Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCorrespondence: Petition from Neighbors 8-21-12feed S- 2l -zol-Z To: City of Carmel Officials and Planning Commission Subject: Prevent rezoning of 146th and Gray Rd. Letter: Greetings, just signed the following petition addressed to: City of Carmel Officials and Planning Commission. Prevent rezoning of 146th and Gray Rd. If the zoning is changed from residential to commercial it will allow for a gas station and convenience store. Sincerely, City of Carmel Officlas and Planning Commision Petition Comments Prevent rezoning of 146th and Gray Rd. Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment Maurine Lehr 46032 United States 6/27/2012 We don't want the increased traffic in this area resulting from rezoning, nor do we need any more little strip malls, gas stations, etc. The more little businesses there are within close proximity of one another will only make it harder for the existing businesses to make a living. The resulting vacant store fronts will not be pretty. Patrick Zircher Carmel IN 46033 United States 6/30/2012 There's empty commercial space at the next intersection to the east. A gas station at 146 & Gray is wasteful sprawl. Bill Harris Carmel IN 46033 United States 6/30/2012 do not want a gas station in my backyard Jill Bousamra carmel IN 46033 United States 6/30/2012 Wasteful use of space. Bundling of commercial real estate makes better sense. 146th and Carey has available space and already has commercial property. cheryl hazelrigg carmel IN 46033 United States 6/30/2012 I am adamantly opposed to a gas station at the corner of 146th & Gray Road! Anne Paluszny Carmel IN 46033 United States 6/30/2012 I DO NOT WANT A GAS STATION ANYWHERE NEAR MY RESIDENTIAL AREA!!! Ken and Diane Klotz Carmel IN 46033 United States 6/30/2012 We have lived in Woodfield for 20 years. We are confident that building a gas station would devalue our subdivision and bring an undesirable amount of noise, crime and problem people to our neighborhood. No other subdivision in Carmel is at risk and I feel many of us would move because of this. Our family would be sure not to live in Carmel if this is how they treat long time, high tax paying residents like us. Mark Duffin Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/1/2012 I'm opposed to gas station next to a residential neighborhood. Claudia Nelson Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/1/2012 There is plenty of commercial space very close to this intersection, including on the northwest corner. This is not a good use of this space. Joel Scherer Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/1/2012 In addition to the negative impact on the residential properties, This intersection is busy and sits on a grade limiting visibility. Situating a gas station here would increase traffic and represent a safety hazard due to the entering and exiting traffic. Diane V. Marshall Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/1/2012 Ridiculous! More Developers Greed...plenty of other corners on the 146th corridor would be more conducive to a gas station /hold -up store! The "Friends Meeting" must be furious! Agree with all previously posted comments! No to rezoning for commercial on south corners of 146 & Gray! Absurd! Kimberly Paarlberg Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/1/2012 There are traffic concerns and water run off concerns with development of this corner for commercial purposes that would have detremental effects on the Woodfield subdivision. David Beebe Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/1/2012 We do not need a gas station at this intersection. It would be a blight on the area. There are plenty of gas stations in the area....we don't need yet another. Page 1 of 5 City of Carmel Officlas and Planning Commision Petition Comments Prevent rezoning of 146th and Gray Rd. Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment Jennifer Sinclair Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/1/2012 This is a lovely residential area, which would be horribly, negatively impacted by the building of a gas station and convenience store. It should not even be a topic of discussion. Mike Hogan Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/1/2012 Home Values will be compromised by the Gas Station. Richard Gaynor Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/2/2012 Not conducive to a residential area and will add noise and more traffic to the area. When U5 31is closed for a prolonged period will add a large influx of cars and trucks to our residential area. Linda Abbenhaus Carmel IN 46062 United States 7/3/2012 There are traffic safety concerns, home value concerns, health and hazardous chemical issues, noise concerns. The area is surrounded by residential homes and a gas station would be inappropriate. Sandra Jennings Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/3/2012 Not only does this pose risk / hazards to the immediate area, the commercial zoning on 146th is way out of control. If they continue, the traffic is only going to get worse and property values will decrease. More traffic also means that our community access at 146th becomes more dangerous. Justin Taylor Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/4/2012 I do not want to add congestion to a busy intersection, and additionally 1 do not want to set a precident with of a convenience stores being built next to residential neighborhoods. a Ann apace Carmel I 46033 United States 7/4/2012 No gas station wanted or needed at this location. Saftey - more lights. Not needed. All residential! Thomas alli Carmel ! 46033 United States 7/4/2012 consern for the safety of Carmel's groundwater supply; Safety regarding traffic flow relative to entry and departure from the facility and potential for "U" -turn related accidents at an very busy intersection, impacts on adjacent residents from increased site elevation, soil fill slope, lighting, noise and potential for unfavorale late night activity. Just because Westfield has chosen to have their south fringe be commercial is not a reason to follow suite for the subject corner. Construction of a low profile, single story professional office facility may be a consideration for rezone. RAY DIVISTEAD Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/5/2012 I am strongly opposed to this proposal. It will devalue the neighborhood, change the character of the neighborhood and increase traffic in an already crowded intersection. Jeffrey lavn Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/5/2012 A gas station does not belong adjacent to any residential subdivision and particularly a church! This is why there is not one in Carmel today. Lr Orley Carmel I 46033 United States 7/7/2012 There is no need for an additional gas station /convenience store in the area. 24 hour businesses such as this add to concerns about cleanliness, noise and major traffic issues. I have deep concerns about decreasing home values if this is approved. Page 2 of 5 City of Carmel Officlas and Planning Commision Petition Comments Prevent rezoning of 146th and Gray Rd. Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment Ron Jobe Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/9/2012 We do not need another commericial site. This will be a negative to our community. We do want this rezoning to occur. Louis Lenzi Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/13/2012 A gas station at that location will significantly reduce home owner values in the immediate area. Robert Konrad Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/18/2012 A gas station should not be placed adjacent to residential homes. There will be increased, noise, traffic, congestion, crime, etc. all of which will decrease the quality of our Woodfield neighborhood and thus decrease our home values. Denise Konrad Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/25/2012 A gas station should not be placed against a residential neighborhood for safety and health concerns. It's now what the land was zoned fair and changing that 20 years after the neighborhood was developed is unfair. It will make property values suffer and create even larger gridlock on that corner. the fact is there are many other places to put this station even across the street with walgreens. Paige Ryan Carmel IN 46033 United States 7/26/2012 Unsafe, change nature of neighborh000d. steve dauby carmel IN 46033 United States 8/15/2012 really concerned about the future water supply and the mitchner drain being so close to the site. traffic on 146th is already becoming stop and go and we dont need this at the intersection Joseph Ezernack Carmel IN 46033 United States 8/18/2012 This site should remain residential. Increased traffic, pollution, noise pollution, light pollution will all decrease the property values for the surrounding residential areas. This is unwanted and unneeded. Susan Hudock Carmel IN 46033 United States 8/19/2012 I don't want increased traffic at a busy corner. Also the 24 hour convenience store brings the risk of increased crime. Joan Graham Carmel IN 46033 United States 8/19/2012 This is a hazardous intersection with an already dangerous past. Many teen drivers on their way to /from school pass through this intersection daily. Magnifying this risk by developing a commercial gas station and convenience store is irresponsible. My children attend this school. Furthermore, we are greatly concerned about the potentially hazardous chemicals that may pollute the waters adjacent to our home, as we are next to the creek, in Morgans Creek Subdivision. Children play regularly in this creek, catching tadpoles and frogs during the summer. Potentially polluting the water and additionally raising the risk of injury to an already dangerous intersection is just bad for Carmel. There are many other locations that have better capacity for traffic, and no school zones in the area. 1 strongly vote to turn down this petition to rezone the property to commercial. Page 3 of 5 City of Carmel Officlas and Planning Commision Petition Comments Prevent rezoning of 146th and Gray Rd. Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment Angie Ting Carmel IN 46033 United States 8/19/2012 1 want my childrens lives in the safe and quite neighborhood. We don't need possible crimes and hazardous near our home. Plus trraffics on 146th street are already busy, why do we need it to let 146th street become a unsafety road! Aiso, housing markets were already down so much Debra Titus Carmel IN 46033 United States 8/20/2012 Increased traffic; decrease in home values; change character of neighborhood mark titus carmel IN 46033 United States 8/20/2012 next to my neighborhood ... Radmila Popovic Carmel IN 46033 United States 8/20/2012 !don't want to see increased trash - especially cigarette packs, soda bottles and /or beer bottles all over Gray and 146th St. There will be a large increase in noise, cars left unattended and /or broken down, muffler noises /engines revving, teen hangouts, drugs /alcohol exchange, etc. There are a lot of teenage drivers in the area and this is particuarly very dangerous intersection even for the skilled drivers. Scott McCombs Carmel IN 46033 United States 8/20/2012 Will decrease value of the beautiful homes within the area John Koven Keri Taylor Carmel IN 46033 United States 8/20/2012 Having served on the County study committee that studied and provided input for the design and use of the "new" 146th Street corridor, it was intended that this road would become a thoroughfare to provide a streamlined access between 1 -69 and 1 -65 without having to drive all the way to 1-465 to make this connection. It was never intended to become the commercial corridor that it has and is becoming. Commercial development with all of its various medians and curb cuts would only slow down this movement of traffic and defeat the purpose of this road. Any commercial development was to have been set back away from 146th Street and have its own access roads. This request for a gas station and convenience store at the corner of Gray Road and 146th St does not meet that standard. The low lying land where this is proposed will make ingress and egress very difficult and will most likely cause significant traffic bottlenecks and resulting accidents at an already underperforming intersection during peak traffic periods. Carmel IN 46033 United States 8/20/2012 1 don't want my property values to decrease and !would not want the extra congestion at an already busy intersection. Matt Moore Carmel IN 46033 United States 8/21/2012 !don't want the increased traffic on Gray road and increased congestion at 146th St. 1 don't think the access to that proposed location will be safe with limited sight lines of Gray Rd. This should continue to be zoned as residential. Christine lafrato Carmel IN 46033 United States 8/21/2012 Many friends have been in accidents at this corner. One girl! work with was killed at the corner. It is dangerous already. Page 4 of 5 City of Carmel Officlas and Planning Commision Petition Comments Prevent rezoning of 146th and Gray Rd. Name City State Zip Country SignedOn Comment Carol Richards Carmel