HomeMy WebLinkAboutPacket 12-15-08
APPlICA nON FOR BOARD OF ZONiNG APPEALS ACTION
QO
USE VARIANCE
CITY OF CARMEUCLAY TOWNSHI~
HAMILTON COUNTY. INDIANA
FEE: $1,430 plus $114.W per acre
DOCKET NO DATE RECEIVED:
1) APplicant:\("'cVOr- 't ANN E.:5l'o..~ \
Address: ?:?Ol~) C\\cw YVl e. R~ p,,6
0/. A
2) Project Name: J'.Jc<(\ ~ Phone: J'
Engineer/Architect ~ 0 (\....z... Phone~ [v /;.
Attorney: N 0 \v;2 Phone: f.....1! ^
Contact Person: ~N ~ e ~ '(' Ci.. -Q \ Phone: -3 it' l..\ q ~- 1 j C: ]
Email: 6. E:) ('0-. ~ \@ .~-A-)(I ~~ \o"l \ i (\ -e -t- 1'---re5'\ 0. ~ ,~ :) b~sd6b,c ~
-.~ . 0~
3) Applicant's Status (Check the appropriate response)
_ X (a) The applicant's name is on the deed to the property
_ (b) The applicant is 1he contract purchaser of the property
_(c) Other:
--
4)
jf Item 3) (c) is checked. please complete the following:
--
Owner of the property inVO!Ved-I'f'(, va I( ~ f\NN GS f A e. t
Owner's address: ~ 0 6 C\ \ L.J Y (\ "< K 0 ' Phone: :)} 7 - {)ca I ." c( Cc 'J- 7
Record of O\NT1ership:
Deed Book NoEme~~. d DO Y - 7 5 Vi] L{
Page: >< Purchase date: O~TO'oe ( . dCOL\
Common address of the pr~perty involved: ex 0 l.... C\\ I...J ,. /'I -e R. 6
Legal description: ~. ~ '('1/ 0-0 ~ f.'.s ~ ::Sf ~ +t c\v\ d- L 0 -+
Tax Map Parcel No.:N A ;'\1 ) Ls 1 C 360 ;::;'0 Y t"\ f\ 5C'0':\
5)
6}
( 1/ - Lj - dOQ \.
+n~"'~ ~
&.4
l.:x~
7) State explanation of requested Use Variance: (State what you want to do and cite the section number(s) of the
CanneVClay Zonin~ Ordinaru:e that appliesandlor creates.the need fur this appeal).
~ \~~ be L 0.. +t-G~\"\e2l ) Of~.~1) l it< A" Sc'nec~L~
~~~:;e~~ ~~~IZ:;~':~~-~~h~n~:d{~Ah'~
"- 1 or 9 - z:_""".1lIZA ~S\ u~ V3tlan<eAppliCaIio<l mv.lllmnroa
.,-:.
.8}
17)
9)
State reasons supporting the Use Variance: (Additionally, complete the attached question sheet entitled "-
"Findings of Fact-Use Variance"), Q /l V "- ^ \ .\ '. J h' .
\r~ ~ ICLt5 ~__lY-0Q,V\C-e L0 I't' FYi.
t::'f1-1 e ~-' I i-y II" rn t' +:s -r () r k ~ (} /I e 1'5 J ? r () K ( 'm ; I-1l
Y-tJ LL A fY) u. -<T- t f--:. If 1<. .ptJ V' (Vl {';/'l A }'l 0 r:5 (' ~ ~ OJ. V'
() e ( 3 h bar it Cl6 ~~ . tOe 13 ~I h[\l!' 'h c6): \r) A ~ no. R ~~. -5 .,
Present zoning of the property (give exact classification): R \
Present use of the property: R e -s (. eje V\ +-1' v'~ I
Size of lot/parcel in question: 1 OJ ~ X I Y ~ O~L' {<1 ~JLo ~ ~ff2acres
Describe the proposed use of the property: K p ~ i c\.> V\ f-, ~ ( L) I ~ \. I :!:\. (I ff). VI <... ~
~ n \ \0 L;__} ('['.0 y'e '+\'l An Lf 0 n,'01cz. {.:5 00 e r ~he
(\ ~ ~~ <0 ~y (Y\ 0 rr-fh :j -
Is the property: Owner occupied X
iO)
11 )
12)
13)
Renter occupied
Other
14)
Are there any restrictions, laws, covenants, variances, special uses, or appeals filed in connection with this property
Ihat wou!drelateor affect its use for the spectfic purpose of this application? If yes, give date and docket number,
decision rendered and pertinent explanation.
