HomeMy WebLinkAboutPacket 11-12-02
r
I...j
[..i
.l.J
.~
\..J
~
BAKER & DANIELS
EST. 1863
96TH STREET OFFICE
600 E. 96TH STREET, SUITE 600 . INDIANAPOl.IS, INDIANA 46240 . (317) 569-9600 . FAX (317) 569-4800 . www.bakerdaniels.com
JOSEPH M. SCIMIA
DIRECT (317) 569-4680
DIRECT FAX (317) 237-8580
a-mail: jmscimia@bakerd.com
INDIANAPOl.IS
FORT WAYNE
SOUTH BEND
El.KHART
WASHINGTON, D.C.
QINGDAO, P.R. CHINA
l...J
~
[..J
I
Ir-J
~
I
I~
I 'l,..j
I
November 1,2002
City of Carmel and Clay Township
Special Studies Committee
c/o Mr. Laurence M. Lillig, Jr.
Planning and Zoning Administrator
Department of Community Services
One Civic Square
Carmel, Indiana 46032
~
\..I
~
[.;j
Re: 145-02 Z Rezoning
146-02 DP/ADLS
Clarian Health Partners. Inc. - North Campus
Dear Members of the City of Carmel and Clay Township Special Studies Committee:
l..I
~
~
~
.J
I..l
l..l
I..J
I..J
~
c.J
[..i
c.J
I..J
I..J
On November 12,2002, representatives of Clarian Health Partners, Inc., will
appear before you to introduce the Rezoning, Development Plan, and Architectural Design,
Lighting, and Signage ("DP/ADLS") Petitions for the establishment of a new hospital and
medical office complex. The petitions are scheduled for an initial public hearing before the City
of Carmel and Clay Township Plan Commission on November 19, 2002.
The Clarian North hospital and medical office complex would be located on the
southwest comer of the intersection of College Avenue and Pennsylvania Parkway. The subject
site is bordered by Pennsylvania Parkway on the north; College Avenue on the east; Interstate
465 on the south; and, the Wyndham Gardens Hotel on the west. The subject site encompasses
23.438 acres. Approximately 5.089 acres of the subject property is currently zoned B-5 with the
remaining acreage being zoned B-6. The rezoning petition is to rezone the B-5 portion to B-6 to
consolidate zoning districts and allow for the hospital use. The subject site also lies within the
U.S. 31 Overlay District.
The current use of the property includes a three story office building; a retention
pond; and, undeveloped ground. The proposed hospital and medical office complex would
consist of a fi}~(~f~lm~N1~l and medical office building, a central utility plant, a two-level
undergroumt~aiking strucfili'~;>and on-site retention ponds.
ji,{) ;/ ..dbf '\/ \
I ,,'1 I?/" ~ \."'\
r--./ heel' ',,, v \
! '--.11' Ii'(ll/ 1; IYJ"IJ . \--\
le;)j ,- F (~) \.- i
'\ ._, <l 1':,. " ~ i
! ^-:1'I.,"'in f" I
'C:.\ UII/l' '/c:' C./
\.,/ , Vt...:e> . '.
'--G_:" U I, I
\;..,. ...)..., /i, ~'/
IN1MAN2 684 736Y'1;... /" )'
'\"~if:~~;:T8..rr;5~))/'
/---'
l...J
l..i
r..
~
~
(..j
l..i
W
[.l
l.J
[.l
l..J
l.J
~
~
~
City of Carmel and Clay Township
-2-
November 1,2002
A petition for variances of development standards has been filed
contemporaneously with the Rezoning and DP/ADLS Petitions. The Variance Petition will be
heard by the Carmel/Clay Board of Zoning Appeals following a determination of the DP/ADLS
Petitions by the Plan Commission.
Enclosed for your review are the following exhibits:
Tab A:
Site plan of the subject site.
TabB:
Elevations of the primary building.
TabC:
Elevations of the accessory building (central utility plant).
TabD:
Two perspective renderings of the primary building.
TabE:
Chart identifying the requested variances of development standards.
_ The Rezonip.g, DP/ ADLS, and Variance petitions and supporting documentation
are on file with the Department of Community Services.
[.l
~
[.l
~
[...J
In closing, on behalf of Clarian Health Partners, Inc., we thank you for your
consideration.
Enclosures
os P M. slfr-
..
~
1..J
i-I
U
u
f..j
I..l
~
w
INIMAN2684736vI
I....i
I
!
"
-:~
=~
lH1
i~
--.
...-................
I
-~ .
~
-
~
,.
~
J
$
~
~
"
~
II
i~
-...-............-.............
oJ
~
"
i
h
~~-
-........-...-
~
I
~
~
I
~
~
~
.
