HomeMy WebLinkAboutCRC-07-19-05CRC Minutes, July 19, 2005
1
CARMEL REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION Meeting, Tuesday, July 19, 2005
The meeting was called to order by President Ron Carter at 7:15 p.m.
Commission members Bob Battreall, Jerry Heniser and William Hammer were present,
constituting a quorum. Also present were Karl Haas, Les Olds, Loren Matthes, Dan
Moriarity, Bruce Cordingley, Steve Brown, Lesley Rogers Barrett from the Indianapolis
Star, David Stirsman, Salon 01 and Karl Meyer from Meyer Najem, Inc. Phyllis
Morrissey as support staff.
Approval of Minutes
Mr. Battreall moved the minutes of June 21, 2005, be approved. Following a second by
Mr. Hammer, the motion was unanimously approved.
Mr. Battreall moved the minutes of June 28, 2005, be approved. Following a second by
Mr. Hammer, the motion was unanimously approved.
Bid Opening
One conforming bid was received for Parcel 5B and 5C, the two 60’ strips along the west
side at the edge of the Monon Trail. The bid was from Pedcor Office, LLC, and was for a
combined price of $1,500,000. The bid will be taken under review and a recommendation
will be brought back to the next CRC meeting.
Public Hearing for Resolution
Mr. Carter stated that on May 17, the CRC approved the resolution making this a
development area and then also on the 17th, the Plan Commission adopted the resolution
and issued a written order pursuant to state statute on this. Then on June 20, the
Declaratory Resolution, the Plan Commission order and the plan and determination of the
area as an economic development area was approved by the Council. We need to go
ahead and hold this public hearing this evening to be in conformance with state statute.
Resolution 7-2005 of the City of Carmel Redevelopment Commission Confirming
Resolution Declaring an Area in City of Carmel as an Economic Development Area and
Approving an Economic Development Plan for Said Area. The Public Hearing was
opened at 7:20 p.m. Mr. Carter invited anyone in opposition or in favor of the resolution
to come forward. No one did so. The Public Hearing was closed at 7:21 p.m.
Mr. Battreall moved for approval of Resolution 7-2005. Seconded by Mr. Hammer. Mr.
Olds pointed out the boundaries of the area, noting it also includes Parcels 4 and 11. The
motion was then unanimously approved.
Resolution 8-2005 of the City of Carmel Redevelopment Commission Pledging Certain
Tax Increment Revenues to the Payment of Economic Development Revenue Bonds of
the City of Carmel.
CRC Minutes, July 19, 2005
2
Mr. Battreall moved for approval of Resolution 8-2005. Seconded by Mr. Hammer. The
motion was unanimously approved.
Mr. Cordingley was asked to update the Commissioners. He presented the latest set of
construction documents for Parcel 5. For the garage itself, more construction oriented
documents should be completed within the next 8-10 weeks. “There is a chance we could
perhaps break ground the end of August. At your August meeting hopefully you are
approving the redevelopment agreement because I’d like that signed and agreed to before
we break ground. The goal would be that by the time the excavation is done, the garage
construction drawings are in sufficient form to be submitted to the State and the City for
at least foundation permits. There will be a series of hundreds if not more, piers that go
down 60’ below our excavated elevation that basically will be holding up the City
Center.”
Mr. Sturtz presented a revised proposal for the retail area fronting on Range Line Road to
solve the problem caused by the elevation changes. Discussion followed.
Reorder of Agenda
Mr. Battreall made a motion to reorder the agenda to allow Mr. Cordingley to continue
his report on other issues. Following a second by Mr. Hammer, the motion was
unanimously approved.
Parcel 2
Mr. Cordingley reported he thought they had found a solution to screening the
mechanicals on the roofs on Parcel 2. They will be submitting the plan. Pedcor will be
moving into building four on Parcel 2.
City Center
Construction on the garage will begin soon.
Old Town Shops
Mr. Cordingley: It was necessary to install geopier foundations because of the soils. They
anticipate in early December to be in a position to turn units over to the tenants. We
would still have some work of our own to do. Brief discussion followed about roof
gardens and other upgrades, including window choices, for the project.
Financial Matters
Mr. Mathes reported the 2003 BAN was renewed for two more years. The 2005 BAN
money will be ready by September. It will not be a draw BAN.
The renewal process must be started this fall for the 2004 BAN which matures in January
2006.
Mr. Carter thanked Ms. Mathes for the good work she did on the bond issue for the
performing arts center. She noted it has gone through the state approval process so the
bonds will soon be ready to sell.
CRC Minutes, July 19, 2005
3
Mr. Olds asked Ms. Mathes to have a brief report prepared for the next CRC meeting.
2005 Budget
Mr. Olds explained details and changes on the updated budget. He noted draws for
Pedcor on the CRC share of the cost on the infrastructure work would not begin until a
month of construction is underway. This does not include the A/E costs agreed to earlier.
An increase to the TIF of approximately $64,000 per year will now occur since Mr. Haas
met with the Hamilton County Auditor to explain the ownership of the AMLI apartments
in Old Town.
Discussion followed about the need for an accounting person for CRC. The Mayor is now
in agreement although he was reluctant to add another person to the payroll.
