HomeMy WebLinkAboutCorrespondencePlan Review - Review Comments Report
Project Name: PZ-2023-00243 The Signature Sign Package
Workflow Started: 9/29/2023 9:46:08 AM
Report Generated: 02/12/2024 02:10 PM
REF #CYCLE REVIEWED BY TYPE FILENAME DISCUSSION STATUS
1 1 Sign Permits
Aliza Shalit
10/17/23 1:54 PM
Changemark
Lighting Schematic
This schematic does not appear to be for reversed lighting. Please update.
Shouldn't the back be clear and the LED be facing the other way with a solid
face?
A020-TENANT PLAN ID Signage-
Column Mesh Detail - 13111 OLD
MERIDIAN - The SIGNATURE.pdf
Responsed by: Casey Niederwerfer - 10/24/23 11:50 AM
Updated as requested. Resubmitted updated plan
Resolved
2 1 Sign Permits
Aliza Shalit
10/17/23 1:54 PM
Changemark
Logo text
Please see previous note on canopy signs. Legend note C and this last bulled
don't quite communicate the same message.
A020-TENANT PLAN ID Signage-
Column Mesh Detail - 13111 OLD
MERIDIAN - The SIGNATURE.pdf
Responsed by: Casey Niederwerfer - 11/1/23 5:52 PM
Updated Signage. Logos to execute like any channel
letter. Have requested owner to recommend lettering
only due to smaller overall tenant sign area with mesh
detail confirmed with mesh
Resolved
3 1 Sign Permits
Aliza Shalit
10/17/23 1:54 PM
Changemark
Rendering
Please make sure rendering matches in mounting mode, the raceway looks
solid instead of what is pictured above.
A020-TENANT PLAN ID Signage-
Column Mesh Detail - 13111 OLD
MERIDIAN - The SIGNATURE.pdf
Responsed by: Casey Niederwerfer - 10/24/23 11:51 AM
Updated night rendering along with updated shop
drawing understanding of mesh letter carrier.
Resolved
4 1 Sign Permits
Aliza Shalit
10/17/23 1:54 PM
Changemark
Updated Raceway
Thank you for working on this. I like that these are much less obvious than
the previous plan and that they are part of the frame holding the mesh. It
also works with the sign and not against the architecture.
A020-TENANT PLAN ID Signage-
Column Mesh Detail - 13111 OLD
MERIDIAN - The SIGNATURE.pdf
Info Only
5 1 Sign Permits
Aliza Shalit
10/17/23 1:54 PM
Changemark
Logos
By Channel style logo, do you mean the background would not be lighted?
In other words, routed out with push through shapes/letters? This is a bit
unclear. - see C in legend.
A019-TENANT PLAN ID Signage-
Canopy Detail - 13111 OLD MERIDIAN
- The SIGNATURE.pdf
Responsed by: Casey Niederwerfer - 10/20/23 12:24 PM
A channel Style Logo is basically a channel letter in a
logo shape. Same fabricated backer and returns, with an
acrylic translucent face, attached with trim capping and
illuminated through the face.
Resolved
6 1 Sign Permits
Aliza Shalit
10/17/23 1:54 PM
Changemark
UDO Sign Standards
Please include text that states that signs will follow UDO Sign Standards for
size, type, height, and design.
A019-TENANT PLAN ID Signage-
Canopy Detail - 13111 OLD MERIDIAN
- The SIGNATURE.pdf
Responsed by: Casey Niederwerfer - 10/24/23 12:11 PM
Added to Notes on drawing.
Resolved
7 1 Sign Permits
Aliza Shalit
10/17/23 1:54 PM
Changemark
schematic
This schematic does not seem to be for a back lit channer letter, please
update.
A019-TENANT PLAN ID Signage-
Canopy Detail - 13111 OLD MERIDIAN
- The SIGNATURE.pdf
Responsed by: Casey Niederwerfer - 10/24/23 3:11 PM
Updated on drawing
Resolved
REVIEW COMMENTS
Plan Review - Review Comments Report
Project Name: PZ-2023-00243 The Signature Sign Package
Workflow Started: 9/29/2023 9:46:08 AM
Report Generated: 02/12/2024 02:10 PM
REF #CYCLE REVIEWED BY TYPE FILENAME DISCUSSION STATUS
8 1 Sign Permits
Aliza Shalit
10/17/23 1:56 PM
Changemark
sign color coding
Why are some "wall" signs highlighted green and some are not?