If...X) 0. ~
15}
Has work for which this application is being filed already started? If answer is yes> give details:
Building Permit Number: /\J fj
Builder: WI f:4,
16)
If proposed appeal is granted. when will the wor\<; commence?
N6 -t O<W1 (' ~'n \e
If the proposed appeal is granted, who will operate and/or use the proposed improvement for which this application
has been filed?
(] ,"" \"e f ~ -\ f~ \! ~( (\ '0 'tJ A ~ ~ """5':)'(' he \
NOTE:
LEGAL NOTICE shall be published in the IndianaDOlis Slat a MANDATORY twenty-five (25) days pnorto1he public
hearing date. The certified "Proof of Publication" affidavit for the newspaper must be available for inspection the night of the
hearing.
LEGAL NOTICE to all adjoining and abutting property owners is also MANDATORY, two methods of notice are
recommended:
Page 2 of 9 - Z:\s~sIB2A appliOoOO!Ui\ u.o Va.._ ~tion rn Ol11112OOU
CARMEUCLA Y BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
CARMEL, INDIANA
Docket No,:
Petitioner:
'Tr~ e. V D V' C\ VI 0 a (\ ~"\. t.. 6 0' (I.. eJ)
1.
FINDINGS OF FACT- USE VARIANCE
The grant of this variance will not be contrary to the public interest, due 10 the existence of spedal condition(s) such
that enforcement of the zoningordin nee wlll result in unnecessary hardship because:
'~ ~
2,
"-
on t1Th!'n~r I'+ hA;'1 hp(o n ~ '16 J..,.( ~ ,...~''.jG.,V'" '~feA.(~
The grant of this variance will no1 be injurious to the publlC health, sa1ety, morals and general welfare of the
community because: J-'-' '\ \ '\ '
-t- ,f / __") e (') u C A. .t--t 0....' A { ot (\ 0 L ('}}')-'\ n'l t...l Vu -f. '
" r
.5 e. 1/' \J i C -e i J....J f'..J A it J. ('~ '
3
The use or value of the area adjacent to the subject property will not be substantially affected' in any adverse
monn.'.o","," ~ \I ~ r- :l::'n~ ~~ (' I;" V1: r~:'5 +::, Q re
f {] 'if. r: ( ~,~ () --. h I f.\ tic c> .:5 /-~ ~ + 0
T~ need for the variance arises fro a natural condition peculiar to Ih subjecl prQperty p
LA. OQ I. -\ '" r. G
4.
5,
IT IS THEREFORE the decision of the CarmelfClay Board of Zoning Appeals that Use Variance Docket No.
is granted, subject to any conditions stated in the minutes of this Board, which are
incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof.
Adopted this
day of
,20
CHAIRPERSON. Carmel/Clay Board of Zoning Appeals
SECRETARY. Carmel/Clay Board of Zoning Appeals
Conditions of the Boaid a~e listed on the baCK.
P&g<! e cf Il- Z;:\ShIml<l\fQflllf;\BZA ""pIi_'" U.., Vorion<:e Appficetion ,",y, 01/111200ll
AFFIDAVIT
l, hereby swear that I amtheowner/contracl purchaser af property !nvalved in this application and that the foregoing
Signatures, statements and answers herein contained and the infOrTflation herewith submitted are in all respects true
and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief. I, the undersigned, authorize the applicant to act on my behalf with
regard to this application and subsequent hearings and testimony.-
Signed:
Pr
),,- ~
ner, Attorney, or Power of Attorney
AfV~ M fnrJO>-.J
(Please Print)
STATE OF INDIANA
S8:
I-h(fll t/nrJ
(County in which notarization takes place)
Before me the undersigned, a Notary Public for ~/ ;Ian
(Notary Public's county of residence)
IIO() If) ;::Siae-/ and acknoWledge the execution of
(Property OWner, Attorney. or Power of Attorney)
County of
County, Stale of
Indiana, personally appeared
the foregoing instrument this
g-ft)
day of
Jl IfJu%l
2Q 0 if
,
V~ (by _
~ Notary PUbliC-Sign~e
J U,Si:J/U
(SEAL)
Print
-~ My commission expires;
h/ID //'-1
P_4 afQ-~\9ZASjl_I\Use \IsAonQeAl';lti<:aliCIn ftt..a1tli/2tlOll
Attachment to Application for Board of Zoning Appeals Action Use Variance for Ann
and Trevor Esrael Docket #
We are asking for a varinnce to appendix A, schedule of uses, Chapter 3 "commercial
kennel" tor () ur propelty at 806 A lwyne Road, Cannel, IN 46032.
