 . (317) 269-2514 Fu
inclianapoWpmlaw.com
James A. L Buddenbaum
jbuddenbaum@parrlaw.com
ATTORNEYS
www.parrlaw.com
~(Q)~)f
August 16, 2001
J. Taggart Birge
BOSE MCKINNEY & EVANs, LLP
600 E. 96th Street, Suite 500
Indianapolis, IN 46140
Re: Sprint Spectrum Collocation/Administrative Appeal A-97-01
Dear Mr. Birge:
I am writing to invite you and your client (and representatives of the neighborhood association)
to meet with myself and representatives of Sprint at the neighborhood association's earliest
convenience to discuss issues surrounding Sprints' collocation on the existing tower and the
neighbors' appeal pending before the Carmel/Clay Board of Zoning Appeals. I would suggest a
meeting in advance of the September 14,2001 deadline for infonnation packets to go to the
board members might be appropriate, if either side wishes to submit additional materials for the
BZA's review.
Please advise as to how your clients would like to proceed.
Very truly yours,
Ijs
bcc: Patrick Allen
Joseph Espinosa
Larry 1. Wallace
Randolph G. Holt
1-3388 I
PARR RICHEY OBREMSKEY & MORTO
Lebanon Office
225 West Main Street. Lebanon. Indiana 46052-0668 . (765) 482-0110 or (317) 269-2509 . (765) 483-3444 Fax . lebanon@parrlaw.com
u
o
PROJECT: Radio Tower Co-locate at 1388
Queens Way, residential subdivision.
. I spoke with Jim Buddenbaum regarding this
permit. (He was provided with an original ILP form and asked to
turn it in when the permit is picked up).
. This is a radio tower on private property that
was approved, without BZA action, several years ago. The owner
is now attempting to sell co-locate space to Sprint. Buddenbaum,
who represents Sprint and the owner, believes this tower is
grandfathered.
. I told Buddenbaum I wasn't quite as sure as he
and looked quickly through the Ordinance while he was here,
however, he stated his firm had 'helped write the Ordinance' and
was sure this permit would not require approvals from zoning.
. I took the submittal and e-mailed Laurence
regarding these issues. Laurence says the submittal needs
Special Use approval from the BZA.
. On Weds., April 18, 2001, I left Buddenbaum a
message on his voice mail, advising him of this finding and
recommended he contact Laurence. Whe aurence &
Buddenbaum meet, I will a enba \ to come into our office
and retrieve this packa ~~\~ ~V' .
Gayle
08/27/01 MON 09:32 FAX 317 269 2514
PARR RICHEY
I4J 002
u 0
City of CarmefC'D AtlG 242001
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES
Michael P. Hollibaugh
Director
August 23,2001
Mr. Jay Lemmon
Q Serve Communications
4515 South High School Road
Indianapolis, IN 46241
RE: Revocation of Permit No.627.01
Dear Mr. Lemmon:
Pursuant to the authority vested in me by the general ordinances of the jurisdictional area
of the City of Carmel, Indiana, under whose jurisdiction all improvement location permits
(building permits) are issued for that City and for Clay Township, Indiana, I hereby
. revoke the above referenced permit.
This office has determined that, prior to the issuance of a permit for the proposed
''Equipment Shelter" on the "Lease Area" (as described in your Application for
Improvement Location Permit), the "Parent Tract" should have been divided into two (2)
or more smaller parcels. Under Chapter 3 of the Carmel Clay Zoning Ordinance, this
constitutes the subdivision ofland requiring plat approval by the Plan Commission.
Should you desire to submit an application for plat approval, you may contact Jon
Dobosiewicz of this Department to discuss the necessary process.
__ __.~it1~_e~IYt __. .
(XL~
Director
Department of Community Services
CC: James A. L. Buddenbaum, Attorney for Sprint Spectrum, LP ~.
ONE CNIC SQUARE CARMEL, INDIANA 46032 317/571-2417
EXHIBIT
I
2
Kendall, Jeff A
u
o
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Stahl, Gayfe H
Wednesday, April 18, 200110:14 AM
Ulllg, Laurence M
Kendall, Jeff A
Radio Tower
Regarding the radio tower in Queens Manor: Laurence, I left a message today with Jim Buddenbaumo that this
project would need special use approval and that he should contact you.
gayle
1
MicroPole
Q
-:
http://www.telestructures.com/products/photos/narrow -photo.html
o
Page 1 of 1
(})
!
RFCFIVED
~[! 18 2003
DOCS
2/1 7/2003
Q
Q
:t
http://www.utilitycamo.comlphotos/asheville2.jpg
~
Page 1 of 1
02/13/2003
Ligthning Tree EnvironmentaLSo1ution from Alan Dick
U
Alan Dick & Company Composites
Specialists in Wireless Infrastructure
[~] Environmental Solutions
Environmental
Solutions
Lightning Tree
Do you wish to reduce the environmental impact of CJ;!llYlc:lJ:
StrltC1lJLes. ?
Alan Dick and Companys' versatile, multidisciplined approach to the
Cellular industry has facilitated our understanding of the difficulties
regularly encountered in the construction of cellular networks, both
in the UK and overseas.
ADC have in recognition of this dedicated significant expertise to
the development of innovative camoufloaaged site solutions
The latest example of this activity can be seen with the ADC
'Lightning Tree'
In addition to the visual benefits provided by the ADC 'lightning tree'
the following further advantages are provided.
. Available in heights of 20m and 25m height variants
. Total concealment, via internal mounting, of antennas, supports
and ladder access.
. Fabrication from low maintenance materials - Providing a 25
year life expectancy
. Realistic profiled colour impregrated 'bark'
. High levels of safety and weather proof working conditions
. Simple, rapid erection due to minimal components
. Full RF clearance for cellular and microwave antennas,
achieving losses of less tan O.5dB at 23Ghz and 38Ghz, using
latest generation composite materials.
Futher benefits from the ADC lightning tree
. Improved possibilities for Planning Approval
. Extended life of internal equipment
. Minimal Maintenance
. Site Share Potential
. Safer conditions for operational personnel
http://www.a1andick.co.uk/pages/enviro/lightning_tree.htm1
(.)
E nvi ron mental
Solutions Home
Cellular Trees
Lightning Tree ,
Church Windows
Flagpoles, Signs &
Pole Structures
Dielectric Structures
Micro Cell Technology
ADC CompoSites
P resentati on s
Radom<!'s
!J.~
Page 1 of 3
6
02/1312003
o
o
Page 1 of 1
http://www.telestructures.com/products/photos/micropole/fullsize _ F .jpg
2/1 7/2003
Cellular Structures and celluDMonoPoles for Cellular Antennas fro(jlan Dick
Alan Dick & Company
Specialists in Wireless Infrastructure
[+] Cellular Communications
Cellular
Communications
Monopoles
The monpole is a versatile tubular pole developed for the world
wide cellular market, with special attention paid to environmental
acceptance. Aesthetic design was considered a top priority during
the development stages. The efficiency of the design allows it to be
an economic option for a range of heights up to 40m
The monopole can be used for microwave links, cellular and
telecommunications applications.
DESIGN
Under normal requirements, tower wind loading and structural
analysis are carried out in accordance with British Standard
BS8100: Code of Practice for the design of Lattice Towers and
Masts using computer models. However, if specified by a client,
other international codes may be adopted.
ADC's extensive world wide meterorological data allows design
structures for any location in the world.
In addition, the ADC design team capabilities extend to the design of
foundations, where any type of soil conditions can be catered for.
SAFETY
In the design and installation of pole structures, safety is of
paramount importance.
. The design code incorporates many features ensuring the
safety and serviceability of structures.
. The monopole comes fitted as standard with a ladder to the full
height of the tower. We can also supply an optional fall arrest
system which ensures the safety of the towers users.
. At the installation stage, the company's commitment to safety
and the experience of the site teams aim to minimise the risk of
accident.
Download Brochure
Monopoles
Do"mload Brochure
Slim line Monopoles
ANCillARIES
http://www .alandick.comJpages/cell ular/molopoles.html
Cellular Home
Cellular Solutions
Cellular Antennas
Cellular Structures
Monopoles
Lattice
Roof Top
Camouflage Solutions
Cable Accessories
Page I of 2
@)
02/13/2003
u
Date:
February 18, 2003
To:
u
::----i - -~- .: -.~,
I. \ r
~
RECFIVED
FEB 18 2003
DOCS
i-
l-
I _'
\ .-
Board of Zoning Appeals
\.---' .,
John Flanigan - Queen's Manor Neighborhood Assoc.
MonoPine Design if~ ~ G
Following is information on design from Penn Summit of West Hazleton, PA 18202.
Paul J. Ford (PJF) engineering company of Columbus, Ohio referred PennSummit.
(http://www.pennsummit.comlproducts.html#monopine )
From:
Subject:
\'/'
, ~
\'<tJ2~i.__
I spoke to Joe Tomsho of Summit and the following are his comments on the MonoPine
for a typical installation:
. The lightning rod attaches to the pole cap - extends higher.
. For a three-carrier pole, the diameter at the top ranges from 19" to 26."
. Three four-foot branches are placed at 75 degrees at the top.
. The branches are closer at the top, about 6" and then are spaced more
approaching the bottom.
. The branch lengths increase from the four feet at the top to ten feet where
branches stop.
. There are three densities offered: light, medium and heavy.
PJF also referred Sterling Towers, but I was unable to contact them. Thank you.
-:3P
MonoPine ™
View photo gallery
. MonoPine ™ Heights available to 200 ft
. Design allows up to 7 carriers
. Branches are RF-Friendly and contain no metal or other reflective
materials
. Branch sizes: 4 ft, 6 ft, 8 ft, and 10ft
. Light, medium, and heavy Branch Densities available
. Base pole is galvanized and clad with bark, camouflaged paint, standard
paint, or partial bark and paint
. Customize your antenna mounts - Various T -arm mounts and other
mounts available-
. Meets or exceeds TINEIA-222 latest version wind load requirements
0.\' ~ A-/Il-dl
2002 PLAN COMMISSION DOCKET LIST
Docket # Proiect Name Proiect Address Develooer Contact Phone # # Lots Acres Zonin!! Action Aoproved
0-02 Sub Waive a SW Little Farms, Replat of Lot 26 1205 E. 105th St;[R3] curbs & gutierWebster, Bruce & Dona Tim Stevens 2 0 Approved 5/2112002
0-02 Sub Waive a SW Little Farms, Replat of Lot 46 10401 Ethel Ave;[R3&R2] curbs & gTimothy M, Brower Timothy M, Brower 2 0 Approved 512112002
0-02 Sub Waive c SW Little Farms, Replat of Lot 26 1205 E. 105th St;[R3] minimum righWebster, Bruce & Dona Tim Stevens 2 0 Approved 5/2112002
0-02 Sub Waive b SW Little Farms, Replat of Lot 46 10401 Ethel Ave;[R3&R2] sidewalksTimothy M, Brower Timothy M. Brower 2 0 Approved 5/2112002
0-02 Sub Waive b SW Little Farms, Replat of Lot 26 1205 E. 105th St;[R3] sidewalks Webster, Bruce & Dona Tim Stevens . 2 0 Approved 5/2112002
1-02 REZONE Brookshire Golf Course NW 116StlNorth Gray Road;[RI to lCity of Carmel, DOCS Department of Law; Mo 0 0 Favorable 1/1512C
2-02 REZONE Lumberyard Mall Rezone[I-lllndsrial t SE cmr of I St SW & 2nd Ave SE City of Carmel, DOCS Department of Law; Mo 0 0 Favorable 2/19/2002
3-02 OA Amendments to C-IICity Center Ord Chptr 20E Sec 20E.0.3, 20E.5, 20E.OCity of Carmel, DOCS Department of Law; Mo 0 0 Favorable 2/19/2002
4-02 OA Amendments to C-2/01d Town Ord Chptr 20F.0.3, 20F.3, 20F.5, 20F.8 City of Carmel, DOCS DepartmentofLaw;Mo 0 0 Favorable 2/19/2002
5-02 SP Settler's Ridge @ Javerstick NW of East 13I1River Rd; [SI] Centex Homes Stoeppelwerth; Fleming, 13 5
6-02 ADLS Am ReguslParkwood Crossing, Bldg 3 (sig 600 E 96 St; [B6] within 31IMeridia ReguslParkwood Crossin Sign by Design; Marchb 0 0 Approved 2/512002
7-02 ADLSAm Hamilton Crossing III, A 1M Kiosk 12800 N. Meridian St;[B5] wthn 311Pinnacle Media, LLC Westergren, John 0 0 Approved 2/5/2002
8-02 DP/ADLS AMU @ Old Town City of Carmel, DOCS Department of Law; Mo 0 0
9-02 SP John A. Phelps Addition to the Town 0 NE emr 5th St SE & I st Ave SE; [R3Ross Moffitt & Elsie Mo Weihe Engineers, Bame 2 0 Administra 2/5/2002
10-02 REZONE Village of WestClay-Primary Plat SW emr West 131 StlTowne Rd(sec Brenwick TND Commun Kreutz, Jose 0 0 Favorable 6/18/2002
11-02 Ord Amen Village of West Clay-Text Amend SE comer W 13I/Towne Rd Brenwick TND Commun Kreutz, Jose 0 0 Favorable 6/1812{:/
12-02 Ord Amen Village of WestClay-Primary Plat Ame SW comer W I3llTowne Rd Brenwick TND Commun ~ 83
13-02 ADLS Am Pier I Imports 715 E Carmel Dr;[B8 & withn SR 43Pier I Imports Architect ~~ 0 Approved 4/9/2002
14-02 Plat Vacati Danbur Estates Subdivision SW comer Danbury Estates Sub.,lotlBoard of Commissioners Mike Ho 0 Approved 3/19/2002
15-02 SP Amend Parks @ Springmill Section 2, Park Place, Lot 56 City of Carmel, Dept of 0 Administra 21712002
16-02 SP Amend Parks @ Springmill Section 4, Park Meadow, Lots 106-1 City of Carmel, Dept of Akers, Bill 0 Administra 21712002
17-02 SP Village of West Clay, Sec 5001 SE ofW 131 StlTowne Road Brenwick TND Commun Kreutz, Jose 41 10
18-02 REZONE Leeper Rezone, S2IResidential to B-21 NE comer 131 StlUS 31 [S2/US 31 City of Carmel, Dept of Department of Law; Mo 0 0 Favorable 3/19/2002
Friday, July 19,2002 Page I of 5
.\ ..,'
Docket # Proiect Name Project Address Develooer Contact Phone # # Lots Acres Zonin!!: Action Aooroved
19-02 Prim Plat Western Hills Subdivision SE corner W 141 StlWest Road;[SI](platinum Properties Stoeppelwerth& Associa 101 80 Approved 4/23/2002
20-02 DP Parkwood Crossing East (College Hills NW of E 96 StlNorth College Ave (PDuke Realty Corporation Nelson & Frankenberger 0 20
21-02 SP Claybourne Estates, Sec I NW crnr Shelbome/w 131 & s side oBoomerang Dev. LLC Schneider Corp; Crosby 98 74
22-02 ADLS Am Merchants' Point Center Sign SE comer of Point Parkway & I 16th Merchants' Point Associa Hennessey,FUchard 0 0 Approved 3/5/2002
23-02 ADLS Am Carmel City Cntr Trct 3-Carmel Schwi NE Comer City Cntr Dr/3rd Ave SWCarmel Redevelopment 0 0 Approved 2/2812002
24-02 ADLS Am Long Branch Estates Subdivision sign ;[SI] Temp Sales Office 10 sign Pulte Homes of Indiana Michael Meneguzzi 0 0 Aproved 3/5/2002
25-02 Ord Amen Amend, Z-379-02 P-IlParks & Rec DOCS Dobosiewicz, IonlMolit 0 0 Favorable 3/19/2002
26-02 ADLS Am Long Branch Estates Subdivision 116 StILong Branch Lane;[SI] Sub sNortbside Investments, L Walter, Tim 0 0 Approved 3/51200
27-02 SP Shelborne Park Subdivision, See I NW sd of W 131 St/1I4 mi E Shelbr Roger Kessler Stoeppelwerth & Assoc, 28 22
28-02 SP Lakes @ Hayden Run, See I N side W 131 St/1I4 W ofTowne;[S ICentex Homes Stoeppelwerth & Assoc, 68 15
29-02 ADLS Am Lakes @ Hazel Dell, Subdivision sign Intesection Hazel Dell Pkwy & DellfiDress Premier Homes Baker & Daniel, Scimia, 0 0
30-02 ADLS Am Fazoli's 465 E. Carmel Dr;[B8] Roberts Group for Fazoli' Naylor, Mark 0 0 Approved 5/14/2002
31-02 CPA Comprehensive Plan, Old Meridian Adopt Mixed Medical Sub-Zone City of Carmel, Dept of 0 0 Approved 6/18/2002
32-02 OA Amendment, Old Meridian District ZO Ch 20G to add Mixed Medical Z City of Carmel, Dept of 0 0 Approved 6/18/2002
33-02 REZONE Old Meridian Mixed Use (Rezone) OM-MU,OM-, OM to OM-MM City of Carmel, Dept of 0 0 Approved 6/18/2002
34-02 ADLS West Carmel Retail Center 4335 W. 106 St; [B3] fence 106th Street Grill Garcia, Robert 0 0 Approved 4/2312002
35-02 ADLS Steak 'N Shake 635 E. Carmel Dr; [B8] Bldg addn Steak 'N Shake Chambers, Joe 0 0 Approved 4/2312002
36-02 ADLS S1. Vincent lrnrnediate Care 13250 Hazel Dell Comer, Lot 5;[B3]S1. Vincent lrnrnediate C Reis Law Firm; Monroe 0 0 Approved 4/9/20()
37-02 SP Village of West Clay, Prt Sec3001-A BI SE of West 13 I StlTowne Rd;[PUD] RH of Indiana, L.P. Schneider Engineering; , 0 0 Administra 4/2/2002
38-02 OA Amendment, Patch III Department ofCornrnuni 0 0 Approved 5/2112002
39-02 OA Amendment, Use Table Department of Communi 0 0
40-02 OA Amendment, Definitions Department of Communi 0 0
41-02 SP West Carmel Center-Block D (Replat) NE comer US 421 (Michigan) & Ret421 Reality, Inc. American Consulting, I 0 0
42-02 PP Sedgwick Subdivision N side W1311112 mi wst offowne Rc13WZ Development-I, L Barnes & Thomburg;W 27 33 Approved 5/21/2002
42-02 Sub Waive a Sedgwick Subdivision N side W13111/2 mi wst offoWne Rc13WZ Development-I, L Barnes & Thornburg; W 27 33 Approved 5/2112002
Friday, July 19,2002 Page 2 of 5
------.-
., "'.
