Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutApplications u u Tingley, Connie S From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Dobosiewicz, Jon C Tuesday, June 11, 2002 5: 13 PM Tingley, Connie S Lillig, Laurence M; Lawrence, Kelli A; Hollibaugh, Mike P; Hanson, Brian P Docket Number Assignment - PP, Laura Vista Subdivision (Primary Plat) Connie, Please print and fax this e-mail to the petitioner identified below and update the file. I have issued the necessary Docket Number for the Laura Vista Subdivision. It will be the following: 81-02 PP $700 + $1,890 ($35 per lot at 54 lots) Total Fee: $2,590 Docket No. 81-02 PP; Laura Vista Subdivision (primary Plat) The applicant seeks approval to plat a 54-lot residential subdivision on 34.94 acres. The site is generally located south of Danbury Estates subdivision between SR 421 and the Foster Estates Subdivision. The site is zoned R-1/Residence. Filed by Brandon Burke of The Schneider Corporation for Primrose Development, LLC. Please note the following: · This Item will appear on the Wednesday, June 19th agenda of the Technical Advisory Committee. · Mailed and Published Public Notice needs to occur no later than Friday, June 21,2002. . Ten (20) Informational Packets must be delivered to Plan Commission Secretary Ramona Hancock no later than noon, Friday, July 5, 2002. Failure to submit Informational Packets by this time will result in the tabling of the petition to the Tuesday, August 20, 2002, agenda of the Plan Commission. . Proof of Notice will need to be received by this Department no later than noon, Monday, July 15, 2002. Failure to submit Proof of Notice by this time will result in the tabling of the petition. · This Item will appear on the July 16, 2002, agenda ofthe Plan Commission under Public Hearings. · This Item will also appear on the August 6,2002, agenda of the Plan Commission Subdivision Committee. . The petitioner will need to provide fifteen (15) fully filled out Findings-of-Fact sheets for the Primary Plat the night of the meeting at which the Plan Commission takes final action on the request. Please remember to fill out the Docket No. and date on each findings sheet for the Commission. Please contact Brandon Burke at 826-6402 (Fax: 826-6410) with this information. I placed the file on your chair. Once the file is updated (copy of fax filed and file labeled on cover and internal files) please return the it to my office. Thanks, Jon 6~\\^f 1 ,...--, Fahey, Joyce 0 w u ..;75''1"0 I From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Dobosiewicz, Jon C Monday, July 01 , 2002 11 :24 AM Fahey, Joyce D Lillig, Laurence M; Lawrence, Kelli A; Hollibaugh, Mike P Docket Number Assignment - PP, Laura Vista Subdivision (Subdivision Waivers) Joyce, Please print and fax this e-mail to the petitioner identified below and un date the file. I have issued the necessary Docket Numbers for the (Subdivision Waivers). They will be t PJltimm~ /-, 81-02a SW $630 81-02b SW $70 81-02c SW $70 81-02d SW $70 81-02e SW $70 Total Fee: $910 o I JIM WHITE, GENERAL MANAGER 317.580.4473 ExT. 302 TEL 317.980.2943 PAGER 317.814.2231 FAX 6135 -NEXTEL 1016 3RD AVENUE. SW . SUITE 100 . CARMEL, INDIANA 46032 Docket No. 81-02 PP; Laura Vista Subdivision (Primary Pla:tr-------------~---~-----------~ The applicant seeks approval to plat a 54-lot residential subdivision on 34.94 acres. The site is generally located south of Danbury Estates subdivision between SR 431 and the Foster Estates Subdivision. The site is zoned R- l/Residence. The petitioner also seeks approval of the following Subdivision Waivers: 81-02a SW SeD 6.5.1 50' offrontage 81-02b SW seD 7.6.3 < 2 points of access to open space 81-02c SW SeD 7.6.3 open space < 75' in width 81-02d SW SeD 6.3.7 cul-de-sac> 600' in length 81-02e SW SeD 6.2.1 subdividing within floodway Filed by Brandon Burke of The Schneider Corporation for Primrose Development, LLC. Please note the following: · This Item will appeared on the June 19th agenda of the Technical Advisory Committee. · Mailed and Published Public Notice needed to occur no later than Friday, June 21, 2002 by PC rule. However, please make notice by July 5th. DOCS will request that the Plan Commission waive their rules and allow the waivers to be heard at the same time as the Primary Plat request. · Proof of Notice will need to be received by this Department no later than noon, Monday, July 15, 2002. Failure to submit Proof of Notice by this time will result in the tabliIJ.g of the petition. · This Item will appear on the July 16, 2002, agenda of the Plan Commission under Public Hearings. · The petitioner will need to provide fifteen (15) fully filled out Findings-of-Fact sheets for the Primary Plat the night of the meeting at which the Plan Commission takes final action on the requests. Please remember to fill out the Docket No. and date on each findings sheet for the Commission. Please contact Charlie Frankenberger at 844-0106 (Fax: 846-8782) with this information. Once the file is updated (copy of fax filed and file labeled on cover and internal files) please return the it to my office. Thanks, 1+1 7//o~ d,r Jon ~ 1 ~~~"'- ~/ ~ ~~#9/PI ~~~~- u u APPLICA TION FOR PRIMARY PLAT (OR REPLAT) Fee: $700.00 plus $35.00 per lot DATE: 05/17/02 DOCKET NO. The undersigned agrees that any construction, reconstruction, enlargement, relocation or alteration of structure, or any change in the use of land or structures requested by this application will comply with, and conform to, all applicable laws of the State of Indiana, and the "Zoning Ordinance of Carmel, Indiana - 1980", adopted under the authority of Acts of 1979, Public Law 178 Sec. I, et seq, General Assembly of the State of Indiana, and all Acts amendatory thereto. Name of Applicant: Primrose Development LLC Phone No. 317-846-6641 Address of Applicant: 1016 3rd Avenue, SW - Suite 100 - Carmel, IN 46032 Name of Owner: Primrose Development LLC Phone No. 317-846-6641 Name of Subdivision: Laura Vista Legal Description (To be typewritten of separate sheet and attached) Number of Lots: 0.44 54 Length (in miles) of new streets Area (in acres): 34.94 to be dedicated to public use: Surveyor certifying plat: Edward Giacoletti, The Schneider Corporation Address: 12821 E. New Market St., Ste 100 Carmel, IN 46032 Phone No. 317-569-8112 ................................. ....................................... STATE OF INDIANA, COUNTY OF Hamilton , SS: The undersigned having been duly sworn, upon oath says that the above information is true and correct As he or she is infonned and helieves. ~ SIGNATUREOFAPPLlCANT~~ . . .tkkf. Print ks ( /JlIJre, tf-M Subscribed and sworn to before me this 17~ day of ~ ,20 D~ cXP'ltUJlL u). ~6n Notary Public ""RoWYlnc. uJ. Hayy-iSOh My Commission Expires: ~ ~'d- / ;J<<>~ -/ / / > .......................................................... 5.1.10 Application for Primary Plat Two (2) copies, or more if necessary, of the primary plat and of the construction plans together with supporting documents shall be submitted to the Director of Current Planning with this application. These plans to be distributed to all Technical Advisory Committee authorities by applicants. " --- FEE: Received by: J:\DOCS\CIVIL\FORMS\City ofCarmetJ>RIMARY PLATAPPLICATION .doc ~ u } NELSON & FRANKENBERGER A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION ATTORNEYS-AT.lAW JAMES J. NELSON CHARLES D. FRANKENBERGER JAMES E. SHINA VER lAWRENCE J. KEMPER JOHN B. FlATI of counsel JANE B. MERRll.L June 28, 2002 VIA HAND DELIVERY Jon Dobosiewicz Department of Community Services One Civic Center Carmel, IN 46032 Re: Primrose Development, LLC - Laura Vista Subdivision Variance Request Applications Dear Jon: (,,) 3021 EAsr 98th SrRFEr SUITE 220 1ND1ANAPOus, INDIANA 46280 317-844-0106 FAX: 317-846-8782 Please find enclosed for filing five (5) Subdivision Variance Request Applications. Please assign docket numbers to each application and contact me with the docket numbers and filing fee amounts for each application. Should you have any questions, please contact me. Very truly yours, NELSON & FRANKENBERGER ~~ L~ Charles D. Frankenberger CDF/jlw Enclosures H:\.Janet\Primrose\Fenstennaker\Dobosiewicz Itr 062802. wpd .. ~ u u SUBDIVISION VARIANCE REQUEST APPLICATION Waiver from 50' frontage' on right-of-way Sec. 6.5.1 4'~U;;{>r;.., "\ ...) I, I .~ \ v<./ '--., ;." /\ V' ',..' / /." )/ A. """ /' 1"-7 T ( ,. f:-;i RECEIVED '<\\~\ (~I JUN 28 2Q02 \~ ~.--\ S k{ \ .~-\ DOC /'--i \",.\ /, / \/\. lei / ,//'~.., _/.:")' '<LX;r...__ ._-<~\:y' Telephone"No'j (~pt8't'4-0 106 (Submit two (2) copies) Docket No. ~\ - OZ-C\ .sw Contact Person: Charles D. Frankenberger PROJECT NAME: Laura Vista PROJECT ADDRESS/LOCATION: Between 136th Street and 146th Street. east of Keystone Avenue and immediately west of Foster Estates. Section 6B APPLICANT NAME: Primrose Development. LLC ADDRESS: 445 Gradle Drive. Carmel. Indiana 46032 TELEPHONE: (317) 846-6641 Attention: Jim White Section (Section Number, Page, Item) of Subdivision Regulations for which variance is being requested: See Exhibit A State explanation of why variance is being requested: See Exhibit A State reasons supporting variance request: See Exhibit A Present Zoning: R-l Date: c~ 4~L- Charles D. rankenberge;- Attorneyfor Applicant $ APPLICATION FEE H :\Janet\Primrose\Fenstennaker\S V A 6.5. I fmntage 50'. wpd .., o Q EXHIBIT "A" I. Subdivision Regulations for which variance is being requested: This subdivision variance is requested from Section 6.5.1 of the Subdivision Control Ordinance which requires lots to have a minimum of SO' of frontage at the street right-of- way. 2. State explanation of why variance is being requested: This variance is requested because the land and residence owned by the Fausts, identified on the Plat as Lot 54, does not have frontage at the street right-of-way. 3. State reasons supporting variance request: The land owned by the Fausts is included as part of the Plat in order to avoid the continuation of an unplatted area. The absence of frontage is a condition that existed prior to and independently of platting. The Fausts will have an access easement to Vista Drive. H:VanetlPrimroselFenstennakerlSVA 6.5.1 frontage SO'.wpd . i'" ..... , w u CARMEL PLAN COMMISSION Carmel, Indiana SUBDIVISION VARIANCE FINDINGS