HomeMy WebLinkAboutApplicationConn, Angelina V
From: Conn, Angelina V
Sent: Tuesday, July 24, 2012 12:22 PM
To: Hollibaugh, Mike P; Mindham, Daren; Hancock, Ramona B, Littlejohn, David W,
'jmolitor @prodigy net', Boone, Rachel M , Tingley, Connie S; Duncan, Gary R; Donahue -Wold,
Alexia K, Blanchard, Jim E, Stewart, Lisa M, Martin, Candy; Lux, Pamela K; Haney, Douglas
C; Mishler, Nicholas F, Maki, Sue, 'GARY DOXTATER'; Thomas, John G, Redden, Nick,
Barnes, David R, Foley, Amanda J; Campbell, Kristyn
Cc: 'Nick Churchill'; Steve@pittmanpartners.com
Subject: Docket No Assignment: Aramore PUD Ord Amend ( #12070017 OA)
I have issued the Docket Number for Aramore PUD Ord. Amend. (OA). It is the following:
Docket No. 12070017 OA: Aramore PUD Ordinance Amendment.
The applicant seeks approval to amend text and exhibits for PUD Ordinance Z- 495 -06. (Related ordinance is 2 -527-
09. )
The site is located at 9801 Westfield Blvd. and is zoned PUD /Planned Unit Development. Filed by Pittman Partners,
Inc.
Nick Churchill, with Pittman Partners, can be contacted at 573 -6692.
FEES:
Ordinance Text
Amend.
$890.50
Total due:
$890.50
Petitioner, please note the following:
1. This item will be on the August 15 meeting agenda of the Technical Advisory Committee (TAC). If not done
so already, the petitioner must submit plans to all TAC members ASAP, via email and /or mail. The updated TAC
members list is online at: http: / /www.carmel.in.gov/ modules /showdocument.aspx ?documentid =1856.
2. Mailed and Published Public Notice needs to occur no later than August 24. Published notice is required
within the Indianapolis Star. Try to get the public notice ad to the IndyStar by Noon, two days prior to the public
notice deadline, in order for them to publish it on time (317- 444 -7163 or publicnotices @indystar.com). Also, the
placement of a public hearing sign on the property is required in addition to the certified mailings; see
application & calendar.
3. The Filing Fee and Fifteen (15) Informational Packets must be delivered to Plan Commission Secretary
Ramona Hancock no later than noon, Friday, Sept. 7.
4. Proof of Notice (green cards, newspaper affidavit, etc.) needs to be received by this Department no later than
noon, Friday, Sept. 14. Failure to submit Proof of Notice by this time will result in the tabling of the petition.
5. This item will appear on the Tuesday, September 18 meeting agenda of the Plan Commission (under "Public
Hearings "), which begins at 6 pm. (A representative must be present.)
6. This item might also appear on the Tuesday, October 2 meeting agenda of a Plan Commission Sub -
Committee, which begins at 6 pm. (A representative must be present.)
7. Please refer to the application /checklist for more detail.
8. Review comments from the Planning /Zoning Dept. will be issued soon.
Angie Conn, Planning Administrator
City of Carmel Planning & Zoning Division
Dept. of Community Services
1
-Ya%aft D o
REZONE /PUD APPLICATION
PETITION TO CHANGE THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP
INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE INTO THE CARMEL /CLAY ZONING ORDINANCE
FEES: Rezone
lus $123 per acre (PUD $2 9 plus $123 per acre)
Fees due after docket number is as gned.)
Date: July 20, 2012
Docket No. 120'1 DO \'1 "Z
• Name of Owner: Pittman Partners, Inc
Owner's Address
P.O. Box 554
City, State, ZIP _Carmel, IN 46082 -0554
Phone No. (317) 580 - 9693
Fax No. (317) 524 - 6001
• Contact Person Name and Company: Nick Churchill, Pittman Partners, Inc.
Contact Person Phone, Fax, Email: 317 -573 -6692, nick@pittmanpartners.com
Contact Person Address: P.O. Box 554, Carmel, IN 46082 -0554
• Record of Ownership: Instrument No.: 2007020184
Instrument No.: 2007020185
Instrument No.: 2007036491
Purchase Date: 3/12/2007
Purchase Date: 3/12/2007
Purchase Date: 4/10/2007
• Legal Description (Use additional page(s) if necessary): Attached as EXHIBIT A
• Common Address of Property Involved (or General Description if no Address Exists):
9801 Westfield Blvd. Indianapolis, IN 46280
• Tax Parcel ID Nos. 17- 14- 07- 03 -01- 017.000, 17- 14- 07- 03- 01- 017.001, 17- 14- 07- 03 -01- 016.000,
17- 14- 07- 03 -01- 007.000, 17- 14- 07- 03 -01- 005.000
• Proposed Zoning Change: From the PUD District to the AMEND PUD District, for the
property shown outlined in red on the map attached hereto, which is made a part of this
petition.
• Statement of compliance with the Carmel /Clay Comprehensive Plan (use additional
pages if necessary): Attached as EXHIBIT B
EXHIBIT A
Legal Description
A part of the Northwest Quarter of the Southwest Quarter of Section 7, Township 17
North, Range 4 East, located in Clay Township, Hamilton County, Indiana, being a
portion of the lands of Pittman Partners Inc., per Instrument No. 2007 -20186 (this and all
documents referred to herein are recorded in the Office of the Recorder of Hamilton
County, Indiana) as shown on a survey by Schneider Corporation, recorded as Instrument
No. 2010007044, being more particularly described as follows:
Beginning at a stone marking the Southeast comer of said quarter - quarter section and the
Southeast corner of said Pittman Partners Inc property; thence along the South line of
said property, North 89 °30'24" West 1275.51 feet to the East right -of -way line of
Westfield Boulevard; thence along said East line the following three (3) courses: 1) North
00 °09'06" East, 323.07 feet, 2) South 89 °31'11" East, 5.00 feet, 3) North 00 °09'06" East,
597.10 feet to the North line of said Pittman Partners Inc. property; thence along the
north lines of said property the following five (5) courses; 1) South 89 °50'54" East,
305.00 feet, 2) South 00 °09'06" West, 54.22 feet, 3) South 89 °47'07" East, 124.20 feet,
4) South 00 °09'06" West, 221.91 feet, 5) South 89 °31'l 1" East, 843.52 feet to the
Northeast most corner of said property; thence South 00 °20'55" West, 646.66 feet to the
Point of Beginning, containing 21.46 acres, more or less.
