Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutApplication u u Tingley, Connie S Subject: Lillig, Laurence M Friday, December 20, 2002 2:05 PM Fahey, Joyce D; Morrissey, Phyllis G; Pattyn, Dawn E; Tingley, Connie S Hollibaugh, Mike P; Dobosiewicz, Jon C; Lawrence, Kelli A; Keeling, Adrienne M; Kendall, Jeff A; Brewer, Scott I; Hancock, Ramona B Docket No. Assignment: King of Glory Lutheran Church (V-208-02 thru V-211-02) From: Sent: To: Cc: The following Docket Nos. have been assigned to the Special Use and Development Standards Variance petitions filed by William E. Erickson on behalf of King of Glory Lutheran for property located at 2201 East 106th Street: Docket No. V-208-02 ZO 25.07.01-2 Docket No. V-209-02 ZO 25.07.02-5(b)(i) Docket No. V-21 0-02 ZO 25.07.02-5(d) Docket No. V-211-02 ZO 25.07.02-5(e) one (1) 3.75-square-foot Traffic directional sign $630.00 two (2) institutional ground signs $70.00 5' institutional ground sign $70.00 zero-foot (0') ground sign setback $70.00 The Total Filing Fee for these petitions is $840.00. . These Items will not appear on an agenda of the Technical Advisory Committee. . Mailed and Published Public Notice needs to occur no later than Thursday, January 2, 2003. PLEASE NOTE THAT BZA NOTICE IS TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE INDIANAPOLIS STAR. . Proof of Notice will need to be received by this Department no later than noon, Friday, January 17,2002. Failure to submit Proof of Notice by this time will result in the automatic tabling of the petition to the Monday, February 24, 2003, agenda of the BZA. . Eight (8) Informational Packets must be delivered to BZA Secretary Connie Tingley no later than noon, Friday, January 17, 2003. Failure to submit Informational Packets by this time will result in the automatic tabling of the petition to the Monday, February 24, 2003, agenda of the BZA, . This Item will appear on the Monday, January 27,2003, agenda of the Board of Zoning Appeals under Public Hearings. . The petitioner will need to provide seven (7) fully filled-out Findings-of-Fact sheets (DSV application, Sheet 8) tor each petition the night of the meeting for the Board's use. Petitioner must also remember to fill aut only the Docket No., Petitioner, and date on each Ballot Sheet (DSV application, Sheet 7) for the Board. The Findings-ot-Fact and Ballot Sheets must be collated. Connie, please contact William E. Erickson at 317/846-1555 (cell: 317/696-7344) with this information, fo+: fL/& ~/S10 Laurence M. Lillig, Jr. Planning & Zoning Administrator Division of Planning & Zoning Department of Community Sel'vices City of Carmel One Civic Square Carmel, IN 46032 317/571-2417 fax: 317/571-2426 llillig@ci.carmel.in.us 1 /\ FEE: CITY OF CARMEL - CLAY TOWNSHIP W HAMILTON 'G(JUNTY, INDIANA U /0"~1! d'i.r}~: APP.. L1CATION FOR.. .B. OAR.. ..0. OF ZO. f'll. N.G APPEAL. S ACT.ION trY REC~VED "~ DEVELOPMENTAL STANDARDS VARIANCE REQUEST \3 NOV 21 2002 $630.00 for the first plus $70.00 for each additional section of the ordinance~'eing V"1~S~" . DATE RECEIVED: ~")...._. A'\.<: '5 '-../ I~ \\1/ ~ r' ~ ......'" """c_ . .~ DOCKET No. 1) Applicant: IHng of Glory Luthe;r,an Church Address: 220.1 East 106,th Street 2) Project Name: Front Sign Replacement Phone: 846.