A022-TENANT PLAN ID South
Elevation All locations - 13111 OLD
MERIDIAN - The SIGNATURE.pdf
Responsed by: Luke Severson - 1/30/24 6:01 PM
Is this still unresolved?
----------------------------------------------------------
Reviewer Response: Aliza Shalit - 1/30/24 3:02 PM
I do not see an updated file for this
----------------------------------------------------------
Responsed by: Luke Severson - 1/12/24 11:19 AM
Added notes as requested to drawing.
----------------------------------------------------------
Reviewer Response: Aliza Shalit - 12/18/23 2:46 PM
There are no uploads or corrections. No note is present,
please add to drawing and upload new version.
----------------------------------------------------------
Responsed by: Luke Severson - 11/29/23 5:19 PM
Note added to Drawing to clarify
----------------------------------------------------------
Reviewer Response: Aliza Shalit - 11/13/23 12:10 PM
Please clarify that in the notes.
----------------------------------------------------------
Responsed by: Casey Niederwerfer - 10/20/23 12:42 PM
Green Highlited areas are actual planned tenant
storefront options. Areas with signage NOT highlited
are potential future sign areas if storefront configuration
changes over time.
Resolved
9 1 Sign Permits
Aliza Shalit
10/17/23 1:56 PM
Changemark
Spandrel Height
Please include the spandrel height for at least one of the "wall" mesh signs.
A022-TENANT PLAN ID South
Elevation All locations - 13111 OLD
MERIDIAN - The SIGNATURE.pdf
Responsed by: Casey Niederwerfer - 11/1/23 5:54 PM
Spandrel Height shown on mesh and letter detail.
Resolved
10 1 Sign Permits
Aliza Shalit
10/17/23 2:03 PM
Comment
Please make sure there is a prominent note stating that all signs will follow
UDO Sign Standards and that all sign require a sign permit application and
review process.
Info Only
Plan Review - Review Comments Report
Project Name: PZ-2023-00243 The Signature Sign Package
Workflow Started: 9/29/2023 9:46:08 AM
Report Generated: 02/12/2024 02:10 PM
REF #CYCLE REVIEWED BY TYPE FILENAME DISCUSSION STATUS
11 1 Carmel
Redevelopment
Commission
Larysa Glaspie
10/17/23 2:59 PM
Comment
Reserved parking signage: No more than 25% of the parking spaces in the
garage can be reserved. Once developer has final parking counts, the
number of interior reserved parking signs may need to be modified to be
within the 25% maximum.
Info Only
12 1 Carmel
Redevelopment
Commission
Larysa Glaspie
10/17/23 3:13 PM
Comment
Will there be a parking garage wall sign(s) or suspended sign labeling the
parking garage at the entrances?
Responsed by: Casey Niederwerfer - 10/20/23 12:35 PM
On the West Elevation there is a parking Blade to direct
off the street. On the same elevation, set back at the
actual garage entrance there is an Entrance/Direction
Style Sign, labeled WCI2. ON the south elevation there
is a parking blade and Entrance Directional Sign located
at the entry to the garage drive. Nothing additional is
planned unless required.
Resolved
13 1 Carmel
Redevelopment
Commission
Larysa Glaspie
10/17/23 3:16 PM
Comment
Will there be any directional signage to help drivers navigate to the garage?
Responsed by: Casey Niederwerfer - 10/20/23 12:40 PM
At the west elevation we feel the blade serves this
function as the entry to the garage is easily identifiable
upon turning into the drive. On the south entry the
drive from the road to the entry to the parking garage is
one way with no decision options until you are at the
parking garage entry. Nothing additional planned
unless suggested or required here.
Resolved
14 1 Carmel
Redevelopment
Commission
Larysa Glaspie
10/17/23 3:17 PM
Comment
Bike parking signage is required. Please submit this.
Responsed by: Casey Niederwerfer - 10/24/23 11:49 AM
Understood, adding to package will resubmit.
Resolved
15 1 Carmel
Redevelopment
Commission
Larysa Glaspie
10/17/23 3:17 PM
Comment
If security cameras are present, 24-hour video surveillance signage is
required.
Responsed by: Casey Niederwerfer - 10/24/23 11:49 AM
Understood, adding to package will resubmit
Resolved
16 1 Carmel
Redevelopment
Commission
Larysa Glaspie
10/17/23 3:18 PM
Comment
No loitering or skateboarding permitted signs are required.