Docket # Proiect Name Proiect Address Develooer Contact Phone # # Lots Acres Zoninl!: Action Aonroved
43-02 SP Townhomes @ City Center-Replat of NsideCityCenter Dr/8miwoDrd Ave RH of Indiana L.P. Schneider Eng.; Lash, K 17 Administra 4/12/2002
44-02 PP Aberdeen Bend Subdivision N side W13111/2 mi wstofTowne Rd;Jones Company Mid States Eng.; Moen, 50 37 Approved 6/18/2002
45-02 DP Amend 103rd Street Medical Building 200 West 103rd Street;[B3] expansioKite Construction Comp EMH&T; Kelly, Rich 0 0
46-02 DP/ADLS Carmax Auto Superstore East 96th St/Gray Road;[B3](2Iot/22 Carmax Auto Superstore Coots, Henke Wheeler; 2 22
47-02 PP Carmax Auto Superstore East 96th St/Gray Road;[B3](2Iot/22Carmax Auto Superstore Coots, Henke Wheeler; 2 22
48-02 ADLS Tipton Road, LLC 1220 AAA Way;[B8] Tipton Road, LLC Reis Law Firm, Reis, Pa 2 Approved 6/1812002
49-02 PP Amend Little Farms, Replat of Lot 26 1205 E. 105th St;[RJ](2 lot) Webster, Bruce & Dona Tim Stevens 2 0 Approved 5/2112002
50-02 Ord Amen Amendment, Parking Requirements Department of Communi 0 0 0
51-02 SP Carmax Auto Superstore East 96th St/Gray Rd;[B3](210t/22:l:)Carmax Auto Superstore Coots, Henke Wheeler; 2 22
52-02 ADLS St. Vincent Hospital 13500 N Meridian;[B6&US31IMeridSt.Vincent Hospital BSA Design; Feigh, Be 0 30 Approved 6/1812002
53-02 ADLS St. Peter's Church 3106 East Carmel Dr;[RI] parking loSt. Peter's United Church Weihe Engineering; Bar 0 0 . Approved 5/1412002
54-02 PP Amend Little Farms, Replat of Lot 46 10401 Ethel Ave;[RJ&R2](2Iot) Timothy M. Brower Timothy M. Brower 2 0 Approved 5/2112002
55-02 SP (Replat) Little Farms, Replat of Lot 46 10401 Ethel Ave;[RJ&R2](2 lot) Timothy M. Brower Timothy M. Brower 2 0
56-02 ADLS Am Mohawk Landing Center SE cmr E 126/S RangeLine Rd;[B7] 5254 Tivoli Partnership Reis Law Firm; Reis, Pa 0 0 Approved 5/1412002
57-02 REZONE Carey's Addition, Lot 8 Rezone RJ/BI- 130IstNE;[RJ/BIOTO] Department of Communi 0 0 Favorable 6/1812002
58-02 ADLS Am Arbors of CarmelNillages of Providen 382 Arbor Dr;[M3] signge Buckingham Arbors, LL Deogracias, Lynnette 0 0 Approved 6/1112002
59-02 ADLS Am Forum Credit Union - A TM Drive- Thr 2359 E 116 St;(B8] ATM Drive-Thr Forum Credit Union Nelson & Frankenberger 0 0 Approved 5/14/2002
60-02 ADLS Am Penske Chevrolet NE off 961Keystone A ve;[B3/SR 431Penske Chevrolet Nelson & Frankenberger 0 0 Approved 5/1412C'
61-02 ADLS Am Old National Bank - Carmel Banking 1430 S. Range Line Rd;(B3] (expansOld National Bank-Carm 0 0
62-02 DP/ADLS West Carmel Center, Blk 6-Carmel Cnt SE cmr W 106/Commerce;[B5/US 4 West 106 Street Propertie Reis Law Firm; Reis, Pa 0 4 Approved 7/16/2002
63-02 SP Settler's Ridge @ Haverstick, Sec 3 NW ofE 13llRiver Road;(SI](3410t/Centex Homes Stoeppelwerth & Assoc; 34 18
64-02 REZONE Dixie Hi-Way Addn, Lot 8/halflot 9 10820 N. College Ave;[R-3 to BI] Voigt, Leonard 0 0 Approved 7/1612002
65-02 SP Townhomes @ Hazel Dell NW E 116/Hazel Dell Pkwy;[R2](87 Platinum Properties Schneider Corp; Sexton, 87 24
66-02 DP Amend Hamilton Crossing Bldg # 5 (Revised) SWemr 131 StlUS 31 ;(B2/31 CorridDuke Realty Corp; Carm 0 0
67-02 DP Amend West Carmel Centr, Blk D, Lot 2 - Fift NE emer US 421IRetail Pkwy;[B3/UKlump & Assoc; Hartley, 0 0
Friday, July 19,2002 Page 3 of5
o
Friday, July 19,2002
Page 5 of 5
2001 PLAN COMMISSION DOCKET LIST
Docket # Proiect Name Proiect Address Develooer Contact Phone # # Lots Acres Zonin!! Action Aooroved
a SW Hazel Dell Ponds @ Waterstone NW of 116/Hazel Dell Pkwy (36 lots Mark Stout Development William Wendling 36 24
0-01 SW 159-01e SW SCO 6.5.1 min lot fintage E 116/Hazel Dell Pkwy Platinum Properties 0 0 Approved 4/23/2002
0-01 Ola sw West Carmel Center - Block G SE of 106/North Michigan Road, < 6Glendale Partners; McKa 0 0 Approved 6/19/2001
0-01 ZW 390la - Meijer Convenience Store NE comr CarmellPennsylvania[OM/ Meijer, Inc. Paul Reis 0 0 Approved 11/27/2001
0-01 Olb sw West Carmel Center - Block G SE of 106/North Michigan Road,con Glendale Partners; McKa 0 0 Approved 6/19/2001
0-01 122-0Ia SW SCO 6.2 suitability of La 14415 Cherry Tree Road;[S I] Robert Feeitt Keeler-Webb; DeHart, 0 0 Approved 1/15/2e
0-01 SW 124-OId SW SCO 6.5.21<two points a Christiansen, Glenn E. Stoeppelwerth; Olmstea 0 0
0-01 SW 124-OIa SW SCO 6.3.3 Elimination of NW comer 106/Ditch Rd Christiansen, Glenn E. Stoeppelwerth;Olmstead 0 0
0-01 SW 124-OIb SW SCO 6.3.7 culdesac to ex Christiansen, .Glenn E. Stoeppelwerth; Olmstea 0 0
0-01 SW 124-OIc SW SCO 6.5.7 Orient.ofhorne Christiansen, Glenn E. Stoeppelwerth; Olmstea 0 0
0-01 SW 159-01a SW SCO 7.0.1 min dist betwe E 116/Hazel Dell Pkwy Platinum Properties 0 0 Approved 4/23/2002
0-01 SW 159-01b SW SCO 7.6.3 min width of7 E 116/Hazel Dell Pkwy Platinum Properties 0 0 Approved 4/23/2002
0-01 SW 159-01d SW SCO 6.3.24 fmtge plexc6 E 116/Hazel Dell Pkwy Platinum Properties 0 0 Approved 4/23/2002
0-01 SW 139-OIa SW SCO 5.1.7 ext offac incld West 1411T0wne Road Centex Stoeppelwerth; Olmstea 0 0 Approved 1/15/2002
0-01 SW 139-Olb SW SCO 6.1.1 confw/comp p West 1411T0wne Road Centex Stoeppelwerth; Olmstea 0 0 Approved 1/15/2002
0-01 SW 139-Olc SW SCO 6.3 provision ofnts West 1411T0wne Road Centex Stoeppelwerth; OImstea 0 0 Approved 1/15/20
0-01 SW 141-01a SW SC06.3.7 cul-de-sac to ex West 1411T0wne Road Roehling, Raymond Nelson & Frankenberger 0 ()
0-01 SW 14I-OlbSWSC07115%StandardO West 1411T0wne Road Roehling, Raymond Nelson & Frankenberger 0 0
0-01 SW 159-OIc SW SCO 6.3.20 evy s prop ser E 116/Hazel Dell Pkwy Platinum Properties 0 0 Approved 4/23/2002
1-01 SP Prairie View Parks Ground @ NE Comer 131lRiver Rd (I Blk; 2.9 Carmel/Clay Parks Boar Keith Lash 0 0
2-01 SP Guilford Park SE comer I 16/Guilford Rd; (109 lot; Kosene & Kosene; Geral Paul Reis 109 0 6/15/200 I
3-01 SP Village of West Clay, See AGO I SE of I 311T0wne Rd. (1810tl2 ca/5.lBrenwiek Keith Lash 0 0
4-01 SP Village of West Clay, Sec AG02 SE of 13llTowne Rd (25 lotll cal7.3Brenwick Keith Lash 0 0
Friday, July 19,2002 Page I of8
Docket # Proiect Name Proiect Address Develoner Contact Phone # # Lots Acres Zonin!! Action Ann roved
22-01 ADLS Mayflower Park Subdivision ;subdivision sign Browning Investments, I Jamie Browning 0 0 Approved 5/15/2001
23-01 SP Meadowlark Office Park (Commercial) Pro Moo Ln (5 lotl???) Charlie Frankenberger 0 0 Admin Ap 3/13/200 I
24-01 SP Village of West Clay, sec 3001c, blk B, SW cor Rhc:ttsbury StlApsley Ln,2 10William Gordon Group, Keith Lash 2 0 Admin Ap 6/21/2001
25-01 Z College Hills RI-PUO East 96th Street and North College GerShman Brown & Ass Charlie Frankenberger 0 20 Favorable 6/19/200 I
26-01 SP Long Branch Estates, See I NW of 116/Shelbome Rd.[SI](5710tPlatinum Properties Tim Walter 57 0
27-01 SP Long Branch Estates, Sec 2 NW coml16/Shelbome Rd[SI](53 1d'latinum Properties Tim Walter 53 0
28-01 SP Amend Delaware Trace, Sec 4 Gray Eagle Ct, Kiowa Ct to Gray EagDept of Communications Dept of Law, John Moli 0 0 Admin A.p 3/1/2001
29-01 SP Amend Village ofWstCly, Sec 12001, Lot 302 1833 Milford St (PUD) address chanBrenwick Dev., Jose Kre David Warshauer 0 Admin Ap 3/2/2C
30-01 SP Amend Carmel Station, Sec I NE of Carmel Dr/Clark St [M3] r/w Carmel Station Homeow Christopher Barrows 0 0 Admin Ap 3/5/2002
31-01 SP Amend Carmel Station, See 3 NE of Carmel Dr/Clark St [M3] r/w Carmel Station Homeow Christopher Barrows 0 0 Admin Ap 3/5/2002
32-01 PP Williams Woods Subdivision (ROSa II NW of Spring Mill Rdl136St[SI] 97 Williams Creek Woods L Dave Barnes 0 0 Approved 6/19/2001
32-01 a subdivision waiver - Williams Woods NW of Spring Mill Rd/136St[SI] 97 Williams Creek Woods L Dave Barnes 73 75 Approved 6/19/200 I
33-01 ADLS Carraba's Italian Grill-Merchants' Squa NE of Keystone WaylKeystone Way Outback Steak House Jim NelsonlPhil Warren 0 Approved 6/19/200 1
34-01 ADLS Meridian Mark I, Onex Sign 11611 N. Meridian, wall sign Onex, Inc. Doug Staley 0 0 Approved 4/10/2001
35-01 OA Amendment, C-I District DOCS 0 0 Approved 4/17/2001
36-01 DP Kite PUD - Lowe's 14598 Lowe's Way; [PUD] 135,000-lKite Greyhound, LLC, K Paul Reis 0 0 Admin Ap 4/17/2001
37-01 ADLS Parkwood Crossing West NE comer 96/Spring Mill Rd[pUD]3Duke Weeks - Blair Car Phil Nicely 0 0 Approved 5/15/200 I
38-01 SP Brookstone Park of Carmel, Sec 2 SE comer 146/Ditch SCM Development Greg Snelling 42 29 0
39-01 ADLS Meijer Convenience Store NE comr CarmellPennsylvania[OM/ Meijer, Inc. Paul Reis 0 0 . Approved 11127/2001
40-01 ADLS Merchants' Point: Lot 2, O'Charley's SW ofl16IKeystone Ave [B8] RestaDesign & Engineering; B Phil Warenburg 0 0 Approved 6/19/2001
41-01 ADLS Merchants' Point, Lot 3, Longhorn Stea SW of 116/Keystone Ave [B8] Resta WD Partners; Koch, War Phil Warenburg 0 0 Approved ( 6/19/200 I
42-01 ADLS/DP Meridian@ 465 Heart Hospital SW comer 106/Meridian St [B6] HmREI Investments Paul Reis 0 0 Approved 6/19/2001
43-01 ADLS Mercants' Square; Donato's Pizza 1422 Keystone Way E [B8] RestauraDonato's Pizzeria Corp Kevin Cavanaugh 0 Approved 6/19/2001
44-01 ADLS/DP Crml City Cner Par 3 Carmel Schwinn! City Center [tl] SchwinnlFitness CeCarmel Redevelopment Dept of Law. - John Mol 0 0 Approved 4/1712001
45-01 SP Brighton Woods, See I NE of 1l6/Hazel Dell Pkwy; (18 lot; Roehling, Raymond James Rinehart, Stoeppe 0 0
Friday, JUlr 19,2002 Page 3 of8
Docket # Proiect Name Proiect Address Develooer Contact Phone # # Lots Acres Zonin!! Action Aooroved
46-01 ADLS Dan Young Chevrolet NE of 96/Keystone Ave [US 431] Dan Young Chevrolet; Y Charlie Frankenberger 0 0 Approved 7/17/2001
47-01 Connn Am Retreat, The NW of 96/Westfield Blvd; [R4] Gibralter Properties; Tod Harry Todd 0 0 Approved 6/19/200 I
48-01 SP Carmel Science & Tech Park, Blk 17, 1185 W. Carmel Dr. [OM/OJ (llotl Landmark Properties; Pa Drouin, Jim; Mid States 0 0 Admin Ap 6/8/2001
49-01 ADLS/Am Carlson Office & Warehouse Complex 9830 N. Michigan Re [SI1] (2.8:!:) Michigan Road Partners; 0 3 Approved 6/5/2001
50-01 CA Victory Beauty Systems 1437 Keystone Way [B8]; additional Victory Beauty Systems Miller, Kevin; Action Si 0 0
51-01 ADLS/Am Victory Beauty Systems 1437 Keystone Way [B8]; signage Victory Beauty Systems Miller, Kevin; Action Si 0 0 Approved 11120/200 I
52-01 PP Hazel Dell Ponds @ Waterstone ) NW of 116/Hazel Dell Pkwy (36 lots Mark Stout Development William Wendling 36 24
53-01 ADLS/Am Parkwood Crossing, Bldg 7, Morgan St NW of 96/College Ave Morgan Stanley John Smeltzer 0 0 Approved 6/5/2OC
54-0 I ADLS/Am Parkwood Crossing, Bldg 6, Duke Sign NW of 96/College Ave Morgan Stanley John Smeltzer 0 0 Approved 6/5/2001
55-01 ADLS/Am Shell Station, 3202 E. 96th St. 3202 E. 96th St, (signage, bldg modiShell Oil Co. Insight Engineering, Ge 0 0 Approved 7/17/2001
56-01 ADLS Chaucie's Place 1118 W. Main St. Hamilton Comity Vesta Sonia Leerkamp 0 0 Approved 6/19/2001
57-01 PP Carmel City Center-Carmel Trace Tow 3rd Ave SW/City Center-Carmel Tra RH of Indiana L.P. Keith Lash 41 2 Approved 6/19/2001
58-01 PP Amend West Carmel Center - Block G SE of 106/North Michigan Road Glendale Partners; McKa 0 0 Approved 6/19/200 I
59-01 SP West Carmel Center - Block G SE of 106/North Michigan Road Glendale Partners; McKa 0 0
60-01 SP West Carmel Center - Block A SE of 106/North Michigan Road; B- Glendale Partners; McKa American Consulting E 0 0 Admin Ap 12/5/2001
61-01 SP Windsor Grove Subdivision SW corner 106ITowne Rd[S 1 ](35 lotJim Caito Jim Rinehart 35 37 Approved 2/25/2002
62-01 SP Village of West Clay, Sec V02 SE comer 131lTowne Rd (8 lots/5.43Brenwick TND Connnlin Keith Lash 8 5
63-01 SP Village of West Clay, Sec 7501-A SE corner 131ITowne Rd (15 lots/5.3Brenwick TND Commun Keith Lash 15 5 C
64-01 SP Village of WestClay, Sec DPOla SE corner I 31ITowne Rd (2 lotlO.49 Brenwick TND Connnun Keith Lash 2 Admin Ap 6/2112001