-.1555" Engineer/Architect: Self Phone:' Attorney: Self Jpower of' Attorney Phone: 846-1555 3) Applicant's Statu,s: (Check the appropriate response) X (a) The a,pplicant!s: name is on the deed to the property (b) The applicant is the contract'purchaser of the property (c) Other: 4) If Item 3) (c) is checked, pleasecotnplete the failowi'ng: Owner of the prop,erty inyolVeG: Owner's adoress: Phor18: 5) Record of Owner!ihip: Deed Book No)lnstrument No. /1171 page: 443 Purchase date: 1-8-62 6) Common address oHhe property involved: 2201 E. 106:th Street Legal description: Attached "A" Tax Map Parcel No.: 1714070000004000 7.) State,explanation of requested Pevelopmental Standards Variance: (State what you wantto do.'and cite the section number(s) of the Carmel/CIClY Zoning Grdinance,Wnlch applies'3l)d/or creates the need forthis request). }.7 - 3!. 75 Sq Ft Traffic Direc,tion'al Sign (3. OSq Ft Permitted) 2S. 7.02-5 (B) - 2 lns'titutional Signs:(1perIrtitted) 2?~ 7:..02-5(E) -- 0' Setback '(Existing sign lQ6th). (In' Required Setback) 25.7.0.2-5 cn) - 6" At Highest Point High (5' permf'tted) Page 1 of8 .. Developmentei Standards V$riance. 'AjOlplicalibn -v /:) ~ l!~ 0~(C IL!d ()0 () {!c---[L r; tft - 73 1t( {!)ff/f( ,~77~:;;if' J 9 [//:ft}I'ZCN ()P:-Ie. ( ?Y& ,- /S'-S-~ ~, a8-- 77'77 ,8) Sfate reasons supportingY Developmel1tal Standards Variance: (AdUnaIIY, complete the attached question sheet entitled "Findings of Fact~Develqpm~ntal :Star)dardsVariahce~). Attached "Bit Present zoning of the property (give exact classification): ~/SQ 4~\ I 9) 10) Size of lotlparcel in .question: 7.0 Acre.s acres 11) Present lIse of the property: Church 12) Describe the proposed use of the property: Fellowship, Worship, and Gommunity Outreach q) Is the property,: Owner occupied x Renter occupied Of her 14.) Are therean:f restdctions, laws, coyenants, variances, special (,lses, or appeals filed in connection with this property that would relate or ,affect its use for the;specific purpose of.this,application? If yes , giVe date and docket t"jumber, decision rendered and pertinent explanation. . No 15) Has Workfor which this application is b.eing filed alreqdy started? If answer is yes, give details: NQ Building Permit Number: Builder: 16) If proposed appeal is wanted, when will the work commence? When weather permits - completion no later than 4:/1/03 1,7) Ifthe proposed vqriance isg~anted, who Will operate and/or use the proposed improvelTlent for which this application Das been filed? Owner NOTE, LEGAL NOnCE shall be published in the Noblesville Dailv LedQer a MANDATORY twenty-five (25) days' prior 10 the public:hearin,g date. The certified "Proof of Publication" affidavitfor the newspaper must be avallable.for inspection the night ofthe hearing. LEGALNOTICE to all adjoining and abutting property ownecsis also ,MANDATORY" two n"1etnodsof notice are recommended;: 1) CERTIFI'ED MAIL - RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED ser;1t toadjoin!ng property owners. (The wbite receipt should be stamped by the Post Offic.e at least twenty-five (25) days prior to the public hearing date.) I?age 2 of 8 .. Developmental Standards'Varlance Application u (j AFFIDAVIT l, hereby swear that I am the owner/contract purchaser of propertyiiwolved in this application and that the foregoing s ignature!i, s~atements and answers herein contained and the ihforfTlatiol1herewith submitted are In all respects true' and correct to \he best of my knowledge and belief. I, thEl unqersigned I autho~ize the applicant toad on my behalf with regard 10 this application and subsequent hearings and t::::~Yitfd4.::.- ~ e~ ~ 1/ P 7~'} (Property OWl1er, Attorney, or Power of Attorney) D,ate Mu/_ e e~"" (Please Print) STATE OF INDIANA S8: County of . ~ ~ (County in wHich. notarization takes place) Before me the undersigned, a Notary Public for P~~I-~/ . . (Notary Public's county of residence) County, $tate of Indiar.\8, personally appeared anq 'acknowledge the execution of the' foregoing ihstrument this c::?,? M dayof 7/ tf75~ ./ , .200 -:2- ~;4''\~:' \" ~ ;" ~.