EXHIBIT B
The zoning change request to amend the PUD designation is in compliance with the
Carmel /Clay Comprehensive Plan because:
• The Comprehensive Plan encourages the adoption of development
standards which promote innovative development patterns.
• These size, location and existing zoning of the parcels support the
application of a mixed use residential community.
• The addition of another residential building form increases the ability for
the property to provide a mix of residential options and can decrease the
number of buildings and the amount of impervious areas while increasing
the useable open space in the area.
-.;.527-aY
Section 13 Homeowners Association and Declaration of Covenants
Section 13 1 Declaration of Covenants and Homeowners Association A Declaration of
Covenants shall be recorded which shall also contain various provisions regarding the
Real Estate, including provisions for an initiation fee a budget requnement to fund
general reserves the use of the Real Estate, and improvement approval requii ements aftei
initial conshuction The Declaration of Covenants will also provide for the establishment
of a Homeowners Association in which membership shall be mandatoi y
Section 14 Approval Process
Section 14 1 Approval or Denial of the Primary Plat/Development Plan
A Dxhibit `E which is attached hereto and incorporated herein by
icfeience shall serve as the Conceptual Plan (the "CP') The CP
constitutes the Development Plan and is the primary plat for the Real
Estate The architectuie, design, lighting and landscaping tor the Real
Estate and the improvements thereon, considered in connection with the
Ordinance, will require further (i) ADLS approval for all uses except
detached single family homes,or(ii) Final Development Plan approval per
the procedure set forth below in this Section 14 If there is a Substantial
Alteration in the approved ADLS and Development Plan/primary plat
review and approval of the amended plans shall be made by the
Commission or a Committee thereof, pursuant to the Commission rules
of procedure Minor Alterations and Material Alterations may be
approved by the,Dtrector
B The Director shall have the sole and exclusive authority to approve
without conditions approve with conditions, or disapprove the Final
Development Plans/Secondary Plats (collectively the FDP ) for
Aramore, provided, however that the Director shall not unreasonably
withhold of delay the Director s approval of the FDP that is in substantial
conformance with the CP and is in conformance with the Development
Requirements of this Ordinance If the Director disapproves any FDP the
Director shall set forth in writing the basis for the disapproval and
schedule the request for approval of the FDP for a hearing before the full
Plan Commission
C An amendment to the FDP which is not determined by the Director to be
a substantial or rnatenal alteration ham the approved CP, may be
reviewed and appioved solely by the Director However in the event the
Director determines that there has been a Substantial Alteration or
Material Alteration between the approved CP and any proposed TOP the
Director may at the Director's discretion, refer the amended FDP to the
Commission or a Committee thereof, tot- review and approval by the
Commission and/or a Committee thereof
6
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
"77
re( d I2- 5- -70iZ
Section 11.1 Parking: Each Townhome shall contain a two (2) car garage and each
(70) external parking spaces. The overall parking ratio shall not be less than two (2)
spaces per unit. Surface parking spaces, parking spaces inside garages and spaces outside
and immediately adjacent to garages shall count toward this requirement. Any place a
driveway is leading up to a private garage the driveway length will be a minimum of
twenty (201) feet as measured from the edge of pavement of the nearest street to the face
of the garage door.
Section 12 Mechanical Equipment
Section 12.1 Mechanical Equipment: Any mechanical equipment visible from an
adjoining street or highway shall be screened with suitable fencing or landscaping and in
general be architecturally compatible with the building(s) with which it is associated.
Section 13. Homeowners Association and Declaration of Covenants
Section 13.1 Declaration of Covenants and Homeowners Association: A Declaration of
Covenants shall be recorded which shall also contain various provisions regarding the
Real Estate, including provisions for an initiation fee, a budget requirement to fund
general reserves, the use of the Real Estate, and improvement approval requirements after
initial construction. The Declaration of Covenants will also provide for the establishment
of a Homeowners Association in which membership shall be mandatory.
Section 14. Approval Process:
Section 14.1. Approval or Denial of the Primary Plat/Development Plan.
A. Exhibit "E ", which is attached hereto and incorporated herein by
reference, shall serve as the Conceptual Plan (the "CP "). The CP
constitutes the Development Plan and is the primary plat for the Real
Estate. The architecture, design, lighting and landscaping for the Real
Estate and the improvements thereon, considered in connection with the
Ordinance, will require further (i) ADLS approval for all uses except
detached single family homes, or (ii) Final Development Plan approval per
the procedure set forth below in this Section 14. If there is a Substantial
Alteration in the approved ADLS and Development Plan/primary plat,
review and approval of the amended plans shall be made by the
Commission, or a Committee thereof, pursuant to the Commission's rules
of procedure. Minor Alterations and Material Alterations may be
approved by the Director. However, in terms of modifying any
quantitative or dimensional requirement, such modification may not be
greater than ten percent (10 %) in aggregate. Cumulatively, quantitative or
dimensional modifications greater than ten percent (10 %) must be
approved by the Council.
r-�c cI
Exhibit M
Conditions to Enactment of PUD Ordinance Z- 569 -12
I. Road hnprovement Commitment. The following are imposed as conditions to the
enactment of PUD Ordinance No. Z- 569 -12 (the "PUD Ordinance "), pertaining to the
approximately twenty one and 46/100 (21.46) acres of real estate legally described m
what is attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference as Exhibit "A" (the "Real
Estate "), and are in full satisfaction of all obligations specified in Section 2.09 of the
City of Carmel's Zoning Ordinance, as amended:
A. Improvements. The Petitioner shall make or cause to be made the
following improvements.
1. Improvements to Westfield Boulevard at the entrance to Aramore,
comprising a southbound left turn lane;
2. Improvements to the western side of the Real Estate adjacent to
Westfield Boulevard on either side of the entrance to Aramore, comprising
acceleration and deceleration lanes;
3. Construct that portion of Maple Drive that exists on the Real Estate to
current City Standards for a public street of that service level.
