HomeMy WebLinkAbout08 August 16 MinutesCRC Meeting, August 16, 2023
1
CARMEL REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION MEETING
Wednesday, August 16, 2023
ATTENDANCE:
President Bill Hammer Present
Vice President Dave Bowers Absent
Secretary Bill Brooks Present
Member Lea Lockhart Sasena Absent
Member Jeff Worrell Present
Member Greg Brown Present
Executive Director Henry Mestetsky Present
Deputy Director Jenell Fairman Present
Finance Manager Michael Lee Present
Project Manager Larysa Glaspie Present
Office Manager Laura Hunt Present
Legal Counsel
City Legal
Ryan Wilmering
Sergey Grechukhin
Present
Absent
President Hammer called the meeting to order at 6:31 p.m.
The Pledge of Allegiance was recited.
BID OPENING
Deputy Director Fairman opened sealed price bids with four separate packages each for the
Palladium Lighting Phase II project. The prices were as follows:
Indianapolis Stage Sales & Rental: a. $199,560.00 b. $332,060.00 c. $41,400.00 d. $10,505.00
VLS: a. $225,258.80 b. $367,543.50 c. $40,762.80 d. $11,417.60
CTI: a. $211,640.39 b. $339,515.27 c. $36,033.48 d. $11,937.66
Mid-America Sound: a. $214,134.30 b. $366,050.58 c. $35,189.65 d. $11,689.31
Approval of Minutes
July 19, 2023 minutes were presented. Commissioner Worrell moved to approve the minutes.
Secretary Brooks seconded.
Vote: Yes No Abstain/Recuse
Bill Hammer X
Dave Bowers
Bill Brooks X
Jeff Worrell X
Lea Sasena
Financial Matters
Mr. Lee stated the Commission’s end of the month balance for July totaled $7,019,743, including
the restricted funds, the balance totaled $12,474,687.
Approval of Claims
Mr. Lee requested the Commission to approve the non-operating invoices in the amount of
$115,822.38.
Mr. Lee requested the Commission to approve the 2021 TIF bond invoices in the amount of
$176,756.85.
Secretary Brooks moved to approve the claims, seconded by Commissioner Worrell.
CRC Meeting, August 16, 2023
2
Vote: Yes No Abstain/Recuse
Bill Hammer X
Dave Bowers
Bill Brooks X
Jeff Worrell X
Lea Sasena
Executive Director Report
Executive Director Mestetsky presented project updates to the Commission.
Committee Reports
Architectural Review Committee – Did not meet.
Old Business
None.
New Business
a. Action Item #1 – Resolution 2023-25 re: Declaratory Resolution for Amended 126th
Street and Proscenium II allocation areas.
Synopsis: This is the first step in removing four parcels from the Amended 126th Street
allocation area and resetting the base for the Proscenium II allocation area.
Mr. Lee explained that the Proscenium II allocation area was created with a base value based on
the existing Walgreen’s building, which has since been demolished, resulting in a loss of TIF
increment. He requested the Commission to approve the resetting of the base value of the
allocation area based on the 2023 value to maximize the TIF for this project. Mr. Lee then
explained that four parcels in the Amended 126th Street allocation area were given a base AV
based on the businesses that existed and were operating there. The property is now owned by the
City, which reduced the AV below the originally set base, resulting in a loss of TIF increment for
the rest of the allocation area. He asked the Commission to approve removal of the parcels from
the allocation area to eliminate the negative TIF increment effect.
Commissioner Worrell moved to approve, seconded by Secretary Brooks.
Vote: Yes No Abstain/Recuse
Bill Hammer X
Dave Bowers
Bill Brooks X
Jeff Worrell X
Lea Sasena
b. Action Item #2 – Resolution 2023-26 re: Franciscan North Declaratory Resolution
Synopsis: This is the first step in resetting the base for the Franciscan North allocation area.
Mr. Lee explained that the allocation area was created with the anticipation that the land value
would increase dramatically once the existing buildings were demolished. That increase did not
occur, resulting in negative increment. Mr. Lee requested the Commission to approve resetting
the base AV for the allocation area based on the 2023 value.