~
"
<
i
~
..
~
"
"
~
----..-.--
....,'
I /
/
/
/
//
;,,/
I
~----_.._...__.
, " I
1 ,~--
I ~ J1
} 'j
!
:
II
I
I
/' .
/~
I~
\
\
\
\
I
....
1m
;~
I
I
I .
I
I
1
,. ,.-
II
'i II-
il
/, /
// I
, / /
1// I I
II
!
I
(Q/~~
\ OV "'
II
oJ
~
,.
~w, ~
il ~
~
:Ii
-- _____1 ~
I
~
,.
..,
I I' ~
L..._..._._......._ ..._....J
! II \ I J
......7 -- -
\
i--.--
i I
I
-='~ ...,J
-.J
I
I
i
OJ
i!
O!
~
i
"'
OJ
i!
~
...
B.,~~-
· B..~~~.-
~<<
Clarian Health
Clarian
North
Hospital
ClARIAN HEALTH PARTNERS
.....
OWNER'S CONSULTANTS
BIAGI, CHANCE, CUMMINS,
LONDON, 1JTZER, INC.
COJIlUL1II8E11811EER1
AMERICAN CONSULTING, INC.
-........
GENE BURTON & ASSOCIATES
MEDICAl. EQlJIPIIBITPUIINER
MAREGAm INTERIORS
IlmRIOR .IIER
JAIN MALKIN, INC.
1IIIERIllR..-..
CINI-UTTLE
FOOD IERVICI: C8IIUlDlfl'
RTM CONSULTANTS, INC.
.... .......-
CORBIN GRAPHICS
IISIIMA1C1
HOKANSON COMPANIES, INC.
..0.1. DMlDPEfI
PEPPER CONSTRUCTION
............ -
SPIT FIRE, INC.
1IFORIM1ItlllECIIIIIUIB1'
HKS, 1Ne.
(RONALD L SKAGGS)
..........
ARCHnEcrSCONSULTANTS
HKS STRUCTURAL
.......--
SWA GROUP
.........-
HI<S
HKS INC. (Ronold L Skoggs)
Projed No. 7867.000
1919 UcKINNEY AVENUE
0AllAS. TX 75201-1753
..."'.
7867
nITe... .eVII!W ONLY
......._-~...
.............~--_...
_....~IIr...-,--.
~......_~
_ _L_
_.,,",-Nt.; _
0-:_-
lit'''''''
"""""
"'"
04 NOVEMBER 2002
SHEETlIlLE
BUILDING
ELEVATIONS
SHEET"'.
A6.01
0_
......
~
~
~
~
'"
~
~
~
~
l<<
Clarian Health
Clarian
...... North
n... Hospital
ClARlAN HEALTH PARTNERS
OWl..
OWNER1CONSULTANTS
BIAGI, CHANCE, CUMMINS,
LONOON, TITZER, INC.
COIIIULIJI8_
AMERICAN CONSULTING, INC.
..... .......
GENE BURTON & ASSOCIATES
IIEDIW. EQVlI'IIEIIJPLMIWI
MAREGATnINnBUORS
-........
JAIN MALKIN, INC.
--
CINI-UTTLE
FOOD lEfMCl.....wrr
RTM CONSULTANTS, INC.
COOl allllULDIIJI
CORBIN GRAPHICS
IISI &IW'HIA
HOKANSON COMPANIES, INC.
..0.1. DEVELOPER
PEPPER CONSTRUCTION
........... --
SPIT FIRE, INC.
1IIFORIIA1tIII1ECIII0UlGY
HKS, INC.
(RONALD L SKAGGS)
........
ARCHlTEm CONSULTANTS
HKS STRUCTURAL
~-
SWA GROUP
.........-
HI<S
HKS INC. (Ronald L Skaggs)
Project Na. 7867.000
1919 McKINNEY AVENUE
llAltAS, 1)( 75201-1753
.....,.
7867
INfe... REVIIW ONLY
~---......-
........................,..
.....-.....-.--.
-.,,....,.--
_......L_
-...- -
--
"".....
~-
-~---
-~--
......
-a;'Wi.;---
..,-
-~....---
.......
-R;"i1N---
_....1I!..Fl&'!il!l...-__
'~.I".(I'
-E~--
-~--
;~...Jl2ftl_
~
-n;t7i-.i----
_~:...2G!!!..---
g,-
-E~.o----
~IL~;~--
IrIIlFLOCIt
~,~~---
-EL::a:.~--
B03~~-
....
B~~~-
"""""
"'"
04 NOVEMBER 2002
S><rT1lIl.E
BUILDING
ELEVATIONS
S><rTNO.
