Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout13074-Comcheck-CarmelUnitedMethodistChurchIJ COMchecik Software Version 3.9.2 Mechanical Compliance Certificate 90,1 (2007) Standard Section 1: Project Information Project Type: Alteration Project Title : Carmel United Methodist Church Construction Site: Owner /Agent: 621 South Rangeline Road Mike Hufnagel Carmel, IN 46032 Performance Mechanical Contracting 3409 Sutherland Avenue Indianapolis, IN 46218 (317) 879 -8255 mhufnagel @pm�-inc- online.com Section 2: General Information Building Location (for weather data): Carmel, Indiana Climate Zone: 5a Section 3: Mechanical Systems List Quantity System Type & Description HVAC System #7: Designer/Contractor: Earl Wade ('Bob ") Boulware, P.E., M.B.A. Design -Aire Engineering 220 North College Avenue Indianapolis„ IN 46202 (317) 464 -9090 dae@daengineering.com Heating: 1 each - Radiant Heater, Electric, Capacity = 39 kBtulh No minimum efficiency requirement applies Cooling: 1 each - Rooftop Package Unit, Capacity = 30 kBtulh, Air - Cooled Condenser Proposed Efficiency= 13.50 SEER, Required Efficiency = 13.00 SEER Fan System: None SYSTEM COMPLIANCE REQUIRED. HVAC System #8: Heating: 1 each - Radiant Heater, Electric, Capacity = 54 kBtu /h No minimum efficiency requirement applies Cooling: 1 each - Rooftop Package Unit, Capacity = 48 kBtulh, Air - Cooled Condenser Proposed Efficiency= 13.00 SEER, Required Efficiency = 13.00 SEER Fan System: None SYSTEM COMPLIANCE REQUIRED. Section 5: Compliance Statement 'irr�awarar +r +. Compliance Statement: The proposed mechanical alteration project repre�Iti�1A�'k s consistent with the building plans, specifications and other calculations submitted with this permit applicatiE alteration project has been designed to meet the 90.1 (2007) Standard, Chapter 8, requirements in COMcheck .2 and to h the mandatory requirements in the Requirements Checklist. NO. � �%7 n Name-Title Signa M Date Section 6: Post Construction Compliance t Project Title: Carmel United Methodist Church Report date: 08/30/13 Data filename: 2:113074 -METH CHURCH%Comcheckl 13074- Comcheck- CarmelUnitedMethodistChurch.cck Page 1 of 2 © HVAC record drawings of the actual installation and performance data for each equipment provided to the owner within 90 days after system acceptance. HVAC O &M documents for all mechanical equipment and system provided to the ownerwithin 90 days after system acceptance. © Written HVAC balancing report provided to the owner. The above post construction requirements have been completed. Principal Mechanical Designer -Name Signature Project Title: Carmel United Methodist Church Data filename: 2:113074 -METH CHURCH1Comcheck1 13074 - Comcheck- CarmelUnited Method istCh urch,cck Date Report date: 08/30/13 Page 2 of 2 �(COMcheck Software Version 3.9.2 l Inspection Checklist Requirements: 100.0% were addressed directly in the COMcheck software Text in the "Comments /Assumptions" column is provided by the user in the COMcheck Requirements screen. For each requirement, the user certifies that a code requirement will be met and how that is documented, or that an exception is being claimed. Where compliance is itemized in a separate table, a reference to that table is provided. 