HomeMy WebLinkAboutPacket
DOCKET NO.
07100013 V
PETITIONER: Donald R Dunbar
& Kathleen A Dunbar
1700 W 10Sth Street
Carmel, IN 46033
Gradison
Building
Corp.,
Buildtr / Developer / Remodeler
.~/~_r ,
l~ <)?' ~
I~:/ RECEIVED
. NOV'6?
. I .007
DOCS
,..
,::-"'" /'
>,'~1"..
, , I I ~ ,..:" ~
CARMEL/CLAY ADVISORY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
Carmel, Indiana
Docket No.:
PetitIoner:
07100013 DSV..
Donald R & Kathleen A Dunbar_
FINDiNGS OF FACT - DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS VARIANCe fBallot Sheet}
1.
2.
3.
DA TED THrs
DAY OF
,20 _..
Board Member
Page 7 of g-z~\shEire-d\fO(m;S\BZAappiic8Uon~~ Dc~"€iopmaiitStcmc3rds Val'iRnL2 A~pHcMicn rev. 1?!29f2{JC>S
CARMEUCLAY ADVISORY BOARD OF ZONING APPEAUi
CARMEL, INDIANA
Docket No.:
07100013DSV
Petitioner:
Donald R. & Kathleen A. Dunbar
FINDINGS OF FACT - DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS VARIANCE
1. The approval o'f this variance will notbe injurious to the public health, safety,morafs and general welfare of the
community because:
. .
. . .
_The new garage that is proposed is going to sit back from the rlght of. way In-excesl;; of 186 feet That makes it at
least 200 reet from the road. We also have a very wooded Jot so it will. not ilegatlvely effect anyone's right t6 quiet
enjoyment of their lot' . ,
2. The, use and value ofJhe8:rea adjacent 'to the property included in the variance will not be affecledin a
subStantiaHy adverse manner because: .... .
3.
VlJeare keeping the Sir'lgle FamilyR<:,sidentia! LIse ofthe .property ang ar~ n'otEOi(pandingthe use in anym~\liner;
3. The strict application of.theterm~ ofthe Zoning Ordi~ance to the property will resl:jlt in practical difficulties ill the
usedf the property becal,.lse: . .
\IV e woUld lleed to park cars in the. drive. area and that \!'iolild be more offensive thana new garage that vvould
enhance the properlY. We also V,iquld enQumber the views from the Crooked Stick. Golf Course if we moved it to
the rear of the Property: . .
DECISION .
iT .IS THEREFOREthe decision ofthe. CarmeJlClay. Board of Zoning AppealS that DevE/iopmentStandards Variance
Docket No. 07100013 DSV. .' .. . is granted, subject to any condftions stated in the minutes of this
Board, which are incorporated herein oyreference ~nd made a part hereof. . ..,
. Adopted this
day of .. '
,20
CHAIRPERSON,. CarmelfClay Boar,qofZqning.AppeaJs .'
SECRETARY, Carmel/ClayBoard of Zo'ning AppeaJs
Conditions of the Board are Ilsted on the back. (petitioner or his representative to sign).
Page B,of 8' Mn z~\nharieO\f::J'm1.t;\8LA. ~ppH~~tiOrJS\ oeve-lt:p,rJ9fll S~a~~daros Varial1ce ApplicutJ'on .r~if. 1?J29120C6.
DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS VARIANCE REQUEST
CITY OF CARMEL - CLAY TOWNSHiP .
HAMILTON COUNTY, INDIANA.
APPLICATION FOR BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS ACTION
- . . .. .
FEE: Singl~ Family (Primary REisidence).$270~OOfor the first variance, plus $83.bOJor each
ordinance being varied. ":.' ... . ..
All Other $1,056.00: for th~ first variance, plus $500.00 for each ",dcHt.ional section af the ordinance being varied.
OR see Hearing Officer Fees. . .
DOCK~T NO. 07100013 DSV .
DATE;.RECE'VED:II~ el~ OJ.