A6.02
.IJ~
<y
------_._---~---~
.-ex "" 1..-cuIIO
vr
------------~~q----~
04 ~,,~~!'L PLANT WEST ElEVAlION
~ -
d
?
IlD::X nP5 a,1IQMD
vr
~ !!
~ .
~ 8
~ .
"I
i,
~ !
~........----.
s
~
02 ~;~!'l PLANT EAST ElEVATlON
:;
~.
cy
~~----+
03 ~~LPLANTNORTHElEVAT1ON
cy
I
S1'CN.1"'IP&1.""'.
8.totIIP AU.I'L WAU. .YST.
w...JlJam....... "".
01 e~~~L PLANT SOUTH ELEVATION
l<<
Clarian Health
Clarian
North
Hospital
CLARIAN HEALTH PARTNERS
......
OWNER'S CONSULTANTS
BIAGI, CHANCE, CUMMINS,
LONDON, TITZER, INC.
-....-
AMERICAN CONSULTING, INC.
- ........
GENE BURTON" ASSOCIATES
--........
MAREGAm INTERIORS
__
JAIN MAlKIN, INC.
1l1IIIIllII_
CINI-UTIlE
FODDIERVlCECOIIIULTAIIT
RTM CONSUlTANTS,INC.
___
CORBIN GRAPHICS
- ........
HOKANSON COMPANIES, INC.
...... .....-
PEPPER cONsmucnoN
CIIIIIIIIICTIII_
SPIT FIRE, INC.
---
HIS, INC.
=LO L SKAGGS)
ARCHITECT'S CONSULTANTS
HIS STRUCTURAL
I1IIllC1UIIoII. ........
SWA GROUP
......... .........
HI<S
HKS INC. (Ronold L Skoggs)
Project No. 7867.000
1919 McKINNEY AVENUE
llAltAS, TX 75201-1753
.... NO.
UITIR.. AeVllW OIlLY
-...--......-
_..........~............,
_110I_......-.___.
-.......--
~ .........L.A-..
_.""11.110.: ~
-~
1ClYP\oIN
.......
om
04 NOVEMBER 2002
SlEET1TJl[
CENTRAL
PLANT
ELEVATIONS
SlEET NO
A6.03
....
......
~ E
w!!,~'-',","-..
~~'ii;;;~~
:;:_it:.-
~:~:~:~_:,-~~~ =~~-
~~~~~~~~-~~~:;-"1n
~ ~ .U:'/1t /02:-
~JUI :o~ F;.~._ ~~~.--
l'(i Clarian Health
;- Methodist .IU . Riley
North Campus
Scheme A
HI<S
Ronald L. Skaggs
Project No. 7867
August 23, 2002
~
~
~.
'~
,I..J
(;.J'
l.J
~
1..1
~
~
[.J
l..J
[..J
CJ
~
~
[.J
l..l
U
W
W
W
\.J
W
U
~
W
CJ
\::J
'~
(:J
Clarian North Campus - Requested Variances
Section of Zoning Development Standard
Ordinance Requirement Requested Variance
23B.8.1 (c) Build-to line of 1-465 frontage Allow building to be located
must be 90' from property line. approximately 200' .from the
property line.
25.1.2.B.1 Maximum height of accessory The accessory building (central
buildings in the business, utility plant) is currently designed
industrial, and manufacturing to have a height of 46'.
districts shall not exceed 25'.
25.1.2.B.3(a)(1)(b) Minimum front yard setback for The accessory building (central
accessory buildings in the utility plant) is currently designed
business, industrial, and to have a setback from College
manufacturing districts results in Avenue of 60'.
a required setback of 85'.
23B.10.4 Protection of existing trees Allow less than 70% of all trees
requires preservation of not less that are: (a) 9" OBH or larger, and
than 70% of all trees that are: (a) (b) located within the Greenbelt,
9" OBH or larger, and (b) located Planting Strips and perimeter
within the Greenbelt, Planting buffering to be preserved.
Strips and perimeter buffering.
23B.8.6 Maximum parcel coverage and The project is currently designed
density shall not exceed a Floor with an FAR of 1.029 when the
Area Ratio (FAR) of 0.70. underground parking levels are
included.
25.7.02-10 Sign ordinance requirements for Permit the submitted sign
Multi-Tenant Multi-level Buildings package.
23B.1 0.2.A(1) Landscape Area: the Greenbelt Permit the Greenbelt width to be
width shall be a minimum of 30' less than 30' in width.
and landscaped per
requirements.
23B.10.2.0 Landscaping within parking lots Permit the required plantings to be
requires a minimum of 1 shade relocated to the perimeter of the
tree and 5 shrubs within each parking areas.
parking lot for every 9 spaces
provided, or not less than 18
trees per acre of parking.