Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPacket 09-21-04 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Bingham McHaleLLP attorneys at law DP/ADLS Petition BW Partners by Mary E. Salada, Esq. 04070033 DP/ADLS 2700 Market Tower lOWest Market Street Indianapolis, IN 46204 317.635.8900 binghammchale.com ST. VINCENT MEDICAL OFFICE BUILDING (filed as Medical Office Building, Carmel, Indiana) 10801 Michigan Road (approximate address) For September 21, 2004 Carmel Plan Commission I I 'I I 'I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I BW PARTNERS St. Vincent Medical Office Building Informational Packet 04070033 DP/ADLS TABLE OF CONTENTS Tab 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Project Narrative Tab 2.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .Aerial Photog raph Tab 3... ... ... ... ... .....Site Plan Tab 4. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Elevations Tab 5... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Sig ht Li ne Exh i bit I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 04070033 DP/ADLS PROJECT NARRATIVE BW PARTNERS, by Mary E. Solada St. Vincent Medical Office Building (filed as Medical Office Building, Carmel, Indiana) BUILDING AND LOCATION BW Partners requests development plan and architectural, design, landscaping and signage approval to provide for a 39,400 square foot medical office building, known as S1. Vincent Medical Office Building, at approximately 10801 Michigan Road (immediately north of an existing Marsh supermarket). ZONING AND COMPREHENSIVE PLAN The property is zoned B-2 and within the US Highway 421/Michigan Road Corridor Overlay. The Comprehensive Plan recognizes this site within a Low Intensity Regional Commercial Employment Area, of which the medical office use is ideally suited. BUILDING TYPE, ARCHITECTURE, AND DETAILS Respecting the overlay zone, BW Partners proposes a two-story medical office building in the Georgian style. The building would be faced with red brick and lighter cast stone accents, with the top of the parapet at 30 feet in height. Rooftop HV AC units would be out of view from all sides, with screening walls incorporated with E.I.F.S detailing. Additionally, extensive landscaping is proposed along the Michigan Road frontage, as well as the entire perimeter and within the parking areas. Some tree preservation, where possible, would be provided in the perimeter, with significant foundation plantings and no landscaping variances requested. I I I ,I I I I I I I I ,I I I I I I I I PREPARATIONS FOR