1)
Applicant:
DonaJd& KathyDunbar
1700 W 1 06il1 StreetCarrnel,. IN'.
Address: :
2)
project N~me: Dunbar '.Residence
_ Phone: _{3i7) 578-4070--:-,--
. . . , . . .
Engineer/Architect: Grac,lisoR. Building Corp...;.. Phone: (317) 594:.7575
Attorney:____
3) Appiicant's Status: (Check the a'ppfopriate response)
Phone: .
.. . . . .
~x~ (3) The applicant's nam~i~ on the deeQtci the.property
. .. ,
(b) The applicant isthe t;:'ontract pur-chaser of the property
_ _~_ (c) Other:. .
4) ifltem3)(c} is: Ghe~ked.:ple~se cornpletEt the following:: .
Owner of the propertYlnv6lved:
Owner's apdress:
5f Record of Ownership:
Deed Book No.llnstr'ument No. 2007-58562
. Page: P~rcliase date: October 1, '2007 . .
6) Common address of the propE;rti.jhv61v~d: 1700 W 106th St. Carmel, IN :46033 :
Legal description:
.. Lot 26 ~nd ;& of Lot 25 Spring Run Estates.
17-13-04-04-02-002.000
Tax Map Parcel No.:
7)
. -
State explanation of requested Development S'tandards. Variance: (State what you want to do and cite the section
number(s) of the Carmel/Clay Zoning Ordinance that applies and/or creafes the ne:ed for'thisn:iquest).
'.. .. ,
'. "
Variance to Section 25.01.01 ,B.3..A.i.b regarding the building line o{ a new accessory structure property
. . .
..
Page 1 of 8, ~ !:(~l1areSMcr~ll~~~~. spplksti~!"lS-\ oev~!~pma.",,! SMr'l;tud~ Va~i.jnce App,lic~~;on ,'\;w. t2/29!~C03
8) State reasons sUPPQrtrl1gt~~'Pevelopment Standards Variql1ce: (Additionally, complete the attacnedquestkll1
sheet entjtled "Findings of Fact-Development Standards Variance"). '
Thjs properlY is an ;acr~age piece that does not have neighbors in 'close proximity. The Neighbors are effected
hayeapproved the proposedxaria,Q9~$~evidenced bythelettE1rs.att,\,ctled. TheHome Owners Association hasaiso
appr()ved me proposed Variance: 'Theqarage is goi ng to he lil excess of.:?O(i feet from 1 oeth street with many trees in
the front yard, not manypeoplewilleven,notice itlsi!! front of the currentresidence. ' ,
9) Presenf~oning of the prClperty (give exact classification): ~S2
Size oflotJparcel i'n question:"
10)
11)
12)d
2.243
acres '
, "
Present use 9Hhe property: SFR
, ,
, ,
Describe the proposed Use 'of the property: SFR
. '. .
,-, .. . . .
. l' 3), ,Is U)6 wo'perty: Owneroccupied
Re:riter6ccupied
Othe( .. ,
x
14)
... .
, ,
Are there any restrictions, laws,: COVElnants, variances" special uses, or appeals filed in connection with this
property th~t:wouldrelate oraffectitsuseJor:tnespeclfic purpose of this app!ic.ation? If yes,give dateahd docket
number, depision renderedaridpertineht expfanation. '
:No. ,
. . . .. . '. .
' ,
15). Has Work for which this appi1cationi(beirigfiled already started? jf answer is yes, give details:
Building Permit Number: .
No
Builder: ,:,
" ,
. ,. ..
16) If proposecfappeal if!; gr~rted, whenwiU the work commence?"