B. All Inclusive. Other than as specified in I(A) above, neither the
Petitioner, nor the Petitioner's successors and assigns, nor any owner, user or
contract purchaser of the Real Estate shall be required to pay any fees or to make
any improvements, contributions or dedications for road improvements, in
connection with this or any subsequent approvals, such as any subsequent
DP /ADLS approvals.
PART 5: CRITICAL CORRIDORS AND SUBAREAS
96TH STREET AND WESTFIELD
BOULEVARD SUBfiREH
Description
The 96th Street and Westfield Boulevard area has been
identified as a critical subarea because it:
• Is surrounded on three sides by major corridors: Westfield
Boulevard, 96th Street, and Keystone Parkway;
• Has stable neighborhoods that have been impacted by the
evolution of transportation facilities;
• Will likely be impacted by office/commercial
development of the land south of 96th Street controlled by
Indianapolis;
• Periodically experiences redevelopment pressure from the
private sector;
• Has areas that are not well drained; and
• Has limited bicycle and pedestrian connections to
regional amenities.
In recent years a new roundabout at 96th Street and Westfield
Boulevard was installed, a residential redevelopment project
was approved at 99th Street and Westfield Boulevard, and
the City of Carmel began reconstructing Keystone Parkway
into a grade- separated corridor.
In upcoming years, I-465 is planned to be reconstructed,
including the interchange with Keystone Parkway. The
intersection of Keystone Parkway and 96th Street is being
planned for grade separation and the Westfield Boulevard
bridge over I -465 is slated to be reconstructed. Also, 96th
Street is expected to be widened into a Primary Arterial
between Keystone Parkway and Haverstick Road, and to a
Primary Parkway between Haverstick Road and Westfield
Boulevard. Therefore, in the future, 96th Street will be
configured with a green median from Haverstick Road to
Westfield Boulevard; potentially with one "intersection" in
that segment for the undeveloped land south of the corridor
to have access to 96th Street.
Critical Area Boundaries
The 96th Street and Westfield Boulevard boundaries are
depicted on the Orientation Map on page 103.
Strategy
Connection between Pennsylvania Parkway and 96th Street: The
City of Carmel will work to connect Pennsylvania Parkway
to the roundabout at 96th Street and Westfield Boulevard.
This connection is considered an essential connection,
especially as U.S. 31 is upgraded to a freeway configuration.
Install Side Paths: There is an ever - increasing demand for
bicycle and pedestrian facilities in Carmel. Side paths along
the west side of Keystone Parkway, the north and south sides
of 99th Street, the north and south sides of 96th Street, and
extensions of existing side paths along Westfield Boulevard
to the north and south are critical pieces to add connectivity
100 I CITY OF CARMEL, INDIANA
to the region; and especially for recreation. Along 99th
Street, a sidewalk is preferred on the south side because it
has a narrower width and greater design flexibility to avoid
and preserve mature trees.
Side paths connecting the Chesterton Neighborhood to
Westfield Boulevard and Maple Drive from 99th to 96th
Streets will add important connections. Also, a side
path along the east side of Haverstick Road will enhance
pedestrian safety and provide another vital pedestrian link
north and south.
Mitigate Light Trespass and Glare: Strictly regulate on -site
lighting of any new development adjacent to stable neigh-
borhoods to prevent light trespass and glare.
Preserve and Install Tree Canopy: The 96th Street and Westfield
Boulevard Subarea has a significant and well established
tree canopy. The character of this subarea is anchored by the
presence of many mature trees. Carmel will utilize its zon-
ing regulations and processes to reasonably protect existing
tree canopy in the subarea. It will also require installation
of new canopy trees along public streets including Keystone
Parkway, when appropriate, to maintain the "green corridor"
aesthetic which exists in areas north along Keystone Parkway.
Soften Impacts from Major Corridors: As the 96th Street, West-
field Boulevard, and Keystone Parkway corridors evolve,
attention should be given to soften impacts to adjacent residen-
tial areas from future increases in traffic, widening of roads,
and new turning limitations at intersections. Specifically, future
roadway improvements should be context sensitive in their
design and improve the ability for residents and businesses to
gain access to the major corridors during peak hours.
Buffer Stable Neighborhoods from Redevelopment: Require per-
manent and effective buffering to be installed between stable
neighborhoods and areas that redevelop. Trees, landscaping,
decorative masonry walls (i.e. brick or stone, not wood), and
earthen berms should be considered, but the preservation
of residential dwellings within stable areas should also be a
factor.
Protect 99th Street and Haverstick Road as Residential - Character
Collector Streets: Assure that 99th Street and Haverstick Road
remain collector streets with residential character. Aside
from pedestrian facilities along Haverstick Road and 99th
Street, these streets generally remain the same.
Stabilize Hamilton Heights and forest Glen Subdivisions: As
residential properties in close proximity to 96th Street rede-
velop, sever Kittrell Drive, Lincoln Boulevard, and Maple
Drive and terminate each in a cul -de -sac at the expense
of the commercial redevelopment. Also, link 98th Street
between Kittrell Drive and Lincoln Boulevard to allow
properties along Lincoln Boulevard and Maple Drive to have
access to Westfield Boulevard. This change would result in
the remaining homes being located on local streets and an
increased degree of neighborhood stability.
PART 5: CRITICAL CORRIDORS AND SUBAREAS
Add Street Lights and Sidewalks: Because much of this
subarea was platted prior to subdivision regulations that
required proper infrastructure, many of the neighborhoods
do not have sufficient sidewalks, street lighting, or drain-
age facilities. The City of Carmel will utilize its existing
programs for public and private investment in such public
infrastructure.
Improve Surface Drainage: As new development has occurred
in the region, and as roads have been improved, local
residents believe issues with storm water have gotten worse.
The City should continue to study and help resolve these
drainage issues, thus helping to reduce basement flooding
and similar problems that can destabilize neighborhoods.
Connect Maple Street to 99th Street: As a part of a recent
approval for a residential PUD, the developer committed to
extending Maple Street from 98th Street to 99th Street. This
link is considered important for emergency services to gain
access to residential structures from multiple directions.