OF FACT Docket No: Petitioner: Primrose Development LLC Section Variance: Section 6.5.1 of the Subdivision Regulations Brief Description of Variance: Variance requiring lots to have a minimum of 50' frontage at the street right-of-way In deciding whether or not the applicant has presented sufficient proof to permit the granting of a variance, the Plan Commission should consider the following: The grant of a variance will not be injurious to the public health, safety, morals and general welfare ofthe community. The use and value of area adjacent to the property included in the proposed plat wi II not be affected in a substantially adverse manner. The need for the variance arises from some condition peculiar to the property and such condition is not due to the general conditions of the neighborhood. The strict application of terms of the ordinance to the property will constitute an unusual and unnecessary hardship if applied to the property for which the variance is sought. The grant of the variance does not interfere substantially with the Comprehensive Plan. Based on all the evidence presented by the petitioner, I approve of the requested subdivision variance. I hereby disapprove of the subdivision variance request for the following reasons: 1. 2. 3. Dated this _ day of ,2002. Commission Member H:\Janet\Primrose\Fenstennaker\F ofF Frontage ROW.wpd -11"'._ "....'~ o o CITY OF CARMEL PLAN COMMISSION CARMEL, INDIANA Docket No.: - Laura Vista - Waiver from Section 6.5.1 of the Subdivision Control Ordinance requiring lots to have a minimum of 50' of frontage at the street right-of-way Petitioner: Primrose Development, LLC FINDINGS OF FACT - SUBDIVISION CONTROL ORDINANCE VARIANCE REQUEST (Ballot Sheet) 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Dated this _ day of ,2002. COMMISSION MEMBER H:\JanetIPrimroseIFenstennakerIF ofF Frontage ROW.wpd " .'io w Q (Submit two (2) copies) Waiver from 2 points of access for Open Space ./f:\-rL-:-i-}-i~~c. 7.6.3 ./ \. t." V-. -"'~' ' "~,, /\, v" . '\ / Y ! /' /\ 6~? RECEIVED '\~(~I \~~T! JUM 28 2002 f:.,-=-,I ,I~ 1"1 .=\ DOCS j.~) c/,\ jk:/ \("i;" /)/.. ;:';' (,.'~'0 /"'\ "" ,.r~_ ...--/..\ "~~:!J];[r21~~.:~~' Telephone No.: (317) 844-0106 SUBDIVISION VARIANCE REQUEST APPLICATION Docket No. 81- O'-b Sw Contact Person: Charles D. Frankenberger PROJECT NAME: Laura Vista PROJECT ADDRESS/LOCA nON: Between 136th Street and 146th Street. east of Keystone Avenue and immediately west of Foster Estates. Section 6B APPLICANT NAME: Primrose Development. LLC ADDRESS: 445 Gradle Drive. CarmeL Indiana 46032 TELEPHONE: (317) 846-6641 Attention: Jim White Section (Section Number, Page, Item) of Subdivision Regulations for which variance is being requested: See Exhibit A State explanation of why variance is being requested: See Exhibit A State reasons supporting variance request: See Exhibit A Present Zoning: R-l C/C.-.~ ~_ AL ". Charles D. Frankenberger Attorneyfor Applicant Date: $ APPLICATION FEE H:Vanet\Primrose\Fenstennaker\SV A 7.6.3 open space 2 access points.wpd ; . .. '. o Q EXHIBIT "A" 1. Subdivision Regulations for which variance is being requested: This subdivision variance is requested from Section 7.6.3 of the Subdivision Control Ordinance which requires 2 points of access to an open space. 2. State explanation of why variance is being requested: This variance is requested because there is only one (I) point of access to Common Areas Band C. 3. State reasons supporting variance request: Open space provided already exceeds open space required. Common Areas Band Care intended primarily as a buffer yard. H:\.Janet\Primrose\Fenstennaker\SV A 7.6.3 open space 2 access points.wpd t 'e Q Q CARMEL PLAN COMMISSION Carmel, Indiana SUBDIVISION VARIANCE FINDINGS OF FACT Docket No: Petitioner: Primrose Development LLC Section Variance: Section 7.6.3 of the Subdivision Regulations Brief Description of Variance: Variance from requirement of2 points of access to an open space In deciding whether or not the applicant has presented sufficient proof to permit the granting of a variance, the Plan Commission should consider the following: The grantofa variance will not be injurious to the public health, safety, morals and general welfare of the community. The use and value of area adjacent to the property included in the proposed plat will not be affected in a substantially adverse manner. The need for the variance arises from some condition peculiar to the property and such condition is not due to the general conditions of the neighborhood. The strict application of terms of the ordinance to the property will constitute an unusual and unnecessary hardship if applied to the property for which the variance is sought. The grant of the variance does not interfere substantially with the Comprehensive Plan. Based on all the evidence presented by the petitioner, I approve of the requested subdivision variance. I hereby disapprove of the subdivision variance request for the following reasons: 1. 2. 3. Dated this _ day of ,2002. Commission Member H:\Janet\Primrose\Fenstennaker\F ofF Open Space Access.wpd ~ . ,.