Immediately
, 17)
If the proposed variance is 'granted. who will operate andlor useth,e proposed improvement for which this
application has been filed? ' " ,
Owner
NOTE:., LEGA4,NOTICE shall be: pUblished,'in fh~ 'Indianapolis Star a. MANDATORY b.yenty-five(25) days prior to the
public hearing dat?: " Thec~r,tif!e'd}'pr96\, ofPLibli6aiion" affidavit for thenewslJaper must be av~ilable for inspection the
night ofthe heari,~,g'H -' H H ' " . H
LEGAL NOTICE toal! adjoining and abutting property owners is aiso MANDATORY, two methods of notice are
recommended: '
1) CERTiFIED MAIL - RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED sent to adjoinjng property owners. (The white receipt
should be stampi:l~,bYthe'Po~t Offlc? 8.1 least't~enty-five (25) days prior toth,e public hearing date.) ,
2).HAND DEUVER~P t:q Bcl}9ining andabuW~g 'property own~rs (A receipt' signed by the adjoining and abutting
property oWner acknowl~dging th~ tV.i~ritY-five (25) day notice should be kept for verification that the notice was
com pl~tedr,' ,
REAUZETHE ,BljRDENOF PROOF FORALL NOTICES IS THE RESPONSIBILITY OF l:HE APPLICANT, AGAIN, THIS
TASK MUSTBECOMPLETEOAT LEAST TVVENTY-FiVE (25) DAYS ,PRIOR TOPUBLlCHEARING DATE,
The applicant understands that dock~LiiU..JI1be'rs will not be assioned kllltif all supoortin6 ihforniation has been subm med to
the Departmenfof CorrHnurJity Services., '" .' " " '
," .... . .. . .
page 2' o.t. 8' -:z,;\s.har'oC\fcrmS\Bz.~ ~PpliC~:\~O~5\ [)~ldP~B~~',Stal1dGi;j~ VWl~nce App:!rcatio(1 "rev,.1?<:2Sti'006
.. . -',.', ,
AFFIDAVIT
I, hereby swear thati am the awnerlcQntraQtpurchaser of.propcny involved in this applic<;ltion and that the foregoing
signatlJres, statements and ~flswersherejh 'contained and the information her~with submltteq are in ail respects lruei3nd
correct to the.besf of my kndwiedg13 ~ndbelief.l, the undersigned, authorize theapplic~ntto act on mybehalfwlth regard
to this application' and subsequent he~:ings and testimony. J \ {'. '-' . "it' 1~J2 .' . .
. .. r\~.;(.U u Ll~ V'lJJlL,~;_'~if
'. ;.r. '1 J ijJL ;// (L, _~-
" Signed: !. /L r -,~, -
. (Property Owner, Attorney; or pqwerof Attorney) Date'
I'f' ,,+ iI" j 't'
. It,\:.r Jue:;:
t)O{lCACd .. (~
(Please Print) .
t~
~>\ t "
l'f\('^ I
"J t I"t 'il.. ..
STATE QFINDIAN;:..
County of
38:..
.J Ifi ~!!, ;i()
I~:../'..A'''-{ .." .': .'
. (County in which'not~'ri~atlontakes.pl~ce).
.. .
. .
. .
. Before me the undersigned, a Notary Public
'J' J. . It..' .... :.
. .II" . i f (, ..w-iF") f)....
'''-J:, j 4'~,j .1" tV,
t:: ,'('-'~'" f' i .-"',...- '. _ ,"
(Not$ry Public's county of'relstdence)
j' 'f : .. :), i\;i'.: 1 '.:. ..
ij,r;'-.i"p" , i' ~'r' ;-.!-' .I YF('fi'Y)/t r" .
~. t~/Cl: ~,'~ ....~- :_J, ~':' ~~::'~.: .".: <~;~ ~ _ .
: I.'. (y.r; /i{[J, :~'. l)i.:r.;in~Jl::r.:.f'L.
-.') v -~ 'LA <or A, . l~..~.~.. '" ,,...... _ _ _ _.
(Property Owner; Attgf.hey, or Power of Attorney):
. . . . . . .. . .
for'
: County,:State of Indtana~ personallyappeared
and .acknow!edge the execution of the fore'going instrument this
. / . ...
.... .' .I.