65-01 PV College Hills NW of East 96thINorth College [Rl] Gershman Brown & Ass Charlie Frankenberger 20 Approved 7/17/2001
66-01 SP Village of West Clay, Sec 3001-C SE corner 13I1Town Rd (2 lot/0.27a Brenwick TND Connnun Keith Lash 2 Admin Ap 6/2112001
67-01 PP Meridian Mark Residence bin & Sprin NW of 116lPennsylvania; [B8] (3lot/Meridian Mile Associate Schneider Corporation; 3 8 Approved 7/1712001
68-01 SP Meridian Mark Residence bin & Sprin NW of 116lPennsylvania; [B8] (3lotlMeridian Mile Associate Schneider Corporation; 3 8 Admin Ap 11113/2001
69-01 PP Hayden Run Subdivision SW of 13llTowne; [S I] (70 lotl44.9:lCentex Homes Stoeppelwerth & Assoc. 70 45 Approved 10/16/2001
70-01 ADLS Meridian Technology Center-Househol NE corner 116IPennsylvania [B-6] (lHousehold International, 0 13 Withdrawn
Friday, July 19,2002 Page 4 of8
Docket # Proiect Name Proiect Address Develooer Contact Phone # # Lots Acres ZoniD!! Action Aooroved
71-01 SP Village of West Clay, Sec 9006 SE comer 131rrowne Rd (2910t/18. Brenwick TND Commun Keith Lash 29 18
72-01 SP Carmel City Center, the Townhomes@ NW comer City Cntr Dr/3rdAveSW f.RH of Indiana, OP Keith Lash 41 2 Admin Ap 9/18/2001
73-01 SP Mayflower Park, Blk 3, Lots 2a-2c) NW of 96/IUS 421; [11 ](3 10t/4.354 :iD & R Realty LLC CrossRoad Engineers; T 3 0 Admin Ap 7/23/2001
74-01 SP Merchants' Pointe SW comer 116lKeystone Ave [B8] (Merchants' Point Associa Weihe Engineering; Wa 0 14 Admin Ap 6/15/2001
75-01 ADLS-Am Old Meridian Professional Center 1185 W. Carmel Dr.[OM]92.46:1:) Landmark Properties, Inc 2
76-01 OA Ordinance Amendment DOCS 0 0 Favomble ; 8/21/2001
77-01 ADLS Am Ritz Charles 12156 N. Meridian [B6] (entrance reRitz Charles; Lazzara, C 0 0 Admin Ap 7/10/2001
78-01 ADLS Am Guilford Park Subdivision S of East 116/E of Guilford; [Rl] (si Dum Development Corp. Lintner, Cmig 0 0 Admin Ap 7/10/2C
79-01 DP/ADLS Townhomes @ City Center NW comer oOrd Ave SW/City Ctr R.H. of Indiana, L.P. Schneider Engineering; 0 2 Admin Ap 7/16/2001
80-01 ADLS Hazel Dell Comer Center ill Ground Si NW comer of 131IHazel Dell Pkwy [Plum Creek Partners, LL Reis taw Firm; Reis, Pa 0 0 Approved 9/18/200 1
81-01 SP Hazel Dell Comer, Lot 4 13190 Hazel Dell Pkwy [B-3](4.215 Plum Creek Partners, LL Reis Law Firm; Reis, Pa 4
82-01 ADLS Hazel Dell Comer, Lot 4 13190 Hazel Dell Pkwy [B-3](4.215 Plum Creek Pamters, LL Reis Law Frim; Reis, Pa 4 Approved 9/18/2001
83-01 ADLS Merchants' Pointe, Lot 1 - J.C. Sipe Je 2259 E. 116 St. [B8] (0.80:1:) J.e. Sipe Jewelers Nelson & Frankenberger 0 Withdmwn
84-01 ADLS Merchants' Pointe, Lot 4 - Macaroni Gr 2375 E. 116 St. [B8) (1.28:1:) Macaroni Grill Nelson & Frankenberger 0 Approved 9/18/2001
85-01 SP Village of West Clay, See 8002 SW of I 31rrowne Rd. [PUD](lllot/Brenwick TND Commun Schneider Eng.; Lash, K 11 3
86-01 SP Village of West Clay, Sec 3001-A, Blk SE of 13lrrowne Rd, [PUD](4110t/2Brenwick TND Commun Schneider Eng.; Lash, K 41 2 . Approved 8/21/2002
87-01 DP Amend North Haven Office Bldg. 9800 N. of Gray Road [RS](20.9:I:) C.P. Morgan; Boye, Mar Nelson & Fmnkenberger 0 21 Withdmwn 8/10/2001
88-01 SP Woods @ Williams Creek NW comer 136/Spring Mill Rd;[S 1 ](Williams Creek Woods, Weihe Engineering; Bar 73 75 C
89-01 ADLS Am Hardee's Food Systems, Inc. 2350 E. 116 St; [B-8] signage Hardee's Food Systems, I 0 0 Committee 9/5/200 I
90-01 SP North Haven Subdivision NW of 96/Gray Rd; [B3](210ts/42.9 C & J Company, LLC CSO; Snelling, Greg 2 43
91-01 SP Amend Crooked Stick West, Lot 68 2017 Burning Tree Lane; [SI](llot/<Richard S. MossIer BenchMark Engineering
92-01 SP Orin Jessup Land Co's 1st Addition, Lo E 108 St. [RJ](110t/0.459:1:) Shelley, James A. BenchMark Engineering 0
93-01 SP Amend Hazel Dell Sununit, Emerald Crest @, ;[SI] Address Change Davis Homes, Sokol, Tre W~, Li-Ching 2 0
94-01 ADLS Am Meridian Mark ill-Residence Inn/Sprin 11855 & 11895 N, Meridian[B6](5.6REI Investments; Hobbs, 0 6 Approved 8/7/2001
95-01 Comprehensi~e Plan, Throughfare Plan DOCS Hollibaugh, Michael 0 0 Favomble 8/21/2001
Friday, July 19,2002 Page 5 of8
Docket # Proiect Name Proiect Address Develoner Contact Phone # # Lots Acres Zonin!! Action Annroved
96-01 REZONE Old Town Overlay Zone City of Cannel, DOCS Department of Law; Moli' 0 0 Favorable 3/19/2002
97-01 DP/ADLS Hilton Garden Inn SE of 13l1llS 31;[B2](5~) Meridian Hotel Partners, Nelson & Frankenberger 0 5 Approved 10/1612001
98-01 ADLS Woodland Shoppes - Nextel Communi E 116/8. Range Line[B8] 95' monop CIS Communications; M 0 0 Approved 9/18/200 I
99-01 OA Village of West Clay-Modification ofD SE of 13 I st/Towne Rd; [POO] Brenwick TND Commun 0 0 Approved 10/1612001
100-01 SP Saddle Creek Sub - Sec. II NE comer 14lst/Towne Rd; [RI](54 Ditch Road Properties Paul [ Cripe; Burget, A 54 36
101-01 SP Saddle Creek Sub - Sec. 12 NE comer 141st/Towne Rd; [RI]~54 Ditch Road Properties Paull. Cripe; Burget, A 54 25
102-01 ADLS Am First Indiana Bank 2138 E 116st;[B8]modify bldg e1evaIFirst Indiana Ba~k CSO; Olds, Les 0 0 Approved 8/7/2001
103-01 ADLS Am Methodist Medical Plaza 100 Block of Pennsylvania [B6](US Methodist Medical Plaza Brernner&Wiley; Link, 0 0 Approved ( 9/8/20C
104-01 SP Village of West Clay, Sec 300l-C, Blk SE of 13 I Towne Rd. [POO) (210tslOWilliam Gordon Group, Schrieider Eng.; Lash, K 2 0 Admin Ap 2/1 9/2002
105-01 SP Amend Guilford Park, Lot 36 11564 Senie Ln;[RI] address changeDept of Communications 0 0 Admin Ap 8/2\12001
106-01 Ord Amen College Hills POO Ord Amendment NW of96INorth College Gershman Brown & Ass Nelson & Frankenberger 0 0 Withdrawn 10/812001
107-01 CA Indiana Developmental Training Cente SW comer 1IIIPennsylvania;[B5] coIndiana Developmental T Roger Ward Eng; Ward, 0 0 Approved 10/16/2001
108-0 I ADLS Indiana Developmental Training Cente SW comer 1IIIPennsylvania;[B5] mlndiana Developmental T Roger Ward Eng; Ward, 0 0 Approved 10/16/2001
109-01 SP (Replat) Valleybrook Subdivision, Sec 2, Lots 6 South end of Deer Ridge Place W. Steele Gudal Weihe Eng; Barnes, Da 2 0 Admin Ap ,9/26/2001
110-01 ADLS West Carmel Center, blk D, Target 10401 N. Michigan Rd;[B3] cart corrTarget Corp; Misialek, 0 0 Approved 9/18/2001
111-01 SP Village of West Clay, sec 650lb SE of 13lst/Towne Rd; [POO](6 loti Brenwick TND Commun Schneider Corp; Lash, 6 2 Admin A.p I 11211200 I
112-01 ADLS Am Carmel Drive Executive Office Park 755 & 756 W Cannel Dr;[M3] tenanShideler Dermatology Shideler, Carol 0 0
113-01 ADLS CH Land Office Building NW of 13lstINorth Meridian;[B-5](ICH Land LLC; Kaser, Cr Coots, Henke & Whee1e 0 2 Approved 11I20/2C
114-01 ADLS Am RCI - sign replacement 9998 N. Michigan Road;[Il], sign re RCI, LLC; Bellefuil, Rob 0 0 Approved 10/2/1001
115-01 ADLS Am Meridian Mark I - Liberty Mutuallnsur 11611 N. Meridian St;[B6] sign repllLiberty Mutual Insurance Staley Signs; Staley, Do 0 0 Approved 10/212001
116-01 REZONE Conseco Rezone 0 0
117-01 SP Village of West Clay, sec DPOIB SE of 131/Towne Rd;[POO]930 lotl2Brenwick TND Commun Schneider Corp; Lash, 30 2
118-01 ADLS Am Lowe's of Camel SE comer 146/US 31 [POO](bldg rn<Lowe's of Carmel Ratio Architects; Smith, 0 0 Approved 10/2/2001
(
119-01 PP Claybourne Estates Subdivision NW comer of Shelbourne Rdll 3 1st SBoomerange Developme Nelson & Frankenberger 259 199 Approved 12/18/2001
120-01 PP Papay Subdivision NE of 134/Towne Rd; [SI](llotl4.3lPapay, Anthony & Alice 4 Approved 11/27/2001
Friday, July 19,2002 Page 6 of8
Docket # Proiect Name Proiect Address Develooer Contact PhoDe # # Lots Acres ZoniD!! Action Aooroved
121-01 SP Papay Subdivision NE of I 34rroWne Rd; [S I ](1 10t/4.3(Papay, Anthony & Alice 4
122-01 PP Fecitt Subdivision 14415 Cherry Tree; [SI](4.4I:1:) Fecitt, Robert 4 4 Approved 1/15/2002
123-01 SP Fecitt Subdivision 14415 Cherry Tree; [S1](4.41:1:) Feci tt, Robert 4 4 Administra 3/4/2002
124-01 PP & SW Santuary, The Subdivision(124-Ola,b,c NE of 106/Crooked Stick [S I ](23 lot Christian, Glenn E. Stoepelwerth Eng.; Olm 23 28 Withdrawn 2/5/2002
125-01 Z 136 Street & Rohrer Road PUD SW of Marana Dr/Rohrer Rd; [B-3 tdIunters Creek Office Par Nelson & Frankenberger 0 5 Unfavorabl 6/18/2002
126-01 DP Amend Carmel Science & Technology Park,BI 790122 St; [M3](bldg addn) Carpenter/GMAC Caveness, David 0 0 Approved 12/18/2001
127-01 Z US Highway 31 & 146 Street PUD US 31/146th St; [B3 & RI](56.79 :I:)Lauth Property Group Reis Law Firm; Reis, Pa 0 57
128-01 Z North Gray Road & 146 Street PUD 146th StlNorth Gray Road; [Sl](l1.6Hearthview Residential, Reis Law Firm; Reis, Pa 0 12 Withdrawn 211 1/2OC
129-01 ADLS USTA Office Building NW of 96th St/Monon Greenway; [P Midwest Youth Tennis F Bose McKinney & Evan 0 0 Approved 11/20/2001
130-01 ADLS Am Meridian Mark I & Ii Sign - INRANG 11611 N. Meridian; [B3] (signage) INRANGE Staley Signs; Staley, Do 0 0 Approved 11/6/200 1
131-01 Z North Augusta, Sec I, Lot 8-11, Ila, I NE comer96/Michigan Road;[S I ](B City of Carmel, DOCS Department of Law; Mo 0 0 Favorable 11/27/2001
132-01 Ord Amen Amendment, Various City of Carmel, DOCS Department of Law; Mo 0 0 Favorable 1/15/2002
133-01 ADLS/Am First Indiana Bank 2138 E. 116 St; [B8] (signage) First Indiana Bank CSO; Huffman, David 0 0 Approved 1l/6/2001
134-01 ADLS/Am Sunrise Cafe (Signage) 11450 N. Meridian;[B6 & within US Sunrise Cafe MC Sign Co; Cotter, Da 0 0 Approved 12/5/200 I
135-01 REZONE Home Place Overlay Zone City of Carmel, DOCS Department of Law; Mo 0 0 Favorable 3/19/2002
J
136-01 Comp Plan Home Place Comprehensive Plan Arne City of Carmel, DOCS Department of Law; Mil 0 0 Favorable 2/19/2002
137-01 SP Hayden Run Subdivision West 13lst/Towne Rd;[SI] (23.444:1:Centex Homes Stoeppelwerth; OImstea 22 23
138-01 PP The Lakes at Hayden Run West l3lst/Towne Rd;[SI] (80.742:t:Centex Homes Stoeppelwerth; Olmstea III 81 C
139-01 PP The Ridge at Hayden Run West 14lst/Towne Rd;[SI](74.347:1:)Centex Homes Stoeppelwerth; Olmstea 105 74 Approved 1/15/2002
140-0 I PP Shelbome Park West 13lst/Shelbome Rd;[SI](39.9IKessler, Roger Stoeppelwerth; Olmstea 54 40 Approved 1/15/2002
141-01 PP The Hamptons West 14lst/Towne Rd;[SI](154.806)Roehling, Raymond Nelson & Frankenberger 192 155 Withdrawn 2/19/2002
142-01 DP Amend North Haven Office Bldg. 9800 N. Gray Rd;[RS] C.P. Morgan Nelson & Frankenberger 0 14 Approved 12/18/2001
143-01 SP (Replat) North Haven Office Bldg. 9800 N. Gray Rd;[RS] C.P. Morgan Nelson & Frankenberger 0 14
144-01 REZONE 96th and Gray Road NE comer Gray Rd/96st Street; [SI tGlendale Partners/Gray R Coots, Henke & Wheele 0 5
145-01 PP CMC Properties Subdivision West l3l!N. Meridian;[B5 & US 31 CH Land LLC & CMC Coots, Henke & Wheele 3 Il Approved 3/19/2002
Friday, July 19,2002 Page 7 of8
Docket # Proiect Name Proiect Addr~ss Develooer Contact Phone # # Lots Acres ZoniD!!: Action Aooroved
146-01 SP CMC Properties Subdivision West BI/N. Meridian;[B5 & US 31 CH Land LLC & CMC Coots, Henke & Wheele 3 II
147-01 DP/ADLS CMC Carmel Office Center NW comer US 31 & Main St(13lst/ CMC Properties, Inc. Coots, Henke & Wheele 0 9 Approved 3/19/2002
148-01 CA Hazel Dell Comer; Lots 2,3 & 4 NW comer East 131 & Hazel Dell PkPlum Creek Partners, LL Reis Law Firm, Reis, Pa 3 0 Approved 2/1912002
149-01 ADLS Am Sagamore Health Network, sign 11555 N. Meridian;[B6] within US 3Sagamore Health Networ Staley Signs; Staley, Do 0 0 Approved 12/512001
150-0 I DP Amend Stewart & Stewart Office Bldg 931 S. Range Line [B7] Stewart & Stewart Stewart, Phillip 0 0 Approved 2/19/200 I
151-01 PP Amend Spring Run Subdivision Northside of 106th1I/4 mile west of Chrisitian, Glenn E. Stoeppelwerth, Olmstea 0 0 Approved 5/21/2002