1 1 High Impact (Tier 1) 1 2 1 Medium Impact (Tier 2) 13 1 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Carmel United Methodist Church Report date: 08/30/13 Data filename: Z:113074 -METH CHURCH1Comcheck1 13074- Comcheck- CarmelUnitedMethodistChurch.cck Page 1 of 7 4.2.2, 6.4.2 Plans, specifications, and/or calculations LJComplies Requirement will be met. [PR2]1 provide all information with which El Does Not Comply; 'compliance can be determined for the : ❑Not Observable : Location on plans/spec: M001, M101 mechanical systems and equipment and ❑Not Applicable document where exceptions to the standard are claimed. Load calculations per acceptable engineering standards and ,handbooks. 4,2.2, 7.4.1 ' Plans, specifications, and/or calculations ❑Complies Requirement will be met. [PR3]1 provide all information with which ❑Does Not Comply compliance can be determined for the : ❑Not Observable ; Location on planslspec: M001, M101 service water heating systems and ❑Not Applicable equipment and document where exceptions: ,to the standard are claimed. Hot water . system sized per manufacturer's sizing 6.7.2.4 Detailed instructions for HVAC systems LJComplies Exception. Requirement does not apply. [PR5]1 commissioning included on the plans or ❑Does Not Comply specifications for projects — 50,000 ft2. ❑Not Observable ; Location on planslspec: M001, M101 E] Not Applicable Additional Comments /Assumptions: 1 I High Impact (Tier 1) 12 1 Medium Impact (Tier 2) 1 3 1 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Carmel United Methodist Church Report date: 08/30/13 Data filename: Z:113074 -METH CHURCHIComcheckl 13074- Comcheck- CarmelUnitedMethodistChurch.cck Page 2 of 7 6.4.3.8 1 Freeze protection and snow/ice melting LJComplies Exception: Requirement does not apply. [F09]3 system sensors for future connection to ❑Does Not Comply; ;controls. F] Not Observable Location on plans /spec: M001, M101 ❑Not Applicable Additional Comments /Assumptions: 11 High Impact (Tier 1) 12 1 Medium impact (Tier 2) 1 3 1 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Carmel United Methodist Church Report date: 08/30/13 Data filename: Z:113074 -METH CHURCHIComcheckl 13074- Comcheck- Carme[UnitedMethodistChurch.cck Page 3 of 7 6,44A.Aj HVAC equipment efficiency verified. Efficiency: Efficiency: LJComplies See the Mechanical Systems list for 6.4:1 5 = -' Non -NAECA HVAC equipment ❑Does Not Comply values. [ME1]z .:..:,.::"labeled as meeting 90.1. ❑Not Observable ❑Not Applicable 6.4.3.4.1 Stair and elevator shaft vents have ❑Complies Exception: Requirement does [ME3]3 motorized dampers that automatically ❑Does Not Comply not apply. close. ❑Not Observable ' ❑NotAppiicable 'Location on planslspec: M001, M101 6.4.3.4.2, Outdoor air and exhaust systems , ❑Complies Exception: Gravity dampers 6.4.3.4.3, have motorized dampers that i F ❑Does Not Complyacceptable in buildings 3 stories. 6.4.3.4.4 automatically shut when not in use -]Not Observable [ME4]3 and meet maximum leakage rates. < ❑Not A Applicable Location on plans/spec: M001, pp Check gravity dampers where l M101 allowed. 6.4.3.4.5 Ventilation fans >075 hp have ❑Complies Requirement will be met. [ME5]3 automatic controls to shut off fan a❑Does Not Comply when not required. ❑Not Observable ;Location on planslspec: M001, ❑NotApplicable M101 6.4.3.9 Demand control ventilation provided s ❑Complies Exception: Systems with a [ME--6]' for spaces >500 ft2 and >40 Z ❑Does Not Comply, design outdoor airflow less than people /1000 ft2 occupant density and ❑Not Observable :1200 cfm. ,served by systems with air side ❑Not Applicable ; economizer, auto modulating outside 3 i Location on plans/spec: M001, ;air damper control, or design airflow_ M101 >3,000 cfm. 6.4.4.1.1 ;Insulation exposed to weather ❑Complies Requirement will be met. [ME7]3 protected from damage. Insulation ❑Does Not Comply E outside of the conditioned space and ;❑Nat Observable :Location on plans/spec: M001, associated with coaling systems is ❑Nat Applicable M101 vapor retardant. 