HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes Sub 03-01-05
City of Carmel
CARMEL/CLAY PLAN COMMISSION
SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE
Minutes
MARCH 1, 2005
Representing the Committee:
Rick Ripma
Susan Westermeier
Dianna Knoll
Dan Dutcher
Representing the Department:
Angie Conn
Subdivision Committee nominates Rick Ripma as Committee Chairman
Three (3) in favor zero (0) opposed
Docket No. 05020016 ADLS Amend: Spring Hill Suites
Filed by Don Miller of A-Sign-by-Design.
Representing the Petitioner:
Don Miller, A SIGN BY DESIGN
The Applicant seeks to replace two wall signs. The site is located at 11895 North Meridian Street and is
zoned B6 in the US 31 Overlay.
Miller: Staff had issue with colors they would like to see the “Logo” green and red, “Spring Hill
Suites” in purple with “Marriott” in red. These would be daytime colors but at night it
lights white. The red is Marriott’s signature color. We are not changing the size. There
will be two elevations one on the south and north of the building.
Westermeier: Why is this changing?
Miller: Upgrading to new logo.
Knoll: It appears busy.
Department: There are a few inconstancies in the information packet. One detail shows top three leaves
different from rendering. The Department is not partial to a variety of colors and would
prefer limited number of colors. There is also some concern about the Screen Wall that
S:\PlanCommission\Minutes\SubdivisionCommittee\2005mar01 1
ONE CIVIC SQUARE CARMEL, INDIANA 46032 317/571-2417
was in the original approval but not erected along Pennsylvania Street. The Department
recommends approval after all concerns are addressed.
Ripma: What is the concern with the variety of colors?
Department: The Department has concerns it will create a cluttered look along the Corridor.
Ripma: I think it looks better than before.
Miller: The Department wants consistency of white at night.
Dutcher: Is there any way to change the red to white at night?
Miller: Yes, they could.
Ripma: Based on what was approved originally the Screen Wall needs to be put in.
Docket No. 05020016 ADLS Amend: Spring Hill Suites subject to
Knoll: I move to approve
making the red in “Marriott” perforated to show as white at night, and further condition
per the original approval to erect the Screen Wall on the east side facing Pennsylvania
Street.
Westermeier: Second.
Motion carried; four (4) in favor zero (0) opposed.
____________________________________________________________________
Docket No. 05020017 ADLS Amend: Residence Inn Marriott
Filed by Don Miller of A-Sign-by-Design
Representing the Petitioner:
Don Miller, A SIGN BY DESIGN
The Applicant seeks to replace one wall sign. The site is located at 11855 North Meridian Street and is
zoned B6 in the US 31 Overlay.
Miller: The vinyl overlay with burgundy “Residence Inn” during the day—it becomes white at
night. The “Marriott” is solid red but could change it to the perforated red to show up as
white at night.
Department: There are a few inconstancies in the information packet—the text “Residence Inn” would
be burgundy in color and the rendering shows white. The Department recommends
approval after all concerns are addressed. .
Ripma: Sounds like we are heading in the right direction as long as we get the perforated red.
Knoll:
Docket No. 05020017 ADLS Amend: Residence Inn Marriott,
I move to approve
subject to
perforated red “Marriott” that shows as white at night.
Dutcher: Second.
Motion carried; four (4) in favor zero (0) opposed.
____________________________________________________________________________
Docket No. 05020009 ADLS Amend: Electronic Evolutions
Filed by Nate Lelle (awning, dumpster enclosure) and Charles Marshall (ramp)
Representing the Petitioner:
Nate Lelle, MEYER-NAJEM
S:\PlanCommission\Minutes\SubdivisionCommittee\2005mar01 2
ONE CIVIC SQUARE CARMEL, INDIANA 46032 317/571-2417
The Applicant seeks approval for a new awning, dumpster enclosure, and access ramp. The site is located at 525
Congressional Boulevard and is zoned B-2.
Lelle: We are working on interior renovations turning one building into three units for a total of
3,500 square feet. They will be using the existing door as new main door with awning. We
received Department comments about the signage on the awning being not greater than
three (3) square feet. Issue on Dumpster Enclosure we are hoping to make it look similar
to other one, shown. The material is wood, painted tan to match the building and locating it
on existing asphalt. Finally, a new access ramp is needed for deliveries 12’ x 12’ x 1.5’.
Department: Recommends approval once issues are addressed.
Dutcher: The fence around the Dumpster—one picture shows one type of material and one shows
another. Which is the correct?
Nate: We can match the existing.
Ripma: Can you see this from the road?
th
Lelle: Yes, from 117 Street and from a distance on College. There is some buffering along
College.
Ripma: That is probably why they are matching the materials with the building. One matches the
building so I think the other should too. The latest Dumpster approvals are brick and
aesthetically pleasing so I think you should match the other Dumpster.
Dutcher: With that said, we want the Dumpster to match the building.
Docket No. 05020009 ADLS Amend: Electronic Evolutions subject
Westermeier: I move to approve
to
the following conditions; Dumpster Enclosure matches existing Enclosure in color and
materials, and the signage on awning is not larger than 3’ x 3’.
Dutcher: Second.
Motion carried; four (4) in favor zero (0) opposed.
________________________________________________________________________
Docket No. 05020044 ADLS Amend:
Goodfellas Brick Oven Pizza (ADLS Amendment)
Filed by Doug Kauffman for Goodfellas Brick Oven Pizza.
Representing the Petitioner:
Doug Kauffman
The Applicant seeks approval for a new awning to cover the outdoor seating area.
The site is located at 13190 Hazel Dell Parkway and is zoned B-3.
Kauffman: Tonight we are asking for Committee approval to add an awning over the outdoor seating
st
area at Goodfellas Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta. The restaurant is located at 131 and Hazel
Dell Parkway. The awning will cover 85 percent of the outdoor seating area and is
approximately 36’ x 15’ x 15. Included is a fabric sample and color, which is Forest
Green.
Department: The Department recommends approval.
Docket No. 05020044 ADLS Amend: Goodfellas Brick Oven Pizza
Knoll: I move to approve
&Pasta
(ADLS Amendment).
S:\PlanCommission\Minutes\SubdivisionCommittee\2005mar01 3
ONE CIVIC SQUARE CARMEL, INDIANA 46032 317/571-2417
Westermeier: Second.
Motion carried; four (4) in favor zero (0) opposed.
The meeting adjourned at 7:38 p.m.
____________________________
Rick Ripma, Chairperson
__________________________________
Pamela Babbitt, Subdivision Secretary
S:\PlanCommission\Minutes\SubdivisionCommittee\2005mar01 4
ONE CIVIC SQUARE CARMEL, INDIANA 46032 317/571-2417