--e: o u CITY OF CARMEL PLAN COMMISSION CARMEL, INDIANA Docket No.: - Laura Vista - Waiver from Section 7.6.3 of the Subdivision Control Ordinance requiring 2 points of access to an open space Petitioner: Primrose Development, LLC FINDINGS OF FACT - SUBDIVISION CONTROL ORDINANCE VARIANCE REOUEST (Ballot Sheet) 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Dated this _ day of , 2002. COMMISSION MEMBER H:\Janet\Primrose\Fenstennaker\F ofF Open Space Access.wpd fl.. ',," u u SUBDIVISION VARIANCE REQUEST APPLICATION Waiver from open space 75' in width Sec. 7.6.3 /(:5~~~\ ~. ' - '/"\, ~/ RE~~[D'<\~ @ JU" 2~ 2002 f;1 ~-3\ DOCS If) / " /.." j' 1'0o~_ -:1\/ ~ I r 'o-r'\\-;- Telephone No:: (J17) 844-0106 (Submit two (2) copies) Docket No. 81- Cl-c. SvJ Contact Person: Charles D. Frankenberger PROJECT NAME: Laura Vista PROJECT ADDRESS/LOCATION: Between 136th Street and 146th Street. east of Keystone Avenue and immediately west of Foster Estates. Section 6B APPLICANT NAME: Primrose Development. LLC ADDRESS: 445 Gradle Drive. Carmel. Indiana 46032 TELEPHONE: (317) 846-6641 Attention: Jim White Section (Section Number, Page, Item) of Subdivision Regulations for which variance is being requested: See Exhibit A State explanation of why variance is being requested: See Exhibit A State reasons supporting variance request: See Exhibit A Present Zoning: R-1 Date: ~~~~,(. . Charles D.' rankenberge~ Attorney for Applicant $ APPLICATION FEE H:\JanetIPrimrose\FenstennakerISVA 7.6.3 open space 75'.wpd .. '. u u EXHIBIT "A" I. Subdivision Regulations for which variance is being requested: This subdivision variance is requested from Section 7.6.3 of the Subdivision Control Ordinance which requires open space to be 75' in width. 2. State explanation of why variance is being requested: This variance is requested in order to maintain desired lot depth west of Vista Drive. 3. State reasons supporting variance request: To add to the existing 55' width of Common Areas Band C, a 20' landscape easement exists in the rear of adjoining lots, where the existing fence/tree row will be retained. Open space provided already exceeds open space required, and a 55' common area permits the retention of more forested area. H:VanetlPrimroselFenstennakerlSVA 7.6.3 open space 75'.wpd u u CARMEL PLAN COMMISSION Carmel, Indiana SUBDIVISION VARIANCE FINDINGS OF FACT Docket No: Petitioner: Primrose Develooment. LLC Section Variance: Section 7.6.3 ofthe Subdivision Regulations Brief Description of Variance: Variance from requirement that open space be 75' in width In deciding whether or not the applicant has presented sufficient proof to permit the granting of a variance, the Plan Commission should consider the following: The grant of a variance will not be injurious to the public health, safety, morals and general welfare of the community. The use and value of area adjacent to the property included in the proposed plat wi II not be affected in a substantially adverse manner. The need for the variance arises from some condition peculiar to the property and such condition is not due to the general conditions of the neighborhood. The strict application of terms of the ordinance to the property will constitute an unusual and unnecessary hardship ifapplied to the property for which the variance is sought. The grant of the variance does not interfere substantially with the Comprehensive Plan. Based on all the evidence presented by the petitioner, I approve of the requested subdivision vanance. I hereby disapprove of the subdivision variance request for the following reasons: 1. 2. 3. Dated this _ day of ,2002. Commission Member H:\JanetIPrimroseIFenstennakerIF ofF Open space 75'.wpd ".. .. w u CITY OF CARMEL PLAN COMMISSION CARMEL, INDIANA Docket No.: - Laura Vista - Waiver from Section 7.6.3 ofthe Subdivision Control Ordinance from requirement that open space be 75' in width Petitioner: Primrose Development, LLC FINDINGS OF FACT - SUBDIVISION CONTROL ORDINANCE VARIANCE REQUEST (Ballot Sheet) 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Dated this _ day of ,2002. COMMISSION MEMBER H:\JanetIPrimroseIFenstennakerIF of F Open space 7S'.wpd ... u u (Submit two (2) copies) Waiver for cui de sac street /' . i I ,Sec. 6.3.7 /,>>~F-'-!_:. ~:>, ~/,. A. ' , T \'.\ RECEWEO \/~\ :._J, jU~ 28 LGGL l:~j ,/, nQC" ,/~--I' \"'--\,. U ,\) ... \ ,(Ii' ~/ 'Or-, /'j ~>"'-- . ~/ '<.!../ T~\ I\...> Telephone No.: Tlf7) 844-0106 SUBDIVISION VARIANCE REQUEST APPLICATION Docket No. 8/-02.d ~y./ Contact Person: Charles D. Frankenberger PROJECT NAME: Laura Vista PROJECT ADDRESS/LOCA nON: Between 136th Street and 146th Street. east of Keystone Avenue and immediately west of Foster Estates. Section 68 APPLICANT NAME: Primrose Development. LLC ADDRESS: 445 Gradle Drive. Carmel. Indiana 46032 TELEPHONE: (317) 846-6641 Attention: Jim White Section (Section Number, Page, Item) of Subdivision Regulations for which variance is being requested: See Exhibit A State explanation of why variance is being requested: See Exhibit A State reasons supporting variance request: See Exhibit A Present Zoning: R-l Date: r:=:~/c-.L-- Charles D. Frankenberger Attorneyfor Applicant $ APPLICATION FEE H:\JanetIPtimroseIFenstennakerISVA 6.3.7 cuI de sac.wpd .... ..' .. u Q EXHIBIT "A" I. Subdivision Regulations for which variance is being requested: This subdivision variance is requested from Section 6.3.7 of the Subdivision Control Ordinance which requires cul-de-sac streets to be less than or equal to 600' in length. 