HomeMy WebLinkAboutReturn to the Writ of Certiorari STATE OF INDIANA IN THE HAMILTON SUPERIOR COURT 3
SS:
COUNTY OF HAMILTON CAUSE NO. 29D03- 0805 -MI -565
MIDWEST HOSPITALITY GROUP, INC.,)
and MOTELS OF CARMEL, LLP, s.e.)
Petitioners,
Honorable David K. Najjar, SpecialJudge
v.
THE CITY OF CARMEL and
THE CARMEL PLAN COMMISSION,
Respondents.
RETURN TO THE WRIT OF CERTIORARI
Comes now respondent Carmel Plan Commission, by counsel, and hereby files its return
to the Writ of Certiorari, pursuant to the Court's Order dated March 4, 2009. This return consists
of 188 exhibits, organized chronologically, as set forth below in the Table of Contents.
Filed this 9 day of April, 2009.
hn R. Molitor
Attorney for the Carmel Plan Commission
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Vol Ex Description Date received in Plan
Commission Office
1 1 Carmel Zoning Ordinance, with amendments effective Spring
2 2 Application for ADLS 10/20/2006
2 3 Site Plan 2/15/2007
2 4 Development Plan Application, with Commitments 2/16/2007
2 5 Technical Advisory Committee Application 3/14/2007
2 6 Christine Holmes email 3/30/2007
2 7 David Littlejohn letter 4/3/2007
2 8 Greg Hoyes letter '4/12/2007
2 9 Scott Brewer email 4/17/2007
2 10 Technical Advisory Committee minutes 4/18/2007
2 11 Amanda Foley email 4/20/2007
2 12 Public Notice 4/25/2007
2 13 Zoning /Development receipt 5/4/2007
2 14 Site Plans 5 /4/2007
Staff notes Undated, probably
2 15 May 2007
2 16 Scott Brewer email 5/7/2007
2 17 Angelina Conn email 5/10/2007
2 18 Angelina Conn email 5/14/2007
2 19 Stacey Fouts email 5/15/2007
2 20 Plan Commission agenda 5/15/2007
2 21 Angelina Conn email 5/22/2007
2 22 Stacey Fouts email 6/4/2007
2 23 Angelina Conn email 6/4/2007
2 24 Site Plans 6/8/2007
2 25 Scott Brewer email 6/12/2007
2 26 Angelina Conn email 6/19/2007
2 27 Plan Commission agenda 6/19/2007
2 28 Department Report 6/19/2007
2 29 Gary Duncan email 6/20/2007
2 30 ADLS application 6/22/2007
2 31 Angelina Conn email 6/27/2007
2 32 Angelina Conn email 7/2/2007
2 33 Angelina Conn email 7/2/2007
2 34 Dave Coots email 7/2/2007
2 35 Angelina Conn email 7/5/2007
2 36 Dave Coots email 7/5/2007
2 37 Mark Wood email 7/6/2007
2 38 Zoning/Development receipt 7/9/2007
2 39 Greg Hoyes letter 7/10/2007
2 40 Dave Coots email 7/10/2007
2 41 David Littlejohn letter 7/11/2007
2 42 Michael Fogarty letter 7/13/2007
2 43 Gary Duncan email 7/16/2007
2 44 Depai tment Report 7/17/2007
2 45 Department Report 7/17/2007
2 46 Plan Commission minutes 7/17/2007
2 47 T.A.C. agenda 7/18/2007
2 48 Technical Advisory Committee agenda, revised 7/18/2007
2 49 Angelina Conn email 7/25/2007
2 50 Angelina Conn email 7/26/2007
2 51 Dave Coots memorandum 8/10/2007
2 52 Angelina Conn email 8/10/2007
2 53 Angelina Conn email 8/10/2007
2 54 Gary Duncan email 8/10/2007
2 55 Gary Duncan email 8/14/2007
2 56 Paul Reis email 8/16/2007
2 57 Angelina Conn email 8/20/2007
2 58 Angelina Conn email 8/20/2007
2 59 Midwest Hospitality Group packet 8/21/2007
2 60 Department Report 8/21/2007
2 61 Plan Commission minutes, plus DVD of meeting 8/21/2007
2 62 Angelina Conn email 8/22/2007
2 63 Angelina Conn email 8/23/2007
2 64 Angelina Conn email 8/24/2007
2 65 Stacey Fouts memorandum 8/28/2007
2 66 David Sanders letter 8/30/2007
2 67 Eric Seidensticker memorandum 9/4/2007
2 68 Angelina Conn email 9/5/2007
2 69 Amanda Dolph email 9/5/2007
2 70 Public Notice 9/7/2007
2 71 Adrienne Keeling memorandum 9/7/2007
2 72 Colin Patterson letter 9/11/2007
2 73 Holiday Inn O &M Manual 9/11/2007
2 74 Secondary Plat 9/11/2007
2 75 Stacey Fouts memorandum 9/11/2007
2 76 Site Plans 9/11/2007
2 77 Dave Coots email 9/13/2007
2 78 Department Report 9/18/2007
2 79 Plan Commission minutes 9/18/2007
2 80 Special Studies Committee minutes 10/2/2007
2 81 Adrienne Keeling memorandum 10/5/2007
2 82 Angelina Conn email 10/8/2007
2 83 Angelina Conn email 10/8/2007
2 84 Department Report 10/16/2007
2 85 Plan Commission minutes 10/16/2007
2 86 Ordinance certification 10/22/2007
2 87 Site Plans 10/22/2007
2 88 Site Plans 10/22/2007
2 89 Site Plans 10/22/2007
2 90 Site Plans 10/22/2007
2 91 Scott Brewer email 10/27/2007
2 92 Carol Schleif email 10/29/2007
