Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPacket 08-22-11CARMEL BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS August 22, 2011 Docket. 11060001A Appeal to Building Permit #11010015, Carport for Thornhurst Addition, Lot 4 Revised Packet Information PETTIONER: THORNHURST NEIGHBORS RECEIVED AUG 1 7 2011 DOGS TABLE OF CONTENTS A. REASONS FOR PERMIT TO BE DENIED B. SITE PLAN, ZONING MAP AERIAL PHOTO C. COPY OF APPROVED BUILDING PERMIT #11010015 D. COPY OF REALTOR LETTER E. CORPORATION STATUS REASONS FOR BUILDING PERMIT TO BE DENIED: It is the opinion of the Thornhurst Neighbors that the erection of the proposed structure submitted as part of building permit #11010015 (carport type structure) would be a visual detriment to the neighborhood. We as neighbors understand the property owner is entitled to erect a structure of some type on his property. However, the Thornhurst Neighbors believe that the proposed structure submitted as building permit 11010015 fails to meet the quality of standard established by the City of Carmel or the intent of the ordinances that are meant to protect property owners. It is also the opinion that the property owner did not obtain the necessary variances that are needed to erect such structure on his property. The City of Carmel Department of Community Services (DOCS) Building Code failed to research the permit for accuracy in regards to the following sections. 1. Chapter 25 Sec 25.01.01.A.1 Accessory Building: Residential Districts. '1. Accessory Buildings and Uses shall not alter or change the character of the premises' 2. Chapter 25 Sec 25.18.01.B.1,2 3 Home Occupation Standards Generally. 'B. Character: 1. The Home Occupation shall not change the character of the Dwelling, Lot or Parcel; 2. The Dwelling shall not bear any indication from the exterior that is being utilized in whole or in part for any purpose other than a Dwelling; 3. The Home Occupation shall not be permitted outside storage or display of materials in connection with the Home Occupation.' 3. 3. Chapter 25 Sec 25.26.O1.A B Commercial Vehicles. '25.26.01 Commercial Vehicles or trailers shall not be parked, stored maintained or kept on any residentially used or zoned lot unless the vehicle has a maximum load capacity of three quarter (3/4) of a ton or less; and A. Serves as the sole vehicular transportation of a resident of the property upon which it is parked, stored, maintained or kept; or B. Such vehicle is within a garage or carport which complies with all standards and regulations of this ordinance.' The City of Carmel Department of Community Services (DOCS) Building Code informed the property owner after numerous complaints that he is unable to store his commercial trailer or his recreational trailer on his driveway. The DOCS Building Code Services explained to the property owner that he had two (2) choices: either remove the trailer and store off-site or erect a carport type structure per the City of Carmel Ordinance- Chapter 25 Section 25.26- Commercial Vehicles. In January of 2011 the property owner submitted a building application to erect a carport. (see Tab 'C') In a letter from Mike Hollibaugh dated March 24, 2011 (a copy of the letter is included as part of the building permit- see Tab 'C') to all neighbors of Thornhurst Drive- including the property owner of 37 N. Guilford. Mr. Hollibaugh communicated that "any new accessory building shall not alter the residential character of the premises, and must be built so it does not create a visual detriment to adjacent property." It is of the opinion of the Thornhurst Neighbors that the proposed structure does not in fact match the character of the existing residence. The property owner to the south will look directly into the side of the proposed structure causing a direct visual detriment to his property. Thornhurst Addition consists mostly of one story post- modern and contemporary styled ranch homes and last year Thornhurst Addition- Section Two was placed on the National Historic Registry. Exterior building materials of homes located in Thornhurst Addition consists mainly of brick, stone, wood siding and one or two homes with vinyl siding. (See photos of 37 N. Guilford and surrounding homes -refer to aerial photo for address locations) The proposed carport as seen in the created photo image below consists of extruded aluminum panels with a metal frame structure. The aluminum panel color is to match the existing vinyl siding. The proposed height of the structure of 14' will be at the same height as the roof line over the garage. The structure itself does not match the architectural style and materials of the property owner's home or any of the surrounding homes. The proposed structure severely alters and changes the character of the existing premise. No other such structure exists in an R -2 zoning in the city limits of Carmel. The BZA requested the property owner to meet with staff and neighbors to