I\.. I r)!/{l '{.",.{flt..'/)
, ~ t.djl ~,"I "",:,,,,1' ''C'' r~;""!,.
r'yl
120 {j- .r-
I 'h
I ,'... -j
11/ ./"1 -:;{;t ." It. f
tl ! J! t~" -. /I. ....~.. l' V,"
p': '~,>_i -~,.'" ,_' . II" .-;' . ~ 'i, A ;} ')':. /f A
;." 'I..) "I/" ".1" ( . 1/ '"" , ""'J-'1 " w/'-'-'
t:.: .' .~~.d,_ - :f.r ~'-" ...~..-' _ ~.r ~ "/
: ~~~~,r Notary Public;-~Sighatu~~.. ()
'.. I . ..... .
(.
"1e~ ;.."";
. Notary Public'-cPlea.sI?Phht......
. . . """.
(pEAL)
My' co.mmission expires: l
i 'C,/1:."'\
. /,11 J./~ J le/
l,. I
P3g~, 4 of ~ ~.:z:'$h.a.r~;:Horm~'~B2A B~~li~:i~~~s1.-ne"~eloprriii:)1il Siand~rd.s V8(j~;".& A~p~ic~tion ff:';' 1?.f29{2:DCf"i
<".t_, ..-:' , ;':;1
C '.0 :;~
X <::;;.
>..,. -.. ',.,,;
October 29, 2007
Mr, & i\1rs. .Donald Dunbar'
1700 .W.. l06th St.;
CarmeL IN 46032
Deaf Don & Kathy:
. ,
Thank yau for taking. the time to shol!\f as your renovation and expansion plans. We unqerstand you
now ,reqUire a variance forV"ur detached garage.
, .
Web~ii~,vevour proposed.renovatipns andad~jtiQlJs are in keeping withthestand?rds of 'the
lieighb~rho~dandh~ve'ro'pr.~QI'7~\;y{ththe detached garage being located southeast of the house.
Wes~PPQrtyot:ir variancereque~t.. .
,/"{ C"'",-
{ .
, \\ \;r<.l:
\/ '
," t .
October 29 2007
< . I....
Mr, & Mr.s. Donald Dunbar'
1700 ~:.' l06th5t, ·
Carmel, IN 460'32
Dear Don &: Kathy:
Thank voufbr taking thetirne toshow'us your renovation and expansion plans, We understand you
now'require a v?rian~e.for Yburdetached garage.
". ;:W~p~lidv~<yoUt.l3rOPo$~d:6?nO'va.ti4rls ~~d'additions are in keeping with'thesfandards of the.
.. ",::~:,;~_,_C::"';_-,:~':-''':''''':'.'''''_;':,:",;,":~~:::'_:";-:'.'::_"',_'_ ::__':_:N:::':'_:_:.:_.~;::'-""". ". '. " _.: ':."," ,"_" ::'.,',,::
'0ejgn.b:qr.hob~a~d'ha\j~ rid,pr6.b!~'Q1 \I{ithJ~e ~etached garage being located'$.?utheastof the house,
We' SUPpodyourvari'anc.e'r'equest".' " - . .,'- -. . - . ,,- , .. . ,
Sin:~~_~~~._ .
(). .. /) Ill:J:~(lF \
J'JlJh~ L6 l'V~J fYyJ
. t''f: I <'1 60 i ()Gt+~~ ?4t.. ·
'.fl\ \'1 C
l'';--\ .
f .
'-\'..",. J
I 0< V .-
~-r"': '/
\ '.
:.-'1
I,,)Cr 4~J I...~ L Uo.',J0~.
Mr, & Mrs, Di7lOa1d Dunbar..
17QO'\/vo }.bstt. St.
:curmelilN4U03i '
Deaf ,Don &,Kathy:
, '
, ' ,
That)k)'oijfortfiking the" tirTie.to s~ow liS,' your lef){)Vatl(llI and expansion pla'os. We understand you
, -.. ' . . . .
~o\,VreqUire fi variance for youfd~tached garage.
We belieVe'your proposE:chenovationsand additiorisare in keeping, with t~e $tondaros. of the
'l1ejghb:orhoodand hijiye n9problr;111 wit.h the detached gara'ge beil1g located southeast afthe house.