-'~?t.r ~.;:.,... --:-'_ , '-!' .f~...~ ;:: _,'.,~-"'''........ 0. "'~A . -.~ ........ ..c" ~_'.;"'l -~. ~$EAL) _-_~! ~...l ' ~~ . \ ~~_ . ~ i ~~ ~ ~ S "7 \ \,,~' ~ -' -: ~ ~/......\. '-~ -.... ~I": <" "-."_~:.a_a /l ~ . \ ;-.............,... - r-"\' (/ Notary Public--Signqtur.e f#m~;v4-#fIJez?d . NQtaryPublic~~Please Print My commission expires: 3~$-devg Page 4bfB.--.Developmenlal Standards va"ance.Applicatiop c c 6ft oft !;jrade ----T 4ft. Double Faced",/, Corner Sign 28 sq. ft. ---...-..--.--- - - ..... .. . - 7 ft. .., 'n_ Win. 18 In. f tt -r~i !~ Yard Sign .,~ '1 . ;j 1.,'1 '2 In. Yard Sign -'3..15 ?Q. f 1 , positioned on "\/" Mount at 60 degree sharp angle PLACE BACK AS CITY CRITERIA ALLOWS Looking to the Hest . Looking to the East u u r . , . I , . '. ? ~ \~." ~_., ~ , . ....~. . '. .. . ,.) ~'l..---' -.0-~~ .,- ,J .. J . ",../ . .. . ", )~ y 'J ) KING OF GLORY LUTHERAN CHURCH KEY SCIENTIFIC NAME SIGN lANDSCAPE PLAN ..-w T AXUS X MEDIA 'W ARDII' SCALE t": l' I>f D. $affen 80 Sons, LANDSCAPE ARCHITEcruRE ,'A ASSORTED ANNUALs ~ .......... ~TW c ~o ~f' \ ~ c SIZE 10"BB 2-1I2"PP u ~._"-_.- ...--......'--..- ~---t-----~(iJ- -~ --~...~-. -...~~-.... J (D(9 PriN:!: ~~.:... 10.0' off easement on Keystone 21.0~ So. off easement at corner of l06th!Keyston .. = .--'.~III '-'''''''-1''/11I ~~. ....~_." -~ .......-..-... -- -: ;.;..::~- .~ ::1',(109 + ~ ~I:''''I, I' .. IIoU" ......, & IiQ 19 .;._- L---- ""'_-... f~~= - Mr::lr~llltl'!' "',II,,'" I I I! t:~~i:l U \l I " (\\~ III EX itj I 'U ~'. J l. ,i ~.. -\ ."E i.~ 1 :J\\ ~~~~- ~~.==~ ; I ~ I I' II I! I r I I L:'-==-=.:/..:.-=--= _ _ -.::.__ . -- -- ~o;:::." "'-DeleirlfCJI PII<I:f, I--~-:--i ' ~s::-- """'J''''''~J -_.,..,1 \ 1_- .....8. p.,.epaTed For. King of Clory Luthenm Church fll:tW~1G WEIHE ENGINEERS, INC. f;!rb~~::;'~~JL ~~~~~ii~ F.~. ~., I 1~1lIW""'~~-0'I~~ . l.IIHIl1i1J1f1ia.:nlil!l' ::... ?ZOI [~S1 lD51!1 SLI't-~L Corm-~L Jl'!d......." l:Jilli"'l;I C""',M;..n" E.~,t>:l ~,. al In.... wn. ME/'!. S-"cl""~' 7. Te.,.....lill.lp O' ~I>lr~t>, "'tl~ <I CC::1. C~ 1'1'111.. l'to....lIlo-n CQ,. Ir~ 0," " NOO.O 1 '22 "E (Record Beoring 17.05' (R&M) by Deed Deflection) "'" .. ,,,. ~" "")~ ) o / ) Curb Street N62"16'08"W 109.71' (R&M) (Record Searing by Deed Deflection) 7-- lJ27 79' iPf ',iorHed fngineerii"19 /' /' ./ Wood -New sign location -Inside angle 600 -6'at highest point -Sign faces 7'x4' -Brick supports to match sign on 106th - 12"x 12" ~ \\ \~ ,. r ::; '" )( "\.. )( )( )( )( '-Chain-lint.: F"ence Wood Fence 7",0 ,. 83'28'27" ^ <D '< UiV> o -+- ;:0 g:J 'j (t) u. b)>- ~ < ~(t) J C Cb \ i \ \ \ \ \ \ ~ \ \ \ \. \ Traffje Signal (Typ,) ^ (t) '< "ZUI o -+- 500 '6:J '5 ill CL 0"1> i: < ~m :J C (1) NorlrleClS't C(:HlIer (If the Wes:l Holf Q{ fhe Norlhwesl Ouor(er, SecUon 7. TlJwn:i~I'p J 7 "lorin, Ponge 4 cost (Bross Plug round iH Bo.< per MCSR) Trorric-Stroir1 Pol,; (Typ.) GM '" 6" Conerel. 135. i 4' '-I' Cu,-b Scale \' " 40' r--)-r'.J o 20 40 . () z: .... U) g ae ! UJ w Z C; Z~~ W" " w ii 2 ~ :!E ~;HP ~mH 6 . Ii ~ w ( .c " !- ;1 .c ~ ,.. g t; .c ;; '-1 i: ~ ';:2 t.; 'r:l ~"o' ~'" .. ,.: ~~ 1 0,1 Address: 2201 E. 106 Street Carmel, Indiana 46032 e-mail: staff(alkoacarmel.com On the web: kogcarmel.com Phone: Office: (317) 846-1555 Fax: (317) 846-1590 Preschool: 846-0597 Pastors: Paul F. Swartz David L. Hewitt Harry N. Huxhold Minister of Operations: Nancy Rumschlag Director of Music: Jean Darling Director of Preschool: lee Bucher Director of Youth Ministries Kristina Monson u u 1/15/03 ~ RECFIVED JMl 16 2003 DOCS Carmel/Clay Board of Zoning Appeals Informational Packets a) Docket numbers and the substance of the matter to be heard - See