Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutUS-31 Subarea PlanJULY 2025 CITY OF CARMEL, INDIANA CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 2 Contents Planning Summary1 Growth Strategy2 Design & Policy Guidance3 Subarea Plan4 Appendix5 JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 3 The US-31 Corridor As part of the implementation of the Carmel Comprehensive Plan adopted in December 2022, the City of Carmel engaged Yard & Company to conduct a US-31 Subarea Plan. This work will primarily focus on recommendations for policy and the MC zoning district and a common public realm framework that, together, will enable and guide the type of development that community members and City leaders want to see along this corridor. The final US-31 Subarea Plan will be incorporated as an amendment to the Carmel Comprehensive Plan. N Note: For visual convenience, the orientation of the plan presented in this document has been adjusted so that north is directed to the left. Woodland Woodland Country Country ClubClub Central Central ParkPark Meadowlark Meadowlark ParkPark Pleasant Pleasant Grove ParkGrove Park Vera J. Hinshaw Vera J. Hinshaw Park & PreservePark & Preserve W M a i n S t W M a i n S t W M a i n S t W M a i n S t Pennsylvania StPennsylvania St Meridian St Meridian St W 1 4 6 t h S t W 1 4 6 t h S t Oak Ridge RdOak Ridge Rd Rangeline RdRangeline Rd Westfield BlvdWestfield Blvd W 1 3 6 t h S t W 1 3 6 t h S t Illinois StIllinois St Spring Mill RdSpring Mill Rd College AveCollege Ave Guilford RdGuilford Rd E 1 1 6 t h S t E 1 1 6 t h S t E 1 0 6 t h S t E 1 0 6 t h S t W 9 6 t h S t W 9 6 t h S t US-31 Subarea 465 465 US31 US31 US31 N US-31US-31 CARMELCARMELINDIANAINDIANA JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 4Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix Planning Summary 1 JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 5Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix Carmel Comprehensive Plan (2022) The update of the Comprehensive Plan for the City of Carmel focuses on refining growth goals for the next 10 years and highlights the significant changes to the physical environment that have made Carmel attractive to new employers, employees, visitors, and residents. The Carmel Comprehensive Plan 2022 has 9 objectives, including managing community form, enhancing economic vitality, fostering a city of neighborhoods, reinforcing adaptability, cultivating community character, lightening Carmel’s environmental footprint, supporting healthful living, and improving mobility options and functionality. US-31 Corridor Future Development Plan (2020) The US 31 Corridor Future Development Plan outlines a vision for US-31, focusing on creating a vibrant, walkable, and mixed-use environment to support transit and office trends. It emphasizes the need for pedestrian-friendly spaces, mixed-use density, environmental health, shared parking, and connected places. City of Carmel Positioning Strategy (2023) The Positioning Strategy compares Carmel to regional competitors and provides actionable recommendations for adapting to national and regional economic trends, including shifts to hybrid work and changing demographics. The Strategy highlights Carmel’s Rangeline corridor as a successful, walkable, mixed-use area that has seen significant growth and strong demand, and suggests that similar areas could be developed along US-31. It also emphasizes the need to review Carmel’s zoning and regulatory policies to support the development of mixed-use spaces. Carmel Mayor’s Housing Task Force Findings and Recommendations Report (2024) In September 2024, the Mayor’s Housing Task Force published a report that describes five key challenges to providing housing. Several recommendations relevant to the US-31 corridor were provided, including: Prioritize infill and redevelopment of underutilized commercial and parking areas; Adopt a development strategy for new apartment construction; Actively seek new collaboration opportunities; Acquire more green space; Assess zoning; Publish relevant maps and data, and more. City of Carmel Transit Study (2020) The planned transit in Carmel would serve the US-31 corridor and much of the CBD. The Carmel Transit Study, prepared by Nelson/ Nygaard, recommended two transit service options: 1) fixed route bus with para-transit service, and 2) on-demand micro transit service with flexible boundaries subject to further study. The long-term transit plan also includes the option to extend the Red Line regional bus rapid transit route from Indianapolis. Planning Summary1 JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 6Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix City of Carmel Transit Implementation Strategy (2025) Building on the 2020 report, TransPro conducted an update recommending on-demand