Allow Employment Centers along 96th Street: Allow private
sector driven redevelopment (i.e. private negotiation and
willingness to sell) along the north side of the 96th Street
corridor between Keystone Parkway and Westfield Boule-
vard. Redevelopment projects should result in employment
centers (e.g. general office, medical office, or service busi-
ness). Neighborhood serving commercial (e.g. small scale
dry cleaners, cafe, or convenience store) will be considered
if it fits the context. Generally, the footprint of new build-
ings associated with redevelopment should be limited to the
areas shown on the map and labeled "1 to 2 Story Employ-
ment Center" on page 103. See the conceptual cross section
drawings below.
1
Transition Area: The area designated as "Transition" on
the 96th Street and Westfield Boulevard Subarea Map,
on page 103, may be utilized for non - building features
associated with commercial redevelopment (e.g. storm water
management or parking), or may be used for medium to
high density single- family dwellings; either of which would
still necessitate buffering to minimize impacts to stable
neighborhoods as described herein.
Growth Management: Redevelopment along 96th Street should
only be permitted when it is contiguous to existing com-
mercial uses and when lots have been assembled into large
enough parcels for the commercial development to be master
planned with organized parking areas, linkages between
parking areas, effective buffers, landscaping and pedestrian
facilities.
Utilize Transitional Land Uses and Form to Soften Impacts of
Potentially Large.scale Office Development South of 96th Street: As
the area south of 96th Street evolves into office and commer-
cial centers (Indianapolis' jurisdiction), transitional uses and
smaller scale buildings should be used along the north side
of 96th Street to buffer stable neighborhoods to the north.
Similar to landscaping, moderate intensity land uses can
also be used for buffering. These buffering land uses would
be limited to one to two stories in height and would be
required to utilize facades and roof designs that are similar
to or complementary with residential development (e.g.
brick facades, pitched roofs, and dormers). Further, heavily
landscaped parking areas should be required.
Conceptual Cross Section Near Kittrell Drive (facing West)
IA
a'
1 Anti 161111111111 Idrilik1
2 Story Empbyment Heavily Landscaped Parking Area Wall; Buffer
Protect Stable Neighborhood
Conceptual Cross Section Near Wild Cherry Lane (facing West)
114 31
da 6-1
2 Story Employment
1 Story Employment
Parking or Storm Water Management Wall I Butter Protect Stable
!neighborhood
Transition
WPF
CARMEL CLAY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
0I
PART 5: CRITICAL CORRIDORS AND SUBAREAS
Reduce Curb Cuts along 96th Street: As areas along 96th Street
redevelop, require significant reduction in the number
of curb cuts. Also control where development south of
96th Street gains access to 96th Street. Street access from
the north and south should align with one another when
possible.
Maintain Westfield Boulevard as a Residential Corridor: Westfield
Boulevard between 96th Street and 99th Street will be
maintained as a residential corridor. The City of Carmel will
consider redevelopment along the east side of the corridor
when proposals are for high density single - family detached
dwellings or moderate density townhouses or apartments
that complement the area. Specifically, the cluster of proper-
ties on the southeast corner of 99th Street and Westfield
Boulevard and the properties between Kittrell and Westfield
Boulevard would be areas for redevelopment consideration,
Design Guidelines
• Protect and enhance existing tree canopy.
• Establish safe means for bicyclists and pedestrians to
travel outside of and around the subarea, especially
to 116th Street, Central Park, Marion County, and
employment centers to the west.
• Protect existing residential neighborhoods from light
pollution by strictly requiring cut -off light fixtures and
other lighting standard.
• Evaluate the most effective and beneficial buffering
system to mitigate potential impacts to stable
neighborhoods on a case -by -case basis. Utilize buffering
systems that are aesthetically pleasing, comforting, and
natural in character. Also consider buffer designs that do
not consume large areas which necessitate the demolition
of additional residential structures.
• When redevelopment occurs, require small -scale office
buildings which complement the building mass of
residential properties. Require new office buildings to be
constructed in close proximity to the right of way with
parking areas predominantly in the side and rear yards.
• If neighborhood serving commercial development is
allowed, it should be designed carefully to fit the local
character and should have pedestrian connectivity to the
neighborhoods.
102 CITY OF CARMEL, INDIANA
Two -story office structures, lake the one pictured above, would be
fitting along 96th Street between Haverstick Road and Westfield
Boulevard
Parking should be primarily located in side yards or rear yards
and the buildings should be pulled forward toward the street. Also,
pedestrian facilities should be installed along the frontage
High quality townhouses would be appropriate residential
redevelopment along Westfield Boulevard.
A limited amount ofsmall- scale, neighborhood serving commercial
may be appropriate when supported by local residents.
APPENDIX A: AMENDMENT LOG
Carmel Clay Comprehensive Plan
Resolution No. Docket No.
Amendment Log
Council Approval Effective Date
Sections Affected
Established C3 Plan, 2009
CC-05-04-09-02
08070020 CP
May 4, 2009
May 20, 2009
CC•07- 06.09 -02
09060004 CPA
July 6, 2009
July 6, 2009
Adjusted Part 4 for Southwest Clay's Thoroughfare Plan to acknowledge the NOAX
Agreement
CC -11 -02 -09.02
09080022 CPA
November 2, 2009
November 2, 2009
Part 2: Added 7.15: Brownfields Redevelopment to City -Wide Policies
CC- 02.15 -10 -02
09120022 CPA
February 15, 2010
February 15, 2010
Part 4: Amended Thoroughfare Plan Map
CC -02 -15 -10.03
09090018 CPA
February 15, 2010
February 15, 2010
Part 3: Amended Land Classification Map
Part 4: Amended Thoroughfare Plan Map
Part 5: Amended 96th Street Corridor Plan and added 96th Street and Westfield
Boulevard Subarea Plan
106 CITY OF CARMEL, INDIANA
Sign Traffic. A sign directing traffic movement into or within the district, the wording, shape
and graphics of which shall, to the extent applicable, comply with the "Manual of Uniform
Traffic Control Devices" or as approved by the Governmental Entity.