resolve the appearance issue of the structure. Several items were discussed and the property owner has mentioned that he "could put a door on it" but no revised plans to date have been submitted to DOCS Building Code Services. The property owner indicated that he currently has the third highest assessed property in the neighborhood. He also stated that the Hamilton County Assessor's office indicated that the proposed structure would raise his assessed value. The home at 37 N. Guilford was erected in the year 2007, thus being one of the newer built houses in the Thornhurst Neighborhood. Newer construction will generally have a higher assessed value. Adding another structure to the property of course would increase the assessed value. After speaking with several realtors they indicated that assessed value does not reflect actual market value. One realtor provided the neighbors with a letter indicating the erection of such structure would in fact "de- value" the property. (see Tab 'D') The Thornhurst Neighborhood currently is an R -2 Residential District zoning. The Thornhurst Addition properties located along Guilford Road abutt the Old Meridian Overlay Zone. Immediately to the west and southwest the properties are zoned OM /MU —Old Meridian District /Mixed Use and or OM /MM- Old Meridian/ Mixed Medical (see Tab 'A'). The Old Meridian District Overlay Zone has strict architectural guidelines and material requirements. Across from 37 N. Guilford is an existing gas station. The gas station was constructured prior to the adoption of the Old Meridian Overlay Zone. Currently a gas station is not a permitted use, special use or even a special exception use. The existing use is currently grandfathered under the OM Overlay Zone. If in the future the gas station property is developed, the development shall look similar in appearance/ style to the development on the southwest corner of the Guilford Road and Main Street (see photo below) per the existing Old Meridian Street Overlay Zone. The proposed carport structure is not only a detriment to the Thornhurst Neighborhood due to lesser quality materials and architectural style but will also be visual eyesore to the Old Meridian Overlay Zone uses. The Thornhurst Neighbors are also questioning why a building permit was issued in the first place for a structure to house a trailer that exceeds the maximum weight capacity allowed? When DOCS Building Code Services informed the property owner that he had to erect a carport, at that time either the DOCS Building Code Services failed to discuss the intent of the ordinance section, discuss the issues of the maximum load capacity of the trailer or verify the maximum load capacity of the trailer with the property owner. The ordinance clearly states "vehicle" can be stored within a garage or carport not a trailer. Since the trailer in question is not the sole "vehicle" of transportation (the trailer is not motorized) and the ordinance does not say "vehicle and or trailer" can be stored in a carport. The trailer should not be allowed to be stored in any carport type structure. The trailer in question is used for the property owner's business as he has clearly stated in letters, emails and in person before the Board of Zoning Appeals. The property owner is currently running his business, Sierra Mobile Labs, Inc. from 37 N. Guilford Rd. The only known address currently for Sierra Mobile Labs is 37 N. Guilford Rd. The corporation status with the Indiana Secretary of State lists 37 N. Guilford Road as his entity address and such, is his "home base" to conduct all business transactions. (see Tab 'E') The property owner is "storing" his equipment (trailer) in an outside manner which clearly is prohibited under Chapter 25. Section 25.18- Home Occupation. During the winter months the property owner "plugs in" his trailer which we assume is to keep equipment from freezing. This action is not even allowed under the Sec. 25.04- Recreational Vehicle for a period greater than 10 days. To date the property owner refuses to supply anyone with the manufacture's data in regards to maximum load capacity. Several neighbors have spoken with various trailer manufacturers and have shown them photographs of the trailer in question. Several trailer manufactures have stated that the trailer in question can easily have a maximum load capacity of 4000 pounds (2 tons or more. The property owner has stated before the BZA that he can't currently place any more equipment in the trailer due to space restrictions. What currently is stored in the trailer has no bearing on what the trailer's currently designed maximum load capacity. The trailer as designed greatly exceeds the allowed 1500 pound (3/4 ton) maximum weight capacity. If this permit to erect the proposed carport is granted to move forward not only will this be a detriment to the Thornhurst Neighborhood, the BZA will be allowing outdoor storage for individuals using their