We support V.Ollf variance /eq\:lel>'t
, '
" '. . -.
whldemere;Neighb~)[hoOd Association
B9iHCl;Mt;mber, /l
:. A,';ft' ,,' /2,"/,'</
: ,-~/Y:::::7 ,/ /l.// .
p7,/ ~':' Ii! '"
,4nthonyD:Altavilla
~.,~ : .
r-" ~
.f
.,.,j
(J)
.~
!
!
!
!
I
I
I
I
I
I
i
i
i
i
I
i
I
1- "'"7::-1- I
I ~
~
I
I
I
e I
f i
E!jz I
I
L__~
~
~~
~
=~ n i'" "0
~ 1 ;: ~ II II II
'!~
P
i
:1"tt .1. o[IUl ~
I I I
.e...
- ~ '.'".:: - ~ ~'"
"
"
o
"Z"""
j~~.",
'.
~E~~
E~i~
:;~~
i~ ~
~n
~~ ~
. ~
h
. .
L1f1'.Jjr
"
"'\..
... \ ~~
\
--~
~
/
,el.
1/
I
I
~
H"I i g
i i I ! : ~
tPfi!~~
i i !I ~ ~i
, I . J ~
. 'i:
I :Ui!3
I b
, ~
....~Z/QN~..
....0""'<>'..70."'... .,u;,a'7!"l':I'.I'-"'\4
N
Ll Vtl .::>t:a:r:CH LVUtp8 .
[' uS~:, J.. V,j. 1
Efd:>J
+0: Wt~f-
http.:/fmaps..live: conl/defal;!lt;1sp~?wip,,",2&v=2&rtp~&F OR1'vl=MSNH
. lli6i2007
-LIVt;; .':H:;~rl.;I1 tVlap.':i
..1.-t-l-5""" J. V,!, 1.
For the o~st possible- printres41ts, ,click theprinter)oon on the Live Seardl Ml!ps page,
. iVt)f~~' "-1-0
-~O~fh
http :J!mapsJiVel?~m/defaultaspx?wip=2&v=2& rtp=-~& FORM=MSNH
1116/2007
_~_;~:VlJ- u\;;a,1 \.rJ~ lV~.Qp~
'" -O.......L 'OJ,"--
Fbr th~: .b~:~f possible: p~infre$UII$, .CtiCkiU\e prtr:t~r icon" o.n th'e ~jv~ Search Maps page.
IJJ t 'SA-
(
'"t1)
E{i~f
http://maps.llve. cQm/default.asp~.?wip::;:2& v=2&rtp=~&FORM=MSNH
1 J /6/2007
~ , .1..11: V v' ~-c.~{-~_ft~, :1:'~":J.",p""
.t. U-5~ ~ '\..... ,I.
~1~
~
, ,
/10(10.
http.:!lmaps<iive.comjdefaultaspx?wip~2&v""'2&rtp=-&FOR!Vr~MSNH,
11/6/2007
(2)~~~.SIDE NEW GARAGE ELEVATION
i
.
CD~~~]AL FRONT ELEVATION & NEW GARAGE ELEVATION
J
"
I
-....
I- II
<.. ~.~ U
~: a~
~ it
9J:. Ji
~u I~
~",p
'-' !'
eil<
CR~ISOfl BlJtO;i'IG
CCI"P'
1"oooo;---
Fe, ----
.....,--
[-"'*----
---
1I...1~:__~
1-","-,,---
"''''''
~JC!OO:I_11
OOtlfllltfl.l:-
IOU:
tIlIt:. tli-srtlr
FRONH RIGHT
SIDE ELEVATlONS
A-1
-""'.
:r' 1iI:IJ'l[ ~.1JoI 0:
(j)~,~~. ELEVATION NEW GARAGE ADDITION
""""..
"li~.o;El.llm'2"
m1~IU::
'W'mlWili
..-
th If IlI\t ~'ro
......