FUTURE DEVELOPMENT The St. Vincent Medical Office Building and related parking would be constructed at the south end of an existing overall parcel of 9.188 acres. A new detention pond would be located north of the building, engineered to service this southern portion of the overall site, as well as a future development to the north. ACCESS None of the site would have direct access to Michigan Road, but would gain access from a new private frontage roadway to be constructed. This frontage roadway would connect Weston Pointe Boulevard in the north to the Marsh adjacent to the south. Access to the Marsh site would be provided utilizing a long-standing easement established for access and potential drainage purposes. Therefore, the St. Vincent Medical Office Building would be accessed via Weston Pointe Boulevard and/or the Marsh site. SIGNAGE Three wall signs are proposed, one on each of the north, south and west facades. None of these signs would exceed the maximum 75 square foot standard. One ground sign would be located in the north of the overall property near Weston Pointe Boulevard, the frontage road and Michigan Road. VARIANCES Three variances are requested to support the proposal: The first variance concerns the requested number of wall signs at three, one for each of the north, south and west facades, where the ordinance would otherwise allow one such wall sign for each street frontage. Given the lack of direct access and the significant overall Michigan Road frontage, the requested wall signage, being compliant in size, is justified for both the Michigan Road fac;ade and for the north and south facades to benefit north and southbound traffic. The second variance concerns the height of the ground sign requested to be 7 feet tall, where the ordinance would otherwise allow for 6 feet in height. Given the size of the overall site, the future development projected to share the ground sign, the separation of the ground sign from the 81. Vincent Medical Office Building, and the number of tenants, the additional one foot in height is justified. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I The third variance concerns the building's projection/recession along the south fa9ade. The south fa9ade would be provided with a 10-foot projection/recession at an 83-foot interval, while the ordinance would require an 8-foot projection/recession at a 60-foot interval. Given the existing development to the south (facing the rear of the Marsh/loading docks), the superior overall building design, and the minor nature of the