The variance is desired so that we may continue to keep our pets and two specific animal
groups for community service and educationat'4-H purposes:
1. Foster dogs and puppies for Adopt A Labrador. A non-praHt organization that adopts
Labrador and Labradonnix dogs and puppies from shelters and owner that are no longer
able to keep their dog, .10 new owners. We have these animals on average 3-4 weeks
from the time we receive them to the time they are adopted to new homes. During this
time we train them, provide health care and prepare them for their new homes. Ann
Esrae\ is president of this organization. This activity has been ongoi.ng. from the time the
home was purchased and has been ongoing within Carmel at our previous home since
2002. A complaint has never been filed against Us during this time and we are very
careful to make sure that tlle animals are never a disturbance to our neighbors and
community. These animals are housed within our residence. They are allowed outside
only on lead or in our fenced area.
We also have 5 dogs of our own, two ofwhieh are fTOm the Adopt A Labrador
organization; one is n-oln.Rat Bones Rat Terrier Rescucand one from the Indianapolis
Humane Society. Our two cats are both from the rndianapolis Humane Society. Our
oldest daughter has shown her dog in 4-H at both the county and state levels for the last
four years and her cat for 3 years. This requires her to attend workshops and tmill the
animals on a regular baSlS. ltoners both community service and educational
opportunities for her enrichment Our son win begin in 4-H this next year and plans to
show his dog in 4-H.
2. Our children raise and show rabbits for 4-H and for the American Rabbit Breeders
Association. We house these rabbits in our garage that is attached to our home. It is a
side load garage with complete visual cover from neighboring propet1ies. Rabbits do not
make noise and so it is not an issue. All three of our children are active in this activity
for ARBA and pmticipate at both the state and national level for the educational "team"
competitions. This requires them to take tests, study alt breeds of rabbits and judge
rabbits. It is a very educational activity and allows our children enrichment
opportunities. Our oldest daughter has been active with these animals in 4-H for 4 years
at both county and state fuir and has been participating in showmanship at both the
county and state levels. These animals have occupied the property since April of2005.
We do not have any plans to add additional structures, we work very hard to keep a clean,
healthy environment and have never had a complaint. Within '4 lnile of OUr property is
an Angus steer and Llama farm. A farm housing ponies and horses is immediately
adjacent to our neighborhood, approximately 300-400 yards from our property. It is our
beliefthat the proximity of these variances to our home should also be taken into
consideration.
L..-__LO.!-" ... .t.....",
Page 1 of 1
, r~t f!
!~! ~i,
rID! (1? r
:x: I !. 1
.z~ r1' i
i 'i i f
,ii,_ ~}. 1,,! )
.,!'I,,: ':,:'!.
!"ii.'
i "
U II)
! ~!
i I f ".~~ J
I ~ i" i
, :,. ,;
I f I' i
Ll i l
'4311 ~,'l
1.,----'-------,." I !
i ?,l l :
, I , !
i j ,~l
! . i ~-' i
t I i!
, , ' CarmeF--1L.,
D
III IB' . II
EO Maill$.'____,______,
-- ',""."n.
I 'Y
IVirt~a.:rEarth.,.F.. .. p1 II I
L J'5 _ II II:
# Address
1 ~'806 Alwyne RD
~
Q~
http://mibor.mlxtempo.com/4.3.05.62/Mapping/MapPrint.htm
r- ~I'
.1 <j
'~' i ~!
[ 01
t ,t;:!
..
....-
'EMs!n sf'
. '
/,' ~'~~~,~.,' ''<I
I . I[ ..