private residence for Home Occupation and the storage of trailers exceeding the allowed three quarter ton maximum weight capacity. Also the erection of the structure for commercial purposes is a direct violation of the Thornhurst Addition Covenants. The covenants states "no structure shall be erected for commercial purposes The property owner has stated several times before the BZA that the trailer is used for his commercial business. At this time we are asking the BZA members to vote in favor of this Appeal to not allow building permit #11010015 carport structure to be erected at 37 N. Guilford Road. The structure itself is a visual detriment and does not meet the quality of architectural standards or the intent of the ordinances that have been put in place to protect the residents of the City of Carmel. Liggett, Brent E Front Stanley:: Hunnicutt.[ stantiunnicutt @sierramobilelabs.com] Sent: Friday, March 25, 2011 Z26 PM To: Liggett, Brent E 'Cc: Hollit5ai4, Mike P Subject: RE' drawing (Hunnicutt) Brent, Page 1 of 4 I have all the information to address the comments Mike had on the carport permit. There aretwo drawings in;this email's:attachmentthat show.the=fihal layout and the supports for the retaining wall. Here are specific responses to the comments Mike made: Comment: I am concerned about the retaining wall and whether it will havesufficientstrength to hold the structural loads, along with the:vehicle, etc. Response:- The support structure is shown in the second drawing in the attachment., A threaded steel rod will be inserted through the middle of the 4" x6" treated landscape timbers and embedded into the concrete pier recommended by the manufacturer recommendations include per side and a size .of'8" in diameter and 18" deep). The timbers and the carport rail will then be secured with a,lock nut and washer. .In addition, after discussionwith several carpenters who have done these kinds of 'projects, the landscape tirnbersswere increased from 4`x4 ":to.4 "x6" for added stability. Although.it:is; not clearly shown on the, drawings; the north' side'of the; carport -willl have:concrete piers that match those on'the south side. The only difference in the north side .is that only one.(or possibly two at the rear) landscape timber will be necessary because of the higher groiind.surface. Comment: It is not clear that the siding details how the siding will be attached to.the frame, can you ask him for a detail of that? Response: As shown in the instruction manual included with the original permit application, the siding is attached to the frame with screws. The screws:arepaint matched to the siding. Comment: What drainage,between`the existing garage and the:proposed'structure? Response: The entire area under-the carport and between the house and thecarportwill be covered in :gravel', This'graiel will allow drainage to takeplace.in.the same fashion as,before,the carport is installed. The water wilt_ drain south under the; carport: ln heavy' downpours, there is additional drainage to the south as the -surface rs,graduallyaloped (perhaps five degrees) as well. Comment:: What; wilLthe •siding:look.like:on east side of this? how will it look where the wall and wood corne together? (or will it beopen on both ends? ;Response: The siding on:,the;east side will affix to the last support rib. This will produce a closed end with no gaps and :thecar,port roof will overhang .this.end by approximately 11 The landscape timbers will wrap around the east end of the carport:in order to maintain a consistent look and not leave unsightly gaps. At the southeast corner the side'and rear sid'rng'will meet at the last carport rib support. The seam will then be covered with a paint matched corner coverto provide a consistent look with the existing house. .I have also looked iri the neighborhood covenants for Thornhurst Addition. I know that the City of Carmel permitting .departmentris:ndt.responsible• for enforcing these covenants, but they did cause me to makean important changetin the plans that want::to. point out The property line offset for the neighborhood is 10'. Thiszre.guirres metoreduce the widthiof the carport to 10:5' and move the carport so that it touches the roof overhang!on: the house. This will still leave a 1' gap between the carport and the existing garage wall. I have 4/1-112011 also moved the carport back from the.front of the house to avoid a rain gutter on the first 3' of the house roof. The.attached.drawings indicate my final plans unless the permitting department finds,sorne things that need be changed. Pleaseaet me know if any such changes need to be.made or when I can proceed with construction. Thanks. Stanley Hunnicutt ;P,resident Sierra Mobile Labs Inc. Phone:.317 -509 -8140 :F0188 -67S -2498 Email: stanhunnicutt @sierramobitelabs:corn CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE- This message is intended exclusively for the individual or'entity'to which it