152-01 SP Hayes Two Level Luxury Townhouses 3774 & 3800 Bauer DrW;(210t/3.43 Indiana Basketball Acad Weihe Engineering; Bar 2 3 Admin Ap 12/17/2001
153-01 ADLS Am . Hamilton Crossing Building #3 Signag 12800 N Meridian St;[B2]w/in US31Duke Realty Corp Sign by Design; Marchb 0 0 Approved I/8/2OC
154-01 ADLS Am Carmel McDonalds Signage 750 Cannel Dr;[B8]; signage McDonalds GSW Lighting; Golden, 0 0 Approved 5/14/2002
155-01 ADLS Parkwood Crossing East (College Hills NW of East 96INorth College Ave; [Duke Realty Corporation Nelson & Frankenberger 0 20 Approved 2/1912002
156-01 ADLS Carmel City Center, Tract I, AMLI ent City Center Dr; [CI] multi-family ent 0 0 Approved 12/11I200 I
157-01 DP/ADLS Carmel City Center, Tract 5,Shapiro's City Center Dr; [CI] Shapiro's Rowland Design; McCo 0 0 Hearing Of I/2/2002
158-01 SP Amend Huntersfield, Lot 56 3802 Steeplechase Dr; addressing ch Dept of Communications Dept of Law; Molitor, J 0 0 Admin Ap 12/14/2001
159-01 PP Townhomes at Hazel Dell Subdivision E 116/Hazel Dell Pkwy;[R2](9910t/2Platinum Properties; Rio Schneider Eng; Lash, K 99 24 Approved 4/23/2002
160-01 OA Amendment, Zoning Ordinance Patch I Z-369-01: Various & Sundry City of CarmellDOCS Dept. of Law; Molitor, J 0 0 Favorable 2/19/2002
161-01 SP Amend Guilford Park, Lot 70, 73 921, 945 North Dr;[RI] address chanRoger Ward Eng.; G1eiss Roger Ward Eng; G1eiss 0 0
162-01 ADLS Am Dan Young Chevrolet NE of East 96 StlKystne Ave [B-3](4Dan Young Chevrolet Nelson & Frankenberger 0 0 Approved 2/5/2002
163-01 ADLS Merchants' Pointe, lot I, Forum Credit 2359 E 116 St [B-8] Forum Credit Union Nelson & Frankenberger 0 0 Approved 4/2312OC
164-01 ADLS Am Meridian Comers 13331 Meridian Comers Blvd; [B5] CH Land LLC; Lunsford, 0 0 Approved 1/8/2002
165-01 ADLS Am Lantern Eye Care & Laser Surgery (sig 10601 N. Pennsylvania Pkwy; [B5] Lanter Eye Care & Laser Premier Sign Group; Bo 0 0 Dismissed 4/9/2002
Friday, July 19,2002
'Page 8 of8
2000 PLAN COMMISSION DOCKET LIST
Docket # Proiect Name Proiect Address Develooer Contact Phone # # Lots Acres Zonin!! Action Aooroved
sw a Springwood Sub NW of 106 & Spring Mill Michael K1ien 13 16 Approved 6/20/2000
C Hazel Dell Road Subdivision 116 & HD/SCO 65.7 Lot I & 16 houMark Stout Dev 0 0 R-2 Table
A Weschase Subdivision SE of 146/Ditch Road Westchase ILC Jerry Co Stan NeallWeihe 0 0 Approved 3/2112000
B Hazel Dell Road Subdivision 116 & HD/SCO 6.3.19(1) 20' LE Mark Stout Dev 0 0 R-2 Table
0-00 c Estates of West Clay - wlin 50' ofDit 0 0
0-00 e OPUS zoning waiver 0 0 C
0-00 c OPUS zoning waiver 0 0
0-00 a OPUS zoning waiver 0 0
0-00 SW A John Phelps Addn, Lot 12, 13 NE Comer 5th St SEllst Ave SE Moffitt, Ross & Elsie Weihe Eng 0 0
0-00 d Estates of West Clay - private street 0 0
0-00 d OPUS zoning waiver 0 0
0-00 b Estates of West Clay - street width 0 0
0-00 a Estates of West Clay - forego stub 0 0
0-00 SW d Bonbar Place -% of scrub woodlands 0 0
0-00 SW c Bonbar Place - less than 50' street fro 0 0
0-00 SW b Bonbar Place - private street 0 0 C
0-00 SW a Bonbar Place - cui de sac 0 0
0-00 e Estates of West Clay - 18.8% open sp 0 0
0-00 b OPUS zoning waiver 0 0
1-00 SP Ashbury Park Sec. I SW 136th & Spring Mill Rd Pittman Partners Neal Smith 35 8 S-l
2-00 SP Ashbury Park Sec. 2 SW I 36th & Spring Mill Rd Pittman Partners Neal Smith 49 15 S-l
3-00 SP Ashbury Park Sec. 3 SW 136th & Spring Mill Road Pittman Partners Neal Smith 14 S-l
4-00 SP Spring Farms Sec. 3 SW 136th & Spring Mill Road Pittman Partners Neal Smith 18 20 S-I
Friday, July 19,2002 Page I of 10
Docket #
5-00 PP
6-00 SW
7-00 SW
8-00 SW
9-00 SW
10-00 SW
11-00 SW
12-00 PP
13-00 SW
14-00 PP
15-00 SW
16-00 SW
17-00 SP
18-00 SW
19-00 SW
20-00 SW
21-00 SW
22-00 SW
23-00 SW
24-00 SW
25-00 SW
26-00 SW
27-00 SW
28-00 PP
29-00 SP
Proiect Name
Springwood Subdivision
Springwood Subdivision
Springwood Subdivision
Springwood Subdivision
Springwood Subdivision
Springwood Subdivision
Springwood Subdivision
Maebeck Cormnons Subdivision
Maebeck Cormnons Subdivision
Anderson Acres Subdivision
Anderson Acres
Anderson Acres
Anderson Acres
Springwood Subdivision
Springwood Subdivision
Springwood Subdivision
Springwood Subdivision
Springwood Subdivision
Springwood Subdivision
Springwood Subdivision
Springwood Subdivision
Springwood Subdivision
Springwood Subdivision
Cannel Science & Tech Park Blk 7
Cannel Science & Tech Park, Blk 7
Proiect Address
Develoner
Contact
Michael Klein
Michael Klein
Michael Klein
Michael Klein
Michael Klein
Michael Klein
Michael Klein
Neal Smith
Neal Smith
Craig Anderson
Craig Anderson
Craig Anderson
Craig Anderson
Michael Klein
Michael Klein
Michael Kldn
Michael Klein
Michael Klein
Michael Klein
Michael Klein
Michael Klein
Michael Klein
Michael Klein
Baker & Daniels
Baker & Daniels
Phone #
814-5400
814-5400
814-5400
814-5400
814-5400
814-5400
814-5400
814-5400
814-5400
814-5400
814-5400
814-5400
814-5400
814-5400
814-5400
814-5400
814-5400
# Lots Acres Zonin!! Action Annroved
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
122
122
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
61
61
2
2
2
2
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
4
9
S-2
Approved
Approved - 3/21/2000
3/21/2000
S-2
S-2
Approved
3/21/2000
3/21/2000
3/2112000
3/21/2000
3/21/2000
4/1812~
2/21/2000
2/21/2000
2121/2000
3/2112000
3/21/2000
3/21/2000
3/21/2000
3/21/2OC
3121/2000
3/2112000
3/21/2000
3/21/2000
3/21/2000
2/15/2000
Page 2 of 10
Friday, July 19,2002
NW of 106th & Spring Mill Rd
SCM Development
NW of 106th & Spring Mill (6.3.20) SCM Development
6.2.1 Suitability of Land
SCM Development
6.3.19 (4) Frontage place landscape SCM Development
6.3.22 AccellDecel passing Blist. SCM Development
8.9 Sidewalks (internal) SCM Development
8.9 Sidewalks (multi-use path) SCM Development
NE Corner 141st & Towne Road Pittman Partners
sca 6.5.1 50' road
Pittman Partners
13496 Six Points Rd
Craig Anderson
sca 8.8 Curb-gutter
Craig Anderson
sca 8.9.1 sidewalk defer.
Craig Anderson
13495 Six Points Road
Craig Anderson
NW 106th & Spring Mill sca 7.4.4 SCM Development
sca 7.6 (F) Open Space
SCM Development
sca 7.7 (A) min.
SCM Development
sca 7.7 (B) Alteration
SCM Development
sca 7.7 (C)
sca 7.7 (D)
SCM Development
SCM Development
sea 7.7 (F)
SCM Development
sca 7.7 (1)
sca 7.7 (K)
SCM Development
SCM Development
sca 7.7 (L)
SCM Development
Keenan Investqlents
Keenan Investments
S-2
Approved
S-2
Approved
5-2
Approved
S-2
Approved
S-l
Approved
5-1
Table
S-I
Approved
S-I
Approved
S-I
Approved
S-l
S-2
Approved
S-2
Approved
S-2
Approved
S-2
Approved
S-2
Approved
S-2
Approved
S-2
Approved
S-2
Approved
S-2
Approved
S-2
Approved
M-3
Approved
M-3
Docket # Proiect Name Proiect Address Develooer Contact Phone # # Lots Acres Zoninl!: Action Aooroved
30-00 DP/ADLS Cannel Science & Tech Park, Blk 7 MlS0 Corp Headquarters Keenan Investments Baker & Daniels 0 0 M-3 Approved 2/15/2000
31-00 CA Cannel Science & Tech Park Blk 7 MlS0 Corp Headquarters Keenan Investments Baker & Daniels 0 0 M-3 Approved 2/15/2000
32-00 SP Lakes At Hazel Dell See. 3 SE I 26th & Hazel Dell Pkwy Zaring Homes 15 5 S-l Admin Ap 6/25/200 I
33-00 SP Lakes At Hazel Dell Sec 4 SE 126th & Hazel Dell Pkwy Zaring Homes 16 8 S-l
34-00 SP Village of West Clay sec 10011 SE 126th & Towne Road Brenwick 5 4 S-l
35-00 SP Village of West Clay sec 15003 SE 131st & Towne Road Brenwick 4 5 S-l
36-00 ADLS Fidelity Keystone Office Park NW Carmel Dr SR 431 Equicor Development 2 4 B-8 Approved 3/2l/2000
37-00 ADLS McDonald's 750 E Cannel Drive Rebuild McDonalds Corp 0 0 B-8 Withdrawn 'e
38-00 PP Fairgreen Trace Subdivision Phase 2 NW 116th & Range Line Road Kosene & Kosene 24 II R-l Approved 4/1812000
39-00 SW Fairgreen Trace SCO 6.5.1 - <50' row Kosene & Kosene 24 II R-l Approved 4/18/2000
40-00 SW Fairgreen Trace SCO 6.3.6 - 40' rig Kosene & Kosene 24 1'1 R-l Approved 4/18/2000
41-00 SW Fairgreen Trace SCO 6.3.6 - 24' pav Kosene & Kosene 24 II R-l Approved 4/1812000
42-00 SW Fairgreen Trace SCO 6.3.15 (4) cur Kosene & Kosene 24 11 R-l Approved 4/18/2000'
43-00 SW Fairgreen Trace SCO 7.7 (D) (7) Kosene & Kosene 24 II R-l Approved 4/18/2000
44-00 PP Treesdale Subdivision NE 96th & Towne Road Adam DeHart 21 39 S-1 Approved 4/1812000
45-00 SP Treesdale Subdivision NE 96th & Towne Road Adam DeHart 10 27 S-1 Approved 8/l/2000
46-00 ADLS Am Tucker Carmel Center 1119 Keystone Way Sign Group 0 0 B-8
47-00 Zone Arne Multi-family Zone Amendment One Civic Square Cannel Clay Plan Comm Same 0 0 Approved 3/2l/200e
48-00 SP Saddle Creek, See 7 NW of141stlDitch Ditch Road Properties Anne Burgett/Cripe 39 II
49-00 SP Saddle Creek, See 8 NW of 141stlDitch Ditch Road Properties Anne Burgett/Cripe 43 22
50-00 SP Saddle Creek, See 9 NW of 141stlDitch Ditch Road Properties Anne Burgett/Cripe 31 16
51-00 SP Saddle Creek, See 10 NW of 141stlDitch Ditch Road Properties Anne Burgett/Cripe 39 19
52-00 SP Westchase SE of I 46th/Ditch 13 16
53-00 SP Prairie View Chapman Claim Sec 2B SE of 131 stlRiver Road BOC/Cardinal Assoc David Warshauer 19 12
54-00 SP Prairie View Brooks Landing See2 NE of 131/River Rd BOC/Cardinal Assoc David Warshauer 17 13
Friday, July 19,2002 Page 3 of 10
Docket # Proiect Name Proiect Address Develooer Contact Phone # # Lots Acres Zonin!!: Action Aooroved
55-00 SP Prairie View Brooks Landing See 3 SE of I3llRiver BDC/Cardinan Assoc David ,Washauer 12 7
56-00 SP Hazel Dell Sununitt Emeral Crest, Sec NW of 131/Hazel Dell Pkwy Davis Homes Brad Ott 39 12
57 -00 PP A Hazel Dell Pond Subdivision 116 & HD/SCO 6.3.7 600' cuI de saMark Stout Dev. 0 0 R-2 Table
58-00 CPA Hazel Dell Pond NW of 116/Hazel Dell Pkwy Mark Stout Eric Pen Ian 31 23
59-00 PP Haverstick Sub Centex Homes Ed Fleming 67 25 S-I Approved 3/Z 1/2000
60-00 DP Providence & Old Meridian NE of Carmel Dr/Old Meridian St 0 0
61-00 DP/ADLS Marriott Suite Hotels 11800 N. Meridian 0 0 B-8 Approved 3/21/2000
62-00 Z City Center C-I District One Civic Square Carmel Carmel Redevelopment 0 0 I-I Approved 3/21/2~
63-00 City Center C-I District One Civic Square Carmel Carmel Redevelopment 0 0 C-I Approved 3/21/2000
64-00 CPA 96th Street Corridor Study One Civic Square Plan Conunission 0 0 Approved 3/21/2000
65-00 PP Amend Westchase Subdivision SE of 146thlDitch Road Westchase LLC Jerry Co Stan NeaVWeihe 13 160 Approved 3/21/2000
66-00 SP Plum Creek Farms, See 5 NE of I 26IKeystone Plum Creek Developmen Schneider 47 13
67-00 ADLS Am Cool Crk Estate Subdivision NE of I 26IKeystone Cool Creek Civic Assoc 0 0 Approved 4/11/2000
68-00 PP Amend John Phelps Addn, Lot 12, 13 NE Comer 5th St SEll st Ave SE Moffitt, Ross & Elsie Weihe Eng. 0 0 Approved 2/20/2001
69-00 ADLS/Am Carmel Science & Teeh Park SW Comer Carmel Dr/Hancock St ATAPCOCarmel Reis LawlMark Monroe 0 0 Approved 4/11/2000
70-00 ADLS/Am Hamilton Crossing 12297 N. Meridian St. W G Grinders 0 0 Approved 4/11/2000
71-00 ADLS/Am West Carmel Center, blk A SE Comer 106th StlUS 421, sign pacGlendale Partners 0 0 Approved 5/16/2000
72-00 SP Springwood NW of 106/Spring Mill Road SCM Development Nelson & Frankenberger 6 13 C
73-00 DP West Carmel Center, blk D 10401 N. Michigan Road, Target De Glendale Partners American Consulting 0 0 Approved 7/18/2000
74-00 SP English Oaks NE of 106/Shelbome Road Deylen Development Paull Cripe/Joe Sharp 0 0
75-00 SP Village of West Clay Sec 3oo0/c blk E,F Wm Gordon Group SchneiderIKeith Lash 0 0
76-00 ADLS/Am 502 E. Carmel 502 East Carmel Marsh Supermarket AGO ArchitectslMark P 0 0 Approved 5/16/2000
77-00 OA Amendment Old Meridian District DOCS 0 0 Approved 8/21/2000
78-00 Z Old Meridian District DOCS 0 0 Approved 8/21/2000
79-00 Z Carmel Oaks (RI-B6) NE of 116/Guildord Rd. Essex Corp, Craig Witz Nelson & Frankerberger 0 0 Positive Re 7/18/2000
Friday, July 19,2002 Page 4 of 10
,.