transit service city-wide as a short-term initiative. A fixed route that connects the commercial area along Old Meridian near Main Street with Merchant’s Square Mall is recommended in the mid-term. Over the long-term, fixed routes along Pennsylvania, City Center, and/or Rangeline/Westfield may be possible. Carmel TIF districts: Carmel has 69 TIFs, with about half located within the US-31 Subarea Boundary. Planned developments along US-31 The Carmel US-31 Corridor Plan includes several planned developments, such as Clay Terrace Phase 1, Hamilton Crossing, and the Meridian Mark Redevelopment. These developments are likely to include a mix of office, retail, residential, and recreational spaces, with varying building sizes and parking capacities. Planning Summary (continued) US - 3 1 S U B A R E A CLAY TERRACE PH1CLAY TERRACE PH1 HAMILTON HAMILTON CROSSINGCROSSING MERIDIAN MERIDIAN MARKMARK E 106TH ST E 116TH ST SP R I N G M I L L R D PE N N S Y L V A N I A S T W MAIN ST W 146TH ST 465 US31 N US31 JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 7Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix Growth Strategy 2 JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 8Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix Growth Strategy The definition of a modern, competitive employment corridor has shifted to now include a mix of hospitality, tourism, residential, and dynamic public space experiences that are welcoming to residents, guests, and employees alike must now be the standard to attract and maintain businesses and workforce talent. Expansive grayfield parking lots and inaccessible or unusable open space should be rethought of as opportunities for more productive assets for the community. Based on where the US-31 corridor is today and needs to go tomorrow, this plan makes recommendations for intentional growth and high-quality development based on these six strategies: 2 Play Both Offense and Defense Promote the New Narrative Focus On Early Needs and Opportunities Infuse Flexibility to Support Active Uses and Green Spaces Coordinate Efforts Plan for Connectivity JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 9Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix The transition from an isolated, pavement-heavy office environment surrounding US-31 into a better connected, more beautiful, and desirable place to spend time is a long-term endeavor. A majority of property ownership involves investors who are generally risk-averse and not interested in leading change, but will respond accordingly once evidence of successful changes are demonstrated. There are a few sites within the district where intentional, mixed-use redevelopment could help establish the new standard. City leaders should promote the following near-term opportunities. At the north end of the corridor, the Clay Terrace commercial district is set to introduce new office, residential, hospitality, and recreational uses to an otherwise dated life-style shopping center. The expected outcome of this development is a new neighborhood offering that continues to provide regional amenities while significantly boosting daily users and opportunities for small businesses. On the southern side of Main Street, between Illinois Street and US-31 are a group of properties along Hamilton Crossing Boulevard with strong redevelopment opportunity. A new development concept could leverage the existing low occupancy, prominent location, and opportunity to construct signature buildings that help establish a gateway at this key node. Given the grade relationship to the highway, the site is largely invisible to passerby which presents an opportunity for US-31 fronting structures to be taller than currently permitted by right and still maintain the Carmel feel through conformity with other quality-assuring standards. The geometry of the highway allows for a terminated vista on this site. Hospitality-oriented gathering spaces could be incorporated to accommodate both corporate business and community needs while improving the experience for existing properties fronting Illinois Street through streetscape and green space enhancements. Another key redevelopment opportunity is south of 106th Street between Pennsylvania and US-31 (the existing Meridian Plaza). These office properties are under-performing and given their outdated format, are ripe for infill redevelopment that incorporates a mix of uses and amenities in place of surface parking. Also on the horizon is the redevelopment of approximately 78-acres across six sites that previously encompassed the CNO Financial Group headquarter operations. While the campus is outside of the Meridian Corridor, its proximity, size, and opportunity to help connect the corridor to Carmel’s core warrants proactive attention and coordinated planning. Focus On Early