attachment "A" b) The legal description of the subject real estate - See attachment "B" c) General location by address or other identifiable geographic characteristic of the property: 2201 E. I06th Street, Carmel IN 46032 d) Name of the person, agency or entity initiating the matter to be heard: Bill Erickson e) A general descriptlon of the Petitioner's request of approval - See attachment "A" f) Date, time and place of the Public Hearing: Monday, February 24, 2003 7:00 pill. at Carmel City Hall, 2nd Floor, One Civic Square, Cannel IN 46032 g) Statement that the petition may be examined at the Office of the BZA - See attac1m1ent "D" h) Statement that any person may offer verbal comments at the Public Hearing or may file written comments prior to or at the hearing - See attachment "D" i) Any other information that maybe required by law to be contained in such Public Notice - See attachment "E" I, u u ". , Attachment "A" 3.7 - Traffic Directional Sign - 3.0 Square Feet Standard - 3.75 Square Feet Proposed Docket No. V -208-02 This sign will be installed approximated 153 feet off the entrance to our propeliy. This sign has already been manufactured awaiting placement, pending variance to permit this oversized directional sign. We apologize for this oversight on manufacturing; we incorrectly assumed that our contractor fully understood the City ofCmmel zomng standards. We see to have the sign installed to ensure that parents/custodians of Preschool children have clear direction to the correct door for drop-off/pick-up of children. 25.7.02-5(B) Institutional Signs - I Pcnnitted - Petitioning for 2 Docket No. V -209-02 We currently have and have bad since at least 1973 or prior, 2 signs on this property. We propose that the sign on Keystone be replaced by a 2 sided sign (60 degree angle or less) between sign faces. Due to this propenties significant acreage, and the heavy traffic that Keystone Avenue enjoys, we wish to continue to have signage on this corridor. We wish to change the current signage as an upgrade in both aesthetics to the property, as well as to ensure our church presence on Keystone A venue. 25.7.02-5(E) Setback - Standard 10' Setback - Petition for 0' Docket No. V-211-02 Our sign on 106111 Street sits approximately 2 '4" on the easement. This sign was relocated approximated 50 feet west when the church agreed to give up one curb cut onto 106tb in conjunction with our church expansion completed in 1998. The turning lane onto southbound Keystone from 1 06th was created in the mid 90's in conjunction with the subdivision development directly to our west. The addition of this lane moved the easement into the previous sign. When the sign was moved approximated 50' west in 1997, we believed (falsely) that keeping the same distance from pavement was appropriate. To our knowledge, this sign has not posed a safety hazard and we understand that the sign is at risk if utility work occurs in the future in the easement occupied by the sign as it sits. We ask pem1ission to leave the sign in its present location. 25.7.02-5(D) Sign elevation - Standard 5.0' - Proposed 6.0' Docket No. V-210-02 Due to. the surrounding elevations, particularly along Keystone Avenue and presence or traffic control box on corner, we petition for this change to standard so that entire sign may be viewed from Keystone Avenue. Due to the significant slope ofthe property behind this sign, the placement, and severity of slope along Keystone Avenue; we believe this petition will not pose a safety hazard to our neighbors or the community. u Attachment "A" u Legal Description of original property purchased 1962. LAND DESCRIPTION (per reCord 8oo~ J 7', Page 443) A purl of the Wes't Half of the Northeast Quarter of Section 7, . Towns.hip l7 North. Range 4 East in Cloy Township, Homiltan County. Indiana, being more particularly described os follows: ' E BEr;.INNING 685.9 feet [ost of the northwest comer of the West Half of the Nor!heast. Quarte; of Section 7, Township 17 Nodn, Range 4 East:. thence deflecting to the right 89 degr,?es and 38 minutes a distance of 420.0 feet to a point; !hen-:e deflecting to the left 89 degrees and 34 minutes a distance of 464.45 feet to the west right of woy of new State Highway #431; thence deflecting to the left 94 degrees, 49 minutes. 15 seconds: a distance of 7.34 fe.et olong said right of woy to Q pdtnt; thence deflecting to the left 5 degrees, J3 minutes, 15 seconds, a distonce of 350.75 feet along said right of way to 0 point; thence deflecting to the left 51 . degrees. 59 minutes, Q distance of 109.71 feet along said right of way to 0 point; thence deflecting to the right 62 . degrees, 17 minutes, :?O seconds, (} distance of 17.37 feet to the north .Iine of the West Half of the above described Quarter section; 'thence deflecting to the left 90 degrees, 0 minutes, 0 distance of 306.82 feet to the PLACE OF BEGINNING. Containing in 011 4.05 ocres more or less. . r .,' Subject to 01/ legol easements and rights' of way of record. ../1:t:ND DESCRIPTION V (per Record Instrument #92-14162) '. Combined Legal Description " . . .. . f-'ort of the Northeast Quarter of SectJon 7, TownshIp 77 lnc1udlng ~rlglna~. North, Range 4 Eost, Clay Township, Hamilton County, Indiana, purchase wHh addltlona+nore porticu/o,~/y described os (allows: 3.0 acres in 1992 r I I . . Commence at the northwest corner of the Northeast Quarter of Section 7, Township 17 North, Range 4 Eost, Cloy Township, Homilton County, Indiana; thence South 90 degrees 00 minutes 00 seconds Eost (assumed bearing), 685.90 feet on the' north line of soid Northeast Quarter to the northwest corner of the real estate described in Deed Book 177, page 443 in the Office of the Recorder of Hamilton County, Indiana; thence South 00 degrees 22 minutes 00 seconds East. 420,00 feet on the west line of the real estate described in said Deed Book 171, poge 443 to the southwest corner thereof, said corner being the POINT OF BEGINNING of this description; thence continuing South 00 degrees 22 minutes 00 seconds East, 625.01 feet on the southerly prolongation of the lost described line; thence South 90 degrees 00 minutes 00 seconds East 511.59 feet porallel with the north line of said Northeast Quarter t6 the westerly Limited Access Right-of-Way Line of State Road #431 (Keystone Avenue) per pIons for IS,H.C. "s" Project #165 (13) doted 1960; thence North 04 degrees 42 minutes 45 seconds West 626.58 feet on said Westerly Limited Access Right...!of-Way t.ine to the southeast corner of the reol estate described in soid Deed Book 171 page 443; thence North 89 degrees 56 minutes 00 second's West 464.11 feet on the south line of the, real estate described in said Deed Book 171, poge 443 to the POINT Of BEGINNING, containing 7.00 ocres more or less, SubJect to oil easements. righ!s of way, covenants and restrictions of record_ u u Attachment "B" 3.7 - Traffic Directional Sign - 3.0 Square Feet Standard - 3.75 Square Feet Proposed This sign will be installed approximated 153 feet off the entrance to our property. This sign has already been manufactured awaiting placement, pending variance to pem1it this oversized directional sign. We apologize for this oversight on manufacturi.ng; we incorrectly assumed that our contractor fully understood the City of Cannel zoning standards. We see to have the sign installed to ensure that parents/custodians of Preschool children have clear direction to the correct door for drop-off/pick-up of children. 