2 93 Carol Schleif email, with notes 10/29/2007
2 94 Angelina Conn email 10/29/2007
2 95 Michael DeBoy email 11/1/2007
2 96 Alexia Donahue -Wold email 11/1/2007
2 97 Special Studies Committee agenda 11/1/2007
2 98 Department Report 11/1/2007
2 99 Amanda Dolph email 11/6/2007
2 100 Adrienne Keeling memorandum 11/9/2007
2 101 Dave Coots email 11/21/2007
3 102 Site Plans 11/21/2007
3 103 Special Studies Committee minutes, with CD 11/21/2007
3 104 Site Plans, Angie's copy, with notes 11/22/2007
3 105 Angelina Conn email 11/26/2007
3 106 Gary Duncan email 11/28/2007
3 107 Department Report 11/29/2007
3 108 Zoning Ordinance amendment 12/17/2007
3 109 Dave Coots email 12/31/2007
3 110 Gary Duncan letter 1/2/2008
3 111 Mike Hollibaugh email 1/7/2008
3 112 Leo Dierckman email 1/8/2008
3 113 Ramona Hancock email 1/8/2008
3 114 Dave Coots email 1/8/2008
3 115 Department Report 1/8/2008
3 116 Steven Fehribach memorandum 1/24/2008
3 116A Traffic Operations Analysis (attached to Ex. 116) November 2007
3 117 Holiday Inn supplemental packets 1/25/2008
3 118 Scott Brewer email 1/29/2008
3 119 Gary Duncan email '1/31/2008
3 120 Angelina Conn email 1/31/2008
3 121 Site Plan 1/31/2008
3 122 Site Plan 2/5/2008
3 123 Site Plan 2/5/2008
3 124 Department Report 2/5/2008
3 125 Special Studies Committee minutes, plus CD 2/5/2008
3 126 Stacey Fouts email 2/6/2008
3 127 Site Plan 2/6/2008
3 128 Matt Brown email 2/11/2008
3 129 Stacey Fouts memorandum 2/21/2008
3 130 Michael DeBoy letter 2/21/2008
3 131 Site Plan 2/21/2008
3 132 Site Plan 2/21/2008
3 133 Site Plan 2/21/2008
3 134 Site Plan 2/21/2008
3 135 Site Plan 2/21/2008
3 136 Site Plan 2/21/2008
3 137 Site Plan 2/21/2008
3 138 Site Plan 2/21/2008
3 139 Alexia Donahue -Wold email 3/4/2008
3 140 Michael DeBoy email 3/4/2008
3 141 Special Studies Committee agenda 3/4/2008
3 142 Department Report 3/4/2008
3 143 Special Studies Committee minutes, plus CD 3/4/2008
3 144 Scott Brewer email 3/7/2008
3 145 Gary Duncan letter 3/7/2008
3 146 Christine Holmes email 3/13/2008
3 147 Midwest Hospitality Group supplemental packet 3/14/2008
3 148 Site Plans 3/14/2008
3 149 Traffic Operations Analysis 3/14/2008
3 150 Fran Bowman email 3/15/2008
3 151 Ramona Hancock email 3/17/2008
3 152 Angelina Conn email 3/17/2008
3 153 Angelina Conn email 3/17/2008
3 154 Dave Coots email 3/17/2008
3 155 Sanjay Patel email 3/17/2008
3 156 Angelina Conn email 3/18/2008
3 157 Gary Duncan email 3/21/2008
3 158" Gary Duncan email 3/21/2008
3 159 Scott Brewer email 3/24/2008
3 160 Steven Fehribach letter 3/25/2008
3 161 Site Plans 3/25/2008
3 162 Stacey Fouts memorandum 3/27/2008
3 163 Site Plans 3/27/2008
3 164 Craig Baird email 3/28/2008
3 165 Scott Brewer email 3/28/2008
3 166 Eric Evie Ambler email 3/31/2008
3 167 Ramona Hancock email 4/1/2008
3 168 Virginia Ken letter 4/1/2008
3 169 Gary Doxtater letter 4/1/2008
3 170 Mike Hollibaugh email 4/1/2008
3 171 Mike Hollibaugh email 4/1/2008
3 172 Christine Holmes email 4/1/2008
3 173 Special Studies Committee agenda 4/1/2008
3 174 Department Report 4/1/2008
3 175 Special Studies Committee minutes, plus CD 4/1/2008
3 176 Supplemental packet, Angie's copy, with notes 4/1/2008
3 177 Dave Coots email 4/2/2008
3 178 Gary Duncan email 4/2/2008
3 179 Gary Duncan email 4/4/2008
3 180 Gary Duncan email 4/10/2008
3 181 Virginia Kerr letter 4/14/2008
3 182 Virginia Kerr letter 4/14/2008
3 183 Gary Doxtater comments 4/15/2008
3 184 Plan Commission agenda, page 2 4/15/2008
3 185 Department Report 4/15/2008
3 186 Findings of Fact form 4/15/2008
3 187 Plan Commission minutes, plus DVD of meeting 4/15/2008
3 188 Plan Commission decision and findings 5/30/2008
4
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned hereby certifies that a copy of the foregoing Return to the Writ of
Certiorari (with Exhibits) has been duly served via U.S. Mail on this 9 th day of April, 2009, to
the following attorneys:
E. Davis Coots
COOTS HENKE WHEELER, P.C.
255 East Carmel Drive
Carmel, IN 46032 -2689
Alan S. Townsend
Paul D. Vink
BOSE MCKINNEY EVANS LLP
111 Monument Circle, Suite 2700
Indianapolis, Indiana 46204
h Molitor
John R. Molitor
9465 Counselors Row
Suite 200
Indianapolis, IN 46240
Telephone: (317) 843 -5511
Fax: (317) 843 -9999