Needs and Opportunities JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 10Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix While large projects continue operating as they are in the near-term, small, complementary efforts can be leveraged to test the market for change. Underutilized open spaces and paved areas on properties with existing users can be opportunities to test activation- focused concepts. This means working with property owners to explore the feasibility of small scale outlot development. Projects could include creation of a food truck park, temporary retail villages with comfortable outdoor seating and green space amenities, incorporating more trees and vegetation where feasible, and other tactics that increase fuller use of sites. Carrying out these quick projects will produce valuable insights that may inform larger redevelopment strategies, including an understanding of how such changes impact the daily lives of neighbors. However, there are existing regulations that may get in the way, such as minimum parking requirements and use restrictions. Initial suggestions for providing controlled flexibility, including specific modifications to consider for the Meridian Corridor zoning standards are provided in this plan and should be supplemented by additional conversations between City leaders, staff, and corridor property owners. Infuse Flexibility to Support Active Uses and Green Spaces JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 11Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix Through the decades-long redevelopment of Carmel’s central core, City leaders and staff have fine tuned the processes and tools for encouraging development that contributes to a long-term vision and Carmel identity, while ensuring development that doesn’t meet that standard is not built. Development expectations were recently updated in the 2022 Comprehensive Plan and are carried out daily by reference to the Unified Development Ordinance. For the US-31 corridor, the C Districts (C1 and C2) and Meridian Corridor District (MC) provide the majority of use regulations and development standards. The mixed- use nature of the C Districts as well as their location within or adjacent to the core of Carmel, provide the City with the necessary leveraging power to influence the projects as needed to ensure there are sufficient public benefits. Redevelopment is time intensive and expensive, and typically requires public investment. Some of Carmel’s best projects are because of the C-District redevelopment partnership process. By comparison, the MC District sets a high bar for development and has been effective in producing projects that conform to the vision and character of the corridor. This is where there is some opportunity to realign standards in the UDO that match market and community interests for this area. These MC recommendations are detailed in the Design Guidance section. Play Both Offense and Defense JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 12Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix A critical element of a dynamic and resilient district where people are making full use of properties throughout most of the day is its ability to provide convenient, comfortable, and safe ways to get in, out, and through the place. As demonstrated in Midtown, incorporating multi-use pathways that are dotted with interesting things to see and do are key to connecting primary destinations. Over time, a fuller network can be built throughout the areas surrounding the corridor, incorporating amenities that benefit existing community members and attract future users. Additionally, new streets can help fill gaps where frontage roads are disconnected and where long stretches can be broken up with mid-block connections. New connections can also distribute hubs of activity currently isolated in the core and along the Monon out to destinations east and west. Centrally located and activated east-west corridors along 106th Street and through the redeveloped CNO campus, both with crossings over Meridian Corridor, should be priorities. Advancing the coordinated planning for future transit options is also key to boosting options for getting around Carmel. Plan for Connectivity JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 13Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix The US-31 corridor has recently landed some new, large occupants, including Republic Airways, as well as a new supermarket. There is great opportunity to build on these wins, develop a succinct pitch of what more could occur here, and promote that to a national and global audience of potential development partners who are likely to value and align with the Carmel brand and sense of place. Leaning on the Carmel identity while being able to promote a clear vision and