25.7.02-5(B) Institutional Signs - 1 Pennitted - Petitioning for 2 We currently have and have had since at least 1973 or prior, 2 signs on this property. We propose that the sign on Keystone be replaced by a 2 sided sign (60 degree angle or less) between sign faces. Due to this propenties significant acreage, and the heavy traffic that Keystone Avenue enjoys, we wish to continue to have signage on this corridor. We wish to change the current signage as an upgrade in both aesthetics to the property, as well as to ensure our church presence on Keystone Avenue. 25.7.02-5(E) Setback - Standard 10' Setback - Petition for 0' Our sign on 106th Street sits approximately 2' 4" on the easement. This sign was relocated approximated 50 feet west when the church agreed to give up one curb cut onto 106tl1 in conjunction with our church expansion completed in 1998. The tuming lane onto southbound Keystone from 106th was created in the mid 90's in conj unction with the subdivision development directly to our west. The addition of this lane moved the easement into the previous sign. When the sign was moved approximated 50' west in 1997, we believed (falsely) that keeping the same distance from pavement was appropriate. To our knowledge, this sign has not posed a safety hazard and we understand that the sign is at risk if utility work occurs in the fnture in the easement occupied by the sign as it sits. We ask permission to leave the sign in its present location. 25.7.02-5(D) Sign elevation - Standard 5.0' - Proposed 6.0' Due to the surrounding elevations, particularly along Keystone A venue and presence or traffic control box on comer, we petition for this change to standard so that entire sign may be viewed from Keystone A venue. Due to the significant slope of the property behind this sign, the placement, and severity of slope along Keystone Avenue; we believe this petition will not pose a safety hazard to our neighbors or the community. ,egal Description of .riginal property .urchased 1962. U Attachment liB" u LAND DESCRIPTION (per record Book 171, Poge 44J) A port of the ~\'es'! Holf of the Northeast Quarter of Section 7, Towns.hip 17 North, Range 4 East in Clay Township, Homilton County, Indiana. being more particularly described os follows: . BE(;JNNING 685.9 feet [ost of the northwest corner of the West Half of the Northeast Ouorte.~ of Section 7, Township 17 Norln, Ronge 4 East; thence deflecting to the right 89 degr,:es and .38 minutes a distance of 420.0 feet to 0 point: then-:e deflecting 10 the lef! 89 degrees and .34 minutes a dis!ance of 464.45 fee! to the west right of way of new State Highway #4.31; thence def~ecUng to the left 94 degrees~ 4~ minutes, 15 seconds. 0 dlstonce of 7.34 fe.et along saId nght of way to 0 pdtnt; thence deflecting to the left 5 degrees, JJ minutes. 15 seconds. 0 distance of 350.75 f-:et along said right of way to a point; thence deflecting to the len 51 . degrees, 59 minutes. 0 distonce of 109.7' feet along said right of" way to 0 point: thence deflecting to the right 62 . degrees. 17 minutes, 30 seconds. 0 distance of 17.37 feet to the north line of the West Half of the above described quarter section; 'thence deflecting to the left 90 degrees. 0 minutes, a distance of 306.82 feet to the PLACE OF BEGINNING. Contoining in 011 4.05 ocres more or less. Subject to 011 legal easements and righfs' of way of record. Subject 10 01/ easements, rights of way, covenants and restrictions of record. E I, f;~ ; I i , I