Invoices
Invoices in the amount of $1,055,053.11 were submitted for payment. Discussion
followed about the Barnes & Thornburg invoice, the Plews, Shadley invoice and the
Woolpert part of the CSO and the Arts District invoice. Following clarification of these
questions, Mr. Battreall moved the CRC approve the invoices in the amount of
$1,055,053.11. Following a second by Mr. Hammer, the motion was unanimously
approved.
Update on Properties
In addition to the information sent in the packets, Mr. Olds gave the following updates:
Kosene is asking for a change in the unit mix condominiums they are building. They
have submitted a design which is being reviewed. They want to convert a building with
flats to townhouses. Mr. Olds explained the changes and noted he has asked Pedcor to
look at it. Mr. Olds will send site plans to the commission members.
Veterans Plaza
Mr. Olds reported there have been ongoing meetings on site with the contractor. The
grass is terrible. All the weeds need to be killed and the area reseeded. The contractor has
been constantly notified. The City maintenance people will be taking over the operation
of the irrigation system once the punch list is satisfied.
Mr. Carter asked when the punch list items will be substantially completed, noting it
should not be too torn up because of the boat races on the reflecting pool July 30 and 31.
Mr. Olds will continue working with them.
Reflecting Pool
Work continues to get the pumps fully operational and the chemicals balanced. The
bottom of the pond will be cleaned and ready for the race.
CRC Minutes, July 19, 2005
4
Mr. Carter stated complaints have been received about skateboarders. He requested we
get signs up as quickly as possible to prevent skateboarding in the area.
Parcel #3
Cinergy will be installing underground chambers; actual sites yet to be determined. This
will eliminate the green boxes in front of Mr. Kestner’s property.
Parcel 5
Conforming bids were received from Pedcor for parcels 5D and 7C for a combined price
of $1,500,000. Mr. Battreall moved the CRC accept the bid proposals for Parcel 5D and
Parcel 7C from Pedcor. Following a second by Mr. Hammer, the motion was
unanimously approved.
Parcel 7
Mr. Moriarity reported an arrangement had been made for Cinergy to use some parking
spaces to do their work rather than move more of the Monon Trail as they had requested.
Mr. Olds stated he was having a problem getting an easement for Cinergy behind
Mohawk Plaza. The City Attorney could file a condemnation for a utility easement. Mr.
Olds will follow up.
There is a problem with the Monon Trail detour being too steep beside Mr. Kestner’s
property. This will be checked.
Parcel 8
Mr. Olds will call Mark Perlstein and set up a meeting with him and Mr. Carter.
Parcel 10
It appears a closing is imminent on the sale of the property beside Shapiro’s. Mr.
McComas will be at the next meeting to report.
Parcel 12, 16 and 21
RFPs for these three parcels are being picked up with bids due at August CRC meeting.
Parcel 12
Mr. Haas reported a purchase agreement for Payless Liquors was ready for signatures.
The purchase price is $1,000,000 plus a $200,000 relocation fee. Mr. Battreall expressed
disappointment in the price increase since negotiations first began. Following discussion,
Mr. Hammer moved the CRC approve the purchase agreement for $1,000,000 plus a
relocation fee not to exceed $200,000. Mr. Heniser seconded the motion. The other three
commissioners also expressed concerns about the cost and relocation fees. Call for the
question. The motion was approved with three in favor, Mr. Battreall opposed.
Environmental testing will be done on Parcel 12.
CRC Minutes, July 19, 2005
5
Old Business
Arts District Signs
The purchase of sign medallions for the streetlights for the Arts District was discussed.
Budgeting for the Arts District was also discussed. Mr. Carter recommended a director
for the district be hired. Signage in general in Old Town was discussed.
Mr. Battreall moved the CRC purchase fifteen signs to be strategically located in the Arts
District. Following further discussion, Mr. Hammer seconded the motion and it was
unanimously approved.
Old Town Renovation Grants
Mr. Olds will bring recommendations to the next meeting. Seven were granted last year.
Carmel Clay Veterans Memorial Corporation wants to place a small temporary
informational sign on their parcel, seeking donations toward the memorial.
Monon and Main
Kosene has dropped out of this project and are selling the project to Gunstra, who has
said they will not be making any changes in the project. CRC will be doing streetscape
work.
O’Malia’s Fireplace Shop
They will be expanding their current location, tearing down the house to the south, and
have asked for a grant towards this. Mr. Olds wants them to grant CRC additional right-
of-way on Range Line Road for future parallel parking. Another street is being
recommended through Parcel 12. Discussion followed. The additional street would be
part of the negotiations on Parcel 12. Mr. Carter requested that any offers on Parcel 12 be
placed in “apples to apples” comparisons and that all developers bidding come to the
CRC with presentations which includes financial information and design. Mr. Haas said
that will be planned for the September meeting.
Next Meeting will be Tuesday, August 16, 2005.
Adjournment
Mr. Battreall moved the meeting be adjourned. Following a second by Mr. Hammer, the
motion was unanimously approved and the meeting adjourned at 9:13 p.m.
Z:\redevcomm\2005\July 19 Minutes