Status List Price
SOLD 198,600 192,500
8/812008
""l'"u"'y .,.. .l~VV
743
Mkro~!}ft'
Virtual Earth....
I
#
1 [?J 806 Alwyne RD
Address
http://mibor.mlxtempo.com/4.3.05.62/MappinglMapPrint.htm
Page 1 of I
11/
; .1
. I
!
'1
I
i'l
i ,. t
;tit
) .1
: 'j
il
! .i
t ~.
~ ~
,
"
~ ..;
't-!
24
~ <
('
,
i ,j
3J
: ~
, .
; t. ;
:" (
, i
r :
j'iJ I.!
LJ I ~
~ . ~
!,~~i i' I
i i !ID I
, O)! I,fl, 'i
I>!
1<( iID!
, Ill' i,lS I:
~ c:j -4-"
10; l,:,'
!l; "'-
\'X:~ z r
izi "
1 I -; I
[if) l<oo'l' l-4iti\'!'~ft Cu~~ V ~ I'lllclJlRl
f I 1 !'V"-HB
Status List Price Sold Price
18
16
SOLD 198,600 192,500
8/812008
PETITIONER'S AFFIDAVIT OF NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
CARMEUCLA Y BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
I (WE} fr:{tVO'l! l)J.. EC;RA EL- ~. A,oJ IlJM " f 5R415L DO HEREBY CERTIFY THAT NOTICE OF
PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE CARMEL/CLAY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS CONSIDERING Docket Number
?, cc.....rt - i:\ () ,"\I e rt (I
(,96 2kJ6u '1 U V . was l'Ogiote,'ed amf-A~j@4-,:)t least twenty-five (25)' days prior to the date of the public hearing
~
to the below listed adjacent property owners:
OWNER ./
1 \\ry,s y KCtS \<e./ ef
/. / /)' Ii'
C~/~/{/(I//i() {jk1?// ~lS/lbitn/l
. 'I '
~~~( Nit1&tZ~;l~5/~
d~C1 n (D.e~
~~~~~~
STATE OF INDIANA
ss:
ADDRESS )
~dO 8t wfl')e ~C\ C/o((Y)e
y; l/l/{,IJ YI) t .-2uac~ (1aVM~(
lS5 A LVSYf\\E Rb ~R14lt=::L
~N f3U:::lJJ ..~
_0(0 B~Jl~_
~~~tft:;~
The undersigned, having been duly sworn upon oath says that the above information is true and correct and he
is informed and,believes. '--r;I..^~_/.-zJ ?t..( ~.;r A- '
Signature of Petitioner ~
County of \-\~i.. \ -\-b~
(County in which notarization takes place)
for ~ \~e:.~
(Notary Public's county of residence)
- .
\c't".J::x-~f9.,c~\ ), ~I/\.u'-. \..-^. ~a..e...\
(Property Owner, Attorney, or Power of Attorney)
OQ..-~~
\5 -v.- day of
,', ," ."; I t 1/
",,~~ ,{..~~.~~/?(:///"
~ ~~"O\ p..R Y'(SEAL1::
:::: ~ :'~ o.'j,\l\\~'l' ". '::.
.:: :", co~{ft-J -t.u\2. -
.lo,l.~ il' J, ,
: ocwll ~':\S'it1'J .
. ,",0' " . '''{ -
::. ,G.: :::: .:::
~ ". PUB'\,:......,"'-\" :::
"/ is'l: .......... ~\I "
->/ "'IfE Of \ \....'
I, . \'\
Ij~, I', n.'"