6.4.4A.2.' ;' j HVAC ducts and plenums insulated. R- R- ;❑Complies :Exception: Ductsiplenums [ME ; ❑Does Not Comply ; located in heated, semi - heated, '[]Not Observable or cooled spaces. ❑Not Applicable 1 Location on planslspec: M001, M101 6.4.4A,:3 I HVAC piping insulation thickness. in. in. ; ❑Complies Exception: piping within HVAC [ME 9]z ❑Does Not Complyequipment. ❑Not Observable f ❑Not Applicable 'Location on plans/spec: M001, M101 6.4 4.2.1 Ducts and plenums sealed based on ... ❑Complies Requirement will be met. z" [ME10]. pressure and location. astatic ❑Not Observab[ely' Location on plans/spec: M001, i ❑Nat Applicable M101 6.4.4.2.2 ' Ductwork operating >3 in. water ;❑Complies Exception: Requirement does [ME11 ]3 'column requires air leakage testing = ❑Does Not Comply not apply. i ❑Not Observable ' ❑Not Applicable Location on planslspec: M001, > M101 6.4.4.2.2 Ductwork operating >3 in. water [ME11]3 column requires air leakage testing. See the Mechanical Systems list for values for HVAC System #7. ❑Complies Exception: Requirement does ❑Does Not Comply not apply. ❑Not Observable ❑Not Applicable Location on plans/spec: M001, M101 See the Mechanical Systems list for values for HVAC System #8. 1 I High Impact (Tier 1) 12:1 Medium Impact (Tier 2) 13 1 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Carmel United Methodist Church Report date: 08/30/13 Data filename: Z:113074 -METH CHURCHIComcheckl 13074- Comcheck- CarmelUnitedMethodistChurch.cck Page 4 of 7 6.5.2.3 Dehumidification controls provided to ,L_1Complies Exception: Cooling capacity 80 [ME19]3 prevent reheating, retooling, mixing of ❑Does Not Comply kBtulh and capability to unload hot and cold airstreams or concurrent Not Observable :cooling equipment. heating and cooling of the same N, i ❑Not Applicable airstream. 9 Location on planslspec: M001, M101 6.5.4.1 HVAC pumping systems >10 hp a ❑Gampfies Exception: Systems with three [ME25]3 'designed for variable fluid flow. ❑Does Not Comply: or fewer control valves. r ❑Not Observable• ❑NatApplicab[e Location on plans/spec: M001, M101 6.5.6.1 'Exhaust air energy recovery on , ❑Complies Exception: Requirement does [ME30]1 systems —5,000 cfm and 70% of El Does Not Comply' not apply. ; design supply air. E]Nat Observable ❑Not Applicable Location on plans/spec: M001, M101 6.5:71 ;Kitchen hoods >5,000 cfm have make ' ❑Complies Exception: Requirement does [ME32]2 up air >=50% of exhaust air volume, ❑Does Not Comply not apply. ❑Not Observable ;❑Not Applicable Location M00 1, n plans/spec: M101 6.5.7.2 Fume hoods exhaust systems ❑ Cnmplies Exception: Requirement does [ME33]' >= 15,000 cfm have VAV hood El Does Not Comply: not apply. exhaust and supply systems, direct E) Not Observable make -up air or heat recovery. –]Not Applicable Location on plans/spec: M001, r M101 6.5.8.1 Unenclosed spaces that are heated ❑Complies ;Exception: Requirement does [ME34]3 use only radiant heat. El Does Not Comply not apply. E Not Observable ❑Not Applicable Location on plans/spec; M001, .... a M101 6.5.9 Hot gas bypass limited to: ­240 ; ❑Complies :Requirement will be met. [ME35]1 kBtulh – 50% >240 kBtulh – 25% ❑Does Not Comply ❑Not Observable ; Location on planslspec: M001, ❑Not Applicable ; M101 h See the Mechanical Systems list for values for HVAC System V. 6.5.9 Hot gas bypass limited to: ­240 ❑ Comp[ies