is addressed, This communication may contain information that is proprietary, privileged or confidential or otherwise legally exempt'fromdisclosure. Ifyou are not the named addressee, you:are:not.authorized to read, print, retain, copy, or disseminate this message or any part of it. If you have received this message in error, please notify the sender immediately by e mail arid delete all copies of the message. From: Liggett, BrentE [mailto:bliggett @carmel.in gov] 'Sent:. Friday, March .18, 2011 3:49 PM To: starihunnicutt @sierramobilelabs.com. Cc: Hollibaugh, Mike P; Mast, Darren; Blanchard, Jim E 'Subject: RV: drawing (Hunnicutt) Stan, Here is the list of details that we went over•earliertoday. Also, as I stated Mike,will'be meeting with our plan coinmission,attorney next Week see what other,Steps. may need to betaken. When you re- submit these items 'please note any changes :in size, etc...that you would Iikeito make. Also, you.will wantsto look into any :covenants./ restrictions of Thornhurst that;could 'bean issue with neighbors. l know thatyou said that you purchased that home because you didn't believe that,there were any restrictions but.that_may, not accurate. Keep,in mind that we will be sending.a letter to the .neighborhood to inform them thatthe forged letter placed in the mailboxes was not sent,.by the City of Carmel. Thank you again for your continued cooperation through out thisprocess. I will contact you on Monday the 28' to see Whereyou are on these issues. Thanks, `great iiggetit Building Inspector 1 Code Enforcement Building and Code Services The City of Carmel (317)571 -2491 A Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail From: Hoilibaugh, Mike P Sent: Friday, March 18,2011' 3 :10 PM To:,Liggett; Brent E; Conn; Angelina V' Cc: Blanchard, Jim,E Subject: RE: drawing'(Hunnicutt) 4 Page 2 of 4 Brent, Thanks far sending.thison. After looking over the.drawings, I have a number of questions /concerns to run by you. Would•you,ask Jim Blanchard if'he has any concerns too? e 'loam concerned about the retaining walLand whether it will have sufficient strength to hold the 'structural ,loads, along; with the vehicle,; etc. It is not clearthat the siding details how_ the siding will be attached to the frame, can you ask him for a detail of that? o What drainage..between the existing.garage and the proposed structure? What will the.siding look like on the east side of this? how will it look where the wall and wood come together? (or will'it be open oh b_oth.ends? (:noticed that a "stop work" has been placed which:wili give some time to get some ofthese details worked out. You should let Mr. Hunnicutt know that,what heir proposing to do, although it may rneet,zoning, does not appear to..meet the recorded covenants >for Thornhurst Addition in regard to. =setback and, possibly, land use. That may become an.iissue withihis neighbors nowthat.they have all been 'alerted' to.this project. I plan to talk with the Plan. Commission attorney about this next week you and I can talk more about this when you get back in the office. I appreciate'your effort on this, hope .you and the family have a nice time away next week. Mike From: Stanley.Hunnicutt mailto: stanhunnicutt @sierramobilelabs.com] Sent: Thursday; March 17, 2011 12:59 PM Toc ;Liggett, Scent E Subject: RE:; drawing Brent, Attached:is the revised drawing for the car.port the house and all dimensions., Please note the drawing isiidt to scale. In.orderto enclose the rear of thecarport.and still fit the:entire trailer ihside,.the carport has been;extended'by 4.5' to a total length of'31.5'. This will incur an extra cost for me, but if this is what it takes to complete the project, I am willing. It is my understanding that this is,all I need to submit at this time. Please let me know if I am incorrect or if you need me to come in to sign something for this addendum. Stanley A. Hunnicutt President Sierra Mobile Labs Inc. Phone: 317 509 -8140 ax: 888-675-2498 Email:. stanhunnicutt @sierearriobilelabs.com c0_NfIDENTIALITY• NOTICE This message i s intended exclusively for the individual or entity to which it is 4/1.112011 Page 3 of 4 addressed. This communication. may contain •information that is proprietary, privileged.or confidential or otherwise legaly- exempt frorn disclosure: If you.are not the named addressee, you are not authorized to read, print, retain, copy,: or" disseminate this any part of it if you received this message in error, please notify the senderimmediately by email and delete all copies of the message. From: Liggett, Brent E [mailtobiiggett @carrnein.gov] Sent: Wednesday, March 16, 2011;4;34 PM Toastanh unnicutt @sierramobiletabs :corn Subject: drawing Stan, I to you a reminder that you need;to ?submit an updated plan of what your'project wiii look like once finished.. Based on the email we sent you in February the conditions put on theipermit:applrrcation I would like yob to submit that to us