2. State explanation of why variance is being requested: This variance is requested to permit a street greater than 600' in length to conclude with a cul-de-sac. 3. State reasons supporting variance request: The cul-de-sac is not substantially longer than 600', and the variance is necessary in order to maintain the desired configuration of lots, internal streets, and common areas. H:\JanetIPrimroseIFenstennakerISVA 6.3.7 cui de sac.wpd ~ u u CARMEL PLAN COMMISSION Carmel, Indiana SUBDIVISION VARIANCE FINDINGS OF FACT Docket No: Petitioner: Primrose Development. LLC Section Variance: Section 6.3.7 of the Subdivision Regulations Brief Description of Variance: Variance from reQuirement that cul-de-sac streets be less than or equal to 600' in length In deciding whether or not the applicant has presented sufficient proof to permit the granting of a variance, the Plan Commission should consider the following: The grantofa variance will not be injurious to the public health, safety, morals and general welfare of the community. The use and value of area adjacentto the property included in the proposed plat will not be affected in a substantially adverse manner. The need for the variance arises from some condition peculiar to the property and such condition is not due to the general conditions ofthe neighborhood. The strict application of terms of the ordinance to the property will constitute an unusual and unnecessary hardship if applied to the property for which the variance is sought. The grant of the variance does not interfere substantially with the Comprehensive Plan. Based on all the evidence presented by the petitioner, I approve of the requested subdivision variance. I hereby disapprove of the subdivision variance request for the following reasons: 1. 2. 3. Dated this _ day of ,2002. Commission Member R\JanetlPrimroselFenstennakerlF of F Cul-de-sac. wpd { u u CITY OF CARMEL PLAN COMMISSION CARMEL, INDIANA Docket No.: - Laura Vista - Waiver from Section 6.3.7 ofthe Subdivision Control Ordinance requiring cul-de-sac streets be less than or equal to 600' in length. Petitioner: Primrose Development, LLC FINDINGS OF FACT - SUBDIVISION CONTROL ORDINANCE VARIANCE REOUEST (Ballot Sheet) 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Dated this day of ,2002. COMMISSION MEMBER H:lJanetlPrimroselFenstennakerlF of F Cul-de-sac.wpd Iii .. '. u u (Submit two (2) copies) Waiver Permitting Sllbdividing Floodway , \' I - /< ',\'~'-- ; "Sec. 6.2.1 ':"'/' t .' ,'. , ~/ ,I.., ,/ \ ~.'\ /< RECE\'.JED \'=, 1:-' Jli~ 28 ~a\)2. :',:.'1 ,-I \:\. ' DOCS \ ,/':-.... '(~:~// /. -- i '- ! I '" ,/ ,/., 'I ',-\ '>> SUBDIVISION VARIANCE REQUEST APPLICATION Docket No. 8J -02. e. 5vv' Contact Person: Charles D. Frankenberger Telephone No.: (317) 844-0106 PROJECT NAME: Laura Vista PROJECT ADDRESS/LOCATION: Between 136th Street and 146th Street. east of Keystone Avenue and immediately west of Foster Estates. Section 6B APPLICANT NAME: Primrose Development. LLC ADDRESS: 445 Gradle Drive. CarmeL Indiana 46032 TELEPHONE: (317) 846-6641 Attention: Jim White Section (Section Number, Page, Item) of Subdivision Regulations for which variance is being requested: See Exhibit A State explanation of why variance is being requested: See Exhibit A State reasons supporting variance request: See Exhibit A Present Zoning: R-I Date: ~~~~ Charles D. rankenberger Attorneyfor Applicant $ APPLICATION FEE 1l:\JanetlPrimroselFenstennakerlSV A 6,2, I Floodway u u EXHIBIT "A" I. Subdivision Regulations for which variance is being requested: This subdivision variance is requested from Section 6.2.1 of the Subdivision Control Ordinance which provides that land within a floodway will not be subdivided. 2. State explanation of why variance is being requested: This variance is requested because certain lots are within a flood plain. 3. State reasons supporting variance request: The residence already exists and subdividing does not reduce its proximity to floodway. The land is being platted in order to avoid the continuation of an unplatted lot. H:\Ianel\Primrose\Fenstennaker\SV A 6.2.1 Floodway w u CARMEL PLAN COMMISSION Carmel, Indiana SUBDIVISION VARIANCE FINDINGS OF FACT Docket No: Petitioner: Primrose Development. LLC Section Variance: Section 6.2.1 of the Subdivision Regulations Brief Description of Variance: Variance from reauirement that land within a floodwav not be subdivided In deciding whether or not the applicant has presented sufficient proof to perm it the granting of a variance, the Plan Commission should consider the following: The grant of a variance will not be injurious to the public health, safety, morals and general welfare ofthe community. The use and value of area adjacent to the property included in the proposed plat wi II not be affected in a substantially adverse manner. The need for the variance arises from some condition peculiar to the property and such condition is not due to the general conditions ofthe neighborhood. The strict application of terms of the ordinance to the property will constitute an unusual and unnecessary hardship if applied to the property for which the variance is sought. The grant of the variance does not interfere substantially with the Comprehensive Plan. Based on all the evidence presented by the petitioner, I approve of the requested subdivision vanance. I hereby disapprove of the subdivision variance request for the following reasons: 1. 