deviation, the intent of the overlay ordinance is met, and the deviation is justified. CONCLUSION The St. Vincent Medical Office Building project will be a significant asset to the Michigan Road corridor. Being consistent with the existing zoning and Comprehensive Plan, consistent and compatible with the architectural standards of the overlay ordinance, consistent with the landscaping standards of the overlay ordinance, and compatible with the intentions of the sign ordinance, the St. Vincent Medical Office Building represents an outstanding addition to the West Carmel vicinity. I I I I )0- m < o ~. ~ ~ ~ ~ t! ~ I.. .....~ ~~ D:::I"'O ffi ~~ ~ o <..? (r~~f' \~~~~~~~/ Indiana, beina more porticul County, ), I \ ) \ ! 1 i i ) \ \ iEGEND ! 2" CHAIRBACK CURB 6' SIDEWALK 5' SIDEWALK I TYPICAL PAVEMENT ~ I CONCRETE PAVEMENl CONCRETE MEDIAN SIDEWALK RAMP 9'x18 PARKING SPACE 9'x20' PARKING SPACE Homilto 3, R 17. @ @ @ @ <D <D @ ~ @ a A port of the Southw described os follows: I GRAPHIC SCALE JOINTS 0 10'-0. ON CENTER. CURBS TO BE BONDED TO PAVEMENT WITH EPOXY RESIN PER MANUFACTURES RECOMMENDATIONS. CURE AND SEAL TO ATTAIN MAXIMUM MOISTURE RETENTION. fL ( IN FEET inch = 50 < z < ~ C) :z 9 :5 z 1-00 :5 ffiw Q. 00 w z[t E>O (I)~ (I)~ (.) ffi :E -.J W ~ 0::: <{ <.) C101 CY JOB NO. 49335 VI 0::: :r VI r;: N -:t en Lf) I en -:t CO r-- 5, x ~ r-- en I.D I CO ~ I o o CO I Lf) I"') en Lf) I en -:t CO r:::- 5, U) ~ 0::: m C Z :s I en m z (5 i5 C) z !5 m ~ o 011 legal highways, rights-of-woys, easements. SPACES 5 SPACES 72 SPACES NOTE: I NO PORiIlON OF THIS SITE LIES WITHIN THE FLOODPLAIN. PER FIR~ NUMBER 18057C0205F, DATED FEBRUARY 19. 2003 ruJ DEPTH ASPHAI ~ r @ @ 0 Q)a> (j) CAuTION LOCATICII or AI.L EXlSTt<<: \INOERGI!OIH) 1ITIU1It5 SHOWN ON THIS PlNI ARE ~D lPON ADO;( CRCuND EWl:NCE. ronc:lucS<lg. .... no! ""'1od to, ......-. ~ _ I: ~~;t~":...~~R[~}~ III: O!H[R DI5lTtICC UNDERCROtMD ISI1IJIIl[S ~:?OR~~~~ ~~~i~l~ (200) "HOLEY MOLEY" SAYS: ~ 1-800-382-5544 au TaU. FREE 1-800-428-5200 fOR CAUS D/mIDl Of IJiDWiA 33 PARKING DATA SPACE PER 300 sq. CON~lE i5P1iOii 2.03 Ac.:t (66.06%) ON SITE I ( \ f 3" 19 5. :GRI 5 4" :CREGA TE 12 COMPACIED SUBCRADE HEAVY DUTY TYPICAl PAVEMENT COMP0S811ONS (FRONTAGE ROAD) SITF DATA ...:;;;.\...,...;~:..,.::~..; ~~ ~. ~. ....,........:'\:.-.::..:..\.:.. .;.~~ ;~~~~i~~; ~;...~.~."t ~~:~ ."' '~':"'.:' ,.: .~:; ~ ~. .: . . . 1. 2" 2" COMPACTED AGGREGATE f53 ..- COMPACTED AGGREGATE 12 COMPACTED SUBGRADE REGUlAR DUTY TYP1CAl PAVEMENT COMP0S811ONS (ON Sl1E) \ \. ---- -- ........... ~V -- -- -- --,~-- ~-'~\ '\' ~ >< -'~-' -' fill' "- \ ~ ~ ~ \ 0:\ ~ ~ ~ 1 \\ ~ - ~ , I( ,. fi a.: ~ ' Ii ~ \ ~ i.