prior to beginning construction: If you were to begin •building' it prior'to getting this information'there is a chance we would poSt a stop =work order on the project. Thanks for your cooperation, ..Br¢eit Ltgg¢tt Building.inspector/Code Enforcement Building:and' Code. S ervices The City of Carmel (317).571.2491 bliggett @carhiel.in:gov A Please consider the environment before printing this,e -mail 4/11/2011 Page 4 of 4 March 24, 2011 JAMES .BRMN;AR1), MAYOR To: Residents, of Christie's Thornhust Addition Carmel, Indiana 46032 Re: Proposed. Improvement- Location Perrnit of Mr. Stanley A. Hunnicutt, 37 N. Guilford Rd., Cannel, IN 46032 Dear Cannel Property Owner: :I "write today in my capacityas supervisor ofBrent Liggett, who is a Building.. Inspector and Code Enforcement .Ofcerin theDepartment of CommunityServices of the City of Carmel. Last week, after.an.internal investigatiori,:l learned.that a forged letter was distributed recently in neighborhood— ostensibly sent to you and your neighbors by.Mlr: Liggett in an apparent attempt to persuade you. that�the. Carmel Board of Zoning Appe secretly approved Mi. l-iunnicutt's•plans to aluminum carport on his property at 37 N. Guilford. The City has not`yet been able to,discoverthe source of this forged letter•(dated "March 2011" and headed "Hi N eighbor however, I w u" ant to assure,yo :letter did notoriginate with -Mr. Liggett nor with any other employee.,or official of the City of Carmel. To set the record straight, here are all theffacts surrounding Mr. Hunnicutt's proposal: 1. This Department i initiated.an:investigation.last November into :the use of the Hunnicutt property; upon ll !fayer.Brainard's,request,after the Mayor received a cop y of an anonymous complaint letter that:was dated:October 31, 2010. 2. AfterreviewingMr: Hunnicutt's practices on behalfof this Department, :■r. Liggett advised Mr; Huiinicutt',that it was a:violationof the Carmel Zoning Ordinance -for' him to customarily park his,business;trailer in the front yard ofhis property. This advice was based on _the.textrof Section 25.26:01 of the Zoning Ordinance which states, "Commercial vehicles trailersshall not be parked stored, maintained kept on any residentially used or zoned.lot:unless the vehicle "s a maximum load capacity ofthree- quarters °(3 /4) of a ton or.less; and: (A) the.sole °vehicular transportation of a resident of the property which it is parked stored maintained or kept; or (B) such vehicle is within..a .garage or carport which:cornplies with:all the.standards and regulations of this ordinance;" 3. When :Mr. Hunnicutt (earned that he was'subject to a :possible enforcement action, he.filed with.Mr. Liggett a "Residential Improvement Location Permit Application which was P.O.ARTmENT OF COMMUNITY SErt'1c }ii ONE CIVIC SO.ORE C'Al2M L IN 46(132 Prrnvr; 31 7. 171.2 :117, 1-:,x 317.i7'1,2426 lMicl iAFI. P.. 11 1o1.1.1I A1k;ir, DIRECTOR received bythis Department on January 6, 2011, and conditionally approved by Mr. Liggett on:Februaly 17, 2011. The condition that Mr. Liggett imposed on the application was that the:proposed carport would "need to screen the sides of the vehicle.fiom view Subsequently'ithas been communicated that any new accessory building shall not alter the residential character of the premises, and must be built so it does not create a visual detriment to adjacent property. 4. Mr. Hunnicutt has. yet to filerevised plans that demonstrate.his:proposed carport would meet the condition stated above. Consequently, this Department has NOT yet issued a final, valid permit to Mr. Hunnicutt Which would allow him to proceed to build .the carport. 5. Contrary to the insinuation in the.forged letter, this matter has,NOT been reviewed or approved _by.the Carmel Board'of Zoning Appeals. 6. If and when this Department does.issue a permit to Mr. Hunnicutt thejssuance would still be subject: to• appeal by any interested,resid:ents. Section 30.01 of the Carmel ,Zoning Ordinancestates, "The Board`[ofZoning Appeals] may hear,: review and;determine appeals taken from any order, requires ents, decision or determination rnade,by the Director or any administrative official or board.charga.with the enforcement;of the Zoning or Subdivision Control Ordinance of the City of Carmel. All appeals shall be filed'with the Director within thirty (30) days: of the action to beappealed." After receiving a copy of the forged letter „I requested assistance from this Department's legal counsel,° provided. by the City government:_ Our counsel has now‘advised the that Mr. Hunnicutt's proposed carport construction while it be permissible under the City's ordinances may violate the private; covenants and restrictions bind''owners.of lots in the Thornhust.Addition, which was platted in 1'957. The covenants and restrictions were formally approved by the Hamilton. County Plan Commission on May 20,.1957, and'recorded in the office of the Hamilton County Recorder on May 