amenable regulatory process will go a long way in attracting a wider level of expertise necessary to create the highly- amenitized mixed-use district that is possible. Promote the New Narrative JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 14Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix Proactive coordination will be key to ensuring everyone is working in the same direction and continuing to have a positive experience in the corridor. Similar to how a Chamber of Commerce functions, an organizing forum specific to US-31 adjacent property owners and users would help galvanize efforts and facilitate information sharing. Regular check-ins could bring to light new opportunities for development, help resolve emerging issues, and make near-term improvements easier to pursue. Participation in these periodic meetings would also help keep the City engaged to support and collaborate in this area. Coordinate Efforts JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 15Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix Design & Policy Guidance 3 JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 16Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix Recommendations »Maintain the transition of scale and massing of structures between US-31 and Illinois Street to minimize impact to residential development along the western edge. »Require high quality, human-scaled urban architecture, site & trail design (including welcoming ground-floor details, walkable blocks, landscaping). »Incorporate pedestrian infrastructure (wide, connected sidewalks, street lighting, etc.). »Provide amenities attractive and welcoming to visitors, employees, and residents (ex: attractive landscaping/green space, seating, retail, art, etc.). »Minimize visual and environmental impacts of parking lots and structures. »Minimize use of high-wall signage and lighting facing residential areas. »Maximize height at ends of vistas such as the curvature of US-31 and terminating street corridors. »Focus design review on creating a safe, active, and vibrant frontage along public spaces and streets. »Strive to provide seamless connections between properties. Design Guidance Example development concept incorporating recommended design guidance Terminating vistas contribute to a sense of place by serving as a landmark or opportunity to highlight key buildings JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 17Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix Recommendations Feature trail development: »Abide by the existing Enhanced Multi-Use Path standards »Use surface treatments (painted concrete or pavers) to delineate space for pedestrians separate from cyclists and other faster moving users »Incorporate signage and wayfinding that aligns with the City and/or district identity »Provide lighting, landscaping, seating, waste receptacles, and bicycle parking along the path »Incorporate public art and other means of visual interest and activity »Incorporate space that accommodates trail-oriented programming and events, such as staging areas for pop-up vendors, performances, and gatherings Planned/Proposed trail development: »Abide by the existing Multi-Use Path minimum standards »Incorporate signage, lighting and other essential elements, in addition to amenities such as seating, landscaping, and bicycle parking as appropriate Design Guidance Feature trail exampleFeature trail example Multi-Use Path Standard (min.)Enhanced Multi-Use Path Standard (min.) JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 18Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix Recommendations »Incorporate the Downtown West development characteristics listed in the 2022 Comprehensive Plan. »Remove restrictions that dictate which floor level a permitted use can be on. »Explore expansion of special uses to include small- batch and artisan manufacturing and high-tech/ biotech research and production. »Specify setback standards for parcels that have two or more street or roadway frontages to ensure all follow front setback regulations. »Allow the market to determine parking needs: • Reduce or eliminate parking minimums, while continuing to mandate accessible spaces. • If minimums are desired, re-evaluate the MC parking ratios to ensure they align with current market trends and encourage shared parking. • Expand the distance of qualifying off-street parking (on-site) from within 300 feet to 600 (2-minute walk) or 1,200 feet (4-minute walk) and remove requirement to be immediately adjacent to the primary lot. • Expand the off-site parking distance from 800 feet to 1,200 feet away from the subject building. Policy Guidance »Incorporate publicly accessible plazas, courtyards, gardens, trail heads, and gathering spaces near entrances away from highways. »Incorporate additional architectural elements