Sign Fascia. The vertical surface of a lintel over a storefront which is suitable for sign
attachment.
Sign Ordinance. Carmel /Clay Sign Ordinance, Z -302, as amended.
Small Lot. A lot having a width at the build -to line of less than 70 feet.
Small Maturing Tree. A tree whose height is normally less than 30 feet at maturity.
Specimen Tree. Any tree with a caliper of 18 inches or more.
Story. A habitable level within a building no more than 16 feet in height from floor to ceiling. A
basement, although wholly or partially habitable, is not a story unless more than 50 percent of
the basement elevation is above grade at the build -to line.
Street Furniture. Functional elements of the streetscape, including but not limited to benches,
trash receptacles, planters, telephone booths, kiosks, sign posts, street lights, bollards, and
removable enclosures.
Strectscape. The built and planted elements of El street which define its character.
Subdivision Control Ordinance. Carmel /Clay Subdivision Control Ordinance, No. Z -160, as
amended.
Texture. The exterior finish of a surface, ranging from smooth to course.
Threshold Elements. Porches, stoops, stairs, balconies, eves, cornices, loggias, arcades,
chimneys, awnings, doors and windows which are placed at or near the build -to line, a side yard
line or a rear yard line and interface between the main body of the building and the street and /or
a property line.
*Townhouse. Two or more dwellings, arranged side by side, separated by common walls, each
having more than one story.
Tree Lawn. A planting area located within or adjacent to the public right -of -way, typically
located between the curb and the sidewalk, and planted with ground cover and trees.
Trustees' Hall. The building intended for use by the Owners Association depicted on the
Development Plan.
Vertical Dwelling. More than two dwellings placed on top of each other. Vertical dwellings
which are developed as condominiums are excluded from the definition of apartments.
11
Section 2. Definitions.
2.1 The general rules of construction set forth in Chapter 3 of the Zoning Ordinance and the
definitions set forth in this Ordinance shall apply to the regulations of this Ordinance.
Words not defined herein but defined in the Zoning Ordinance shall be interpreted in
accordance with the Zoning Ordinance definition.
2.2 ADLS: See DP /ADLS Approval definition.
2.3 Apartment: A Multiple Family Dwelling owned by a single person or entity in which the
Dwelling Units are rented or leased.
2.4 Building, Attached Residential: A Building including any one or combination of the
following: Attached Dwellings, Multiple- Family Dwellings, Two - Family Dwellings, and
Townhouses; and its ancillary uses.
2.5 Building, Village Neighborhood: A Building that contains any use permitted by this
Ordinance within the Village Neighborhood Planning Area.
2.6 Character Exhibits: The illustrative exhibits attached hereto and incorporated herein by
reference as Exhibit K. The Character Exhibits are a compilation of conceptual plans,
images and sketches designed to capture the intended character of the District. Although
the Character Exhibits do not necessarily represent the final design of the District's built
environment, it does establish a benchmark for the quality and character of the overall
District as well as the District's various design elements that contribute to this vision.
7 7 Cnmmnnity Amenitipc• RPrreatinnal farilitiez and cnarrc including without limitatinn
Apartment House. A building containing more than one (1) Apartment placed
one on top of another and /or side by side, and sharing common walls and
common floors and ceilings.
Architectural Review Board. A board, established by the Declaration(s) of
Covenants, responsible for reviewing all improvements after the initial, original
construction of Buildings, Dwellings, and other improvements.
Attached Dwelling. Dwellings which are attached vertically or horizontally,
including Townhomes, flats, duplex, triplex, or quadruplex dwellings. Attached
Dwellings may be sold as condominiums or as individually deeded lots.
Apartments shall not be within the definition of Attached Dwellings and, as such,
all references in this Legacy Ordinance to Attached Dwellings shall exclude
Apartments.
Block(s): Any one or any combination of (1) the Suburban Residential Use Block,
(ii) the Neighborhood Residential Use Block, (iii) the Urban Residential Use
Block(s), (iv) the Primary Office Use Block, (v) the Village Core Use Block, (vi)
the Corner Use Block, and/or (vii) the Open Space Use Block(s). The size of
each and every Block may be enlarged or reduced by up to twenty percent (20 %);
provided, however, that the Maximum Unit Limitations specified in Section 17
below shall remain unaffected.
Building: A structure having a roof supported by columns and walls, for the
shelter, support, enclosure or protection of persons, animals, chattel, or property.
Separate but attached units within a Building, separated by party walls, shall be
considered part of the same Building and not separate Buildings.
Building Height: The vertical distance from the lot ground level to the highest
point of the roof for a flat roof, to the deck line of a mansard roof and to the mean
height between eaves and ridges for gable, hip, and gambrel roofs.
BZA: The City's Board of Zoning Appeals
Commercial Building: Any Building, other than a CCRC Multi -Unit Building, in
which any commercial office or retail use exists, other than (i) a sales /rental office
for the sales and/or rental of Dwellings located in the Building in which the
sales /rental office exists and (ii) a home occupation.
Continuing Care: The provision of lodging, nursing, medical or other health
related services to an individual pursuant to an agreement effective for the life of
the individual or for a period greater than one year, evidenced by written
contracts, and in consideration for the payment of an entrance fee, with or without
other periodic charges.
Section 2. Definitions and Rules of Construction.
Section 2.1 General Rules of Construction. The following general rules of
construction and definitions shall apply to the regulations of this Legacy Ordinance:
A. The singular number includes the plural and the plural the singular, unless
the context clearly indicates the contrary.
B. Words used in the present tense include the past and future tenses, and the
future the present.
C. The word "shall" is a mandatory requirement. The word "may" is a
permissive requirement.
Section 2.2
Ordinance:
Definitions. The following definitions shall apply throughout this Legacy
Accessory Dwelling. A Dwelling which is detached from but located on the same
lot as a Detached Dwelling, has an independent means of access and is owned by
the owner of the principal dwelling.
Accessory Retail: Supporting retail which acts as a convenience for office uses.
Accessory retail must be integrated into buildings or sites that are of primarily
office use.