Before me the undersigned, a Notary Public
County, State of Indiana, personally appeared
and acknowledge the execution of the foregoing instrument this
['\
~\::a...c '~
Notary Public--Please Print
My commission expires: '\D - S - \'7
,* 10 days if appearing before the BZA Hearing Officer
Page 6 of9 - Z:\shared\foITns\6ZA application.1 Use Variance ApplicaliDn rev, 01/1112008
/
,I
{
I
I
\
\
'-,
It
-~'::::.~~,-
80000-5334850
PUBLISHER'S AFFIDAVIT
Stale ofIndia1l3 55:
MARlON County
Personally appeared before me, a notary public 111 ancl lor said cOllnty and state,
the undersIgned Kerry Dodson who, bell1g duly SWorn, S<JYS that SHE is clerk
of the INDlANAPOLIS NEWSP APERS a DAlt Y STAR newspaper nf general cirenlatlon
printed :md published in the English language in the city ofINDJANAPOLlS in state
and county aforesaid, and that the printed matter attached hereto is a true copy,
which was duly published in said paper for 1 time(s), between the dates of:
t O/04/2{1{}8 and 10/04/2008
~'lSUG~
Clerk
Title
Subscribed and SWorn to before me nn 10/04/2008
1Vv~J1M1b~Yr.'bH'
Form 65-REV 1-88 My eOrTUTlission expires:
STA TE PRESCRIBED FORMULA
DENISE HAMSRJTE
R-'f:rUOUC
SEAL
STArE OF INDIANA
My COMMISSI~)plj:ll:r="'~"'r'n.~n.
--~, 'l".c'I:"r. """",,:u<B.2015
7.83 PICA COLUMN ~94 POINT
94 POINTS /5.7 PT. TYPE - 16.49
16.49 EMS /250 - .06596 SQUARES
.06596 SQUARES x $5,14 - .339 CENTS PER LINE
PUBLISHED 1 TIME = .339
PUBLISHED 2TIMES= .509
PUBLISHED 3 TIMES= ,679
PUBLISHED 4 TIMES= .848
Board of Zonine AppeaJsPublic Notice Sign Procedure:
The petitioner shaJ I incur the cost of the purchasing, placing, and removing the sign. The sign
lTlust be placed In a highly visible ,md legible location from the road on the property Ihat is
Involved with the puhlic hearing.
The public notice sign shall meet the following requirements:
I. Must be placed on the subicct property no less than 25 days prior to the public
hearing
'lhe sign must follow the sign design
requirements:
Sign must be 24" ." 36" - vertical
Sign must be double sided
Si~'Il must be composed of weather
resistant material. such as corrugated
plastic or laminated poster board
The sign must be mounted in a heavy-duty
metal frame
The sign must contaiIl the following:
" 12" x 24" PMS 1805 Red box with white
lext at the top.
. White background with black text below
G Text used in example to the right, with
Application type, Date*, and Time of
subject public hearing
* The Date should be written in day,
month, and date format. Example:
Monday, Janual}' 23
The sign must be removed within 72 hours of the Public Hearing conclusion
2.
3.
4
1~-:1-
T
{:--.F\lt.'\J-'\
"';\'.\'~ ~;..~~~~J
--t'''\'''' ,
,,' ~,,'rJ.~
-\. ....~\\'....,
..-\"....
.":,-
{.\I'I:~t.:;Il"-~1 T~ ,'.;'
II b",; ,
d'IIII~>
['or Mure lllr()rmati(ln:
oweb) \\'lI'wxannel.in.go"
( 1/571-2417
Public Notice Sh~n Placement' Affidavit:
I (We rTi? ~ \I'DK wfs.t:'Al" <or It;!! ,j M. '.;~teby certify that placements ofthe notice public
hearing to consider Docket Number OjCflcll9,~~as placed on the subject property at least
twenty-five (25) days prior to the date of the public hearing at the address listed below.
STATE OF INDIANA, COUNTY OF t\-~\~ ,SS:
The undersigned, having ,bee duly sworn, upon oath says that the above informaty,pis true and
correct as he is informed and believes. .~ lu ~/ . ~ ;f)-' ~:::::--<__~1~i
(Signature of ~ioner) .
Subscribed and sworn to before' me this ~~day of Q-\--c, 'oe:....c- ,20 De;.. \ \' i i. .'
~ -...... ,,\ \..iA Y '$c.:'~,., >
~ \..' ~ ........ "'" //
NO~I;po ~ ..~ ~OTARj>?..%
: y l.Omm Expire"' -
_ : OClU06'0, ;Dl..' : =
::. '. No 63591"ii : :::
~ iJ"':....PUBL\C..... 2
.1'.... .' "?"' "
....... -?)-r...,.........."-'\\ ,.....
.. '-.' .....\O~...
II OF Ih\," \\'
I { . \ \
l'f~Jn~\
My Commission Expires:
~D~ 'S~ \'2-