~ I..j 085.12' .; 00 .. REVERSE GUTTER CHAIRBACK CURB 8 2.R. SLOP~ ....: .'. ..' . ": ~. d.. ~~ -'. ~4. . ~.. O&DJ'$ o OCOoOOCJ) oo~'8o 24 6. COMPACTED 8ACKFI ,I I I :1 'I ,I 1 ~:.t::u:ur.':;II~~itl:~!" cUIIl PI m DIULOPIIIIIT PI.AII rD. ma Ie" II1I1I11UIII "D IlIYnT IIoIY ATIO... ., TYPICAL SWALE DETAIL 10'-0" SlOPE ASPHALT PATH TO 1/4"/I'r. IIJN. ~ OR TOWARD lOP OF BAN~ ~ii1~~f:;~ff(;{${J1~#.1i1&~~ nP1CAL AlPHALT f15J':~\i/~WIt" SURfACE NO. 11. LV ON ~ PAm CROSS-SEC1'IQM ~~OlOld~C~~~C~~~OeiA~,L';.r: NO. @ @) 0 Q)@ <D del, UNDERDRAJNS WllHlN INVERTED S1REETS s. w. COR.. s. w. 1/4 SEe. 8, Tl7N. RJE REGULAR: HANDICAP: TOTAL SITE OPEN SPACE LOT COVERAGE Fncl I ~rUI TYPICAL PERIMETER s: \49JJ5\legol\Plot-Finol September 9, 2004 AAA(R), CTR(F) FTleI I ~ro I 20' g' SURf ACE COURSE BINDER COURSE STONE BASE EXTRUDED CONCREtE CURB DETAIL (ON Sl1E) OFFICE Of' THE HAMILTON COUNTY SURVEYOR I I I I I I I I I :1 I I BY REVISIONS DA TE I MARK SCALE ,"=40' ~ I ~ n CI i ~ z E ~ ~ ~ ~ ~I~I~I~I~I~~ ~I ~I~ -1"-"'1,~~,-----,-~.-'---1fl~~ IIII!I! S I - ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~ III -'--.'-1-1- ~ -- ---- ~_.- !l > ~ ;i1 "U ~ ~ a ; z "I ~ ~! ~ : ,.." ~ i ~ I ~ ~ i l ~ .. I ;:; .., ~I .. ~ I ;:; I .. iii I ~ i /'- "- '> / ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ::r: ,.." T ~ s -- ..-- ---- -- -- / ----- - ------ INDIANA FISHERS LANDSCAPE PLAN ST. VjNCENT MEDICAL OFFICE BUILDING I~~ !eO EI ~ -;:0 'fTI r'l t.l3:: ~~ .,..,.. < r'l ::::0 U1 , C) :c ~~ ::::0 ::::0 O::{ r'l c ~8 r'l OJ Z -0 z 0-0 I (1)1 )> Q)> z b:;z ::j ::j z z C) C) 0 0 r'l ~ ~2 r'l -I -I )> ;;1 ~~ )> I ~ -o~ I ~ ~!;! g ~~ CONSUL TINS ENGINEERS - lAND SURVEYORS (317) 849-5935 1-800-728-6917 FAX:(317) 849-5942 CERTIFIED: -I" ~ ;:0 c m m ;:0 ~ -0 ~ 1"'1 Z n ~ ~ ~ ;:0 :::0 ~ r'l ~ I'l C'I -0 ~ I .... 5)> ~ (l)z (")-1 f?- ,.."z G) ~_ ?F;---a-~ ~ ~ W ~ VI Q ~~ II ~~ ~... ...0 ~ i I~I~I~IRI~ Ii ~ ~ I ~I ~I ~ o a ~! IR IR ;:Ix i I ~i ,. ~ Si )> I z z z: I G ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ i ~ ; ij! ~ j:' 1" JI' 'll ~ g ~ ~ ~ ! ~ e ~ ~ -1:\ -- - n- ~ ~ ii i -- -'i-~ J 9. z 9 ~-I;:O ~ R1 o~~ ::E ~:o\~ ~ ~~~ ~ C'I;:oo -I-oZ {ij ~~~ i ~ Ii ~ lin I ~ I ~ > ~ ~zo (;)3:: ) \\\(,/.\ ; ~ i ~ ~~ J 11;:;1 ij! ~ I R !'> I s I - z !'> . 9 3::~ W ~ :~ . I ~N~ ~ ~g ~~: ~) ~~~ ;g~ ....~ ~ ~~~ -:tI I ; ~~ ~~ !j> ~~~ ;:;:~ ~ ~!I! ~~ ~ C'I~~ @~8 ~ ~~ VI 1"'1 ~(;) 1"'1...0 ~ ~; ~~ 5N~ 1"'1 z 5~ !6~~ 00 ~ . ~ > -- VI c m ! ,~ t.l3:: ~~ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ I - - - - - - - - - - - - - - .' CARMEL ~~q~~SiI!l~1 [~~~ I~ -<g~M;;I~ ila; Ie i:8!i~~ tpiq Z IdibH 1,R ~ ~~Ii!!m .fil~2i ~ p!2lilb i~~ lit ~!