Accessory Structure: A structure which is subordinate to a Building or use
located on the Real Estate and which is not used for permanent human occupancy.
Accessory Use: A use subordinate to the main use, located on the real estate or in
the same Building as the main use, and incidental to the main use.
Aggregate Side Yard: The sum of the widths of the two (2) side yards located on
one (1) lot.
Alley: A private right -of -way or easement located in the interior of blocks and
providing vehicular and service access to the side or rear of properties.
Amenity Area: An area containing recreational facilities including, without
limitation, any one or a combination of the following: (i) a swimming pool, (ii) a
bath house with changing rooms and storage, (iii) recreational equipment, (iv)
tennis courts, (v) basketball courts, (vi) bocce ball courts, (vii) indoor and/or
outdoor workout areas, and (viii) any other recreational facilities approved by the
Director.
Apartment. A Dwelling intended primarily for rental.
6
CITY OF CARMEL ZONING ORDINANCE
DRIVEWAY. That space or area of a Lot which is specifically designated and reserved for the movement of motor
vehicles within the Lot or from the Lot to a public street.
DRY CLEANING ESTABLISHMENT WITH ON-S11E PLANT. An establishment or business maintained for the
pickup and delivery of dry cleaning and /or laundry with an on -site plant and the maintenance or operation of any
laundry or dry cleaning equipment on the premises.
DRY CLEANING ESTABLISHMENT WITHOUT ON -SITE PLANT. An establishment or business maintained for the
pickup and delivery of dry cleaning and/or laundry without an on -site plant and without the maintenance or
operation of any laundry or dry cleaning equipment on the premises.
DUSTLESS HARD SURFACE. A surface adequately covered in accordance with the current standards of the City of
Carmel and required to be maintained in good condition at all times.
DWELLING. A Building, or portion thereof, used primarily as a place of abode for one or more human beings, but not
including Hotels or Motels, lodging or Boarding Houses or Tourist Homes.
DWELLING UNIT. One or more rooms in a residential Building, or residential portion of a Building, which are
arranged, designed, used or intended for use as a complete, independent living facility for one (1) Family and
which includes permanent provisions for living, sleeping, eating, cooking and sanitation.
DWELLING UNIT SIGN. See SIGN, DWELLING UNIT.
DWELLING, ACCESSORY. A Dwelling that is attached to or located on the same Lot as a detached or attached Single -
family Dwelling, has an independent means of access and is owned by the owner of the Principal Building but
occupied by another. Accessory Dwellings include Apartments integrated within or attached to a Single-family
Dwelling, or located in detached Accessory Buildings located on the same Lot as the Single - family Dwelling.
DWELLING, ATTACHED. A Townhouse, duplex, triplex, or quadraplex dwellings, developed side by side for sale as
condominiums or fee - simple dwelling where land is sold with the Dwelling. Attached dwellings whether sold as
condominiums or as individually deeded lots are excluded from the definition of apartments.
DWELLING, MULTIPLE - FAMILY. A residential Building containing three (3) or more Dwelling Units and occupied
by three (3) or more families. Except as otherwise provided by state statute, a Group Home shall not be
considered a Multiple - Family Dwelling and treated as such under this Ordinance.
DWELLING, SINGLE - FAMILY. A residential Building containing only one (1) Dwelling Unit and not occupied by
more than one (1) Family. Pursuant to IC 12- 28 -4 -7, a Group Home for the mentally ill shall be treated as if it
were a Single - family Dwelling, unless the Group Home will be located within three thousand (3,000) feet of
another Group Home for the mentally ill, as measured between lot lines. Pursuant to IC 12- 28 -4 -8, a Group
Home for not more than ten (10) developmentally disabled individuals which is established under a program
authorized by IC 12- 11- 1.1- 1(e)(1) or IC 12- 11- 1.1- 1(e)(2) shall be treated as if it were a Single - family
Dwelling.
DWELLING, TWO- FAMILY. A residential Building containing two (2) Dwelling Units and not occupied by more than
two (2) Families.
E
EQUIPMENT SALES & REPAIR. The use of land, buildings or structures for the sale, storage or repair of equipment
and machinery, which may include but is not limited to farm implement sales and repair and small engine sales
and repair.
Chapter 3: Defmitions
3 -10
as amended per Z -320; Z -339; Z -340; Z -345; Z- 365 -01; Z- 369 -02; Z- 389 -02; Z- 415 -03; Z- 416 -03; Z- 417 -03; Z- 419 -03;
Z- 453 -04; Z- 461 -04; Z- 471 -05; Z- 486 -06; Z- 530 -09; Z- 534 -09; Z- 547 -10
Winter 2011 vl
CITY OF CARMEL ZONING ORDINANCE
MEDICAL LABORATORY. See LABORATORY, MEDICAL.
MEDICAL OFFICE. See OFFICE, MEDICAL.
MEETING OR PARTY HALL. A building designed for public assembly, containing at least one room having an area
equivalent for four hundred (400) square feet per dwelling unit or 2,400 gross square feet, whichever is greater.
MINERAL, SOIL, OR GRAVEL EXTRACTION OPERATIONS. Any process used in obtaining, from the earth,
naturally occurring substances.
MOBILE HOME. Any vehicle, including the equipment sold as a part of a vehicle, used as a conveyance upon streets by
either self - propelled or non self - propelled means and which is designed, constructed, reconstructed or
structurally altered in such a manner as will permit the occupancy thereof as a Dwelling and which is both used
and occupied as a Dwelling but having no foundations other than wheels, jacks, skirting, or other temporary
supports.
MOBILE HOME PARK. An area of land upon which two or more Mobile Homes are harbored for the purpose of being
occupied either free of charge or for revenue purposes, including any Building, Structure, vehicle or enclosure
used or intended for use as a part of the equipment of such Mobile Home Park.
MOBILE HOME STAND OR PAD. A stationary foundation designed for a Mobile Home providing support, water
supply, waste disposal and electrical convenience.
MODEL HOME. See HOME, MODEL.
MORTUARY. See FUNERAL HOME OR MORTUARY
MOTEL. Any Building or group of Buildings containing five (5) or more rooms with direct entrance to or from the
outside, designed or intended to be occupied for sleeping purposes by guests for a fee.