Docket # Proiect Name ProJect Address Develooer Contact Phone # # Lots Acres Zoninl!: Action Aooroved
80-00 PP Hazel Dell Comer Subdivision(80-o0a NW Comer 1311Haze1 Dell Plum Creek Partners Schneider Co. 6 15 Approved 6/20/2000
81-00 ADLS/Am Parkwood Crossing, Bldg 5 50 I E 96th Street Bose McKinney 0 0
82-00 OA Amendment ROSO City of Carmel 0 0 Favorable( 9121/2000
83-00 PP North American Park, lot 3 4102 W 96 Street Bill Estes Chevy Gary Murray 0 0 Approved 9/21/2000
84-00 DP/ADLS North American Park, lot 3 4102 W 96 Street Bill Estes Chevy Gary Murray 0 0 Approved 9121/2000
85-00 SP Village of West Clay SW of 13llDitch Road Brenwick/Tom Huston Keith Lash 36 36
86-00 SP Fairgreen Trace NW of I 16/Rangeline Road Kosene & Kosene Roger Ward 24 10
87-00 PP Amend Springwood Sub NW of 106 & Spring Mill SCM Developer 13 16 Approved 6/20/2C
88-00 SP Haverstick Settler's Ridge, Sec 1 NW of 131 & River Road Centex Homes Ed Fleming 27 15
89-00 SP Haverstick Lost Oaks, See 3 NW of 131 & River Road Centex Homes Ed Fleming 33 9
90-00 SP Haverstick Stone Haven, See 6 NW of 131 & River Road Centex Homes Ed Fleming 31 12
91-00 SP Shelboume Green, See 3 replat Davis Homes Li-Ching Wu 0 0
92-00 ADLSI Am Meridian Mark I 11611 N. Meridian Liberty Mutual- Robert Scott Newby 0 0 Withdrawn 1I/21/20oo
93-00 ADLS/Am Hamilton Crossing West, Bldg 3 0 0
94-00 SP Lakes @ Hazel Dell, See 5 SW of 126/Hazel Dell Zaring Homes Keith Lash 20 7 Admin Ap 8/27/2001
95-00 SP Lakes @ Hazel Dell, See 6 SW of I 26/Hazel Dell Zaring Homes Keith Lash 12 5 Admin Ap 5/15/2001
96-00 SP Lakes @ Hazel Dell, See 7 SW of 126/Hazel Dell Zaring Homes Keith Lash 14 6 Admin Ap 5/15/2001
97-00 SP Lakes @ Hazel Dell, See 11 SW of 126/Hazel Dell Zaring Homes Keith Lash 12 4 Admin Ap 11/1/2C
98-00 SP Lakes @ Hazel Dell, See 12 SW of I 26/Hazel Dell Zaring Homes Keith Lash 15 6
"
99-00 SP Village of West Clay SW of 131lDitch Road Brenwick Jose Kruetz 14 28
100-00 PP Sunset Heights 9900 Westfield Blvd Fleenon, Edgar' & Mary Dave Barnes 2 4 Approved 8/15/2000
101-00 SP Sunset Heights 9900 Westfield Blvd Fleenon, Edgar & Mary Dave Barnes 2 4
102-00 PP East 96th Street Auto Mall Subdivision Nelson & Frankenberger 4 0 Approved 9122/2000
103-00 SP East 96th Street Auto Mall Nelson & Frankenberger 4 0 Approved 1215/2000
104-00 Z Carmel City Center Carmel Redevelopment 0 0 Positive Re 6/20/2000
Friday, July 19,2002 Page 5 of 10
Docket # Proiect Name Proiect Address Develooer Contact Phone # # Lots Acres Zoninl!: Action Aooroved
105-00 OA Amendment C2ICity Center Cannel Redevelopment 0 0 Positive Re 6/2012000
106-00 Z Cannel City Center Cannel Redevelopment 0 0 Positive Re 6/20/2000
107-00 SP Mayflower Park NW of 96thlMichigan Road Browning Investments 0 0
108-00 PP Long Branch Estates Subdivision NW Comer of 116/Shelboume Pulte Homes Anne Burgett/Sean Deg 150 119 , Approved 11/21/2000
109-00 PP Guilford Park Subdivision SE comer 116/Guilford Kosene & Kosene Roger Ward 170 36 Approved 12/19/2000
110-00 PP Amend Parkside Village David Barnes 0 Approved 8/1512000
111-00 PP Amend Willson Village David Barnes 0 Approved 8/1512000
112-00 Plat Vacati Parkside Village David Barnes 0 Approved 8/15/2C
113-00 SP Wilson Village David Barnes 0
114-00 DP Amend St. Vincent Hospital Expansion 0 0 Approved 8/1512000
115-00 ADLS Saddle Creek Subdivision NW Comer 136 & Ditch Road - Per Ditch Properties Tim Walter 0 0
116-00 PP Amend Little Farms, lot 41 SW Comer of 104/Combs Ave Dave Barnes 4 0 Approved 8/1512000
117-00 SP Little Farms, lot 41 SW Comer of 104/Combs Ave Dave Barnes 4 0
118-00 ADLS-Am Parkwood Crossing, Bldg 6 600 E 96;Baker & DanielslDuke WelBaker & DanielslDuke Joe Scimia 0 0
119-00 SP Prairie View, Brooks Landing @, see I SE of 131/River Road George Krake BOCICardindal Assoc;G. Keith Lash 0 0 . Admin Ap 6/12/2000
120-00 SP High Grove; sec 2 NE of 116 StlHoover Road Estridge Brandon Burke 16 10
121-00 SP Lakes @ Hazel Dell, see 8 SE of 126thlHazel Dell Pkwy Zaring Homes Michael Willis 13 5
122-00 SP Lakes @ Hazel Dell, sec 9 SE of 126th1Hazel Dell Pkwy Zaring Homes Michael Willis 13 10 C
123-00 SP Lakes @ Hazel Dell, see 10 SE of I 26th/Hazel Dell Pkwy Zaring Homes Michael Willis 11 8
124-00 ADLS Lakes @ Hazel Dell subdivision SE of I 26th/Hazel Dell Pkwy / perm Zariing Homes Michael Willis 0 0
125-00 ADLS Am First National Bank & Trust 5683 Caff!1el Drive 1 signage Harcourt Management David Newton 0 0
126-00 SP High Grove NE of 116/Hoover Rd 1 address chan Dept of Communications Bill Akers/John Molitor 0 0 Admin Ap 7/6/2000
127-00 SP Lynwood SE of 126/Hazel Dell Pkwy 1 address Dept of Communications Bill Akers/John Molitor 0 0
128-00 SP Amend Chapman's Claim street name changes BOC Cardinal - George Keith Lash 0 0 Admin Ap 7/13/2000
129-00 PP Bonbar Place Subdivision - ROSa 7 q NW comer 1-465 /Manon Trail Kosene & Kosene Paul Reis 0 0 Subdivisio
Friday, July 19,2002 Page 6 of 10
Docket # Proiect Name Proiect Address Develooer Contact Phone # # Lots Acres Zonin~ Action Aooroved
130-00 SP Haverstick Lost Oaks sec I, lot 81 5854 Lost Oaks Dr / address change Centex Homes Tom Kutz 0 0
131-00 DP/ADLS Mayflower Park, blk 6, lot 2 SW Comer 99IMichigan 1- I auto deaCprysler Realty Paul Reis 0 0 Approved I 1/2 1/2000
132-00 Z Dodd Rezone SI-B8 SE Corner 146/Hazel Dell Plum Creek Partners Corby Thompson 0 11 Withdrawn 4/17/2001
133-00 PP Estates of West Clay Sub - I Non Q/R NW of 13llDitch Road Reserve @ Springmill Steve Pittman 25 45 Approved 9/22/2000
134-00 Z North Augusta sec 2, lots SW Corner 97/North Augusta Majestic Residence Majid Rastegar 4 2 Favorable \0/17/2000
135-00 Z North Augusta SW Corner 97/North Augusta - MajeMajestic Residence Majid Rastegar Approved 10/17/2000
136-00 SP North Augusta Sec 2, lot 29a replat SW Comer 97/North Augusta - MajeMajestic Residence Majid Rastegar 2
137-00 DP/ADLS Meridian @ 465- Thomson Electric SE of 103/Superior St - parking lot Hines Interest Pam Fox 0 14 Approved 8/1512C
138-00 Z Newark Village - lot 2,3 R2- B7 731 S. Range Line Rd Paul Reis 0 0 Approved 9/21/2000
139-00 DP/ADLS Newark lot 4 pt - 7 Newark Village lot 731 S. Range Line Rd Paul Reis 0 0 Approved 11/21/2000
140-00 SP Brookstone Park of Camlel, sec 1 SE of 146/ Ditch SCM Development 0 0 Admin Ap 7/25/2000
141-00 Z East 116th Street RI - M3 1306 & 1342 East 1l6th Street CP Morgan Communitie 0 7
142-00 DP/ADLS Carmel City Center-tract IA AMU City Center Drive City of Cannel/S. Engelk Dept. of Law 0 0
143-00 bThoroughfare Plan Amendment 131 st Street abd US 31 Carmel City Council Dept of Law 0 0 Certified \0/1712000
143-00 OA a Amendment Fee Schedule (see 143-0 ZO 29.6 Carmel City Council Dept. of Law 0 0 Approved 9/19/2000
144-00 SP Village of West Clay, sec \0005 Broad Street, addressing change Dept of Com Services Dept. of Law 0 0 Administra 8/4/2000
145-00 SP Village of West Clay, sec 10006, lot 34 Frogmore, addressing change Dept of Com Services Dept. of Law 0 0 Administra 8/4/2000
146-00 DP/ADLS West Carmel Center, Blk F N Michigan Road, Home Depot Glendale Partners, Kevin ACE, Kerri Buctcley 0 0 Approved 1/16/2C
147-00 SP West Carmel Center, Blk F N Michigan Road, (1 lot) Glendale Partners, Kevin ACE, Kerri Buckley 0
148-00 SP/Amend Delaware Trace, Sec 2 Navajo Way, Street name change Dept of Communication, Dept. of Law 0 0 Administra 8/22/2000
149-00 DP/Amend Providence @ Old Meridian NE of Carmel Dr/Old Meridian St, n Buckingham Companies Lynette Williams 0 0
150-00 ADLS/Am Burger King 613 E. Carmel Dr, monument sign JRF Coinstruction James Freiberger 0 0 Approved 9/5/2000
151-00 ADLS/Am OPUS Landmark @ Meridian Pennsylvania Pkwy Paul Reis 0 0 Approved 10/1712000
152-00 SP/Amend Lakes @ Hazel Dell, Sec I, Lot 141-14 Pebblestream Dr., addressing change DOCS 0 0 Admin Ap 9/1/2000
153-00 SP Huntersfield, lot # - # Addressing change DOCS 0 0 Admin Ap 9/8/2000
Friday, July 19,2002 Page 7 of 10
Docket # Proiect Name Proiect Address Develoner Contact Phone # # Lots Acres Zonin~ Action Annroved
154-00 REZONE 'Parkwood Crossing West S2-PUD NE Comer 96th/Spring Mill Road (3 Duke Weeks Phil Nicely 0 36 12/19/2000
155-00 PP Five-Ten Subdivision 510 1stAvenueNW Dave Barnes 0 0 Approved 1/16/2001
156-00 SP Five-Ten Subdivision 510 1st Avenue NW Dave Barnes 0 0
157-00 PP/Amend Little Farms Addn, Lot 15 (Minor repla NE Comer 105th/Combs St. Dave Barnes, 3 Approved 12/19/2000
157-00 SW a SW Little Farms Addn. Lot 14, 15 NE Comer 105th/Combs SI. SCO 8.8 Dave Barnes 0 0 Approved 12/19/2000
157-00 SW b SW Little Farms Addn, Lot 14, 15 NE Comer 105th/Combs St, SCO 8:9 Dave Barnes 0 0 Approved 12/19/2000
158-00 SP Little Farms Lot 14a, 15a, 15b NE Comer 105th/Combs SI. Dave Barnes 3
159-00 PP/Amend Dixie Highway Addn, lot 7 (Minor) 10801 N. College Ave. Dave Barnes 2 Approved 12119/2C
159-00 SW b Dixie Highway Addn 10809 N. College Av~ue, SCO 8.90 Dave Barnes 0 0 Approved 12/19/2000
159-00 SW a Dixie Highway Addn, lot 7 10801 N. College Avenue, SCO 8.8 c Dave Barnes 0 0 Approved 12/1912000
160-00 SP Dixie Highway, lot 7a, 7b 10801 N. College Avenue Dave Barnes 2
161-00 PP Merchants' Pointe Subdivision (comme Jim Nelson 0 0 Approved 11/21/2000
162-00 REZONE 99 Gray Road S l-RS NW of 96/Gray Road Jim Nelson 0 0 Favorable ll/21/20oo
163-00 PP/Amend Orin Jessup Land Co's 1 sl, lot 175 (2 lot ?7?) Jim Vires 0 0 Approved 7/17/2001
164-00 SP Overture, Sec 2 0 0
165-00 PP Meadowlark Office Park, Subdivision ( Pro Moo Lane (5 loti???) Charlie Frankenberger 0 0 Approved 12119/2000
166-00 SP Esates of Clay West NW comer 131 stlDitch Road;(25 loti 0 0
167-00 ADLS Am Carmel Science & Teeh Park, Blk 15 NE comer City Center Dr/Guilford RTimber Creek Homeown Ron Koster 0 0 Approved 10/18/20
168-00 DP ADLS/ Indiana Municipal Power Agency Adam DeHart 0 0 Approved ll/21/2oo0
169-00 PP Amend Hayes Two Level Luxury, blk A Jim Nelson 2 3 Approved 12/19/2000
170-00 SP Amend Hayes Two Level Luxury, blk A Jim Nelson 2 3
171-00 ADLSAm West Carmel Center, blk A - Walgreen 10595 N. Michigan Rd-sign package Kerry Buckley 0 0 Approved 1/16/2001
172-00 ADLS Am West Carmel Center, blk A - Wendy's 10585 N. Michigan Rd-sign package Kerry Buckley 0 0 Approved 1/16/2001
173-00 SP Plum Creek Farms, see 6 Cort Crosby 0 0
174-00 SP Lakes @ Hazel Dell, Sec I, CA 3, 4a 0 0
Friday, July 19,2002 Page 8 of 10
Docket # Proiect Name. Proiect Address Develooer Contact Phone # # Lots Acres ZlminS! Action Aooroved
175-00 SP Kensington Place, Lot # # Stan Neal 0 0 Admin Ap 10/18/2000
176-00 SP Haverstick, Lost Oaks @, see 2a, blk L W of Haverton Wy/River Rd. (I blkl Phil Nicely 0 0
177-00 OA Amendment, City Code Park Impact Fee Ordinance 0 0 Favorable 11/2112000
178-00 CPA Comprehension Plan, Thoroughfare PIa D1inois Street 0 0 Favorable 11/2112000
179-00 SP Prairie View, Brooks Landing @ See 1 Franklin Hall Tr (2 LotlO.7oo:l:) Zeller Construction Nelson & Frankenberger 0 0
180-00 SP Hazel Dell Comer, Lot I, Osco Drug ; (1lotl## :1:) 0 0
181-00 ADLS Hazel Dell Comer, Lot I, Osco Drug 0 0 Approved 3/20/2001
182-00 SP Hazel Dell Comer, Lot 6, Children's W ; (1Iotl## ) 0 0 Approved 8/28/2C
183-00 ADLS Hazel Dell Comer, Lot 6, Children's W ,. 0 0 Approved 1116/2001
184-00 Z Town Centre West NE of 106/Michigan Rd; (34.825:1:) 0 0 Withdrawn 3/20/200 I
185-00 ADLS Town Centre West NE of 106IMichigan Rd; (34.825:1:) 0 0
186-00 Z DePauw Rezone S2~B5 0 0 Favorable 6/19/200 I
187-00 Z DePauw Rezone S2-B5 0 0 Favorable 6/19/200 I
188-00 Z DePauw Rezone S2-B5 0 0 Favorable 11120/2001
189-00 ADLS Am Ford, Pearson 0 0 Approved 2/20/2001
190-00 ADLS/Am First Merchants Bank (21-97 DP/ADLS) sign, 106IMichiga Todd Ruetz, Camp Kyle 0 0
191-00 ADLS/Am Parkwood Crossing; B1dg I; Verizon 250 E. 96St; Verizon sign Verizon Wireless, Beccie Phil Nicely 0 0 Approved 12/19/2000
192-00 ADLS/Am Parkwood Crossing, Bldg 7, Morgan St 280 E 96St; Morgan Stanley Dean WMorgan Stanley Dean Wi John Smeltzer, Bose Mc 0 0 Approved 12/19/2C
193-00 ADLS/Am Newark, Lot 9-11, Stewart Place 821 & 831 S. Range Line Rd. [B7], ZThompson Thrift Dev.; P Jim Nelson 0 0 Approved 111612001
194-00 SP Newark, Lot 9a, Stewart Place 821 & 831 S. Range Line Rd. (11otllThompson Thrift Dev.; P Jim Nelson 0 0
195-00 SP Newark, Lot 5a, Ace Hardware 731 S. Range Line Rd. [B7] Ace Har Paul Reis 0 0 Administra 12/20/2000
196-00 ADLS Merchant's Sq. - First Indiana Bank 2138 E. 116 St. [B8] Bank David Huffman, CSO 0 0 Approved 1/16/2001
197-00 SP Mayflower Park, Blk I, Lots 4-6 Browning Development Jamie Browning 3 0
198-00 SP Merchants' Point Subdivision SW comer I 16/Keystone [B8] monu Jim Nelson 0 0 Approved 4/17/2001
199-00 ADLS Merchants' Point, Lot 5 - Border's Jim Nelson 0 0 Approved 4/17/2001
Friday, July 19,2002 Page 90flO
Docket # Proiect Name Proiect Address Develooer Contact Phone # # Lots Acres Zonin~ Action Aooroved
200-00 ADLS Merchants' Point, Lot 6 Jim Nelson 0 0 Approved 4/17/2011
201-00 ADLS Merchants' Point, Lot 7 Jim Nelson 0 0 Approved 4/1712001
203-00 SP Village of West Clay, See 8501 ; (#Iot, #,j,) Brenwick lND Commun Jose Kreutz
203-00 SP Yillage of West Clay, Sec 10001 ; 3810ts,19.186,j, Brenwick TND Commun Jose Kreutz 19 38
204-00 ADLS Am Carlson Office & Warehouse Complex 9830 N. Michigan Road, ArchitecturC & C Realty Reed Carlson 0 0
205-00 REZONE Ritter's Frozen Custard N. Rang~ Line Road 0 0 Withdrawn 2/20/2001
206-00 SP Delaware Trace, Sec 3, Lot 115-116 13300 & 13304 Kickapoo Tr., AddreDept of Communication, John Molitor 0 0 Admin. Ad 12/1912000
207-00 PP Amend West Carmel Center, Blk A, Ritter's Fr 10575 N. Michigan Rd. [B3] Glendale Partners, Kevin Kerry Budkley 0 0 Approved 2/2012C
208-00 SP Kingsborough, Sec 4 NE of 141stlDiurh Road Zaring Homes, Bob Kroh 0 0
c
Friday, July 19,2002
Page 10 of 10
1999 PC DOCKET LIST
7/19/2002
iIQll!RtM::; , '"!~0NQ l'bfflijl,f 8SliiN .~.~ t!i", ~ "'....a. J: ~G~8 ellOO eRCOOEa~li ~bE.VEli.€JeE, ., . m;<<er . ~ "'IIIEr'" ;SiI;~ llIfACn$~-t
1 Ii!I U U U ~ Ill! DP/ADLS 1-99 Hancock Profe IE of HancocklS Richard Carrig !Adam Dehart '574-0140 0 7
U ~ U U U U SP 2-99 Hancock Profe IE of HancocklS Richard Carrig iAdam Dehart 574-0140 0 7
u U Ill! U U U OA 3-99 PUD Ordinanc 1 Civic Sauare City Of Carmel .Mike Hollibaug 571-2412 0 0
U U U u ~ Ill! DP/ADLS 4-99 Hamplon Inn SE Corner 1261 Shahel Holels Sieve Granner 574-3704 0 2
5 U ~ U U U U SP 5-99 Fosler Estates SW Comer 146 Quadrand Dev Richard Hende 898-8282 40 27
6 U ~ U U U U SP 6-99 Villaae of West S of 131st, 1/4 Brenwick Devel Keith Lash 574-3797 14 8
~ U Ill! U U U U SP 7-99 Village of West S of 131st, 1/4 Brenwick Devel Keith Lash 574-3797 27 18
8 U ~ u u u U SP 8-99 !Village of West .S of 131st, 1/2 'BrenwickDevel,Keith Lash 574-3797 31 22
9 U ~ u u u U SP 9-99 IVillaae of West is of 131st, E of :Brenwick Devel 'Keith Lash 574-3797 8 24
10 ~ ~ U U U U PP/SP 10-99lRosemeade C i11642 Roseme IJames & Paule IDave Sexton 574-3797 2 0
11 ~ ~ U U U U PP/SP 11-991Carolina Com IE of Haverstick Will Wright IRichard Hende 898-8282 6 0
12 U U U U b{J U ADLS Am 12-99 iMarsh Signage 1536 E Carmel IBames Invest iBob Jolley 1692-0620 0 0
13 Ill! U U I U U U !PP, 13-99lFairareen Trac IE 116th Street iJerrv Kosene IDave Sexton 574-3797 40 13
14 U u U , b{J u I u Rezone 14-991Duke Rezone i96th & U.S. 31 iDuke Sieve Granner 1574-3704 0 64
I
15 Ill! Ill! U U u I U PP/SP 15-99 iBuckhorn Subd [Stone Dr, Lots Jim Dugan Sian Neal 846-6611 3 0
16 U Ill! U U u I u SP 16-99 iMoffitt Farms, IRiver Rd & 131 !Brenwick !Keith Lash 574-3797, 25 13
17 ~ U U u U I U PP 17-99 IHazel Dell Sum 'NE Comer of 1 'Davis Homes iChris White 1595-2900 163 88
18 b{J ~ .U U U ,U PP/SP 18-99 iShelborne Gre NE Comer 96t ,Davis Homes IChris While 1595-2903 1 2
19 IllI U U U U U PP 19-99 !Hiah Grove (for NE Com Hoov Estridge Devel ISteve Van Soel !582-2471 32 25
0 U u U , U b{J Ill! DP/ADLS 20-99 ILakeview Land 805 W Carmel StamP. Altman !John Altman 1257-6500 1 4
1 U Ill! U U U U SP 21-991Carmel Scienc West Carme Dr!Reliastar !John Altman 1257-6500 2 8
2 U U U U IllI Ill! DP/ADLS , 22-99 Hamilton Cross iSW Cor of 131 Duke Realty In iSteve Granner 1574-3704 1 9
3 U U U Ill! u u Rezone I 23-99 !Grevhound Sel Kevstone Way Skinner & Broa ISleve Granner 574-3704 . 1 4
4 U u U U IllI I Ill! DP/ADLS 24-99 !Carmel Conve NE Corn of 97t 'BK Partners Jamie Poczeka 547-5580 2 2
75 Ill! Ill! U U U U PP/SP 25-99 [North Augusla NE Com 97th BK Partners Jamie Poczeka 547-5580 2 2
6 Ill! ~ u u u u PP/SP 26-99 'Cherry Tree Es Cherry Tree Ea RDJ Custom H Adam DeHart 1574-0140 , 7 6
27 U U U U b!I IllI DP/ADLS 27-99lThomson India 1621 Chase C 'Greg Dawson Adam DeHart 574-0140 1 2
78 U Ill! U I u u u SP 28-99 ,Carmel Scienc 1621 Chase C Greg Dawson Adam DeHart ,574-0140 2 2
79 U U U U IllI t Ill! DP/ADLS 29-99 IOld Meridian 0,12401 Old Merl 12400 Old Meri Adam DeHart 574-0140 1 2
30 U U U U Ill! b!I iDP/ADLS 30-99 'Carlson Office 9830 N. Michig Reed Carlson Reed Carlson .876-2519 1 5
1 U U U IllI U U Rezone 31-99 ~ccu-Med 10820 N Colleg Leonard Voigt ,Leonard Voigt .846-7755 1 1
32 U ~ u u u u SP 32-99 Overture Subdi NW Com 126th Estridae Devel Cart CrosbY 898-8282 19 9
3 U Ill! U U U U SP 33-99 'Camden Walk W ofTowne R Camden Walk Ed Fleming 849-5935 35 33
4 U b!I U U U U SP 34-99 Hazel Dell See ISE & SW Com. Zaring Homes Richard Hende 898-8282 120 74
5 U U U U b{J u IADLS 35-99 'EDS Sian Ius 31 & 126th Glenborough P ,Matt Urbanski 451-4789 0 0
Page 1
c
c
1999 PC DOCKET LIST
7/19/2002 .