27, 1957. According-to otir-counsel, neither this Department nor the :Board of Zeining-Appeals has authority under Indiana law, to enforce .private covenants and restrictions;_ however, they may be enforceable by "any other person owning any -real property; situated. in this;: subdivision Therefore, concerned residents may have to "consult a pi ivateattorney if they want to take effective action to prevent the proposed carport from being built:. Thank= youfor your attentionfto this;matter. If you would like to discuss any of the above :in furtherdetail, youmay.callme?at`317571 2417. Sincerely, `Michael Hollibaugl cc: Douglas Haney, City Attorney MayorJames-Brainard 01/01/2002 00'02 111 JUN--21 -2811 16 28 a� Prudential To: Becky Feigh Thomhu st Neighbor's 18 Thomburat Dr Carmel, IN 46032 Dear Ms. Feign: FF Auer reviewing the material on considera'tilgt of Docket 11060001A and appeal to building permit 011010015 for the rpait i be erected at Thornhurst lot #4, it is my belief as a Realtor and having almost 30 yews experience in residential sales, that it is a tough real estate market already, and when neighborhood includes an unsightly yard with vehicles used for business purposes and—plans to put up a substandard carport to house such vehicles it will be doubly diffi{i It to sell, any home in the neighborhood. In some cases, the eyesore can pose a legal iss� "ey and not only header the sale of properties, but can dig deep into the communities pockets with legal fees to have the carport, metal sheds or housing of the like removed. Following the design of a cornmunity,'confiiiriaing to the architectural integrity of the builders and developers orginial designs to any cozmmunity.keeping up the value of their homes and properties. As Th:ornhtt was recently placed on the National Historic Registry, 1 believe it is even more importantfor not only the homeowners of Thornhutst to conform to th© neighborhood home dest4is but for any adjoining to adhere to strict codes as well. Should a+ny`prospeve home buyers see a metal carport within view of a home of interest; it will no doubt tietour their decision to buy, Not only would such a building cause a problem for those{ %tl is in sight of, but could also lead other people to think there may be the possibility of otia homes constructing a similar building in the area and further header sales across the c i oi aurrity. It is my professional, advice; that you tale -41 possible actions to stop the erection of this substandard vehicle housing that would.dainlsb the value of all property resales in the commtmity and sun'ounding area. Should you have further inquiries; plc atelel free to contact rue anytime. Sincerely, Robb Clark Realtor Prudential Indiana 1111111 1ADJGJMPTWMJ INC PRUDENT I1LINDIRNRREALGRPN 3178416390 prudential tndisno Realty Group Fishers Ulrice 8402 •E st118th Street, Fishers, m46038 46038 BUS 317841-8880 Fax•317.694 wwv+r,prudentiMindianacem '1t PAGE 01 P.01/01 An independently owAOd sad operate rnfsrtg r of Pruden tai Real Estal Moo, Inc. TOTRL x.01 MO View additional information for the entity, including transaction history, merger information, registered agent, principals and corporate report information (years paid and years due). Mb Generate an official Certificate of Existence /Authorization. There is a total fee of $18.00 for IN.gov subscribers and a fee of $19.38 for credit card users. Example Certificate. Please note that when an entity has a past due business entity report, the Certificate of Existence will indicate that the entity is not current. An entity is current if no reports are past due. ea Generate Copies of Business Entity Documents. Request Information Printouts or Certificates. There is no fee to place an order; however, you will be billed for any statutory fees associated with your order. View fee schedule View turn around time c File Supplemental Filings. Select this option to determine what filings are available online for this entity. More Information Page 1 of 1 Name Searched On: SIERRA MOBILE LABS (Legal) Entity Legal Name: SIERRA MOBILE LABS, INC. Entity Address: 37 N. GUILFORD ROAD, CARMEL, IN 46032 General Entity Information: Control Number: 2005052400624 Status: Active Entity Type: For Profit Domestic Corporation Entity Creation Date: 5/24/2005 Entity Date to Expire: Entity Inactive Date: This entity is current with Business Entity Report(s). There are no other names on file for this Entity. Additional Services Available: Back to the SOS Web site fritw:� :�ntzcr t,l Current Information If you encounter technical difficulties while using these services, please contact the IN.gov Webmaster. If you are unable to find the information you need through the resources provided on this web site, please contact Secretary of State Charles P. White's Business Services Division at 317 232 -6576. https: /secure.in.gov /sos /online_ corps /view_details.aspx ?guid= 9EBCD078 -A699 -481 A -9E... 4/18/2011