2. 3. Dated this _ day of ,2002. Commission Member H :\Janet\Primrose\fenstennaker\f of f floodway. wpd u u CITY OF CARMEL PLAN COMMISSION CARMEL, INDIANA Docket No.: - Laura Vista - Waiver from Section 6.2.1 ofthe Subdivision Control Ordinance which requires that land within a floodway not be subdivided. Petitioner: Primrose Development, LLC FINDINGS OF FACT - SUBDIVISION CONTROL ORDINANCE VARIANCE REQUEST (Ballot Sheet) 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Dated this _ day of , 2002. COMMISSION MEMBER H:\JanetIPrimroseIFenstennakerIF ofF Floodway.wpd ,~ t-.-, ,~.:.. 7--.5 ~ y. o - u <~;;-~~ :- <~;V',c-'C'LJ~ ](':-... /\\'>' . .. -" 1:~~~V.t ~j 1::/ RECE\VEU ~\ . JUN 26 2002 DOCS OWNER'S CONSENT AND AUTHORIZATION ,.e, Gary F. Faust and Cynthia S. Faust, the undersigned, hereby authorize and appoint Development, LLC, and its representatives, and Nelson & Frankenberger, P.C., and its attorneys and representatives, to represent them before the Carmel Clay Plan Commission and its committees, and in all other entities and committees, in connection with any and all public hearings, meetings, conferences, and related communications necessary to obtain primary plat approval and secondary plat approval of the real estate described in what is attached hereto and incorporated here and by reference Exhibit "A". Date: If'd :111 2002 ~ 0- ~--?: <----cJ Gary F. Fa Date: b /0.3/0;2.../ , w ~~~~d.~"':r./ . Cyn ia S. Faust H:\JanetlGuest~Primrose Faust Owners Consent OS 1302. wpd ,. 1- . .. - "'1.. r~.. . u .w ." LA JI A oa~t of the South half of the Northwest Quarter of Section 19, township 18 North, Range 4 East in Clay Township, Hamilton County, Indiana, more particularly described as follows: Beginning 12 feet South of the Northwest corner.of the South half of the Northwest Quarter of Section 19, Township 18 North, Range 4 East, and on the West line thereof, said point ~lso being on the extended centerlir.'! on a 24 foot easement for ingress and egress to this property beginning at the East right of way line of U. S. Road 31, thence l~ortn 90 degrees East:)O and along aforesaid centerline and parallel with the North __..'" of said Half Quarter Section 1404.2 feet to the P.C. of a curve to the right with a radius of 63.17 feet; thence on and along said curve 83.22 feet to an p.c.c. common to aforesaid curve and a curve to the right with a radtus of 200.72 feet; thence on along said curve 98.6 feet to its p.t.; thence South 13 , -~ees 23.5 minutes West 152.6 feet to the P:C. of a curve to the ie, ~ with radius of 158.66 feet; thence on and along said curve 96.87 feet to its p.t.; thence south 21 degrees 30.5 minutes East 93.95 feet to the place of beginning of this tract, and the end of the centerline of aforesaid easement for ingress and egress; thence North 17. degrees 26 minutes East 116.25 feet; thence North 75 degrees 35 minutes East 244.10 feet; thence South 32 degrees 18.5 minutes East 294.41 feet; thence South 72 degrees 13 minutes 46 seconds East .45.69 feet; thence South 05 degrees Ii .....,lUtes West 48.06 feet; thence North 89 degrees 41 minutes West 406.76 feet; 'thence North 43 de~~rees 52 minutes West 68.39 feet; thence North 15 de9rees 56.5 minutes West 66.17 feet; thence North l7 degrees 26 minutes East 29.44 feet to the place of beginning. -- ------- ; I I _" _ ~_ _._;.- _--;_. .__~....~- ,", __, m i .:Ij. /r, J\ -"~ \ \ \J\,/,;":';! I -~......... /\ ';}j:,--\..-L-<-<<....(j A /E""Y" ",'of / '\ I!!:~~' T "<',\ f,::--:/ RECEIVED '~~:;, ,;\ 16JI \ t=JJUN 26 2002 0;, \(f;\ DO, CS I' -j \/~ " 'A '<. ~"..'<l "'~.;"';.__ /\A '. I I ,_ _ '1-> //811'\\)0./ The Ward R. Fenstermaker Family, L.P., hereby authorizes and appoints Primrose Development, LLC, and its representatives, and Nelson & Frankenberger, P .C., and its attorneys and representatives, to represent it before the Carmel Clay Plan Commission and its committees, and before all other entities and committees, in connection with any and all public hearings, meetings, conferences, and related communications necessary to obtain primary plat approval and secondary plat approval of the real estate described in what is attached hereto and incorporated here and by reference Exhibit "A". u o it ~ ~; OWNER'S CONSENT AND AUTHORIZATION Date: Sp 9/rD~z. The Ward R. Fenstermaker Family, L.P. ~ ----- -~--~ ------------------'--,-~ -'~~ .- --. _._.