,........, ,rtl~ ... "., 'S0,1
.. ~ .
M-3 looroved 2/16/1999
M-3 ",proved 2/16/1999
PUD Ipproved 4/27/1999
8-3 \Dproved 3/16/1999
5-1 \Doroved 2/2/1999
PUD Ipproved 2/2/1999
PUD \Ilproved 2/2/1999
PUD \Dproved 2/2/1999
PUD \Iloroved 2/2/1999
R-1 \Doroved 2/2/1999
S-2 .ooroved 2/2/1999
8-8 ",proved 5/18/1999
R-1 IOOroVed 4/27/1999
-2/8-5 Tabled 9/21/1999
-1 \Ilproved 3/2/1999
-1 pproved 3/2/1999
S-1 \DO roved 6/15/1999
R-1 ",proved ' 4/20/1999
S-1 \Iloroved 5/18/1999
M-3 ",proved 4/20/1999
M-3 ",proved 4/20/1999
8-2 Approved 4/20/1999
8-8 No Recommen 5/18/1999
8-2 ",proved 8117/1999
8-2 ",proved 8/17/1999
S-1 ",proved 4/27/1999
M-3 - \Ilproved 4/27/1999
M-3 .ooroved 4/27/1999
M-3 Approved 4/27/1999
1-1 Approved 7/20/1999
R-3 Denied 6/15/1999
S-1 \Ilproved 4/13/1999
5-1 \Ilproved 4/13/1999
5-1 \Ilproved 4/13/1999
8-2 \Iloroved 5/18/1999
c
c
Page 2
1999 PC DOCKET LIST
7/19/2002
'iM~~jjtilSl!:'G,'()f,(IriR;jiiQlN" QN~ l!Wll(sreIDavEif~f ~8]~l31fjfiQ~'~" . RRQ'iJEQ.1t'AIiJi'ii 6l)~lfJrJeE~ I!;i:E.:Q~'il~: > 'Q~ .. ; aeSiim
6 0 0 i 0 b!J U U Rezone 36-99 !Fuller Property INW Comer of Gibrltar Prooert Jim Nelson 1844-0106 0 71
7 U U U U i'lI ~ DPAmendl 37-99 Parkwood Cros 'Nw Comer 96t Duke Realty In Steve Granner 1574-3704 0 7
8 0 U 0 U i'lI i'lI IDP/ADLS 38-99 Carmel Office lWest Carmel 0 'Brownine InvesJamie Brownin "1237-2828 1 4
9 U U U U b!J i'lI IDP/ADLS 39-99 'Corporate Hea 10801 North M Brownina Inves Jamie Brownin 1237-2828 1 6
0 U ~ U U U U SP 40-99 Stone Haven A NW of NW Cor Centex Homes 'Tom Kutz /915-2200 23 10
1 U ~ U U U U SP 41-99 !Village of West is of 131/W of Brenwick Devel Keith Lash -1574-3797 0 24
2 U b!J U U U U SP 42-99 !Plum Creek Fa ,E of Hael DellI IPlum Creek De CortCrosbv 898-8282 0 1
3 U ~ U U U U SP 43-99 jEmerald Crest iNE Corn.131st jDavis Homes IChris White !595-2903 I 74 32
~ b!J U U U U U PP 44-99 'Brookstone PariSE Corner of 0 ;SCM Develop- IBruce Faean !814-5402 107 49
5 D U U i'lI U I u z 45-99 :Providence @ NE Corner Car ,Buckineham C ILvnette William '974-1234 0 0
6 TI u u .U u I u PV 46-99 :Franke's Subdi !E of Old MeridiBuckinaham C ,Lvnette William ,974-1234 0 0
7 U U U U b!J , ~ DP/ADLS 47-99 !West Carmel C ,SE 106th & 42 Glendale Partn IKevin McKasso :264-9400 1 8
8 U ~ U U 0 u SP 48-99 West Carmel C SE 106th & 42 IGlendale Partn ,Kevin McKasso 1264-9400 1 8
9 b!J U. U U U U iPP 49-99 jAshburv Park S iW SpringmilV 'Pittman Partne ISteve Pittman 1580-9693 104 57
50 U U U , U b!J .U ADLS Am 50-99 iT elamon COrD 1000 E 116th S Telamon !Albert Chen 818-6666 0 0
51 U U U U i'lI .U ADLS Am 51-99 iBank One ATM 1200 E Carmel 'Bank One ,Mark Gummer '613-1300 1 0
52 U b!J 0 U U I U SP 52-99 !Village of West is of 131stIW of Brenwick IKeith Lash 574-3797 46 32
53 U b!J .U U U U SP 53-99 !Delaware Com W of Hazel Dell 'Oak View Asso iDavid Georee :898-8282 51 30
154 u u u u b{J U ADLS Am 54-99 'Blockbuster Aw E 116th Street !Blockbuster .Georae Fishell 248) 588-2244 0 0
155 TI U u U b!J U .ADLS Am 55-99;Baker Hill Sign NW Corner US IBaker Hill ,Jim Leahv 595-8111 0 0
56 U U U U b!J : b!J iDP/ADLS 56-99 Meridian Point ,SW Corner 106iREI IJulie Hall 573-6048 0 14
57 U U U U b!J i'lI nP/ADLS 57-99 !Max and Erma' ,SE Corner 126t 'Max and Erma' Steve Granner 574-3704 0 2
58 0 ~ 0 U U U SP 58-99 iKingsborough NE Corner Ditc IZarina Homes !Bill Brvant 849-5935 29 .17
9 U b!J U U U U SP 59-99 !Villaee of West S of 131st 1/4 'Brenwick Devel ,Keith Lash 574-3797 48 14
0 U ~ U U U U SP 60-99 IFairgreen Trac N of 141st St, Jerrv Kosene Keith Lash 299-9999 40 14
1 TI b!J U U U U SP 61-99 Carolina Com INorth of 106th, I Will Wriaht .Richard Henge 898-8282 2 0
2 U U U U b!J U ADLS 62-99 Merrill Lynch SI!Parkwood Cros Phil Nicely !Phil Nicely 574-3700 0
63 U U U U b!J i'lI 'OP/ADLS 63-99 'Seven Parkwo .280.E 96th St Duke Blair Carmosin 1808-6179 0 4
4 U b!J U U U U SP 64-99 jHigh Grove IN of 116th & E iEstridge Devel Steve VanSole 1846-7311 16 16
5 TI i'lI U U U U SP 65-~Parks At Sprin 'N of 131st SE Estridae Devel IDave Sexton 582-2471 3' 0
66 U IllI U U L,J. U SP 66-99 iPlum Creek Fa 126th & River Plum Creek De Corbv Thomps 849-7607 28 10
67 U U i'lI U U U OA 67-99 !Zoning Ord, Su Carmel/Clay PI Department of 1St eve Enaelkin 571-2417 0 0
8 U U U U b!J U ADLS 68-99lBennett Techn 11200 Michiga Buckinaham C Lvnnette Willia 974-1234 0 0
9 U U U U b!J I U ADLS 69-99 IPenera Bread 2476 E. 116th Knead Bread, Phil O'Connell (616) 983-3888 0 0
0 0 U 0 U i'lI I U ADLS 70-99 :Park Place Ce ,NE Corn Adam Park Place Ce Adam DeHart 574-0140 I 2 7
Page 3
c
o
1999 PC DOCKET. LIST
7/19/2002
lafllsGi "~-']o~ IlJ1\1iEtAee90~
5-2 - R-4 Approved 6/15/1999
B-6 IPproved 5/18/1999
M-3 IPproved . 5/18/1999
B-5 Vithdrawn 6/15/1999
S-1 (Clust IPProved 5/5/1999
PUD pproved 5/5/1999
15-1 IDOroVed 5/5/1999
S-1 Ipproved 6/15/1999
15-1 IpproVed 8/17/1999
M-3 loproved 8/17/1999
M-3 IOOroved 8/1711999
B-3 Ipproved 7/201.1999
B-3 IPproved 7/20/1999
15-1 IPoroved 7/20/1999
M-3 \Ooroved 6/1/1999
B-8 Ipproved 717/1999
PUD Ipproved 6/1/1999
S-1 Aooroved . 6/15/1999
B-8 IPproved 6/15/1999
B-2 pproved 6/15/1999
B-6 \Ooroved 8/1711999
B-3 IPproved 9/21/1999
S-1 IPproved 7/6/1999
~UD IPproved 7/6/1999
R-1 IPproved 7/6/1999
S-1 looroved 7/6/1999
B-6 IPproved 7/20/1999
B-6 lPproved 811711999
S-1 \Ooroved 8/311999
S-1 IPproved 8/311999
S-1 IPProved 8/3/1999
lPoroved 811711999
1-1 \Ooroved 8/17/1999
B-8 IPProved 9121/1999
M-3 IPproved 10/19/1999
c
c
Page 4
~'
2 U
73 U
74 U
75 U
76 U
7 u
8 u
9 U
o U
1 U
2 u
83 U
84 U
5 ~
6 ,U
7 U
8 u
9 U
o U
1 U
2 U
3 U
4 u
5 U
6 U
7 U
8 U
99 U
100 u
101 U
102 U
103 U
104 u
105 U
1999 PC DOCKET LIST
.,:.liJNI!fIORDII':l' Ecl:ll!litWAQliiS?lnmtlill M.R~rJl O~(:({~W1P..ll~EQ,'t',i;8~ A({~aE - "fr)~Ee"",,,,;;II~'l!!'~~W.A~"
~
U
b!1
~
~
U
U
U
U
b!1
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
~
b{J
b!1
~
b{J
b!1
U
U
U
~
U
b!1
~
b{J
U
U
~
U
u
U
U
U
U
U
U
u
U
U
U
~
U
U
U
U
U
.U
U
U
U
U
U
~
U
U
U
U
U
u
U
U
U
u
U
u
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
b{J
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
b{J
U
U
U
U
U
U
b{J
U I
b{J
U
u
U
U
b{J
~
~
U
b{J
U
b!:I
b!:I
U
b{J
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
~
U
U
U
U
U
b{J
~
U
U
U
b{J
U
U
o
U
b{J
U
o
U
U
U
b!1
U
o
U
U
~
U
U
b{J
U
U
U
b!:I
~
b{J
U
U
U
U
U
~
U
U
SP
DP/ADLS
SP
SP
SP
CA
DPIADLS
ADLS Am
ADLS Am
. SP
ADLS
OA
DP/ADLS
ADLS Am
Prim.Plat
ADLS
Rezone
See, Plat
Sec. Plat
Sec. Plat
iSec. Plat
Sec. Plat
Sec. Plat
Ord. Amen
DP Amend
'DP/ADLS
SP
,Rezone
SP
SP
SP
ADLS Am
ADLS Am
SP
Rezone
71-99 IPark Place Ce NE Com Adam !Park Place Ce 'Adam DeHart 1574-0140
72-99 Valvoline Oil L 10400 N. Michl Moench Engin Brian Moench 539-4915
73-99 'Ashburv Park S ISW Quad 136t Steve Pillman Steve Pittman 580-9693
74-99 Ashburv Park S SW Quad 136t Steve Pillman Steve Pillman 580-9693
75-99 SDrina Farms SW Quad 136t Steve Pillman Steve Pittman ,580-9693
76-99 iPenn Corp. Offi 10900 N. Penn Greg Snelling Greg Snelling 634-6434
77-99 Penn COrD Offi 10900 N. Penn Greg Snelling IGreg Snelling 634-6434
78-99 12400 Old Meri 112401-12415 N 'Jeff Worrell !Adam DeHart 574-0410
79-99 'St. Vincent Car 13450 N. Merid 'St. Vincent Hos [Christopher An 633-6300
80-99 Chapman's Cia 1131st & River Brenwick DevellJose Kreutz '574-3400
81-99 Meadowlark Of:698 Pro-Med L ,Steve Dauby !Steve Dauby 1848-5700
82-99 10ld Meridian Di ,Old Meridian C iDOCS Mike Hollibaug !571-2417
83-99 ,Old Meridian P ,1185 Carmel 0 ,MSE iBrian Pahud 1580-2650
84~99 IN In~urance 350 E. 96th Parkwood Xg 'Jos. Burger 349-7600
85-99 iWestchase Su ISE of 1461Ditc rWestchase LL IJim Nelson 844-0106
86-99 ipenn CorD. Ph. 10900 blk N.Pe iBrowning Inves iGreg Snelling 1634-6434
87-99 HealthlDental 0 :E. 96th !Jasneek Health iHarvinder Dah '876-0876
88-99 'Brookstone PariSE of 146/Ditc ISCM Develope iGreg Snelling 684-6434
89-99 iBrookstone PariSE cor 1461DitclSCM Develope ,GreG Snelling 1634-6434
90-99 'NIl. Clay 5006 '126thlTowne R iBrenwick TND iKeith Lash 574-3797
91-99 W. Clav 1001 1126thlDitch lBrenwick TND !Keith Lash 574-3797
92-99 'WClavProvost 131stlDitch . '!Brenwick TND iKeith Lash 574-3797
93-99 Del. Trace See E Hazeldell/No 10ak View Mick Scheetz 844-5111
94-99 US 31 Overlav ICarmel Plan C iDOCS 'Mike Hollibaug 571-2417
95-991 homson Cons 10330 N Meridi CSO Charlie Franke 844-0106
96-99 lIVest Carmel C iN Michigan Rd 'Meijer, Inc. Jamie Poczeka 841-1000
97-99lir.1est Carmel C IN Michigan Rd Meijer, Inc. Jamie Poczeka 841-1000
98-99 ,Kite Rezone ISE Comer 146tKite Real Estat Paul Reis 848-4886
99-99 lLakes @ HazellNE of 131stlHa iZaring Homes, -David Sexton 574-3797
100-99 !Buckhorn Estat !Ditch/141st St ICarrigerlWilso iStan Neal 846-6611
101-99 Stone Have At 131st & River ICentex Homes Stoeppleworth 849-5935
102-99 iWindsor Court 11610 Technol !Stephen Dumi Stephen Duml 818-1786
103-99 Goddard Scho 160 Medical Dr !Garv Wirtz Garv Wirtz 610) 265-8510
104-99 Eaale Ridae S 121st St & WesiDura Develop 'Dave Sexton 898-8282
105-99 iMerchants' Poi SW 116th & Ke !Linder GrouD Schneider 898-8282
Page 5
711912002
"-"i1\~"'J",'''~,,,'_' -,'
"r~'Mli;:S1,'f;~
2 7
o 1
35 13
49 15
o 0
o 10
o 0
1 2
o 0
46 25
1 3
0' 0
o 3
1 0
13 17
10
o
20
29
14
19
7
- 49
o
o
26
o
26
6
o
o
6
1
51
o
c
o
58 .