~ "'I ~~ h2~~H ~fi~1 . i!a~HiS~!}I~ 28 "'~i.. ~- -~ 5!~ ~ = 1.;0 0 0 ~~~r!, ~S ~~ ~~ ~II: ;*~~ "5 s:o ~ . S!o ~ --- .~_.- _.,....-'~._- Q ::t! > "'lj ~~ en n > t"'"' 1:1:! r: ~ ad m~ ~~ ~itil~I~I~ ~!g~ ~ i~~ gi FJ~ I'!!! ~ i I...;tilg ! !ii i "'i Ii i ~ i g ~;i ~~ · i'!~Uiil ;s~ ~ ~~~ Ii i h~i~CI~~ ~~~ ~ bi Ii ! ii~~:i:! ~ii > B~l ~i ~ ~~~~~~~ :i:I~ S ~RI!I m i gi~~gi! si: s ~~i: CI ~ ~h;>~~ ~~~ ~~i i i h"'i~!i IIIz~ ~ i~J; ~ iii ~Iid~i Iii i · I I i ~5!..g i~j ... 'I' ~ i 51 r:1!!!j PiiI'" ! ~~~ j i 1iI:lj~ii il! :Il ~i ~ 8 ~~~~~.~ -< & ~ ~ I CD gi~~~;~ !Pi~ {;! ~ .. i SR~ii iil!" g ~~ I I ~"i~: ~!~ ! ~: a B ~ ~1iI~ II' :-' po '" In!F lilili al~ ~~ 1Ii~~F ~~ lnF j~~ ~!I ~~a Ii '~8i iiil !S~ ~6~ ~~ lIIaa 5I~ a~~~ ~& giil ~!~ iiI~ ~!il1II ~~ ~ig ;F ~~ I,: !. i;!i !~ iili ii &; ;~ ~l ;~~ :i lit ~~ ~!iI I!! 5; I~~ ~l iill ~! ~~ ~..~ ~i ;t!l! @ ~dl ~~ 9m i: i~ i!; ! :~~~ 81 ~~ i~ n !~~ ~ i~i~ ~~ Ii !~ ~6 !3~~ ~ ~~~~ ~~ ~j ~i! 22 1~!iI ~~~II! ~~ i} i~ il :~i ! !i~I;~ i ..~ gi8lf~ 5 jIIt~ 13~ ~j a!2 ~~ jjj ~~i ! J g!ll ia~, PIg> ~ ~ i! ~g ~ ~~i!I ;( i ~I ~~ ~-<~ i l;e~ i 6 51 f ~I~ m "'iii ~ ~ ;:: p ,.. liJ~; !Irii !~ IliiF ;(!2 Bi~i~ ~ l~~~ ~i Bi~~~ Is: g~jlld m~l!!i~~ Clj i58~~~ Qa~ j~~ iii ~~(3ili! ~ I cob a ~9~ ~g;b i8ai~~ a~ ~!~I; ~d 51 f:i... ~1~n3" ~~ ~~ ~ ...~II! I;~i slIIjbi II !illlt l~1 ...f:~ ~ -<~a~ 1:a IIII~i R~~ ~~EI~ t\ "! ~ &l lj~; ~I~ io61111 ~I"" ""IR 1II~f:!:I ~ii ~iI i i i;~1R ~ ~~lIIa i~~ rc a.s... l~iI~ml i l;a~ ~ .. ~i~i ~!Ii me! ;; ;:~!~ li~ rc..!! ;;I~ ..II ~~ 111m! .I"~~ ~sS!~ ~l"'~ ~!iI~1 ii:~ iiI~:1 !~l:1I! ! ~ii~ i~~ ~2 a I",el:~ 6 Ili ~..g i~!!II ~U~ ~ a!llB ~I~ ~ !ilm~" ~r - - - - (liOlOJ <'1:1110) :1'S\'11 'rrYrJ ,f.)Vj>ll1J:S :nuv 1~H31VM 3SON11n1l ;L\,jO!h"i1rm TIV A\ 1()fI!iI ami 3S:8:1OO'!f:l!(!1OS )I:)J'>>9 U:!1i 'ilU 'Sii3N'HOJ 1\' (110'10) :.blnij) SN1onb~IIDl 3S"Hno:nr:u<nos XJlllum:i tllUIM"j:IU\-.'Al ;S"IIVJ~((J 37_:;nu (U\'V ~JI~;)-'S'AT:'I ililIHN,,-,NO) ~~ldO:Jiv.vn\: iii01()')~U(UJ) 3SVflWrf;)lIJV,J-lndS I.L\'.M. 3SUNTlflU i'lXOJ.S"dNl 11VA\ ')IJOItHEnI 'd,\1 'S~I3N1IOJl'f rHo-IOJ dMm) SNltKID :DU!I] ta.illt"'".:bI:Q} 'dAl 'tIIVHO -:mnUON'V :DI:>."I:IO)'S':IT:I {llII-LWHOI ')Njo:!o..I1\iHt't (!:!SS]((J)3 ':l.11'11t'1 ~3LN~~ ')!jl~n JO o'mu J1SNI {::'W1M\"3JOJ',t'.1's11Vl.'tt:1 1Jl'i1n1,Hl~...:V::1JIN1[ro'S'1Ta -_. (illU-L",.'no)oxtd.o:nv1.ill't ~-_/ \ Li)UVNrnS -XYi\'H Us ',<1.1,1 mSNV313AOOV SSV"J!) 131tON.V.,f5 ",{,i'V .lIf@THS'MDlH..