~----- ~if H :Vanet\Guest\Primrose Fenstennaker Owners Consent 051302 . wpd !I'" <;. ;iILt%INJ [D) lQ)~~l_Ril] lFflJJ~(Q)~~ U "A * .' ^ PMd Ole THF c:;OUTH HALF OF THE NORTHWEST QUARTER OF SECTION 1 ,.J. lC'Wl\J':~;HIP 18 NORTH. RANGE 4 [,A,S T LOCATED IN CLA Y TOWNSHIP. HAMIL iON COUNT!. INDIANA BEING DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS: BEGINNING AT THE STONE WITH CROSS AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF HiE NORTHWEST QUARTER OF SECTION 19. TOWNSHIP 18 NORTH. RANGE 4 EA~T; THENCE NORTH 00 DEGREES 29 MINUTES 55 SECONDS EAST (ASSUMED BEARING) 1328.25 FEET TO A 5/8 INCH IRON ROD IMTl1 YELLOW CAP STAMPED MILl.ER '~;URVE'rING A T THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF THE SOUTH HALF OF SAID NORTHWEST OUARTER; THENCE NOfHH 90 DEGREES 00 MINUTES 00 SECONDS WES~T 1160.90 FEET. MORE OR LESS. C)N AND ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF THE SOUTH HALF UF SAID NORTHWEST OUARTER TO /\, 5/8 INCH IRON ROD 'Nlnl P I. CRIFE (,\P AT Hie NORTHEAST CORNER OF A 13.464 .l\CRE TRACT OF PEAL [S TATE DESCRIBED IN INSTRUMENT NO. :2000 .36993. SAID 5/8 INCH IRON ROD WI fH CRIPE CAP BEING NORTH 90 DEGREES 00 MINUTES 00 ':,LCONDS [AS T 141482 FfFT FROM THF NORTHwrq CORNER OF THF (~nIlTH I-IAI F or SAID NORTHWEST OUf\TTER (THE FOLLOWING 2 COURSES ARE ON A~[) AIJ'NG THE EASTERl.f BOUNDARY OF 'cAIO 13464 ACRE TRACT) (1) THCNCE SOUTH 00 DEGREES 55 MINUTES 19 SECOND':, WEST 100000 FEU f(l _.A,_5.LB_.1ND:UF~LRDD_\MJJLYELLO.w_CAfl.-SJAMEED-.MILLEfL.~_ __ ___ SURVEYING: (2) !HeNCE SOUTH 24 DEGREES 08 MINU~l') 29 SECONDS FA::;T)Sf,'\8 rC,1 TO A 5/8 INCH IRON ROO WlTHrTHOW CAP ::;TAMPFn MILLER C,URV['fiNG ON THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID NORTHINEST QUARTER, THeNCe ~;OU TH fj') DEGREES 50 MINUT[S 06 S[CONr,~; LA', 1 101959 f:Ef: r rer fHE PI)iNT or BEGINNING CONTAINING 3494 A(:F<Lc,. MORE OR lXSS [xU.PT A ::' 34 ACRE TRACT OF REAL ESTA TF ftECORDE[) IN INSTRUMENT NO. QC.18334 t./.JD DE~,CRI8ED AS FOLLOWS A PAPT OF THE SOUTH Hl\LF OF THE NOF:THWEST ()UARTf:Y Dr SECTION 19. TOWNSHIP 18 NORm, RANGE 4 LAST IN CLAY TOWr--.CH1P, HAMILTON (OUNn. INDIANA, MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOW'; BEGINNING 12 ~T[T SOUTH OF THE NORTHWEST CORNEP or THE SOUTH HALF OF THE NORTHWEST QUARTER OF SECTION 19. TrIWNSHIP 18 NORIH. RANGE 4 EAST. AND ON THE WEST LINE THEREOF. ';AID F'OIN T AL SO BEING ON THE EXTENDED eEN TLRUNE ON A ::'4 FOOT EASEMEN T FOR iNGRLSS AND EGRESS TO THIS PROPERTY BEGINNING A T THE EAS T F:I(;~n or WAY LINE or us. ROAD :31. THENCE NORTH SlO DEGREU, EAST t)N AND ALONG ArORESAID CENTfRLlNE AND PARALLEL \'IlTH THE NORTH LINE OF :j"'I[) HA.LF OUARTER SECTION 1404.2 FEET TO THE POINT (iF (~I_JRV^TURE Of' /. (~UR\!E TO THE RICHI WITH A RAOIlY:, OF 6.3.17 FEET. THENCE ON AND AU)NG SAID CURVE 8.3.?2 FEET TO APe C COMMON TO AFORESAID CURVE AND A CURVE TO THE RIGHT WITH 1\ RMJIUS or 200.72 FEU: THENCE ON AND ALONG SAID CURVE 98.6 FEET TO I TS POINT OF flltllGENCY; THENCE SOUTH 1J DE_CREES 23.5.MINUTE::; WEST 152.6 FEET_ r, HiE f'IJIN T OF CURVA TURF: OF .A CURVE TO THE I_EFT WI TH RADIUS OF r~,(\ (,6 FFTT: THENCE ON AND ALONe. SAID CURVE 96.07 FEET TO ITS POINT ,IF lANC.FJ.J( I; THENCE SOUTH 21 DEGREES 30,5 MINlrlES fA:) T 939~) FEU 11.\1 HE PU\CE' OF BE.GINNINC OF THIS TRACT. AND THE END OF THE (ENTt:RLlNE. or AFORESAID [A~;EMENT FOR INGRESS AND EeRES'::.; THEN'" NOFlTH 17 DEGREE''; 26 MINUTES E.'\'3T 11 f) ~'') fELl. THEN'-::E "J:lh',f, -~c, r)F(;RFF'-~ 7,.S MINIITF<;, FAST )4.4 in fTrT. If-IFN('- '~nIITH ?,:' f-f(;r-;>[t', ~B5 MiNt ':; EA5T 294.41 FEU; THENCE sou [!-I.' DEGPEES 1:, Mlr-..:UT[~. 4ti '~EC()~ ) EAST 4569 rEEl; THENCE soun-I C", MINUTE:'. 17 MINU TF'~) WEST de< FEn; THENCL NOfHH 89 DEGRE[('11 MINU rES WEsr 4lih 'f., HI:!, IHUJU-_ NORTH 4,S DEGRlES 52 MINUTE', WI:.sr 68.59 FEEl. IH[Nd NURIH I') DLGHElS ~t,S MINUIES WlSI bbl' H-U; THENCE N()f;>TH 1'J DEGREES ?6 MINUTE:, FA::,T 2944 FECT TO THE PLACE OF H( i':iNN:r.J(, , "N I ^I~.MJ': .^f II P illl loA' ,fd 1,)[; lJ".',. .\HIM UL';-:r-:lf:5EL' EXCLPTl9N.J2.60 ACRES, ""~~:~,~~~~~!:> ,,' '....~:'::,,~4. . ......,..:i;'l'r,f.'t';fi. ;~ '~ ....~i> ~--0 (UJ rDJ, \Vl rl~ \V7(i r:':::0 __ I ni \ / I L., )( , IN ACCORD ANCE WI TH Ti' THROU(;H 34 OF THE IN! OBSERVA TlONS AND OPI/, VARIOUS UNCERTAINT1[~. CORNERS ESTABLlSH[[) I' 0) VARIANCES IN THE b) DISCREPANCIES IN I c) INCONSISTENCIES IN d) RANDOM ERRORS 1~1 , ",UNCERTAINTY); _r;<:>~_n,.' .t~t(c,~{_;'; .,,~:,_ ,.', ::jn~E;'~'THE0RETICAt:; UNCEr: MEASUREMENT) OF THE IN THI'; SURV[ Y IS WI; I. THIS IS AN ORIGINAL Sl:: REAL ESTA TE OESCRIBEI' rHl NORrHEASr CuRNEH ~I.~,....."'r't ".......-.,... .....,.',.-.....r~n ,-.r' ,- r .oJ,' .f U' U' /<;~T??Sr--", /<:.>> "........ "../'(,t;\.. I "'" ,f. \/ \ t]' RECEIVED \:\ OWNER'S CONSENT AND AUTHORIZATION I-I JUN 26 2002 \- d DOCS ~ The S.E. Fenstermaker Family, LP, hereby authori7.es and appoints Primro~elopmen\K I' LLC, and its representatives, and Nelson & Frankenberger, P.C., and its attorh~\ \ representatives, to represent it before the Carmel Clay Plan Commission and its committees, and before all other entities and committees, in connection with any and all public hearings, meetings, conferences, and related communications necessary to obtain primary plat approval and secondary plat approval of the real estate described in what is attached hereto and incorporated here and by reference Exhibit "A". 