CRC Meeting, August 16, 2023
3
Secretary Brooks moved to approve, seconded by Commissioner Worrell.
Vote: Yes No Abstain/Recuse
Bill Hammer X
Dave Bowers
Bill Brooks X
Jeff Worrell X
Lea Sasena
c. Action Item #3 – Resolution 2023-27 re: 3rd Avenue ATT TIF Pledge
Synopsis: This will pledge a portion of the TIF generated from the 3rd Avenue ATT allocation
area towards the bonds that will support the 3rd Avenue ATT project.
Mr. Lee requested the Commission approve the pledge of 95% of the TIF received from the
project to pay the bonds that will aid in the development of the 3rd Avenue ATT project.
Commissioner Worrell moved to approve, seconded by Secretary Brooks.
Vote: Yes No Abstain/Recuse
Bill Hammer X
Dave Bowers
Bill Brooks X
Jeff Worrell X
Lea Sasena
d. Action Item #4 – Resolution 2023-28 re: 3rd Avenue ATT project terms
Synopsis: This will approve the terms of the 3rd Avenue ATT project.
Executive Director Mestetsky requested the Commission approve the terms of the project
agreement for the 3rd Avenue ATT project.
Secretary Brooks moved to approve, seconded by Commissioner Worrell.
Vote: Yes No Abstain/Recuse
Bill Hammer X
Dave Bowers
Bill Brooks X
Jeff Worrell X
Lea Sasena
e. Action Item #5 – Resolution 2023-29 re: Property acquisition
Synopsis: This will approve the purchase of properties located at 444, 506, and 508 S. Rangeline
Executive Director Mestetsky requested the Commission approve the purchase of three properties
for $2.9M, which was lower than the average of two appraisals received by the CRC. The funds
for the purchase will come from the 2021 TIF Bond proceeds.
CRC Meeting, August 16, 2023
4
Commissioner Worrell moved to approve, seconded by Secretary Brooks.
Vote: Yes No Abstain/Recuse
Bill Hammer X
Dave Bowers
Bill Brooks X
Jeff Worrell X
Lea Sasena
f. Action Item #6 – Palladium Lighting Phase 2 contract awards
Synopsis: This will award the contracts for the Palladium Lighting Phase 2 project to the lowest
and most responsive bidder.
Deputy Director Fairman reported the lowest bids for each bid package opened earlier in the
meeting. The results are as follows:
Bid package a: Indianapolis Stage Sales & Rentals - $199,560.00
Bid package b: Indianapolis Stage Sales & Rentals - $332,060.00
Bid package c: Mid-America Sound - $35,189.65
Bid package d: Indianapolis Stage Sales & Rentals - $10,505.00
The total for all bid packages combined is $577,314.65, which is a savings of $6,000 - $7,000 for
breaking the award out into individual bid packages over accepting the single lowest bidder for
all packages combined. The funds will come from the 2021 TIF Bond proceeds and are within the
budget.
Ms. Fairman requested the Commission to approve award of the contracts as read and to delegate
the finalization and execution of the contracts to the Executive Director of the CRC.
Secretary Brooks moved to approve, seconded by Commissioner Worrell.
Vote: Yes No Abstain/Recuse
Bill Hammer X
Dave Bowers
Bill Brooks X
Jeff Worrell X
Lea Sasena
g. Action Item #7 – Grant increase
Synopsis: This will increase the grant in Resolution 2022-26 by $10,000.
Executive Director Mestetsky requested the Commission to approve the increase of grant funds,
previously approved by the CRC, to the CMCDC from $50,000 to $60,000 to help incentivize a
hotel being built at 103rd and Pennsylvania St.
Secretary Brooks moved to approve, seconded by Commissioner Worrell.
Vote: Yes No Abstain/Recuse
Bill Hammer X
Dave Bowers
Bill Brooks X
Jeff Worrell X
Lea Sasena
CRC Meeting, August 16, 2023
5
Other Business
None
Adjournment
The Commission adjourned the meeting at 7:12P.M.
The next scheduled meeting is set for Wednesday, September 20, 2023, 6:30 p.m.