%1;10I,1\.ZL ,.-- :-g.\'iOOM,~3001flsau 1"-- " i I ~$ .t',( !!!Si~jq,lrl.1Jj.'lA\$ ~~;15JOOJ:;;:;~$ "d'u11i(}'f(xJ&ID1IJ IS(JNV5T:UNn;fJlW .0-....0'.1 :a1Y~ NOI~V AtI'13 H~)lON ,,~,~-,~~,,~{j. ~,11<X't.i~4 I I I I I I I I I {}j(HOO ,:unij) '.JSVtl'in<;.)3:w,aI1JS 3SOX11~~~t:i~i~ ~/ '" 11000 J.1f.1.NiI 'ilat-s m""~/ rlVM JiJHli.I o:t~ ~---~~ i5:mOJ 1j::mJ1OS )j:mm (lJIj .o".t...1:rr~ 3)1nS0'1;)N3 )l3~SdWna t-,--..,,---, -.L j 4a -iI'~d If-:&:&_"m~_~ Mf1ilW_~ .~..{ ~11!S/~tij;'l">>W.,\\ '~f~~' ~'~;fDjiOOHwTi k~O)nNI HJ1fIiI\-:!-tOi 3Z:lmi ON'\' :iJJN~ro .lN1JM~ 11J!\!~,(OJ.1)Nl'U\-'-130 '5':113 '(l'ID1RR'SiTNi111F'JlilMLTIl\' dOJ.viOO~trol!)NlN;IEl.1:TJS. .U';\QSXI;'~ 01"00" ~V'iO~I;1}t{INV~S ",:ffY .8[@ TlJS'IJ!JIH ~% 1'3C:jJ,'f\.U :s.>\I.(XlNL\\ )f001,i lS1iU ~mtitlNV 'iJINHClllNOXi IIJIYI'i. 01 !JmlIY.t3G .S'JT3 '(JNO.J..38 'iIlft.!} lV)],~llH;)~n ~VBI1JOJ l}j{}d 1,\1IJX, (1fjmU-:10) ~IIVJ;ro%'fdI)J"I\!11~~ h.l;Q:..,1 :tI"t"r.)S 30VNOIS ~~,_""_m... DNIHUJ31(~1\'1I /-- CBINIVd':iJVlU ~JU '.9',1 T.f jSTi~Nd N~)[SJ,"\'N~U ~9) iitI!atI~~~ <T1SS.:UJdX3 }I:mm ~EW\3.J '){J!1fU 10 (llEUJ HSNI tUJH,V.".lIDJ ",LoU, 'slJ\'13fJ 3Z3n1J (]~V ~D!1\li()) -S'JT:J .(",n ~tjtdj~'J:!J (lliR,\'dJO} lllNn 3~1:UL"Xn,li:i(M /.\11:1\'3 G:-iSS:l~d)(~ ~IHij 1\:UN:3;) "1)IUa JO (Jl~JJ L:J$NJ ..o','w"o-.I;g'1y;)s NOI~V A3'13 H~nOS ~$ 'O-....h.l~ _,~___~OI~VAg'13 ~S3A\ I I I ,1i,i.SWJN)j();)IV !'H01Q) ;M,,'iU.) SNHl1b ::onrn .o-..=.o-d~ NOI~V A3:'13 ~SV3 --.~~~~~ -"jilltQSiwJ~~$ I I I I OS 0 NOO:Jn>>J.SNOO ~ "~~a tOO, '!j J.qW.!d>sC OUt. # .,.fOJd VNVIONI 'UIWV;) avo>> NV~JH;)n\l'N 10801 [)NIU'IIfUI 33IJlJlO 'IV3IU3J\I LN33NIA "1.S "'" ."c.' .}3-=~~,...",.,..".~' ,==,==<==.=-" ""'= JU3lU3SVlIVW A.rnM. ~ AI!lPV:/ I I Z Z ;- 0 0 z Z - ~ - 0 0 ~ - E-t - > E-t ~ u:I > -( ~ Ii: ...:I u:I > oesi u:I ...:I u:I u:I u:I ...:I ...:I ~ :I: :I: " u:I u:I.. E-t~ E-t~ ,~ f-4~ E-t~ .::: ~~ '<:; ;>~ rlh rI.)~ t1: 0" ~i .. 0" ~~ ZQ rl.)g ..I.....I~~ I~JO 1j ,1 ~ 4~::S b I I 1 ! ! J 1 j , j j c z ~ Q ~ ~ ;:J = ~ U ~ ~~ .. ~o-<~ O"z,; .~ z -< ~ , -<_J Ic~!:?~e ..< =;..": U ("i ...... _"'N ~~~~ ....... z -< ~ ~-"t : ~i"'l ~:: E- Z ~ U Z ~ > . E- 00. ------------------- ./. NEW PERIMETER LANDSCAPING (s YEAR GROWTH) EXISTlNGFENCE AND MOUND I s PARAPET -. ---------' CORNWALLIS LANE NEW PERIMrfER LANDSCAPING (sYEAR GROWTH) PROPOSED :BUllDING ~ CSo I I I (:) '-^ f .i:: ~ ~ SIGHT LINE ST. VI.NC:,ENT :MEDICALOFFICE BUILDING 10801 N. MICHIGAN ROAD CARl\tEL, li~DIANA Project ## 14210 Septe~ber 8,2004 & F acilily MOJlagement US 421-- bB ~ Medical