Responsed by: Casey Niederwerfer - 10/24/23 11:49 AM
Understood, adding to package will resubmit.
Resolved
Plan Review - Review Comments Report
Project Name: PZ-2023-00243 The Signature Sign Package
Workflow Started: 9/29/2023 9:46:08 AM
Report Generated: 02/12/2024 02:10 PM
REF #CYCLE REVIEWED BY TYPE FILENAME DISCUSSION STATUS
17 2 Sign Permits
Aliza Shalit
11/13/23 1:22 PM
Changemark
Sign mesh
Previous format is preferred, otherwise can we only have the two thin
raceways without a mesh at all. Please remember that with this updated
format, the spandrel panel becomes the smallest frame round the sign
requiring the sign to be reduced to 70% of that spandrel height and 85% of
that width (not the full space as marked here. Please update signage.
A020-TENANT PLAN ID Signage-
Column Mesh Detail - 13111 OLD
MERIDIAN - The SIGNATURE.pdf
Reviewer Response: Aliza Shalit - 1/30/24 3:02 PM
----------------------------------------------------------
Responsed by: Luke Severson - 1/12/24 11:18 AM
Removed Mesh from Plan entirely. Moved tenant
signage to direct to canopy top mount.
----------------------------------------------------------
Reviewer Response: Aliza Shalit - 12/18/23 2:49 PM
no contact has been made
----------------------------------------------------------
Responsed by: Luke Severson - 11/29/23 5:01 PM
Discussion taken over by architects on building
modification of the mesh section. Will update as soon
as I know more.
Resolved
18 2 Sign Permits
Aliza Shalit
11/13/23 1:25 PM
Changemark
Parking Sign
Sign should span the width of the entrance. Please update.
A010-Parking Wall Sign2 Detail and
West Elevation - 13111 OLD MERIDIAN
- The SIGNATURE.pdf
Responsed by: Luke Severson - 11/29/23 5:03 PM
Entrance is very large and would substantially increase
sign cost to scale over entire concrete header beam.
entrance is set back and normal garage style. Is this a
requirement to approval on this sign? Signs shown on
requirements doc "Public Parking Sign Design & Criteria
2022b" don't span entire entrances and other sign on
this property doesn't as well.
Resolved
19 2 Sign Permits
Aliza Shalit
11/13/23 1:26 PM
Changemark
Sign
Please keep this sign mesh format
A021-TENANT PLAN ID Signage-
Column Mesh Render - 13111 OLD
MERIDIAN - The SIGNATURE.pdf
Responsed by: Luke Severson - 1/12/24 11:18 AM
Removed
----------------------------------------------------------
Reviewer Response: Aliza Shalit - 12/18/23 2:49 PM
no contact has been made
----------------------------------------------------------
Responsed by: Luke Severson - 11/29/23 5:02 PM
Discussion taken over by architects on building
modification of the mesh section. Will update as soon
as I know more
Resolved
Plan Review - Review Comments Report
Project Name: PZ-2023-00243 The Signature Sign Package
Workflow Started: 9/29/2023 9:46:08 AM
Report Generated: 02/12/2024 02:10 PM
REF #CYCLE REVIEWED BY TYPE FILENAME DISCUSSION STATUS
20 2 Carmel
Redevelopment
Commission
Larysa Glaspie
11/14/23 1:04 PM
Comment
Conditional Approved - No more than 25% of the parking spaces in the
garage can be reserved. Once developer has final parking counts, the
number of interior reserved parking signs may need to be modified to be
within the 25% maximum allowed. - Approved pending resolution of tenant
signage comment with DOCS. - Any additional signage in the future needs
to be submit for review.
Info Only
21 4 Sign Permits
Aliza Shalit
1/30/24 3:05 PM
Changemark
wording
Should this say Letters not logos
A020-TENANT PLAN ID Signage-
Column Mesh Detail - 13111 OLD
MERIDIAN - The SIGNATURE.pdf
Responsed by: Luke Severson - 1/30/24 5:46 PM
Channel style logos are logo elements fabricated in the
same fashion as a channel letter. allows for the unique
logo shapes to be made and be face illuminated to
allow for logo colors and logo elements to be more
easily replicated using printed materials on the face.
Happy to update wording to whatever translates that
effectively for you.
----------------------------------------------------------
Reviewer Response: Aliza Shalit - 1/30/24 3:05 PM
Should the word Logo really say letters? (Letters to be
channel style only, no cabinets)
Resolved