: ~:o!-
HI 'ilID' 111
!U1<Ii'l.l."'JI.Ml.
3 ;,fI-~l!AL REAR ELEVATION EXISTING GARAGE
0) ~!9,~T SIDE NEW GARAGE ADDITION
...""
1l"'t'H~
IJIfll.':'E
i~ ii- 'I
1:==1-
CO li
'iol ~,~
"
I- l~
- !'
I
.
I
!
GR".'llISONliUlD'NG
'OOP.
1'1""'0:___
,;,." _n
1Iobo\o:___
[~0II:li:---
Pt.a.l..---
'0: ___
tloill..---
[-uc",---
Oi'itlEft
~1IJ:;wr,1I
t.\IJ~~_JOJI
~L- .M>oto.".,.._
Cl.1I, I~&ll
REAR
ElEVATIONS
A-2
f'Q.NDArr~ NOlES,
I
:~~.~ ~
I
I
:::/"""''''0'''' j
""'"' I
I
-.J
--.............-.-.......-
,..._""v_._.._...._....
"'_"~.......-..",-,,-..-
-...---"'-.........-
_....._......,_O<...,_.._~""
.....-___...'......._.......L__...~
.........._--.....~._._....--.:>..---
-------....~.......,......._...
--...-.......--.,-......---
......._a:uo____..."4"..._.......
__........"'-"'.........~......_L-.-
----..-".......
""""....
CfB..=..~
CD~~~~DATION PlAN EXISTING GARAGE
,-
I
..~IIJaW6-:li:...lJ.>:-iIIolUli"".......
1'___.'r...:""",,.oIO"'[]GIII'~
~,I..-..::r-..cou. 'o::no!-.colO.-.n
._Ia.",.J;OO;u
"'1II1<t'~
=~
Ti I I
I I I I
I (
I I I
I I I I
""""- I I I
""u._~~ : I I
I I
m ' : I I
. , I I I I
I I I ,
,..t I
I I
L----l I
I I
" I I
I I
..J I
'"
~WG.~,1IlU
~",~fN51
0;,:?~~pATION PlAN NEW GARAGE
~.c:t.t:.~"'()O....q
-, ~-'-"14l:Y'.i 'N"
G'Ulilll:~I~IwlIID.
- /"~.'.~~-
/ _1tLTIJnJ.\
_____ .1l:l:b.'I:P _ JlJJL
~ ,fJWO..........U;F\.IU'.
.'Wl(Wil:-:'~.~
FOUNDATION DF1AII
AT GARAGE DOOR
s::AlL I/f'....-r!' ~~"..11
"._..,u,~. .."",,,,~....
liirt. 1'SJ\WICIr~MJ
J~{~"lBW.iWII. ~'lIH ~ ~
. -;.....
,- nrn,Dtl..t1J.t..
...
@r~,C!ENED FOOTING UNDER BEARING WALL
~
{
Q)~~,~,~R PLAN NEW GARAGE
.....ID:fI:ll... ru~
~.,
F'~
~ -.
L
~mo_&I..E!i
"...-FlURillWfl't'IWZ-n
// ;:'~~~T L>.
'IIl'M","""
1't'....00I'I'Il1)jf
~.ffiJ
~~~~-
.....
i
i
!
- a
i
I
i
i
1'.'10" F:iUE lIlL
GJ::'I()ISON IfJIUXMG
row,
1f[:N:W.lU!
..""'
f'to:w-__
r"" __
1Oobk.-__
~-",",--
(~il2~?.r.rNG UNDER STEEL COLUMN
~I~
~ ;
':'! ~
HAR GiIR,G[
~"T
w~
~"
....
1"I)\lrJ;(JI;U'I1
mi:il~~ ~.t;: ~
-,
I'~~~~
Bi.I:~(.I
M~__
:!.""'~
CD~~~GE WALL SECTION
o.~~1i:
l'fiM:Crm:1007.ll
W~ru,~_I.MI,!\""
"'"
!lI.lL 1l],~r
FO'JNDATION
PlAN
A-4