Requirement will be met. [ME35]1 kBtulh – 50 % >240 kBtulh – 25% ❑Does Not Comply ; ❑Not Observable MEIN :Location on planslspec: M001, ot Applicable ;M101 See the Mechanical Systems list for values for HVAC System #8. Additional Comments /Assumptions: 111 High Impact {Tier i} 2 Medium Impact (Tier 2) 3 ILow Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Carmel United Methodist Church Report date: 08/30/13 Data filename: Z:113074 -METH CHURCH1Comcheck1 13074- Comcheck- CarmelUnitedMethodistChurch.cck Page 5 of 7 Electric motors meet requirements where ❑Complies Requirement will be met. applicable. ❑Does Not Comply, ❑Not Observable Location on plans/spec: M001, M101 Additional Comments /Assumptions: 111 High Impact (Tier 1) 1. 2 1 Medium Impact (Tier 2) 13 1 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Carmel United Methodist Church Report date: 08/30/13 Data filename: Z:113074 -METH CHURCHIComcheckl 13074- Comcheck- CarmelUnitedMethodistChurch.cck Page 6 of 7 9011 (2007); standard:. Final Inspection Complies? Comments /Assumptions 6,4;3 1.1 Heating and cooling to each zone is ❑Complies Requirement will be met. [FI2]2 controlled by a thermostat control. El Does Not Comply' ❑Not Observable : Location on plans/spec: M001, M101 ❑Not Applicable 6.4;31 2, Thermostatic controls have a 5 °F ❑Complies Requirement will be met- 64.3t:2.; deadband. ❑Does Not Comply; 64; 3 3 , ❑Not Observable = Location on plans/spec: M001, M101 6A 3 1 ❑Not Applicable 6:4:313:2::,:: 6.4.3.7 When humidification and dehumidification ❑Complies Requirement will be met. [FI6]3 are provided to a zone, simultaneous ❑Does Not Comply; ,operation is prohibited. ❑Not Observable ; Location on plans/spec: M001, M101 ❑Not Applicable 6.7.2.1 `Furnished HVAC as -built drawings ;❑Complies Requirement will be met. [F17]3 submitted within 90 days of system '❑Does Not Comply acceptance. 1­1 Not Observable El Not Applicable 6.7.2.2 Furnished O&M manuals for HVAC systems: ❑Complies Requirement will be met. [FI8]3 'within 90 days of system acceptance_ : ❑Does Not Comply; ❑Not Observable ❑Not Applicable 6.7.2.3 ,An air and/or hydronic system balancing ❑Complies ;Requirement will be met. [F19]1 report is provided for HVAC systems El Does Not Comply serving zones >5,000 ft2 of conditioned ❑ Not Observable ; Location on planslspec: M001, M 101 area. , ❑Not Applicable 6.7.2.4 HVAC control systems have been tested to ❑Complies Requirement will be met. [FI10]1 ensure proper operation, calibration and ❑Does Not Comply ,adjustment of controls. ❑Not Observable ,Location on planslspec: M001, M101 El Not Applicable 6.4.3.2 ,Temperature controls have setpoint overlap ; ❑Complies :Requirement will be met. [F120]1 restrictions. ❑Does Not Comply; : ❑Not Observable Location on planslspec: M001, M101 ❑Not Applicable 6.4.3.3.1 HVAC systems equipped with at least one ' ❑Complies Requirement will be met. [FI21]1 automatic shutdown control. ❑Does Not Comply; ❑Not Observable Location on planslspec: M001, M101 El Not Applicable 6.4.3.3.2 Setback controls allow automatic restart ❑Complies Requirement will be met. [F122]1 and temporary operation as required for ❑Does Not Comply, maintenance. ❑NotObseroable ;Location on plans/spec: M001, M101 E] Not Applicable Additional Comments /Assumptions: 111 High Impact (Tier 1) 1. 2 Medium Impact (Tier 2) 13 1 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Carmel United Methodist Church Report 08/30/13 Data filename: Z:113074 -METH CHURCH\Comcheck1 13074- Comcheck- Carme[UnitedMethodistChurch.cck Page 7 of 7