MOTOR BUS OR RAILROAD STATION. See STATION, MOTOR BUS OR RAILROAD.
MOTOR VEHICLE. See VEHICLE, MOTOR.
MOUNDING. Slopes with a ratio in excess of 1 (vertical) : 10 (horizontal), 1:10 (10 %) slopes require approval by the
Commission per ADLS review. Approval of mounding must be a part of the overall site landscaping plan.
MULTI- FAMILY HOUSING COMPLEX. A building(s) for residential purposes with three (3) or more dwelling units,
having common or party walls, on a single lot.
MULTI- TENANT, MULTI -LEVEL BUILDING. See BUILDING, MULTI- TENANT, MULTI - LEVEL.
MULTI- TENANT, GROUND FLOOR BUILDING. See BUILDING, MULTI- TENANT, GROUND FLOOR.
MULTI- TENANT BUILDING COMPLEX. Two (2) or more buildings designed to function as a unit or one (1)
building with seven (7) or more tenants.
MULTI- TENANT BUILDING COMPLEX DIRECTORY SIGN. See SIGN, MULTI- TENANT BUILDING COMPLEX
DIRECTORY.
MULTIPLE- FAMILY DWELLING. See DWELLING, MULTIPLE- FAMILY.
Chapter 3: Definitions
3 -22
as amended per Z -320; Z -339; Z -340; Z -345; Z- 365 -01; Z- 369 -02; Z- 389 -02; Z- 415 -03; Z- 416 -03; Z- 417 -03; Z- 419 -03;
Z- 453 -04; Z- 461 -04; Z- 471 -05; Z- 486 -06; Z- 530 -09; Z -534 -09; Z- 547 -10
Winter 2011 vl
CITY OF CARMEL ZONING ORDINANCE
THEATER, INDOOR. A building or part of a building devoted to showing motion pictures, or for dramatic, dance,
musical, or other live performances. Uses include but are not limited to a movie theater and a performing arts
center.
THREE - COMPONENT MEASURING SYSTEM. Instrumentation which can measure earthbome vibrations in three
directions, that is, vibration occurring in a horizontal as well as a vertical plane.
TOURIST HOME. See HOME, TOURIST.
TOWER. A ground or roof - mounted pole, spire, structure, or combination thereof taller than fifteen (15) feet, including
supporting lines, cables, wires, braces, and masts, intended primarily for the purpose of mounting an Antenna, a
meteorological device, or other similar apparatus above grade. The term does not include (1) a water tower that
is owned by public utility or municipally owned utility; or (2) any pole, spire, structure, or combination thereof
on which an amateur radio station antenna is mounted.
TOWER, RADIO OR TELEVISION TRANSMISSION. Any ground - mounted pole, spire, structure, or combination
thereof, including supporting lines, cables, wires, braces, masts, intended primarily for the purpose of mounting
a radio or television transmission antenna (other than an amateur radio station antenna) above ground.
TOWNHOUSE. One or more Single - family Dwellings with a minimal Front and Rear Yards, and no Side Yards,
arranged side by side, separated by common walls between living areas, each having more than one story.
TRACT, PARENT. A tract of land described by metes and bounds, the description of which has been recorded in the
office of the Hamilton County Recorder of Deeds and which existed prior to the date of adoption of this
ordinance.
TRAFFIC DIRECTIONAL SIGN. See SIGN, TRAFFIC DIRECTIONAL.
TRUCK STOP. A facility intended to provide services to the trucking industry, including but not limited to the following
activities• dispensing of fuel, repair shops, automated washes, restaurants, and motels; all as part of the facility.
TURNAROUND. A space on private property that permits the turning around of any passenger vehicle without the
necessity of using any public Right -of -way to turn around.
U
UNIFIED CENTER. See CENTER, UNIFIED.
UNIVERSITY. See COLLEGE OR UNIVERSITY.
URGENT CARE CENTER. See CENTER, URGENT CARE.
USE. The employment or occupation of a Building, Structure or land for a person's service, benefit or enjoyment.
USE, ACCESSORY. A Use subordinate to the main Use, located on the same Lot or in the same Building as the main
Use, and incidental to the main Use.
USE, CONFORMING. A Use of a Building, land or premises which does conform to all of the applicable provisions of
this ordinance.
Chapter 3: Definitions
3 -37
as amended per Z -320; Z -339; Z -340; Z -345; Z- 365 -01; Z- 369 -02; Z- 389 -02; Z- 415 -03; Z- 416 -03; Z- 417 -03; Z- 419 -03;
Z- 453 -04; Z- 461 -04; Z- 471 -05; Z- 486 -06; Z- 530 -09; Z- 534 -09; Z- 547 -10
Winter 2011 vl
Attached Dwelling. Rowhouse, townhouse, duplex, triplex, or quadriplex dwellings, developed
side by side for sate as condominiums, or as fee simple dwellings where land is sold with the
dwelling. Attached dwellings whether sold as condominiums or as individually deeded lots are
excluded from the definition of apartments.
Bed and Breakfast. The renting of dwelling rooms or suites on a daily basis to tourists,
vacationers and business travelers where the only meal served is breakfast and it is available only
to guests.
Blank Wall. An exterior building wall with no openings and generally constructed of a single
material, uniform texture, and on a single plane.
Buffer. An area within a property or site, generally adjacent to and parallel with the property
line, either consisting of existing natural vegetation or created by the use of trees, shrubs, berms,
and /or fences, and designed to limit views and sounds from the Development to adjacent
properties and vice versa.
Build -to Line. An alignment which dictates the maximum front yard setback from a street or
public right -of -way, to be followed by buildings or structures fronting thereon. The build -to line
does not apply to building projections or recesses. Where a build -to line is specified, the area
between the frontage line and the area forward of the build -to line specified in Section 9.1.B is
the required minimum front yard setback, subject to the variation permitted by Section 9.1 .B.
Build -up Line. An alignment which dictates an average height to the cornice line or to the roof
edge line on a street or space.
Building Height. The vertical distance from the highest finished grade relative to the street
frontage to the cornice line or to the roof edge line. The vertical distance from the cornice line or
roof edge to the parapet or roof ridge (including gables), and the height of towers, steeples,
cupolas and other architectural roof embellishments are not included in calculating building
height.