IN 46033 United States 8/21/2012 Please do not rezone 146th and Gray Road for commercial use. We moved to Carmel a year ago for many reasons, but one was because how well the city protects its residential areas. Please place commercial properties along US 31, 146th... there are plenty of commercial zones already established. We don't need or want a gas station or convenience store right in our neighborhood. Carol Richards Carmel IN 46033 United States 8/21/2012 This intersection is at the crest of 2 hills with bad visibility, very near the high school AND the intersection is in 3 juridictions: Carmel, Westfield & Noblesville...so planning will be a nightmare. It would be way better to put a gas station over by the Kroger at 146th & Hazel Dell. Carol Richards Carmel IN 46033 United States 8/21/2012 That intersection is always congested, especially when the high school is in session and there have been many accidents there! Page 5 of 5 Signatures Name Location Date Steve Dauby United States 2012 -06 -27 Melisa Keiser Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -27 David E Grass Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -27 TRACEY RAY United States 2012 -06 -27 Todd Hale Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -27 Holly Schneider Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -27 Elizabeth Wolff Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -27 Julia Sicklesteel Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -27 Michael Birk United States 2012 -06 -27 Barbara aitken United States 2012 -06 -27 David Sicklesteel Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -27 Maurine Lehr United States 2012 -06 -27 Debra Dawson Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -27 Thomas Smith Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -28 James Kraft Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -28 Steven Steiner Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -28 Ruth Petersen Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -28 Jean Kraft United States 2012 -06 -28 Barb Dauby Carmel, United States 2012 -06 -28 susan stayer Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -28 shedy berrios jacksonville nc, NC, United States 2012 -06 -28 Nicole Heston United States 2012 -06 -28 Jugnoo Husain Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -28 Mark Acey Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -28 Judith Harkey United States 2012 -06 -28 Robert Petersen United States 2012 -06 -29 Rhonda Petersen , United States 2012 -06 -29 Cathy Reed Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -29 John Dawson Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -29 Name Location Date Joan Barnhart , United States 2012 -06 -29 Sherri Smith Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -29 Cesare Turrin Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Emily Ward Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Christine Wickenheiser Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Patrick Zircher Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Fernando Segovia Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Kaeley Ritterskamp Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Bill Harris Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Marcia Roberts 2012 -06 -30 Mary Ann Grass Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Rebecca Barber United States 2012 -06 -30 William Ward Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Teri Dervenis Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Todd Smith Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 maria m segovia carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Joan Smith Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Jill Bousamra United States 2012 -06 -30 Ruth Conner Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Weinian Shou Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Damon Melcho United States 2012 -06 -30 cheryl hazelrigg carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Anne Paluszny Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Ken and Diane Klotz Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 Jeff Nearpass Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -06 -30 James Gordon United States 2012 -06 -30 Mark Duffin Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Claudia Nelson Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Joel Scherer Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Anne Burley Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Name Location Date Sue Nearpass Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Michael Conner Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Omer Waddles Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Derek Wallace Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Stephanie Cooper Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Jennifer Konesco Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Vince Blanchford Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Barry Hindman United States 2012 -07 -01 Diane V. Marshall Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 David Meier Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Andrea Ackermann United States 2012 -07 -01 Kimberly Paarlberg Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Kathy Calhoun Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Cindi Melcho United States 2012 -07 -01 Mark Paluszny Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Judith Evard Carmle, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Susan Beebe Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 David Beebe Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Patrick Burley Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Jennifer Sinclair Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Stephanie Meier Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Jill Osleger Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Kai Alt Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Anne Gardner Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 WILLIAM FREIJE Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 robert giczewski carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Harvey Sax United States 2012 -07 -01 Gail Barrett United States 2012 -07 -01 Steven Bousamra United States 2012 -07 -01 Mike Hogan Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Name Location Date Nancy Gaynor Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 David Van Remortel Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -01 Cindy Brandt , United States 2012 -07 -01 Marianne Merchun United States 2012 -07 -01 Schawn Walthall Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Alina Clavijo Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Richard Gaynor Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Nancy Brechbuhl Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 GRETCHEN JARRETT CARMEL, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Philip Bradney Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 tokunbo OSUNTOKUN CARMEL, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Mary Paris United States 2012 -07 -02 John Paris Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Paul Haut Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Jim Sinclair Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 John Wisel Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Larry Brechbuhl Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Harold Sadowy Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 jannet Duffin Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Ellen Gullett Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Laura Bond Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Gavin roberts United States 2012 -07 -02 Timothy Blad United States 2012 -07 -02 Mary Giczewski Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Robert Martens Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Keri Taylor Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Sheila Morone Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Linda Abbenhaus Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Lara Stickford Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -02 Steven Barrett Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -03 Name Location Date Donnie Ginn Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -03 Sandra Jennings Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -03 Justin Taylor Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -03 Paul Kamiak Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -03 Jean Kamiak Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -03 Mary Ann Wallace Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -03 Thomas Weaver Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -04 Thomas Kallio Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -04 Jane Blanchard Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -04 Kathryn Whitlock Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -05 RAY UMSTEAD Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -05 Kim Miley Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -05 Jeffrey Klavon Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -05 Stephen K. & Rhonda A. Turner Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -05 Julianne Sicklesteel Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -05 Debbie Umstead Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -05 Jennifer Tidwell Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -06 dave scheller Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -06 Mark Mennen United States 2012 -07 -06 Jennifer marsh carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -06 Larry Worley Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -06 Goel Ahdoot Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -07 michele mennen Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -08 Angie Audia Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -08 Dawn Haut Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -09 Ron Jobe Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -09 Tina Shute 2012 -07 -09 Cheryl Camp 2012 -07 -09 Judy Lenzi Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -09 Name Location Date Jim Nestor Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -09 Ed Banta Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -10 Robert Jennings Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -10 Pat Cowall- Hanover Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -10 David Hanover Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -10 Peggy Hackl Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -11 Louis Lenzi Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -12 Jan Boles Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -13 Robert Konrad Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -18 Steve Cobb Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -19 Candace Broady Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -23 Laura Tobias Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -23 Denise Konrad Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -25 Wendi Mcclain Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -25 Brian Jackson Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -25 Paige Ryan Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -26 Albert Roemhild Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -26 Carla Healy Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -07 -26 Terri Caraballo Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -01 Jeff Pedersen Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -15 steve dauby carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -15 Joseph Ezernack Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -18 Susan Hudock Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -18 Joan Graham Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -19 Angie Ting Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -19 Debra Titus Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -20 mark titus carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -20 Carol Richards Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -20 Radmila Popovic Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -20 Scott McCombs Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -20 Name Location Date John Koven Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -20 Dave Iafrato Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -20 Pamela Cousins Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -20 Sebastian Cousins Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -20 elliot cousins carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -20 Keri Taylor Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -20 Matt Moore Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -21 Julie Connolly Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -21 Christine Iafrato Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -21 Todd Barrett Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -21 Frank Sansone Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -21 Ellen Sansone Carmel, IN, United States 2012 -08 -21