HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes Sub 05-01-12 \otnC% \\
iY 1 )
\ .!NDIFNN
Carmel Plan Commission
SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE
May 1, 2012 Meeting
LOCATION: CAUCUS ROOMS,2„d FLR TIME: 6:00 P.M.
CARMEL CITY HALL (DOORS OPEN AT 5:30 P.M.)
ONE CIVIC SQUARE
CARMEL,IN 46032
The Subdivision Committee will meet to consider the following items:
1. Docket No. 12010005 OA: Patch Ordinance IX. The applicant seeks to amend Subdivision Control
Ordinance Chapter 3: General Provisions and Chapter 7: Open Space Standards for Major Subdivisions.
The applicant also seeks to amend Zoning Ordinance Chapter 2: Compliance with the Regulations, Chapter
3: Definitions, Chapter 5. S-1/Residence District, Chapter 6. S-2/Residence District; Chapter 7: R-
1/Residence District; Chapter 8: R-2/Residence District; Chapter 9: R-3/Residence District; Chapter 10: R-
4/Residence District, Chapter 20A: I-1/Industrial District, Chapter 20G. Old Meridian District; Chapter
21: Special Uses&Special Exceptions, Chapter 23B: US Highway 31 Corridor Overlay Zone; Chapter
23C: US Highway 421 —Michigan Road Corridor Overlay Zone, Chapter 23F: Cannel Drive—Range Line
Road Overlay Zone; Chapter 24:Development Plan and Architectural Design, Exterior Lighting,
Landscaping&Signage Regulations; Chapter 25:Additional Use Regulations, Chapter 26:Additional
Height, Yard, Lot Area and Buffering Regulations; Chapter 31: General Provisions, and Appendix A:
Schedule of Uses. Filed by Carmel Department of Community Services on behalf of the Carmel Plan
Commission.
• New attempt at defining CCRC which then domino effects into a modification or edit to the nursing,
retirement, or convalescent facility definition as well as fixing the problem/ordering issue that exists
with some of the definitions.
o New definition is no longer tied to the state code and the term itself is now Continuing Care
Retirement Community.
• Removed the phrase on dimensional requirements about lot area,widths, setbacks, etc. Should we add
"accepting density"just to clarify that density is a zoning variance?
Proposal will be sent to the Plan Commission with the Committee's favorable recommendation.
2. Docket No. 12040008 ADLS Amend: Jacquie's Café Outdoor Dining Area(Carlson Office&
Warehouse Complex). The applicant seeks approval to add an outdoor dining area(while removing two
parking spaces). The site is located at 9840 N.Michigan Rd. It is zoned I-1/Industrial and located within
the US 421 Overlay Zone. Filed by Jacquie Bols,owner.
• Parking.Whether or not by eliminating these spaces will there be adequate parking on the site?Aerial
photo shows that there were originally an additional 2 parking spaces than originally required; however,
owner has never seen the parking lot 100%full.
• Furniture.Railings around the concrete and planter boxes on the inside of the railing to make the area
seem like a small oasis.Plans to work with a landscaping company. Aluminum-looking chairs,but not
quite sure of the color scheme yet.Reminiscent of the furniture located at the restaurant Taste.They
Page 1 of 1
ONE CIVIC SQUARE CARMEL,INDI_ANA 46032 317-571-2417
May 1,2012 Meeting Agenda
Carmel Plan Commission Subd. Committee
•
have not decided how many table tops they will use yet, will match the space and ensure ADA
compliance. During the winter, furniture will be put in their storage unit.
• Signage. Size of the signage. Owner is clear on and will not install right away. Will install on the
umbrellas located on the table tops outside.
Items that should be addressed in the motion:
1) Fence should be inset a minimum of 18 inches from the edge of the pad.
2) Logo area on the umbrellas will be compliant with the sign ordinance as it exists at that time.
3) Furniture is at least reminiscent of what is already there for commercial grade.
4) Ensure there is handicapped parking.
ADLS Amend. Approved
3. Docket No. 11120028 ADLS: West Carmel Commons,Lot 1 -Outback Steakhouse. The applicant
seeks architectural design& site plan approval for a restaurant on 1.7 acres. The site is located at 10220 N.
Michigan Rd. It is zoned B-2/Business within the US 421/Michigan Rd. Corridor Overlay Zone.Filed by
Joe Calderon of Bose McKinney&Evans, LLP on behalf of OSI Restaurant Partners,LLC.
• Traffic circulation and access to Michigan Road.New site plan shows that there will not be direct
access to Michigan Road to avoid temporary right in/out.
• Bike parking will be located out front of the store. Connection configuration to the north and west is
now straight through for future connection purposes. Added pedestrian connectivity from the back of
the parking lot to the building.
• Changes to the building. Michigan Road façade has additional windows for articulation.
• Signage. Proposing only one sign on the building for presence on Michigan Road. Window canopy will
have a small take-out sign as well.
• Staff concern regarding architectural style.Would like to see a single connected tower instead of a
building with separate portions of brick.
• Committee concern regarding potential connectivity to the property to the north combined with the
volume of spaces that are on the west side of the access road;would like to see more provisions for safe
pedestrian traffic from the west end of the lot to the restaurant.Upgrade from striped pedestrian access
(within the city engineering's department standards).
• Upscale 12 trees in diameter on the east side of building if main signage and entrance is moved to the
south side of restaurant.
Items to be addressed for Plan Commission:
1) Revised plan for the tower.
2) Enhancements to the pedestrian access plan from west end of parking area.
3) Landscaping the trees with the Urban Forester.
Sent with a favorable recommendation to Plan Commission
4. Docket No. 11100022 DP/ADDS: Gramercy PUD (Mohawk Hills Redevelopment). The applicant seeks
site plan and design approval for a multifamily residential infill and renovation project on 116.4 acres.The
site is located at approximately 751 E. 126th Street,at the southwest corner of 126th St. and Keystone Pkwy.
The site is zoned PUD/Planned Unit Development. Filed by Matthew Griffin of Buckingham Companies.
• Created a list of ways that the submittal complies with the PUD and the design guidelines within the
PUD.
Page 2 of 1
ONE CIVIC SQUARE CARtV[EL,INDIANA 46032 317-571-2417
May 1,2012 Meeting Agenda
Carmel Plan Commission Subd. Committee
• Still working on access and circulation. Having a traffic study done by request of the city.
• The cut on Keystone is no longer likely. If it were to happen,it would occur at the south end of the site
as a right end/out on the deceleration ramp at the Carmel Dr exit. Cannel Dr access would be through
the Fountain's site.
• Committee concerned over construction logistics from a standpoint of proximity to nearby residents in
regards to traffic flow,noise, hours of construction, and keeping the residents housed during the
construction process.
o Identify a block of homes and work with the residents to fence the area of for construction
isolation. Renovations typically take between 4-8 weeks. Will separate the construction into a
series of phases.
• Main point of emphasis for next meeting will be on the architecture.
5. Special project 1: Committee to come up with criteria or conditions for which a PUD/Planned Unit
Development rezone proposal should even be considered.
6. Special project 2: Committee to consider when a"Traffic Study" should be considered mandatory and/or
when some other less comprehensive traffic study(e.g.Trip Generation Analysis) should be initiated.
Brad Grabow, C irman Lisa, tewart, Recording Secretary
Page 3 of 1
ONE CIVIC SQUARE CARMEL,INDIANA 46032 317-571-2417