Building Scale. The relationship between the mass of a building and its surroundings, including
the width of street, open space, and mass of surrounding buildings.
Caliper. The diameter of a tree trunk measured in inches, 6 inches above ground level for trees
up to 4 inches in diameter and measured 12 inches above ground level for trees over 4 inches in
diameter.
Cartway. The paved driving surface of a street or alley and any curbing.
Civic Building. A building or facility the use of which is principally devoted to civic uses.
Civic S ace. The area occupied by a civic building, including the surrounding Lawn, plaza or
courtyard, on -site parking and appurtenant structures.
3
CITY OF CARMEL ZONING ORDINANCE
CHILD ADVOCACY CENTER. See CENTER, FAMILY or CHILD ADVOCACY.
CHURCH, TEMPLE, OR PLACE OF WORSHIP. A Building, together with its Accessory Buildings and property,
where persons regularly assemble for religious purposes and related social events and which Buildings, together
with Accessory Buildings and uses, is maintained and controlled by a religious body organised to sustain
religious ceremonies and purposes.
CIRCUS. See CARNIVALS, FAIRS, OR CIRCUSES.
CIVIC, COMMUNITY, or CONVENTION CENTER. See CENTER; CIVIC, COMMUNITY, or CONVENTION.
CIVIL VIOLATION. See VIOLATION, CIVIL.
CLINIC or MEDICAL - HEALTH CENTER. An establishment where human patients are admitted for special study and
treatment by two or more licensed physicians or dentists, and their professional associates.
CLUB OR LODGE, PRIVATE. An association organized and operated on a non -profit basis for persons who are bona
fide members paying dues, which association owns or leases premises, the use of which premises is restricted to
such members and their guests, and which manages the affairs of such association by and through a board of
directors, executive committee or similar body chosen by the members. Food, meals and beverages may be
served on such premises, provided adequate dining room space and kitchen facilities are available. This
includes fraternities and sororities.
COKE OVENS, BRICK YARDS, KILNS, OPEN HEARTHS, OR BLAST FURNACES. A use typical to the
manufacture of brick or block materials for wholesale distribution.
COLISEUM. see STADIUM OR COLISEUM.
COLLEGE OR UNIVERSITY. An Institution accredited at the college level by an agency or association recognized by
the U.S. Secretary of Education and legally authorized to offer at least a one -year program of study creditable
towards a degree.
COMMERCIAL RECREATIONAL ENTERPRISE OR FACILITY. See RECREATIONAL ENTERPRISE OR
FACILITY, COMMERCIAL.
COMMISSION. The Carmel/Clay Advisory Plan Commission.
COMMITMENT. A covenant concerning the use or development of a parcel of real property which is made in writing
by the owner of that parcel, either voluntarily or in accordance with an order or request of the Commission.
COMMUNITY CENTER See CENTER; CIVIC, COMMUNITY, or CONVENTION.
COMMUNITY, CONTINUING CARE RETIREMENT (CCRC). A place where three (3) or more levels of continued
care are provided to senior citizens, including but not limited to: independent living, assisted living, and skilled
nursing/memory care. It can include independent apartments, detached or attached cottages, and nursing home
rooms in a congregate building, as well as support services and facilities.
CONDOMINIUM. One or more Structures, each Structure having two (2) or more Dwelling Units or other units for
occupancy, wherein provisions have been made for separate ownership of each individual Dwelling Unit or
occupancy unit. A type of ownership.
CONSTRUCTION, COMMENCEMENT OF. The point in time commemorating the breaking of ground for the
construction of a development or Structure.
Chapter 3: Definitions
3 -7
as amended per Z -320; Z -339; Z -340; Z -345; Z- 365 -01; Z- 369 -02; Z- 389 -02; Z- 415 -03; Z- 416 -03; Z- 417 -03; Z- 419 -03;
Z- 453 -04; Z- 461 -04; Z- 471 -05; Z- 486 -06; Z- 530 -09; Z- 534 -09; Z- 547 -10
Winter 2011 vl
Subdivision Control Ordinance: Carmel/Clay Subdivision Control Ordinance,
No. Z -160, as amended.
Suburban Residential Use Block: What is identified on the Concept Plan as
"Suburban Residential Use Block ".
Substantial Alteration: Any change to an approved plan of any type that involves
the revision of ten percent (10 %) or more of the plan's total area or approved
materials.
Townhome: A single family Attached Dwelling that is attached vertically and
provides for individual unit access. Units s are party walls, but ownership can
t • 4..
include small yards. k
a On \a" +vt5 wkovte GHQ
Urban Residential Use Block: What is identified on the Concept Plan as the
"Urban Residential use Block ".
Village Core Use Block: What is identified on the Concept Plan as the "Village
Core Use Block ".
Village Supporting Commercial Use: A small neighborhood serving retail /office
use the primary clientele of which lives or works within close proximity of the
Legacy District. Each individual Village Supporting Commercial use shall not
occupy more than two thousand five hundred (2,500) square feet and must be
pedestrian oriented in design and accessibility. All parking shall be
accommodated in the rear, sides, and on- street. These uses can be detached, or
integrated within a mix of other uses.
Zone Map: The City's official Zone Map corresponding to the Zoning Ordinance.
Zoning Ordinance: Carmel /Clay Zoning Ordinance Z -289, as amended from time
to time.
Section 3. Accessory Buildings and Uses. All Accessory Structures and Accessory Uses
allowed under the Zoning Ordinance shall be permitted in the Legacy District; provided,
however, that any detached accessory building shall have on all sides the same architectural
features or shall be architecturally compatible with the principal building(s) with which it is
associated.
Section 4. Suburban Residential Use Block (s). This Block is predominantly a suburban
setting of Detached Dwellings on larger lots. While this Block is primarily Detached Dwellings,
Attached Dwellings are permitted through special use review and approval by the BZA, and the
standards and character illustrations for Attached Dwellings in Exhibit 9 shall apply to all
Attached Dwellings approved by the BZA in Suburban Residential Use Block. No more than 4
12