in public frontages that support a comfortable pedestrian and trail environment, such as seating and landscaping. »Consider increasing the 8-story height maximum at key intersections where a structure fronts US-31 and an arterial street. »Remove waiver required for use of permeable materials for surface parking lots. »Describe preferred proportions and heights for glazing and other facade features to promote human-scale design. »Ensure ground-floor glazing is transparent and uncluttered. »Reconsider requirements for all structures to have upper floors designed in similar format to multi-story office buildings in favor of proportions and features, such as operable windows and shallow distances from windows, which accommodate a broader variety of uses. Examples of activated frontages that provide amenities JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 19Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix Subarea Plan 4 JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 20Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix Existing US-31 N S Guilford RdS Guilford Rd W M a i n S t W M a i n S t W M a i n S t W M a i n S t N Pennsylvania StN Pennsylvania St N Pennsylvania StN Pennsylvania St N Meridian StN Meridian St Ol d M e r i d i a n S t Ol d M e r i d i a n S t Sm o k y R o w Sm o k y R o w W 1 4 6 t h S t W 1 4 6 t h S t W 1 4 6 t h S t W 1 4 6 t h S t Ke y s t o n e P k w y S Ke y s t o n e P k w y S E 1 3 6 t h S t E 1 3 6 t h S t W 1 3 6 t h S t W 1 3 6 t h S t Oak Ridge RdOak Ridge Rd N Rangeline RdN Rangeline Rd S Rangeline RdS Rangeline Rd Westfield BlvdWestfield Blvd W 1 1 4 t h S t W 1 1 4 t h S t Spring Mill RdSpring Mill Rd Illinois StIllinois St Spring Mill RdSpring Mill Rd Spring Mill RdSpring Mill Rd N College AveN College AveN College AveN College Ave Woodland Woodland Country ClubCountry Club Central Central ParkPark Meadowlark Meadowlark ParkPark Pleasant Pleasant Grove ParkGrove Park Vera J. Hinshaw Vera J. Hinshaw Park & PreservePark & Preserve E 1 1 6 t h S t E 1 1 6 t h S t E 1 1 6 t h S t E 1 1 6 t h S t E 1 0 6 t h S t E 1 0 6 t h S t 10 6 t h S t 10 6 t h S t W 9 6 t h S t W 9 6 t h S t E 1 1 1 t h S t E 1 1 1 t h S t 465 US31 US31 US31 JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 21Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix US-31 Subarea Plan S Guilford RdS Guilford Rd W M a i n S t W M a i n S t W M a i n S t W M a i n S t N Pennsylvania StN Pennsylvania St N Pennsylvania StN Pennsylvania St N Meridian StN Meridian St Ol d M e r i d i a n S t Ol d M e r i d i a n S t Sm o k y R o w Sm o k y R o w W 1 4 6 t h S t W 1 4 6 t h S t W 1 4 6 t h S t W 1 4 6 t h S t Ke y s t o n e P k w y S Ke y s t o n e P k w y S E 1 3 6 t h S t E 1 3 6 t h S t W 1 3 6 t h S t W 1 3 6 t h S t Oak Ridge RdOak Ridge Rd N Rangeline RdN Rangeline Rd S Rangeline RdS Rangeline Rd Westfield BlvdWestfield Blvd W 1 1 4 t h S t W 1 1 4 t h S t Spring Mill RdSpring Mill Rd Illinois StIllinois St Spring Mill RdSpring Mill Rd Spring Mill RdSpring Mill Rd N College AveN College AveN College AveN College Ave Woodland Woodland Country ClubCountry Club Central Central ParkPark Meadowlark Meadowlark ParkPark Pleasant Pleasant Grove ParkGrove Park Vera J. Hinshaw Vera J. Hinshaw Park & PreservePark & Preserve E 1 1 6 t h S t E 1 1 6 t h S t E 1 0 6 t h S t E 1 0 6 t h S t 10 6 t h S t 10 6 t h S t W 9 6 t h S t W 9 6 t h S t E 1 1 1 t h S t E 1 1 1 t h S t 465 US31 US31 US31 N US-31 Subarea Planned Bus Route Possible Bus Route Priority Development Site Feature Trail Planned/Proposed Trail Gathering SpaceMain & Illinois Clay Terrace Phase 1 Meridian Plaza116th & Illinois Monon TrailMonon Trail Monon TrailMonon Trail Monon TrailMonon Trail Note: Existing and planned multi-use paths are not shown for clarity purposes. Please view that full network online at carmelcomprehensiveplan.com. W 9 6 t h S t W 9 6 t h S t E 1 0 6 t h S t E 1 0 6 t h S t Ci t y C e n t e r D r Ci t y C e n t e r D r MeijerMeijer CNO Campus CNO Campus RedevelopmentRedevelopment Merchants’ Merchants’ SquareSquare JULY 2025 CARMEL US-31 SUBAREA PLAN 22Planning Summary | Growth Strategy | Design & Policy Guidance | Subarea Plan | Appendix Appendix 5 Click here to review these documents: 0.1 US 31 Corridor Future Development Plan 0.2 US 31 Corridor Future Development Plan: Appendix 0.3 City of Carmel Positioning Strategy 0.4 North Rangeline Road and US-31 Plan 0.5 116th and Meridian District Master Plan 0.6 Hamilton Crossing Master Plan 0.7 Meridian Mark Redevelopment Proposal 0.8 Hotel and Retail Infill at 116th and Penn 0.9 City of Carmel Transit Study 10 City of Carmel Transit Implementation Strategy 11 US 31 Subarea Stakeholder Input Summary Report 12 US 31 Stakeholder Webinar 13 Carmel Mayor’s Housing Task Force Findings and Recommendations Report by CARMELUS-31