1'" Date: )i, ly ff / IJ ~ o()2 . .. _._ . J J~ S.E. FenstermakerfamilY, LP By' S. E. Fenstermaker, Jr., Trustee, General Partner 72:;~(j j!J II: IJanet\Primrose\F enstennakerIConsellt-S. Fenstennaker. wpd 1 .(' .r~-"" k ;; ii, ' ',I A '\, i ',' iii' r, "\ I, r'~)llS' c-:-' (<,~l (,/, ",j: r ~;, ',', i : D)'L 1 r 'I' j' / i"',\ I' r\J,'j' , " , I' , , I 'I' I " 'l ' :J"" I ' , ,," I 'I II " ,~ ~ i_"r~~,\lj' ,J:~':'/ i..:.::l Si oI':,:)!J "~U iF U L \~/u \,\ ~ ^ L,;-r,i "~ iHf':,C'L'TH H~ OF !~f: NORTHWE')T 1,~i".iHt'Y'1f SEe" I ,. fl'W!>.j')"" !,'3 fl.J!:lPTH, RANGE -1. f',\':;T L()CJ\,TED Ifl.J ',",ll'! f0wN',;HIP, i IM"'1i ;"~J "Uti j" !NDIANA BEiNG DESCRI8ED AS FOLLOW:;: 8[(;INNIN(;t\i rHE STONE WITH CROSS AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF TI~E ~V)RTHWE':, r I)Ut\PTEP OF SECTlCN 19. TOWNSHIP 18 NOPTH, RANGE 4 lA:,) T, THENCE NC,q lrl C,I) DCGREES '''j ""iNUTES 55 SECOND', EASl (ASSUMED BEARING) i ::,?i:1 25 rEU If) A :i/8 INCH IRON ReD 'MTl-i YELLOW I~AP S rAMPED MILLER ':;UfN[r1N(..\ T THE NOPTl-iEAST CC)R~Jc,F< OF THE SOU TH HALF OF')AIf) NOR T~WE <:. T ()Ui\P TER, THENCE NOP fH 90 DEGREES 00 M!N:Ji[S 00 SECOND:~ ViE:;T 1160,90 FEE:, MORE OR LES'3. eN AND ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF :Hr~ '::,c)UTH HALF Uf SAID NORrHV4IE::, T QUARTeR TO A 5/8 INCH IRON PC.C '1;1 TIt P I CRIFe (,\[' t,l TH[ NORTHEAST CORNER OF A 134641\CPE TRACT OF RE AL EST A IT DESCRIBED IN INSTRUMENT NO 2000 ,3699.3, SAID 5/8 INCH IRON POD WlfH CRIPE CAP BE;,-.JG NORTH 90 O[l;P[['O 00 MINU1E'3 00 ':.fCONUS r:^'~ r 14/4 R7 FFFT FROM THF NnRTHWf'r; T ('ORNf}, t,lF THF ';01' TH il,\; F 'iF SAID N(lRTHWE:',l our rER (THE FOLLOWING ;, COURSFc~ APr:,N AND AiJ)~G THE EA'-,TERl' E'.(ll.lNrit\R. (jF ,:10 1.3464 ACR~: ,PACT) ii', ThC'!\;,-::r SOUTH OC) OEGRFES 55 MINUTr:::. Li SECOND::, we"T l~)OOOO FEE T [e ' s /8 INCH IF ') ROD 'v\1iHrELLOW CAP STAMPED MILLEY :,i,<R'/[lli,' (2)H~NCE SUUTH 24 D[(~REC:; 08 MINU-;-[", '/9 :,ECONDS ~. ,,:-,T Yir, ,r)!) I, ' , TO A 5/-9 INCH IRON ROD WITH ,'fl ,i)'yV CAP :::iTAMPFfI M!LL[R SURV['''i~i(; ON THE ')OUTH l..INE OF SAID NORTH',vt:ST QUARTER, 1HLWr ';,nu if-! Ri) DF:GR[[S 50 M!"jUTr~S 06 cJrCONG',) E J\r" 1 1019 S9 q:T 1 '" rH~ Pl',.!NT 1,1f HEGINNING (ONit\iNING 3494 ACf:.>tC" MORE (lP 1[")'=; [xdT r ,~ .; 34 A'':'RE fPACr iA ~EAL ES T,fIH: RE(;ORDEU iN iN.';TRUM[NT \i(f f~~:, \,3 j ':,4 t,ND DESCRIBED AS ~f)LtJYN'; i, ~,l~'l I,i; THE S('>,j 11--' I-Pl.;: I);: iHl f'.JOf;: "YVES r ()U,\PTty ',' ''olC nON l:,l, TI::WNSHIP ! 8 NORTH, RA,N(,f. 4 E!~C:.T IN CLA,'( TOWN':'-HfJ, HAMILTON (OUNTf INDIANA, MORE PARTICULAR:.., DESCRIBED AC. r:~'LLOW:; REGiNNING 1;' ~rTT SOUTH OF :HE NORTHWEST COf?NFP ()F THE SOUTH HALF OF THE NORTHWEST OUARTER (IF SECTION 19, ,;'IWNSHIP 18- NOR1H, RANGE 4 EAST. AND ONTH[ \'lEST LINE THf::F;!:J1F, ';A.!(1 POINT ,\L SO E[ir,jl,~ ON rHE EXTENDED eEN iEYLlNE. ON A ;':-1 f')I)1 EA::'EMEN I inF iN'~Rf,<, ANL' EGRESc~ i", r'i;'; PP'JPERTr' B[(,INNiN(, A f THE EAsr F:i';HT ,;f WI\'( LINE OF U:'< f'>l)A[; )1, PleNe:E NORTH '91.: U[<:;R[[:., EAST 1'--)(\ ..'\;'4[\ ;;:...c)~J(; Af.()r[(~A!D C[NTfJ~l ~~\)~~ f\ND P/\RALL[l_ '111 TH :1.:[ N(jPTf--t LiNf ':>~ ':,^Ii.' HAL"JIJARTf-Y:,U;Tlf)N 14042 FEET T':; THE POINT I:';: i:,;,JRIJ..T',IF<[ ,> ;, ,'I,if;'\/F Tn fHF. Pi"Hi WiTH A PM)III", (,f 6517 FEET. THUiC[ :,)N AN[j AU,'N'_, S/..ID CUR\'[ fL3 :):: FEET TO ^ P c= ,'::OMMON TO ArOFE':,AIO CURVE AND A CURVE ro THE RIGHT WITH j\, R'\DIUS or 200,72 ern, THENCE ON AND ALONG SAID CURVE 986 FEE: TO ITS POINT OF fM-J(,FNCi. THENCE SOUTH 13 DU::PEES 23,5 MINUTE'~, WEST 152,6 FEET TdE F';jIN T OF (URVA TUR[ OF t" CURVf TO THE LFFT WITH RADIUS OF '~':" (.~; tf'E1, THE~jl--:E ON AND I\Li)N'~ SAID CURVE 9687 FEET TO ITS POINT ','F ;1\N'A)~t I, THENCE SOUTH 21 Di:':;REES 30.5 MINUIE, E,A~:'T 939::) FEET ft.' lHt PL,lI,(;[' I)F 8EGINNIN(. OF THIS, TRACT, AND THF. END (,F THf, 'TN nRU~~E. OF AFORESAID r:A~~EM[N T FOR iNePE S5 ANC' EGPE '-;~" !li(N' I\Jr,fHH 11 [I[(;REES 2b MINllfl::; [.\',1 11F, ;,~ fUT. ~HlNrF. ',' '" "" ,', [',r,;PFF", C,O, MINIITFC, f' A'~T :'.~:; ::: II'V f, JH~ N" F~(\f ITH ',:' :,f'"!~',:,, :,:':. MiN':, Ft.'"T }94'~1 FEEl; ;HENCE SOU!!;', DlGPf:F::, !~! '.':~,:Tc 4'; ::,E'~')' EJ,'~1 4~"j'-] 'TfT. THENCE S0Urfl "' MINUTE>:. 17 MI"-i!ITf,',: WE')T d," FEET, THEWL NnfHH 89 DEGRE~':;1! MINUTES WEST IU '., fU I, fHU"U:. NORfH 'k) 1)f/;Hf:,lS 52 MINUTE";~ WI-,sr 68,,39 FFJr, !fltNd N,)h:lf! 1', lilG~ll::' ')/:,S MiNUlr,S WlSI 51): HLJ,IH[NCL "\j1;RTH ; 7 ,TGPF.['c; :'6 MINUTE::, r',\?,T 2944 FEET TI) THe PLACE OF !-[ ":NN:',, ~l:'''~!''!'' ^' fit.. ,'If' "i'l'!i i,i', f"!EFD EXCLPTlON '32,60 ACRES, ~);.\f\'; (II; \t',', '.:~{.f#~Jib;-' :::.,.....'" ~A .. (~, (Ln jD; \\jll"eJ \\~' r:::-') " ,n I \ / C, i r IN ACCORDANCE WITH - THROIX'i 34 OF THE i' OBSERVA now; AND Of VARI00S UNCER T AIN TiE CORNERS ESTABLlSHHI 0) VARIANCES IN rHf, b ) DISCREPANCIES I~~ c) INCONSIS TENCIES i ,d) RANDOM ERRORS UNCERTAINTY); '.," ':',.::.: -, "'" THEilHEORE11CAL UNCE ME^SURE~ENT) OF THE IN THi'o, SURVF'r I"; 'M' Tfilr.; IS l\N ')RIGIN,\L f,tAL ESTAff: rF:,(Plt~f i~H', Nl'l-oI iH[A',: 1",J,Ni