42
42
38
61
o
1
01
2
171
o
o
1
1
102
o
c
1999 PC DOCKET LIST
7/1912002
t~NlNcmIEA1~;'IL -::~l&f~ei\Q~
M-3 Approved 10/5/1999
1-1 Approved 10/19/1999
S-1 .ooroved 9/7/1999
~-1 ,pproved 91711999
5-1 .oproved 91711999
8-6 ;pproved 10/19/1999
8-6 .pproved 10/19/1999
M-3 pproved 9/21/1999
8-6 I,pproved 9/7/1999
5-1 Approved 91711999
B-6 .pproved 2115/2000
.pproved 11/16/1999
M-3 ,pproved 11/16/1999
B-6 .pproved 10/19/1999
5-1 ,pproved 12/21/1999
8-6 pproved 11/1611999
R-1 ithdrawn 211512000
5-1 pproved - 11/3/1999
5-1 .oproved _ 11/3/1999
PUD .pproved 121711999
PUD ,pproved 1217/1999
PUD .pproved 1217/1999
5-1 Approved 1217/1999
Approved 12/21/1999
B-3 Approved 12/21/1999
B-3 Tabled
B-3 Aporoved
B-2 Approved 3/21/2000
5-1 Approved 3/21/2000
S-1 Approved 121711999
S-1 Ipproved 121711999
B-6 \pproved 1217/1999
B-8 -. \pproved 121711999
5-1 Ipproved 1/412000
M-3 \pproved
c'
c
Page 6
1999 PC DOCKET LIST
Page 7
7/19/2002
~E;'
1 4
1 4
27 21
o o.
c
c
1999 PC DOCKET LIST
7/19/2002
, '~'rt~.. '''Q;
11/21/2000
11/21/2000
2/15/2000
Page 8
c'
c:
1998 PC docket dbase
U' " ,'i"\ ~~~,;.~ w lli. IRizg ~,t1f~ fi)1Y.'11~!llit QaJ:Ket p.r.orilc.~Niltfi'; f!i:tliWAaafn/fmQll~op_@n. \fj'oniifml ~aoti lA'ttiill6H! . ~#,if '''"" ~ ,,~
~1'ID1ir'"
U 0 0 0 ~ U ADLS 1-98 Carmel Center Executive Dr. 'Mick Scheetz Richard Hende 1(317) 898 1 2B-8 .pproved 1/20/1998
U U U U b!1 U ADLS 2-98 Carmel Center Executive Dr. Mick Scheetz 'Richard Hende (317) 89/3 1 21B-8 .pproved 1120/1998
U b!1 U U U U SP 3-98 Lost Oaks @ H INW Comer Riv Centex Homes Tom Kutz (317) 574 33 17 S-1 , .pproved 3/3/1998
U U U U b!1 ~ ,DPADLS 4-98 Pro Care 9801 N August Pro Care Mort Rolski (317) 871 1 5 S-1 .pproved 2/17/1998
U U U U Il!1 ~. DPADLS 5-98 Weston Shopp , NE Comer 106 Glendale Partn Jim Nelson (317) 844 0 5B-2 lAPproved 1/20/1998
U U U U .~ Il!1 DPADLS 6-98 Conseco, Bldg . 560 College Dri Conseco Bob Olson (317) 848 0 371B-2 Approved 1/20/1998
U b!1 U U U U SP 7-98 Moffitt Farm @ NW Comer 13 Brenwick Jose Kreutz (317) 574 29 16 S-1 Approved 1/20/1998
Ill! Il!1 U U U U PPSP 8-98 Lucky Forward SE Comer 131 I Vincent Schnei Vincent Schnei 1(317) 844 2 5S-1 Approved 1/20/1998
U U b!1 U U U iOA 9-98 Open Space 0 Carmel Clay PI :Ramona Hanc 1(317) 571 0 0
U U b!1 U U U OA 10-981Suodivision Or Carmel Clay PI Ramona Hanc 1(317) 571 0 0
U U U ~ U U iZ. 11~98'Parkwood Cros NE Comer 96t !Duke iSteve Granner 1(317) 574 0 3!B-6 Approved 3/17/1998
U U U U Il!1 ~ IDPAMEN' 12-98 Parkwood 5 96th & College'Duke ,Craig Flanderm . (317) 574 0 11 [B-6 Approved 3/17/1998
U U U U ~ U ADLSAM 13-98 Kahns Signage ' 313 E Carmel IKahn's Joe Husar (317) 817 0 OIB-8 Approved 2/17/1998
U U U U Il!1 ~ DPADLS 14-98'Carpenters Bet 122nd St., East-Carpenter Dave Cavenes ' (317) 844 0 61M-3 Approved 3/17/1998
U ~ U U U U SP , 15-98 Carpenter Bett 122nd St., East:Carpenter IDave Cavenes (317) 844 0 6!M-3 Approved 3/17/1998
~ b!1 U U U U PPSP 16-98 Woodhaven,L ,Lot 27 IJohn Olenick IBob Edwards (317) 696 1 21S-1 Approved 3/17/1998
U U U ~ .U U ,REZONE 17-98 Village of West 131st & Hoover,Brenwick Devel David Warshau (317) 574 o 6811S-1 pproved 2/17/1999
Il!1 U U IU U U PI" 18-981Village of West 131st & Hoover ,Brenwick David Warshav (317) 574 o 6811S-1 '\pproved 1/19/1999
U U U U b!1 b!1 DPADLS 19-98 World's Gym 820 E. 122nd S 1W0rld's Gym Richard Erikso (317) 580 1 3[M-3 ~proved 3/17/1998
U b!1 U U U U SP 20-98'World's Gym 820 E. 122nd S IWorld's Gym Richard Erikso (317) 580 1 3iM-3 iApproved 3/17/1998
U U U U U U 21-98 Void Void J !Void Void 0 01
u u u u U Il!1 01" 22-98 Carmel Lodgin US 31 & State Coots, Henke, Dave Coots (317) 844 1 2!B-3
U U U U 1l!1, blI DPADLS 23-98 Wamsley Law '851 S.Rangelin ,Vaughn Wamsl!Bob Doster 1(317) 574 1 16-7 Approved 4/21/1998
U U U U ~ U ADLS 24-981Lilly Industries 103rd & Illinois iLily Bob Olson (317) 848 1 10 B-3 Approved 4/14/1998
U U U U U Il!1 ADLS 25-98lPearson Ford 10650 N. Michi iJohn Pearson IDave Coots (317) 844 1 7B-3 ,Approved 4/21/1998
Il!1 Il!1 U U U U PPSP 26-98 Lake Forest, L 11618 Rose C !Terry & Ann Cr IAnn Cray (317) 815 1 0,8-1 Approved 4/14/1998
U U U U U blI ,ADLS 27-98 Weston Shopp 1106th & Michig 'Glendale Partn Kevin McRass (317) 571 51B-2 . Approved 4/21/1998
U Ill! U U U U SP 28-98:Brooks Landin se.comer 131st'Brenwick Dave Sexton (317) 574 4 21S-1 ' .pproved 5/4/1998
U blI U U U U SP 29-98' Foster Estates, s.146th,w.Care Quadrant Dev. Steve Schutz 31 14iR-1 pproved 5/4/1998
blI U U U U U PPAMEN 30-98 PlUm Creek Fa Hazeldell Rd/1 Plum Creek De Corby Thomps (317) 849 225 851S-1 pproved 5/19/1998
U U U U ~ b!1 DPADLS 31-98 Telamon 1000 E. 116th Telamon Dik Hoover (317) 547 0 OIM-O , ""proved 5/19/1998
U U U U ~ ~ DPADLS 32-98 FCC Developm 755 & 765 W. Frank Cosmas Frank Cosmas (317) 846 1 71M-3 ""proved 5/19/1998
U ~ U U U U SP 33-981FCC Developm 755 & 765 W. Frank Cosmas Frank Cosmas (317) 846 1 71M-3 Approved 5/19/1998
Page 1
7/19/2002
c'
c
.,
1998 PC docket dbase
I~R~.~~s:nH~~ni:li~zflldl6s;mal:Q~l(lat Q~~~:: ~~e~~~::~ :~:~e~=-:~s~::~~~:=~G:6~~;~~;~~i::f#!~~7 ''''~'''nl~Qn&tDat~Atitiro
u u u U blI U ADLSAM
U U U U blI U ADLSAM
U U U U blI blI DPADLS
U U U U ~ blI DPADLS
U blI 0 U U U SP
U U ~ U U U OA
blI blI U IU U U PPSP
U U U U blI U ADLSAM
U U U U blI U ADLSAM
U U U u blI o ADLS
U U U U blI U ADLSAM
U blI U U U . U SP
blI U U U U U SP
blI U U U U U SP
blI U U U 0 U SP
blI U U U .0 U SP
blI U U U 0 U SP
U U U blI U U REZONE
U blI U U 0 U SP
0 blI U U 0 o SP
U U 0 0 It:! o ADLSAM
U U U U blI U ADLSAM
U U U U blI U ADLSAM
U U U U blI blI DPADLS
U U U U Il!"'I blI DPADLS
blI U 0 0 U [J IPP
blI U U U U U PP ,
U U U U U blI DPAMEN
U blI U U 1 U U SP
U blI U U U U SP
U blI U U U U SP
U blI 0 0, U o SP
35-98 Marsh Hiring Tr 116th St. & AA Marsh George Cochra (317) 594 0
36-98,Lanter Eyecare 10610 N. Penn Earl Lanter Doug Staley 0
37-98 Penn Mark II - 11555 N Meridi CB Commercia Kelly Gill (317) 269 0
38-98 Meridian Plaza 10401 N Meridi CSO Bob Olson (317) 848 0
39-98,Lost Oaks @ H IW of River/N of Centex Homes Tom Kutz (317) 574 65
40-98 US 421 Overla lOne Civic Squ City of Carmel Ramona Hanc (317) 571 0
41~98 Woodgate SignlWorchester Dr Langston Deve Jim Langston 1(317) 846 '0
42-98 Bath and Body 12176 E 116th S :Bath and Body iPeter Hauser (800) 348 0
43-98 Windsor Court 111610 Technol Winsor Court Christine Wrigh (317) 818 0
44~98 Blockbuster Bu INE Comer 116 !Linder Com pan ,Jim Nelson (317) 844 0
45~98 Meridian Villag 113610 NOrth M Flynn & Zinkan 'Kelly Flynn (317) 634 0
46-98 Kingsborough, Ine of 141st & 0 Zaring Homes Bill Bryant (317) 849 27
47-98 Saddle Creek, SE 141st & Dit Saddle Creek Jeff Kennelly (317) 846 34
48-98 Saddle Creek, SE 141st & Dit Saddle Creek 'Jeff Kennelly (317) 846 28
49-98 Saddle Creek, SE 141 st & Dit 'Saddle Creek Jeff Kennelly (317) 846 52
50-98 Stone Haven A ,NW of 131st & Centex Homes Tom Kutz (317) 574 36
51-98 Brooks Manor lEast 116th, W. ISteve Wilson Dave Barnes (317) 846 2
52-98 !Barrington Clu '\NW Com 131 st Century Develo iDave Coots (317) 844 0
53-98 ,Chapman's Cia :SW Com 131 st iBrenwick Devel Keith Lash (317) 574 501
54-98 Trails At Avian 11/4 north of 13 Davis Homes Li Ching Wu (317) 595 44
55-98 Rosemeade C lEast 116th St 1 Scott Unger Scott Unger 1(317) 844 0
56-981Carmel Corpor 1645W. Carmel American Tradi IKeith Gray (317) 842 0
57-98,Arobors of Car 1850 W. Carmel ~erican Tradi iKeith Gray (317) 842 0
58-98lHamilton Cross iN of 126 st, E s :Duke ICraig Flanderm (317) 574 0
59-98lHamilton Cross ISE Com 126th Duke 'Craig Flanderm .(317) 574 0
60-98lBrighton Wood !E of Hazel Dell 'Ray Roehling Curt Huff (317) 849 38
61-98 Brighton Wood ,IE side of Hazel Ray Roehling Curt Huff (317) 849 38
62-98lMayflower Park IMichigan Rd. & :Browning Inves Greg Smelling (317) 634 0
63-98 Plum Creek Fa lEast of 126th S !Thompson Corby Thomps (317) 849 46
64-98 Plum Creek Fa lEast of 126th S Thompson Corby Thomps (317) 849 ,45
65-98.Plum Creek Fa lEast of 126th S Thompson Corby Thomps (317) 849 36
66-98 Laurel Lakes S ISW Com of To lOon Smith Stan Neal (317) 846 I 30
Page 2
20 S-1 Approved
OIB-8 Approved
o B-5 Approved
o B-6 ~pproved
o 8-5 .pproved
26 S-1 .pproved
o .pproved
o R-1 ' .pproved
01B-8 .pproved
6 B-6 .pproved
OIB-8 pproved
17,8-3 .pproved
141S-1 .pproved
251S-1 pproved
15S-1 Approved
26 5-1 Approved
13.5-1 Approved
OR-1 Approved
2215-2
25'5-1 Approved
245-1 Approved
o R-1 jApproved
o M-3 Approved
o M-3 Approved
01B-2 .pproved
01B-2 .pproved
22!5-1 lIithdrawn
221S-1 Approved
011-1 .pproved
24!5-1 .pproved
1315"1 Approved
1615-1 .pproved
2615-1 .pproved
5/4/1998
5/6/1998
5/19/1998
6/2/1998
6/2/1998
6/2/1998
6/16/1998
6/2/1998
6/2/1998
6/16/1998
6/16/1998
7/21/1998
7/7/1998
7/7/1998
7/7/1998
7/7/1998
7/7/1998
7/7/1998
8/4/1998
8/4/1998
8/4/1998
8/18/1998
8/18/1998
9/15/1998
10120/1998
1/19/1999
9/15/1998
9/1/1998
9/1/1998
9/1/1998
9/1/1998
7/19/2002
Ci
c
1998 PC docket dbase
!laillual aiGO,iiii ofCJlQi i{~t _1t.$J D'e~i itilii',~t.t 1:).6cR.tllfl'i!iolli~~Nlmii\llew.'1'e~~C(.re$~tfeYJilo1)i' .'ii:itlcj! '-.~-i'17,~; ". , ,r- '--~ (i ~~ t1 . ,"" ori-llP'itli!~iJt$;
;;.
0 0 0 0 Ii'l 0 ADLSAM 67-98'One Penn Mar IN. Meridian Str !Lowe Enterpris ,Zeke Beiser 0 OB-6 Approved 9/1/1998
U U U U I3lI U ADLS 68-98 Goddard Scho 160 Medical Dr Goddard Scho Doug Floyd (317) 773 1 1 B-8 Approved 10/20/1998
U U 0 Il2I 0 0 REZONE 69-98 Meridian Plasti 1200 W. 106th S IMeridian Plasti Mary Solada (317) 635 1 1 S-2 Approved 10/20/1998
U U U [l!1 U 0 REZONE 70-98 Meijer Automo !NE Comer Car Meijer Matt Maudlin/C ,(317) 571 0 0 Approved 1/19/1999
~ U U U U U PPAMEN 71-98 Foster Estates SW Comer 146 Quadrant Deve ,Jim White (317) 846 40 26 R-1 ~proved 10120/1998
I3lI U U U U U PP 72-98 Lakes At Hazel SE and SW of Zaring Homes !Bob Krohngold (573) 489 273 .160 S-1 pproval 12/15/1998
I3lI U U U U U PP 73-98 Country View E '3300 W. 131 st Jack' Keck Ueff Keck (317)849 1 3 S-1 pproved w/ 11/17/1998
U U U U I3lI U ADLSAM 74-98 Pizza Hut 10 E. Carmel 0 Pizza Hut 'Nick Quintana (317) 257 1 0!B-8 !Approved
U U U U I3lI I3lI iDPAMAD 75-98 Hamilton CrossNW Com 126th Duke Craig Flanderm. (317) 574 1 01B-2 Approved 11/17/1998
I3lI I3lI U U 0 u IPPSP 76-98 Buckhorn Lots 141st St& Buc.Jim Dugan Dave Barnes (317) 846 2 01s-1 Approved 10/6/1998
U U [J ~ U o lREZONE 77-98iParkwood Cros 96th & College 'Duke Realty In Steve Granner (317) 574 0 OIB-6 1 Approval 11/17/1998
U U U U U ~ lOP 78-98 Parkwood Cros ,96th & College :Duke Realty In Steve Granner (317) 574 0 OiB-6 Approval ! 11/1711998
U U. 10 ~ 0 0 REZONE 79-98:REI Rezone iMichigan Rd & 'REI Julie Hall (317) 573 1 51s-1 Approved 11/17/1998
U U U [l!1 U U REZONE 80-98jOverture Open iNW Comer 12 Estridge Devel 'Steve Van Soel !(317) 582 48 18!S-1 Approved 1/19/1999
U U U U [l!1 [l!1 DPADLS 81-981Josie Building 'Chase Court Weihe EngineeGreg Rasmuss(317) 846 1 2,M-3 iApproved 11/17/1998
U IllJ U ,U U U SP 82-981Josie Building iChase Court Greg Rasmuss !Weihe Enginee 1(317) 846 1 21M-3 iApproved
U U U U ~ ~ ADLSDP 83-98iUnion Federal NW Com Colle IBlaze Construe IMike Beesley (317) 580 0 O!B-6
U U U U U U CPA 84-9812020 Vision Th One Civic Squ City of Carmel IMike Hollibaug (317) 571 0 0 .pproved 3/2/1999
U U U U ~ U ADLSAM 85-98lMerchants Squ i2472 E 116th S \Linder Com pan ICraig Hessee (317) 844 0 O!B-8 .pproved 11/17/1998
IllJ U IU u u u PP 86-98 Camden Walk W of Towne, N !Wilson Carrige !Curt Huff (317) 849 71 55 S-1 ""proved 12/15/1998
~ U 0 ,0 0 U PP 87-98 Camden Walk W side of Tow Wilson/Carrige Curt Huff (317) 849 71 55 S-1
U U 0 Ii'l 0 u ,Z 88-98 'US 31 Map Am lOne Civic Squ City of Carmel Mike Hollibaug . (317) 571 0 O! TempWithd 12/15/1998
IllJ U U U U U iPP 89-98,Overture Subd !NW cmer 126t Estridge , Steve VanSoel 1(317) 582 0 0 Approved 12/15/1998
U IllJ U U U U jSP 90-98!Delaware Trac IHazel Dell Nor, Oakview Assoc Richard Hende (317) 898 37 19 S-1 Approval 12/1/1998
U IllJ U U U U !SP 91-98IBrighton Wood iHazel Dell Rd Ray Roehling lEd Fleming (317) 849 20 12 S-1 Approved 1/19/1999
U ~ 0 U U u ISP 92-98/Trails at Avain iNW Cmer 131s!Davis Homes ILi Ching Wu !(317) 595 2 O'S-1 Approval 12/1/1998
U U U fl{J U U REZONE 93-98!Homeplace Lot jNW Com 105th'Mike DeBoy/Ail iJim Nelson (317) 844 0 2R-3
U U U U ~ U ADLSAM I 94-98ICarme' Center Carmel Dr & E Mlck Sheetz IRichard Hende (317) 844 0 OB-8 Approved 12/15/1998
U U U UI ~ U ADLSAM i 95-98iHamilton Cross iSE Com 126th Duke Steve Granner (317) 574 0 0'~-2 Approved 1/19/1999
U ~ U U U U SP 96-98!Kings Mill Secti 1106th & Towne Steve Wilson/R Dave Barnes (317) 846 27 18 S-1 ""proved 1/19/1999
IllJ I3lI U U U U PPSP 97-98!Carmel Scienc SE Com Old M Reliastar Gary Murray (317) 842 3 8M-3 ""proved 1/19/1999
U U U U I3lI I3lI DPADLS 98-98101d Meridian M iBlock 17 Carm Landmark Prop Brian Tierney (317) 262 1 2M-3 ""proved 3/211999
U U U U I3lI U ADLSAM 99-981Todd Witsken INW Comer 13 Steve Pittman Gary Murray (317) 842 0 o R-1 Approved 1/19/1999
Page 3
7/19/2002
Cl
c
v
1998 PC docket dbase
'::';"'.1,1''''''''''' c!:Irtdn;Jtlfflil1 K,ei~ rAiJ,lii$!' flJji~lJl IAlfl)tl\'ifat DQt:kel\ :eniti.atNli~ pp,omB~(tli-B:.v"lQj:lie .Dfie ,."'aR!l!.6" ~:'lf ,-;:, < 'Ira "',,"'" to
..
Ill! Ill! U U U U PPSP 100-98 Little Farms Lot E of 104th St Habitat for Hu IJohn Alsop (317) 846 4' o R-1 I
U Ill! U U U U SP 101-98 Parks At Sprin N of 131st E of Estridge IDave Sexton (317) 574 1 4S-2
U U U U Ill! Ill! DPADLS 102-98 Lakeside Corp NE Com Guildf IAtapco Carmel !Joe Scimia (317) 237 1 23 M-3 Approved 2/16/1999
U Ill! U U U U SP 103-98 Lakeside Corp NE Com Guilfo Atapco Carmel !Joe Seimia (317) 237 1 23 M-3 Approved 2/16/1999
U U U Ill! U U REZONE 104-98 Carmel Seiene E and W side 0 Reliastar Ed Mitro (317) 237 0 OM-3 Approved 2/16/1999
U U Ii!! !ill 0 0 REZONE 105-98 US 31 Overlay US 31 96th St DOCS Mike Hollibaug (317) 571 0 0 Approved 1/19/1999
U U U 0 Ii!! 0 f1.DLS 106-98!First Indiana B SW Comer AA ,Redevelopmen Steve Granner (317) 574 1 018-8 [Approved 1/19/1999
Page 4
7/19/2002
c"
c
u
/.j
IN THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
CITY OF CARMEL, INDIANA
SPRINT SPECTRUM L.P.
Docket No. A-III-OI
Appellant,
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
8 /~
A "~i\
4.' ~/ \
RECf Y':\
A'VV IVED \e'\
!II 15 2001 tl
DOCS /l~)
1((,',')1
/"j
/"Y
/~"Y
.T7DV
1:9
Re: Revocation of Building Permit,
Number 2001.0627.B by MICHAEL P.
HOLLIBAUGH, in his Capacity as
DIRECTOR OF THE DEPARTMENT
OF COMMUNITY SERVICES,
CARMEL, INDIANA,
MOTION TO DISMISS
Richard Deer, an adjacent property owner to the site commonly known as 1388 Queens
Way, Carmel, Indiana (the "Site") respectfully requests that pursuant to Section 30.1 of the
Zoning Ordinance, Ordinance NO. Z-I60, as amended, of the City of Carmel and Clay
Township, Hamilton County, Indiana (hereinafter, "Section 30.1 of the Carmel Code") this
Board of Zoning Appeals dismiss this appeal and would show as follows:
1. Michael P. Hollibaugh (the "Director"), in his capacity as Director of the
Department of Community Services (the "Department"), Carmel, Indiana revoked the issuance
of the improvement location permit (the "ILP") on August 23,2001
2. Sprint Spectrum L.P. (the "Appellant") filed its appeal on September 24,2001
(the "Appeal") thirty-three (33) days afterthe revocation of the ILP.
3. The Appeal was not timely filed.
4. Pursuant to Section 30.1 of the Carmel Code, Appellant has to and including
September 21, 2001 in which to file its Appeal.
5. Section 30.1 of the Carmel Code states "All appeals shall be filed with the
Director within thirty (30) days of the action to be appealed." The action which is the subject
of Appellant's appeal is the revocation of the ILP. The last date which is within thirty (30) days
of the revocation of the ILP is Friday, September 21, 2001. The Board of Zoning Appeals must
u
o
administer the ordinance in accordance with its stated terms. T.W. Thorn Const., Inc. v. City of
Jeffersonville, 721 N.E.2d 319 (Ind. Ct. App. 1999). If the Board of Zoning Appeals had
intended that the Appellant should have thirty (30) days after the date of the decision to revoke
the ILP to appeal, Section 30.1 of the Carmel Code should have been drafted in accordance with
IC 36-7-4-1003 which states:
The. person shall present the petition to the court
within thirty (30) days after the date of that decision
of the board of appeals.
As drafted, IC 36-7-4-1003 clearly provides for thirty (30) days after the date of a decision by
the Board of Zoning Appeals to present an appeal to the trial court whereas Section 30.1 of the
Carmel Code only allows for an appeal to be filed within thirty (30) days of the date of the action
to be appealed. Any interpretation of Section 30.1 of the Carmel Code to the contrary violates
Indiana law as an ordinance must be given its plain, ordinary and usual meaning. Johnson Oil
Co. v. Area Planning Com'n of Evansville and Vanderburgh County, 715 N.E. 2d 1011, 1015
(Ind. Ct. App. 1999). Failure to comply with the stated time limitations is fatal to the appellant's
claim. Biggs v. Board of Zoning Appeals of City of Wabash, 448 N.E.2d 693,694 (Ind. Ct. App.
1983).
6. Assuming for the sake of argument that Appellant's argument that the thirtieth
(30) day fell on September 22,2001 is correct, there is still no basis in the Carmel Code for the
Appellant to have until September 24, 2001 to file the appeal. In certain situations, Indiana Rule
of Trial Procedure 6(A) extends a deadline that would otherwise fall on a Saturday, Sunday, or
legal holiday if the statute is silent as to the method of computing time. However, according to
the text of Trial Rule 6(A), it only applies to the trial rules, orders of the court, or any applicable
statute. Because the issue in front of the Board of Zoning appeals has to do with the
interpretation of Section 30.1 of the Carmel Code rather than a trial rule, court order or statute,
2
" 'W
o
Q
the Board of Zoning Appeals is not required to extend the time limit if the last day to file the
appeal falls on a Saturday, Sunday or legal holiday. Under Indiana law, "because a zoning board
is a body usually composed of persons without legal training, courts are reluctant to impose rigid
technical requirements upon their procedure as long as they are orderly, impartial, judicious and
fundamentally fair." quoting McBride v. Board of Zoning Appeals of Evansville-Vanderburgh
Area Plan Com'n, 579 N.E.2d 1312, 1315 (Ind. Ct. App. 1999). Thus, unless the procedures
used by the Board of Zoning Appeals to determine whether the Appellants' case should be heard
are not orderly, impartial and fundamentally fair, they will not be held as contrary to law. Id. at
1315.
WHEREFORE, Richard Deer, an adult resident ofIndiana, respectfully requests that the
Board of Zoning Appeals dismiss this appeal because it is untimely under Section 30.1 of the
Carmel Code.
Respectfully submitted,
-r~ 8,~
J. Tagg ge (Arty No~ 2 9-4~
BOSE McKINNEY & EVANS LLP
600 East 96th Street
Suite 500
Indianapolis, IN 46240
(317) 574-3732
Attorney for Richard Deer,
an adult resident of Indiana
44148
3
~.
u
u
IN THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
CITY OF CARMEL, INDIANA
SPRINT SPECTRUM L.P.
Docket No. A-IlI-OI
Appellant,
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
/-QI'fill\ It(j)'-r,-
./ \ .,,- _~'----"'1__ . I ;.,"_
" y -,' ,.'_~
~>->- "'" .,'<(/\
~ ~ \,,"..\
4'fJ//JpPcIJ ^",
~, bOCS ;t7~
Y:\.
~~" ...,':.(...../
'- / ,_ -,'It". , ..,
"- ,~~~J._L'--~;.'.//
Re: Revocation of Building Permit
Number 2001.0627.B by MICHAEL P.
HOLLIBAUGH, in his Capacity as
DIRECTOR OF THE DEPARTMENT
OF COMMUNITY SERVICES,
CARMEL, INDIANA,
SPRINT'S OBJECTION TO RICHARD DEER'S MOTION TO DISMISS
Appellant, Sprint Spectrum L.P., (hereinafter "Sprint"), by counsel, hereby objects to
Richard Deer's Motion to Dismiss Sprint's appeal of the revocation of its location permit by
Michael P. Hollibaugh, in his capacity as Director ("Director") of the Department of Community
Services, Carmel, Indiana, and in support thereof states:
I. The Director revoked the improvement location permit at issue (the "Permit") for
property located at 1388 Queens Way, Carmel, Indiana, on Thursday, August 23, 2001. The
Director notified Sprint of his decision by a letter sent by regular mail on Thursday, August 23,
2001. Sprint received the letter of revocation on Friday, August 24,2001.
2. Section 30.1 of the Carmel/Clay Zoning Ordinance provides that "all appeals shall
be filed with the Director within thirty (30) days of the action to be appealed." The Director's
decision to revoke the Permit on Thursday, August 23, 2001, is the "action" being appealed by
Sprint in this case.
u
o
3. The Department of Community Services is the entity responsible for the
acceptance of Appeals to the Board of Zoning Appeals. Its office is not open for business on
Saturdays or Sundays, and therefore, no Appeals can be filed on those days.
4. The thirty (30) day period, as provided by Section 30.1 of the Carmel/Clay
Zoning Ordinance, commenced at the earliest on Friday, August 24, 2001, which was the first
full day after the Director's decision to revoke the Building Permit. I
5. The thirtieth day fell upon a Saturday, and Sprint could not file on Saturday.
Sprint timely filed its appeal on the very next day the Department of Community Development
was open for business, which was Monday, September 24,2001.
6. Under Indiana law, where a statutory period mandates that an appeal must be
taken within thirty (30) days, that period commences on the first full day after notice is received
of the initiating event and expires thirty (30) days thereafter. Most notably, the Indiana Supreme
Court held that "every conceivable element of fair play, common sense and logic mandates that
the [appellant] be afforded the full thirty days to complete his appeal." Ball Stores. Inc. v. State
Board of Tax Commissioners, 316 N.E.2d 674 (Ind. 1974).
7. This principle is embodied in Indiana Trial Rule 6(A), which in pertinent part
provides:
In computing any period of time prescribed or allowed by these
rules, by order of the court or by any applicable statute, the day of
the act, event, or default from which the designated period of time
begins to run shall not be included. The last day of the period so
computed is to be included unless it is: (1) a Saturday. (2) a
Sunday. (3) a legal holiday. .. (emphasis added)
1 Sprint did not receive notice of the revocation until August 24, 2001 by regular mail. To allow Sprint the full
thirty days, the first day of the period should be Saturday, August 25th. Computation of the period in this manner
would make the thirtieth day fall on Sunday, September 23rd, with the appeal still due on Monday the 24th.
Therefore, this objection treats the date of issuance at the trigger date. Both the Indiana Trial Rules and the Federal
Rules of Civil Procedure, the principles of which are applicable by analogy as discussed below, provide that three
additional days are to be added to any time period when notice of the triggering act is provided by regular mail. In
this case, addition of three days for service by mail makes Monday, September 24th the twenty-ninth day.
2
o
o
8. The principle embodied in T.R. 6(A) applies whenever the applicable statute is
silent as to the method of computing time. Here, Section 30.1 of the Carmel/Clay Zoning
Ordinance does not provide for a method of computing the thirty (30) day limit, and therefore,
T.R. 6(A) applies by default.
9. Trial Rule 6(A)'s method of computing time limits was properly used by the
Indiana Public Service Commission when neither the applicable statutes nor rules of the Public
Service Commission specifically prescribed a manner for computing the thirty (30) day time
period. City of South Bend v. Users of Sewage Disposal, 402 N.E.2d 1267 (Ind.App. 1980).
Similarly, where the statute of limitations on a personal injury action was silent as to how the
time limitation therein was to be computed, T.R. 6(A) was also applicable. Jenkins v. Yoder,
324 N.E.2d 520 (Ind.App. 1975).
10. In the context of an appeal from a property tax assessment, our Supreme Court
held that when the receipt of an appeal is impossible (e.g., because of the closing of its offices
and/or the non-delivery of the United States mails on Sundays and holidays), receipt on the next
business day is a timely receipt of notice-particularly when the taxpayer's inability to make
delivery of such notice is beyond his control. Ball Stores. Inc. v. State Board of Tax
Commissioners, 316 N.E.2d 674 (Ind. 1974). Here, the Department of Community Services'
office was closed both Saturday, September 22 and Sunday, September 23, 2001- thus filing its
Appeal on those days was impossible and beyond Sprint's control.
11. This method of computation has also been adopted in the Rules of Appellate
Procedure. Specifically, Indiana Appellate Rule 9(A) provides that a Notice of Appeal must be
filed within thirty (30) days. In Board of Commissioners of Lake County v. Foster, the Court of
Appeals determined that under Indiana Appellate Rule 2(A), Rule 9(A)'s predecessor, ifthe time
3
Q
u
period expires on a Saturday, the appellant has until the next Monday to file a timely praecipe.
614 N.E.2d 949 (Ind.App. 3 Dist. 1993). Similar to T.R. 6(A), Indiana Appellate Rule 25(B)
provides:
In computing any period of time prescribed or allowed by these
Rules, by order of court, or by any applicable statute, the day of the
act, event, or default from which the designated period of time
begins to run shall not be included. The last day of the period so
computed is to be included unless it is a non-business day. . . .
12. As indicated by the Indiana Supreme Court, "every conceivable element of fair
play, common sense, and logic mandates that [Sprint] be afforded the full thirty days" to
complete the appeal. In accordance with both Indiana law and Section 30.1 of the Carmel/Clay
Zoning Ordinance, Sprint timely filed its appeal on the next possible day of business, which was
Monday, September 24,2001.
WHEREFORE, Sprint respectfully requests that the Board of Zoning Appeals deny Mr.
Deer's Motion to Dismiss.
Respectfully submitted,
LOCKE REYNOLDS LLP
~
By'
. Tho · dsole, #15980-49
Attorney for Appellant,
Sprint Spectrum L.P.
LOCKE REYNOLDS LLP
201 North Illinois Street, Suite 1000
P.O. Box 44961
Indianapolis, Indiana 46244-0961
Phone: (317) 237-3800
Fax: (317) 237-3900
538986_1
4